Nusfjord: Big Box Review (New Expansions!)
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today before we close out this year I wanted to talk a little bit more about my favorite game from 2024 it is not a new game per se but the expansions that were released this year brought this game to the top and so that's news fured this is an uve Rosenberg game that came out in 2017 or 2018 I forget what year off the top of my head but uh as the years went by new expansions were released namely two and after that this year in addition to this big box Edition being able to collect all of the different expansions that were previously made two new expansions were released and therefore uh new content was added to this game and I wanted to talk about those in particular but also give this the the treatment that I have been giving all of my games thus far and give it a rating um based off of the Criterion that I've developed so fortunately there is a tabletop simulator module that has all of the content that is found in the big box I do own a copy and I have played it multiple times with the new content and new expansions physically I know there have been some comments on Board Game Geek about the components especially the the color of the components the lack of metallic coins as well
I decided when I sold my original copy of newer to keep those metal coins so um I apologize if you have not had the chance to get those if you wanted them but all just to sum up what I think the components are great the the uh I think the coloring uh doesn't bother me that much as well it looks great and it plays totally fine so getting into what news is all about if you haven't heard about this game before it is very akin to a lot of uber Rosenberg games in terms of how it's how it's played and and you know we start here with the worker placement aspect of this game uh this game takes place over seven rounds and you take three actions per round equaling exactly 21 actions by the end of the game so it is a very quick game and it is a very tight game when it comes to what you can do you can do various things such as you know gaining resources and ter terms of wood um you have your personal Tableau where you start off with wood you know you think of and I'll go into some game comparisons right off the bat with games like glass Road where you do start the game with forests and and other things in glass Road and here in particularly uh in particular you have your forests that you can remove for extra wood and you're gaining other resources such as gold and fish the fish income is laid out here beneath your board and as you build ships you increase the
amount of fish that you gain in each round and you utilize these three resources wood fish and gold to purchase buildings and to place them onto your Tau it is a very Dynamic Tableau where you can take these forests out you can reforce them and place them into new spots hopefully covering up these negative spots by the end of the game and you add up your points and whoever has the most wins so it my might seem a little standard when you look at the actions as it were you know with worker placement it seems like it's a repetitive approach to a game the things that make this game stand out first are the fishing phase so every phase as I mentioned before you will gain fish based off of how far you are up this track and you know for example you place a cutter here and you will gain six fish at the beginning of the round but the fish doesn't go directly into your own Supply you have to feed your elders and and shares um and not to go into too much detail but there are ways to gain more shares um at the risk of having other people buy those shares and so there's a little bit of interaction that goes on in the timing surrounding when to issue your shares which would go here on the main board for someone to potentially buy it and you would have to feed them fish throughout the remainder of the game per share so you also feed Elder cards which are
not depicted here they are somewhere in this mod um but essentially these these Elders are another unique aspect of this game where they give you personalized special actions that are sort of a combination of a lot of these actions that are mentioned here on the main board and you can take these actions if there are fish on this dinner plate spread essentially and and so there's also some interaction to filling this space when someone takes the Ser F fish action you will allow not only yourself but other people to have the means to take Elders or to use Elders that you've already taken to your personal Supply as a personalized action that you can take think of games like or at labora where you have your own buildings that allow you to do certain and unique actions think of laav uh where you purchase buildings to be able to use as well the difference is in this game you don't use other people's Elders you only use your own so it's similar to a lot of the cards in agrica in some of the expansions where you play it and you have your own personalized actions that you can take so that adds a little bit of interaction and a little bit of a race to go go for some of these Elders that may offer beneficial actions in efficiency uh depending on the decks of cards and of course lastly but not least the actual cards themselves make this game
variable there are three different Decks that come in the base game and you have a b and c decks uh in my opinion there aren't a lot of nuances between you know the A and B decks in particular the C cards are more of your endgame big Point type of buildings so they don't have the same uh differentiation as you would see in the buildings such as in glass Road however I do feel like there is difference of focus among the Decks that you have and so segueing into my thoughts on the new expansions we'll talk about the ones that were previously released back you know a couple of years ago the the place de deck and the salmon deck the salmon one I had not had the chance to play yet but uh I did own the place deck which is where I believe the metal coins came from from so just kind of looking through some of these cards as you'll note here the very first uh card kind of shows you what the focus of this deck is which is in ships so a lot of these cards I feel like have some sort of benefit where it allows you to gain certain resources or allow you to um progress your game in certain ways as you build ships and have certain types of ships in your uh Fleet and and so I thought that was pretty interesting for this deck in the and that's the place deck in the salmon
deck um I just recently played this uh today just earlier before I started recording a lot of these cards deal with gold and gold essentially allows you to build buildings but they are worth a point a piece at the end of the game and so I found that I had a much higher score at the end of the game when playing with the salmon deck because of the interactions that this deck has in particular with gold in and of itself and so I had a lot of gold left over and yeah had a substantially higher score than what is usual in the base card uh base decks as well as the other decks moving on to the newest decks the trout deck this is I don't know who exactly designed this I know uh Tony boell designed the next deck which was the bonda which we'll talk about in particular because I think that adds the most um interesting and unique effects to the game but these cards in the trout deck I felt had a lot to do with Elders now you'll see that a lot of these cards have a lot of overlap dealing with wood fish Etc as many of the other decks do but I felt like this one had more interaction with the elders in particular and so I ended up having more Elders out and play when I played with this deck than I have with the other decks on average so I thought that was interesting as well on a side note before I continue
you can play this game um this is not just uh because of tabletop simulator but I believe it's in the rule book as well you ordinarily would only play with one fish type of deck per game but you can mix some of these around which I think would make a very interesting play and really ramp up the replayability as well there are I mean if you do play with a single deck as you can see there are certain focuses that are that would make each game feel different but more so in comparison with some of the other decks uh but mixing them all together would be quite an experience so in any case let's focus on the bisca deck the bisca deck which I know was designed by boell introduces a new resource in guests now these guests just as an overview they allow you to it it's kind of a wild resource that you can choose to utilize in a few different ways one you can reduce the cost of fish and wood when you build buildings by spending a guest for each type of resource respectively you can return a guest to fill a plate uh so you can use Elders without having to serve fish yourself uh so it's a alternative resource in that regard you can also place them on your ships with one guest being able to be on each ship and they will add an additional fish on top of the fish that you are
gaining from the fishing line from every round and they are also worth points at the end of the game if you have any left over so a lot of decisions were when I played this game they were uh you know they a lot of the decisions were how can I say uh increased or or made more complex because of the possibilities that the guests offered but then the cards themselves some of the buildings and this is the way that you gain guests if you if you can play some of these uh buildings out you gain one or even more guests and in addition to these cards kind of interacting with guests in in certain ways a lot of them were very thematically interesting as well if I can find the one that I was thinking about um I don't know if I'll find it in in time but a lot of I loved these uh these different buildings that were designed and the way that they worked I felt like it kind of hearkened back to agrica with how um interesting and thematic the effects of the cards mirrored and reflected what the card actually was whether it was a occupation or a minor Improvement so anyway oh like this ghost ship for example this is the one that I was thinking of you can you you essentially leave a space open on your fishing line to increase the amount of fish that you would gain from round to
round but you don't you know you don't gain the points or the physical space that you would have with the fish or with a ship which is represented by this uh invisible ghost ship and so so I loved the flavor of a lot of these cards and here's your FL LGS your friendly local gaming store so you know a lot of kind of tongue and- cheek but uh but pretty neat thematic cards in this deck in particular which I really enjoyed so that's a a basic overview of uh newsford big box so let's get into my specific ratings for what I think about this game okay so we're going to do this sort of on the fly but uh here are the criteria that I have and as a overview I am giving a score from 1 to 10 10 being highest uh on each of these different categories that I find personally important and fulfilling when analyzing a game for myself a board game and then an overall score out of 100 will be made and that will be translated to what I will write this game as on Board Game Geek so for rules and plain complexity I'm going to give this uh an an eight I feel comfortable doing so because it's not it's not terribly hard to learn um it's not hard to play either it's very quick um I might I might bump this up to a
nine because I I do enjoy how streamlined this game is especially if you have a background in either Rosenberg games or board games in general that are more hobby Centric with worker placement Tableau building Etc and so it's not a hard game to get into or to play I've either on a weekend or even a week night you can bust this game out pretty quickly especially at if you play this Solo or even two players um I'm I'm teaching this game and playing it with another player in about an hour to an hour 15 minutes and so it's it's pretty quick and even quicker when you're playing solo I can bust out a a session in about 30 minutes so I really enjoy that complexity I I think what misses the mark for me for making it at Perfect 10 is I do refer to the rule book quite often as well as refer to the appendix for each of the new cards a lot of the cards as you saw in the the overview were uh text based right and you know they're so there aren't a lot of icons utilized in this game it's mostly text based and so I felt like it might have been you know I feel like this game could have used icons to portray what each card does and made it a little bit more language independent and as well easier to ascertain what each card does around the table it's hard if you're sitting on the opposite end of the cards
that are in this market available for you when they are upside down and only text based and so you would have to like take a picture of this to refer to as the game uh progresses and so I think for that that's why I will miss out on a point there for skill expression this is kind of like what kind of strategic Avenues can you take in this game and how high can that skills ceiling uh reach you know as you play this game more and understand the nuances of this game uh for me this hits really close to home where I find it's not you know terribly difficult to understand what is going on on a basic level but it's also that it has strategic depth to it not only in the variance of the different kinds of cards that you see in this game but also just in in general as a base you know as as you are uh you know moving around this worker placement board and understanding what each Elder does um knowing that you know it's good to increase the amount of fish that you get every you know round by building a few ships and knowing when to build buildings Etc and issuing shares uh to be able to increase the amount of fish that you retain uh each round is very important and I think there's a base level of understanding here and I'll compare this to a game that I've gotten into a lot recently which is glass Road yes on the surface I feel like the game could be portrayed as pretty simple you know it is probably a
medium to medium light type of Euro game but there is a lot of depth when it comes to the interactions and so when a lot of people play this game and I and I feel like this is true about newsford as well when you have a lot of people who have good experience with this game knowing some of the ins and outs of what is most efficient and desirable as well as combining the cards as are depicted in the market randomly and knowing what Avenues will be most effective uh there is a lot more interaction and strategery involved and so it's not terribly complex but I such as a game like teror mysa or you know other more advanced games I feel but for me it hits really home for how you can express yourself and increase your ability to play this game well through repeated plays the mechanism uniqueness and execution I'll probably give this I feel like it's you know interesting I mean there's not a lot of uh uniqueness I would say going on with the worker placement it's a little unique with the elders although you have seen this in other Rosenberg games before there I guess there really isn't a lot of I think the most unique thing would be the fishing phase and how you gain fish as an income as well as the shares um so I'll give it a seven for introducing a few unique aspects but
it's not entirely unique which does help you know it makes it very approachable and easy to understand but it's not breaking any barriers by any means so maybe maybe like a six how about that just to be fair thematic integration so this one I'm going to give like a nine uh I feel like the you know the worker placement is fairly abstract and I feel like that is and the Tau building as well is you know something that does take Liberties to make this into a viable game but things like the fishing phase where you you know as you gain your fish income from every round you have to feed your elders first right and then feed the shares that are in foreign possession which include here on the board or if they are purchased by other people you you have to give them those that fish to them as well before you get your own fish and you can only gain as many fish as you have shares before they are given up to your reserve to hopefully be transferred later on if you take that action so I really love the the theme that is involved with the way that this game works in the economic sense I should say and once again hearkening back to the guest deck or the biscon Deck with the guests that uh thematic integration from card to card was really topnotch if it were the same for the most part there are cards here in the other Decks that do portray that as well but if they're at the same level as uh the bisca deck I think I would be comfortable giving that a 10 variability
I'm going to give that a 10 I I feel like there are enough cards here that allow for a wide variety of games to play and I will mention at this point when you play the solo game it's interesting that you can play a camp pain version of this game think about ARS which is recently released where with the expansion box you play three games back to back altering what happens from game to game based off of the results and it's not as complex in this game but you do have a campaign mode where you can play the same deck over three different games where you end up seeing all the cards in each deck but they come out in a different order and you add up your scores from those three uh games and that is your campaign score and it's really cool that you can um uh you know have a kind of an ELO or ranking of how well you play this game from campaign to campaign you can alter the uh the score you can add or subtract to it based off of your results and so there's a possibility for this game having uh a physical ranking system which I think is very interesting so um so for that I'm going to jump down and give a 10 for solo as well I think this game plays really quick it's really simple like a lot of Rosen games where you are placing workers out and then using a different color to uh utilize other worker placement spots but being blocked by your own spots from the round before Allah games like a feast for Odin and um yeah aast Roden is probably the best example of that adwa is also a recent
example of rosenbergs um so yeah the solo mode is great you can play the advanced mode where you use three different colors uh really affecting how tight the game can feel and so I haven't tried that yet but you know there a lot of different ways to play this game and it makes Not only multiplayer but also the solo mode I thought had a lot of thought put into it and makes it a really fun experience playing it solo it's one of my favorite games to play solo replayability I just love playing this game U there's so much to explore and you know honestly this has more content than a game that I've explored a lot which is glass Road glass Ro is probably inherently a little bit more interactive with the card system that it uses but in this game because of the she amount of cards that are available from deck to deck in particular with the big box yeah there is a lot of replayability here the fun Factor uh for me it it I mean this game is really fun I'll give it a nine because it's you know not like laugh out loud type of fun or anything like that it it's more of that strategic type of fun and it's not I guess as strategically rewarding as a game like AG gria where you know people are you know playing that for you know a longer session and over you know thousands you know hundreds of cards that have been released for that game I suppose the Strategic Fund in that game is heightened to a very elevated bar whereas this game I think does come close with the variability and
replayability but um but not quite at the same level as AG gria player interaction I'm going to give this an eight because there are plenty of SPS to interact not only with the tightness of the board but also Racing for elders using the served fish on this plate to utilize those Elders as well the share issuing you know I'm going to give give this a nine because the more I talk about it and think about it there are so many points of interaction in this game where whereas at first it seems like it's more solitary like multi multiplayer solitire but this game you know functions so fast and is so tight with the different races that you are going for even at two players the timing around issuing shares and buying them was so interesting to me that yeah and then Racing for certain buildings if you are able to eye certain Combos and get those before your opponent does I think that's just amazing and being able to play this game at five players as well I haven't done that yet but I can't imagine the interaction on such a small and tight space for work replacement uh how that would be so very Interactive strategic competitiveness uh probably an eight for me uh it's once again not at the same level as a more advanced game like teror mystica or even at the level of Agricola but I think it's pretty close and would love to see this game be available on a digital format or something that is more widely accessible
to uh players to be able to play this game repetitively and at a competitive scene and I think because of the different cards and decks that are involved it can approach the complexity in the tournament scene that Agricola uh has shown in the past and so it's not quite there but I think it has the potential to rise for sure so adding up the score we got so I added up that score and that is a 90 out of 100 so a nine out of 10 which is exactly what I gave this game on Board Game Geek I swear I did not plan that at all and so yeah that I think reflects perfectly how I feel about this game I think it's near Perfection uh I don't know what would make this game uh you know hit a little bit more I I suppose I don't mind that this game isn't as mechanically unique I think it's executed really well so I could probably raise that ah let's do that right uh I could probably the way that it is streamlined and executed is really well done I think it's not unique but it is um I think a well-designed game it just plays so smoothly and uh so if you are a fan of work replacement games that play quickly and have a lot of replayability in terms of cards that have unique effects then newford is definitely a game that you should try it's a very cozy theme as well um I I love coming back to this game and being in this world as it were even though
this is a real place but yeah and the big box Edition just brings it all together with new content that just elevates it as well probably elevated this game from like maybe like an 85 or 86 or like 88 to a 91 for me so I really enjoy this and highly recommend it it is probably in my top five uh games of all time as a reference so thank you for Consulting with me and listening to my ramblings on newsford hope you have a Happy New Year and here is to hopefully another year of you know content for you and uh thank you for all the support thus far so hope you scheduled an appointment with me real soon and I'll catch you on the next one take care