Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 33:36

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for unfathomable uh which is basically the reprint to fantasy flight spouse or galactica that can no longer be found anywhere for a reasonable price um so the biggest question that a lot of people are basically going to be asking themselves is should you get this if you have battle star uh or should you get this in place of uh one i think that comes down to theme like if you if you love that show then battlestar does the whole the entire show justice um but also you're paying 300 400 bucks to even try to find if you want the expansions right you can get the base game for 100 but this is and this is only about like 80 70 80. uh but this is also you know in stores and it's and it'll probably be supported because it's fantasy flight um but i uh absolutely love this version um i'm super glad that they did a lovecraft it's it's that's like my favorite theme in gaming so i think that this theme and this you know as the was it the ss atlantica or whatever uh fits extremely well and this is so much more streamlined than actual battle star battle obviously because battlestar was uh you know 10 is like 10 years old at this point um but they basically do a lot of this uh the same things and incorporate some of

like you know the elder tour stuff with items and you know the similar skill checks that you do as well as spells and things like that so it modernizes it but also keeps it similar if you have played the original uh what do you guys think well as i told you before i've only experienced battlestar one time and it was about 10 minutes worth of rule giving and i'd never played it before and it was probably the worst gaming experience outside of munchkin that i've ever had and that's because you were the traitor right you were the cylon i was asylum right off the bat and i had no idea on how to play this game it was literally within five minutes we were playing and it was way easier to grasp so i mean it you know had i had had been teach properly i probably would have done better but yeah this one i like the theme better even though i love the battle star series from from 2003 to 2006 or whatever it was great but uh i i definitely like this this version better and i i would play again yeah yeah because it's also in only a couple hours like in a four player game one they incorporate the cultist role and then the hybrid role so there's still two traders you just don't know um but it feels extremely balanced i don't think the game leans one way or the other um because like the original from what i remember it's still a nail body you don't know who's who uh because you have to still play your role not showing your hand too early if you're a trader because then everyone's actively against you uh but it still comes down to the wire i mean even then we had four soul

but two food one fuel and two sanity uh it i mean it still came down to one of the trader's turns well did you receive your hybrid card in the second deal and i did it too oh so the first half so we no no traders until second dealing oh okay i was wondering about that amy what do you think so i do like it um i'd like to see what some of the other characters do i've had the benefit of getting to play a couple that's true we randomly got the same ones i like her um but i i think i liked my other character better i think she had more interaction uh and capabilities with the items right yeah um than what this one does i feel like i mean it's great to be able to play with the white cards of doom i mean honestly though if you didn't if you didn't have her we probably would have won that's true because it was bad or bad for much of it yeah but you got to basically decide oh is the ritual track going up or is the ship track going out correct uh which is huge yeah but that ability is huge in in being like if you're if you're a good it's huge either way if you're a i was gonna say cylon if you're a hybrid then you're like oh no we only have to we have to move up the ritual track oh no mother hydra's going again there's nothing i can do about that so the other thing is that is difficult for me but playing more get used to it more is you need to use these cards

like the first right the first time we played i didn't use these at all except for skill checks i will second that because i saved myself from you know from being defeated that one time that and that is huge yeah rampage twice yeah it's great yeah so i would say that that's that's something that people who do pick up this game need to pay attention to these cards that we get and not just throw them away on skill checks because they're a good number or something because typically yeah the the lower the number the better the ability right like uh actually no because there was a strength five and that was my get out of oh well it's because you're giving up a high yeah which which is huge yeah um so i do think yeah you're absolutely right that was something that was also in battle star was the actions of i mean because there were actions they let you go and repair um because in that game there were tokens they just got placed on a spot this one it's actual structural damage cards that you need specific skill checks too which is it's cleaner like you don't have to hope for a specific card to repair you just have to have a value to go in which i like and then i found that i didn't use these and the items and i think well not just the item but your one-time use card also i think that that would have been important to look at but it i found no or remember to use before everybody uses their cards right so well these were placed uh so in battle star you had a negative

ability and you had a ability you can use and you had a one time so uh they kind of did away with the negative ability for every character they gave you an actual ability and then they gave you your one time which is on a card which i much prefer because this is something tangible that you can get rid of to know that you've done it versus it being permanently printed on your card um however uh i will say in these are these are all good like some of these i i can't really see as um because everything in this game is supposed to be kind of double-edged sword oh if you're a human that's good for humans if you're a hybrid that's good for hybrids some of these are only good if you're human i cannot see the full steam ahead being um you know good if you're a cultist yeah if you really needed to get to 12 well i i guess but even then then you burn it and you hope that that's your one time to try and screw it over the only reason i could see this being bad is if because you lose a fuel you have to lose a fuel so it's like if cat was like the hybrid or trailer and we only had one fuel he's like i'm gonna use this once and then we just lose yeah so and like i said this would have been good to use at some point i just i never thought about you change a die value to any result right i mean see because that's good because like that i wouldn't have failed that you know mine is like monsters uh as an action i can just cast the top

spell card and with the keeper tome i can look at the top two and put one but that's the thing is it's it's lucky i have to hope that one of these is bad if i'm the trader um and funny enough though there was one moment i had because i was as i was the hybrid there was one you know whenever i cast the ritual and injured all of you uh there was one in here that i had that i put at the bottom and it was heal all of you got out of sickbay and i was like that's going on the bottom because obviously i was trying to have the game lose um because card i mean card advantage is so great like if you have no cards you're failing crisis over and over and over uh and that's why it's so rough to start the game because if you're the only one that can draw a certain amount of cards then it's like well let's hope that's not you know needed for the skill checks because otherwise none of you guys have it so we're failing and failing and failing and that's whenever the game can kind of spiral in favor of the traitor through no fault of anyone's it's like there's nothing we can do about that cat what do you think i liked it you liked it i did um yeah i mean i'm just kidding this right up my alley um i definitely like the deep one because i feel like there's not enough of the deep ones all the time like it's always just landlocked arkham um and this is a very like spooky spooky theme because it's like it wasn't until the end of the game that i was like man just imagine dying at sea like

wow with these things that are just gonna drag you to the bottom of the ocean yeah it eats ass yeah um so i liked it though just in general um it's not yeah i mean as solid as a uh battle star but no i like this better than the battle you like it better i mean i mean i one because like i guess i haven't played battle story a long time and funny enough i did just play it like a couple weekends ago and don't be wrong it's still great like this isn't like oh battlestar needs to be thrown in the [ __ ] trash because of this no if you have balustar and you don't want to shell out if you have everything for it i wouldn't say shell out the 80 bucks for this this doesn't improve it enough but if you don't have either and you can spend 80 bucks and get this or 100 and get the base game of battlestar i'd say get this because this will be supported fantasy flight will release expansions for it that's true um there are a couple things that i don't like about this though that i do feel are explored more in in battlestar one the deep ones they're just that like they're they there's nothing special about them and they all lump up into one i feel like the theming they'd be crawling up on different you know different sides of the board and there are some crises that cause them to spawn in different in the different deck spaces but for the most part we had one actually multiple times where oh there's 17 in this and then 17 here and it's like why are they all on just one side of the ship i feel like it would make the game a little bit more

exciting if you had to divide and conquer okay but it's a fair criticism but it's also fair to see that if there's 17 like oh [ __ ] we've all got to now move to this crisis area and we have to ignore other things going on so it's true it's six one half dozen of the other yeah yeah that's true um i also and this is probably gonna be because there are different types of deep ones probably in expansions for it but in original battlestar they had i don't remember what the ships were called but they had different types of alien ships that did different things the bay star and the rain yeah the bay star are essentially these um yeah the raiders and then the the heavy troop transporters yes yep so they had those and that was just another different way but maybe that's why well no that's maybe that's why they have father father daegon and because he spawns them and she damages the ship and that's like the bait she's the base star she's the one that is damaging uh the the ship and he's the one that's putting the centurions the more deep ones because that is the way you lose i don't think that's the way you lose in regular battle star i think if you run out of deep ones to place you lose the game so yeah i guess uh i guess i'll have to pull back that as a negative because technically have father hydra or father dagon mother hydra are essentially the different types of ships and i like that i also like the fact that thematically when you advance they move that's cool um so it i like you don't have to go out into the ocean to kill them that is also very nice because that is a very clunky rule i do like the

the card though that lets you kill from anywhere shriveling yeah yeah yeah that's a good spell it's also yeah it's a great spell in every other arkham game um the the other negative that i was going to bring up and i was kind of talking to amy and cat or before we started recording was i don't i still do not feel there's any player interaction there is strategy of hey i'm gonna do this on my turn so then you can do this on your turn but in and i have a perfect example for this whenever i played battlestar the other day there was a choice i got to make uh out on a card and it was like oh if if i choose this we lose food if i choose this we lose fuel and we were very low on fuel so i was like i'm gonna lose food and my friend who was a cylon he had a one-time ability that's like nope i'm gonna reverse like he had to reverse a choice that's the kind of interaction i didn't feel was in this there wasn't really anything no one-time ability no card play that's like nope as a height like because basically if you're a hybrid or a cultist you just have to hope that the two traders aren't back to back it's like okay well [ __ ] it's getting real close to the the humans winning i just got to hope for my turn and all right well you guys won there's nothing we can do yeah and i wouldn't mind seeing a thing like if you're in the same ship location being able to trade cards or items that way you can trade trading is an action ah that's a thing that i did not know yeah yeah you can uh where is it um action you can move attack rescue enable

the trading of items between players and like i said that other character allowed me to receive items and then give them and hand them out so i mean there is some of that but i guess i'm talking about more about in terms of being a traitor yeah kind of like my one time screw you the only time you can do that which i i do like i do like that everyone has a reveal as a traitor ability that is because also what's nice and this is brilliant on their end in battle star that was on your card so if you for if you drew like your cylon card and you forgot your ability you'd have to pick it up again and then read it and at that point everyone's like what are you reading right yeah because there's nothing else there's no reason to read your your human card it would be great if we'll talk about another game that we recently played uh shadows you know it had you know if you're a trader you know it's got that stuff on it it's a play raid you can see it plain as day so that like because i totally when we were supposed to be looking at these that's revealed trader rules on the back of that but does it have the cultist on there it's there the cultist is essentially the same the only thing that's different for the cultists is your win right which is which is what i i didn't read it here because i didn't you know you were like you took two seconds to put it away and i was like well [ __ ] i don't want to be sitting here looking at this i mean cat did say hey we're supposed to read it and i was like all right all fairness i was like because that's that is unfair to you

it is true but um i was like oh i just can't remember so i was really getting into looking at the the people that's what i was doing on the phone i was trying to find online rules for the culture because i was like [ __ ] i can't i mean because that's the thing is that you have that 30 second rule but the problem is is you don't need it because there's nothing different it's like there's different texts if you're a human there's no different text of your hybrid so it really is i guess just for players to kind of see how they win when they're all of a sudden dealt you know a traitor card however yeah i mean if you've played i mean if you play this game a couple times and you're gonna know oh i'm the cultist i know how to win but there is yeah uh the play raids are very very nice like and there's enough of them for everyone to play of what you do on your turn how the brig works revealing as a trader it's all here and what's also great is if you see somebody reading the revealed trader rules you know that's kind of a giveaway it is also as hell yeah right yeah uh and that's just kind of it it is one of those things in every single trader game that's like how do i do this i guess instead of shattering it yeah yeah um yeah that's an unnecessary cost and right uh but other than that i really have like no negatives uh like it still would be and they can add that in the expansion you know ways to make the you know the traders you know easier for them to win you know kind of a balancing act on both sides if you're having a hard time on either side uh one other thing that you mentioned the other day was the players that you play as aren't your

