Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 20:35

welcome to John gits games today I'll be reviewing stockpile this is a two to five player stock market auction game where players are trying to buy low and sell high and more importantly read each other because everybody knows a little bit of information as to how everything is going to fluctuate and reading your opponent's best is going to be a key to Victory first I'll show you how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review at the start of the game each player gets $20,000 and they take a random one of these stock cards which they look at they know that they now have one stock in the bottom line Bank they put a face down on their board and they're ready to start the game each turn is comprised of six different phases and in a four-player game we see that we're going to be playing six turns although it might fluctuate a bit based on the number of players so the first phase is information phase and in this one we're going to take these six cards which are associated with these six companies that are in the game we're going to shuffle these up and we're going to give one of these to each of the players and then one of these is going to go face down and one is going to go face up on the board we're going to do the same thing about these indicators which say that a stock price is going to go go down it's going to go up or maybe even pay dividends we Shuffle these up we give one of these to each of the players we put one of these B down and then one of these goes face up so now everybody has a little bit of information everybody knows that American Automotive is going to go up plus one on their stock but this player secretly knows the bottom line bank is going to go up plus four and nobody else knows that each player has their own bit of hidden information and of course this is a pair of a surprise information that everybody will see at the end of the round and now we move on to the supply phase we have this large deck of cards that has all sorts

of stocks for different companies as well as some action cards and some trading fees we're going to shuffle these up and then we're going to put one face up under four of these uh calculators in the four player game and we can tell that because we see this little four plus if it was a five player game we would be doing all five calculators in a three got player game we'd only be doing those three and now each player also gets two of these cards face down from the top of the stack this gives them a hand beginning with the start player each person now needs to play one of these cards face up into a stockpile and one of these cards face down now we see that we have an American Automotive car which we know is going to be good it's going to go up by plus one in this round uh we also have this stock uh Boom Card which will allow the player who takes this card to be able to bump up the stock value price of any one of the stocks by two we look over here there's also a stock bust which allows the player to reduce the stock price by two which is also very powerful so this is an interesting decision because they could put this face up and this face down making this a very lucrative uh column for people to grab later on or they could even switch things around put this face down over here and leave this face up over here giving somebody a lot of control to bump uh some stocks and put it down so uh you want to try to hide some information if you were to hide this over here and put this face up over here people might think that this is a penalty because some of these cards cost you uh money and stock fees when you take them so there's a bit of uh bluffing here once all players have placed all of their cards uh one face down and one face up onto the board then you can go into the demand phase and this is essentially an auction where each player is going to be claiming one

of these stock piles and bidding money to try and take them so you begin with a start player and the way it works is you put your bid down on the value on the calculator that you want to spend so in this case the purple player might put this here saying they're willing to spend $6 the next player might come along and they'll say they're fine with spending zero dollar in order to take this St stack now the red player might come along and say you know what that's too good I'm going to spend $3 and that bumps out the green player before the green player can do anything else however the blue player comes in and they might decide they want to go 0 over here and now the green player gets to jump back in they could go $ Z over here or in this case decide maybe this really is worth $10 bumping purple and what's going to happen is these are going to keep getting bumped until you have equilibrium where everybody is on a spot at this point each player is going to spend money equal to the bid value for the stockpile that they are associated with beginning with the start player again each player will now spend any astion cards they picked up in this given round and they will do things to the board so for instance this one could cause a stock to go up twice and this stock bust might cause this one to go down over there we've now reached the fifth phase which is selling so starting with the start player again they can now sell as many stocks as they want from their hand and they're going to get money equal to the current stock value so for instance this Bottom Line Bank is now worth $7 whereas these other three stocks they haven't fluctuated at all so they're all worth $5 each now um considering this purple player actually knows that the bottom line bank is going to go up by four in this round they're definitely not going to want to sell

this stock but instead they might have a bad feeling about purple they might decide to sell one of these to get $5 another thing about this is it gets them money which they can then spend in the next auction so it gets them liquid to buy some more stocks so this could go away and they'd get $5,000 for it we've now reached the sixth and Final Phase which is also the most exciting and this is the one where we reveal all of the stock market movement so first of all we see that uh American Automotive that's going to go up by one so that red goes up here Will Reveal this hidden one which nobody knew about and this actually means that every player who has stock in Epic electric is going to have to show that stock and they'll get $2,000 for each of those stocks so that was beneficial for the purple player not to sell that stock they now get $2,000 in dividends and they keep this stock and we also reveal all the matching pairs that each other player had we see that Stanford steel is going to go down by two which is pretty scary we can see that Cosmic computers goes up by two we see that leading Laboratories goes down by three which is really good that the purple player sold that one stock although maybe they should have sold both of them and finally the purple player knew that bottom line Bank was going to go up four so it goes one two 3 4 now the interesting thing here you see this little dollar sign that's being cut in half as soon as you hit this point you actually Port back to the other octagon you see how they're matched and all green stocks now split when the split happens each player takes all the stock of that color that they have and they move it over to this 2x zone They prove that it's the right color and they flip it over and each stock in this area counts as two stock for the purposes of selling so essentially double in its

value if you split a stock that's already split over here then you get an extra $10,000 just right into your bank for each one of those the opposite of stock splitting is bankruptcy if you ever have a stock go below one into this trash can then every single player who has any of that stock has to immediately discard it and get nothing for it even if they're in this stock split area so that's pretty bad for all these players and then the stock value bounces back to five but again nobody will add this Point have any of that stock in their areas at the end of each turn you move this marker over once and you pass the starting player token once to the left once the game goes through all of these different rounds the game will be over and every player will sell all of the stock they have in front of them for the current stock price at that moment Whoever has the most money wins before I move into the review I want to show two extra kind of expansion variants that come with the game the first is on the back side of the board you'll see this different stock market area where each of the companies has a very different setup we see that Cosmic computers has a very short one they start here and they can easily split but they could also very easily go bankrupt whereas you have the Stanford steel which is a huge track it starts over here it could split very easily right from the very beginning uh but if you'll notice it goes from 4 to Four 3: 3 2 to two so bumps up on this track are a lot less lucrative however the Stanford track is the only one that's different this way it actually has some dividend payouts on it so when you move this token over to this spot with this dividend payout then everybody gets $1,000 for every one of the these gray stocks they have and in fact up here they'll get $2,000 for all those gray stocks so as you can see it adds a

little bit of variety where some stocks are much more um secure than others and the other thing I want to talk about is this investor pile now these are all kind of special abilities that you can unlock or not unlock you can have from the very beginning of the game if you want to use these you're going to pass two of these out to every single player they're going to pick between the two and they're actually going to tell you the starting amount of money you begin with so it's not 20,000 in this case if you picked uh Golden Graham you would only start with 16,000 but then they have a variety of quite powerful abilities um that they can use throughout the game for instance this one right here will let the player look at a all the face down cards in one of the given stock piles and this one will give you an extra ,000 every time you sell any piece of stock so now let's begin the review for stockpile and we'll start with a few positive points the first of these relates to the supply phase of the game this is the one where you have two cards in your hand you have to put one face down and one face up into the various stock piles and I think this is an excellent incentivization mechanic it's a really well done implementation in this game because you have the usual things you have to think of with this type of thing and it's not new in this game Colorado uses it as well as other games where you are trying to put bad cards into Stacks that already look good and in this case maybe face down so that they take it not knowing what it's going to be and then suffering the consequences but you also want to put good Cards into piles that you want to take maybe for a good price and you might want to put that card face down so that people don't see it because they know that it's good but only one can be be face down and one could be face up so it's a really interesting decision not only where you put these cards but which one is actually showing

if you show a bad card and then hide another card people are well I'm not sure what they're going to think they might think that's a really bad card or maybe they're probably going to think it's a good card and you're trying to hide it and they're more likely to take that pile what if they are both bad cars then you might have just gotten into their head a bit so it's a great implementation of this incentivization mechanic and it's just uh probably my favorite part of playing the game in general positive number two relates to the scarcity of information in this game and how that creates a great bluffing atmosphere where players are really playing off of each other and the actions that people are doing now this is the part where there are six different companies and every single one of these companies is gonna have something happen to it in every turn of the game it's going to go the stock market price is going to go up it's going to go down or it's going to pay out dividends and the question is just how much and in what direction so each player has a private piece of information they know one company and what it's going to do that nobody else knows there's a bit of public information as well and they're going to play their turn knowing this like that's going to in um dictate how they put the cards out into the stock piles it's going to dictate how they um do bidding in the auction to buy these stock files and most importantly it's going to dictate how they're going to potentially sell stocks and selling stocks happens one at a time around the table and this is the part where bluffing could really come into play where someone might know something and try to Telegraph something else by selling a stock in one way to make other people like do a run on the banks and then they find out actually that stock went up and this person just sold one of them and kept three behind and now it splits and they're really happy and you can definitely play The Players around the table in addition to just the game and all that comes from this really simple mechanic of just each

person knowing one piece of information and playing around it it's a very cool idea posit number three relates to the two different board types that you can play with in this game you have a fully symmetrical side of the board where every single company is functionally identical and the only real differen is is how they're going to fluctuate as the game goes on but then on the back side there is a significantly more interesting asymmetric uh board where the companies are very different from each other you have a tech company that could split stocks really fast but then go bust really easily and then you have a steel company which when a stock market price goes up it doesn't actually get that much more worthwhile but it will pay out dividends as it's going up and there's a variety of other companies in between functionally only one of them is really different and that is that one that pays out dividends that's the only extra complication the rest of them just um split faster or go bankrupt a little bit sooner or later and various fluctuations there and this adds so much more to the game I I strongly recommend honestly that every just plays the asymmetrical side I think it's a much more interesting experience but it is also good that there is that symmetrical side in case the asymmetry bugs anybody it's great to have the option even though I think one of them is better than the other it's just cool that they're in the Box it feels like something they could have easily put into an expansion but it's here in the base game and I'm really glad for it so now let's move into a couple neutral points and the first of these relates to the potential perceived complexity of this game there are six different phases to every single turn and all of them are important the order in which you play them is important but it is not a very complicated game and it kind of feels like it is when you first start trying to teach it to people I would recommend

teaching this game while playing the first round honestly um explain what you're doing in this first round and then maybe a little bit about the next round like when you're doing the supply phase putting the cards down say well we're going to do an auction you can see the little points on the thing but not actually get into the specifics of how each one of these future phases work until you get to them because if you just teach people by just laying it all on them right at once which I trying it can sometimes just be overwhelming and I've seen people kind of lock down and be like Oh kind of scared of the game and then they play a round or two and they're like oh this is simple like it it does make sense um that being said every time I've played this game I've gotten out the rulebook and had the back page right next to me with all the phases on it so that I don't screw anything up and you know what last time I played I completely missed the cell phase until after we had um done all the modifications to the main board which is pretty important so even though I played this game before and I had the play right in front of me I still got one of these uh phases out of order and it's important to put these things in order so anyway this is a neutral point because there is a perceived complexity that's possible here but you can definitely uh tell people that don't worry this is not a complicated game it's worth it once you get through all the steps to see how this all works they're all necessary there's just a few of them neutral number two relates to the demand phase of the game which is the auction where you're trying to buy those specific stock piles and I have a couple things to say about this the first thing is there is definite potential for analysis paralysis here uh I had some and I saw it in some of uh the people who were playing the game with me and the reason for this is because you are spending victory points essentially like the game is when the

game is over Whoever has the most points wins and you spend or the most money wins and you spend this money at a one to one uh ratio in order to buy these stockpile so unlike some games where you have an auction and you're spending a resource to get things but that resource you know maybe converts at 5 to one to victory points or something like this here man it really feels like you can lock down trying to think you know is this going to be worth it how much are these stocks worth right now versus how much money am I spending and it's really easy to spend way too much on these auctions and if I'm being honest that's me I'm the guy who spends way too much on these auctions at the wrong time and then does not have the money to buy the right auctions I'm really terrible at this phase um but that's not necessarily why this is a neutral point some people are really good at this phase as I've witnessed as I've been crushed while playing this game I just I feel like it's worth noting that analysis pris can creep in pretty strong at this point in the game it's a good auction I don't have a problem with the auction but it's a really important auction and the ramifications of this important decision that you're making can be pretty significant on how well you do in the game in general let's now shift into my one negative point for the game and that relates to the asymmetric player powers that you can have in this game now this is technically an optional expansion that comes in the game as is that asymmetric board that comes with the game and I think that you should always play with that asymmetric board but when it comes to these asymmetric Powers I feel like you should maybe not play with these much If Ever I don't feel like they're balanced and I know that it's going out in a limb as a reviewer to say oh this isn't balanced and the designer

you know could have done this better but they' obviously played this game you know orders of magnitude more times than I have but when I played these roles I just I did not feel like some of them were as good as other ones and uh in particular the uh the the discount Donald rooll really threw a monkey wrench in the whole game uh with how to do the auction bidding man you thought there was analysis paralysis before this guy only pays the price of one below it so in order to try and outbid that character was incredibly difficult but when looking at the other characters too it just it really did feel like everybody was on a Level Playing Field and I will say that people enjoyed playing these characters like it's a cool INF U um uh it's a cool amount of replayability that's kind of put into the game like it makes one game play differently from the next when you have these relatively significant different powers but I will argue that I almost I don't think I want to play with them strictly because I feel like it puts certain people on the back foot and I think some people are going to love them and I think that um I could be wrong they could be perfectly balanced and I'm just terrible at this and this is just my perception after playing the game a couple times but for what it's worth that's my opinion on them the replayability for stockpile I think is a bit above average and the biggest reason for this is well the different amounts of variability that you could throw into the game you know one of them is the two different types of boards that you could play with that's going to make one game play differently to the next just playing that asymmetric board over and over again is going to feel different from one game to the next because those different companies behave so differently from each other in in one game you might be going more for one

company than other so you're not always going to be having the well-rounded experience of really trying to see if you can make a uh steel Works uh company kind of thing work by getting lots of discounts or the um the dividends versus you know trying to have your stock split in the tech company and sell them off before it immediately busts those two experiences are going to be different and I will throw into this there's the asymmetric player that I just talked about um kind of rubbing me the wrong way but I think a lot of people are going to love these and for a lot of people this is going to add a bunch of replayability to the game because there's quite a few of these in the box so if you do play with these you are going to have significantly different play experiences from one game to the next as you use the different player powers that these uh unlock for each person so yeah definitely above average replayability stockpile plays two to five players and I've only tried the three and four player experience and I think that it likely plays good at all of these player counts I think four player is probably best and that's because you have a good variety of stock piles to pick from and you're going to play the same number of turns as the two-player game which is uh essentially a four-player game because each person has two different auction markers so the same four stock piles out there on the board so those experiences are probably going to be pretty analogous although in that two-player game you're going to have a lot less downtime because it's going to be one at your opponent and then it's going to bounce right back to you and you're also going to win two different auctions so you get a lot more stocks and you could potentially do more things so that sounds pretty cool I think I'd probably uh like the two-player game when you look at the three-player game you have one less stockpile and the game goes an additional turn and I think the reason for that is to bounce out for the overall game time because you have one less person so it's probably going to be

a similar length game but I like having the variety of those stock piles and then when you go to the Other Extreme when you go to the five player game you play one less round and you have five stock piles to choose from so again it probably takes a similar amount of time I wouldn't be surprised if it was it was longer than a four player game even there it was a less one less turn just because now you have five stock piles to analyze on the auction and where you're going to put these cards down man there's a lot going on that being said it probably plays good at five I just haven't tried it so yeah it's probably good two to five but I think four is probably best in conclusion stockpile has been an odd experience for Me overall I can look at the game and say that I see a really good design here it's got great decisions from the start to the end it has a bunch of different phes but they all make sense you have incentivization mechanics of trying to put those cars down in the right stock piles you've got a really good auction where you're trying to pull those uh get the right pile into your area you've got some bling as to what your opponents are doing and who should I sell my stock now or should I maybe hold on to it also maybe you just need to sell stock in order to get some money so you can buy more stocks in the next round all the stuff comes together really well and on the other hand I am terrible at this game I have come dead last every single time I've played it and if I'm being honest that has kind of hurt my impression of the game overall so as a as a reviewer I think I can strongly recommend this game it's a really good package it's a really good experience but as John Cox the guy who likes to play board games I don't know if I'm going to play it anymore because man this game just makes me feel dumb I I think I'm terrible at the auction phase I spend way too much money at the wrong

time and I I usually have my score doubled by the people who win and usually everybody's clustered in like the 120s and 130s and my high score ever I think was 70 and I've definitely had 40 point games so take that with a grain of salt I think that it's a really good game it's not really for me which surprises me because man I really thought was going to be better at this game in general and there is something to be said also for continuing to play a game you're bad at to try and get better but at a certain point you got to cut your losses so to wrap it up and to say it again I recommend this game it's a really good game just not sure if I'm G to be playing it anymore I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this Channel Through patreon including the producer level pledges if you too would like to directly support this channel you could do so at patreon.com jongetsgames also if You' like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full getting playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel thanks for watching

Progress saved