Maracaibo: The Uprising Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast
Transcript
hello and welcome back to friendly ties uh today i'm here with my friends jonathan and nick and we are going to be talking about maracaibo uprising which is the expansion to maracaibo that just came out this year uh in 2022 you could be listening to this in any year but right now in 2022 this has just come out and we've had the opportunity to play this a couple of times together i think nick and john have played a time themselves with another friend of ours and we've been having a lot of fun with this one so let's dive in and talk about it yeah so this is the first time we're highlighting an expansion which is kind of interesting um and uh we've talked about maracaibo quite a bit well i guess you all did uh in a previous episode uh where we did uh well i keep saying we it was uh anastasia nick it was the two of you doing strategy and today we're gonna really just branch off from that again and also take a similar stance to the previous strategy episode where we're not gonna go into a description of how the base game really works um we'll be sort of assuming you are relatively familiar with the game although um we'll we'll try to give you some framework for sure i will say that from a john gets games perspective um which is my youtube channel i did make a tutorial video for that one so if you are at all interested in learning how markibo plays if you want to watch that before this episode i
totally understand and i put a link to that in the description of this episode now this expansion actually brings in four different modules that you can play or i guess scenarios is a better way to put it and we've played two of them but overall the main idea is two of these modules are a fully cooperative experience which is very different from the base game because that's a competitive and then the other two modules are competitive uh we played one of the cooperative ones and one of the competitive ones and we're going to talk about those today we're gonna do some cross comparison and and all that kind of stuff uh we want to start with the cooperative though um or certainly i do because i feel like i'm slightly more excited about that one because it really turns this game on its head uh the expansion is called uprising and the main idea thematically is that instead of fighting for europe in the caribbean like you do in the base game you can now be a part of the uprising and actually fight against europe removing them from the caribbean while still doing a whole bunch of maracaibo type stuff so in the cooperative game that we played um europe already started like they controlled everything and then we collectively kicked them out and i really enjoyed the overall experience and i'm curious how it uh played out for you two so when it comes to expansions i'm a total cheapskate and i almost never like to pick them up uh and i really want an expansion to do something just very fundamentally
different with the game like i want to feel like i just purchased us a second game essentially and i think the co-op version of maracaibo does this uh you're still playing maracaibo in this game there's no question about it but i was really impressed by how the cooperative was executed in this well actually of the four modules of in this expansion the cooperative is actually your favorite right john yeah yeah it is i i mean i've played a decent amount of competitive maracaibo but the cooperative one um really i guess surprised me with how different and familiar it felt uh there's a couple things that are different with it uh for one thing you're fighting against jacques collectively it's essentially a super yeah jacques is a super easy ai to facilitate you just draw a card every single time it's their turn and then they do something simple and they get a bunch of points and the thing is everyone needs to get a bigger score than shock which is kind of cool it means that just because one person is doing really well and doesn't mean you're all going to win like everybody needs to beat jacques so maybe somebody needs to sacrifice some good moves to make somebody else around the table do well because you know it's it's cooperative there's also some asymmetries and whatnot um but you know that fighting against this entity together i just found it really fun to be playing mark ibo in all the markiboy ways while you know talking everything through and working together uh we actually recorded a playthrough of this one the three of
us um this was a little bit ago and uh this one is actually a patreon exclusive uh most of these playthroughs that we've recorded uh go out onto the main channel this one was recorded when we were still developing some things um the play was super fun i definitely recommend you check it out if you are a patreon subscriber of the channel even though there's maybe a little bit of funny business with the pink screen that we tried out there um it was a really fun time and uh maybe we won or maybe we did we're definitely gonna be referencing that play as we go through this uh episode while trying not to spoil how uh ultimately it went uh so yeah that was actually the only time that you anastasia have played this game so i'm curious uh what did you think about it yeah well so that was a really interesting experience so you know what was really fun about it is nick and i have played a ton of maracaibo we've we've also played with john obviously we've we've talked maracaibo strategy and we've always played the game online so not not only was that my first time playing uprising it's also my first time playing maricaibo in person ever so that was actually just really cool it has been a long pandemic um and it's funny because i own maracaibo and it just sits on my shelf so what was really fun about that was was just kind of taking in the whole experience but also just some little elements about the game that that are really nice about this expansion there's these double layer boards there's just little upgrades and
improvements but what was so fun about that experience is that we also haven't played a ton of games together in person and and so sitting around the table with you guys i was having the hardest time sitting down playing maracaibo cooperatively trying to figure out how do i play maracaibo without trying to beat nick like i just didn't realize like my entire experience with maracaibo has been through this lens of like trying to beat nick at maracai but like nick taught me america i don't know nikki i just i don't know what happened anyways so it was like sitting there and you guys were making fun of me i kept being like okay so i'm gonna score more points and they just kept saying to me you do know this is a cooperative game like it took me at least a full round of the game to start to be like okay we are trying to work together because i was like sure sure we're working together wink wink i'm gonna have more points than both of you and um and yet i was very pleased to see that you were still kind of able to do that one of my kind of concerns about it is when they had kind of told me when nick and john had played it before and they sort of mentioned it sean was like oh i just very willingly like took turns that were super lame and i was like why would you ever do that john and i could now see that there's this really fun
aspect of trying to beat jock to trying to kind of play your best game and and it also opened itself up to some great opportunities like i mean before we even started i don't actually know if this is on camera but like nick and i just traded hands i was like look your hands better than mine now that's not part of the game at all it's totally totally cheating but it it encouraged the environment of playing it kind of was like hey this is fun like we're we're going to play together and and and we had a great time with it i don't think that's cheating i mean i don't maybe i missed it but i don't read it i don't remember reading anything in the rulebook that said you can't show cards that you can't talk like there's no communication guidelines at all um we full-on trade at our hands there's no rule in the rulebook says i can't give you five dollars either but i'm pretty sure that's wrong oh you mean you never trade the cards back you just no no like ellie we looked at our starting hands and i was like this one's better for you and she was like great and then gave me her cuts which we never would have done if we were playing competitive maracaibo like no way and so there's mechanical differences to cooperative versus competitive but i think one thing i really want to highlight is the non-mechanical difference that i think all of us really felt in uh certainly both the times that nick and i played it as well where suddenly you're just talking so much there's so much to discuss when you play maracaibo cooperatively because there's so many aspects to this game that
interact with your opponents for example the explorer track um you can never land where somebody else is but you can leapfrog over them and in the competitive game that's oftentimes part of the minigame is trying to leap frog over somebody before they run away and then they try to leap frog over you before you are in a way to keep things um you know to stop being efficient for your opponents but now when you flip that on its head and you're playing cooperatively we were frequently talking about like okay i'm thinking about moving up on the track and then somebody would say ah could you wait one round i want to move up on the track i want to jump over you and then you can jump over me i'm like ah that sounds great i'm glad we had this conversation i'm going to do something else and i think that's maybe what anastasia was alluding to a little bit with like not doing the the big turn that i was planning on doing you know putting it off a little bit maybe doing some slightly mediocre turn and then doing the big turn next turn so that somebody else can also have a really big turn and i really like that also the timing of the game you know you still play four rounds this truly just felt like playing maracaibo but it happened to be cooperative and a big part of the competitive game is ending the round when other people are not ready for the round to be ended and like oh no i have to do this and that and i was hoping to do more oh well well in a cooperative game we were frequently just asking how many more actions does everybody want to take should i end this i don't know should you end this and i loved that conversation yeah that i think that that conversation piece is what made the cooperative game so much fun it's the mechanics are fine or the mechanisms are fine for it right like
they do they do the trick but really what the design is clever in is that it gets out of your way to play this game together yeah and it seems like it shouldn't work but i think it does and i thought about this a little bit every every time you sit down to play this game you're trying to play your best game you're trying to score at the most points as anastasia was saying earlier and you're still trying to score the most points when you are playing the cooperative version of the game yes you have an extra thing that you need to pay attention to to knock out the the european settlers but um that also gives you some rewards so that's fine you're you're still just trying to score the most points you can but the thing that that maracaibo has when you're playing competitive is this like race like i'm gonna go to this city and and discard the good for the the upgrade the ship upgrade there and all of a sudden it's like wait are you are you gonna go and ship upgrade there um because i have a different other pretty good play that i could do instead it's like yeah i was really hoping to go there i was like okay cool i'll do this other plan then and that like ability to sort of like weave between each other and make the decisions of how can i play this game while getting out of your way rather than how can i play this game and get in your way uh was was really dynamic yeah and i and like i said it took some adjustment to kind of like think okay how does that work and then on the flip side here we go we play this cooperative game and and and the funny part is that you actually can get so lost in in kind
of helping each other and playing your best game that you can almost forget about jock except for the fact except for the fact that like here we are playing this and uh we get to the end and and this is complete and full spoilers if you are planning to go uh watch the play through um on on john's patreon uh campaign but it it it gets to the very end and we forgot that if you don't push back the europeans from the board you just you lose and here we are we're like playing we think we've got this figured out and then i didn't have enough military to push them back in the last turn and so we just lost and they were they had like set it all up so that i could take the military and they we we just hadn't calculated it right and and we'd let him by that point run so far ahead because him being jacques him being jock because jacques jack does want you to take less turns going on the round but you can go slower because you're not trying to beat each other so like we i mean he has multiple difficulties and i guess we were playing him at hard and he he just just beat us by so many points but it didn't matter because we just lost and um but you know that was fabulous and fun and we couldn't believe we'd done it and we just laughed and laughed and laughed and and it was just it was one of the most enjoyable experiences i've ever had playing
maracaibo and i've had a lot of them so it was it was a good time yeah i also got kind of lost in the fun of just doing stuff and taking long rounds um but that sneaky jock every single round boom five points boom 10 points boom 10 points and at the end of each one of the overall rounds of the game we're like getting ready for the next round of the game and how many points did jock get oh jack got 50 points and we're all just like and then we start playing and we just kind of get lulled into the fun of the game again and the rounded end it's like oh it was really kind of funny like we were we were playing a cooperative game but we were almost playing like a like a a care bear game like like we were truly just playing for the play to a certain extent and then we just lost so hard but i will say like you alluded to that was shock on hard mode the first time we played was shock on medium and we won relatively handily i'm not sure why there was such a gulf there maybe we were just being a little bit too cavalier i think it's very likely that the cooperative game when played against the higher difficulties is still a race because jacques can get so many easy points that you really do kind of have to weigh like okay cool i want to take one more action nick wants to take two more actions nick is that second action worth a shock getting 10 points you know pro maybe not and in that case maybe that's kind of a conversation we could have but that's not the conversation we had and we still had a freaking great time yeah my uh last thoughts about that the co-op
here is that because you're playing cooperatively and you're trying to get out of each other's way you're a little bit more incentivized to try strategies or mess around with cards that you normally wouldn't yeah it's it's you know first of all like you don't feel as you're you don't feel as bad for like dropping in the strategy ball and then second of all you're like okay well i'll do this which is like a little orthogonal to your two strategies so we're kind of we're cooperating and that i'm not getting in your way to do this kind of thing um so i liked that it encouraged me to explore more of the game and along with that when someone else uh generates a cool combo you're like oh those cards are so good together um a you have enthusiasm for that person rather than like a jealousy feeling and b at the end of the game or when the game is nearing the end you know which player is the one who's gonna like take the kind of like not as good actions uh to push towards the end of the game because they're they're ahead on points and so it's like okay i want to make sure that you're scoring the maximum because your your beginning of game was not as strong and that's cool yeah yeah what i really like is that it it actually encouraged me to be like hey nick like look at this card like what do you think like or or john like which of these should i play or like which which path should i take or or hey i'm thinking about this like there was just like i had a better awareness of what you guys were doing and i felt like i played the game even
better because it was this kind of collective experience rather than me being like oh i have to hide these cards i my you know and if i put this on my shelf they're going to know what i'm going to do and like just you know in a competitive game you're you're not as inclined to show your hands if you will and this is just much more fluid i would draw a card and be like look how cool this is and i wonder if i do this with this and then it's like and even if you are taking a quote-unquote lame turn it doesn't feel that way because maybe you've set it up so that you know john's gonna get this crazy combo and he's gonna get to go here and do this and so you're like in a way participating in that action you've made it happen and that was really fun and then the fact that jock he does a number of things including taking quests off the board so even though i think a couple of times we were like i was like okay i'm going to skip this but john's going to go get it or nick's going to go get it and then jock just took it away and don't take that map i'm going to take that map like it's just there's there's a lot of little elements of that that you you don't even think like i want to fully admit i just i didn't think co-op maracaibo would be fun but but it actually really is i feel like if i had a headline like for this i'd be like i really didn't think this would be fun actively i didn't say like avoided it but i just definitely wasn't like yeah guys let's do that it was a little hard to pin you down to get you to play yeah both just like you're gonna like it and you're like yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah it's it's a lot a lot more fun than i expected
now we haven't really gone into the mechanical nuts and bolts of the differences between the games and i don't really want to delve into that too much but there is one mechanical elephant that isn't in the room that i do think we have to talk about and that's the influence tracks um one part of a huge part of base markibo are these three influence tracks with spain england and france and as you are fighting for those countries in the base game you're gaining influence in them and this becomes a potentially monstrous victory point multiplier near the end of the game um i don't want to put words in your mouth but when i listened to your mark i was strategy it definitely seemed like you were saying like you have to play the influence track in order to win the game and then the cooperative version comes around and you completely excise that entire mechanic from the game you just ignore the influence tracks entirely you don't put those no cubes ever go there there's no more multipliers and i think some people were incredulous about this um nick were you incredulous about it's omission considering how fundamental it is to the base game i i don't see it as an omission i think that it is even you you literally cannot win the game if you don't fight if you don't succeed at knocking all the europeans out you've lost and so even more so you have to fight to win the game i guess that's true and they just changed the way that rewards are handed out through this system um i think the rewards are a little bit
less dynamic maybe than they were in the base game and i think that's completely okay i think you know i'm gonna be honest like the fact that there was no fighting i'm just going to call it the influence the fighting in the game like and i say no fighting because nick is completely right that you have to fight in order to keep the europeans back and that's 100 why we lost and i mean it totally takes the blame for that because i like started that play through and i was like i don't have to fight i'm not gonna fight you guys deal with that problem and you know that obviously didn't help because oh nick was saying to me the whole time um yeah cooperative it means we're a team and not everyone has on the team has to do everything some of us can do other things there's no i do work in team right you two deal with that no i i honestly that the reason i say that is because my least favorite part of maracaibo is the fighting which i know is kind of like backwards given how important it is but i i don't like it and part of the reason i don't like it is because for some reason it doesn't matter how many times i played this game i cannot wrap my mind around it there is something about keeping track of which country has the most influence or which swords or which things are like or or the point benefit that i'm gonna get
like i'm it's starting to sink in but i have played maracaibo like i i don't know almost a dozen times like and it still for me just doesn't click for my brain just naturally and i still will be like nick explain this or nick which one should i fight for poor nick i'm always being like because i know nick i know you just get it right like so it's very easy for you to parse and the amount of time it's going to take me to parse it's just going to slow the game down so in some ways that's a crutch and you should stop telling me and then i'd be forced to you know finally learn it um so i say all of that because and i i do understand it but i say all of that because that was actually the piece of this co-op that made me most want to play it you know i was like okay there's no fighting and and to me that is one of the best parts in it yes you have to fight but it's completely different it's just there aren't traffic there's no influence there's not you don't have to compete yeah you don't have to figure out which one to fight for and all this and which one's the best and not nothing it's just it's very simple it gives you some great benefits for doing it so even though i said like you guys deal with the fight about halfway through i was like ooh fighting's kind of fun like it gives you like rewards for it i was like let's do this like so i love it i love that part of it i'm great with the excision of of influence tracks on board well how do you two feel about switching over and
talking about competitive or all-inclusive uprising at this point yeah let's do it it's called all-inclusive that's that's the that's the name of the scenario yes that's the name of the scenario so um so we played cooperative um the three of us and that was the second time for nick and i and after that game the three of us talked a bunch and we were just like we should make a friendly ties episode but i adamantly felt like we needed to play one of the competitive ways that come in the expansion before we could talk about it and i'm really glad that we did so as i said way back at the beginning of this there's four scenarios two of them are competitive uh one of them is just competitive uprising where everybody is competitively fighting against europe um so it's a lot like the co-op in that there is no influence tracks or anything like that the other way that you can play is called all-inclusive and it's kind of like ultimate maracaibo realistically that'd probably be a better name for it because the influence tracks come back and now what happens is everyone are truly mercenaries every time you do an attack you decide who if you're going to fight for or against each of the countries so you're not just fighting against you're not just fighting for you're making that decision while also deciding who you're going to fight for or against and now this whole incentivization mechanic comes into play because if you remember from before in the co-op uprising when you fight you remove cubes from the board but standard mark kybo when you
fight you add cubes to the board so in all-inclusive if you fight for europe you put cubes on the board and you get stuff just like base mark hybo but if instead you decide to fight for the uprising you remove those cubes and the more cubes that are on the board when you remove a cube the more stuff you get in the form of victory points so essentially the longer the game goes with nobody fighting for the uprising the more lucrative it becomes to fight for the uprising and the inverse is also possible where i suppose if people just go crazy kicking cubes out then the incentive to kick more cubes out is lower so maybe it makes more sense to add some cubes in this uh this was a flop for me i just ran out the gate yeah just jk i thought i was gonna like it i really did i mean because i love this game first of all and i really like thematically the idea of this right like you just said you can also fight for the the natives to to kick out european colonizers um and then uh further like the idea that when you would make those decisions changes seems like that that to me is like oh great like then i really have to pay attention and then in practice what i found was that it was taxing to pay attention to um i'm gonna fight for one of these nations or i'm gonna fight for um the the caribbean peoples and at the end of the day was like a lot of counting and recounting and now i need to see how many cities there are left
and is it worth it to do this one or that one and it just added like an extra layer to what was already a robust system that i just didn't think added enough to merit the additional overhead i completely agree with you nick if i thought that you know i was like nick explain which one i should fight for was already happening then now it's like double dribble that and and and almost frustratingly so actually because i in this play that we did of competitive america i was actually trying to do a military strategy because you know i i fully admit it's not something i i'm i i really felt like i grok so i was like okay i'm gonna just do it until it just i'm just gonna get it into my head right so i'm gonna get to go all military in this game and i was so focused on doing that i like almost couldn't compute this idea of fighting for the natives and and and nick was over doing something else too and so john comes along and he just he's like oh i'll do that and then suddenly john's like getting 15 points off of fighting and then nick's like i'm gonna do it now you know like and it's like there's also a lot of other stuff going on in this all-inclusive module so adding in this layer it was almost just frustrating to be like yeah okay well if i stopped the game right now and spent five minutes computing which way to fight like that would be good but like i know
i'd probably get more points if i did this and i've got them to help me figure out which one it would be good but like it just yeah it i i really wanted to like it more but it's almost frustrating to me that this element is is here because it does seem like so much more computational energy is needed when i loved big big l loved the rest of what uprising had to offer which you know i'm sure we'll talk about right now but i don't know quite how to hold that the love of all of that with now what is a just an even harder mathematical puzzle that i'm going to have to go through if i want to keep playing competitive uprising so i do want to emphasize i guess at this point that we've only played one of the two ways that we can um we can competitively and we did the ultimate mark ivo you know in quotes john's version john's term for it um and like you said it did feel like there was a lot more to compute i do wonder what the competitive version of the just uprising would be like where once again are you saying there is a version that we can play without this like super influence track fighting exactly yeah you can play it where it's just like the cooperative mode except it's competitive so there's no influence tracks you start with cubes all over the board um and then when you fight you just always fight against europe and now you're right oh my god i'm doing all that 100
why did you make me play this other version i wanted to play ultimate margarita 100 okay everything i just said i just ignore it because oh my god the game like just there's a i'm so excited now oh my god when can we play this let's okay let's just stop recording and go play well i mean like i said i kind of just wanted to try all of it all at once and maybe you were totally right to do that i just didn't realize that was in it this is exciting and again you know there's four scenarios and we've only played two of them so you know if we we did our due diligence we would have done all four of them but you know logistically we felt like we had a lot to talk about now and so i just want to be very clear about that um now one thing that really jumped out to me again kind of like i said for the cooperative um the one thing that jumped out to me wasn't mechanical it was the vibe of the play again we played cooperative maracaibo i played it twice before we went into this and suddenly the game was so quiet you know we're playing competitively again we're trying to beat each other in this euro game and we're not talking because we're looking at our cards making these plans trying to you know subvert the other players and i found myself really missing the discussion again like maybe i just got super stuck on the uh the newness of the cooperative but the omission of that discussion felt like uh like a gaping omission i guess you had that thanksgiving experience where everyone is talking at the table and having a wonderful time and then the food comes out and everyone stops
talking because they're stuffing their face and you wish they were talking because the conversation was so good yeah something like that i just think it you know the vibe of the table is definitely going to be an uh an impact on you know my fun for the game and i was surprised how much that did impact things i think it's it feels like what normal maracaibo feels like so if you're looking for competitive play that's still going to be there like the impression i'm getting john is that it has it has um changed your perception like base perception of like what it means to play maracaibo and so now right what i'm hearing is maybe you just rather play cooperative all the time i mean that is essentially where i'm at i mean i will say you know us kind of talking this through and you know kind of you know mentioning that we have not played pure uprising competitively does make me want to visit that and i totally will because i think there is interest in that but i have to admit that i feel like my preferred way to play maracaibo every single time i play it into the future is likely going to be cooperative i know we're kind of veering back towards that but i just liked doing all that euro-y stuff and then you know feeling like i could take big risks we're working together and and not feeling like i'm probably just going to come last again and maybe that's just because i i always play with nick but you know i i it just had a different vibe to it i just felt more tension in a way which is kind of strange in the uh
cooperative version than i did in the competitive because i've maybe that's just me being down on myself for my my capabilities when when i sat down and was putting together my thoughts before we we jumped on to record this i was like okay well i felt the same way john i was like given how i feel about the influence tracks i think cooperative is the way that i'd want to go because we haven't talked about all the other things that the expansion adds but it just it it it adds it adds this new layers of variability it adds some really kind of game breaky kind of spots and and and new story tiles that come out that are just fun and interesting and it adds a new kind of beginning bonus that you can unlock on your board yeah asymmetries like the choices and the things that it adds are are really fun and i'm going to be honest like nick and i recorded an entire strategy episode on maracaibo for this podcast and uprising breaks all of the rules like that's what i loved about it i was like i didn't feel like i was sitting down to play the game and thinking okay this is kind of the best way to play this not the best way not that there's ever a best way but just sort of seeing the path lay out because in my opinion it just it changes things up so much that a lot of what nick said he liked about the cooperative mode that
he got to try out different strategies i felt the room to do that in the competitive mode because i was like ooh there's so much more there were there were things slowing our game down making it harder for us to go around the loop and there were spots that were like incentivizing me i was playing this like innkeeper strategy it was incentivizing me to do that and it was just i i just thought that was awesome and this is the first time i played maracaibo where i about halfway through legitimately thought i had a chance to beat nick i've never thought that before and i totally credit that to uprising and at the end of the day i think i only lost to him by like it was ten points it was i was so close i was not close i feel like there's a meme here of like anastasia like a picture of like you holding your hands to the sky just being like thank you uprising no so i like i i loved the opportunities that it presented me and so i when we finished that competitive game i was like i don't think i'd ever want to go back i was just like i would i would play this way if it weren't for the military and this says a lot about how we play games that like jon or nick especially this game i've been such a tag along they've both taught me the game i've never read the rules i probably should i might understand military better if i just sat down and read the freaking robux so clearly i didn't even realize there was i knew that i knew there was like a hostage thing i knew there were other ways to play but the fact that you're telling me right now and i'm admitting to my naivete
that that is there i'm that's it i'm done competitive maracaibo no influence track haven't even played it that's the only one a way i want to play maracaibo again in the future poor nick i don't even think he wants to play it that way but that's what we're going to do nick that's what we're going to do i think i'm the one who's going to be sad in that situation because you know i definitely do think i preferred the cooperative way to do it but uh we could do that too we could do that it's so fun jacques it is really fun but i i it's just a different experience right um and you know also going back to the difference between co-op and competitive is those uh asymmetries that we briefly alluded to um there's a whole bunch of them like 24 i think something around there and at the start of the game you draw three of them and choose one and it's another unlock that you have on your board and when we played cooperatively i was frequently just like oh that's so cool over there when you just how did you just do that oh man you get that huge discount and you have so much money that's amazing and then the we played with these you know competitively and instantly my little uh gremlin inside my brain came out of its cave and was just like nick's asymmetry is better than mine and i am very sad about that and this is not balanced and you know i told that gremlin to shut up and go back into the cave and just kind of glowed at me this is a little bit of a thing john though you don't like asymmetries like you say that about every game with asymmetry i i want to like them but i so frequently have the grasses greener yeah i just i can't help
but have that little grouch inside me feel like oh that one is better and i even said it and then like you know 15 minutes later i took it back because i realized yeah yours was awesome i was like oh actually mine's great because of this other thing that i didn't realize but you know for a full 20 minutes i was wrestling with that that silly gremlin and i just remember thinking in those 20 minutes like if we were playing cooperatively i would be super psyched about the fact that i feel like nix is more powerful even though ultimately i feel like like i said i i rescinded that but in the moment you know those emotions are valid i think or at least they matter to the fun yeah the home ports are weird i i think they're really cool i like them and i agree they don't totally feel balanced i mean they're probably okay balanced but i'm glad they're in the game uh just because it lets you try new fun stuff you know and you can play without them too like if you truly hate them you can flip them over and then that upgrade just gets you a new um compass for your quest so like you know if if you're like me and you just a big grouch about him in competitive then at least the game has an emergency valve for that yeah that's a good point uh another frill that they they put into this game are new what they call the legacy tiles the uh the setup tiles that you put onto the board at the beginning of the game which by the way is one of the things i really like about maracaibo that like initial setup where different aspects of the game are kind of like open or unlocked in a game i think it's a nice way to generate just a little bit of extra variability in the gameplay
