Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beige Games Matter 1 - Sylla, Amyitis, & Nefertiti Reviews

Transcript 11:53

hey everybody today I'll be taking a look at three Euro board games and sharing my thoughts on them the games are amiitis and Cilla these are both by Starry games and then we'll also be taking a look at Nefertiti now before I get started on my review of these games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor and the place I believe you can acquire these games that is keyienda dot Co dot UK you're my go to online retailer for picking up board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so I'm going to start from my least favorite and work my way up to my most favorite and that means we're starting with amiitis and I don't want that to sound negative because I actually think all these games are very good so this one is a two to four player game takes 60 to 120 Minutes to play and that is very heavily dictated by the players because this has a conditional end game trigger where a certain amount of these tiles are taken from the board and that'll be the final round of the game so you can be quite slow or you can be quite quick you know depending on how you approach the game and what you're trying to do in this game is that you are acquiring resources by placing them on the main board here and then you're using these resources to try and claim these different tiles but before you can clean those tiles you need to make sure they are irrigated by placing these cubes in the kind of um the different faces of these different Gardens I suppose but you can only do them on continuous paths and work your way up The Gardens of Babylon to get to the really juicy stuff at the top now mechanically this game is actually very

simple I think you only have one of three choices to make on your turn the first of which is to use one of these characters which will be displayed in sets of three and this is actually one of my favorite mechanisms in the game because all these characters have different abilities um but when you select them first they are going to be free but then if if someone selects the second character in that set of three then it's going to cost you one coin and then the final character is going to cost you two coins and the money is very tight in this game so you have to be quite careful about when you can use them and you're going to use these characters to claim resources from the gardens here or the Farms you're going to be using them to try and get a little majority in these sections at the bottom in order to generate income at the end of the round to give you more of these camels to help you travel around this other board which will actually let you get coverage on the um the main Gardens here by collecting those tiles I'm trying to get coins which of course will let you take more actions I'm trying to get you victory points and also try to again let you plant more stuff in the farms and harvest more resources um there's also quite a quite cool tension to this game because there are these Tech trees that you can climb um which will let you kind of travel around this camel board quicker they'll let you get straight up points or they'll let you generate income by having your own personal bank and there is always fewer of those cards available than the number of players so you need to be making sure you get in there quickly or miss out on the opportunity to get onto that ladder so it really there really is this sense of urgency with the game that shines through strong in pretty much every aspect to it if you're doing one thing in this game you are giving up something else you know for example I might really want to claim one of

these characters while they're cheap but if I'm doing that somebody might move this camera around rondelle meaning that's completely messed up my ultimate plans so definitely um yeah it definitely has a lot of turn angst here and you need to prioritize your turns very carefully I actually think the game is very good it's actually extremely well balanced you can go for quick grabs by trying to climb those Tech trees or getting points by instantly irrigating these tiles or you can go for those more meticulously you know long game playing where you are trying to get the right resource to irrigate the right tiles and clean the right tiles that you want to not only get the points on them but also to get the bonuses on them as well um which might let you shortcut to get those Tech trees Etc so a really well cohesive and well synergized game here so I actually think the gameplay is really strong and it feels quite different to anything else out there on the market which is normally a thing I say about these games by um estari now that being said despite all the praise I have on it I do have a few criticisms on it number one is what I touched on before which is saying this game is heavily um or the pace of this game is heavily dictated by the players like for example we played this one the other day um I was pretty much the only player really focusing on grabbing the tiles from the gardens here and what that meant was the game was quite slow because again that game end doesn't get triggered until there are quite a fair amount of these Gardens taken whereas if we all focused on that strategy the game would have ended a lot quicker so we were pushing towards that kind of one and a half two hour mark where I'd have been much more comfortable if this game was quite steadily or reliably 60 Minutes long I also feel the game can feel a little bit grindy at times

because you do need very particular resources at particular times and lining them up can be quite difficult especially considering that you cannot carry resources from one round to the next or at least you have a very small capacity to do that so it can be a bit frustrating when you you have the perfect resources but somebody moves the camel past the card you wanted and you have to wait for it to go all the way around the rondelle before you can do it again that that is part of the turnangs and you really do need to consider that and factor that into your strategy but other than that the game is Rock Solid um you know my few issues with it slightly take it below a recommendation but it certainly is way better than most of the games being released today and I definitely wouldn't look past this one and um you know if you are interested give it a look and um you know if you can find a secondhand copy out there on the market I would recommend you give it a go so that is amiitis the next game I'm looking at here is Nefertiti so this is a three to four player game that takes around 45 minutes to play so there is unfortunately no two player option here but this is an auction and set collection style game as you're trying to collect these artifacts here but there is a Twist on the way you collect these artifacts because you are incentivized to monopolize a certain item so for example if I was the player to have or the only player to collect all these mirrors for example um I would get way more points than if those mirrors were shared amongst the other players so what that means is that of course you are trying to hoard a certain type of item but you also want to try and prevent other people from holding a particular type of item and get some investment in there to not only help you but to hurt them as well and I

