Witchstone Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at witchstone which is a 2021 release board game designed by ryder kenitzia and martino chia kiara this one accommodates two to four players and takes 60 to 90 minutes to play so this is a euro style point salad game that looks a bit like this when it's on the table so you've got the main board here which is essentially divided up into different sections so you've got this pentagram in the corner you've got this kind of bookshelf full of these vials you've got this big crystal ball in the center you've got these cars that you can draft from and so there's card row in the um on the right hand side of the board and you've got this magic wand to the bottom of the board um these are all going to kind of relate to the different actions you can take throughout so it's kind of a bunch of little mini games that come together kind of harmoniously and they'll synergize with what they do but we'll touch on that a bit later individually each player is going to have their own cauldron which looks like this we've got all these different gems surrounding a black gem in the middle and that's essentially going to be blockers throughout the game but you do have potential to move them each player is going to have a bunch of witches and a bunch of these crystals and you've got your main kind of tiles here which are going to be laying on your cauldron to take actions we're going to have five in your immediate supply and a bunch of them here face down and you're going to replenish from this face down pile um at the end of your turn to always have five in your in your immediate fold additionally you you should be playing with these shields but obviously for demonstration purposes here i won't be using them so the objective of this game is to get as many points as you can by the time you only have four of these tiles left
you're going to keep playing and taking actions until you do that and the way you take actions is by placing these tiles onto your individual cauldron and trying to compound these symbols together to get stronger and stronger actions so for example i might take this um this tile here and i could put it on like this like so and what this will mean now is because i'm connecting two of these pentagrams together then i can actually take a strength two pentagram action but of course the more and more i add them together in a big chain that i can get you know strength four strength five strength six and so on actions um so as the game develops and your cauldron is filling up the actions are gonna get stronger and stronger and stronger so let's talk about what the actions actually do so the pentagram action relates to this part of the board here where you're going to have your little owl token here and depending on the strength of that pentagram action you're going to move a number of spaces around this rondelle so let's say i moved five spaces i could go one two three four five and because i pass these tokens along the way i can take them and i have two options what to do with these um with these colored ones i could either put it on my cauldron as an almost flexible tile so i might say put it somewhere like here and where this one is either going to be a pentagram or a crystal action and you know depending on what you connect you can actually use that as either so these are really flexible and useful additionally if you don't want to choose um to add it to your cold cauldron as a one-off action you can choose to discard it and take a strength two action of either of those types so again i can go two more spaces around the pentagram or i could take a strength two crystal action additionally there are other spots on
this pentagram here where you get to these gold spots which relate to these owl tokens and the sooner you get to those it means you're going to get a bigger dump of points so the first person to get there is going to be seven points and then six and so on until it depletes all the way down to strength two so you want to be going around as quickly as you can getting up those higher point value tokens so that you get more points the crystal action relates to the crystal ball here where depending on the strength of action you're going to take a number of the crystals of your color from your supply and you're going to add them to build roots on this crystal ball so for example here let's say i had a strength three crystal action i could perhaps go one two three like so now i've completed that route i'm gonna have a look at the little book here which shows how many points i get for complete completing a route so a strength one route will only get you one point but a strength three route will get you a big six points and these are going to be really important corresponding to the witch action which i'll explain shortly so with the witch action you're going to take one of two moves really and that again relates to these crystal routes here so as a as an action you can choose to lay one of your witches from the supply at the feet of your starting which here which starts on one of these um kind of major towers and you're going to get a bonus token for doing that at the beginning of the game and which will give you kind of a leg up on one of the different areas and additionally if you don't want to lay another witch down you can choose to stand one up which is going to get you two points and then you can choose to follow these routes in order to get to these tokens which again will give you
more action so this will give me a scroll action um and you can actually choose to trace through as many of these crystals as you want as long as you um build a chain of your color so as a single move i can maybe move all the way down here through here and on to here as a single which action so the kind of the crystal action and the witch action do really work together hand in hand but additionally if other players build route because of course this is a multiplayer game and i'm just using one player's pieces as an example here but say um let's say the blue player built these two spaces then i would actually have to pay an additional witch action to travel through other player's routes so my which is going to be really efficient to get through but it's going to be a bit of a speed bump when i start using other people's crystal routes additionally every one of these tokens you collect at the end of the game is going to be worth another two points the scroll action relates to the card row here so depending on the strength of the action you're going to have the choice of more cards to take so no matter how strong that action is you're still only going to take one card but let's say i had a strength three action i would actually have the choice of one two or three if i was strength one action had i'd have no choice but to take this card and of course if it's a stroke six action i could take any of the cards available and all these scrolls are really useful and good ways to get points because normally they'll give you an objective to go for so for example here this card will say if i have a witch on any of the red areas on the board and then i'm gonna get up to seven points if i have it on three different ones or the ones here you get some kind of boosted ones as well like this will say no matter what action i take i can
choose to discard this card and take it one strength stronger but if i don't use that card it's going to give me two points at the end of the game you've got ones like this which will relate to your cauldron so if i have up to six maps touching each other on my cauldron then i'll get a massive seven points but if i don't quite get to that height i can still get points by getting you know four or five of those maps touching with each other and you've got more specialist cards like this which will mean like when you take a specific action then you can get it at strength plus two the magic one actually relates to this track at the bottom here so again depending on the strength of the magic wand action you take you're going to move a number of spaces along this track here and when you meet certain points you're going to get bonuses so this one here for example will give me the gem action which we haven't covered yet but the first person to do it will get a strength two rather than the normal strength one so you are incentivized to be further up the track than your opponents because you do get stronger versions of those actions and additionally once you get to these spots here you get points depending on this different bald state or your your personal condition so this one here will say you get a point for each one of your completed routes on the board so sometimes it's a good idea to hold back on different things so that you get the full benefit of these points some outpours and this one here for example say get you get a point for each which you have in the um in the crystal ball this one here will give you a point for each map you have uh a point for each of these tokens you have and so on so this um this magic track is really useful as long as you are in the front but it's still useful regardless but being in the front is even stronger the final action we haven't covered yet
is the gm action so if you ever take a gem action like so i'd have a strength two action here and you can choose to move these gems around your cauldron a number of spaces equal to the action you've taken so i had a strength two there i can go strength one and strength two and the idea is you wanna be getting these gems out of the way because they do actually just cause congestion and stop you from placing certain tiles and become a bit of a pain but when you push them off the side of the board here like so then you get to take the corresponding action so you can take again you can take a scroll action or you can take another gem action and so on and when you do that you're going to remove the um the gem from your board and you can place it on the shelf here corresponding to the action you've just taken so let's just say i i pushed off to that gem section i could put it on this one here which gets me another strength to gem action so these are really useful but alternatively if you don't want to use the actual one you've landed on you can choose to put it on one of these spots here which will relate to these tokens which weren't laid out at the start of the game so you do have some flexibility there so these are really useful tools to have additionally if you want to push the black gem out of the way then you get another plus strength two on there so you'd actually be taking strength four actions if you take one of these corresponding things which is of course a very powerful thing to take so the gem action is not only good for bonus actions but for clearing out your board and giving you more flexibility on your own personal cauldron additionally if you build these routes into the center here into the witch stone then the first person to do so and travel a witch along that route is going to get five points and then three points two points and one point depending on how quickly you do that so there's a bit
of a race there to get to the center and that's pretty much how all the different things work together they're all simple in their own right but the way they string together is really where this game shines because whenever you take an action almost all the time you get some kind of fallout action so as i said if you want to move the gems you're going to probably end up in one of these spots here which will let you do something else so you know if i took the one action i could choose to maybe go up a few tracks which will get me another two actions here which might get me another action and might maybe go around the pentagram a few more which will get me one of these symbols so even though all the different mini games are simple in their own right and you do really have a lot of synergy and a lot of kind of domino effect um combinations going on throughout the game which can give you really powerful turns especially as the later turns develop so let's talk about my feelings about which stone so of course it all stems back to this core mechanism here about laying these tiles on your cauldron this has a real cool puzzly aspect where of course you want to line up these symbols as much as possible to get those stronger and stronger actions but still abiding by this restrictions that these annoying gems get in the way and this is a really satisfying thing when you do string these things together and of course spinning those plates and trying to move these gems out the way is important because they will inevitably get in your way and cause you some frustration and that kind of steps back to all the different things you want to do in this game because all the different actions you can take are equally as powerful i really like the fact that you can take a different route and specialize in something you know different than your opponents do in order to get almost this you know the same reward from it so i like the way you have to kind of diversify the pentagram is fantastic
because if you keep blessing it before your opponents do you can get a hell of a point by getting to these seven and six tiles before the other people do and of course even get these bonus actions and even more capability of adding them to your personal cauldron so that gives you really great tools to have under your belt additionally the route building part of the game is fun because you want to get into the routes quicker than your opponents do and build off from your center witch here because it's so cheap for you to travel around the map if if you're using your own routes and of course it will start slowing you down if you have to start stepping on other people's toes and using their routes costing you an extra which action for each time you do that and there's even a scarcity to get to these tokens to get you bonus actions not only for the points but of course for the actions themselves and even building the roots in the first place is going to be a really good source of points on top of that you've got all the cards here that are all really interesting and you do want to have these because because these can be a real kind of um you know a game a way to determine who's going to win the game because these are all really strong and if you keep getting you know all the seven point objectives then you're probably going to have a really good chance of winning um and on top of all that the actual magic wand action as well is equally as fantastic especially if you are in the lead and can start getting these really great bonuses you know taking your four actions as a single thing or four witch actions which can really expand your coverage of the board really quickly and get you again stringed bonuses by collecting more tokens and there's more tokens that you get more points and let you travel on other tracks so everything you do here is important and you can't neglect anything and the way that you can string these
moves together is so satisfying you know sometimes you'll find yourself um just having actions that you couldn't even see coming in the first place and that is a really great thing and and i think a lot of the um the word on this game is that it feels like a stefan feld game especially in the way you're just showered in points and i have to say i could not agree more so if if you put this game in front of me and didn't tell me it was a randy kennedy game i would have confidently told you this was a stefan feld game because it just feels like his his recipe for a game that he puts out i mean even this part here it feels just like bonfire where you're matching up these symbols and it has the exact same mechanism but maybe slightly more complex and even the um you know the witch mechanism where you're spawning witches and then shooting them down these routes it reminds me of the military action in trajan so it does have a lot of similarities and a lot of feeling of a steppenfeld game which of course is um one of my well i love that because steppenfeld is one of my favorite designers but it's a real change of direction for reiner kenitzia and you know i'm you know accepting it with open arms because i think this is a really really fun experience especially in terms of the combos and again that domino effect when you do take certain actions the pacing of this game is quite fantastic before you know it you are taking stronger and stronger actions and it kind of ties into the game length as well because this game does take about 60 to 75 minutes to play which is such a nice time frame for a game of this
magnitude there is a lot going on here but i think because the rules overhead are so simple and easy to digest you are simply just explaining all the different well the five different actions you can take in there you know in their own right as i said are all so so simple but when you start stringing these things together it does start feeling like a more meaty game than at the surface level so i do love the time frame this one takes the uptime itself is generally really decent it's not you know you're not taking really ap inducing tans but sometimes you know when other people do string together these particularly powerful moves and can end up taking you know maybe 10 plus actions a 10 and triggering other actions that they didn't even see coming then there can be a bit of you know sitting back and just watching it all happen where you can't really do anything about it but you know resolving them isn't going to be too cumbersome and it isn't too frustrating and you know what you're only going to return the favor when it comes to your turn so i do like that and additionally the board does have a really good sense of development because you start mulling over your mistakes you know i shouldn't have placed this here i should have put it over here instead um you do have to work on the tiles you have available to you because you do only have five and sometimes you might not have the action that you want you know available to you immediately but it's going to come out soon so you do have to react somewhat to here but a hand number of five i think is the sweet spot as well so you do have a lot of flexibility but not too much to you know completely engulf you and drown you in options so i really do like that and the you know the ongoing restrictions you start realizing that you should have moved these gems out the way earlier um
you know i should have added these symbols together to get more stronger actions because i'm very getting myself into a corner so again the sense of development on this game is great and i love the way i kind of mentioned earlier the balancing here each single action you can take is equally strong as the other and you don't want to neglect anything because as soon as you fall behind on something you could potentially be giving up the double actions on the on the track here you could be giving up the good cards here you could have waited too long to get all the routes established so other people are i've already got a good coverage on the board and create the roots of their own and travel around quicker and of course got the points for doing so they're going to be gobbling up the tokens before you they're going to be gobbling up the more high points values than you so there is a good amount of player interaction here albeit quite passive and there certainly isn't anything in your face or anything like that but you do have to be on the ball and watch what other people do so you don't fall too far behind on a certain you know points pool um additionally the um there is a scarcity here to get these gem bonuses so as i said you when you're pushing these gems off the side and you claim one of these you've only got a limit here so in a two-player game you've got a limit of four in a three-player game you've got five and in a four-player game you can do six i think you can see from yourself here this is a very attractive game that's very well laid out you can clearly see what all the actions correspond to without any convolution or fiddliness you can you're very clearly divided up things you know what each action relates to without without feeling so dissected so i do like the way that everything comes together but still feels distinct in its own right so that's really great and
going on to the production itself as well you know gorgeous artwork definitely does pop these cauldrons work really well and the actual iconography and symbology is crystal clear next to no room for confusion here at all and the actual components themselves are top notch now these little witch meeples are great these crystals are really nice colors the cauldrons work wonderfully all the towels are nice and strong and again nice clean iconography so no issues at all with the production even the card quality is um is a high stocks the slightest nitpick i have with this game relates to the scalability and that is the coverage of the main crystal ball here so in a two player game it does feel relatively open and you can pretty much do your own thing without standing on the other player's toes or even having to consider using their roots whereas when you start injecting that third and fourth player then the competition of the board is going to become a lot more ferocious and it's going to bring this crystal part of the game a bit more to life so it is a bit of a shame that it's not it doesn't quite pop us strongly in a two-player version but the rest of the game is still perfectly fine and i'm not saying it's a bad thing it just would be nice to maybe close off some roots or something in a two-player game just to keep it a bit tighter but other than that um it scales perfectly fine so overall my thoughts on which stone is that this game is wonderful and this one is such an easy teacher remarkably so actually i had no issue at all teaching this to a relative you know newcomer in terms of gaming they understood what everything did straight away um and
there really is no room for you know misinterpreting the rules there's no exceptions to rules or anything like that it really is just a simple place your tiles and take the corresponding actions and of course the more you match the symbols the stronger actions they are sometimes it can be a little bit fiddly in terms of remembering what you have to go and what you've already resolved because as i said that is kind of uh a double-edged sword already because the the potential for combinations is so so huge that sometimes you lose track with what you have done and what you're yet to resolve but um you know that comes with experience really you do start to monitor things a bit more you know being a bit more on the ball with that kind of thing but i love the way all the different things correspond to each other the i could go back to the different um the cascading domino effect that's really what you're going to take away from this game and this is probably one of the best examples that i've seen using that particularly corresponding or always going back to this simple core mechanism where you are just taking one of these very simple actions that i said in their own right all these actions are an absolute doddle but when you start stringing them together and you know getting one thing to trigger another thing to trigger another things trigger another thing that is where the game does come to life there's some great interaction here in terms of you know racing for the different things and it all just comes together so wonderfully for a real fun experience especially for a game that takes around an hour to play so i absolutely adore this one i love this key concept here of the tile laying um i love the root building i love the um you know i love the different options of the cards and the actual puzzle the aspect to it is great and yeah what you're going to invest in what you're going to specialize in it's
just an absolutely just just a joy to play and i'll be very surprised if witchstone doesn't make my top 10 of 2021. i like it that much so i'd highly recommend this one this is a very versatile game that you can choose to introduce to relative newcomers to the hobby but still having all the juicy satisfaction you'd want with a combo-riffic euro so highly highly recommend which stone if you like your point salad games and if you like stefan feld i know this isn't steffenfeld but if you like his style of games then this is going to be an absolute well this is going to be a treat for you you're going to love this one because it does feel like a steppenwold game despite being by the good doctor reina knits yeah so this one is a no-brainer for me this one gets my shield of quality absolutely loving it that is which stone by ryder kinicia and martino chia chiara thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time