Skip to main content
Loading video...

Keyflower Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 18:11

hey everybody today i'm talking about key flower which is a 2012 release board game designed by sebastian bliesdale and richard breese this one accommodates two to six players and takes 90 to 120 minutes to play this one the two key mechanisms are bidding and worker placement but there is a fraction or an element of tile placement as well so the table state is going to look like this when the game starts you've got a number of these hexagonal tiles depending on the player count so an example here we've got a three player game where you're going to have these seven season tiles out there you're gonna have two turn order tiles and you've got a number of boat tiles as well which is important for future reference in terms of getting more resources into your supply and we've got the additional seasons here waiting to be played in future rounds you've got a number of these kind of profession tokens which are face down and you've got these green workers here and your bunch of resources each player's also got their home town tile here looks like this these very very very slightly and each player is also going to get given eight workers at random in in three different colors so you've got yellow workers you've got red workers and you've got blue workers at least initially and that's going to be your kind of resource throughout the game and what you're going to use to activate these tiles and actually acquire these tiles so as a general rule each season works in the same way with the exception of winter because winter you are actually given the tiles at the beginning of the game and these towers are going to have end game victory conditions on them so for example here for every set of each worker i have i'm going to get three points

or if i have five different resources or any resources on this windmill at the end of the game i'm gonna get five points or the water mill if i ever every same resource i have on this tile i'm going to get a 0.4 so these kind of give you a direction or a strategy to go for throughout the game and when winter comes around you can either choose to play these up for grabs as a normal season tile or you can choose not to put them into play if you don't think you're going to do so well and i will say that this was actually one of the concerns i had about this game because i generally don't like it when um games force you to make a decision that you you're not really prepared to make especially for for new players however these are extremely simple and they're quite clear on what they want and um that kind of concern was uh instantly rectified and um just just disappeared because this isn't a hard decision to make and you are flexible and whether you want to play these or not so um that initial concern was completely gone so let's talk about how gameplay actually works so as i said each player is going to have their random assortment of these um of these workers behind their screens here so no other player is going to see what you have and then in turn you are either going to activate one of these tiles by placing a worker on them like so like for example if i did this i can convert a yellow worker into a green worker um or i can choose to bid on that tile by putting a number of workers on my side of that hexagon so for example if i really wanted the ability to um have this keystone quarry here i could bid

say two yellow workers which means that i'm bidding two at this time and then they'll go to the next player and they can either choose to raise that bid by by bidding more workers however they are restricted now to only playing with that color that's already been allocated to it so as soon as a resource is dedicated to one of these tiles either by activating the tile or by bidding for it then that's going to be locked in and the other players are going to be subject to only using that type of worker if another player decides to outbid you then you have the ability to move these workers as long as they stay together to another tile where you can use to bid for them or you can even choose to activate them so when you activate a tile you simply allocate a number of workers onto them and get the depicted resource here um on this top box so here i'll get two of these black resources um however there are some further restrictions on these worker placement spots where if um you or you are restricted to only having six total workers on there so say for example if the first player bid one in order to get these two resources and if somebody wanted to go there after they'd have to bid two and then after that they'd have to bid three but after that there is no chance of going any further because you are limited to a strict value of six workers on any of these tiles now on top of all this is quite an important factor of um of bidding because say for example some people had used to uh had used workers to use this activation spot here and somebody actually ends up winning the tow uh the title at the end of the game or end of the round

then not only are they going to discard these kind of back to the supply but they're actually going to acquire all the workers bid on that tile so you know you are potentially giving away workers which is an important resource um when you choose to activate powers that somebody else has bid on so once everybody has decided to pass and no longer bid for any of these um of these spots or use them as their work replacement spots then all the ones that haven't been bid for are going to get discarded however all the ones that have been bid for are going to be allocated to your own little hometown here so as you can see i've won these two tiles i've placed them onto my little tableau here abiding by the restrictions so roads have to go into roads for example water will have to go into water now this means that from now on i can choose to activate these work replacement spots and not only that i can actually choose to keep hold of my workers when i do so but you are not actually only restricted to using your own tile so for example this plate over here may have acquired these tiles like so i can actually still choose to use those worker placement spots should i choose to so if for example i wanted to play my yellow work here i could still get a black resource which would go straight on to my hometown tile like this however i've got to bear in mind that when i do that then i'm actually giving this worker up to that player so there's quite an interesting economy here where you when when you acquire more um more tiles and you really want something somebody else's has got in their little tableau

then you are going to have to give workers away to that player which of course gives them a lot more power to not only use new tiles but to use their own tiles and to bid for future tiles as well as you acquire more and more resources you have the ability to upgrade your previously bought tiles by using this action here so say for example i place my my blue worker here this means i can activate this ability which means i can move one of my resources from tile to tile and i get to have one upgrade represented by this kind of upwards arrow which looks a bit like a house and when you do that you can either move resources as i said you could move this resource to here to here as a as a one movement action and i also get one upgrade action and sometimes that might say you know you need to spend one of these additional uh kind of profession tokens like i have here and if i choose to do so i can just upgrade that token by flipping it over like so which means that i now have a more improved version of that action now i can acquire gold and get more victory points at the end of the game so as you're building more and more of a tableau you're going to want more movement points so you can start shifting these resources around and upgrading as many tiles as you can players can also choose to go for these player turn tokens here where as normal you'd bid for that um bid for that action and the player with the most um workers allocated through sports in end of the game or end of the round will get priority on taking the boats that they want in future rounds we're just going to ship them more workers in maybe they're short of a certain color and they can't compete in a color then for example they might want to take this tile here and get all these reds

and also some of them have these uh profession tokens which of course are really useful for upgrades and sometimes for scoring abilities as well and that's going to basically how that works so again if you want if you're really specific on what you want and particular about what you want then you can choose to sacrifice workers in order to get priority and give you a lot more autonomy on what you want into your supply and that's basically how each round's going to work obviously you're going to get a new bunch of tiles from round around which are going to ramp up in what they can do in their power and what they produce and how you're going to get victory points but that's the general fundamentals of the game however you know despite the simple rule set there's quite a lot of depth here and a lot of decisions to be made and for example as the game develops you're going to have the ability to get these green workers and these green workers are really powerful because nobody actually starts with any of them and of course they are just a brand new resource where if you have the monopoly on them then nobody is going to be able to compete with you so if you know for a fact that nobody else has a green worker you can end up getting quite a powerful tile in your in your city for a very very cheap price so yeah as you can see like you're going to end up trading our resources in to get all these um professional tiles to get a bunch of other resources you can do the same here you can convert workers into one other you can convert one worker into two other workers and you can convert tiles into other tiles some tiles in the summer even give you these boat abilities which give you kind of game breaking rules such as in this example if um if somebody chooses to lock in a in a tile here as blue

i can actually get around that and still compete in a different color so i could say i'll be two reds which normally you wouldn't be able to do and as the game goes on you start getting into autumn you're gonna start finding more and more ways to get victory points and converting goods into others for example so you want to be making sure you're pushing resources around your tableau into the right areas to get you all those juicy end game points so despite being a relatively straightforward game in terms of its rules this game has a lot of depth and a lot of nuance so for example of course you want to be building the best city you want to be making sure that your roads are connecting for example and making sure you have enough ability to shift goods around because if you don't you're going to end up having to use other players boards and ultimately giving away your your workers now that the idea of the workers is definitely the hook for me in this game it kind of has this real economic feel to it where you know you have to be wary about what you have behind your screen you have to be worried about giving to your opponents about even like an idea of memory where you know i know i'm strong and yellow so i can really compete on the tiles i want to get i'm being aware that i'm going to have to throw away the ones back into the supply when i win these tiles and if i choose to use them as workers without actually acquiring the tiles in the first place then i'm risking losing them to other players as well and of course if i want to use other players tiles then i'm also giving them those workers making them stronger in future rounds now of course you've got the ability to bid for um player order as well in terms of getting the new workers you want in

uh you want to be making sure that you get particular upgrade tokens as well so that you can actually upgrade your your little buildings here and end up getting more and more victory points like so and getting more upgraded abilities so yeah there is a lot going on here and and player interaction is embedded in this game you cannot get around the way or get around avoiding uh the way you interact with other players because it's fundamental to this game you're out bidding each other you're using each other's tiles other people are using your tiles and it all really is about min maxing and getting that best cost benefit of each of your actions the game is silky smooth i mean there's little to no confusion in terms of uh kind of portraying the rules or explaining the rules to other players because it is so simple you know just using that user worker placement sport or end up just uh bidding for one and of course building up your little town which is so so simple but again i always love games that have such a simple rule set but just a plethora of options loads of different routes you can go down different end game strategies you've even got that mitigation of you know having the uh having the winter tiles knowledge or having the knowledge of those winter tiles that were given to you at the start of the game so you have the option to build towards something as well which other players might not be wary of but even in that facet where at the end of the game when it comes to winter then people are going to have the option to play those tiles down or not so that even if you even if you do build towards a certain strategy for example you know if i wanted one of each worker type leftover it's going to get me

x amount of points then i can actually choose to play that but i might not even win that tile because it's going to be put up to auction just like all these other location spaces and also despite all these being relatively simple mechanisms in their own right you know simple bidding simple work placement and simple town building i suppose they come together so seamlessly and kind of a game that's bigger than the sum of its parts i would say and that slight twist of locking in colors when you play when you play one of your actions is just genius because as i said earlier you know you could know that you have a particular strong you know strong fleet of a certain type of worker and you know that other people can't compete with you so that's just a great idea of just um knocking people out spots and there's also an additional wrinkle where if you want to use a certain spot as um as workers you know for example if i really wanted to use this spot here if i end up placing three workers down there at once instantly then i'm actually blocking other people out of using that because as i said you can only ever go to a spot uh with six workers and each time somebody has to raise you so if somebody else went there after me they'd have to place four workers which of course is an illegal move because there'll be seven total so that's just an extra little wrinkle there and all these little wrinkles just build up to quite a rich game which i absolutely adore i think the pacing of key flower is excellent now each of these rounds do fly by pretty quickly and before you know it you know the

initial ones in spring are just kind of acquiring resources and then the second one they're kind of converting those resources and giving you abilities and then it's all about caching all those things you've built into victory points and it certainly doesn't outstays welcome it feels like it's ticking along out rapidly from start to finish and it's it just again it always feels that you need to be on the ball and you can't waste your actions the replayability of the game is pretty damn good because depending on the player count you're not going to see all the tiles from game to game you know there's a whole bunch of tiles for each season and um you know you're only going to play a certain amount of those the rest are going to remain in the box and but not only that you are obviously not going to be winning the tiles as well each time you want them so of course you're competing constantly and sometimes you won't be able to compete because of that imperfect information about which um which works you have at your disposal so you're going to have to be able to zig and zag and try different strategies and build towards different things because you're not going to have your hands on the same tiles from round around so yeah i really do like the replayability and i think there's a lot of scope for getting to the table several times from a production and aesthetics point of view i think the game's decent i mean i do like the artwork and stuff i'm not so keen on some of the symbology on these cards i think it looks a bit too a bit too simple but basic and a bit too prototypish it would be nice to see a bit more uh you know a bit more bling on the symbology and it feels just a little bit amateurish but i am nitpicking it certainly doesn't detract from the gameplay at all you know certainly

uh the gameplay outshined that massively um also these player screens aren't the best although they look wonderful you know like these houses they're a little bit flimsy kind of this plastic um sheet kind of thing the sheet paper it just doesn't it's not gonna really hold up very well and the mine's already starting to fray and stuff and they just they're just not as good as i would have liked to know a lot of screens um a lot better than these ones and it would be nice to see nice robust cardboard ones but other than that you know all the cardboard stock is quality you know these are really durable the tokens are fine you've got the additional workers as well and all the resources again they're all these cylinders so i suppose some people might prefer um kind of individual resources but for me i've got no issue at all with that the game is not overly expensive so i think it's all proportionate in terms of what you're paying for and ultimately i'm perfectly happy with the production and artwork so overall i am absolutely delighted with key flower this is such a lovely game and these are the kind of games that just do stay in my collection for the long haul games of simple elegant rules but with a well of deep strategy the economy is just so satisfying how are you going to spend your workers how you're going to give them away to other players if you're willing to do that if you want to invest in your own little city and just keep your own little closed economy here loads of different things to go for the pressure of moving these resources around is great just the little element of city building is just satisfying enough you've got the individual player powers you can invest in that interaction of bidding for different tiles the interaction of blocking people from certain spots

and it's just it's just a wonderful package as i said earlier better than the sum of its parts in fact way way better than the sum of its parts it just comes together just magically and it's not often that when i play a game as soon as i play it i just it just clicks me i think yeah this is good this is the good stuff that we're all looking for and i know i know key flower is regarded as one of the best kind of euros of the modern era you know certainly still extremely well regarded you know nine years on from its uh premise initial release and i will say this one definitely holds up well way better than 90 95 percent of the other worker placement games out there because as i always kind of say on this um on this channel work replacement games have to be something special for me to enjoy them because there are so many pedestrian ones out there and this one is just magnificent um yeah two mechanisms i love the economy i love uh just the little wrinkles of strategy and little little nuances i love such as the green workers you know the idea of giving works to other people buying tokens that other people have bid on to get those workers it all just comes together wonderfully so this one is a top-tier game and certainly one of the best games i've played this year this one definitely gets my elite shield so my highest accommodation there and i've got no reservations whatsoever giving it that because this game is fantastic so that concludes my thoughts on key flower i hope you've enjoyed this video if you have please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved