Inis Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about inish which is a 2016 release board game designed by christian martinez and published by matago games this one accommodates two to four players and takes around an hour to play so the main mechanisms in this game are area control and car drafting and the game is going to look a bit like this once it's set up so you have this map made up of these modular tiles which all have these different landscapes so you've got your stone circle here you've got your lost vale and your mountains and this is going to change from game to game depending on the setup you choose or or randomly pick um each game is going to start with a capital represented by this big kind of plastic miniature here and you've got these sanctuaries as well which can come into play and be quite important for win conditions and each player is going to deploy some pieces onto the board um during setup um you are also going to pull out these um advantage cards from this deck of cards here which match the different landscape so as you can see i've got mountains los vale and stone circle i pulled out the matching cards for those and that can give the player controlling those regions a bit of a boost and a bit of a power to use throughout the game should they control that region uh each player is going to have their supply of pieces and there are a few different decks here as well so you've got this deck of kind of action cards which are going to be used from round to round you've got these epic tail cards which can give you kind of real powerful abilities and of course those advantage cards i mentioned earlier and in addition to all of these um these modular tiles here you've got a bunch more that can come into play you've got these deeds tokens
which can give you a bit of a boost when it comes to winning and you've got these pretender tokens which again are going to be quite important throughout the game so let's talk about how the game actually plays out so the each round of this game is broken into two pretty distinct phases the first being the assembly phase and the second being the season phase and these card references are really good they're a good aid to help you understand how each round is um is broken down so in the assembly phase it's pretty simple you're going to have a look who is the dominating faction where the capital is so as you can see here the orange player is the only person there um so they are dominant but say um the blue player only had one in there because the orange player has two they're still going to be dominant so whoever's got the majority is going to be the bren and the bren is kind of a little useful tool that gives that player a little bit of a tie breaking rule when it comes to winning so being the brand is often quite advantageous and after that's done you are going to have a look at all the different terrain types here and see who is the dominant faction so again the orange player controlled the lost veil so they would take the lost veil card which can give them a bit of a boost the the stone circle was controlled by the blue player so they would get the stone circle card and the mountains is controlled by the white player so they would get the mountains card and let's just take a little look at what these kind of things can do so for example the mountains means that whenever somebody moves into the mountains you would normally have to basically kill a clansmen so basically to
represent how dangerous that terrain is and i should say not all of these different um boards have a special rule on them but some of them do but the mountains um if you have the if you control that region you are not going to have to forfeit that that player piece so you've got an advantage there so you don't have to suffer a casualty should you choose to travel through the mountains the brent is then going to flip this flock of crows tiles just like a coin and wherever it lands is going to determine the turn order so it's going to start with the brand and then go clockwise in this example but the other side shows anti-clockwise and that can be important for a number of things and finally after that you are going to shuffle or the brent is going to shuffle these action cards and there are going to be a full action cards per player plus one in this deck so you've got a pretty good idea what's going to be in here and you're going to dish out four cards to each player and then a draft is going to start so if you're familiar with this channel you're probably aware about how card drafting works but once each player has been given their four cards they're going to select one of those cards so let's say for example this player wants to choose this migration card they would put it to the side and then pass the rest of them to the next player meaning that when this player is done they're going to get a new bunch of three cards however inish works slightly differently where the card that you've set aside in the previous drafts is not locked in place you can actually choose to put that back into the fold and then pick another two so in my second hand i could say oh i'd actually pick these two and
leave the uh the migration card that i had in the first round back and pass it on to the other player so you're actually not as restricted into staying on a certain strategy path on the draft you've previously picked so that's quite a nice little change there and gives you a little bit more freedom and flexibility to adjust as you go throughout your drafts so what each has their four cards and added their advantage card to the fold then the actual main part of the game is going to start taking place starting with the bren you're going to start choosing these action cards and resolving the action on them and with the purpose of trying to win the game of course so let's talk about the actual winning conditions of inish because it's quite unusual and a bit unlike anything else out there so there are basically three different ways you can win this game the first is to be in a region with or be in regions with at least six shrines in there so you've got these or sanctuaries i should say so these little sanctuary tokens are going to be um you're going to start with a couple on the board or maybe just one and as the game goes on there's going to be more and more built on there and if you're ever in regions doesn't matter how many people you have in there but just in regions with at least six sanctuaries then that is going to be a potential endgame trigger uh the second one is to basically dominate other players so for example here um these these two white clansbern are actually dominating this region and they have one player or one piece under them meaning that they've got one of their six that they need to do in order to get another win condition so if you are ever controlling
the clansmen or six other clansmen of other players then that is another uh endgame trigger and a potential winning condition and the third one is rather simple where you just need to be present in six different regions so as i mentioned earlier you start with three of these regions but there is potential for it to grow i'm quite a bit larger so without going into too much detail let's take a look at what some of these cards actually do and as you can see here the uh the cards are beautifully illustrated and are quite striking but we'll touch on that a little bit later so let's start with this sanctuary card here so as i mentioned one of the win conditions is to be present in regions where there are at least six sanctuaries and this one simply lets you place a sanctuary somewhere on the board where you're present so you have got this big supply of sanctuaries that can be deployed onto the board meaning that the game state is going to change and when you play this card you're going to draw an epic tail card now this is another deck in the game represented by these reddish cars here and whenever you draw these epic tail cars you're gonna just put them in your in your hand and you can actually keep hold of these for as long as you choose not to use it so unlike these normal action cards which would normally get discarded at the end of the turn whether you use them or not these ones are always going to be available to you and these are generally quite a bit more powerful than these standard cards but sometimes a bit more circumstantial um but we'll touch on a few of these a bit later you've also got this like conquest card here which are kind of the more aggressive cards so if you have these symbols in the corner like with these
crossing swords it normally means that you're going to move in and start encroaching on another player so this one here says like you choose a territory and you can move any number of your clans from from adjacent territories into it and start a clash so clash is basically the combat system of this game which again i'll touch on a little bit late later the guys here lets you cancel the ability of another player's action card so you can kind of veto the effect if it's going to affect you negatively you've got the migration card here that lets you move around and potentially start fights you've got the festival which is a bit of a protection mechanism which basically means that you put this token somewhere and if somebody starts a fight in that region then they have to basically suffer a casualty before the fight even takes place you've got the bard card here that lets you draw an epic tale card um or you'll notice that some of these cards have two abilities on them this kind of tree symbol means that you choose it as a basic action but these other ones are kind of a reactionary move where if somebody does a certain thing then you can play this card as a response to that so this one says after one of your maneuvers removes one of your opposing clans you can gain a deeds token and these deeds tokens are really useful because they basically proxy one of the winning conditions that you would need so as i said normally you'd have to be present in in six regions for example to uh to win the game but if you had one of these you'd only need to be present in five regions i got the new alliance here that makes it basically means that you can place a clan member or where an opponent has two clan members you can replace one of them with your own you got the craftsman and pleasants here which means that you can um wherever your pla wherever you're
present you can place a clan member for each territory in that after he said with that territory sorry so in addition to the capital and the sanctuaries you've got the ability to place these citadels down uh you've got the uh okay you've got the new clansmen here which basically lets you place two um two clans in any territories where you're present uh you've got the druid here where you can go through the discard pile and pick an action card that's already been used and you've got the warlord here that lets you start fights um and initially initiate a clash or when you've um or during a clash where you're involved after a maneuver is performed you can place one exposed clan into uh into a territory and choose who performs the next maneuver so it gives you a lot of fighting power there but i'll go into a bit more detail on that one in a minute i got the set style here that lets you place it out on the board and potentially still the advantage card associated to that location if it's not being played yet and you've got the exploration card here which where the brain chooses a uh an adjacent sorry an area adjacent to two regions and places a new region tile onto the board like so and you draw the corresponding advantage card from the deck and of course whoever controls that region in the future is going to get that advantage card ready for the next round so let's have a brief look about how combat works in this game because although this isn't a massively confrontational and in your face combat style game it can be quite pivotal uh
pivotal in determining who it has the advantage throughout the game and control certain regions so let's say for example this player here the blue player plays one of these conquest cards which means you can choose a territory and move any number of your clans in from adjacent territories into that one so let's just say i pick the mountains and then i move this blue piece into here a clash would start so basically that means we're going to square up and start fighting before that before anything happens if there is a citadel in place then in the order of the um of the flock of crows token that any player who's exposed is going to have the the choice of whether they want to kind of retreat into one of these citadels kind of protecting them from the warfare and once that's done you are going to start basically fighting and when you fight you've got the ability to pick a number of maneuvers so the first one being to attack another player and when you attack the other players either gonna have to withdraw a piece or remove it from the board or discard one of their action cards therefore limiting their options in future plays and then the other player is going to have the ability to either fight back or to withdraw but you can only ever withdraw into regions adjacent where you have uh you have control so let's just say for example he didn't go in here and there was a combat in this region and the white player didn't want to fight anymore he could withdraw into this region because there is nobody else there and they are actually controlled in that region but if that wasn't the case then they could not withdraw and the fighting is going to keep taking
place until either all or some of these pieces are removed or until the players basically call a truce and decide not to fight anymore of course as the game develops more of these sanctuaries are going to be placed onto the board there are going to be more citadels out there and of course more player pieces now as soon as one of the end game triggers is kind of um is fulfilled or a winning condition is fulfilled i should say then the a person who has that um has that completed is going to have the option of instead of playing one of their cards they can choose to take one of these pretender tokens and basically reveal to the other players that they currently have one of the victory conditions completed so for example here the orange player is present where there are at least six sanctuaries so you've got one two three four five six and there's an orange piece in each of those they can say look i've got one of the win conditions um completed you have to stop me before the end of the round otherwise i'm going to win the game so that's quite a weird little mechanism there almost like a chest or like a like a check or a checkmate style fill like that you might be familiar with chess where you have to say to the players that i've got at one here stop me or the end of the game is going to actually take place and once all players have passed in a row then at the end of the round is going to be um completed and you're going to go on to the next phase where again you'll start with the assembly phase going through that order determining who the new brand is and of course if
anybody has one of these pretender tokens still in play and they still have that victory condition completed then that player is going to be declared the winner in case of a tie then the bren is going to break that tie and um of course if somebody has two of the victory conditions completed and somebody only has one then that player is going to win the game so hopefully the overview there gives you a good idea about how inish plays out and as you can tell this game has a slightly different vibe to a lot of these dudes or the map style games where normally it's just in your face smashing each other with lots of different monsters and things and i will say the thing i really like about this game is how the actions are boiled down to these actually these few cards so as i said there's only ever going to be four cards per player plus one in the play at any time and of course the more you play this game you're gonna pretty much have a good idea about what each of those cards do so there's not a tremendous amount to remember and you've got a good idea what other people are capable of so i like the fact that this one is quite condensed down into those few actions and not it doesn't have a bunch of variables it doesn't have all these different exceptions to rules and things like a lot of these other games do um where you know you normally have a monster that does this and another monster that does something else and um they if they're together they do something else so there isn't that rules by neutral there isn't that bloat and confusion that goes into this one i also like the actual winning conditions of this game so it's not like one of those games where you have to go and just smash all the other people and the person who's murdered the most people at the end of the game is going to be the
