10 Mistakes Most Board Gamers Make
Transcript
when i was first getting into board games i made so many mistakes i was buying games that weren't right for me hosting disastrous game nights because i had no idea what i was doing so today i'm going to share the top 10 mistakes that all new gamers make and i've made all of these so you can avoid making them yourself the fastest way to ruin a game night is to not read the rules beforehand i thought i won't open it until they arrive so we can go through it all together if it's your game then it's on you to know how to teach it not learn it yourself in front of everyone else you're not going to believe this some of us will have hidden roles learning rules is one of the biggest reasons people hate board games so if you've invited non-gamers you are an ambassador for this hobby you're an ambassador for the hobby right now and we are all relying on you to represent us well because when your friend moves in next door to me and i ask them round for games and they say i don't play board games i tried it once but i just hate all the rules that will be your fault and i'll be reporting you to rodney smith if you don't know who that is you've proven my point it's like trying to get your children to eat vegetables you've only got so many attempts before they swear them off forever so you better saute those rules in butter wrap them in serrano ham and serve them with a jew because i'm not about to lose another potential gamer to rock climbing you can't do both you have to pick a side some people watch rodney smith videos
some people read rule books in bed some people watch rodney smith videos in bed but i think that's for other reasons it doesn't matter how you learn it just learn it the less time you fuss around with rules on game night the more games you get to play if you're new to board games you might think that this number on the side of the box with a clock symbol next to it is the amount of time it takes to play that game no that is a number plucked from thin air you'd be better off reading the barcode in fact it's so inaccurate that if you finish a game in the time stated on its box you win a trip to the factory where they make all the board games and inherit it like in willy wonka if you've got an hour before you need to drop your partner at the train station and you start a game that says it lasts an hour you can kiss goodbye to kissing them goodbye they will be halfway to prestatin by the time you're counting points and for context that is in wales here's the formula for working out a game's real length start by multiplying the number on the box by two add fifty percent if you're playing it for the first time and twenty percent per extra player then times it all by four if any of those players get analysis paralysis if all your friends get analysis paralysis you might consider a different hobby i haven't got analysis paralysis this is how long it should take anyone to scientifically compare all the options and pick the optimal one what you absolutely mustn't do is tell the internet that a game took you many hours
to complete because within seconds you'll receive a reply like this um actually my group can play game of thrones in under an hour yes stuart if no one goes to the toilet or talks or has fun it's possible to finish any game within an hour and if i take all the good bits out of my burger i can eat it quicker one of the silliest things to do as a new gamer is to buy expansions you don't need them no matter what some overzealous reviewer might tell you and i would rather waterboard myself than play the game without this expansion if you've played a game less than 30 times you're still exploring it and if you're bored of it already i'll let you into a secret you don't like that game an expansion isn't going to fix that but john this expansion provides more variety yeah but you know what provides more variety a different game we all have limited money to spend if you don't go to patreon.com forward slash actual so save it for something that will offer a completely different experience that game might be even better i own 300 board games which is too many by the way but it's my job so i grant myself special dispensation i have 72 expansions because i was once like you and of those i would confidently say one is worth getting out of 72.
this idea that you need an expansion is a marketing trick have you not got the expansion oh no not yet i did hear it makes it better try loads better when i was starting out i would believe that hype and buy the expansion at the same time as the base game which is such a mistake because you're robbing yourself the journey of exploring that game it's like telling your waiter to bring out your dessert and your main course at the same time i've even started to get rid of expansions now for games i love because they're not worth the hassle when my neighbors ask to borrow carcassonne i have to take out the expansion stuff every time so it doesn't confuse them those are the custom tiles i had made you'll probably want to ignore them they use non-standard iconography that's actually easier to pass but takes longer for the average person to grok it's sort of like my draw at keyboard layout treat it like marriage buy an expansion only if you love a game if the thought of playing it trumps the thought of playing something new and different but if you're the kind of person that's always got your eye on the next hot game then you need to get out of your system before you go bringing any little expansions into the world we've all made this mistake playing a game at a bad play account if you have a box that says two to eight players on it you've been sold a lie yes magic maze can theoretically play two to eight players and my body can theoretically
run a marathon but it won't be fun and i'm never gonna do it the trouble is publishers know that a horse that rides two to eight people will sell more so they stick a horn on it and call it a unicorn then we wonder why it buckles under our weight this game says three to six players on the box but it actually means five to six players unless you have an expansion this game says three to six players but i would only ever play it with five and these are all games which say they can be played at two players but they really can't flexible games can end up being a jack of all counts master of none i'd much rather play a dedicated two-player game like watergate lost cities or onotama because no flexible game can replicate the push and pull feel that they have but if you're on a budget there are some unicorns out there like carcassonne and ticket to ride which are fun for two three four and five players the trick is to look up a game on board game geek and check the recommended player count section it's been voted on by users people whose game nights died so yours don't have to hello michael have you left yet okay good because you can't come anymore no i checked the play account on bgg and it's only four players so you're out yeah but are you still free next sunday for game of thrones because we need five for that i honestly do this every time i play a game for the first time and if it doesn't fit the group size then we'll play something else we're here for a good time not a long time for game night
that is but we will also die i made this mistake so many times when i got into the hobby don't take the board game geek top 100 as gospel i was given my first board game for christmas by my wife 10 years ago now it was ticket to ride europe and i was disappointed i thought i'd been given a bad game because it wasn't in the top 10 on board game geek it wasn't even in the top 100 no it's not a bad gift it's just as 130 better gifts you could have got me if you've done your research that's why i sought my most popular on amazon and gave you 50 shades of grey again it turned out that my wife knew me better than a website because i loved ticket to ride and to rub it in that same christmas i received puerto rico a game i'd specifically asked for because it was the number two game of all time on board game geek and i hated it but i also hated the number two film of all time on imdb just like any art form there are no objectively good games that everyone likes you have to find what's good to you and the top 100 is a fun reference point but i only own six games from it and they're not my favorites either and actually as a newbie the board game geek top 100 is a bad place to start because it skews towards more complicated games because the people voting on it are seasoned gamers you won't understand what's going on the first 10 times you play it but after that it really starts to get good if you play it with the same
group gloomhaven is currently the number one game of all time on board game geek and it is a huge complicated commitment of a game the people that love it love it but if you're new to games it is a mistake to start with gloomhaven and if you're watching this saying well my first game was gloomhaven and i didn't struggle at all then i give you this a fanfare on the world's tiniest trumpet whereas katan ticket to ride pandemic and carcassonne the games that got most people into board games none of them are in the top 100 so don't obsess over it if you're new to games and you want to know what games to get first subscribe to this channel then go watch my top 10 gateway games video you could try other channels but weirdly when it comes to board game videos mine are objectively the best if you've been into board games for a year or two i can say this with full confidence that it'll apply to you stop buying so many games i know what it's like all day every day you're thinking about them i love board games me i wish i was playing them right now james could you mute your microphone you're talking to yourself about board games again but you're only playing them once a week if you're lucky i haven't played a game in weeks it's miserable maybe to cheer myself up i should buy a new game every wednesday you check this week's new releases and that game you've been waiting for is finally back in
stock but this game's been out of print for as long as i can remember you've been into board games for three months yeah and it's been agony if i don't buy it now it could sell out and be another three months by then you'll be into another hobby exactly i'll never get to play it you'll buy a game that you don't even want that much just because someone's selling it half price on facebook you'll buy a game that you don't even have enough friends to play it with but you just really love the sound of it you'll buy a game on payday and on your birthday and on someone else's birthday i've been there and done it all i'm old enough to have seen all the games i feverishly overspent on come back into print many times when we went on holiday to new york i took an empty suitcase and i ordered 25 board games to arrive at our hotel so i could get them cheaper than in the uk i spent more time planning which games i was going to fit in that suitcase than i did planning our trip this evening since it's our last night in new york i was thinking chinatown yeah and after we've played that we should go for dinner and none of it was worth it i don't have half of those games anymore i get it you've only just discovered this wonderland you've got so much time to make up for but it's okay the beauty of board games is that you'll never get too old to play them they're here for the rest of your life in my experience this phase doesn't last forever i reached a turning point after a few years where i stopped hoarding and i started curating now getting rid of a game for me feels just as good as getting a new one
i wish someone had told me this one when i was starting out don't rely on your family and friends to play games if you're the one watching videos about board games the chances are they're not as obsessed as you are and they don't want to play as often as you it's nice playing a game at lunch time isn't it yeah and it gives us time this evening to do other stuff you mean all the games i always found it so frustrating to have to wait weeks until my friends were free so that i could play something are you still on for pandemic legacy tomorrow oh yeah the funeral so sad just thinking every week i've ever been to his had tables at it yeah you're right i wasn't in the mood to do anything when sonia patel died you know the virologist she got caught in that outbreak in bogota the solution is to go to a local game group and find new people to play with it's nerve-wracking and awkward at times but i first went to one seven years ago and this is a photo of the friends i've made through that group now i can play games whenever i want to and to fill in the time between meetups try gaming online it's not as good as playing in real life but i found that the games i play against my patrons on bga give me that daily hit that i crave or a healthier analogy that doesn't make me sound like i'm addicted if you're new to board games the last thing you should do is go on kickstarter it's like getting on a deadly motorcycle before you can even ride a bike
kickstarter is a land of wonder where all the prettiest board games sing their siren song luring you in with the promise of miniatures and exclusive content then when you get in close they kill you well they take your money and make you wait ages to get your stuff which is worse but if i don't back it now i'll never get all the add-on boxes you'll never get them i'm not seeing the downside when you're new there are so many good games for you to discover that are all available to have fun with right now you shouldn't lock up your money in deferred gratification on a game that might not even be any good many kickstarters are from inexperienced designers or publishers on a platform where you don't need to have designed a good game for it to sell because you can't play it before you buy it this game uses a brand new mechanism called hope we found from minimal play testing that with hope even if the game is poorly designed players will delude themselves into thinking they're having fun their biggest goal is to make an enticing box of goodies full of endless content and deluxe components but those things don't make a game better they just make it more expensive the miniatures come with a pre-painted metallic wash and if you look at them closely enough you can start to forget how bad the game is i say this from experience of the 54 games i've backed on kickstarter i've only kept 16 of them and all that exclusive content i paid the fomo tax for i never touched it i
didn't get that far before realizing i hated the games i'm not saying to resist kickstarter forever it's given life to some wonderful games but the hit ratio is low and if you wait until people have reviewed it you're more likely to buy a game that's good i have a friend with a shelf of flashy kickstarters that turned out to be duds that he just can't sell because even though no game is objectively bad some games are subjectively bad for the entire population of the world this one's important don't make people play games they won't like let me tell you an embarrassing story back when i was relying on my friends to play games i became obsessed with game of thrones the board game that takes five hours to play i was so desperate to play it that to get the full six players i invited two friends who have never played anything more complicated than a party game they hadn't even watched the tv show and when i invited them i wasn't exactly honest about what they were letting themselves in for we're starting at 10 a.m sharp no no reason just nicer to play in the morning and maybe bring a sleeping bag it was a disaster they hated the game and i felt terrible for putting them through it so i didn't even get the fun time i was hoping for just a memory that makes me cringe whenever i think about it and it's not just long games i have friends who hate negotiation games or how heated social deduction games can get if you're
a host you wouldn't just serve the food that you're most excited to eat it has to suit everyone because if they have a bad time they might think twice about coming back the most common mistake that new gamers make is to buy a game just because you like the film tv show or video game it's based on i love board games i love d-day i'm certain to love d-day monopoly if we've learned one thing today it's that a board game box is a set of lies designed to sell you the game and nowhere is this more true than when dealing with games based on an ip it will look appealing it will have your favorite characters on the cover but that doesn't make it good remember george rr martin did not design this game and thank god because otherwise you'd never be able to finish it in fact it might suggest it's bad they don't have to make a game good when they know it will sell itself the lesson is don't jump in do a quick search on board game geek if the rating is below 6.5 put the game down you'll get as much joy from it as your jon snow funko pop thankfully there are some great games being made from ips but even they can be a mistake for a new gamer if you've spent two and a half hours staring longingly at timothy chalamet also known as watching june then you go home and buy the game of the same name you'll end up with a four-hour game with a 24-page rulebook that was originally designed in the 70s it's not a bad game but i don't have to be your favorite character benny
gessera to predict that most fans of june will find it to be too much the trick as with so many of these mistakes is to keep a healthy dose of skepticism and do your research because the disappointment when you don't enjoy the big exciting star wars game will be more than your 10 year old heart can bear although by this point it should be used to the disappointment those are my top 10 mistakes but let me know the worst ones that you've ever made in the comments and i put links to where you can find out more about the games i mentioned in the description below as well as places to buy them if you're new to the channel please subscribe to see more videos like this i'm john perkis thanks for watching
you