From FFG to Earthborne Rangers with Andrew Navaro - TCbH Interviews
Transcript
hello and welcome back to another episode of the cardboard Herald my chance to talk with creative Gamers and game creators and joining me temporarily from Costa Rica is Andrew Navaro from earthborn games welcome to the show man thank you very much for having me I'm happy to be here yeah I'm glad that you're taking a break from all of your friends guests whatever situation is going on there where they're eating dinner and you're here talking to me from Costa Rica to Alaska it's an amazing world we live in isn't it for sure for sure So speaking of an amazing world dude you just came out with this this game you it's getting delivered to backers earthborne Rangers is beautiful it's gorgeous it's Lush and that's the reason why we're here to talk about like the long road getting to the point of this game coming out how long you been working on earthborne Rangers oh man well we're still working on it because we're working on the campaign expansion right now so I've been working on earthor Rangers for about three and a half years at this point what was the Genesis because I I noticed when you go to the BGG page for this most of the times you go to the BGG page and you see like there's a designer or there's two designers but you got a whole handful of designers on this project I feel like there's some kicking around wheeling and dealing you know like there there's a real uh uh game design soup going on here so tell me about the origins yeah so uh well from that perspective um I
started working with Adam and Brady Sadler who are uh two guys who I um enjoy quite a bit um they've I think most recently with Blacklist maybe Brady was with Lucky Duck for a little bit uh but they both worked at FFG and I got to know them there and uh they did some freelance work for us um during my time at FFG anyway I like them a lot and I know they really like card games so I had this idea to do kind of an lcg Style game at the time when I was talking to them first like the beginning of 2020 it was it was very different from what it eventually became uh at the time I really wanted to you know start my company my new company off Strong by uh creating a product that had uh good cash flow like that's something that Christian Peterson taught me about really early on is like the importance of cash flow for a board game company and I knew how the lcgs worked you know with the releases every month or every other month but you know that turned into every quarter or every year now uh so I originally envisioned this game as a was a game that was more like a traditional like lcg Style game that came out with monthly releases so that we could have a solid foundation of money coming in we could build from there uh that all went out the window really fast yeah uh all all through like the first like year year and a half two years of
working on earthborne uh the thing I learned the most was making those style of games requires a huge team uh to do them at that pace and since I'd never really done anything on my own to this degree uh I I I just didn't have the context for that so uh that ended up just being something that was not possible to do there's no way me and a couple of Freelancers could put out a quality product like every couple months it just wasn't going to happen not very viable no not at all just not just just not possible uh and there there's a lot of things I've learned uh running my own company the last few years that uh where I've gained all sorts of New Perspective and appreciation for the different roles at uh at Asma day and FFG that I knew about but didn't fully comprehend until now until I had to do it myself right right right right so uh but anyway so um uh originally approached the saddlers because I knew they really they were big fans of Arkham Horror they really liked the LCDs they liked Lord of the Rings the card game and I wanted to do a Cooperative card game along you know kind of a similar type thing um and uh I knew they'd be interested in uh doing the design so I had some basic ideas that I brought I brought to them um and I had some very specific ones like I
wanted to feel kind of like an RPG I had the uh the challenge resolution system uh just a basic basic idea of what I wanted because I had played Gloom Haven recently and I liked I liked the card reveal thing I was like and we can do something like that yeah the DNA is totally in there yeah uh and then um you know I talked about a couple other things and said you know just go uh so they started working on the first the first version of the game um in early 2020 and at that same time I was working with Sam Gregor Stewart on the world and uh as they were putting together the skeleton of the design we were fleshing out the details of what would become the Valley now the world itself this is a post-apocalyptic game and you don't you know shy too much away from that it's not like a a big reveal you can see remnants of future technology in here was that something that was important to you or the team from the get-go to kind of set in this post-apocalypse fantasy Allah say thundar the Barbarian or sord of shinara or something like that uh well I I I so I don't like using the word fantasy because to me that says from the get-go like this isn't possible possible right and what I really wanted to try to do was create a world that seemed somewhat believable um that we could potentially get there and I really
wanted to set the story Set the World After All the Troubles are done like I I didn't want to dwell in that Fallout style everything is horrible all the time people are horrible to each other I wanted to get past that and not necessarily uh like gloss over it like P be respectful of the time that has passed but show that we went through a troubled time we came out on the other side and now this is where we are so we're we have this you know like apocalypse it's not necessarily an apocalypse because uh the people of the earth figure stuff out right um and while not everyone made it through that period and it was a difficult period of uh the settings history uh everyone came out the other side of that way better off um so I think that was for me like working with Sam the thing that was most interesting to me was trying to put ourselves in that head space of you know say you know 2 200 years in the future people have gone through this thing um how different are they than than we are like what is their frame of reference how would they treat each other what things would be important to them uh what would their values be uh what would their technology be like how would they want to live um these were all questions that were super interesting to me far more interesting than just what most uh you know
post-apocalyptic games futuristic games set on Earth dwell in which is mostly human misery and I just wasn't interested in dealing in any of that stuff even apart from postapocalyptic games just apart from most games in general uh especially Campaign games one of the the things that struck me is just the the kind of tonal quality the the texture of the world is not inherently combative right you know like you you definitely have dangers and threats and suspense in the world but this isn't inherently a game of survival it's not inherently a game of Conquest it's not inherently a game of I need to go to this Castle to kill these people you are helpers you know you you are Rangers you are the the people who are helping the Dennis of this Valley through their highs and lows and the various things that you can do and that must seem like such a distinct thematic uh uh direction to go into as compared to your lengthy history at Fantasy Flight games for sure where you know you guys were known as the Brawlers right you know the the Brawlers the beaters the mystery the Explorers you know like all that kind of stuff um was that aspect like bringing a new flavor to even what the the concept of you know uh uh adventuring in this world would be yeah yeah and that was
really important I I because I feel like you know like you just listed off like there's so so many games most games in the hobby space deal in kind of the same thing it's a lot of combat a lot of a lot of conflict um and uh in violence uh and all stuff you know that like I've enjoyed I enjoyed working on all those things I still enjoy playing those games but there's so many of those things I I didn't feel like doing another one yeah which is really necessary so right yeah so I really wanted to try something different that could be appealing to more people uh because I I feel like this uh this kind of like deeper card game um that's uh it's you know it's got basic systems that are pretty easy to understand but it's got like a layer of complexity that if you haven't played a game like this before like a magic or you know any kind of collectible card game or a Cooperative card game before it can be can be pretty daunting um but I feel like when you try to share these games with other people often times the theme is what turns them off not the complexity of the mechanics so I wanted to make a game that uh you could play with your kids and not worry about like oh there's just really like it's really fun don't worry about all the gross
imagery right right like Arkham Horror is a is the car game is great game I I love it uh but you know it has like images of people like gouging their eyes out like just lots of really really intense gross imagery uh and you know what happens to your characters is really intense and it's uh I think a lot I think there's there's a fair amount of people who are just kind of put off by by that type of thing um so I wanted to create something that you know provided a a similar level of of depth and complexity but was uh was appealing to to more people and like I said and brought something different something that just I wanted to create a world that that felt good to be in yeah I I like the idea that the game compels you to help but not out of like a a personal gain you know like I I've seen some other um open world type of card games you know I've played seventh continent and really enjoyed that or I I I've played uh sleeping gods for example has an open world system but in both of those the the thrust of the game is surv survival you've been put into a dangerous survival situation so any help that you're giving is really about this self centered notion that I need to survive this game you drive forward because you want to help other people
solve their problems and I think that alone gives it a just enough of a Twist that uh lets it stand apart and also feel so obvious at the same time right like you know like come on you know there there's a thousand of these other games which are great games but you know how many how many games at least in the the the the campaign Adventure game Space uh are you like just a helper you you're someone helping people with their personal or great Global problems yeah absolutely now I would be a fool if I didn't talk to you a little bit about like your your lengthy history in the this entire career that you've had I definitely want to talk more about earthborn Rangers and earthborn games as a company but let's give us a little bit more context for how you got here um now you spent a lot of time what 15 years at Fantasy Flight games yes okay okay so were you a Minnesota guy to start with or did you end up getting recruited over to there no not not at all uh uh actually uh I so I was born Wisconsin which you know neighbors Minnesota uh but I moved to Ohio when I was teenager or when I was when I was younger I was there through my teen years I went to school down there uh and then uh just life circumstances led me back up north I ended up in Minnesota and um at the
time when I when I got the job at FFG I had been working for oh maybe maybe about a year as a freelance illustrator uh for for a lot of like Indie RPG projects um that I just kind of found my way there through uh this website called the forge uh online which is old school yeah yeah yeah it was great like I I you know so I got got in touch with a bunch of guys there and uh just did did did some jobs and then every time i' do a job people would then refer me to other people and then I just was doing more and more uh for very very little money but it was uh it was a lot of fun cuz I was uh technically like unemployed at the time uh technically well yeah I I was unemployed enough to collect unemployment checks it was the first time that I've ever been like fired from a place I work I used to work at Starbucks and I there some ridiculous circumstance getting fired by Starbucks and uh but then had this awesome opportunity to um to have money through Unemployment but then work on my uh art skills and my freelance and that was really really awesome it was an amazing it was amazing moment in my life uh where um all I did all day long was just draw and it was great um it was so much fun and uh my skills improved vastly in that time and
uh but it didn't last forever obviously eventually I had to get a job and uh it had been maybe a couple months I had gone to Gen Con i' showed my stuff around uh I didn't really get a whole lot of bites um it was near the end of the D20 era and uh when everyone was doing all these you know D20 supplements that had all these really cool like pencil illustrations or like black and white illustrations and that's like what I was best at uh so I feel like I I missed out on my window of uh of working in the on dung and Dragons products by a couple years um but uh uh during that time I I I stopped by the FFG booth at at Gen Con and showed my stuff there to a guy named Rob vaugh who was in charge of the RPGs at the time uh he and I later became friends obviously U but uh he he said he'd call he said he'd send me an email he never did but uh when my unemployment was running out I needed to find a job I had gotten like a temp job someplace um I was like stuffing envelopes or something and and uh almost everywhere I'd ever ever work for like temp work or whatever I'd always get end up getting offered uh like a full-time job because uh I'm a reasonably capable person do a good job they're like yeah let's just hire that guy so I had an opportunity to get this you know this I don't know some admin another Administration job in an
office building and I was like man I don't want to I don't want to do that again I'd done that once before and it was a couple times before and it's uh I it was very very draining on me um but then uh my wife suggested I uh look online to see if Fantasy Flight was hiring because she remembered that that they were in town uh so I did and uh they were for a customer service position so uh I applied got the job and uh that's how I started in the 2004 so customer service for FFG 2004 uh let's see here uh Battlestar Galactica had not come out yet or had uh no cuz I worked on I worked on Battlestar galaa no the the games that came that were pretty new at the time was uh Twilight Imperium Third Edition MH Doom had just come out there you go uh Warrior Knights maybe around there nope because I worked on okay you worked on all of them of course uh no uh so yeah Doom was the big one because I remember seeing that and being like oh man that looks like spacehulk kind excited about that ended up being nothing like space much to my disappointment um but uh War of the Ring had just come out um and they FFG had published that in the states um yeah so right around that time uh so yeah so I started doing customer service and then from there I ended up getting a job in graphic design and then I worked in graphic design for about six years and I worked on Warrior nights B Star
Galactica Cosmic Encounter Game of Thrones second edition maybe Game of Thrones second edition yep uh no I didn't work on Game of Thrones second edition the board game mhm yeah no I worked on the card game okay there you go yeah the first version of the lcg that that was me yeah that that board game was Kevin childis he worked on that okay there you go yeah yeah yeah yeah so worked on a bunch of stuff over those six years and then dabbled a little bit in art Direction during that time and then uh ended up um a position opened up to uh run the art Department uh which was kind of a new thing because art had been done by pretty much one person up to that point but we were doing we were doing all these lcgs we're doing all these 40K RPGs we had so much art it was ridiculous uh so we needed a honest to goodness department so um uh Chris promoted me to do that and I did that for a few years and then after that I moved on to our uh our digital team to work on some apps and the app integrated board games so like manches of Madness uh XCOM yeah yeah y XCOM was the first one man that that was something I mean that that's that's actually to me like you know like I I've been playing games my entire life uh variety of games you know starting with heroquest and uh then you know like playing Magic when it first came to Alaska 1995 I think is when Bosco's cards comics and games got this new game magic
you know and my older brother and I playing that and then um you know following through games uh but I think the first time when I really heard about this controversy of app integrated games like the game is not playable unless you have a device was with XCOM and you know like you had a hot designer on the game you had a legendary publisher at that point because like if you were into American style games then you were into Fantasy Flight games and then XCOM is also one of the most legendary computer gaming properties and so like it kind of put all this attention on it and man the number of Internet fights over whether or not apps belonged uh integrated with board games was something else yeah yeah no yeah we were definitely uh Chris really believed really strongly in it and uh it was a it's a pretty intense project to work on um uh but it was a lot of fun learned a lot and then you know we applied a lot of that knowledge to man's man's second edition which I think is a much much better integration of an app uh and then later obviously uh much much later onto uh you know the current version of descent which I think is kind of like the kind of the Pinnacle of the the integration of the app in a board game totally totally yeah so then after after that I became the uh creative director uh at FFG uh and then became
the head of Studio so what when did you become creative director like roughly uh 20 15 14 okay 16 wow yeah wasn't that I wasn't that I wasn't in that role for very long it was a uh kind of a um training wheels role before I became head of Studio during this time you got to see the the incredible shift in this industry right you know like when when you started at Fantasy Flight games no one had heard of crowdfunding a project right crowdfunding a project meant Christian T Peterson trying to you know get people to help fund Twilight Imperium first edition that's what that meant yeah you know how long during this trajectory you know 2016 uh 156 you become creative director was there any point during this where you were like you know what if I had my own Studio I started to think about it a little bit just starting to get ideas for things like and wondering you know maybe I'd be interested in going off and doing it on my own but uh I don't know it was working FFG was challenging uh at times for sure but it was also incredibly satisfying and I got to work with some really amazing talented and knowledgeable people oh absolutely yeah so like I I
wasn't like hot to leave or anything like that um most of my most of my experience in talking about crowdfunding was mostly like us looking at it as what is this is this something that we should do as a like this seems weird if we were to do it because we're established we don't need to do it but but man look at how much money they're making you know so a lot of conversation wondering if it's something we should do or not um a lot of really interesting uh observations from the people on the business side who saw what was possible through Cod funding and not possible through the traditional methods um because you know at FFG we were we were making products for distribution so you know the the the goals there are very very different than the goals of a a game that comes out comes to a crowdfunding campaign right you can do whatever you want because you're just you're taking all that margin for yourself so like if you're charging you know like $200 for a game that costs you like $75 to make fine yeah yeah but it do that doesn't work when you're making games for distribution so um I remember it being like just kind of like an eye openening moment for some people uh to just see what could be done and maybe a little bit of little bit of envy and jealousy going on uh but uh thankfully you know