typical lovecraft that are oh it's not michael mcglenn and jenny barnes and ashcamp it's not them every single [ __ ] time where it's like i know their story how much can you give me uh yeah these are different characters definitely yeah i mean because cthulhu death may die was the same way right it was like oh these are just one of them's rasputin as a character so uh they had to come up with stretch goals for their kickstarter campaign that is fair but yeah here it's like i don't know if these characters are in um an actual lovecraft lore yeah or if they're i mean they have their arkham horror files or if these are characters that they have actually created but the their backstories are all still extremely fascinating and pertain specifically to why they're on the ship which i always enjoy it's not just like some vague oh weird stuff happened at the cafe and this waitress went to go become an occult leader it's like what so that is very nice um do you guys have any negatives no no yeah i mean yeah i i'm trying to think of things well there is the two ritual tracks uh instead of just because in battlestar there's just the one track that you move up you have the jump drive that you can risk passengers to kill to try and jump ahead of time or wait uh what do you guys think of the banishment spell i like it you like it i think it balances the amount of deep ones that you have

yeah um but at the same time if you're not careful you also take negatives so i think it's a balancing act yeah maybe that's their counter cards are everything in this game and being in sickbay drawing one card is terrible yeah that was also in battle star going in sick they sucks uh i mean i'd much rather draw one card and still get to do a turn then versus just be like oh you're skip your turn you're in sickbay uh the brig also sucks if you get sent to the brig um and that is a negative that's also a negative for battlestar is if you're sent to the brig your game is essentially over if we did not want you to get out no there was no way there's no if we had those cards somebody could do it every turn well exactly and if we had those cards early on with the trader and the cultist yeah then i would have just been sol mm-hmm yeah i mean pretty much if if i was the hybrid at the beginning or let's say you went to the break after i did get the hybrid like i would have actively kept you in there yeah just because i wouldn't risk it because it's like well the cultists can't really help me as much at um really putting cat in the break is what would have been important that extra moving extra spots um god and you can [ __ ] send people to the break i forgot yeah i totally could kill you yeah you go to the cap you go to the freaking oh well we can't because it was broke it was it was damaged um for granted i had the will if i had known like at that point we both should have just revealed you had the will but did you have the way well i could have went there i could have fixed it and then you could have went on your turn and sent cat to the break because

she was yeah that's a good point she was the one to uh that was gonna ramp it up and we it was damn but then we would have had to heal the ship to try and stop it so we would have had to try the risk um you don't want to do too much in the favor of humans yeah i know and i had to keep showing that that was good by oh i'm going to cast this plague locus and kill five literally the only time that i was like this isn't right is when you were like when i looked over because i was i thought yeah you're full steam ahead i was like i was checking to see if you had to damage the ship i was hoping you were the cultist i was like because i was like yes double move the ship and damage it but you weren't you weren't okay with damaging this that was my only hope because at that point i saw how it moved up and i'm like okay the only way i'm winning is i figured that's the cultist yeah it was like there was no benefit to me to reveal because then i could have you know because you reset it you can actually attack other players too there's your there's your player interaction if i was as well my reveal is um if i'm not in the break i get to damage an un-damaged interior yeah usb cultist or the hybrid would have been this one would have been fun too because i get to choose four different water spaces and spawn a deep one in each of those spaces that's not bad because you can also draw up and try mine's not actually that great is is uh when i reveal as a trader i can retreat or advance the ritual track up to two which it's that's only good if there's a lot of passengers yeah or if you guys

are uh mine's great for the cultist because it resets this track yeah but for the traders no point yeah so it's it the the trader mechanic is kind of give or take some are better than others i think as as a trader like they're situational like mine could be good if i risk a bunch right and then it's like ah move it up and then kill five of them um because you can also i think there's there's something that happens i can't remember if you have no passengers to take but some of these are oh i guess only two of them two of them are doubles one's a soul and a sanity and then two you know two souls uh but there's also a couple misses um but yeah you're right there's there is there's some player interaction when you reveal because yeah you go out and you attack someone um you you can personally go out and kill passengers uh as as the trader so um but yeah you can send people to the brig um but yeah that's uh that's all i can really think of uh for uh for this game i am very happy with how it turned out i had heard rumors that they were making a cthulhu remake for battle star um i won't be keeping battlestar i would much rather play this over that one because it is streamlined and does everything that the original does and it actually has art instead of

stupid stock like your theme and the theme's way better yeah because all the flavor texts in battle star it's like they're from the show and i'm like well i haven't seen the whole show so i don't know what the [ __ ] they're talking about and this one everyone can i mean obviously some people don't like lovecraft but you can generally get people into and they're going to understand what's going on versus being like i don't know who this character is you know like no one this isn't a real person so you don't have to know in battlestar it's like oh hey you're starbucks you're starbuck or you're the the shitty guy that everyone hates in the entire show what was his name guys guys baltar it's like uh yeah in the show everyone hates him and it's like okay who cares i don't know i haven't seen the show um i mean he only sold out the human race yeah but there was never a cylon right why yeah well because then in the africa six and she was hot well then oh yeah yeah the belongings yeah the uh i mean because in the in the board game he starts with two loyalty cards at the beginning of the game so statistically and he whenever we played he was a cylon it's like yeah statistically you're gonna have it um but there's also a chance you won't uh and i just love these kinds of games like this one still does the trader mechanic the best in my opinion because it's never a time where you're like maybe someone isn't a trader and once everyone kind of clicks with that it's like okay game's super easy dead of winter is that way if you if no one's a betrayer the game i feel like because everyone's working for christ but you gotta play on the more difficult

but with this game you know that there's a traitor and you know that there's a cultist and yet the fact that you know i didn't pinpoint it as either of you guys i couldn't really pinpoint it the same way yeah yeah well that's that's what that's what's fantastic is at some point it's like okay maybe we are working together i definitely didn't know until until i'm looking over and i'm like we need to get you to play thing outpost 31 yes please and uh and then once we can get it and then get it here because that is you may all start out as normal but then there are the imitation cards that come out and you know so it might start out with one invitation but then the next round you know now there might be two or three imitations and it's like at the end there's four seats on the helicopter okay who's gonna make the vote to who gets on and like okay we can use some blood test kits and try and rule some people out and it's it's very i've been human every time and i've been murdered every time they just won't let you on it's a good movie and i bet it's a great game it's a great it's great well and that's what makes these these games super fun because you you don't have to be like aggressive about it like yeah it's fun to kind of be like oh cat's the traitor but then as as you keep saying it over and over someone does something you're like whenever you didn't kill both and jumped over i was like why wouldn't he do that that's interesting uh anyway catch the traitor and then it's like then you slowly start to you know doubt and this one because

i just love the fact that someone will be a traitor at some point um and it might even be you you might be human then you're all of a sudden like okay [ __ ] all right now i gotta like all right i was helping out a lot now i also don't have to aggressively try the test oh yeah because the second card uh yeah you did get the the hybrid um i figured your negative would have been the cultist uh i think the cultists is difficult because you definitely like if i was the hybrid i would have tanked it the first chance i got yeah um unless i had revealed and you knew and you know you were like okay either i can tank it and win or i can try and get this through and help steve and me to win together see that's the thing there's no loyalty between i'm loyal to the hybrid but you're like i don't give a [ __ ] you know that's true i'll tank the game it's like it's it's a what is it means to an end it's like i wouldn't want to go against you because you're going to help me win at the end of the day uh now there is something that is i should bring up that is gonna be more prevalent in a higher player game because it plays up to six whenever you reveal like let's say i have two hybrid cards when i reveal as a trader you reveal your non like so let's say i had two hybrid or let's say i had i my first card was the cultist my second card's the hybrid i reveal oh yep i'm the cultist and i take this one and i hand it to another player so now i know for a fact if i happen to have both that cat's now a hybrid so you could actually infect other players to

what if that was a human card would you still pass it you still have to pass it but i can try and i mean now you guys so if i would have revealed as a cultist you would have handed your human card out to another player to another player but it's face down so it it's it sews um doubt between players because now you guys might think well he revealed okay we're not gonna go with cat we're gonna throw a cat in the brig um like so it and i like that idea because one if let's say it is just me as i happen to have both and it's like well [ __ ] okay i'll reveal myself you know as you know as the hybrid and then do my stuff and then i i'm like and now i want because that that's perfect to get someone who can move the ship be like okay because now cat wouldn't be working to try and full steam ahead and it's only if the distance is less than 12 do you give your unrevealed loyalty card to another player yeah so giving it to someone who has control because once again this game has variety and situation it's like nope i want the person who can control this right now i want the person who can move that all the way back because we're right there it's uh who's going next oh it's steve there you go buddy because if i don't know you're the traitor or the cultist or it's like okay well now you are now i need you to reveal and move that back so it there is i guess the more we talk about there is player interaction but there isn't any gotcha right so uh that's it that's all i can think of um

on a scale of one to ten uh we'll start with amy we'll go this way so capitalize i will give you a seven or an eight okay which one seven point five i guess that's what i'm giving yeah seven point five right in the middle um and it's only because like i said i would love to do more playthroughs with other characters and even seeing what a bigger group would do yeah i think i think it would cause it a longer game but i think that it would be you'd be surprised yeah it might not be this took about two hours my six player game of battlestar was about two and a half okay two and a half three so it does make it longer but like i said i i like the dynamics i'd like to see what the dynamics would be with the more players in a six player game uh the loyalty cards there are nine humans one cultist and two hybrids see and so that sounds like it'd be kind of a fun dynamic because then you have to really try to figure it out and it's not like oh well i know two people are yeah yeah i will say i would never play this with three i mean three makes it fine yeah i mean because it's always gonna be the the loyalty cards are half um four i actually thought was was really good that's good four four i would say four or six no and i think you also make a good point i think that i would give it the eight because it is up to six players and sometimes we have trouble finding games to do like higher numbers of players that aren't just like this one isn't convoluted to teach right you get a winner it you know has that hidden trader in it it's a longer game it's more complex for new players this one is pretty

simple for new players i think they struck a good balance because they could have easily [ __ ] this up and it's like great okay it's a shittier battle star i don't want to buy this because it's bad and i can't get battlestar anywhere because it's you know 300 bucks um but yeah in a six player game it is fantastic because there is still that chance the opening six cards are all human but you with more players you're like statistically that is unlikely who the [ __ ] is it like which one are you all right can't be cat cause she's not playing well what's your score nine i absolutely love i mean i give battlestar 9 as well this this basically is the exact same game um but just streamlined and matches matches a theme um i almost never like on a top 10 gaming experiences battlestar would have been been in there because it's always super tense uh this matches a theme well i'd probably get valve star in eight because i like this scene a lot better um the fact that streamlined they didn't do any weird weird stuff to make it like fantasy flight they didn't do some weird crisis deck [ __ ] uh they added enough newness that there's no crisis deck which is in your hand by the way no no like because in like fallout for example they have that's those stupid quest cards and then arkham or third edition which is dog [ __ ] like they they and they didn't just re-skin it this isn't the paces on theme they actually incorporated the theme deep ones uh the item decks the spells um

it they just did a fantastic job at allowing people to have that battlestar galactica experience and have a readily available game so i'd give it a nine cat giving it an eight wow i guess you hate it no yeah that's good for cat that's the highest score since i've since you've started been on the channel that's true uh i'm always getting like three for four and you go together typically if it's cooperative it's gonna go i love a co-op game unless you're the trader even if it no i like being a trader i was hoping you were because i rely on your ability to to crash the ship uh i did crash the ship just into the [ __ ] harbor and also you're all going to jail i know that was my objective i could swim in the ocean i survived you died unfortunately my robes got filled with water all right perfect so eight point five yeah nine eight all right so that's our thoughts on unfathomable let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other

than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved