Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hanami: Knizia's classic Samurai reimagined - TCbH Review

Transcript 8:08

Okay, folks. We are a couple years deep on the 2020s Knizia ascent. Many of the designer's most iconic games have been reprinted. His arguably most legendary and oft out of print game, Tigris and Euphrates, has had a massively successful crowdfunding campaign and is on its way. And the designer has released several new games that have received critical acclaim. It's cool. I'm here for it. But, following their resurrection of the not Knizia game Harvest, [snorts] Keymaster is now setting its eyes on other classic games and wants a piece of the Reiner pie, which brings us to Honami Samurai reimagined.

Throughout the Japanese archipelago, you are trying to have the most fulfilling visit, grabbing the best picnic spots, absorbing culture, nature, and food. On your turn, you take one of the five tiles available to you, randomly drawn from a larger pile, and place it on an empty space. When a token is completely surrounded on land, the player with the most pips worth of strength next to that token claims it, which can get tricky considering you have a fixed pool of tiles and smart play means you're contributing to multiple tokens at once. And oh my god, the cats are wild, counting towards everything around them. And you would never dream of leaving the last placement to your opponent's turn, giving them the upper hand. Point being, the game goes on. The adorable wooden tokens are scooped up. You employ every cunning strategy at your disposal, given the few tools to work from. As you play tiles, you draw to replace them. There are some unique tiles with special powers. I especially like the sneaky flight that allows you to replace and move a previously placed tile, or boats that can go on water spaces. And the fast token mechanic is cool, too, allowing you to play any number of fast tiles on a turn, though once you run out, you really wish you had more.

In very short order, when the last token of one of the three types is claimed, players are awarded the Grand Chongo for having the most of a type of token. The player with the most Grand Chongos, with the series of deciding tiebreakers, wins. Hanami is beautiful. Hanami is expertly crafted. And Hanami [clears throat] is kind of boring, which is a shame to say, and maybe because we've had so many iconic designs by Kemetia coming into availability lately that I might be grating a bit on a scale here. And if I didn't have a beautiful new edition of Through the Desert, if Raw wasn't such a banger, if Cascadero wasn't so clever, if if if Point being, I go into every game review with some excitement. I don't sign up to review games that I don't think will be fun, or at least interesting in a way that's worthwhile to talk about. And Hanami is no different. I sought this out. I can't remember the original Samurai Donning, the game shop that I worked at as a teenager. I can understand the attraction, the allure, the impetus to bring this game to the forefront and to make it available for gamers who may have never played the original, or did play the original and wanted to see it in a new light.

But as I played, I I just couldn't help but feel that it was just kind of okay. Not bad, but not speaking to me either. So, the obvious next step was asking myself, why is that? First, while I appreciate the attempt to transition the game away from martial themes, there's something weird to me about competing over the best picnic spots. Like you're carving up a foreign land as your personal playground. I'm not saying I'm morally opposed to vacations, but the juxtaposition of joy, appreciation, and relaxation paired with I'm stealing this food token from you to show I appreciate cuisine in a way you never could, loser, just feels off. But that's theme, and talking theme first for Knizia games is maybe a losing battle. The updates to Samurai, now making it Hanami, introducing a couple of new special tiles and some unique one-time bonus actions players can deal out at the beginning are kind of cool. And the dual-sided board creates a bit more versatility.

But this doesn't seem to really do much to vitalize itself mechanically beyond the original, which is okay for preservation, but even if the gameplay involves a lot of strategic nuance, both the original and this version, the blind draw to me always feels like you're more railroaded than the dude's other games. Sure, you may want to work toward some grand scheme, but sometimes all you get are slow-playing, low-power flowers or whatever, and the best affiliated spots are already well guarded. You have some opportunity to pivot, but you got to play tiles to be able to draw more tiles. It doesn't have the usual reliability, the subtle mechanical intrigue that I love most about Knizia games. And also, while it's exceptionally easy to teach, a credit to the game for sure, there's a fundamental disconnect from the ease of gameplay to the path to victory here.

The interesting victory is again a strength, but one in opposition to the other. I find a lot of people are really into their first game until everyone reveals their holdings and finds out they didn't concentrate on one token type enough or push enough toward game end to cut the legs out from their opponent, the scoring itself ends up feeling an abstraction that kind of deflates the experience. Of course, repeated play is rewarded, but I find the depth of play remains pretty stagnant after a few games. Cunning, yes, but hardly surprising. So, here's what I'm going to do because I think this is worth equivocating on just a little bit here. I do think that there are just flat-out better Knizia games. In fact, I think you could have 10 Knizia games that are easily better than this.

But, that's only a numbers game when there are also hundreds of Knizia games that are less interesting, less beautiful, less available, and just flat-out worse. By another designer, this might be considered their best game. But, there's an undeniable aspect of been-there-done-that. That's an unfortunate consequence of so many iconic titles over the last 30-year career coming back to the forefront of popularity in such little time with a lot of overlapping DNA. How many Knizia games does one shelf need? So, if the look of Hanabi speaks to you, if you want something that's approachable but tactical and never overstays its welcome at the table, and especially if you don't already own a bunch of other Knizia tile-laying games because there's sure a heck of a lot of overlapping concepts, then this may be the game for you. But, it is not the game for me. And that's our review. But, let me know, what is your favorite Knizia game? And if this is one of your all-time faves, put your argument down below in the comments. I want to hear it. I want to celebrate that we have such an abundance of great games to play. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help this channel grow.

The likes, subscribes, comments, checking out our Patreon, and sharing videos like this

does a monumental mound of help for us. But above all else, just thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved