Spirit Island: Jagged Earth - Discussion
Transcript
Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, this video is brought to you by Audible. Audible is offering you a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership. All you need to do is go to audibletrial.com/bgunlock. The link is in the description below and now enjoy the video. Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for Spirit Island and Spirit Island Jagged Earth. So Sunny, this is your first video on the on the channel. What did you think of Spirit Island? Um it's it uh it has a lot of moving parts. Um there's a lot of things to try to understand. Um I think the biggest challenge for newer players like myself would be um really kind of finding the niche of your character. Luckily for me, my the character that I chose um it was really pretty basic as far as how to play him if you have any experience with games whatsoever.
Right. Um it was straight defense and attack when I could. Um but it did take a lot of strategy as far as where do I put my next piece, when do I make it a sacred island or sacred land. Um and really I think the the cards that I ended up getting at a certain point when I got the minor cards, I wasn't even looking at what the cards do. I was looking at the symbols that it gave me Oh, got you. the abilities because I you know, with the two yellow ones you can repeat the power and that power is actually pretty OP. So Right. Um That's interesting because I don't think I've ever played this game where I focused heavily on the innate powers.
Uh this is the first time I've done both mine at the same time for sure. Right. Like normally what I do is the innate the innate powers are just a extra thing. Yeah, not not a priority. So it's interesting that that's the route you took and it ended working incredibly well because you've got to be able you got to defend and retaliate back. Um and yeah and I got to kill things which helped the fear which my character's not a big fear character and I was just actually surprised at how much fear I was able to generate from him just by well well played cards and abilities. Mhm. Yeah, so one quick thing that I should mention because we did it's not the biggest rule mess up um but it is it probably will be noticed and I'll mention it in the run-through uh is that invaders don't give fear.
Towns generate one fear and cities generate two. So uh so we accelerated the fear a little more than we should have but I think it's not as bad because one we destroyed a lot of towns. Yeah. Uh we did a little extra fear there but two a lot of our fear came from our our cards. This is true. So it's not like we relied heavily on aggression like with your character or or a lot of damage where that's where a lot of our fear came from. So it's not the end of the world um but we probably I I think we still would have won I'm going to say because we were so close to wiping the board of cities. It was going to be Well even even yeah even without the fear if we would have changed up our strategy and got rid of those and then I had this card where I can deal one damage to each one we could have killed those cities and I could have used my And then we could have focused on on those two. Yeah, so I think we still would have been fine. I just definitely needed to bring that up cuz I was sitting there and I was like cuz it would be brought up. Cuz I was looking at the at the way to win and what makes Spirit Island so fantastic. I this is my favorite co-op game.
Um because in a lot of cooperative games that you'll probably come to find from playing games with me is some of them can rely on one person quarterbacking the whole time. That's like, "Okay, you should do this. You should do this. Everyone should do this." And I kind of delegate with and like this game it it it it lends itself to that can't happen. You know the cards you have in your hand. Like you're the one drawing the minor powers. You know your abilities and your and your elements that everyone gets to participate, be a a equal member on the team that can that contributes. Um And just And the synergy between players. Like there's no There is no There's no like one spirit that's like, "We won because of me." It's like, "No, we won because we all worked together.
We like I'm sitting here like, "Okay, I can prevent I can prevent some ravaging, but I can't do a damage as quick. Cat Oh, Cat, can you do a damage?" And you just pop one damage and it's like, "Aha! Now you're weak. So now we can't do it." And you get that synergy with everyone's cool powers that just make this game amazing. Um so that that's that's one of the things that that I love about this game and and I but I definitely have to bring in the fear because I was like, "Ooh, someone's going to be like, 'Actually, you guys shouldn't have won.'" [ __ ] we were going to win anyway. We were going to win. Uh side note, with the with the sped-up version, it still took over 2 hours. That's also true. I know. That was like the first thing I said to Sunny when you were going to the bathroom. I was like, "Well, that took a little longer than I thought it would."
I forgot that this game does have a a time limit to it. Like in a two-player game, you have a pretty good because all it does is just now there's two boards instead of three. Um but that just now cuz it's like I was thinking I'm like cuz we had it set up before cuz your wife was going to join or or Haley was going to join and I was like, well nothing changes in terms of difficulty so this should be easier with four. Then I forgot, oh no that means there's more land for them to explore. And that's what that's where the difficulty gets upped. Um, and yeah, I mean do you have any negatives about the game? Anything that you didn't like? Um, some of the rules are a little difficult to understand which is going to come come from playing. Um, and I could see where there would be a lot of negatives if you were playing with a very inexperienced just overall game player.
Oh, yeah. Where a lot of these abilities and the wording, if you don't play games on a regular basis. True. So like if for instance, um, we had someone other than Haley, like my wife who hasn't played a lot of these board games, it might be a little harder for them to grasp that concept. It's true. especially with like symbols on cards. Yeah. I mean this game isn't that symbol heavy which is nice and they do a pretty good job with the player aids but you're right. And for the record this is not a game that I would actually bring out to anyone who I didn't think couldn't handle it. Um, Yeah, definitely start with the original. a beginning cooperative. And like most cooperatives it's just like yeah, don't worry we'll we'll figure it out because I I can help. Like a lot of competitive games it's just like I have to feel out the person I'm going to be playing with cuz it's like are they going to be able to grasp it? Um, cuz I I think I'll answer questions. I'm not going to be like a dick and be like, "Listen to me."
But it's it's hard cuz it's like I'm still trying to play but cooperatives lend that for me to bring in someone who isn't experienced and we can just casually be like, "Oh no no no, that's what the symbol means." And you can aid them along the way. It's definitely a nice change up from like a competitive game where you always wanted to slide. Um I I'm relatively new to co-op board games. So, it's still pretty exciting like, "Hey, let's help each other. Oh, my character and your character, let's be friends cuz we're going to kick ass all over this board." Right. And that's what happened today. I I think it was a really good first run um for me to get to feel this out feel this game out. Um I mean, not a whole lot of negatives. It's just it's one of those things where we had the right amount of of experience and the fact that we we do other things outside of this and have that kind of commodity Right.
comradery comradery The made it better. Right. Yeah, no, absolutely. The the team synergy like that's another thing that I love about about this game is there's especially with Jagged Earth, there are so many different spirits. And they're all radically different in what they can do, how they level up, their growth, their innate powers, their special rules that each time you play, you're going to find some different cohesion with the the spirits that you didn't even see before. Like I just picked these three just because they were they're new. They came with the [ __ ] that came with the expansion. And I was like, "Okay, I'll pick this one because he sounds [ __ ] cool." I wanted to get a high complexity um and uh and fear. So, I was like, "Okay, so I'll go with him." And then I'm and I picked that one cuz I'm like, "Oh, the birds. That sounds [ __ ] neat. Uh and it had What was it? It was mainly It was just high control.
High control, very High control, high fear, and high defense. Okay, so the fear Because of your beast, you had no offense. That's what it was. You had no offense, no utility. Um and yeah, and moderate complexity. Uh and then I had moderate complexity and I literally maxed out on defense. Offense and defense. Almost maxed out on offense. Everything else was pretty sub par. Um but but having that Badlands ability, I The the four cards that they start you out with this character really do set you up for success. Absolutely. And And here's the thing for the um you were talking about the it might be difficult for new people. I I do agree with that, but what's nice that they try to counteract that is they tell you the play style of the spirit. So, you can sit there and hand someone they could be like, "Oh, okay." Like it it tells you kind of what you should be doing with your spirit. Um that a lot of games where that are complex where it's like here's your character, figure it out.
They are like, "Well, this is kind of what they do." Um Kent, do you have any negatives? Of the game? Yeah. No. Yeah. Uh I have No. Of the game of you, yes. No. Aw. Listen. I have I have two and they're very minor. Um because this game lends itself to being incredibly thematic. Where every ability you're doing you can you can give a reason of how you're slaughtering really in it. They're they're they're innocent people. We're the bad people here. What are they? Probably not. That guy in particular, he's he's He's a real ass. He this yeah this he thought this was like Steam Island. innocent people out there? he Uh but there's there's two things. One, you mentioned the the starting power cards, which I love because they are extremely they tie to your character.
One minor weird thing that I don't like is I wish cuz you would you have this whole deck of minor car of minor powers or major and it's like I'm going to get a new power. I'm the mist guy, but apparently I can do car I can take this land ability. Yeah. You know, and it's like, "Well, that doesn't really make sense to my character or my spirit." So, it's like Right. Um I mean, some of them you can really like what the blood draws predators. Who the [ __ ] drew Who the was that you? Uh next time the are destroyed in target land, you add a beast and one damage per beast. You should have taken that one. have taken that one. Oh, that was one of my last cards. Good. I wasn't going to get to use it. but there is kind of a slight disconnect. Like I said, everything else you can really just hone in on the theme, but sometimes when you get a new power, it's just like uh treacherous waterways. Why would that I mean I I I picked that because it's going to help us, but it doesn't make sense that my Silent Mist spirit can deal with water.
I don't know. Um granted this time with a lot of the abilities that I had, I tried to tie it into my theme, so you can almost always do that. But still, like the Thankfully with spirits and things that don't, you know, behave with the rules of this world, you can bend it pretty easy and be like, "Oh, the fog pushed them into the water." Like Yeah. Right, right. And that's where the synergy of things lies. It's It's not just like totally out of left field and you're like, "This is so stupid." Yeah. Yeah. Uh yeah, you can you can definitely still make it thematic. But the I It could have been It would have been nice if like each of the spirits had like either it's like different tiers of their spirit or they just had a deck. And it's like, "Here are your starting four cards, but you have a deck of your own personal that whenever you add gain a power, you you either can pick one or you draw the same way." And they're all tied to your character.
in deck building fashion, it also gives you a chance though that if maybe you're not really liking your spirit and you're not liking your powers, you can at least look for some that you do like. That's fair, actually. I'll take an aggression card because I'm like, "Hey, you know what? I want to do damage, too." Yeah. Okay, yeah. That's fair. Yeah, that's that's a good that's a good counterargument. Um cuz that was actually going to be another thing when you were mentioning the complexity, uh something that could be a negative for this game is if you're given a power or a spirit that you don't like. Like this is not my play style, so I'm not having fun because I don't feel like I'm helping anyone. Uh and maybe that's what they thought. Maybe they were like, well, this is the one you got." Uh but yeah, I'm get powers and then start altering how your your your spirit morphs into this lightning spirit that now does things. But yeah, that's that's a good counter. Um the other negative that I have is the game pretty much looks like [ __ ] The board game looks like [ __ ] Uh there is, for the record, a theme side that all it does is now it's like the terrain it it looks like the terrain instead of being color coded like it is.
It's just harder to see. It's just harder to see. I think it just doesn't Like it looks better for sure, but it's like I want to be efficient. There needs to be like a middle. Yeah. ground. Like the borders need to be thicker or brighter or something. Mhm. Cuz that side is pretty. It is pretty. Right. if I Yeah, if I had a complaint it's the board is ugly. Uh but I mean it it does exactly what what it does. Um I don't know how I feel about the events. I like that the events are there. And I like that it's like a bad thing and then a good thing. Like the top card is like most likely going to be something bad um depending on where you're at, but then you get the like the beast or the token ability and then the day haunt ability. Yeah. I don't know. What do you guys think about the events? Uh I think you're right at the beginning like when it said it's like, "Oh, you got to skip the first one because, you know, it can be swingy. It can either be really hurtful or just an okay thing."
I think it was a good move on their part to sit there and be like Well, yeah, that first card would have completely wrecked us. have just taken the wind out of our sails real fast and that's never a good thing, right? Cuz everything we did that one turn essentially was like, "Nope, you actually didn't do any of that." And it's like, It's like, "Oh, you know those cards that you need in the beginning? They're all wasted." Right. Yeah. But I mean all in all like it it could come at a really bad time when you have a lot of fear. And then it all goes back to you. You need one more? Right. That's right. terrible. Yeah. I would have felt less bad mid-game than I would have at the beginning where it's like, "Okay, we started off already behind." in the negative. And we're now we're fighting an uphill battle. Cuz now we got to reclaim our cards. One thing I will mention is with these having your your pre-made starting kind of four cards, I could see how it could get really repetitive if you wanted to play the same character. So like I enjoyed this character, but with this type of character, you before you said you've heard that this guy was kind of meh or No, I I've never played him.
Um I had no idea. He's um the one thing I found with him is I pretty much did the same thing the whole game. That Yeah, that's true. It was super repetitive. I played the same three cards and it was just maximizing the efficiency where you guys had a lot more that you could do with your character, which I mean for my first time playing, this is a great kind of opening Sure. person, but I could see where maybe house rules instead of starting with these four, you would start with like a random four out of the minor. Yeah. Mhm. But that was just a side note that I thought while you were talking. You know that's interesting because uh I've played uh there's a Where is he? He's actually not on the cover. Uh he's a beginner spirit in in the base game Shadows of the Flicker Like Flame. He pretty much does nothing but his fear is maxed out. Um I've played him multiple times and I have a blast with him every time.
Okay. But it could it could easily be placed out. I don't know if you're in in tactician games if you're a defender or if you're more aggression or kind of like the like maybe controller that if it's So there's a variety of spirits that alter to play styles um where that I think where the the replayability comes in is that okay, you play him again if you liked him. If you didn't, then obviously don't play him again, but if you did like him, then it's like, "Well, let's see what he would do with this guy and the and the lizard. Right. And that's that's kind of where and I mean the conscious decision of being able to do it worked. Right. and and it from my perspective even though you were doing the same stuff each time you were you weren't doing the same stuff each time on the board. So you got to at least be like, well here's the three cards I'm going to do but because of the alternate ways that they're invading, ravaging, the events that are coming out, you had to be like, okay how's this going to work and well as well as coincide with the abilities that we were doing.
Um but I definitely see like the point that that you're making that it's like, oh I could see this guy being the same. This guy is weird. He I I don't know I mean I'm sure they've they've play tested it multiple times but like you guys had moderate and I'm pretty sure it's low, moderate, high, and very high. I think those are the four tiers. I feel like moderate to high I was like I'm not doing anything with you. Guys are like, oh yeah let's do fear and let's push and then let's kill and I'll defend and I'll defend and I'm like well guys I'm preventing these that one from attacking. Yeah. Like in the in this game I felt like I was the complete underdog that both of you carried until he was very slow moving. No energy. Like I only was gaining energy finally once I started moving my people, my presence Well you would have been gaining energy at the beginning of your But only one to pay for the one card.
Which yeah one's better than none. basically like your character you should have gone for a major. You had the energy to do it and be like, okay well here's a big one. Oh I'm just going to do 15 damage or whatever it was. Like you can get sea monsters or venomous fires, things like that. Uh like I was like, yeah I'll try and go for a major. Oh it cost four? Oh that's never happening. So it's interesting because then you get to learn I think that's where if you're like, well, I'm not really having fun with the moderate kind. Okay, we'll try a high one. Figure figure that one out. Try that very high one where it's a customizable spirit and figure Like yeah, and figure that out. So, Cat, what what did you like about Spirit Island? Uh I like the variety that uh No.
Um Confuse. Yeah, just the variety of getting to choose your spirits each time. I like that the expansion brought in even more Really cool ones, yeah. they're creative spirits, too. It's not It's not just like your run-of-the-mill. Like you do have, you know, like earth, wind, fire, stuff like that. Sure. Um but, you know, like lightning, lava, Yeah. animals. Some some star crystal guy. Yeah. Uh I actually got a promo spirit. It's a hummingbird. Very cute. A hummingbird. It's a hummingbird. You know, I like the fact that you're trying to defend your native land um from settlers because you you know, like it's just it's nature reclaiming Mhm. reclaiming its area. Um I think that's cool. And for the record, also one thing we didn't do, uh which I've actually never done with this game, there are scenarios you can play with that change the victory conditions and change how certain things are going to react. So, you can also throw in victory conditions.
Um and also there's these adversaries. What did you guys think of the adversary? I didn't like it. You didn't like it? Nah. I think I like it. I think in a game where so much is already going on, it's kind of just like just keep one less thing to worry It's definitely an extra added challenge, for sure. Um I'm kind of in the middle because that one really didn't do much other than the extra damage. Right. But, it made you change how you were defending. Because normally it's just like, oh, there's one invader. Okay, he's not going to do anything. Here it's like, oh, wait a minute. No, he he he will blight it, yeah. Um I like I actually did like it. I thought I wouldn't because it's like, man, they already expand so quick and build so quick and ravage so quick that an extra difficulty. We were only level one, but it was manageable. It may It give you an It gave you an extra thought where it's like is where if you're defending and you're trying to defend um and I'm also trying to damage them to prevent them from dam- uh from attacking that we had to think about, "Oh, these two here weren't going to do four damage and kill all the Dahan." Like I liked it. I liked it. I don't know if I would do it every time, but it was a nice change of pace.
Um yeah, this is absolutely one of my favorite uh games. Um so, Sunny, since this is your first video on the channel, uh at the end of a discussion, we always give it a ranking on a scale of 1 to 10. Um that our my ranking is a one is the it it it it doesn't work. Like you can't even play it. Like it's the worst obviously ranking you can give a game. I've given uh zero games a one. I have given Now, I've given one game a one and it was the worst game I've ever played. I've given a few games a two. A five is average. Um that it's just like, "Yeah, I'll give it or leave it." And then six a little bit above average and then 10 is sheer perfection. Um or in the way I view a 10 was even if you have some qualms with it, they're so minor or you don't even really think about it that I That's how I justify a 10. Uh so, with that being said, Cat, what would you give Spirit Island? I know you thought I was going to go the end.
Oh. Shh. Who makes it up? I Uh I'll give it opinion doesn't matter. I'll give it an eight. No. An eight? Yeah. Eight out of 10? Yeah. Um I think Is that Is that with everything? Yeah. Okay. Well, I mean yeah. Yeah. I honestly think with Spirit Island Uh man, I'm really close. I'm going to give it a nine. I almost gave it a 10 because it I d- I personally don't have but the complexity allows me to not bring it to the table as much as I would like. Right. Like if it was like I mean cuz you can now you can play with five or six, but now with that's going to make it a four-hour game, you know, which I would love it with five different spirits, but that's something you have to mentally plan for. Um and also the complexity it there is a barrier entry. So I I have to give it a nine.
Okay. Um I haven't even seen the amount of characters, but with the variety of the characters and the uniqueness of kind of each ability because we all three have majorly different things that we did. Right. Right. Um and it actually paired really well. It was a very good first experience with the game because of course we won. Right. And we found ways to click and work together. I think there's around 22 spirits total. There's a lot of spirits 22 20 maybe 22 or 26. Um less. With the with the like the very minor details that you mentioned, I would I would probably be right there with you. I'd with both of you guys I'd be about an eight or nine. Eight or nine? 8.5? 8.5. I'm going to go I'm going to go in the middle. Uh 8.5. Um I feel like like you said if you got a if you got a bad character it might have been less fun.
Um but the first experience with the two-hour game and you're just like I don't get it and I'm not enjoying my time. Yeah, that's true. And I mean I had a like I said it for first time players go with this guy. Um he's They do have four beginner ones in the base game. They actually kind of tell you how to play them. So they're they're in there. But yeah, uh eight eight and a half for sure. It was very very fun. Perfect. So that's our thoughts on Spirit Island and I guess it's expansion Jagged Earth. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching. I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.