The games i got rid of in 2024
Transcript
this video is brought to you by the 3-minute board game patrons keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon kyota Coto and welcome to this video about the games I got rid of in 2024 now it's a relatively short list this year of only around about 20 games I got quite backlogged last year with games because of working on red dust rebelling coming out working on the kickstarter and the final design work for shadow Moon syndicates and working on my book that's coming out in May this year and because of all of that I ended up not playing quite as many games as I wanted yet the games kept arriving so I have a giant backlog that I desperately trying to work through right now and as part of that I'm going to do some combination reviews shortly where I review a bunch of games all at once just to clear through that backlog and get those games out of the house but until then here are the 20 odd games that I got rid of in 2024 and why I got rid of them and we'll start off with Assassin's Creed now assassin's cre is actually a very cool game it's based on the computer game and it captures that computer game feel quite well it's a stealth game and it's all about how to plan out an assassination run get in do what you need to do and get out with a minimal amount of fuss the problem is it's ginormous it's one of those big Delux Edition games it takes up a huge amount of space so while I like the game I wasn't in love with the game and keeping that on the Shelf would have been getting rid of another five or six games in its place and there's very few games I consider to be that good still
if you like the idea of stealth games you like Assassin's Creed you've got a ton of shelf space and plenty of money because it's a very expensive game it would be worth checking out but if you don't took all those boxes Assassin's Creed's probably not for you certainly wasn't for me in the end the second game on the list is Barcelona which is a pretty good game it's a mid to heavyweight Euro game but the problem is I have a ton of mid to heavyweight Euro games already in my collection and not a lot of people to play them with you see my main test group is into that sort of game but we tend to play the games that we're testing on the channel don't tend to revisit games that often and my other groups are more interested in more thematic fear than they are something like Barcelona it's got a really cool action system in it and it is a very interesting game but for me it wasn't interesting enough to take the spot in my collection compared to something like a a guy project or a barrage or something like that simply put Barcelona is a good game but it wasn't quite good enough for me to want to keep it and it certainly wasn't good enough for me to want to teach it to people one of my big bug bears at the moment is teaching middle to heavyweight Euro games to people a lot of the time I'd rather pull something off the shelf like June Imperium that they already know and just play that rather than teach a new game and with a number of games coming through with the channel I just can't afford to keep something like Barcelona around good game just not a great fit for me it's the sort of game that if I went to someone's house and they all knew how to play it I'd gladly play it again but I can't be asked teaching it again next up is a game called Deep state which is all about
conspiracy theories and shadowy forces controlling the government I got sent this as a review copy a very long time ago and every time I went to table it people were just not interested in playing it used to be kind of fun back in the ' 80s and '90s to laugh about the Illuminati but way too many people take this stuff seriously these days and talk about the Deep State and all that kind of stuff for it to have that Whimsical Joy it used to and when I finally did get it to the table the game playay was kind of Aver so you have this combination of a lackluster dated theme and gameplay mechanics that are kind of me and yeah just it wasn't a game that I felt particularly interesting and was happy to see the back off next up is dog park a game that I like the first time I played it but the more and more I played it and the more I got into it the more I didn't like it very much at all gamep play as a combination of auctions and a Parks type system where you collect resources and initially when you're playing it it feels like a very approachable friendly sort of game but then they put out the expansion which I also got which bolts on all these extra systems onto a game that just can't handle them and it felt like a bloated convoluted mess for for what it was and yeah the more I played it the more I was like who's this game for who's the target audience for this because toy store game people are going to be put off by its complexity and Euro game fans are going to think it's a little bit shy so I can't quite figure out exactly who dog park is for these days it's certainly not for me Doctor Who Don't Blink is next and it's a sort of lightweight small box off offering from gale force 9 around Doctor Who and the
whole weeping angel thing so the Weeping Angels only move if you're not looking at them and the game play kind of represents you trying to get away from these things that as long as you're facing them they can't Advance towards you but overall it's a sort of mediocre flimsy IP game that you sort of come to expect over the years uh the unfortunate thing here is this is G Force 9 and they at one point used to be really really really good for making IP based games uh they did the firly game they did Spartacus uh Star Trek assist and a few other Sons of Anarchy a few other IP based games that were really really good but their offerings of late have not been great and don't blink is a very forgettable game like don't blink and you'll miss it next up is Enigma Beyond code and this is a game of quite an interesting premise it's all about code breaking and the Enigma machine it's a deduction game you kind of play like a party game and the average round only takes about 10 minutes to play the problem I have with this one is it felt way harder to teach than it really should should have been it should be a comparatively simple game but the people I tried teaching it to really struggled to sort of rock on to what was actually going on here which meant it failed in the niche I wanted this game to be which was as a small box uh filler game that I can use at the start or end of sessions with people because it was just something about how the game worked that didn't click and every time I tried explain the game I just somewhat failed and it just took way longer than it should have uh so I kind of got rid of this one just because it was a slightly frustrating teach next up is is forever home by the same people who designed dog
park and in every way shape or form this is a worse game than dog park it's a much lighter game and it feels like it was pitched at a much more casual crowd but fundamentally I found it mechanically a bit busted and broken there was some degenerate strategies that really seem to pay off now in my reviews of games I don't tend to go on too much about strategy or balance because normally I'm only playing a game three to five times before reviewing it you know just enough so I can learn the game and give you the cliff notes in the 3 minute format but this is one that after I played at those times we we kept looking at it and yeah there was just something a bit busted about it something a bit wrong and I was pretty happy to get rid of it uh it's kind of ugly too and just yeah just a vaguely unpleasant kind of dog game it definitely did not find its forever home here next we have king of Monster Island which is actually a rock solid kind of game uh the problem with king of Monster Island is it's a ginormous box and it's a more complex form of King of Tokyo well it's a sort of a Cooperative version of King of Tokyo and basically the people I like to play King of Tokyo with didn't want to play a Cooperative version of that not quite happy playing a competitive version of King of Tokyo which is why I kept my King of Tokyo Dark Edition and got rid of king of Monster Island because when people want their giant monsters they want to be smashing each other in the face they don't want to be working as a team at least that's what my group was like still of the idea of getting Giant monsters and smashing things cooperatively does appeal to your group
you probably will like king of monster iseland it's it's a pretty good Game it just wasn't a great fit for my groups uh next up is mywind the game that made my bottom game of 2024 I think mywind is awful I think mywind is a game designed to drain you of your will to live it is a cozy game it's a game where you're supposed to sit down and do like wood activities and build things and steadily progress and develop your village it just takes 3 hours each session or so to get freaking nowhere it is a Time sync of a game there's there's nothing fundamentally happens your decisions don't matter you just go through a process it's like doing your taxes over and over and over again until the Sun Burns Out mywind is the antithesis of what I find engaging in in a game there's no challenge there's no uh sense of urgency there's nothing to really sink your teeth into it's just nebulous busy work absolutely rich gameplay experience uh looks nice like the box is pretty the Arts pretty and the the game components are well made and everything it's just the game is evil uh because evil things waste your
time probably most controver commcial game on this list will be nucum because I hear a lot of people like nucum and they think it's absolutely awesome I've heard it described as the bastard child of barrage and Brass Birmingham and there in lies the problem it's also got a little bit of power grid going in there as well so if you taken power grid brass birming and barrage and put them into a blender you come up with nucleum the problem is I would rather play Brass Birmingham barrage or power grid than nucum itself as say it's a terrible game or anything it's just a nightmare to teach to people one of the worst teachers uh of any Euro game I've played it's just a convoluted mess in many respects it's a fine enough game but yeah I think the other games that it is derivative of or it's inspired by um are just better games than nucleum itself again this is what I probably play at someone's house so they dropped it on table and said we're going to play nucleum and we all know how to play it then I would probably play a game of nucleum but the idea of teaching this to another group that's not quite paying attention to the rules teach uh gives me the White Knuckle Terror I don't want to go through that again yes a nucleum i' I'd rather just play barrage or brass be a great games nucleum is a good game it's not a great game next up is snapship tactics a game I really really enjoyed and thought was a really good time to play there's just one major problem with snapship tactics
and that it's a skill Skirmish game and skirmish games really need a community around them you need to have more than just one or two people to play against so you can you know build your specific Fighters and kit them out the exact way and come up with strategies to defeat different people they just don't quite offer enough out of the box if you're only going to be playing with one or two people and people need to be invested in it themselves you can't just turn up and go hey here's a ship I built for you next fight that's not quite how skirmish games really work you know things like blood ball or a necromunda or X-Wing they need a Vibrant Community around them to make the game feel supported and like there's something Dynamic that you're working inside of with the game snapship tactics does not have that it's barrier to entry is colossal so when I see there was only one problem the actual problem here is it's ginormously expensive and there's very few players and that is a death nail for anything that's a skirmish game Cool figure cool mechanics uh it's just I knew no one else was going to spend money on this game I wasn't going to be able to get anything out of it they were just going to be cool toys that sat on a shelf forever and I thought well maybe someone else will get some joy out of this so I let the game go cool mechanics though if this game was repackaged with small accessible effective Fighters like it's a really good gameplay system here for Starship combat just not with the really really expensive figures that came with I mean those those things are
cool as toys but boy are you limiting yourself to the size of your audience with that price tag and that style of game skirmish games need to be accessible and they need to have a low entry point and snapshot tactics they not do that at all next up is solar sphere and this is going to be the weirdest thing you'll probably hear in a border game review in your life solar storm is a co-op game that I always played solo about being on a space station that's blowing up and you're trying to stop it from blowing up it's a classic firefighting Co-op game where you have limited time and bad things are happening to you constantly and you have to run around and try and solve all those problems to win the game I quite enjoyed solar storm and I've still got a copy of it solar sphere is the sequel to this game and I know very little about solar sphere despite having got rid of my copy because they printed the rule book in a material that makes my skin crawl so I've not mentioned this on the channel before I don't think or I haven't very often but I am on the auto spectrum and there are a few things that set me off and one of them was the texture to this rule book there's something fundamentally I I could not handle I couldn't pick up the rule book I felt physically repelled by it I had to put it down go away and get someone else to put it back in the box there was something about it that really really fundamentally upset me and it's almost impossible to get across to someone who uh isn't on the Spectrum or doesn't have something similar how visceral um this
was and how like even even now I'm actually feeling like weirded out by thinking about this this rule book and the lovely people at the company it's it's got nothing to do with them that how would they know that this was going to um you know literally get under my skin that much and make me that uncomfortable and they often send me a different copy of the rule book and I'm like I I can't I can't think of your game now without having my skin crawl um so that is yeah even now I'm just like fritzing out about how awkward um that rule book and the texture of it of it made me feel just who gross like deeply unsettling and i' no idea how good a game it is uh for all I know it's an amazing game it's a brilliant game it's a wonderful game I will I will never know because I just I couldn't get over that because of this neurological thing and yeah that is the weirdest reason I think I've ever gotten rid of a game or I've um not been able to review a game is just the teure of the Rob book gave me the absolute heavy jbi anyone out there uh owns solos spere um go touch the rle book and see if see if you have that kind of response or see if you can understand what there what it is about the rle book that that got to me but yeah uh hi I'm I'm Jared from 3 board games um I am on the autism spectrum I have a person with autism and
sometimes it comes out um and this is one of those times it might be why I'm really good at condensing things into summaries though it's probably part of why I can do the channel next we have Star Trek away missions and Star Trek away missions has a lot of the same issues that I mentioned with snapshat tactics it's a skirmish game in this case it's got a lower barer to entry but it doesn't really have a community either I don't think this one's done very well and I don't think there's a lot of people out there playing it uh there's just something about the game as well that fell flat for me it felt like a skirmish game but really it was like completing missions it was all so Mission focused that you could essentially ignore your opponents in some ways and just go and complete your missions and you can have two teams where it's actually more incentivized for people to just go and complete missions all over the place than it is for them to shoot each other just felt very very weird as a skirmish game to me I get the idea of skirmish games being with you just mow down your opposition being a little one-dimensional this felt like an overc course correction to the point where if people had built their decks in certain way their mission decks in certain ways fighting was almost no point to it aside from to slow your opponent down but any action you're taking to slow your opponent down as an action you're not using to complete an objective unless your objective is to damage your opponent so again if both sides are full of missions that aren't about damaging their opponents just kind of run past each other very very weird
sort of game H yeah so Star Trek way missions had a lot of Hope for this one but I think this is the kind of product that's going to be dead in a year or two and yet again gForce 9 they used to be one of the great publishing houses for IP based games but yeah there's not a lot coming out of them these days that feels particularly great and as a New Zealander that bugs the hell out of me because they are New Zealand's biggest board game publisher
only four games to go and this one is tillum or tum or Tilly tuby tumt or however this place's name is pronounced and if you've been paying attention to the video you'll probably figure out why this one left the collection as well and that's because it's a m to heavyweight Euro game that I don't want to teach to anyone and I actually thought this one was pretty average as far as the games go I would play nucleum or Barcelona before I play tala it then again it's super inoffensive as well uh so yeah this is just another mediumweight Euro game that's fine it's okay but there's so many medium to medium heavyweight Euro games out there uh that I just yeah don't need to worry about this one next up we have Twilight of the Gods and honestly I cannot remember a single thing about this game aside from that it was designed by Chris KY uh who was a punter in the NFL of I recall and it's turned out to be quite a interesting fascinating dude online ever since he's also known as Chris Warcraft now I looked up this game to refresh myself to say hey why did you get rid of this one and there's basically no owners of it so they published the game sent me a review copy and then no one bought it so I don't have anything particularly insightful and informative to say about it I can't remember a damn thing about the game I know I set it up and played it and it's like a a collectible card game format utterly utterly forgettable or at least I forgotten everything about it and I have a very very good memory V
sabotage another genuinely good game this is virally the same game as Assassin's Creed in in fact Assassin's Creed is a adaption or modification of V sabotage V sabotage is set in World War II and it's all about World War II Commandos it's a Cooperative stealth game where again You' got A Sneak in do as much damage as you can complete your mission and get out with creating as little noise and distraction as as possible because once the fights happen uh your Commandos aren't good enough to take on whole hordes of enemies you much better to sneak in stab people quietly and then blow things up ultimately it wasn't the sort of game that interested me hugely like I respect this game I think it's a very good game but I find the gameplay Loop sort of slightly frustrating uh because you really do want to get in and do it perfectly and get out without having the fights when you're getting attacked on all sides that's really an indicator you've screwed up and to me the frustrating element was I feel like you had to do the mission perfectly because once you screwed up and the alarms went off things were so rough and so bad that you might as well just start again and I didn't find that game play stealth look very rewarding it was sort of yeah if you've ever played a stealth game on uh PC like one of the ones where you got machine guns or a thief type game and once the alarm goes off you you're just running around for the rest of the live desperately trying to wait for the alarms to go down well in V sabotage the
alarms never go back down you're just on that constant flight fight mode and you're out gunned and you really really unless you're right at the end of the mission you're probably going to die it's just a matter of time and ultimately that wasn't my cup of tea so yeah V sabotage if you're into that sort of perfect stealth game and are happy to play through and maybe reset when you up um then you'll you'll probably enjoy V sabotage for me it was just a little required a little too much finesse and last and almost certainly least we have waterfall Park the reimagining of Chinatown now Chinatown is an absolutely brilliant game about Chinese communities in the 1960s uh with racist zoning laws try to do the best they can with allocations of land and setting up businesses so that they become all prosperous it's a really cool game I have played it with some people of China to who find it a bit cringe and apparently that sentiment had got back to the Publishers that some people did find the game quite cringeworthy with its theming and clearly they went well oh oh well what's the least offensive thing possible I know a waterfall park because this game makes no freaking sense at all it's set instead of in Chinatown where you're trading businesses you are all working in the same water park and you get randomly allocated plots in this water park and then you have to trade things between each other and set up
attractions in this water park who are you meant to be in this game you're you're all working in the same water park it makes no sense it's it's like they was just so pissed off and indignant that some people might have had a a problem with the original Chinatown theme that they threw a tantrum and this is what they made as a response mechanically it's a giant step back in every regard the the game shortened which ramps up the randomness in it the map is awful and how it's laid out and overall it's just an ugly giant step backwards and I can only imagine that it's this way because someone either the designer or one of the Publishers took that feedback on board that Chinatown was a little bit cringe and threw their toys about it and this is what we got as a response and yeah I would like to see Chinatown remade again then something decent this time I or it just bring back the original China down it turns out that a game being slightly cringer theme is way way better than turning the game into a pile of crap waterfall Park absolute trash one of my two least favorite games of last year along with mywind uh absolutely angry after playing both those games and I'm glad that they are out of my collection so that concludes the games I got rid of this year and it was a very small list because of the back I've had I have some big videos coming up soon where I'm going to review a whole bunch of games uh all at once and then next year there
should be a really massive games I got rid of video because I have limited Space Games keep coming in I need somewhere to put them and uh currently some of them are sitting in the ceiling up there and that's not a great place for board games board games should be being played and being handled by people board game shouldn't be sitting up in my ceiling and if you have any strong opinions on the games I got of let me know in the comments if you got rid of a ton of games last year let me know which ones in the comments and let me know why and as always if there's any games you think I might like based on my comments here let me know in the comments as well and a reminder 3 minute board games does not do paid content keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon and you enjoyed the video like share and subscribe to the channel