while we were there we were still we we we had so much success uh that there was very little that we that we couldn't do right uh if we put our mind to it um sometimes we did things that maybe we shouldn't have done just because we could but I'm glad we did them anyway yeah yeah and you know like we don't have to dwell on this I I'm sure that uh you've been uh asked privately or publicly million times about you know the transition from uh Fantasy Flight games to FFG being uh Asma Day USA and that kind of stuff and your exit uh but you know clearly at a certain point you decided I am going to you know take a chance on uh creating your own Studio working with uh other folks uh who you knew through the industry who may have worked with you at Fantasy Flight or you know been contract with Fantasy Flight at a certain point um what are some of the things like just as a a publisher or a studio that you have as a freedom or or something that you're still amazed by like oh I can just do this now I'm not covered by the red tape you know like whether it was asthma day or maybe it was you know having a boss or someone else but you can just go that's awesome that I can just make this decision yeah no that's it right there is I I'm not I don't have anyone
that I need to report to like except in some ways the backers in of like I but uh I think our backers have been awesome uh they're uh they've been very very supportive um and haven't really haven't really bristled at any of the creative decisions that I've made because I think when I've talked about it like I've been pretty clear where the game that I'm making even though I you know obviously appreciate the backer support and couldn't do it without them um I think they know at least I hope they know that the game's gonna be better for me to not do what they want but to to do what we think is best uh so um just being able to rely on my own creativity and uh my own Direction um and make decisions uh is is awesome like I I I love not having to justify any any creative decision to anybody you got an example like a specific example of something where you're like I know this would not fly had I been working for another publisher yeah well um the scope of the game definitely wouldn't fly at all um the style of the game um it it being a a card game uh that's expensive that's all in one box is like even people who understand pricing still get
weird about there being like a $100 card game oh yeah yeah yeah uh even when I point out like like again to the example of Arkham like hey if you buy this campaign expansion and the player box it's more than $100 like and and you want them both like you're G to spend more like I just I'm putting it all in one box and it's less why are you freaking out about the price um so uh uh so that's that's funny so yes so that that's one thing I think for sure would be really really challenging at a TR traditional publisher especially the way that we produced it um because pretty much every decision I made on the manufacturing side made the game more expensive and that is the opposite of what you do when you're trying to run a a for-profit business well well let's take a tangent on that because it's clear you know that there there is a commitment to uh certain ecological and sustainable standards in the production of the the game you know like it's all recyclable components right there's not an ounce of plastic that I found at least in the review copy that got said um the the cards were wrapped uh you know in uh recyclable materials instead of cellophane um and that really impressed me like that that was just like a tonal difference in opening the box and seeing what was in
there um was that something that came out of uh like your commitment to the theme of the game and it just occurred to you in the middle of the production or was that like one of those decisions that was foundational to the company starting out yeah that was foundational to the company um yeah when when I first started out I uh was working with um another guy who I had worked with at Asma named M Michael early and we kind of started on it together and then uh I ended up kind of just taking it Taking it over on my own after a little bit but that was something that uh I thought was really important to try to to push for and the fact that we were going to try to go to uh to crowd not necessarily crowdfunding but try to try to not really engage in distribution try to go direct to Consumer and then to uh like indiv idual retailer Partnerships knowing that we uh were going to be capturing more of that margin because of that fact made me made us feel like we could push the sustainability side and do things more responsibly um but uh yeah as far as it being married to the theme that was just kind of a happy accident it's just kind of the way things worked out uh and is it's a nice Confluence of things uh for sure but it that was not part of a master plan it just all kind of came that way I think maybe just because that's where my head was as we were developing the game yeah well I mean it
it just again kind of has this narrative I guess of being you know like a different approach to things we don't have to do things the same way that we've always done them in the past which yeah you know I I as a reviewer who gets sent games Great and Small to check out I buy games I'm interested in you know like I I try to not be a hoarder and have every game under the sun you know like I only want to have so many games that I'm going to be able to get to the table and even the amount that I do keep is still too many and I look at the pile of games that I have to find homes for because I cannot throw them away like I am unwilling to throw them away not just because they're games but because I don't want to have a landfill full of Miniatures um it's definitely a different approach that um I I really appreciate now the opposite must also be true to my earlier question about the freedoms and luxuries you have as uh your own publisher there's got to be a couple moments where during the production of this game that you were like oh man this problem would have been solved by someone else had I still been at FFG you know like you ever run into any of those moments oh yeah yeah no I think all through production and then through fulfillment uh and post post production um that was all stuff
that's brand new to me um I was obviously aware of it and worked with people who worked on that thing and were uh you know I was part of the leadership group at FFG for over a decade so I got to sit in on lots of meetings and learn lots and lots and lots from from those people but like I said earlier hearing about a thing and doing a thing are just completely different uh because like when you're here in a meeting and you're and someone's complaining about uh one problem or another oh yeah that sounds tough and like oh yeah I would do that and then you know then you don't actually have to do it that this goes off and then you hear the report of how it went later on uh but yeah it's it was it's really challenging um and uh to try to do all that while still making time to do the Creative work uh is also very challenging so you end up going through all these Peaks and valleys of you know I'm doing creative work for this this month and then I'm completely neglecting this entire other portion of the business and then I'm doing this other part of the business here and I'm completely neglecting the creative part so uh just having a small team where it's just it's it's me it's three other guys two are full-time and and one's part-time uh and that you know that is a much much much much much smaller team than what we had uh when I was working at FFG uh so we all have to do different things and I kind of like kind of like when I worked at FFG I would I take on all of the
things that I know no one else would want to do though I don't want to do them I know that role yeah so I I end up doing that a lot and I'm not you know not necessarily like the best at any of these things because I've never done them before so i' I totally made some mistakes uh and um hopefully I'll I've learned from them and next time around I won't make them again but uh yeah I mean there's there's definitely times where I uh especially when I discovered the uh so we had a a punchboard issue with the with the printing where uh I realized that uh much to my dismay that that we had submitted the wrong files for the bside of the punchboard and uh I just I kept replaying the moment in my head when I approved that punch board and I just I could see it and I knew it I was like oh man how could I have made that mistake and it's just I just there's just so much going on uh but then making the decision to reprint the punch and then everything that followed uh I don't know if I would do that again like I think the version of the game you got has the has the incorrect punch board yeah but you know for the for the copies that we had extra that were intended for uh for people to buy who didn't back the game we repacked it with an additional Shia punch so you know we spent all that money on that thing we've put it on at the end of the
day I don't know how many people would have actually cared we probably would have been better off just printing some extra punch and then shipping it out to anyone who asked for it uh but uh yeah so anyway um decisions like that where you you where I got to that moment where I was like what should I do should I try to fix it or should I leave it and there's no one really to turn to right right right to ask what should I do I could ask people for like what do you think but ultimately I got to make that decision you could call him Chris be like Mentor me tell me tell me what to do you'd say you should have done a better job checking your proofs um uh so anyway yeah stuff like that it's really really hard and yeah you in those moments I you know I just really wanted to you know hide but then you have to you have to make the decision you have to tell the backers what's happening you got to say Hey you know in that moment I was like well we're just going to delay the game a bit so uh sorry and yeah none of that stuff none of that stuff was fun I was pretty down in the dumps after that someone needs to make a call and you know people are still pretty stoked about the game anyway now yeah exactly exactly no that's the good thing is everyone's still really enthusiastic which is awesome right and we're almost there almost there almost there so with the game the the actual game play itself and you know like entering into the world of the game uh one thing that I just was over the moon about in my
review um which even if I was wasn't trying to avoid spoilers I would have spent so much time gushing about was the tutorial I feel like it is a tutorial that seems so obvious and so natural in retrospect but feels like I've never seen anything like it personally in the tabletop boxed adventure games talk to me about the evolution of this like tutorial that handles narrative character creation it handles introduction to rules Concepts unfolding as you go yeah so this was in your list of things that you wanted to talk about and I was trying to remember I was trying to remember what made me think of this and I think ultimately what happened is I just woke up one day with this idea where I wanted to where I wanted to make a game out of the the character creation process I wanted to create like a uh because I I know that people who come to this style of game they can be really intimidated by the uh the prospect of like building a deck and since our character creation process is so thematic I uh can you hear that dog barking in the background I love dogs so you know it's just a flavor you know all right that's character to the interview we've been adopted by a dog down here so he's he's been hanging out for the past few days Costa Rica I expected the loss
of raptors you know I haven't gone too much in the jungle yet so maybe they're out there um so so it kind of started with this thinking thinking about the deck building process as a uh like making it a kind of a a drafting game between the people at the table so you could do it together um you don't need to make any really crunchy rules decisions you don't need to spend a whole lot of time reading cards you can just kind of pick the things you think look cool and put them in your deck and then go and then just see how get a feel for how the systems work uh because also another thing about deck building in these games is that you're kind of asked to build your deck before you even have an opportunity to play it right right right so it's like how do I know what I want in my deck without you I have no context for any of these things like I I think that sounds good I'll put that in there but then you play you're like this is terrible um so uh yeah so like trying to create a um trying to create a game experience where you were eased into the game's Concepts and also eased into the deck building um because the way we have you build your decks is is kind of modular like you have your your background your specialty your your personalities uh it allowed it allowed me to segment that out so that you could introduce them slowly um and then by the end you have
your full deck and then you have a at least some sense of how the game is played and then at the end you know we give you the opportunity like hey if you want to change everything go ahead but right right right you get the idea so um so yeah it just kind of came to me one day and and I think um when I think back to uh similar experiences I think uh probably the most similar is like the beginning of like an Elder Scrolls game right uh I just play the opening of Oblivion again the other day I was like yeah this is really similar to what we're doing you know where it's just it's taking you through it it introduces Concepts it like brings things to your character and then before you got out in the world you have a chance to undo everything and start all over again it's a completely familiar experience just not in the context that you have it and you must be one of the few people on the planet that has spent more time than me thinking about how games are taught right you know like and I've obsessed over this both in a tabletop and video game thing like I at one time heard shagaru meet a mamoto um the the famous uh creator of Mario and Zelda and all that kind of stuff like I I know I know of him yes yes you know uh you know at one time uh heard him uh explaining the um opening of the original Mario Brothers where you know like if you have the controller and you're just moving forward the first thing that you do is you have that direction pad you can't move left okay I
can't up and down they don't do anything I move right and you just hold that button down and boom you die by Goomba okay so that you start right over at the beginning and then you go what else can I do I move over okay and then I have jump okay I jump over the glomba and just like everything about the first level one one is designed in such a way to organically teach you this now that's not the same thing that you can do in a tabletop game because you you can't just feel your way through it there's there's rules that you have to apply the game can't apply them on you in the same way that a video game can but uh the kind of unfolding process is about as naturalistic or organic of a project a product um or progress through the tutorial that I can imagine uh and uh I'm wondering if in your play testers was that something that you know really struck them uh was it you know something that was just kind of glance over for me it felt like this is the evolution knowing your history I remember when Fantasy Flight had the Tome of a rule book that was you know indecipherable I remember when you know like eldrich horror had the separate rules reference and then the learn to play guide I remember when Imperial assault came out with three Rule books and you know like
clearly you've spent a lot of time thinking about how people absorb information in games yeah yeah yeah absolutely um yeah and I went through that too and at chip Theory because I worked on cloud SP Spire second edition and we wor we did a tutorial for that and um yeah it was really important for me to try to do something that was not what we ended up doing in cloudspire or not doing what is done in root where the game is really you're just following the instructions and you're not really making any decisions you're you're just doing what it says and uh from my experience because I've played I've played root a few times but not in such quick succession that I never had to play the tutorial right but it's because of the way that it's structured and how prescriptive it is uh it just it never lodges in my brain I can never remember how to play because I'm not actually thinking I'm just doing what it tells me to do you're performing yeah so uh so yeah so I know you called a tutorial it's the prologue I I think we I think I tried to say even in the beginning like this is not a tutorial yeah yeah though a lot of people you know feel like it should be or call it a tutorial kind of colloquially um then and actually some of the feedback I've gotten from uh from some people is like that it's not uh it's not prescriptive enough like
it's too free form it leaves out details I'm like yeah it leaves out details it's fine like I tried to have this thing where it's like this is a way of bringing other people into the game or a way of trying to test your knowledge of the game after you've read the rule book right right and I I think that's exactly what worked for me is that I when I read a rule book that's uh lineer unless it's an incredibly simple game then I I have like this Bank of information but it really isn't applied to anything right and then there's a second time of learning the game where you sit down and you have have the rule book and you're like okay uh now I'm going to play around with the components and actually kind of check my understanding um and that's doubly hard in a game with a lot of systems and a lot of expectations and it's a game that wants to be different than most other games out there like this is not oh it's another version of descent uh you know it's not Arkham Horror if you know Arkham Horror then you're going to be able to pick this up no problem this is a a fundamentally different system and uh reading the rulebook start to finish which I I I did before sitting down with the prologue it was you know kind of abstract I was like okay I kind of get it I don't know I can hang up anywhere what are the consequences is this going to work but with that context then sitting down with the prologue it was just such a fluid
experience and yeah I did have to reference back to things and check my understanding um but I got to tell you it's a hell of a lot better than learning wor the ring for the first time with the original rule book Because I had that first edition yeah me too yeah no I'm glad you liked it yeah the yeah the feedback we got from the testers uh was was really positive um yeah I was really excited about it uh it's uh it's I think rules wise content wise it's the one of it's the maybe the only thing in the game that I've like really authored myself so uh I was really I was really I was nervous uh to have it tested uh but it went over really well with everybody and they had a really good time and we've gotten lots of lots of positive feedback on it I'm glad people enjoy it um and it's only a couple Pages which is great this game is an open world game which means there's a lot of content that in one campaign um which can take place over many sessions uh without getting too spoilery here uh how difficult was it to design around the ability to let the player just kind of find their adventure and maybe funnel them into certain directions if you could kind of catch them but also give that freedom and flexibility to just kind of explore yeah no it was you you could uh
have another interview with Andrew Fischer and talk to him about uh the challenges he he had in turning it into an open world game um but I think the uh the challenge I think we we the challenge was trying to make sure we had touch points that kept things moving uh regardless of what you ended up doing um and that was something that was really important to me is I wanted I was really inspired by uh I read uh dungeon world uh I think in 2019 uh RPG book uh and what I what really struck me about that book in the way that the game world was described there is they made a point of talking about the world as of exist of existing outside of the outside of the players actions and to imagine what would happen in the world if the players took no actions um so I really wanted to have a similar thing with earthborne Rangers where the world feels alive so that regardless of what you do things things are happening and you can interact with those things or not and it's really up to you and we just needed to make sure we had a system in place that moved things along regardless of uh of what your actions were and that doesn't mean that the plot will like autoresolve it's a different outcome if you don't engage but there is an outcome and that was a really
important part I think that's that's kind of The Secret of of keeping the a AR overarching narrative going in this open World Experience where you can really just strike off in any direction do whatever whatever the heck you want it was a great Confluence of things in my life to have this come at the same time that balder's gate just came out right you know and this realization that there are elements to this that um are unpredictable um though accounted for uh and that's what I love you know like in playing balder's gate uh there are so many things in the game where I'm like oh my God this is aware of this or I never expected a game to you know be counting how many times I take a long rest or something and then maybe I missed an opportunity because of it uh and this game because it's not necessarily a game where there's like a clean fail State and there's also not a real fail forward element it's not episodic in the way that a lot of campaign games are you start becoming suspicious of everything Andrew that day clock on the top you're like should I camp what's going to happen if I camp you know like what's going to happen with this lingering quest uh and I love that it feels so vibrant and alive uh
because of that um and you know like uh even flipping one of the uh cards to uh see how you did on a skill check and seeing that there's weather elements that are going to trigger based off of that that were unpredictable and then sometimes those lead into really Niche and obscure and lengthy interesting things like uh you know the the level of minations to get the the essence of this game working is is stupendous I got to imagine that you guys internally play testing that it it must have been tremendously difficult yeah yeah it is really really hard um and I think it's also hard to you know keep myself in check because when I would play it uh so I've played through it a couple times uh and my my most impactful play test I did was uh spring of man has it been that long already spring spring of 20 22 Yeah spring of 22 um and I wanted more and more reactivity like I kept like coming like having these moments like where that you can't you can't plan for them in the outline uh you have to just play the game and encountered the situation and I'm like well if this is happening then I want this to happen uh I want this person to say this thing in this certain in this instance because of X Y and Z so uh it if I could if word count and page count
were no uh if it if if were an app I was about to ask like is there we could do anything we could track all sorts of stuff I I think the physical component is really important um so we wanted to try to check ourselves there but yeah I'm not going to lie there's a part of me that kind of wants an online campaign guy that we can just go nuts do whatever we want well it occurred to me while I was playing um you know there is a limitation to uh keeping it as a physical product which means that you'll have certain repetition if you were playing the same game over again there's going to be a lot of distinct things that are different but because it's you know like beginning Point um you know you're going to run through the same narrative beats a couple times you'll like have certain instances happen just like playing a video game like even if you're playing an open world video game you play Skyrim or Oblivion or you know whatever ever again you're going to have certain things come up that are oh I remember that happening even though it felt so emergent the time that you played it before uh you really could come out with DLC for this game using all the same physical components as far as cards but just coming up with new narrative moments like you you really built a structure that allows you to just come out with like oh here's a print andplay camp cign if you're willing to print 25 Pages or something um or just refer to a
website or something then here's all kinds of different narrative beats you could play with yeah yeah no it's it's it's definitely an important part of the design that I wanted in there uh and that is definitely something that uh is intentional like the way that the the way that the journal entries are printed on the card and not and are not necessarily the narrative isn't NE necessarily baked into the card itself right allows us to do anything with those cards that have those Journal General entries on them and that is 100% part of the plan well then let's talk about the plan first off naming the company you are earthborne games you are clearly committed to this game itself was there ever any anxiety about like well are we are we pigeon ho holding ourselves by naming ourselves after our like Flagship Pro uh produ uh no it was a uh so yeah that it was that came out of a conversation I had with a uh a for former cooworker when I was telling them about the company and uh before I'd even it was when I was telling about the company before but before we'd had we had the game idea in mind and uh I was excited to share like that we because I going through a bunch of different names trying to figure out what what what's a good name it's a lot of names are taken let me tell you that it's like naming a band I get it it is yeah uh but yeah settling on earthborne was really exciting and um when I told
it to him he's like well that's a really good name for a game I was like oh yeah that is a good name for a game you're right and then it kind of just that that's was kind of the leaping off point for me uh for in my imagination to to kind of run with the setting um but no I think uh having it be earthborne Rangers and our and we're earthborn games um no there's no not not concerned or worried or you you know full full confidence I knew what we're making was was awesome I I believe in it and I think it's I think it's I think it's an incredible game and uh it's just one less name you have to remember I I suppose that's true I suppose that's true it's like it's like Katan you know Katan Studio makes Katan earthborn makes earthborn Rangers just easy to remember then is that what your plan is going forward or do you have lots of irons in the fire like how committed are you to earthborn games is making earthborn Rangers and that's what we will be known for or are you already thinking about like well what's our Euro game or you know like what's what's our our soldiers on a map game going to look like are you uh you know thinking about diversifying the library yeah we're definitely not uh doing the FFG approach of like we need one game in every single category uh who knows maybe one day we get there but that's definitely not part of the plan um no so uh yeah we're very committed to the earthborne setting and uh and very committed to earthborne
Rangers So the plan for Rangers is we have this uh campaign uh expansion that'll be coming out soon we also uh kickstarted that at the time of the first game um we have upcoming game found campaign where people can late pledge for that campaign expansion they can get on board the second PR printing of the game and we'll have more ranger cards you can get and other all sorts of fun stuff but the uh the long-term plan for Rangers is we'll have this campaign we have two more campaigns planned uh we have more ranger card expansions planned um I'm not sure how long that will take it this takes a very it takes a very long time to make game that's this detailed with this much writing with this much art uh it's it's a lot of work and it's uh and I and don't think it's worth rushing uh because if we rush it then it's going to be bad so um so I'm not sure how long it will take I'm not sure how much we will grow I'm not interested in being a huge company um but ideally you know we'll we'll I think if we can get to a spot where we're releasing a game a year I think that's that's pretty nice I'd like that that sounds like a good Pace to me um but yeah so the next few years we'll be doing more earthborne Rangers and then we have a really huge idea for like the culmination of of the story uh that I was just thinking about earlier today again in preparation for this discussion and uh in some ways I think it might be
even bigger than the than the core game in the end we'll see uh we'll see what happens um but uh yeah so we'll do a lot of stuff with Rangers we also have another game we've been working on for the past couple years um that uh we're going to be hopefully uh revealing to everyone at the end of this year and then bringing into crowdfunding uh sometime next year and uh I have one other G one other idea that came to me very recently I had a day where I just had all these ideas pour in uh for just a board game um that is not not an earthborne setting game but a really a game that I think be really really cool and speaks to a lot of what I enjoy in life um so yeah we're really just I what I tell the guys is I I just really want to make games that we feel passionate about we feel strongly about that are games that we will enjoy like I I feel like if we ever make a game where we say to ourselves what do we think we'll sell uhhuh your fa then it's time yeah it's time to hang it up like I right I don't want to do that I just want to make games that that we that we feel inspired by so uh so yeah we have uh one other significant iron iron in the fire and then one that we're just kind of just kind of started talking about recently but we got get this this campaign expansion done you know this might be uh the most PR question that I can ask you know but uh what do you want people to think of
as like the principles of your company because you know like obviously you worked for a long time for the biggest dog in Hobby board games uh you know and uh or at least on this side of the pond and towards the end there um it became less uh probably uh the the type of company or at least run with the same principles and ideas and goals uh than it was founded on and that you were accustomed to and it seems like throughout this project both through just like playing it as a as a product that I got to get my hands on and then also talking to you and knowing what some of these sensibilities are you know like what do you want people to think of as like core tenants of earthborne games or you know core principles convictions even yeah well I think that's it's two things it's the it's the sustainable production so like always trying to do as little harm to the Earth as possible when we're making what we make uh and to me that means sorcer responsibly and creating games that aren't just going to again just go to a landfill and last on this Earth forever and be here long after we're gone to be a Remnant in the artwork of earthborn Rangers you know exactly like the goal is is that eventually our games will biodegrade and
be gone um uh you know that's not going to happen in our lifetimes but the the plan is is that they'll go away that's okay this might be a little depressing but I really hope that you put as a as a subtle dig um you know to maybe your least favorite game that you ever worked on or you know you were tangentially related to and a component from that is you know like a background shot in earthborne Rangers and you know it's clearly being misused in some way uh but has been adapted into you know like a ritualistic totem or something that you know has a shaman is wielding as a thing of power that's right they're like they're in a temple built of action figures a cyber demon from Doom you know right uh yeah so the the production the sustainability side of it is one thing and the other thing is the the types of Stories We Tell the types of the themes and creating experiences that uh are are deeply enriching to the people who play them like that's something that's really important to me I I'm not interested in creating uh this kind of like frivolous versions uh I really want you to when you play our games to really feel invested and to feel that we put a lot of love and care and attention into it and you can feel it coming through and
that it affects you deeply like that's the goal so uh hopefully people feel that way and hopefully they feel like the thing that we made enriches their lives and they feel better for having played it well having never spoken to you in the past and Drew and only knowing a bit of your reputation a little bit of the reputation of the team and for the most part going in blind that was the feeling that I got so at least in that it is clear that you know this is an authentic game with a point of view that is you know both something thoughtful but also damn mechanically interesting it's a Gamers game too it's it's not just like a fluffy feel-good thing it's like oh my God how we going navigate this thing it's near and it's far and I got to be able to get over this and we're going to you know like exhaust this and be able to it it's a hell of a game and uh I I'm really impressed with what you have so far and I can't wait to see what's on the horizon I'm still working on the game myself and Diving through and telling everyone here in Juno Alaska about it so I really appreciate you taking the time to talk with me about earthborn games and earthborne Rangers thanks for coming on the show Andrew you're welcome Jack thanks for having me