Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 20:51

welcome to John gets games today I'll be reviewing Gold West in this two to four player game you will be using a mancala style track in order to evaluate your turns and build encampments and settlements all throughout a valley in order to mine a whole bunch of minerals and use it in many different ways you score victory points for all sorts of things in this game first I will go over how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review here's a starting setup for a four player game of gold West first of all we randomly placed all these large tiles down that each have seven spots for these little colored terrain discs then you place the terrain discs down on the board matching the color and you leave them all face down except for the ones that happen to be touching the river in the center now you randomly give the star player token to a player and then put the second third and fourth going around the table this is pretty interesting because on each of these tokens it shows you what resources you start with on your player board so as a first player I would have one wood green Cube at the top spot and then a copper mineral cylinder and a black stone cube in my second spot here which you can see the structure of return is really quite simple you see down on the bottom under player board it says first you activate your supply track then you use your metals and finally you build or loot so beginning with the activate Supply track all you do is take one of the four slots on your player board and you grab all the resources in that slot and then you move upwards and in each subsequent slot you hit you must put a single resource down into each one of those compartments until you finally get to the end and all the remainder kind of spills out onto the table in this case the purple player only has a single Stone Cube left over

so next we move on to the use Metals phase of the turn but stone is not a metal so let's go ahead and skip that and we'll come back very shortly and finally go to the build or Loop phase each of these triangular tokens at the bottom of your player board indicate encampments and in order to build a single Gammon out on the board you're gonna have to pay either Stone Cube or a wood Cube so in this case they could spend the stone Cube here in order to put this token out on the board a player can put an encampment down anywhere on the board where there's a current face up tile so for instance this one right here then it came in goes down and then and in this case they would get three silver from the supply and the moment you clear a space for any reason you must flip all the tiles that are adjacent to it that are currently face down and it's important to note that on future turns you don't have to necessarily place next to your previous encampments so now you take this tile and you flip it over and you put it down on your player board and the associated terrain track and then you get the resources that that tile gave you and you put them into one of these four troughs if you put it in the second third or fourth trough you will actually take a number of victory points equal to the number on the side but for the moment let's say that the player puts it down here in the very top trough this would end their turn and play would continue clockwise it's time to demonstrate a couple more things so I'm going to cheat a little bit and put this black token in here and let's pretend it's the purple player's turn again so in this case they only have one of their tracks that is currently open so they would activate it by grabbing everything and pushing it off to the top of their board and they would not have to drop anything down because they were already at the top the second phase of a turn is use metals and right now they have three silver and one copper there are three different ways you can use Metals in the

game and you could do a little bit of all of them on a given turn you're not restricted in any way the first way is you can purchase one of these investment tiles that are over on the side of the board for instance this one right here costs three silver and one copper which the player currently has available to them if they were to take this card they would get seven victory points and then you'll see that this says you can upgrade a camp to a settlement so settlements are improved camps this is a camp right here on the board now you get to take one of these discs that I said are used for multiple purposes and you can slide it underneath the encampment and now that area is a settlement for the case of the board right now it doesn't change anything but it could modify your end game victory points and lastly after doing the upgrade and taking the seven points they would also grab this right here which is a five point bonus in future turns as more people grab these Investments the bonus gets smaller and smaller so this is a bit of an incentive to grab these Investments early the second thing you can use your Metals for is Boom Town over here now these four tiles were randomly pulled from a bag and put down on the board as you can see there are a lot of different files that you can choose from in putting into the Boomtown area for each game what you could do is spend two different pieces of metal one for the row and one for the column in order to put a token down at the intersection of those two metals so you could do that with the two silver or you could do this with a copper in which case that would go down there and of course you could also do this which gives you the option to put this token over here so a couple different options with this set of metals all of these tiles give you end game victory points with the exception of this spot right

here which just gives you four points immediately for instance if you put your token here you would get one Victory point for each settlement you have on the board at the end of the game and remember that situation is where you have a little encampment on top of one of your discs a player is only allowed to put one token in Boom Town each turn but on a subsequent turn they could put another token here and now they would get two victory points per settlement out on the map and then as another example down here you see this one gives you victory points for buildings along the edge of the map and there is a large variety of different scoring things that you can grab here in Boomtown and the last spot you can use your minerals is the shipping track and this is quite simple for instance if you had these three silver here you can move your car forward three different slots so on the silver track we need to kind of you know what let's just get rid of all these it's kind of a crazy stack and then you go one two three in this case the moment you cross this line right here you would get two victory points and then of course you could spend this one copper to go up once on the copper track these tokens here are not actual spaces you stop on you jump over them and when you do you get the victory points that are listed on the tile and as you can see the victory points go down so again this is another race where you're trying to get as far ahead as you can before your opponents to get the majority of the victory points so let's just say that the purple player decides to get this investment they spend the minerals to do that and then they get 12 victory points and then of course they would do their upgrade action and one other thing happens when you turn an encampment into a settlement and that is that the train bonus you put down now counts as two slots along the track and now we would go into the Builder Loop phase and I mentioned before you could spend a wood and a stone and when you do this you actually build a settlement out on the board immediately so you would take both of these and put them out and let's say

that they decided to go over here so that would immediately flip all of these tiles because they are now adjacent to a spot that got cleared and then they put this token down on the board but again settlements let you bump up one extra spot so you put it here instead of here for an encampment so let's say the purple player decides to put their tokens down here they would immediately score two victory points for that and then it would be the next player's turn by the time it comes back around to purple they need to activate a supply track and so they might they would have to grab this one they would drop one here one here and then this would come out the top they would use their metals like normal but once they got to the Builder Loop phase they'd realize they don't have any wood or stone available to them because of this this means they cannot actually build a settlement instead they're going to have to lose when you loot the board the first thing you do is put an encampment down in The Wanted area and you immediately lose one Victory point then you can take a face-up tile from anywhere on the board for instance they could grab this one right here and you don't put anything in that spot it's going to stay vacant but of course you flip over the tiles that are adjacent to that spot you get your materials as normal and you could put it like in this slot and get a victory point but then you don't get to place this token down onto your player board and that's how you play the game in a four player game you will all take 10 turns in a 2 or 3 player game you will each take 12 turns once everybody has taken all of those turns we will go into end game scoring first of all you would evaluate any tokens you have down here on Boomtown giving you victory points for all sorts of things next up the person who has put the most of these encampment tokens down in The Wanted area is going to lose one more Victory Point per encampment token and then the person who puts the second most is going to lose one version point for every two and Camden tokens that they put down

here now each player gets two points per building in the largest contiguous group out here on the map so right now this is a group of one and this is a group of one so there is a reason to try and put your buildings together because you'll get two points per each and the largest one but you don't necessarily have to and finally we score for majorities in the four different terrain types and this means that the person who went the highest along the fourth track is going to get eight points and the person who went second highest will get four points and then on the gold track nine and five Etc all the way down the line once you've done that you see who has the most picture points and they're the winner all right now let's start the review of gold West and we'll begin with a couple positive points the first of these has to do with that Mancala action track now this is far from a new mechanism where you pull everything out of one slot and you drop one thing off in every single slot to run out the new thing as far as gold West is concerned is it doesn't make it a loop you just have a straight line and once you get to the end your remain just fall out and that's what you get to use on a turn which is an ingenious idea uh it also gives you lots of decisions like first of all which one of the tracks do you use on a given turn but more importantly which one of the slots in the track do you put the new Goods into and it's got this great idea where the farther back you put it the the more you invest it into the future the more victory points you get but it's going to be a lot longer until you can actually cash that out you're probably going to need to put two or maybe even three lots into that deep um farthest down track and then have a monster turn and you have to plan accordingly to allow yourself to do that because you'll have maybe some short-term turns and some long-term turns and then just a monster turn and

that's some great stuff you get to think about you have short-term things like maybe I just put it in the farthest forward slot and use it next turn or you put it all the way at the end and you say I'm going to do something big several turns from now and I love how the McCullough track makes all that work positive number two relates to the Boomtown area of the track now you have a bunch of tiles that you Shuffle up and you shove in there randomly and that will dictate a lot of what you do in the game like the big stuff that you do each game is not going to change you're still going for the majorities on the different terrain tracks you're still um uh trying to uh get as high you can on the main tracks and get those Investments none of those things change but how you go about doing those things is going to be subtly Modified by that boom town area maybe you try to focus on getting lots of settlements because there's a Boomtown uh Victory Point thing that lets you cash out big on that or maybe you intentionally place your little encampments on the board next to as many opponents as possible because again there you get victory points for that in this game but the next time you play you might get no victory points for that so it doesn't affect the big things but the way you go at the big things will get shifted uh to and fro based off of how the Boom Town tiles uh come out and then of course there's a little bit of a race a little bit of tension to get your token down on those tiles you might be doing the thing that's going to get you points but you gotta cash out and make sure you have your token there at the end of the game I think it's just a really brilliant idea so now let's move into my neutral points for the game and the first of these relates to the amount of thinkiness that goes into playing this game I was surprised when you look at the game and you see how simple a turn is you just pick one of these four slots move forward and then do stuff

with those minerals it seems like there's not that many things that you need to think about in turn but I was really wrong there is tons to think about when it's not your turn you really should be looking at the board and trying to make plans to figure out what you're going to do and sure an opponent might do something before it's your next turn that will screw up your plans but you still need to be making plans because there's so many different things you are kind of Point solid all over the place you have the Investments where you can dump a bunch of minerals you got the tracks that you want to be first to get the really big cash outs for those and then you constantly need to be paying attention to the majorities in the different terrains uh there is just many different Avenues to split your mind up and I enjoy thinking about a lot of these different things but there also is analysis paralysis issues that I bumped into especially late game where certain people especially people who are prone to analysis process can really tunnel down very hard on the numerous different options that they have available to them uh even just trying to figure out what spot to go on the board can be an arduous decision especially when you get into the late game so that's something you should definitely know this looks like it might be a light Euro game but in my opinion it's definitely medium if not a bit medium heavy for my taste neutral point number two relates to a couple areas of fiddliness when you're playing the game the production quality of the game is stunning really it's just a gorgeously made game it's got thick cardboard components I love the way the Boom Town all snaps in together but when you look specifically at those mineral tracks you've got these great wooden pieces that are printed and they look awesome but when you try to put a four player game and you put all the caboosas

in that area it just becomes a mess like this the tracks were not big enough I don't think they it was thought about enough like maybe they were going to be small cubes and then at the last minute they upgraded to these awesome caboosas and it just it works but kind of just barely and you need to like leave caboosas off and and stack them up and I just I don't love the way that area looks and I don't love how prone it is to potential mistakes and fillingness and the other thing is just with the tiles out on the board it seems like every single time I played the game for pretty much everyone who's playing the game people have forgotten to flip tiles over when they put a new encampment down and you realize it either on the next turn or maybe a couple turns later and I think that's just because it's one more thing to think about you're thinking about all these things about the things you want to do your strategy the specific things you're doing on a turn and there's just one more thing when you put that in camera down you gotta flip those little tiles over and the fact that it's pretty much happened to everybody means it's probably going to happen to you and it's not a huge deal but it's a bit annoying neutral point number three relates to the number of very difficult painful terms that you can end up having in the game through various reasons uh you will pretty much always have a time where you look out on the board and you're like I just need this one item and this one item like those two things on any tile and you spend like a minute and just look around and you look around again look around a third time and it's just not there and you're like crap okay well what is my secondary thing gonna be and part of that has to do with tile flipping luck you know the person who went before you they put an encampment down and it probably is going to flip over some tiles and you might get lucky and they might flip over the one that you need but you also might not also there might

be one spot on the board and that person that just took the turn right before you went into that one spot and you had this complicated plan that you were all going to be it was going to be based around going in that one spot and now it's gone you need to go back to the the groundwork of figuring out what you're going to do on your turn and then you flip over those new tiles and they don't have what you need so there is a little bit of Randomness there with what is going to come out with the tiles if the exact thing that's going to work for your plan is going to be out there uh and also just when you're playing with the other players they can either intentionally or not really wreck your plans and I've had many turns while I'm playing the game where I just go back to ground one and I figure what what am I going to do from now and and those options are rarely great and you had this wonderful turn and you kind of mourn the loss of that wonderful term that you almost had or that you could have had if that tile had been flipped over correctly and it's just a little bit of harshness that you should be aware of all right now let's go into negative points and the first of these has to do with the point solid nature of the game there is victory points pretty much everywhere you look and this might be on me and me just being a bad board gamer but I found myself while I'm playing the game not really sure what the best thing to do is and what I end up doing is something that just kind of feels interesting enough like I guess solid shoot for that investment um for the night in two turns from now and I'll kind of plan accordingly and then oh like I'll try to kind of stay up on those area majority tracks and oh but there's those racing tracks for the minerals over there and you kind of kind of run around in circles in your brain like what should I prioritize on what should I prioritize on um should I put

this little camera down on the board so that it's next to all my other encampments so I get a bigger bonus for that or do I put it way over here and is that going to be worth it and then you're trying to Crunch in your head okay if I don't go over there then I lose a couple points but I get this and that's going to give me a couple points especially if I put it here and that number point is compared to this number of points and my brain just kind of it just kind of stops and I end up just doing a thing because I don't want people to be staring at me from across the table because again I mentioned the analysis paralysis possibilities and it seems like I rarely decide no this is the right thing to do I usually decide this is an okay thing to do and I hope it works out and then I'm done with my turn and then the next person goes and it comes back to me and I do kind of the same thing again and for certain people I imagine they will always have a game plan they're going for that game plan and that's just not me especially with this game because there's so many mild mathy things that all kind of pile up into a really big pile of decisions that you need to make and you just it's really hard to figure out which way to go so that's a bit of a bummer and negative Point number two definitely stems from negative number one and that relates to the overall atmosphere of the game while you're playing it it is a very quiet situation while you're playing this game because everybody's staring at the board and staring at their board and staring at everybody else's board contemplating they're crunching numbers they're crunching options they're trying to figure out can they pull this off can they pull uh this other thing off and it means that nobody is talking and I've had situations where people come over they're like oh this game isn't very good huh we're like no no it's good like just we're just thinking really hard we don't have the brain space to even talk

to the other person across the table um and their the interaction between the players like you can definitely take spots that you really needed and that is a little bit of indirect action and you can also have somebody maybe bump up really big on a track that you were gunning for and feel like you're definitely interacting there but it doesn't but like it's like it's a silent interaction almost and if somebody takes a thing you really need you're definitely gonna be like ah crap that was perfect that's exactly what I needed and then you'll go back to silence as everybody tries to figure out what's going on and across the room somebody might be playing another Euro game where you're actually talking back and forth and you're you know maybe you're making trades or you just it's not so crunchy that you can figure out what you're gonna do on your turn and then ideally talk about the game or something else with somebody else around the table it's just it's a very dry quiet atmosphere and that's not my preferred way of playing games all right let's discuss gold West's replayability and I think it's pretty good uh definitely above average and it all has to do with that boom town area that I already discussed so I don't want to go into it uh too much again but I just like how random it is and how many don't make it into the game it definitely makes one game feel different from the next because even though you're shooting for those main things uh with every single gameplay the way you make it to getting those Investments or running up those tracks is gonna be slightly different uh based off of how the Boom Town tiles come out I think it's a really good mechanism for increasing the replayability of the game so now let's go into the various player counts that gold West supports it is a two to four player game and I think it's best with three uh the issue I have with it at two is that you only have that one

person that you are competing with for uh dominance on the different terrains as well as racing up the different tracks it feels like you do need more than that one person to keep it as interesting as it can be it's not a bad game at two I would play it again at two uh the board is smaller when it's a two player game so you're definitely still jostling around um but then you flip over to the four player game and it's very tight the board is bigger but um you are all in each other's business like crazy and Analysis paralysis can definitely become an issue especially late game The Last like three rounds going around the table can take forever because there's so many things going on and you can start to tell that you only have X number turns to figure it out so then you start mapping out what can you do in three terms then what can you do in two turns and it definitely slows down uh the three player game has the same size board as the four player game but because there's a one less player it's more open you can have more options you can be less constricted by the different tiles you can go and also just being squeezed out of a an area where you're trying to make consecutive encampments so I think three is definitely the best way to play it but it's fine at two and four I wouldn't say don't play it at either of those counts in conclusion I think the gold West is a very well-designed board game but I don't think it's necessarily for me I have had fun playing it but it's almost been a little too close to work as I'm crunching through all the different things that are going on on a turn when I first heard about the game that I got pretty excited about it I didn't realize just how thinky and point solidity it was going to end up being and I'm okay with having points for all sorts of different things in a game but I have an issue when I start to not be know what I

should actually go for even in the game like about a third to two-thirds to a game I feel like I should be like okay this game I'm going for x and just following through that plan and I never really had that feeling in Gold West I still felt like I was kind of trying to do everything at once and kind of doing it all poorly and maybe that's why I haven't won the game yet maybe I should be dedicating to one specific thing but it hasn't really clicked in to make sense for me there um I do think that uh the way the Mancala system works is brilliant I think that the production value of the game is really great and I think if you like medium to heavy weight you're games you very likely will very much like this game but if you or the people you play with a lot are prone to analysis paralysis you definitely need to know it it can creep in in a pretty big way with this game so ultimately I recommend it to people who enjoy those medium to heavyweight Euros but if you are looking at this and you think that it looks relatively simple I would caution you that it definitely is not at least from my perspective if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also you can directly support the channel at patreon.com John getsgames thanks for watching

Progress saved