Roma XLI: A Book-Box Game of Exile & Deceit for 1-9 Players - Kickstarter Critique Review
Transcript
Ohoy there YouTube. I'm back again today for another Kickstarter critique where I take a look at a different Kickstarter tabletop game project every weekday at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time, giving my honest thoughts on how the project is being ran. And today I am mildly excited to be checking out the 14th most popular project in all of games. But before we get into that, I just want to say I love it. I put a feather in my cap. They improved their main image after my video. coincidence or not, I don't know, but they added that skull that wasn't there before. And they also mentioned uh that as well. So, I just love seeing when I feel like I'm kind of like moving the industry standard a little bit. Like, yeah, of course you should have player like time count age on the front of your freaking game. The godliest god game, which crush it, by the way. Uh, but Roma XLI, a bookbox game of exile and deceit for one nine players. Love the fact we're mentioning bookbox game. I can see it. But those were mentioning the one and nine players. Nice to mention component shot. I'd get rid of that. It's not great. It's not even good. It looks bad. An AI rendered from this far out, which it is what it is.
I'm not an anti- AI person, but it that doesn't look good either way. If it is or is not, but it's 1100% funded. Vote your opponents into exile. Gain influence. Form and break alliances. Light strategy. 20 to 40 minutes, one to nine players. Bookbox. Okay, put some of that stuff on the main image instead of bricks. I know these bricks are very nice, good-looking bricks. Somebody really laid those in, took the time to do it well, but I feel like there's other stuff that probably could be better used in that graphic. Am I Am I live now? It shows that I'm not. Let me double check something real quick. No, we're good. Okay. 333,000 bucks. Kudos for them. Holy crap. That is awesome. 5,000 backers from Dayton, Ohio. I'm going to guess this video slaps. I don't use that word often. As always with the video, I'm thinking three things. Do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? Let's see how they convince people to give them their money for this game.
Caesar.
Okay. Nice shot right there. What? Oh, respond
is dead.
Oh, wow.
And
now that that looks great. Like people love box inserts. People love uh convenience. When they open the box, they want to know everything's going to go in the right place. I feel like most people do. And that's based on how people SHOP ON KICKSTARTER. HEY, thy doctor. Thanks for joining. But that that's a great first presentation. Honestly, I'd kind of zoom in on that for the main image at some place. That looks great. Okay. So, and once again, it's just how far out that was zoomed out didn't look great. But when I actually see it zoomed in, it's like, okay, it looks elegant
and nine good Romans are poised to take the throne.
Deluxified.
Eight are left.
Also love the fact you're doing the subtitles on the bottom here. Very great job spotlighting the game. I think now that we're into this video and spotlighting it quick 13 seconds in and I' I get it. This is a deluxified smaller game. This is going to be a piece. It's going to be up there. You're hoping someone will ask about it. It's responding. I'm here. Stop it.
When the first one go.
By the way, this is a great time to mention uh if you want to support the channel, I'm running a Kickstarter later this year to hopefully upgrade some equipment so my computer can respond.
Those down text on the cards.
He was getting a little too ambitious.
Metal coins.
Six. Five. Poisoned. Delicious. Four.
Love that personally.
They were too slow. Three, his lover. Obviously a traitor. She had to go. Four, the queen. She's
I feel like we're going a bit long here now. You're doing a great job spotlighting the components, but I don't really understand gameplaywise. I know people are dying, but I I don't know. It's just I don't feel like it's feel like we're just doing a little great component spotlighting, though. Like, and I have a feeling if this is anywhere $40 or under, I think it's a pretty easy back. So, hopefully you spotlight your price if it's a good one, which I imagine it's going to be.
Three is a crowd. This alliance ends.
Actually, I think it's going to be much more. Maybe maybe I'm going to go 50ish now after seeing those wooden components with the screen print, the metal coins.
Two zone. A final duel for the throne. one remains and takes all of Rome.
I wish they did a longer shot showcasing their other games cuz I think those are Yeah, those are their other games which I think is going to help with the can you do it aspect for some people cuz at first I thought it was just you were showcasing the fact that this was actually uh you know the book shape but it's like no no no we've actually done a whole bunch of other games. All of Rome.
Hi, I'm Holly and this is Travis and we're the creators of Roma XLI.
The game is for one to nine players and takes 20 to 40 minutes. Turns are simple. Just play a card face down as a vote or face up as an action.
Players will be eliminated one by one as the exile track progresses. though each player remains in.
And now knowing this, this gets me even more excited of the nine player aspect. Like the party game lane this could potentially fill if you're with nerdier people. Love that. And I felt like that was missing in the video, like was just the oh hey so what here's what you're actually going to do. It's like a really simple decision. This or that. Like okay, now I get it. So I'm glad they came back and they picked this up and they're doing it.
Involved in the outcome and will have a chance to return to the game. The last person standing wins. Deluxe backers will receive a free Kickstarter exclusive box which includes a mini expansion of event cards, a set of metal medallions, and more.
Excellent job there on the how much is. I don't know what the price is, but I already know which one I want. Good. And you sold me on the deluxification plus expansion content. I don't even know what it is. I'm excited to have it because I already like the cut of the jig. I want to like the game.
We have been making games for over 10 years now and you can order any of our past Dark Cities games during this campaign. Oo, spotlighting add-ons. Third of a point. Great bump up for this video. I didn't like how he didn't interweave more of the mechanisms like and what was going on. I'm here. I'm responding. But but since then, just great great stuff. Everything I need to know being informed back of the can you do it? We've done other games. Excellent.
Friends, Romans, countrymen, I've always wanted to say that. Join our campaign today for Roma XLI before it's too late. and a personal touch, too, which I imagine goes goes a long way with people being less jerky to you customer service-wise is personal. $333,000. That's awesome. So, I'm going to go with brand loyalties probably and a great video there. Why we got ourselves such a huge audience, but let's see. Seven created 41 backed. Let's go check out the track record. Facade Games is owned and operated from home by Travis and Holly Hancock in Dayton, Ohio, where games are stuff things. Let's make sure people got their stuff. Dark Cities, Hollywood, 1947. And I imagine they totally did because otherwise this comment section would be a flaming dumpster fire. But let's get into it. Make sure this one. It's not loading it.
We'll see. Always check the comments. Make sure people got their stuff. I see there is a six volume in the works. Cool. Yes, indeed. Hi. This get paid was over a while ago, but there's something that has come to my attention that I'm quite confused on. It was minor saying that all the deluxe versions offered this two months ago, two months ago, four months ago, four months ago, six months ago. Respect my authority. Uh, awesome. great customer service when I imagine it permeates into Hollywood 1947 and now we see why we're at $300,000. Like you treat your customers well, you don't print garbage and people will come back, right? Because there's so much uncertainty in the crowdfunding field, right? There's so many companies are like, "Oh, really?" Like they they're having issues like good stuff. And then Bristol makes sure but I I expect nothing else of it.
Quick update for a buyer almost spent three years I still play this game at Tutuga blah blah blah blah blah two years ago and they responded to good two months ago. So they actively monitor that. That's great. Can you do it? Excellent customer service. Love when we see it. Makes me more excited for the campaign page. Let's go. So can you do it? Absolutely. I hope they spotlight a little bit the track record of their games or any awards or anything like that, but we'll get there. From the creators of Salem 169, and I expect them to do that potentially now in the add-ons. Normally, I'd say you'd lead with that, but now that you've already kind of mentioned everything, I wonder if they're going to spotlight it later. Our most exciting and most dangerous game yet. One to nine players solo and dual modes. Okay. 20 to 40 minutes, quick to learn, social deduction, light strategy, free kickstart exclusive, the spoils of war, the expansion that I want. Welcome to Roma. This might be our new favorite Dark Cities game. I'll immediately back every game you guys release in the series. you haven't done me wrong yet. So, rock solid quotes there in spotlighting the credibility, right? And then also like how good this game is because it's like, oh, how many games is that? That's quite a few games.
It's like six, seven, whatever it is. All right. Play a card, do the stuff. I just want the price. Honestly, love to get to that quicker. Here's a threeminute explanation. Oh, great. Three minute how to play. Awesome.
Enroll.
Excellent. I love that the game has multiple strategies that we can use to win. So, no two games are the same. The mix of cooperative and competitive play is a fresh twist and keeps you on your toes. Alliances could quickly turn to rivalries. Fine. Seriously, the games that I like to play with folks who tell me they don't like board games. That's useful to know. Kudos on the quotes. Standard edition, the standard versus deluxe. Wood coins instead of metal. Plastic temple tokens instead of metal. Wood circle pods instead of custom paper tuck box instead of heavy plastic. No bag of fate. Wow. You could not have done that in a cleaner, clearer way without pictures. Just, hey, here's the text here. Like, not like what what are we doing here? You came to this massage parlor. You know why you're here. You're not buying the standard. You're getting the deluxe, but we're going to do like we're going to put on the the good face. The game is packed in a magnetically closing box. It includes mosaic artwork by the people, by the stuff. Just hit me with the price already. You mentioned the standard.