know there are a ton of auction games out there and bidding games um and I have a lot of them but this one is a solid one and that is because it does a few things differently and that is mainly linked to the way that these auctions end because you can see here you have a bunch of different auctions going on at once and these will all trigger it will the end of these auctions will trigger in certain ways like for example uh this one here um I believe you want to be trying to do like a tic-tac-toe kind of thing so as soon as there is a a diagonal line a vertical line or a horizontal line of bits being placed then that is going to end that auction or there's ones here where you want to get a complete total value of 17 plus in terms of the bids that have been made or this one here we the auction will end when there are four chaining together so yeah they're all different they all work in different ways and also when these auctions are ended they will start from the highest bid and work down in terms of collecting these items and you'll have to spend this this amount of money that you've bid of course but if you are following another player bidding you have the option to either bid that amount of money you've spent yourself and claim another item or you can mop up the money that the previous player spent and this is a closed economy game so money in this game is very tight there's never any more money added to the system so having your fair share and having that kind of Leverage throughout the game is an important part of it so that's what I like about the game there are few things here that I'm not saying I have an issue with but I think they are a little bit Superfluous like for example you have these special character cards and when I've ever played this

game um these really don't come into play I think the symbology isn't great and sometimes there's more effort than it's worth to actually research what they do and but other than that it's a very simple game it's kind of a family plus weight game but there's some cool little twists on it and if you want an auction game out there that's a bit different to anything else I would give this one a look so I think this is a really good game it probably would be higher on my ratings if I didn't have so many great auction games I think this is a really solid one but it's not up there with the best of them therefore it's hard for me to say you know recommend Nefertiti amongst all these other ones but still it is good in its own right and if I'm you know reviewing this in isolation there's certainly not much I can criticize about it so that is Nefertiti and the final game I'm looking at here is Cilla so this is another three to four player only game that takes 60 to 90 minutes to play and I would certainly describe this game as unique because I can't think of any direct comparisons to this one so this game has a strong degree of commodity speculation involved as you're trying to collect these three different types of tokens and the value of those tokens will fluctuate as the game goes on and the players have a little bit of control over that this game has a very cool card system as you're drafting these characters and using them for their abilities they might be things such as these Senators which will give you voting power or give you more strength when it comes to being first player which is a very important part of this game um or there might be these Merchants which will give you more income during the income phase or these Builders which will give you more again more power to build buildings but the Twist on this

one is that if you want to use these characters for their powers you're going to have to sacrifice them for their ability to claim these buildings and these buildings are very useful because they will let you get these kind of fields and these fields will let you or reduce the risk of you losing points when it comes to feeding your kind of economy I suppose or feeding your little civilization or it gives you like more tokens it will give you more income during the income phase all these kind of things so I love the way that in order to do one thing you're going to have to sacrifice another I also love this blind bidding system when it comes to this phase here where you have this event for the round I suppose we are using your influence which is either money or your senators and blind bidding them with the other players and trying to have the majority and if you have the majority you will kind of get more points or you can have the power to manipulate the different Commodities which we've talked about before I also love the way that this game fights back against you because you have this kind of threat management system where at the end of every round you need to you need to be making sure you are kind of trying to contribute to fight off these communal threats which will kind of let you or force you to flip over some of your characters or it might make you um you know slides that Commodities down and make them worth less that kind of thing but you can really use this to your advantage like for example one of the cards is to flip over your slave cards and if you don't have slave cards and everybody else does you might think well I don't need to contribute to that because um why do I I don't care if the other players lose their slaves because I'm going to benefit from that so it works really cool it's always kind of changing it's a very Dynamic game and a very nice cohesive package here that it just feels

like it's got everything involved and you don't need to add any more content to it I was blown away with the way this game was designed I know it's not terribly well reviewed at least on Board Game Geek or anything like that and I'm absolutely astonished why that is the case this is one of the most impressive games I played for quite some time and I think this is a Hidden Gem I'm definitely going to um you know going straight into my collection and I cannot wait to play it more because I have an absolute blast with this one I highly recommend you get this one on another game I can probably pretty certainly say you'll get at an affordable price on the second hand market so if you can find a copy out there in the world and you like your euros and your tastes align with with mine then definitely give Cilla a look it definitely gets a Chairman's Commendation and it's gone straight into my top 100.

so there we have it that's my thoughts on these three games um some really good designs here especially Cilla which I think is an absolute great game um hopefully you've enjoyed the video and I've cast some attention on these games that aren't often talked about and are often overlooked if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved