Avalon: The Riven Veil Review — The Oathsworn devs made an Area Control!
Transcript
Well, big area controls are so back with Avalon the Rivenvale brought to you by the designers of Oathsworn. The same team that made Oathsworn. So, have they made some magic again with this game? Welcome to the Isle of Avalon where four factions seek to control the land. Some to heroically defend it, others to possibly defile it. This is Arthurian legends inspired. You know the world of the King Arthur and the Holy Grail. Uh yeah, the thing is that this game, Avalon, we'll just call it Avalon for short throughout this review. This game takes itself very seriously. It's definitely pretty deep and unique with all the card play it has. Uh yeah, all these cards here, they're all unique and they lead to a fantastic hand management. Uh sorry, I'm being rude. I need to go back to overviewing the game. Avalon the Rivenvale is area control and exploration to go through with the mist to discover the Isle as you move your leader, place troops in strongholds, and fight at the end of each season to score for a good source of points. It's full of asymmetry and while there is a symmetric version, that's more of a tutorial in our opinion and we'll mostly talk about asymmetry. Oh, also there's a bunch of ways to play this game, so to have it concise in one area, these are the modes we're going to be mostly talking about. And the game is for two to four players. Our players are on screen and we tried every single player count for the base game. Mostly talking about this game from a three to four base game play perspective. Last couple things for housekeeping, this review is sponsored by Shadow Board Games, you know the people behind Oathsworn again, but also you might see that this is not a prototype review. They're currently doing a reprint of the game and from what they told me, the reprint is exactly the same as what we're covering here, but then later on they told me they switched some wording on some
things, but it seems to be game play wise exactly the same. You could probably find a copy of this game right now if you can't wait. But of course, our disclaimer here is that we never compromise scoring here at Shelf Side, but I totally understand, we totally understand if you want to click off because of the sponsor written lands game of board game reviews and all that stuff. But yeah, we're going to do our best to really dive in deep with this game with the time we've had with it. So, let's finally go. Let's go.
Very bare bones version. Goal of the game is to get the most points by the end of two seasons, which are each mega phases consisting of three turns per player ending with a war phase. If you want to play a longer game, you can do three seasons, but this review is mostly for the two season perspective. Thus, a game will be three rounds each of one turn per player, then fight, then three more turns per player, then fighting again to close out the game. To get points, you want to well, win fights. That's a main way by having the highest strength after combat resolution and getting the first place prize in that region, and getting and scoring the artifacts if there, including the Holy Grail if it is there. There are a bunch of other smaller ways to get points, so we'll run through some of them quickly. Like you can move up on the favor track, or you can win bids for monsters to get their VP in addition to spawning them, or you can place settlements on the board. So now let's get to a turn.
You'll have a hand of eight cards and all you do is pick a card that you want to play for the turn, lock that in, and then lock in what cards you're going to discard to play it. The initiative in which your card will activate is on the top left. Higher number means slower. Actually, you can't even play the red battle plan cards now, so they're just discard fodder unless you want to save them for later. For the other cards, there's a lot of text and symbols, but they do hold true to their categories. So deployment cards to put down dudes, settlement cards to put down settlements to help you in one region permanently and also spawn dudes. And lastly, there's movement cards which well, yeah, you got it. Everyone picks their cards simultaneously then flips over. Ties are broken by lower VP. Struggler goes first, but someone can use the Holy Grail artifact ability if they have it to use its once per season effect. This will usually not be in the first season.
Then everyone just does their card in order. So here we get to move. Well, this is very useful because you'll notice that the map is completely face down at the beginning. We flip regions face up as our lords go around exploring. So let's move our lord. They can move from your player supply onto a coast, that's one move, and you get one explore reward on the top. Normally, you do every single action from left to right, top to bottom, but let's just fast forward to the text. So we'll finish the card by deploying two units specifically in the region we're in. But normally, deploy lets you you where you have a settlement, or you can just deploy on the coast. And yes, technically you could deploy to an unexplored coast, but that region isn't going to score end of round until a lord explores it. Your turn isn't quite done yet. You're allowed to do optional actions before or after your card fully resolves. So, let's just say you do this free one to move to the inner region here.
Now your turn is done. Draw two of any sort of card you like from the decks. So, now it's probably time for the next round of the same season. So, pick another card and it's discard. If this is end of round three in a season, it's time to fight war. Give Excalibur to whoever has the highest honor to give them a bonus during the war phase cuz they're honorable. Oh, also Excalibur doesn't go on the player board slots. It just floats around to buff your lord. But normally artifacts get to go in slots and they'll give abilities, but are also the primary way your champions and lord units get stronger. More on these unit specialties later though. Then you fight clockwise starting from the northern edge of the map and then going to the inner regions. To do combat calculations, each piece you have is normally one strength. And this can get increased by abilities or artifacts being equipped to units. That strength number is locked in for the combat unless you have a lord or champion there, which we have here. So, these let you play a combat card from your hand to add strength, but we'll explain that nuance later. First place gets the artifact card and the points according to the season. Second place gets half the points for that season. Once every region has scored, that's the end of the season. Actually, every unit on the board gets returned to the players.
Whoa. Actually, the mist is going to come back. Whoa. Except for where the settlements are. And then you randomize the rest of the map for the next season. Remember to return Excalibur, too.
Then everyone draws back up to eight cards for the next season. That's the bare bones for now. There's so much more still to explain in the
Okay, so for component pros, it is obvious that this game is a real looker on the table. There's all this extra nice looking stuff like Look at the box outside. It's pretty cool. We got every single faction there. But this game also has some very functional and good feeling components to boot, so let's get into all of that. Actually, before going deeper, we are using all the bling from the collector's edition that they've sent us. And my group really wanted to use the 3D settlements and more metal pieces. And while they're nice, they're definitely not that necessary. In fact, the faction cubes look pretty much exactly the same. It's just the weight that you're paying for. And yes, you have the metal grail that you can put in a cube in to say you use it. Oh, but then you can just put a cube on the normal token or card. Or how the Excalibur piece is literally pure fluff. Oh, also the gold paint is coming off the middle of the grail. Uh yeah, initially I wanted to drink from this for a little sketch, but that might not be good for my health, so I won't do that. Probably the most notable upgrade is the strength token upgrade, and this goes into settlements, which is nice, except for the green one. But then you're also not really constantly touching these tokens anyways, but they are bigger and easier to see. Blinged version or not, the central map is the same and it's going to be a bunch of these double-sided cardboard boards that are nicely cut out on the sides. You can easily slot them into place and flip them over, which is really nice, cuz trust me, you flip these over a lot. The art is all bright and inviting, and what type of region it is is very clear. And man, the mist side just looks so good.
It's certainly a strong vibe to start game night with a big swirling mist in front of you. And then you're going to put down the small cards you can explore on top of that, and they just look so naturally at home on the board, especially in this middle section. Then this map is framed with this nice circle that also acts as a round tracker. And just like Dune 2019, you move a token clockwise to keep track of time. It doesn't take up a lot of space, and once you're used to the game, you don't really have to worry about moving it constantly and it being eye-sore cuz it's discreet enough. Point trackers going around the board is quite clean, too. Yes, these bigger metal pieces are a collector's edition bling. But of course, the miniatures, the minis, they're incredible. We have the mist-touched version, and they're just fantastic. Durable, very distinct looking, and even the big lords have little plastic for more bling on them. There's actually two types of soldiers per faction and three different heroes with little notches on the bottom to differentiate them. And then with the white knights, you get two lords, and Mordred has a special extra evolved form if you get the extra version. Also, regions not having occupancy slots while being a big tile means that you never have to stress for space with the minis.
And so the five-unit cap, not including settlements, is fairly easy to see. You can have a lot of leeway with positioning guys around each other just to move things around to make it look good. It just looks clean. Since we didn't get the standees, we can't test that, but by looking at the website, you get really nice looking art still, and you get the Lord miniature. And so, if you're on a budget, we suspect these would be just fine and still give you the high quality vibe. To pair on top of the awesome miniatures are the gorgeous card art. Now, this is truly an undertaking. It's four different decks that all have unique art on each card. Yes, this is four decks of 40, so 160 unique cards for the action cards. And then you also have art in the mythical beasts and also all the artifacts. This is adding dozens more unique art. Like seriously, what type of game has this much art that you're seeing all the time? Also, in our version, we got the deck holders, which are absolutely fantastic with function. They always keep your decks straight, and they have a discard pile underneath it for easy access and dropping in. And if you need to pass the decks around the table for someone to draw, you can just do that in a cinch.
And the four player boards are gorgeous to look at to really get you in the headspace of them. You got elegant loud whites, grungy green forest thing, mysterious blue like the ocean, and then brooding shadows for the zombies guys. And the game packs up fairly well, even including all the metal stuff. It just packs up into one box. The card trays pack up super cleanly. The miniatures have their own inserts, nicely divided by faction color, too. And the tiles have their own plastic cubbies. It's useful to follow this packing sheet, but it is a little odd how there's no dedicated space for the little cards or prophecy cards. So, we just tossed it in with the card trays and called it a day. Enough gushing about the component pros. Again, we have the collector's edition, so it's possible that you might not even get to see some of those stuff cuz you're on a budget. Totally get it. But despite what tier you pick, this game is going to have graphic presence with all the art, so you got the board and all the cards. Looks good. So, now for the gameplay pros, and let's go back to the cards. These aren't just a pretty face with unique cards. The hand management is incredible. It's probably the best I've played this year in terms of having unique cards added onto a very robust system, so you have to squeeze the most out of every single card. So, very quickly, as you draw more cards, you realize that they're all unique. So, they're not steeply unique in that yeah, sure, they're kind of cousins of each other with very similar symbols or ideas. See how these two building cards are literally mirroring each other. But, this is probably a good thing for most groups in that you have this slight similarity, so you're reducing the possible action space. So, that favors mastery over each style of deck. And it makes for a lot of intuitive sense.
Sure, you get to go faster, but now you get one less perk. The cards feel really true to the categories to make choosing them just very straightforward and never feeling unfair. Like, deploy, settle, or move all do the main symbol. Then they'll do a little extra on top. Then there's of course the speed to worry about. Or you can get a bonus by doing it in a certain region. Oh yeah, so then discarding to pay for said card is fairly nuanced as you're losing cards to play other cards, but you can even save cards if you discard a certain kind of card. But, since you want combat cards at the end of a season to fight, you might want to start planning around some that you found early in a round. So, then you might have to sacrifice some more positioning style cards. The initiative timing game is tight because going first, that is playing a three, is good sometimes because you get to explore things and get the rewards right away.
But then many cards also say that you can only move or deploy to explored regions. So, sometimes you want to purposely go after someone else explored for you. Then of course in area control fashion, going last is good to get the final movement before fighting. By having only three numbers of initiatives, then having the game filled with tiebreakers not only makes it easy to guess what number people might be playing, but also gives a reason to play certain speeds if you're higher in victory points. Meaning that the person lower in VP gets to choose their place within the tie order. And you don't always want to be at the mercy of that. As a side note, making the game so card centered with only one type of card makes the game not that fiddly to play in preparation phase. You have one type of size, and you even have this nice divider card to help you organize cards when you commit to them. You commit them at the start of a turn, you commit them for bidding for monsters, or even fighting. It prevents the whole "Oh, I bid cards." Oh, well, you clearly just put down one card, right? Now it looks like you put down your entire hand, but you didn't, really. Back to hand management, the sheer quantity of cards is really important for fighting as you can discard up to three bonus cards with your battle plan to increase the limit by three, one for each card. Oh, yeah, we'll explain combat card interactions really quickly here. So, when you reveal your battle plan, any ability might go off, then you can draw as many cards from any deck as you want, as these will add to your existing strength. But, if you ever draw a sum greater than your limit, you bust and get zero bonus strength. Hence, increasing your limit by spending cards to do so is immensely useful. So, often you're torn on saving cards in hand during the main phase game. Then you can also get more cards by moving up in favor or exploring. So, there's also a lot of healthy spending to gain cards. More on
combat later. Hand management is also quite interesting with the monster bids, as it's really a game of chicken and seeing how much people are willing to spend for an extra strong unit on the board with an ability. Hey, it deploys right away and increases your overall army size on Avalon. It's just that it can be really expensive, and we've seen the numbers go up to seven or nine in combined initiative value. Oh, yeah, they're also another reason to maybe save those threes in your hand. The final ace in the hole of hand management is how you can actually decide to change your mind and just get a weaker action, called a standard action, and that saves cards. This ends up possibly making a big difference in combat and getting those extra cards in hand, but remember your board presence might be slightly weaker, so this is kind of like a high-risk, high-reward play. But again, the cards you have in hand never felt outside their identities, so it never felt like we were forced to do a cheaper, yet sub-par standard action if we didn't want to. Okay, so now you know that the main engine is cool, it's time to talk about the ace symmetry. Everyone's right board is full of nuance, and then the left board is a little bit more simple until you progress it, and then it'll have a bit more nuance. So, you're immediately strategizing how quickly you can flip it over early game. The boards provide the extra action areas to flush out the card system, because now the game isn't only pick an interesting card, reveal it, until everyone just does this in a static order, because now you can do multiple somethings before after your card play every single turn.
This is especially if you have the faction power resource saved up, so that's another thing to manage. You can move your lord to explore an area before you start to play units, so it's already explored, you know where to go. Or you can do a last-minute deploy before fighting. Or say you can start using the right side of your board as you're lining up things with your faction. Like when you have a lot of strongholds with undead, you have more errors, you can do an extra deploy. Okay, so now let's actually get to the asymmetry. The undead faction is kind of a swarm faction with having four more basic units over everyone else. They can quite easily cap out to place all of them because every time they deploy to a stronghold, they get an extra dude. Plus them putting down strongholds is more cheap and convenient with their once per season ability to get two for the price of one action card. While the undead units are just grunts, your lord Mordred gets stronger by consuming the essence of wild beasts that you want to bid for, getting permanently stronger.
And he can teleport around once during combat to replace two skeletons. So he can suddenly just play a card there. And of course, you got to talk about the Round Table Knights who are led by Guinevere. Where's Arthur? Well, he's missing, but you'll eventually find him by doing quests to complete prophecies or get his Excalibur or the Holy Grail. Then he can fight alongside Guinevere on the board, so you have two lords.
Your elite units, the heroes or what I like to call champions, the knight ones can be bestowed at any time with the honor of being a certain named knight of the Round Table. Then you can spend a faction power to actually use them. Like Lancelot can duel another champion, getting you favor, and you call a number between one to three. If your opponent can discard that card, they can. If not, their champion dies. If undead are more of a big swarm skeleton blob, then the knights are more in the conservative high-value direction. They have quite strong once per season abilities through their champions, but sometimes the champions have to be in a certain place to use them. Guinevere can try to tie the odds during combat, and then their strongholds are double strength. And Arthur is three power cuz he is cool. Then the Fomorians led by Sir Balor are all about the water. The tide will naturally shift at the end of the turn, so they can spend faction power to move it into a zone they like. High tide to destroy things, medium and low tide are more economical. They can actually be in a lot of places at once with the Leviathan, adding two strength to three regions. And even the middle region if they have a stronghold close to the Leviathan, which they probably will. So yeah, it's just adding two around strength to regions. Yes, that helps for every single one of their fights, incredible flexibility. They can also take any combat card discarded after battle, so they can just take other people's, or they could double down their own strong cards.
These from Morians tend to be the most flexible, and definitely feel like they're dealing with the water. I'm not going to talk about the Druids here, otherwise we'll be here forever, but they'll come up later, promise. The next gameplay pro is going to revolve around the combat. The two combat phases in a standard game are both straightforward, yet dynamic, and you can actually predict outcomes fairly well if you're perceptive with people's things on board and stuff in hand. Yes, even with all the asymmetry in the game, even extra abilities you can get through small cards, it's pretty straightforward. Okay, let's just get into that. The main thing to know is that units don't die during combat, and it's possible to move them after combat, so the order of fights resolving is really important. As you can grab a guy from a previous fight and move him via an ability. Speaking of combat cards, they allow you to get extra power in combat if you have a hero or lord there. So, you have to position those guys carefully, and it's clear to see that if you have cards and a hero, and your opponent doesn't have that, you're just getting a lot of power from cards in hand, so you will probably win. This also makes units feel way more special, because despite everything having a strength of one, the moment you see a hero, you go, "Oh, wow, this player is committed to the region." And also, you never want to commit the sin of having two guys that can play cards in one region.
So, you got to be careful about deploying and moving. As for the battle cards, because of their abilities, you can set up very specific fights, like trying to win more by winning the fight and getting some extra rewards, or embolden to basically double your soldier strength, or last stand to purposely start with two less strength than your opponent. There's lots of losing or second place reward cards that not only help newcomers not feel as bad for losing in fights, but it also means that in the lower scoring regions, sometimes you want to lose to get those special rewards instead. It's always fascinating to see the flip script sometimes in fighting. Like you can move enemy units in a future fight with Weilai. This also means that you're pretty rewarded by just spreading across the map, and even if you don't straight up steal someone's region that they invested into, you at least pose a threat and you got some rewards. This is just great to drive more player interaction, as you always want more fights, and rarely want to have places just auto score for points at the end of a season, because that would be more like a low-conflict Euro. And when you lose a fight, the card comes back. So, as you do multiple fights, you will get knowledge of what cards are in people's hands. But, this doesn't mean it's hard predictable what's going to happen, because people might have been holding tricks for those last fights worth more points.
Seeing how there's 40 battle cards in the deck, and people are constantly drawing them to get ready for combat, when you get really comfortable with the game, I'd imagine you start to get a pretty good idea about what people have in their hand, especially in season 2 and 3. And you can always go through this card to know what cards are out. This is how you can project a low-threat subterfuge or griefs towards you, or project a legendary hero that someone's going to suddenly move their hero. You can even plan for high-impact plays like trickery to steal people's cards. And you can even get marginally rewarded by playing perfect and having some cards left over, because any cards you have at the end of the round are points. I mean, three points by discarding three cards at the end of a season can be pretty solid in tight games. Lastly, for combat, the push-your-luck system in combat might seem a little zany at a glance, like, "Oh, we're just drawing cards until we maybe bust. Isn't that like Blackjack?"
But, actually, it's quite well handled, and it's actually really clear whether or not you'll bust. So, all cards, except for these two, are within the three-to-five range. So, you won't really bust off a single card draw. Then, you can decide to add in more bonus cards to give you leeway, depending on how you're feeling. Then, you're given the choice of what deck of cards to pull from. So, if you want to go super big brain, you can go through every single discard and actually calculate the odds of getting a two versus a three. This system also makes the combat fairly fast for three or four people fighting in one region, which does happen multiple times a season, so you want it to be fast when it does happen. It's fast because everyone can just draw simultaneously their certain cards. It also makes outcomes more dynamic, because there's more possibilities of people busting with there just being more opponents. And it's also a nice player interaction thing, as you try to gauge other people's temperament what before you even put in your combat card, especially when you're fighting against like three people. Like, who is the greedy one here? Who is going to play more safe? And you can actually scare people by drawing cards and pretending you didn't bust, so they think they need to draw an extra card. But, what about all the combat abilities? Well, they're actually very straightforward for combat, where they're usually triggered before or after combat resolution. Like maybe they'll add an extra strength if a condition is met, or if you have Excalibur, maybe you can add more strength to break ties. Or maybe you can spawn Kelpie in a place before combat.
This keeps combat calculation very smooth, and actually actually almost every single artifact in this game is just plus one strength. And the artifacts all slot in very nicely under your board, too. So, you can look at your opponent's unit, and then just look if they have a card underneath that slot, and then you go like, "Okay, it's plus one power, so that thing is two strength." Okay, now time for a smaller gameplay pro, the wild beasts. So, there's 14 of them, which is really cool because they all have different abilities. And we already talked about the bidding having plain interaction, meaning the already great hand management. But also the fact that wild beasts exist mean that you can spawn guys on the board outside of the normal loop of movement and deployment. And also lets you head to the more elusive middle area easier. And those abilities have a lot of fun stuff. Like some are more straightforward to give combat flexibility, or Tempest can help move guys around, give your lord a nice ride to the middle. Others are a bit weirder, like Carcados can get stronger over time. He can easily be four strength in season two. Or the wandering mountain can give you an additional card for moving into a specific region. You can just move him a lot and get a bunch of bonuses. Then the green man gives you extra points, but he doesn't want any enemies there cuz he likes peace. He's a peaceful guy. You also can never move him. He just silently scores points.
In general, there's just a lot to think about with Avalon while having a fairly straightforward turn structure. It really is just play three cards, one per round of the season, and then you go to war. Like it really just feels quite well tied together without really any fiddly phases. Like here's some more pros that didn't really fit into any umbrella, but they still feel well fitted here. Settlements are a great trade-off, as you have to spend probably a little bit more cards to do the action, but they're great for area control long term, as they permanently stay on the board, and you have to decide whether to play in a coastal or inner region. And it helps advance your symmetric goals. And since your unit cap to five units region, having a settlement might give you an extra strength you need to win. And prophecies facilitate people moving into the same region to get those points, which is a race to do it first to get the first place extra favor. But also people being in the same area means you're going to fight more, so that's great. More player interaction. Then the favor is a really nice source of points to easily pursue and you're given an extra cushion for combat with Excalibur if you go harder on favor. Then the Holy Grail, which is always hype when it comes up, is a way to make one of the fights have a little bit more narrative weight because you're fighting over more points that only go to the winner of the fights and they'll also get the Holy Grail ability for next season. We fight for the Grail. It's cool stuff and again, it can happen not in the middle. Lastly, we didn't really get to talk about the artifacts much in depth and there's a couple of cool abilities I want to highlight, but before we go further, they actually give some initial and emergent asymmetry because you draw three at the beginning of the game and pick one, so you start with a cool power and then you'll get some as the game progresses. So like maybe now you have an extra deploy when you do to play off a green card, so now you lean more towards playing that
color. Or how about trying to play more slow initiative, initiative three to now destroy people's wild beasts. Or how about this one to let units all go towards this unit's base. Okay, so now it's time to start wrapping up all the pros so far and I want to talk about how this game handles scoring.
So at a glance, the game might seem a little bit point salad cuz there are a bunch of different sources of points, but then the emphasis on getting points from fighting is so strong that you just have to do that. And this is great because fighting happens last in a season, so it's the ending to your game on the end of season two and that we found that all our games typically came down to the last one or two fights. I mean, look, you getting double digits over an opponent is huge. We played without a catch-up board after a more tutorial-like symmetric game and we found that the Green Knight is already a really great catch-up mechanic. So he's a wild beast that you can get if you're two stars behind the second-to-last player and this is huge because it gives you two strength anywhere plus he acts as a hero, so you can play cards there. So bam, you're contesting another area for more chance to get double digit VP. The existence of the Green Knight plus how tiebreakers are broken by whoever's lower on VP means that you might not want to actually always get that many points all the time.
Especially how how play cards to lose points early on and get board advantage. Nice combination of sandbagging and purposefully going negative sometimes. The final pro to wrap up this entire list is the replayability. Now, I don't want to say so far that it is insanely replayable, but it's definitely impressive as it's as it's getting at that good to great level. That's because the cards, while different, do mirror each other a lot, so you'll eventually get a really good idea of the scope of cards. And while the regions to explore are different, they're not so different from each other to vastly change the game. It's not like you're finding the lost city of Atlantis or anything or slowing down movement or blocking off a movement. They're just different points with different exploration rewards. And also, there's only two center regions, which I'm surprised that this could have been three, no? But yeah, openings might look the same for a six-round game for standard mode, but how you get there might be different as you have different cards in hand. But generally, people are going to be exploring early on and then maybe placing a settlement or two in the first season. But again, the cards are different. And the devil's in the details with the faction you're playing or how exactly other people are playing.
I would say each faction needs at least one play first to fully figure them out unless like you're a genius. So, if you're really, really picky on your replayability, I would say you could play each faction two to three times at least. They have different power spikes and definitely different ways of handling settling. So, four factions, two to three times each, I mean, you do the math, right? But yeah, there's also another faction available over there, but we haven't tried them, but we'll talk about them very lightly in scoring. Component cons time. So, the rule book initially seemed good to us and we actually had it in pros. And sometimes it is really good, like setup is good, although a bit wordy. Playing cards is well explained, although it's a bit long-winded. Uh, is this a trend here? But the more we played, the more rule confusions we had. And then, so I had to move the rule book from pros to cons. We were often stopping games during the main action rounds and during combat, even after we played the game two times before. So, it's overall not that bad, but it really feels like death by a thousand cuts cuz this game is just so technical and the rules have to get things right. Some rules explanations are just kind of vague and annoying to go back on. Like it'll say that you can only use the green knight in the catch-up mode, but that's not true. You can still use them if you don't. Or how lords can explore if they go on an unexplored region. Okay, why would you ever want to optionally do this? Just make it mandatory. Also, it doesn't say it's maximum once around here. Come on. Or how examples sometimes are all just text that don't describe much or are a bunch of pictures without text. I mean, come on, more clarity, please. One big culprit is
actually the factions. Yes, there's a weird glossary of them that's not really a glossary and so minimal. Like there's only two to four lines for each faction. Like at that point, why not explain the whole faction with like a quarter of the page and or give advice. Then there's just some wording in the game that's not rulebook specific, but it's just unintuitive. So, the game will often ask you to have the most of something. Well, if there's three people and they all have four bidding power, you'd figure that none of them are the highest, right? Well, kind of, they're tied, but they're also simultaneously the most/highest and least/lowest, which is so unintuitive. I don't know, probably just use another term for something instead of most and least cuz literally having the most of something is having the greatest in number, not tied. So, maybe use a word like dominance or combat. But what makes the rules confusions hit harder and how you have to keep going through the rulebook, even after playing the game a lot, is because the player aids are so minimal. You actually only get two, which is very odd considering that most people are playing this game three or four people. Like it's so weird. Like this doesn't even talk about the entire season structure. It doesn't talk about Misthaven. And then yes, the standard action is on the corner, but again, you only have two of these. So, what about the two people that don't have these?
And it doesn't explain clearly enough the options on your turn. All it says is that you reveal and resolve cards. So, what about the player board actions? This makes it seem like the player board actions don't even exist. Like those player board actions allow for so much flexibility. Why don't they mention it here? Or what about in combat? There's a max of three bonus cards you can add. Well, why don't the player aids talk about in combat that there's a max of three bonus cards you can add? Or why is there no explanation on what the other factions do? Like at least a sentence on them since you want to play this game for asymmetry. Luckily, there's these printout sheets from BGG that will actually tell you what you can do on a turn. Then the back of the player aid is oh my gosh, so many symbols. This actually gets us to the next component con, which is this game has way too many symbols. It's excessive, which isn't terrible after the second game or so you play. But for new players, it's just so much and some could easily just been text like enemy. I'd reckon that there's no need to put in a symbol if it's not explicitly clear what the symbol is anyways. Like uh what is this uh stunned unit? And especially since this game is leaning towards color blind friendly.
Like move card symbol. Oh yeah, that makes sense when you see it on your movement card because it's bright yellow. But if you saw it in another way, uh does this mean I draw a card or a card is getting added to other cards? Or deploy card means wait, do I draw cards based off how much I deployed? Or there's moving in and moving in after you explored because that's when an arrow pointing down means? Draw card looks similar to discard a card, but they couldn't use X for discarding like most games because that's how they denote discounts for discarding. So uh oops, maybe a double X would have worked though. As we look at the arrow literally meaning the word two, it's frustrating when you could save time and just take up the same amount of space by saying two. Again, there's 48 symbols or 49 symbols, so it's a lot. I mean, think about how sweeping Twilight Imperium 4 is. Even with all the expansions, you don't get caught up in symbology because it doesn't really have that many symbols. So there's an adage that a picture is worth a thousand words. Totally agree. But sometimes, you only need one word. So then I had another really hard think. Why are there so many symbols and even though each of them isn't that confusing, it still kept like the same ones kept tripping us up.
And then it finally it hit me. Haha. Okay, it's because most games usually use symbols to denote nouns like units. Or sometimes like adverbs like traits of a unit. But in Avalon, they're not only using symbols for these, but they're also using symbols for actions. So then there's two different symbols to draw or discard cards or move units differently. And that's why something like settlement and settle are very similar symbols. And it makes sense once you understand the plus means add, but you wouldn't really see this in many games, especially to the degree of this many symbols. But whatever, this basically just means that the first games are more confusing than usual, a lot more confusing than usual for symbol-heavy games. And eventually the usage becomes kind of smooth as you can quickly decipher your hand. It's likely why they did it, and then just print copies of the player aid or just use an alternate screen while you're playing.
Or here's another wording thing. What about this really crucial Holy Grail usage? That you can actually use Holy Grail, you can flip the Holy Grail during bidding for monsters. Because the wording right now is technically correct because bidding for monsters is an initiative bid, but you wouldn't think of so because you're not really competing for initiative as in speed when you're bidding for these. Oh, or did you know that the Grail and Excalibur don't actually go on your player board? They go on the side of it. Well, you could very easily forget that, so this could have been denoted on the player board. Or why not just have a slot for it on the left side? And then currently when they're on the left side, they kind of don't even look like they're equipped to your lord, so you can even forget about those combat bonuses. Then there's two asymmetric boards that have two glaring confusion points. First is the druids, who can say you can empower your settlement. Well, what does empower mean? There's no definition of that in the rulebook. Come on, can we just use cleaner language?
The other one is the progressed Mordred, who is kind of weird in that he says that you can teleport mid-war, then delete two units. So, are those soldiers a cost? Shouldn't you just have to pay the two soldiers first? The way it's worded is that you can just teleport anywhere. And hey, if you happen to have two soldiers, then they die. So, just don't spawn where you have two soldiers, right? Then there's some visibility issues with the main board, making placement of minis a little bit tricky. So, yes, there's a lot of space for them, but actually having no dedicated area can also backfire as you place them wherever. So, now there's freedom to have them block each other. And big minis easily block smaller ones, leading to a "Wait, what? You had You had that all that space?" moment. Look at the druid lay lines being blocked by Merlin in front. Sheesh, I miscalculated a couple fights cuz you can't see the lay line. Or how the small flags for the beasts just isn't good enough. This reason why the tried-and-true color rings around mini bases well, works.
It's tried-and-true. Often times the beast itself would block his flag. Oh, speaking of flags, do you see these ones for the Knights of the Round Table? Well, how is another player supposed to easily remember that yellow is Sir Galahad who gains VP from each artifact? Or green is Sir Percival who will move himself into warriors if you bond with a mythical beast. The flags aren't marked to remember, there's no card you can hand out as the white player to other people, nor is there really any art around it whatsoever. The last component con is this prophecy card. They will forward and forage is just way too vague. Does it mean that there's three units in each region or three units throughout the three regions? So, one each? Why didn't they just say one in each? So, they clarify this at the back of the FAQ as the design team pointed me to, but then why even have this when you can just have the card's wording be way stronger? The very obvious wording issues and rules jank just really screamed to us that this game, despite its fantastic gameplay, was not blind play tested at all. Like the moment you hand someone that's never played this game the Merlin board and they start reading empower and no one at the table knows what it means, you start going like, "Huh, well, I got to make up some rules, huh?" For us in our last games, that was when we were playing the asymmetric Merlin side and that was when I was emailing Shadow Born Games and they actually told me that empower is going to get removed from the game. So, nice job, guys. I won't be in the new printing. In the new printing. But then they're not removing any of the other jank? Maybe? I don't know. Okay, actually there's more. Let's look at the player boards again. When you're thrown into playing asymmetrical, sure the game is complex, so you'd imagine it'd be pretty tough to get started, but why not have the back of the left side of the player board explain what your faction does. Oh, right, because you flip it to
progress yourself. But does that really need to be the case? Very little changes actually. You just change it once per season ability and get another ability. So, couldn't this have been a card or a set of cards you unlock to keep the back side of the board useful? Wouldn't it be more useful to have for the extra units you get like the ancient one or King Arthur? So, then others could pick it up and look at what the ability does. Because you can't currently pick up someone's player board from across the table. Okay, gameplay cons time. Let's talk about these two cards, faint and hit and run. They're both just kind of too good. They They you move a guy away and then since you lost the combat, the card goes back into your hand. Okay, so you have a double reward with no real cost or penalty. If you have a hero you're moving around, you can easily just start sniping a bunch of second places and areas. Or forcing others to commit more power to places they thought they were going to win already. This is fine as an idea to do so. It's a motif of the combat system, but specifically spamming faint over and over again is too convenient. Like either they should have made this spend VP to do this, like lose two VP, or make you discard another card, or even itself to use. The other cards that reward you for losing come with costs. But what about counterplay?
Cuz you have these cards to discard people's combat cards. Well, you can't rely on these because they're three out of 40 cards, and they're super conditional because discarding cards is super good. Also, you can't discard the card if they're using it, right? It's not in their hand. These two cards are a bit more abusable in deterministic combat, where combat is more predictable, so you have a much better idea of losing the region. Oh, yeah, deterministic combat. Let's talk about that because it is a suggested game mode for the game. It's not a variant, it's just one of the main modes. And it really does take away from the combat flow, and we would recommend against using it. It feels like a house rule variant rather than something that should be in the front of the rulebook. It nulls these three card abilities in the game, and even Merlin, like one of the lord powers. So, that's awkward. The payoff? Well, everyone is putting fights where at most they can usually add plus nine to a battle.
Since the highest limit is six, but usually you're adding plus eight at max to a combat. So then if you have plus eight or nine in your hand, well you probably just win the fight if you're tied or already winning on the board, so the fights are just little less interesting. There's no upsets from people busting. This is especially the case for the later battles on the map. As this late during combat, there's little reason to save extra cards because winning a fight is just too important. So then you just pick a good limit card and dump your entire hand in. Like say you have Indomitable Will and a bunch of cards in hand to use as a bonus. Well, you can just go around winning a bunch of fights and get Indomitable Will back to your hand. And then once other people see that you have Indomitable Will, the plus five limit minimum, it's going to be less interesting to fight against. We'd imagine most people won't play with that game mode, so it's not that big of a deal, but you have been warned. Now, we want to talk about something very similar in that line of thinking where you have two versus three seasons. And it's a little wonky on how many seasons you should actually play, especially in the asymmetric mode, because two seasons is a standard game, but when we look at the asymmetric progression, it feels like maybe three seasons is the way to play.
So, you will tend to flip your asymmetric board sometime between the beginning of season two to the end of season two. So, then maybe you'd want another full season to play after that to use it. Plus, settlements placed in season one get to prevent misfall once, and settlements placed in season two don't do that, but settlements will still score when placed in season two, and still help combat, and they'll still deploy when you place it. So, yes, placing in season two is still a viable action. It just feels kind of lacking. So, the standard game, two seasons, is actually plenty long and full. So, at a glance, the game may seem very, very short and simple. Oh, it's only three cards per season, and then only three seasons, right? Shouldn't it be a short game? So, yes, six cards I'm playing in total, easy-peasy game, right? It's easily 90 to 120 minutes. Well, I mean, this is kind of the case, so technically, yes, you have three turns, but the real game is so much more complex than the actual player aid hints. Each card is doing about two to three things. Then maybe you'll explore, which interrupts your card, and you'll do a possible bid or fulfill your prophecy. Then you have all your faction abilities or lord abilities you can do.
And yes, they're once a season, but when to use them adds complexity of thought, and then when you do actually trigger them, it can easily double the length of your turn cuz you're just moving more pieces. Also, the start of a season tends to have some analysis paralysis as people decide what exactly they're doing first. So, they're roughly sorting their cards and determining what's worth discarding.
And man, when you get up to four players, the AP can be deeper with more places to explore, and the fighting just gets longer. I mean, here's some math on screen for it. Now, we didn't have time to play the long game, even though we tried to for one session, and realized we just ran out of time. So, we're really unsure what's the best mechanical game length. The first three-player asymmetric game was under 3 hours after trying the symmetric game once. The symmetric game was about 2 and 1/2 hours. And when you play the game a lot more, we can see it becoming 90 to 120 minutes eventually for the standard mode. The rulebook says that the third season is an extra 20 minutes per player, so an extra hour for three players, and that sounds roughly right. Maybe it's a little more generous as we'd imagine season 3 just gets more complicated with more options and more abilities. And with the four players, it's probably at least another 90 minutes with the extra season. And so with four players, it's probably at least another 80 to 90 minutes with the extra season. So, if you really want to play the full game, you got to have a lot of time. Say you play the full game, three seasons with four players, well, that's probably at least 4 to 5 hours for your first game, which is way longer than 90 to 120 minutes listed on the box. So, yeah, shorter is probably way better for most people. Okay, so now I have a little bit more discussion on the asymmetry balance, which isn't that bad, so feel free to jump ahead to scoring if you're not really too concerned about balance. Feel free to jump ahead.
Okay, all right. So, we're going to go into it now. The green druids are definitely a good deal stronger than the rest, and I would first actually big picture echo everything said in this BGG post a couple of weeks ago. Their board is trivially easy to flip early. The rewards are all solid and good. Ancient One good. Merlin is good. They really have zero weaknesses. But we wanted to go a bit deeper to maybe give more insight on gameplay, and look, they're just able to place stuff on Avalon to get them ahead of others. And cards? Well, yeah, you can just get them mid round through your player board. Power? Well, your Ancient One has power and is a settlement to spawn more guys. Oh, again, you were placing laylines cheap the entire game throughout the board, which give you one power in a lot of areas for combat flexibility. Oh, actually, having laylines scattered around the board can help score prophecies easier. So, they're just generating overall advantage better.
Each start of season rewards are better, which slightly snowballs into creating prophecies, which snowballs into getting favor, which also snowballs into getting Excalibur to help with fights. And you know what the heck's going on in fights? They have more cards to fight, and they have the Merlin power to help with combat cards. Let's contrast the druids with the mighty Knights of the Round Table who are just okay. I mean, they're possibly the weakest in the game, but I will say they're at the very least inconsistent and a lot more player dependent than Druids who are just a mega value. Because to flip and get Arthur, they must either get the Grail or Excalibur to complete a prophecy card. Well, sometimes prophecies are just really hard to do based off of the map. But Grail or Excalibur is much harder to get in four players cuz everyone wants these cards. Well, pretty much everyone can guarantee flip their sword by the end of the game, the Knights have to put in a lot more effort and can flounder around to get it mid to late season two. The Round Table does have some nice moves though, like having a second lord at three strength is no joke to explore a notably contested place by himself while playing cards.
And he has a pretty solid faction power ability. Or how Sir Gawain lets you just move units to a bunch of places. That's really strong for one faction power. They're just more prophecy card dependent and player count dependent. With less people, it's just easier to get the Grail and or Excalibur. So, we're playing with all area control veterans. And in our last two games, the new players, which are still area control veterans, but they're new to the game, they played the Druids and they just readily destroyed everyone else in their first game of playing Avalon. But I'm sure as you play more, you'll be able to compensate for Druid strength by just being more mindful of it on the board, but hey, it's something to think about. Like they're not so strong they break the game.
You know, give a good give a good faction to a genius and it's over. It's just easy to do like
Scoring! Now it is time for a recommender score because from what I've been told, this game is barely getting changed for the second printing. They're just switching out some terms like empower and then changing the rulebook slightly. Digital rulebook is already online on BGG. And so, we're going to quickly evaluate the aforementioned pros and cons with knowing that we're not completely unbiased, but we're trying to be and with the knowledge that the standee version currently is like $80 on their website. So, this is going to So, this is going to get a recommender score of eight out of 10. It is great. At first, this was barely a nine out of 10 after our first two three-player games with the card play system potentially being an X factor. But then after the remaining two games, this slid down very comfortably to the eight out of 10 position. Avalon the Riven Veil has fantastically crafted area majority meets some Euro wing player board management with very high player interaction and incredible hand management. However, the flow is just bogged down by too many rule and iconography confusion. The card system is still impressive, but no longer an X factor and how there's just too much crossover. Then there's a slight uncertainty about seasons. It was really the case that the symmetric side was totally understandable minus the symbols, but then once we introduce the asymmetric boards with all the new words and exceptions, it started getting really confusing. And this made me think, couldn't it have been possible to take out some of the product bling in favor for a smoother learning and reading experience? Like there's a swords on the back of the card holder we didn't mention in pros or cons because well, they're just there and don't really mean anything. The game isn't even about wielding swords anyways. In
fact, it was only after our fourth game when I started filming that I realized that we didn't even bling out fully. We weren't using the special lay lines and plastic stones for Excalibur. And at this point, the bump in that premium feel has diminished so much already. I'm not denying that these are cool and what you're kind of signing up for if you go for a collector's version, but why not reduce this just a tad and put in fundamentals like player aids, better text, more supplementary cards, less symbols. The reality of game night is that cool looks and weighty metal don't mean jack if you don't understand the game and have to take an extra hour or two per game night. Not enjoying the game mind you, just debating and researching rules. Still, once you go through the undertaking of fully understanding the game that is playing a symmetric game that's pretty straightforward minus the symbols, and then just struggling through that first asymmetric game, then yeah, this is mega value of a game, especially $80 for all the nice standees and gorgeous art. So you're getting this game with the promise of it being part of your rotation with a consistent group. Don't worry, you don't need to know or even enjoy a 3000 Legends to play this game.
It's more about the mindset of the gaming. Then with that committed group, you could probably play this for years and years to come, but of course how often you can play because of this game's true length may not be that consistent. And that actually gets us to our resident Rising Sun fan who thought he would like Avalon after looking it up. He actually reached out to me saying, "Oh, this looks really cool. When are you playing it?" And then after my third game with him, he said, "Yeah, this is definitely replacing Rising Sun." And Rising Sun for him, he used to play that like once a month, and it became maybe a couple times a year. And then I don't know when's the last time he played it after we made the review. For him, Rising Sun was the go-to asymmetric minis on a map with cool monsters to get with a very playable combat with the sequence fights and tons of abilities triggering. However, he didn't like how the game did alliances in general, especially how you can be forced to betray or how some guy can be left out of an alliance. Oh yeah, there's not really any alliances in Avalon and I guess he didn't miss that. I personally don't like Rising Sun at all, so that's not even a comparison for me in terms of enjoyment. I would never play Rising Sun voluntarily, but I couldn't end the section without bringing up the other Eric M. Lang, much beloved area control game, part of the trilogy, which is Blood Rage. Just like Avalon, you're repeatedly deploying to the map. You fight in the middle last. You still want to lose fights sometimes. Fights are simple. You're normally just playing one card with an ability, and there's plenty of monsters you're borrowing and then deploying for cool effects. But Blood Rage is far simpler with a very simple draft that goes into the main game. And while it has three ages, each age is far simpler to make it a true 60 to 90-minute game instead of a three to four-hour game. Oh, also my Rising Sun
friend said that Blood Rage was not better than the sum of its parts, namely that the drafting didn't really go well into the area control. Although he's beating me every time we played Blood Rage. So, yeah, maybe he knows something I don't. But yeah, Blood Rage is so much simpler than Avalon or Rising Sun. So, if you're new to area controls, maybe check that out first. Lastly, we opened but didn't really fully use the Myths and Monsters expansion. We just took the Stronghold bling, but this box introduces more monsters and artifacts, which is probably cool. Again, haven't tested it. And then also more prophecies to increase replayability. We just haven't tried the Fae faction at all, but the other players told me when they looked at it, they went, "Uh, doesn't look very good as it's a faction that wants to get third fights." So, surely it's only good in four to five players, and its true power, hard to tell. I mean, usually these Kickstarter expansion factions aren't that good anyways. And then the other box of Mistwalkers gives the Mistwalker and quest mechanic, so it's a new deck of cards. Not sure if the game needed that, but it's another deck. And then one more mini per faction. Again, haven't tried these.
All right, so now it's time for my personal score. This is one of those games that really makes me think about what do I like in multiplayer games because I really like all the substance and prose. I think it's all fun. But then uh the game is just too long. When I was going through the main rules and witnessing the card mechanic, I was like, "Wow, this is really cool. It's going to be a seven out of 10 with maybe the chance to go to an eight out of 10." Then after my second game, I was thinking, "It's still a seven, but maybe it could go to a six out of 10." Then after all four of my games, I settled on a seven out of 10 personal score. It is good. My enjoyment actually goes between a five to an eight out of 10, and I want to give the game the benefit of the doubt because I generally like how it looks. I like the Arthurian theme. I like the player interaction, and two players was a lot more charming than I thought. So, yeah, seven out of 10. And truly the game will get shorter on later plays, right? Probably. Pretty much everything I am personally doing is fun.
I think the card play is awesome. The fights are super engaging. Artifacts and monsters are all really cool. The point scoring is rubber banded in a healthy way, so everyone's in the inning. And even moving around all the nice miniatures and cubes is nice. Oh, the asymmetry is really cool, too. But then also, there wasn't really anything that mind-blowing after really getting to know the game. I'm not the type anymore to super min-max my hand because the possibility is here, but at some point, I just want to keep the game moving forward when there's going to be randomness later on. And maybe the day is just getting late. So, that I find that my commitment of cards for a round is like a fourth of the time of everyone else because I'm just not overthinking it. But hey, maybe that's what you need to do to consistently win. And again, our final game was a little bit over four hours with a new player, so maybe it could get down to two and a half hours, maybe. But when I played two-player with an opponent having his first game ever, but he's pretty smart, but that game took under two hours with the teach. So, I feel like I could get two players to even about an hour, which I think is an insane time for gameplay value. Although, the setup is a little fiddly for two players and the fights aren't as epic for two players. But, I still got to partake in about 90% of the fun. Like, sure, the game is Arthur and legends, but I feel like it doesn't really go too hard in that direction and it can kind of feel like window dressing at times. The regions are named, but I don't really pay attention to that at all, much less the art when there's so many things to worry about in the game.
All card abilities are cool, but they all feel very safe. The chalice? Yeah, sure, it just breaks ties. Or Excalibur, again, just breaks and adds strength. Everything is very incremental, which most people want that in a balanced deep game with only six turns. Perhaps my experience of it is also very incremental compared to the other area control games I've played. And so, it being incrementally more interesting, while being still a very long game, is just not enough for me nowadays. Like, when I'm in the war phase, which is about a third of the game, I keep going like, wait, didn't I experience this already with different minis? And for Blood Rage and Godfather, they're just way shorter and less fiddly, so why don't I play that? Like, the bidding in Godfather felt more impactful because everyone discarded cards. Rules are way more elegant. And Blood Rage was a blockbuster to play with like anyone and to get in those big monsters, bash, and then just get out. And the comparison to Avalon is real because both games don't have that much progression, so maybe I'd rather have something shorter. But, I don't know, too. Like, there's a reason why I sold Blood Rage, right? It was fun, but I never had a desire to consistently whip it out because I felt like maybe something was missing from that game. And then, Rising Sun's alliance system and combat system was supremely unfun to me. So, then maybe I just have The Godfather and leave area control to TI4. And maybe another issue with Avalon for me is that because the structure is so, so tight and the board keeps resetting and you got to get points from winning fights, there's no alternate victory condition. So, it doesn't really feel like there's a lot of room for player expression. And the bouncing of units kind of interferes with my imagination, making units feel more like workers instead of fighters. Again, they're not actually eliminating each other anyways.
Like, it's a lot more min-maxy than I would have imagined. Even the push-your-luck for combat is pretty controlled. So, yeah, I I don't know. I'm I'm left with a lot of uncertainty even though I do like and heavily respect the game. And I could see it going down to a six out of 10 right away if I play it again multiplayer and it just takes 4 hours again, but I could also see it going to a eight out of 10 if I just get this game to under 2 hours. I'm unsure if I'm just starting to age out the super lengthy area control game or if my patience for long games is slipping cuz on my last hour I'm like, "Dude, it's just a game. Hurry up." But the game is really complicated and I'm really not so sweaty anymore to constantly count every region and triple guess by every card. And as a board game reviewer, I can't really have a dedicated long game besides TI4 to keep playing over time. But if I wasn't a board game reviewer, maybe I could have room for this in a rotation. Maybe. So, I'm hardly giving this copy to my Rising Sun super fan friend and this will replace Rising Sun for him and I don't know if I'll play it again.
I don't know. Like I don't know, maybe it's not for me when there's other like three or four hour games out there for me, but maybe I will play it again or maybe I'll play Old King's Crown again and do the review for you guys. Maybe. It's kind of has a very similar uh card system going on. It has bidding and asymmetry. Huh.
That was it for Avalon. Holy cow, that took a long time to make. The script for this was just kept kept getting bigger and bigger. So, thank you to our patrons for making videos like this possible and um yeah, just let me know what you guys think. Um If there's an area control we should check out next, hopefully not as long as this, or what you thought was the coolest mechanic from this game. Yeah. Okay. That's it for now. Okay, thank you to our Malts and Cardboard. That's it. Bye-bye.
Before the fights
You got it.
Hm?
So, I Oh, you're laughing, yeah.
Well, you're you're plus six. You're you're plus six. I'm going to be plus six.
He's going to like plus six to all
I'm plus six to you. I think I'm plus I'm plus 15.
This is right. All right, good game, Mr. Man.
I'm plus 15.
No, it's the freaking Avalon. That was or it's Caldarius. That was the
Yeah, but it's Caldarius. So good.
was trying to fight for, but I I couldn't
Wait, why? When I ask Caldarius is not even in the fight.
It was plus two.
Wait, no, this is not in the fight.