That's good looking. Uh the cards, 81 cards. And now like knowing what the game is, 81 cards seems like a lot better with the amount of text on the cards and the dual use. The delightful presentation, straightforward game mechanics make it pleasure not to have to engage what but also to probably own and showcase. There's a game of honor, deceit, delicious intrigue where I just want the price. Here's the expansion. I want it said everyone. You get stickers. Okay. Don't want them, but I guess I mean I didn't find one. So we're enable pins. The bounties of peace Kickstarter exclusive box of extra gameplay and goodies. That's huge. Want this. Can we just get to the We got the the more stickers. How to play. I really wish the reward levels were higher. Like I feel this is the second time you've told me how to play, but also it's the third time if you count the how to play video and the rule booklet would then be the fourth time if if we're counted correctly. But that also doesn't spotlight the fact that I watched your video. So this is now the fifth time I've learned how to play, which is great. But can we get a price first? Uh, rules overview from Bitewing Games. We got the play through one through. This is great. A video dump, but it's not. It's a nice clickable thing. Two-player bag of F. This is great.
Excellent. Like that whole spot right there is just can you do it city like on the game like I could I could see exactly how this plays it. Six players two players excellent ros as good as party games get shaky alliances backstabbing and glory from anonymous production quality components are always well worth the cost. Uh oh this is about our previous stuff and components are always worth the cost. These games are some of the most popular of the games I demo. Always a good time and I cannot recommend them enough. Just a nice smattering of quotes. Very well done. Oh, that's Oh, that gets me more excited about the cards. I didn't see that part of it. Excellent. The table talk, the blood. This is all It's all icing on the cake. I want the game if the price is reasonable. Is it going to be a terrible price? Is that what you're doing here?
Is that what it is? Tortuga 16967. Here's our other games. Maybe because you want to sell me everything before you get to it. Maybe they were worried I was going to just get this and not get the other stuff. It's 25 bucks. That's the standard. That's for plebs. 40 to 60. Bingo. I go all and what did I say? 40 to $60, right? Boom. Here we go. 55 because now I'm getting two expansion boxes. If I want to get everything, I'm up to 195. I said, "Oh, that's $140 jump." But for an extra 30, uh, I get recommendation for new. I love this. Are you Are you Are you a new backer? We recommend you purchase everything we have ever made. Yeah. Yeah. I bet most companies would recommend that as well.
Uh, okay. But still for 225, like that's a great price. Like like that felt like an like I'm not getting 25, but I could. Cool. 40. It's fine, but that's not me. I need the expansion content because we're completionists. I'm really interested to see how they did conversions on these. And they spotlighted the $55 one, too. Good. Good deal. So, I can't even knock it. I forgot about [clears throat] the featured. Excellent. 4,084 people got that standard 300. Good for you people. Sanity 523. I don't need the extra expansion content. I'm expect I'm kind of surprised that's 500 people there. Uh then 195. So everybody So 25 people got that. But 145 people got that. So kudos. That is 70 games sold of all their backend stuff.
Like good for them. Good for them. Uh, retailer access 36. Great number. Good stuff. Good stuff. They have a distinctive look. Like it like the cut of the jig. Coaster set. Hate it. Hey, the following items are available to add to your I would zoom in on these. You want me to buy your coaster set? What? I can't even see. Featuring artwork from these for this, but why don't you show me the artwork? Index box. The empty book box is the same size as our Dark Cities games. It offers you additional storage space, especially if you like to sleeve your cards. Okay. Expansions, standard games, closer look. So, they didn't really spotlight at all how highly rated their games are. So, I am curious to see if they could have potentially done that better because they spotlighted definitely that they exist really well. Like that I'm not worried about it not getting to my door kind of thing. But the the actual like our games are much beloved aside from some smattering of quotes here too.
1764 1789 227. Wow. Holy Toledo. Yeah, I think they did a bad job on that. Like just point blank if that's the consistency. These were nominated for things like if you're in the top 2000, you got some you got some some YouTube channels throwing your stuff your way there, I would imagine. because that's that's a really nice rating. Yeah. A top 100 party game. There you go. You're making a party game from the creators of uh uh you know this series including the number 99 ranked party game on Board Game Geek Salem 1692. Like that perks up the ears, right? So I feel like that could have definitely been done better. Uh thousand%.
But still that gets me more excited about it. Yeah. And just by mentioning this track record too, I think it would have made a much easier sell on the pledges where you were you're you're uh the one where you recommended that I buy everything of yours. Yeah. If I see that they're Yeah. top 100 32 two of the top 140 part rated games. Like we put out bangers 147. Yeah. These are all This is like cuz this now feels Menser recommended Golden Geek party game nominee. You see what I'm saying? Like this feels like this could be an incredibly impressive graph that you're only going to update in the future. It's like, yeah, we consistently put out banger after banger after banger out of from party games and from the board game geek crowd, no less.
Not just like the Target crowd, but like these are the people that are the nerds buying the $200 games and they like our party games. Like that says a lot. Any reward lever four bucks? Wow. This feels buried. This feels totally buried. I would 1,000% one billion% move that higher. $4 if I go ahead and buy all those books from you, the the six books like now it goes from okay like it's just and I'm not saying they did poorly necessarily, but I feel like they could have done a lot better because that's that's a selling point with how much shipping and I I mentioned this earlier with the brand loyalty with how much uncertainty there is around Kickstarter gamefound projects now like the fact that you have this distinguished track record and you have this great shipping price which is just it's up in the air and there's companies every other week like, "Yeah, we need more money for shipping. Sorry." Um, great stuff. Good stuff all around. Uh, FAQ 8 reasonable updates. What they have to say this for February 26th. First of all, thank you so much for making this a reality.
We love you. You're great. Stuff like that. Is it a shame this campaign doesn't run through April 1st because that would have been a great opportunity to have said the game would be housed in a scroll instead of a book. Uh, regarding the neoprene mat, would the places look too small or disproportionate to care how they fit on the original board? So, hopefully they'll come in there and answer that. But yeah, let's check out the comments and then give this one a solid, very rock solid grade. Uh, but I do I think the main image is bad, especially for what it could be. Like just like all this wasted brick here, like and just this zoomed out doesn't do it justice and I think makes it worse, right? Like I feel like it doesn't help and it's actually counterproductive. Well, the cards still be able to fit into the tuck box of sleeved. It would depend on the sleeves. So, I know this isn't entirely related to the campaign, but since I have your attention, I'm going the full deluxe pledge. I was wondering about Tortuga. So, some background. I randomly stumbled upon Tortuga in a game shop years ago. Obviously, I bought it immediately. Obviously, it had everything I wanted. A cool unique box, pirates, and social deduction. Since I've been a big fan of all the games of years I've played, looking forward to trying Deadwood first time in November as well as Escape. My question, what's the rule change for Tutuga in the deluxe edition? And they come in here, they answer this very specific question. What is the project shipping date? Couldn't find on the main page. Would love to.
Yeah, cool. Looks good. Um, no stretch goals, but it looks just you get it right because it's like deluxified from the ground up. Final grade rock solid like once once they get your claws in there, you know, with the personal touch. But I feel like they just need to I think they need to puff up their chest a little bit more there. Like it's like I feel like that personal touch would have been a great time to be like, "Oh yeah, you know, we got four of the the top 140 rated uh party games of all time. Apologies for that." And and this is our newest one. We think it's our best one ever. I think it would have I think it would have went a little lot further. And also that shipping spotlight that bring that way up higher. Like honestly, like the fact that that is not slapped on that 200 and whatever pledge level. Like I feel like this was a spot where we could have zoomed in and said we zoomed so far out, but if you tell me this is $4 shipping, like I was already partially there. Like I feel like I could have like right here if it's just like, by the way, these other games, they're really highly rated. And maybe it's in here. Maybe it's in the text. I just have to read through it. Each volume is a neat game.
Yeah, this is not you. Like this spot right here, this would have been the perfect spot. This was nominated for this. It's super highly rated. People love that. Like like and I think they were hoping the quotes would do that. But it's just n I feel like they they totally could and hopefully in the future do do that a lot better because I said do and they got they got the pedigree and when you got the pedigree, showcase it. Overall though, great grade. Go with a B+ A minus range. I think I'm going to go a minus. Great customer service. Main image I think is lacking. Spotlighting a couple things. Yeah. Just just the not spotlighting your pedigree. Like I like nearly at all. I feel like that's you're you're crushing it. You're crushing it. You know, because it's like here's the thing. I generally said to say around 12 to 14,000 when you're rated around that is when it starts to be okay. It's it's a lot more misses than hits. especially if you buy an expensive Kickstarter. Uh so to be this highly rated this consistently means you're making great rule booklets. Uh you're not ticking your customers off too because there's plenty of Kickstarter games that are way better than the board game grade because people just got ticked off the people who made the game and and so they're doing a lot of good stuff. Well, I'm going to go a minus. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Roma XL1 a book box game of exile and see for one and nine players. If you're enjoying the content, please be sure to click on that subscribe button down below as I'm trying to reach a larger number because that's that's how it works. I like to reach the larger ones as always. Thanks for your time,
YouTube. Bye-bye.