winner this one has a slightly more distinguished and more refined feel to it we have to be a bit more cunning and manipulate the board to your or to your taste and try to actually get those objectives done and try to prevent other people from messing up your plans because of course unlike anything else out there you've got that that pretender mechanism where again if you have one of those um conditions completed then you have to reveal it to the other players you can't really pull the wool over other players eyes and just catch them off guard they are going to be aware that the game is going to come to an end unless they do something about it and that just makes this game feel a little bit different than other games out there because there are such few cards in play at any time you really do have to be careful about what you're drafting and because of course you want to keep getting people onto the board but if you take one of those cards you might give the other player an ability to you know veto one of your actions by taking the geist card um of course they might have the ability to move in on you and try to fight you and if you can't defend yourself then you're not going to be in a good position so every draft is quite pivotal or pivotal and what you can do from time to turn so i do like how the giraffes are meaningful and you can't just you know pick one and hope it kind of sorts itself out and um it will work out for the best where it just won't happen you know if you have if you don't pick a good set of cards to get you through that round then you're going to pretty much suffer however i do really enjoy that tweak that i haven't seen before in drafting games where um where you if you have your hand of four cards you pick one of
them you get the new bunch into your hand you can actually choose to put the one you picked earlier back into the fold and go again with a new set i love that it's really different and just that small tweak gives quite a big sense of flexibility and just makes you have the ability to kind of pivot and change your strategy on kind of the spin of a dime so i really do like the way that works now despite being impressed about how the game is condensed down to these um to these action cards i will say i have a few little issues with the game and i think some of them are personal and some of them are a bit more of a broader scope so first off i i find the combat in this game somewhat unsatisfy you know essentially with the game this again it's quite it's quite refined until the point where you end up fighting with other players so as i said if i move this place in it's going to start a big scrap and then it's basically just uh just a big smashing party where people are going to keep discarding cards and um just losing people from the board and that can feel a bit abrupt that can feel a bit too in your face for a game of this vibe so i will say that she didn't it had a little bit of a disconnect for me and i didn't find that overly satisfying or fun i would have liked to a more you know a more refined combat system and a way to get people on and off the board so i just felt a little bit too a bit too smash mouth for me and it just didn't quite sit right additionally these epic tale cards they do vary quite a lot in what they can do and as i mentioned earlier some of them are quite circumstantial and some of them are pretty strong at any time so i
will say that these are generally a bit too swingy for me and a bit too a bit too powerful at times and something i did like about this was the fact that again because there are so few cards in it you always had a good idea about what people could do and if if they did do something to you know to trick you on to to get the advantage over you then it's probably your fault because you've let that card slip through your hands whereas with these epic tail cards it does have that vibe of oh um you know you didn't see this one coming so have that and i find that a bit annoying at times where you know you couldn't foresee that this could happen they've got this kind of trick in their pocket that they could pull out any time and just catch you off guard with it and there's no way that you could prepare for it so let's just take a quick look at what some of these cards do i mean there is a big deck of these for a lot of variability i should say so let's have a look at this braze um tyranny card so this one lets you move one opposing clan from one territory where you're present to an adjacent territory and that doesn't initiate a clash that one's quite simple but then you get ones like this where after you perform an attack card you get a deed and those deeds are extremely strong and are going to have quite a significant influence on who wins the game because you know getting the objectives is is not overly difficult but the fact that you can get those deeds cards to proxy one of the victory conditions is is extremely strong you've got this like uh this daggers club here where um if you would remove a clan you wouldn't have to remove it anymore and of course things like that they might not seem big but when you've planned your turner caught like you know
as precisely as you can um something that can throw a real spanner in the works and just completely shift the balance to the other player and i would have liked to have seen it being a little bit more deterministic than that and i think again this is going back to a bit more of a personal vibe thing where i i tend to like area control games where you have a good idea about what can happen and people just can't throw something in your face that you just didn't see coming so almost like the thing that makes english unique some of it is great for me such as the card drafting and some of it is just not my style of of game where you know i almost would want to change the game away from being what inish actually is which i don't think would be fair if that makes sense the pacing and tempo of energy is also pretty interesting because although the box does say you know the game takes an hour to play um that is going to fluctuate quite a bit from game to game you know if you have players who are really on the ball and can constantly counteract your and your you know when you take pretended tokens then it does have the potential to go on longer than that but of course it can also go the other way as well where you know you can actually end up getting that objective fulfilled in you know half an hour 45 minutes so i i quite like the fact that this has a an undetermined amount of time how long this is going to take it does keep you on your toes and it does keep you engaged and has to kind of force you to be on the ball at all times um however be prepared that it could outstay it's welcome or at least i'll stay that 60 minutes that's um printed on the ball on the box
but i don't think that's a negative for this game i would say the replayability of finnish is generally pretty good um especially if you're playing with the same group because again if you get more familiar with these cards then each draft is gonna become more meaningful from game to game where as in your initial games you're probably just going to go with the flow and just draft things and try things out but once you're familiar with each of these cards and what they can do then you are really going to be aware about what your other players are going to go for and what's out there in the field to be played so i do like the way that the game does reward repeated plays and has a certain richness in terms of rewarding people with increased kind of dividends the more you invest time into this one and there's also a big stretch of these um epic talk epic tail cards as i mentioned so you're going to see different ones from game to game you've got a bunch of these different regions again for a a variance in gameplay some of them with special rules some of them with not special rules so yeah there is a good amount of replayability here should you enjoy the game from a production and aesthetic perspective i think this game is remarkable i'm blown away with the way this game looks i'm not massively a fan of these um of these miniatures but the artwork itself is phenomenal and the production quality is top-notch so as you can see not only the tiles themselves look great but these cars and the artwork on these cards is just absolutely breathtaking i think this style of art is so unique and different out there and it's just it's so captivating and striking and i'd love to
see this art style explored more this is just right up my um right up my alley and the kind of artwork that i love i think it's just so interesting and it just it just feels alive i just i'm blown away with the way this game looks it's just phenomenal of all these cars as well just all have different artwork and it's just so beautiful i'd actually put this kind of artwork on my wall i think it looks that good so yeah i cannot fault the production or the effort that's gone into the artwork here and i believe um this was all pre-done artwork and um and it actually ended up buying the artwork for the game and it wasn't made for the game but that doesn't change anything it's still absolutely stunning to look at i think sometimes the obstacle for this style of game is the setup and tear down whereas enes does get around that pretty nicely because you do start the game on quite a small scale with just the three different regions and a few player pieces onto the board and again you don't have all that massive buffet of different miniatures and stuff that are going to come into play with a lot of these style games you've just got the same bunch of cards so i do like the fact that there isn't actually that many components for a game of this scope so that keeps things nice and concise and nice and compact and from game to game which is going to be again a bit of a one of those speed bumps has been flattened out in terms of getting this one to the table and in terms of scalability i would almost definitely never play this with two players and would sit in that three to four player sweet spot probably four player being the uh the ideal player count um but yeah if if you are playing with three players this is still going to be a rich experience so
overall my thoughts on inish are generally positive you know i love the car play this game i love how it's boiled down into a few cards now not too uh not to beat that drum too many times but i do have a few issues with it number one again the combat system is a bit too abrupt for me um and a bit too bit too in your face i would have liked to have seen that be somewhat refined and a bit more intelligent and a bit more a bit more euro in its feel and that's why i struggled this game because this one isn't as you know amira trashy as a lot of these other um a lot of these other area control style games but it's also not euro it's almost like a hybrid there's some crossover between the two um and ultimately i think if i was to play a game of this length and this this style i would always lean to something a bit more euro and all the things i would change about this game would end up turning it into a game that is not supposed to be i would end up being something that's already my collection such as you know el grande for example so yeah all the things that i don't like about this game are just going to be enough not to you know not to stay in my collection and not to be something that i'm going to look at exploring too much further now that being said i think it's a wonderful design objectively i think it's clever i think it's um interesting in terms of the winning conditions and things i really do like this um this this pretender mechanism and i like the car drafting uh these cars are a bit too swingy for me they're a bit too um they're they're a bit too in your face a bit too unpredictable and again some people are going to really like that but it's just a
personal tasting and the style of games i like generally steer away from this style of thing but yeah from a production standpoint i think it's wonderful i think there's going to be a lot of people who enjoy this style of game um and again i did enjoy it i thought it was a fun experience but not something that's going to um stay in my collection and not something i'm going to be look at and playing too much further because it's just not my it's not my jam so um yeah objectively a good game but ultimately not quite for me because of those few little issues i had thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation and i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time