I Think GW Should Make Things SIMPLER!
Transcript
in this video I'll tell you why games workshops should make things simpler opinion piece to some degree I mean well really like all of my videos are pretty much opinion as I'm not a journalist or an expert or anything along those lines but I just wanted that up here front that this one is my opinion man I love the concept of necromonda it's a game that's been around for a long time from Games Workshop first came out in the mid 90s was kind of had a big re-release in 2017 and it's just it's necromonda is a a hive City on a world and there's all kinds of stuff going on in Hive cities all the rich people live way up at the top and all the you know the the gangers and the the scum and villeneer all out in the bottom in the sewers and there's all kinds of stuff going on and just a zillion people like packed into one giant structure and there's all the stuff that goes behind it the lore is super interesting to me um a lot of what a lot of my favorite stuff in you know written in for black Library happens in different Hive cities a lot of stuff that goes on and um you know eisenhorn Raven or that kind of stuff but there's also the different kind of emergent narratives that can come from that type of game because it's designed to be played as again a campaign you've got this small group and they kind of grow and get better and
sometimes die and stuff like that I was talking about emergent narratives just quite recently pachao uh the models are spectacular I love the model line I've bought tons of them I'm not going to say about everything I've bought a lot of things um and it's a skirmish Style game right like it's not a big army game it's Skirmish style and that should frankly be like right up my alley you know but sadly I don't play it and it seems unlikely that I will the issue for me is that necromunda is too crunchy crunchy um this discussion came up recently on Twitter I was replying to a friend who had been talking about you know necromonda and whatnot and all that kind of stuff and I mentioned that I that I wish I would enjoy playing it because of you know like all the things that I just mentioned uh in the previous bit about you know the lore and the models and all that kind of stuff but I said that the rules are just too much for me and you know he agreed he said uh he said saying he basically he said that necromonda was the most not-for-you game that Games Workshop has ever made and he was also including apocalypse into that not only is there so much detail in the system rules um you know just the the amount and that's why I'm talking about crunch that's that's a big part of it is the amount of rules and the detail on the rules and all the stuff that goes on uh another friend of mine was running uh an
ash waste demo at the tabletop minions Expo last year it says little convention convention that I run here uh and uh a friend of mine was running a demo of Ash waste that had just come out and the game that they were playing the specific you know scenario every turn each figure had to roll to see if they had gone blind uh if they had I believe um gone insane like some sort of mental breakdown kind of thing that was caused by minerals or animals that were doing it or pheromones I have no idea or and I think the third thing was to see whether or not they were on fire like all of these things just to play to for each activation to start you know and and it's just there's a lot going on and it doesn't seem to be stopping anytime soon and not only all that but the rules and this is the really weird thing for me is that the rules are spread across multiple books and PDFs and whatnot now we expect that with Games Workshop stuff we expect codices and things like that and admittedly they have like you know different House books house cut or in the house and they call them like the the such and such of avarice and such and such of this and what and they give them all these different names so it's kind of a little hard to look at it and go is this a book I need for these guys but there's also stuff that's kind of in PDFs the market stuff is now at least available in PDFs there's stuff in white dwarf there's all these different things the most recent main version of the rule book is I believe and I looked earlier today still only available in the ash wastes box set which is three hundred dollars
and that'll just kind of makes things also more difficult and there's a bit of a pattern here as well I don't play ninth Edition 40K uh because it's got too much going on you know between the the tactics cards the stratagems all that different stuff and then you've also got the the command points and you've got all these different things you've got to track and everything that's going on kind of same thing with Third Edition Age of Sigmar now admittedly both of those games 40K age of Sigmar are also army style games and I'm predominantly into small Skirmish stuff these days I I get it but 40K does have the new um like retooled combat Patrol you know thing that they're doing like I got into 40K originally back in fifth edition uh be and I got into it because of combat Patrol like that's how me and my friends were all playing I was even going to some like little local tournaments and stuff like that but we would get together and play Combat Patrol which back then was 400 points and had all these kind of special you know like you can't take a vehicle bigger than this and you can't do this and you can't have this many wounds and all that kind of stuff and the 500 point is a little bit different to the new you know combat Patrol but then there's also the new boarding action thing as well so there are small versions of 40K that are available but I'm still not playing ninth Edition one of the reasons I'm not into super detailed crunchy games is because they can take up like a really long time to play and I got stuff to do you know I mean I'm not usually interested in taking
four to five hours to play a game and if I even do have that time to play that many hours in a stretch like I've got it set aside I've got four to five hours of stretch I can do it I'm interested in also taking that amount of time to play games and whatever all that kind of stuff then honestly I'd much rather prefer playing two or three or four you know sessions in a row during that same amount of time the other big reason that I'm not super into crunchy games is because frankly I think that super crunchy games go against the idea of tabletop wargaming in the first place tabletop wargaming should be abstract maybe even sometimes a little bit vague right you know you see people in movies and stuff like that and they got those long sticks and they're moving around like troop movements like on a big table during a war or something like that I'm not saying that abstract but still generally kind of abstract because here's the thing simulate nation is actually for video games right so if you are you've got a character and you're going to throw this grenade because you think there's somebody over there so you go and you Chuck that grenade and you're gonna throw it over that fence but it actually it hits that little that flagpole that was right there but you you couldn't hit that if you tried but you didn't try and like you did hit it and then that it bounces off and it lands over there behind that car where there's another enemy over there that you didn't even know was there and it lands right between their legs and blows up and that's pretty awesome except it also causes the car to explode which
then comes over and squishes you against the wall and then you die all that stuff happens in video games every day like the simulation is designed specifically now in this day and age 2023 in first person shooter type games that type of stuff happens all the time you can find that stuff you know all kinds of crazy stuff like that on YouTube but I wonder if that amount of simulation which is fun and great for video games and whatnot specific typically first person shooters I wonder if that amount of simulation that that video games can provide is what's Driving Games Workshop to add more Crunch and rules and detail into their games you know to kind of almost keep up a little bit because after all video games are generally seen as a competitor to tabletop wargaming although Games Workshop does love to you know take money from licensing for video games so maybe they're not as worried as I might think but in general now I'm sure that there are plenty of people out there right now watching this video who prefer the very crunchy aspects of 9th Edition 40K uh age of Sigmar 3.0 kill team 2021 like that kind of stuff and that's fine there's nothing wrong with that again I'm this is this is my opinion right but I know there are people out there who dig that stuff however if the complaints that I see online more and more frequently on you know Facebook and Twitter and all kinds of other places YouTube um if those complaints that I see are any indicator right then specifically
with 40K and to a lesser degree with age of Sigmar and kill team there are a lot of a decent amount of people out there who think like me so then the question becomes is there a fix to this problem with Games Workshop titles um well currently like currently I'm fixing this problem for myself by just not playing those games right like I'm not playing uh 40K I'm not playing age of Sigma or not playing uh I'm not playing the new version of kill team but I am still playing war cry because they made a second edition of war cry this past uh summer 2022 and they didn't make the second edition like weird they didn't change a whole bunch of things and they didn't add in a ton of detail now they did add reactions so they added the kind of like one big thing it's not even that big really but it's just another kind of special ability that you have that does I think add quite a bit to the game and it's really cool and it's also not too much right so they added reactions they tweaked some things here and there they tweaked some stat numbers and some point costs and the compendium and all that kind of jazz but otherwise that's pretty much about it so I'm still enjoying it and I'm still playing it but going forward how does Games Workshop fix this problem if they're actually even interested in doing that like how did they make both the simpletons like me and the crunch enjoyers you know both happy with the same rule set I don't think it seems that hard games have been using optional rules for years
like many games out there have a basic game and then Advanced rules or optional rules or something like that and there is a very strong divider between the two so you know this is the basic stuff and you know you want to get your head Raptor on this first and then you start moving into the other parts and maybe you can even pick and choose and not just be like we have to take all the rest of this maybe it's a little bit here and there one page rules is a great example of this now if you go and download the free version of pretty much any set of one-page rules rules um and you can find those all over the place specifically at their website and whatnot those ruled PDFs generally stop at the end of the basic game okay um and you can play that game with those basic rules and it will totally work and you can have a good time with it and it won't take all day right but then if you buy the full game experience which usually is like five bucks like you but now you have not just like like I think in Grim dark future fire fight the basic game is like 17 pages and if you buy the full thing it's like 38 or 36 or something like that right but you get the full game experience all the extra crunch is added on for example like I said in grimdar future firefight it adds extra missions side missions extra actions random events Battlefield conditions uh terrain effects fog of war the Tactical phase the command points Critical Hits suppression all that stuff kind of sounds a little bit more like
heading towards again simulation and crunch having a very simple base rule set and before you comment just the the free core rules the GW kind of lets you download as a PDF or whatever for their games you know for for free if you can find them it doesn't really count it's sure there's a free version of this and a free version of that but it's still got a lot of the crunch built into it that you don't necessarily need and it's kind of basic and it doesn't really allow you to play the full game to so it's not exactly the same thing right okay but having a very simple base rule set and then having all of the Crunch and the simulation and all that kind of stuff as add-ons right ones that you and your play group can pick and choose yourselves to tailor the game the way you want and to give you and your players agency uh it would really help to cover all different play Styles and get more people playing right tournaments obviously would probably pick the rules and add-ons that they like and publish that and say this is how we're playing the game but frankly they do that already I mean even Games Workshop at official conventions um with the previous version of kill team they just were like we're taking out the the Scout phase that that's not a thing that we're putting in tournaments so you know these things can be variable and having a big list of different uh optional rules Advanced rules whatever you want to call them available to players and term players alike it makes everybody happy so since Games Workshop is certainly watching this video as they do all of my videos
um will they do it will they well uh 10th edition 40K will probably be coming out this summer so about seven months from now um the launch of 8th Edition and the like the indominus box and stuff like that it seems like it was last year it just seems so close but we're on that that three year kick and so it's gonna keep doing that anyway I doubt we'll see anything like this in the upcoming Edition in 10th but I do think the 10th will probably hearken back to the days of 8th Edition to some degree a lot of people are talking about how I'm not the only one talking about I think ninth is is too much and so I have a suspicion because eighth did so well for them in the past they'll they'll just be like let's make another eighth and they'll kind of head in that direction um so I don't know we'll see maybe that'll be something however if I'm wrong uh and for some weird reason 10th edition 40K is even crunchier and like more dense than the ninth Edition well know that there are other Alternatives out there that give you the choice to do what you want and determine how crunchy the war game that you want to play is going to be as always I hope this gave you something to think about in your wargaming hobby if you liked it there's a free like button just down there and then you can hit that and it'll it'll help me out and subscribe if you're not already new videos every single Friday and also a lot more thanks for watching