and uh i think that some of the new tiles are wacky fun the new dutch city is like crazy you lose entirely you just forsake your allegiance to one of the other european nations and then get a bunch of money from the dutch who are like yep we'll keep paying you as long as you're ruining everyone else's life out there yeah and then there's like another one where you can explore a temple in the jungle uh which and anything that makes the exploration strategy better i think is always worth it to put into this game and uh and also just thematically very cool yeah there's one that um connects one part of the loop with another part of the loop essentially turning it into a doubling the length of the overall loop once per game like you go from 13 back to two again like what yeah just like i that's what i mean like those tiles are fun and you know maybe the fun of those will wear off after a few plays although there's quite a few of them and you you know that you can pull out and so you know over time they may just kind of be what they are but there were also just tons of cards in the deck too the new cards with crazy abilities and maybe some of that's just the fun of finding new cards in the deck right but like it did just seem like i i was pulling up these cards and i was like i i can't even play this but like man if i drew that in my starting hand in another game that would be really fun like i just you know and i liked that freshness and i liked the way that i felt like it made
me feel like i could you know do some different strategies around that but one downside to an expansion like this where there's so many modules and and i'm actually not a huge fan of modular expansions like this because maybe this is the way that i sort of play board games or you know kind of look at my collection or whatever but like i tend to like i tend to like not want to have that much choice when i sit down to play a game like i don't really like do you want to play it this way this way this way or this way i like i i tend to just want to be like there is one rule set to play the game i'm not talking about strategy i'm talking about like literally how to play the game so i'm not someone who generally likes modular expansions because it creates it for me it creates ap before we even start like which way do i want to play yeah so i say all of that but i do think it's really fun that we that there's like this co-op it's competitive that there's there's all of these options but what often can happen in modular expansions like this is that there are cards and things that now no longer apply depending on the game that you're playing right so nick you brought up this dutch city that was really cool and here i am being like oh it's going to be so cool when you play this next time without the fighting but i don't think we could play with that city right like because the whole reason that city is so powerful is you have to sacrifice
one of your influence tracks and if you don't do that then you can't play that one and there's other cards and other upgrades and things that you can't use in the cooperative game because again there's no influence tracks so that is the one downside to me and again i want to say i think that's a flaw of not even a flaw i think that's just something that can happen when you have so many modules like not everything is going to work perfectly right but it is a little bit of a downside because you are inherently limiting the things you can do based on the way that you play like you're going to come across things and you're going to have that kind of moment of like ugh this would have been super cool but i can't even play that in this game or it's just less i remember at one point in our cooperative game you got really excited about a card in your hand and you showed it to us and then we're like oh that doesn't really work in the cooperative game well it's just it's just really bad yeah if you're playing competitive really it'd be amazing and you were deflated you're like oh that's no okay well fine i guess we'll play that card then i wish that there was like we've talked about this in arc nova like when we don't we never play with any of the interactive versions of the cart but everyone has another benefit to it that's from the solo game but that you know we use a designer variant whatever that like lets you just use that and it's never as good as if you were using as an attack card but it's still like a benefit and i feel like i wish that was the case here with some of these cards that there was like an an alt that's like well if you're not playing with the
influence tracks this card does x and uh maybe that's asking for too much but i wish that was there there's a bit of a catch-all in that you know if a card gives you influence and you're not playing with the influence tracks you get two points but that that doesn't apply to all of the effects for sure i agree i think that those like clunky points exist and then what you were saying about the like module selection i also agree with like what happens when we sit down and john's like i don't want to play with the home ports and i'm like but i like the home ports like yeah there's a navigation that comes there with module-based expansions that um you know the having your choice of how you want to play is nice and also uh it just requires an extra navigation so that's something to be aware of when you're considering this expansion for sure yeah yeah well overall i i really like this expansion uh in general i'm not actually one for expansions to games i'll be honest i would not have bought this expansion if it did not have a cooperative mode in there and i'm not necessarily like a big cooperative person i just was super intrigued at the idea of playing maricarbo which is a game i quite like cooperatively much in the same way that i was super intrigued to try concordia in partnerships with concordia venus like i it had a very similar feel to me in that i was playing it i'm like this feels like that other game but it also feels like something totally different like it's alternate you know reality maracaibo even though you know everything i'm doing feels very similar it just it just has a different i don't know aura to it or something
like that and uh i really dug it um i'm definitely gonna try to play more cooperative in the future but i will i will definitely uh bow to trying some fully competitive uprising as well i think maybe i just i just like the idea of working together instead of just kind of like falling off to the wayside score wise i'm really glad you brought up concordia venus because i do think that's a nice comparison to this and yet i say that and i really don't like concordia venus you gotta try it again i'll get you to try it again i know i will i will try it again i know john loves it and i i you have yet to be convinced but you became relatively convinced on maracaibo but i did and that's actually why i wanted to bring it up it's like having said that like i i like i said playing cooperative maracai with you guys was one of my favorite times playing that game ever like and it was it was a nice reprieve from do i have any chance of beating nick here i was still trying to beat nick but i it was it was just fun and so like i think that opening that door up is is really cool and the reason i i tie it to venus is because i i do want to say that if you're listening to this and you're thinking oh well i don't like concordia venus so like i don't think i'm going to like cooperative maracaibo i i am like you and i liked cooperative maracaibo like i just it it's different very different to me than
venus and i think it's it's just that because you're playing with that with jacques it it just it you are still being competitive with someone and so you and yet helping each other and and still trying to play your best game especially if you're you know like i just it it's really fun and so i will very happily play that i do think that there's a part of me that's just eager to explore more uprising competitively because i do think it's probably my best chance i'd ever be beating nick at this game and apparently that's all i want to do with and then i'll never want to play maracaibo again no but i i think for me what uprising has done is it's actually breathed new life into the game oh for sure and i think that i honestly had kind of reached a point where i was like look i'm never gonna get as good at this game as i'd like to be and for some reason this game is in my head it's just it it was a game where i i i just felt like it would take me dozens and dozens of more plays and to get to a level and it seemed like the strategy of it had already been mined and i just didn't know if like where my future was with it and you add an uprising and i just it was like this is a totally new experience it opens up so many new pathways and it up ends like i already said a lot
of the strategy and stuff we've already talked about so i i really like that so i think i i'm just i'm just eager to keep exploring it and and and i like i admit it i was pretty cool on the whole thing i i wasn't thinking any of it was going to be that great and i'm very happy to have been wrong i do want to very briefly say that you know i keep mentioning these four scenarios and there's one i haven't mentioned at all the other cooperative scenario which i also would like to try at some point um works just the same way that we've said but it has this additional rescue mechanic where you actually have to find somebody and then rescue them in addition to beating jacques in addition to removing all the cubes and i think that also sounds like a cool aspect of the game to explore at some point just seems like there's quite a bit in the box and we've only really scratched the surface with just a couple of plays it's i'm sure it's not a surprise based on the the things that i've said already but as far as this expansion goes i think that the the co-op really adds a nice new way to approach the game the frills feel like nice little expansion bonuses but but for me the co-op is really what makes it interesting so if that's what appeals to you or if you just play tons and tons of maracaibo and you just need a couple more options then i think this this expansion is is uh good for you i'm actually trying to like place for myself how highly i would rate this expansion and i think it's like up there with uh feast of odin norwegians expansion that's high praise are you gonna buy it
are you like you i don't even own maracaibo so oh that's so funny you know what i actually america was never gonna get played my house i'm gonna give you my copy and then you can hold it for the two of us that's so funny well i think that's uh gonna pretty much wrap up our thoughts on on this one as you can i'm sure infer we're certainly gonna be exploring this one more in the future i had a lot of fun talking about this i also had just a lot of fun playing with it and exploring this with uh the two of you um and i'm curious you know if anyone out there listening has any thoughts about this if you've tried mark ibo or if you have worries about it or you know any real comments at all we'd love to hear from you um please leave a comment on the youtube version of this episode you can find a link to it in the description of this podcast and uh yeah let's keep the conversation going because there's a lot to say about this if anyone has actually played either of these scenarios that we have not we'd love to hear about that as well thanks again so much for listening