Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 16:08

welcome to John gets games today I'm going to talk about guild hall this is a sec collection card game with a light engine building mechanic and a whole bunch of player interaction thrown in first I'm going to go over the rules and then i'll tell you what i think in go home there are six different professions and five different colors that consist on these cards what we're trying to do is create sets also known as chapters for each of these guilds which can be turned in for victory points a set is only completed when there is one of each of the five colors in the game inside that one specific guilt so how do we go about doing this well on our turn we have two actions which can be chosen from three different options the first option is to play a card from our hand we'll pretend this blue farmer right here was in our hand now when you play a card there are a couple things to know the first thing is that you do not immediately put it into your ongoing chapter that's in front of you you put it in front of your chapters and only at the end of your turn you take all these cards that might be up here and put them into their corresponding chapters the second thing to note is you're not allowed to play a card into the action area that exactly matches a card you already have inside your chapters so if I had a green farmer in my hand like I potentially do over here I would not be able to play that card into the action area because I already have a grain farmer the third thing to note is that you're not allowed to play the same guild twice in a turn so if i play the farmer as my first action then my second action would not be able to be the farmer so how do these cards work well we see we have rose on the cards and all these cards in the game and that a

number on the left hand side and this correlates to the number of that specific type of card you already have in your chapter so in this case I have a single farmer in my farming guild and I go to the one farmer row and that means I get a single victory point from the bank if I had had three or more farmers over here that I could have taken to victory punch in the bank instead one thing to note you're always allowed to evaluate whatever row up to and including the one that um you qualify for on a card but you have to do everything that's on that specific row the second type of card is the dancer and the dancer is very easy to evaluate you simply draw cards equal to the number of dancers you have inside of your chapter so in this case I would draw four arms and once you've done that you get another action which is great so the dancer pays for itself action wise and you'll get three actions on that term I'd also like to know there is no hand them in this game so you can go well beyond your initial hand of six the third type of card is the assassin now the assassin you'll see has a zero here which means it can actually do its bottom row with zero assassins already in your chapter so we'll see here it says you get to kill one card in an opponent's kill ball and put it into the discard pile if I had two assassins I could have killed two different cards in a single opponents guildhall but they would have had to be from two different chapters and the four level I could do to from the same chapter which is quite powerful the historian is the counterpoint to the assassin and at the zero level the historian lets you essentially take the top card from the discard pile and immediately put it into

the applicable chapter as long as it's legal with the color at the two level which I have right here in front of me I would actually be able to look through the entire discard pile and choose a card that I both want to and legally can play and I put it immediately inside the chapter at the four level you can draw two cards at this point I've actually like to point something out and that is that if I had done this by taking this blue dancer and put it on top of my dancers here then immediately this would have completed a set and whenever a set is completed you turn it over and you put it off to the side and that happens even in the middle of your turn even before you take the cards up here and shuffle them all down you uh and once you have a completed set there's nothing any opponents can do about it the fifth type of card is the Weaver now Weaver lets you take cards directly from your hand and put them into your chapters bypassing the whole playing the card first bit at 0 Weaver's you can put one card from your hand directly into the applicable chapter house at two you can put two cards down from your hand you got to pull one up this can actually be pretty powerful if you want to like pull up a farmer and then play them again later on that turn or in a following turn you can get more victory points out of the farmers by pulling them back up with the Weaver and at the four level you can put as many cards as you want down from your hand into your chapters but you have to pull to back up again the last type of card is the traitor and this is where another bunch of the player interaction comes into play with game at the zero level you central you simply give one opponent one of your cards and you get one of his cards of your choice at the two-level you give

them him or her too and you take two but this has to be legal so you have to make sure they can accept both the cards you want to give and that you can accept both the cards you want to get back from them at the four level you can actually trade an entire chapter for an opponent's entire tracker so i could give an opponent my entire chapter of one card and take their chapter before it could be a pretty big swing so for the second thing that we can do on our turn is discarding cards from our hand and drawing new ones so you can discard as many as you want and then you draw back up to six in this instance maybe I don't need a second blue historian and I don't need a second purple dancer and this green farmer isn't doing anything for me cuz i already have a grain farmer so i could discard those three cards and then draw three more cards getting back up to six cards the third thing that you can do on your turn is you can spend your completed sets of chapters in for victory points so the top of these cards here shows you the number of chapters it costs to take that specific victory point card this nine card over here will cost two chapters where all these only cost a single chapter down on the bottom is a little action box and this is something that happens immediately once you take that victory point card this can be really quite interesting for instance to picture points doesn't seem very much but you can see you can steal an opponent's entire the entire chapter not completed and put it into your guild hall over here with the three you can put as many cards from your hand as you want into your current guild hall at the

four you just get another action which could do something that's really great for instance you can buy two cards you could spend an action to buy a car dance but get a free action to buy another one over here we can just draw five cards the nine doesn't have any action space on the bottom that's just because it has a lot of victory points associated with it the game ends once at the end of a turn where one person has 20 or more victory points so that's pretty much how the whole game plays now I'm going to jump over and tell you what I think about it all right I'm going to begin with things that I really like about guild hall and the very first thing that pop to me was how you're building these small little engines in your chapters down here and as you add cards you get more more powerful effects but as you add cards it gets harder and harder to make each little engine better because there are less legal cards that can be played you know for these dancers there's I can only play a blue dancer and there's only four of them in the entire game whereas this farmer can take every non green farmer as a playable action uh and you know to balance that when I play this farmer with a little guy I get a week action but when I finally get that blue dancer it's gonna be big you know I'm gonna draw four cards and then I you know get this guy and I draw the four cards I complete this I turn this into victory points that's great and then yeah and the next part that's really cool about this whole mechanic is that I now have no dancers if I have three dancers in my hand that were just dead to me because I couldn't play them cuz i already had four out now I can start playing dancers out on the

following turns and working through my hand and building up a little engine again it's just really neat the next thing that I really like about this game is how every single roll seems to have a place in the game like no role in particular seems more powerful or less powerful than the others and and how they they combo really well together you know the farmer might seem kind of boring and weak you just get your victory points but you need victory points to win the game and when you pair a farmer up with the Weaver like I said the rules well that could just be really powerful you know if you have for farmers down in your chapter and then you play a weaver to pull one of them pack and then you play that as your second action the one you just pulled up with a weaver you're generating two more victory points and it's just it's just really really cool you might be in the situation that I was just in where I didn't have this food answer and you know that an opponent has a blue dancer and so there are a couple different options you have you could play a traitor and give them a card to take their blue dancer or maybe you don't have a legal trader in your hand but you could play an assassin to kill that blue dancer and that is your second action you play a historian to take the blue dancer you just killed and go in here and complete it so there's lots of different ways you can get around the fact that there are or fewer illegal cards that you can play because you can see them in other people's decks and also you know as the historians are interesting because the beginning of the game they're very weak because this card pile will be tiny but late-game your discard pile it's going to look like that or not maybe not late game because you cycle through the deck

but at various phases in the game they're storing it's more and more powerful because you're not allowed to look through this before you play the storian but you could remember what might have gone in there or you might just say the odds are really good the card I need is in there especially once people have started completing sense you know if someone completes a set and then pays for it for victory points they put that into the discard pile and now everyone knows there's at least one of every color of that specific role and if you kind of remember that then that can be really good for you so just the way there are other combos as well it's just I really really like how the cards all work together in a very interesting fashion the next thing that I'd like to mention is uh this game this is something I like about the game that I don't necessarily like the chaos of the game that this game can have a little bit of chaos but I like that you can control the chaos because at least in the the base game if there's an expansion for guildhall I haven't purchased uh and I know it changes this and that's actually the reason I have not purchased the expansion is that in the base game of guild hall nothing can affect your hand there is no card than a pony can play that's going to pull something out of your hand so you you're safe with the cards you have in your hand you can decide whether or not you're going to play a card um out there because once you play a card out there it's it's very vulnerable to assassins and traders and that kind of stuff but if it's in your hand it's totally safe and you could plan ahead and wait for the right moment to play your cards out I know the expansion has a card that

lets you take card some other people's hands and that's honestly the reason i bought the expansion um alright so those are the things that I oh actually one other thing going in with the cool combos this victory point system is just really really really really cool that you have this you know these these completed sets that you can spend to buy victory points but almost every victory point has these varied actions they let you combo into other things I mean some of them are reeling you can steal entire chapters of the people like I said and this is just a couple examples of the things you can do there are more in here there's a there's a seven point one that gets you to actions and I think at some point don't quote me on that but there are there are lots of different options in here they add a lot of variety to your turns so that you can you just there's so many ways to combo and do the things you really need it's just it's just really really cool though the victory points and these cards go together so I'm gonna go into the things I'm kind of neutral about like things I want to point out I'm not sure if they're particularly good at particularly bad the first thing is that the iconography in this game while it took a little bit to get used to the first few games I had to have the rulebook out and just had all these things and this got passed around quite a few times as people wanted to double check i mean the eyeball makes sense but i don't know just something about it it took at least half a play before people really started to sink in and totally understand the icons i don't think the icons are bad i can't imagine them doing them better but there's a lot of them on the cards so for a couple people that

was a some people a little slower at getting those into the brain than others but not not particularly a problem next thing is is really just the analysis paralysis problem or actually in this game the trader paralysis problem these five roles not much AP involved but when the trigger when someone played a trader everyone else at the table kind of an okay well this this might take a little bit because especially if if you're playing in a 3 or 4 player game there's just a lot of options you play a traitor and there's all these cards you can give and there's all those cards out there that you can take and what do you want what you probably want one card but if you're playing the two-level trader okay well what other car do you want to get and weld you want to target the person who's in the head over hi it's just the analysis process is not is not terrible but especially with a lot of people around the table is so and if multiple people play the traitor there can be the occasional very slow round intermixed with some quick rounds and that's mostly with the four-player game I'm not going to say that the four-player game and this is bad a a few of the I play the seven times a few of those games have been played for players and they be great spoiler alert I love this game and even with more players it's fine but occasionally especially based on the personality of the people you're playing with in a certain turn or two can slow down pretty heavily when someone's trying to combo a traitor with cashing in some victory points to do some big mega turn and sometimes that's that they look they think I can win this turn please give me a couple minutes and i

think i think i could puzzle this out and get it but like I said that's pretty much always just with the trader with the rest of these cards turns are relatively straightforward and uh yeah oh and also going into that going back into the chaos I mentioned unfortunately you can only do so much planning on your turn you can plan with the cards you have in hand because there's nothing that's going to happen to those but any plan that you're making on a someone else's turn that involves the cards are in front of you you have to keep in mind that this state could be so completely different by the time it gets back to you someone might steal an entire chapter from you they might swap this card with that card you might get you end it's not always bad I mean especially with the traitor someone might unwittingly give you cards that work really well with the cards you have in your hand it just there's only so much pre-planning you can do when it's not your turn unfortunately um now I'm going to shift into the things I dislike about this game and I'll be totally honest I was only able to come up with one thing and it's it almost could be a neutral it and the one thing that I potentially have a problem with is that uh you can sometimes just know you're out of this game like you could be three quarters away through the game and you're just looking at your piles and your look at your victory points and you're looking at your opponents and you're like that person just nothing I can do that person over there is gonna beat me out they just for some reason maybe they played better maybe they got a little bit more lucky although I don't think luck is that huge in this game there's a lot of room for very intelligent play to get you ahead I just sometimes there's just one player and there at eight points and someone else is at 17 and it's just those last two

turns around the table or so they just kind of checked out because they know there's they know they're not going to win and sometimes you know someone says well I'll get the best points i can i'll shoot the third and that's fine but I'm also just the there you can there there really is no ketchup mechanic in the game there's lots of leader bashing potential but once again once they you know once you have a completed set over here there's nothing anyone can do about that if you have a massive hand there's nothing anyone can do about that so I don't know I'm not gonna say there's a runaway leader problem with this game at all but every now then there's a a run behind follower who just cannot catch up uh but I'm really scratching to try and find things I dislike about this game I this game is excellent i really really love it i'm kind of surprised i've only played at seven times i'm looking forward to playing this one another 20 and it's definitely going to stick around for me for a long time I hope you've enjoyed my review please let me know if you have any questions or comments thanks

Progress saved