The Hunt: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to war games unlocked and Zack and I doing a discussion over the hunt a game about uh a a submarine warfare World War II summering Warfare of Supply ships yep pretty much uh that is the game uh where one person plays as uh the Germans the other person plays as the British German has hidden movement and it's it's a cat and mouse Style game seems to be heavily inspired by Watergate yeah um and whereas Watergate succeeds on every level I feel that this game fails in a lot of aspects yeah uh because here's the thing about this game for me it would I'd actually like it a lot more if it wasn't basically 100% random on how well one side did versus the other yeah uh and I remember watching a review over this game because I was like I mean it's super cheap it's like I think it was like 30 bucks or something uh production value is good Arts good components are good um except you have to provide your own paper God can't even provide paper to its players right um and I knew because at this point I
like I've been in this hobby long enough that I can kind of hear a game and listen and be like I'm probably not going to like that but maybe not you know I could be wrong maybe the die won't be that big of an issue nope it was exactly what I thought it was going to be uh barely and it's roll to resolve right and here's my other thing so again with roll and resolve there's some things that are good with that yeah number one if you're going to do Rule and resolve please send a good die don't do cheap dies um do a die that actually is weighted correctly mhm because we rolled that die a lot of times and definitely did not hit 33% success R it was like ones and twos basically the entire time right uh which means your di is weighted incorrectly it's again it feels light yeah um it feels like an afterthought like they Because the actual cat and mouse like movement and and trying to maneuver and Bluff and all that that's good right like I didn't mind that it went on way too long to where it was like okay this is kind of I'm over it right uh but the card play was was kind of a nice tug of war of you know when to use your action points when do you want to use the event when do you want to blow through them for the removed cards that's that's all completely from from Watergate and and I like that decision making it's like man this card is a five that's
really really good I mean I used two five cards right out the gate right uh it's like but those are gone and it makes it harder for me to get my mitigation back I guess we only have one plane in the entire World War II German Fleet and to me that's some of the things like searching like as the British player searching it's stupidly hard like realistically i g I came to the conclusion that they told you it's hard to escute your ships I came to the conclusion that's the only way I'm ever going to find you yeah I I have to wait for a ship of mine get sunk and then hope that you don't move far enough out or I can find you close enough to make it count yeah I mean and and to be fair the the result of searching is the same for both it's five or higher which is [ __ ] dumb d y like if you're going to at least do it make it 50/50 four five or six um when you're rolling one die yep uh because even then with the very limited use of the plus two from the uh air airplane which also the rules don't say whether you have to use that before or after your roll right um it's like like if it's if it's four five or six that increases my odds and actually makes me think about wanting to spend my plane or not but because it's five or six I have to still roll higher to even make my mitigation right beneficial um and it's just so frustrating because it's like
what's also dumb about the rules is like I you have to like surface I guess it might not even be submarines I don't think it is actually I think it is just regular ships it feels like it would be submarines but I don't think it is you sure because otherwise you can see mine and I can't see yours so I really don't think it's a it's submarine I don't anywhere in here it says submarine I think that's the implication because um again German uboat sinking frig wild British Naval forces cuz mine are even label as forces that's true yours is an individual ship like yours is two individual ships yeah umz you have a supply ship I mean cuz the the art on it is just a regular ship yeah it's just a regular ship so it could just be art but I'm pretty sure it's not a submarine anyway that's the um uh oh yeah so whenever you search or at least especially when I search I have to uh show my location right uh because and that's okay I'm searching here I am now let's hope I succeed right boo okay all the advantages on you and I guess I'm [ __ ] hosed right because I think what they did is they're like oh hidden movement is so benefit beneficial we have to compensate for that instead of making a balanced game they had to be like okay well the British player doesn't know where the German player is and it's easier for them to run away yeah I mean theoretically because I can go I can start wherever I can go wherever but I only win by syncing your
ships or getting lucky enough in battle right so for me to always basically declare where I'm at uh it's I find the die extremely frustrating yep and the fact that I basically always have to just sound an air horn when I try to do anything on top of the fact that you have cards I mean I have the same card storm at sea prevents you from from searching right um like we both L of cards were the same they they really are like it's basically kind of like the remove from game there's a few that are different right it's like my I have one that hurts your plane um yeah but realistically the vast majority of the cards were identical yeah um I mean of course I'm GNA have some like so new Convoy routes REM puts your reserve to zero yeah um and so again there's some things that are a little bit I have cards that move your your freight ships so they can come to me and I have ones that move freight ships as well but I mean another thing is it's fairly expensive for me to get more forces out I just so happened to have draw one of the very first ones that basically moved it and then I could spend the 2 A4 to get it out yeah okay that's not bad that's that's pretty decent um but there's multiple times where because you could hide in essence and wait you could boost up your AP for later on there's no way for me to do I have one card that allowed me to do it one time a one right um it's not really the card play that is my issue I
actually kind of like it kind of like the the idea of like storm at sea being very annoying whenever it's like because the German player has hidden movement and again I feel like that was their Crux on only giving them the benefit uh because the stor at C it's like okay no one gets to search all right well the British player still benefits from that way more because they just have their Freights they get to now freely move Y and it's like okay well I can't even search for them uh I guess I'll just do nothing theoretically yeah I could just be like okay I'll repair my ship or I'll attempt to it's the [ __ ] or not repair my ship repair my plane that's not even a guarantee it's not even it like they should have just an exponential AP cost like instead of it being like they [ __ ] die man like 1 two 3 4 5 6 seven eight uh it's just like it's a die roll like if I have one removed card and I go to repair my ship spinning I could roll a one and it's now gone for the game right like cuz it has to be greater than the number of removed cards it's like why not just make it to where it costs more AP so I have more it's like do I want to spend this five right and use f just to repair my plane right it's like probably not but at least give them the choice versus like a well that's literally impossible right my di mitigation is out whereas you don't ever lose that no like all your
cards have ways to put hint markers or increase your searches where it's like guess we just have one plane no wonder we're losing the war apparently yeah not a huge fan of the hint markers they yeah they're almost in every single hidden movement game though but in this case like in Le from White chap they are expensive and in Leathers from White Chapel it's like I have to put them in places I've been so you can get a trail versus here I mean I get you can't do that it's water but here it's like it does you no good when I can just be like oh adjacent to me but even that's free so like in White Chapel that's a free thing you either arrest in one spot or you search everywhere that you're touching that's true you're right and so that's where my search was like kind of rough it's like that's why I didn't search all that often because I had you put out a couple but then it's like but you can now be in one of seven spots right didn't tell me anything I knew you were close to there that's why I had you put one out yeah yeah exactly yeah whenever it's like oh it doesn't have to be where I'm at or it doesn't have to be like off my sheet has to be adjacent to where you are where you are or where you uh so just where you are or adjacent so literally unless you on an edge it's seven possible which I did happen to be in that one case but yes yeah if I'm in the middle of the ocean it's and I get it some of the decisions that we're complaining about are thematic like huh where has this ship been in the water let's check the water that's right we can't track but
but kind to the whole increased AP cost so like I get one AP to search that one spot to see give me three AP to search an adjacent spot so I don't have to move there I can start making choices yeah I think the reason why they did that was because they the game ends in in three ways basically there is a fourth but it's like you have to basically play the card that lets your we both had it we both had it to see the other person's hand and then it's like oh okay you have it so we're not using it right I'm not using it at the end right um I did well yeah but there was no there was no it's it's like okay yeah like why I can't even think of a reason why the German player is on worse ground than the uh because if we tied in the two fights you would get to remove two of your damage markers thus winning the fight that's assuming no that's even in this case like I guess no you're right you're right y yeah yep yeah you're correct um yeah so so you would win the fight but that would be the only reason is to do it trick play not well not that card specifically I'm talking about why do like ties go to you why it even says hey by the way the British player has a huge advantage in in battle it's like but why I'm I'm amazed they didn't do combat as just roll a die five times see who rolls higher you you really could yeah well uh I don't know it was fine it's they they
were on the right path but they're like well this is too much like Watergate Randomness people love Randomness in their asymmetric 1V One games you know how to tell who's better than the other player not through skill or strategy die rolling see the real uh Crux of it is was it's my wrist technique years of masturbating just really has honed in my die rolling skills to where this is going to be a four right here so so I'm trying to decide if if the D is actually Square I yet lopsided I actually uh opened this and I melted it on one side so only I knew the we inance it was going roll uh I mean I will say I mean the game wasn't like lopsided uh no like each time it was close on on ships but here's the thing it even says in the rules that it's like hey by the way it's very unlikely like for the British player to get all their to win with getting five freight ships in theory yeah all I do is search roll a three or higher if I get my plane um and then I and I sink it that's it you have to find me uh successfully search and then win the battle right but that if I roll one two or three or four uh without having my plane I don't syn anything right I don't do anything
so theoretically your ships can just march on you play cards to boost the movement they keep marching on I keep trying to Trail them announcing my location hey we're here all right by the way trying to syn this ship one what okay I got away one got away like the whole game could not saying that it will be like that but the fact that it can is so it's such a bad design yeah um like because the search is also once per turn yep so it's not like I Bank a bunch of Reserve uh AP spend a five you know or four and then spend that too so I have six AP and try and search three times right uh like I can't uh or let's say you had two Freights that were near each other um which probably wouldn't happen uh just by cuz they no there were a lot that were coming from the same spot they almost all go to GB um so I mean I have two essay to two GB you have well in that case yeah I guess I I was thinking enough if they were different locations trying to right because it's random you pull them we had two that were coming from AR that literally was stacked one after the other one yeah so it's like in that case I can't like search succeed move and search and succeed again right uh to try and catch up um I mean the only reason I sunk you is because I can search with each of my per force yeah so I stacked two ships on
top of each other searched with the one you canel it search with the second one and succeed it happen to succeed yeah cuz otherwise it's like oh that was your turn oh and let's say the second search you failed oh I have a five boom and then I move over and then if I succeed we win yeah I don't find that satisfying Head to Head it's well let's hope the die like the entire game the die was not in your favor and at the very end it did and you won because battle is lopsided for zero reason and I'm not taking historical context into this like I like I like the fact that every single card from the German cards and the British cards have history in them that's cool Watergate did the exact same thing that's neat I'm not a history buff I don't give a [ __ ] about that um I don't need in my board game I mean yeah not if it's going to affect a gameplay mechanisms if the British forces were stronger than the German uh uh it's why X and allies is a bad game oh because you have to basically follow how World War II went heard that too it was designed that way like they literally made the game to follow world War II so right all you have to do as the Allies is wait for America America is such a Powerhouse but they take a long time to get there yeah but eventually yeah you have to like do the Japan Pearl Harbor thing like at the right time yeah I've heard that exact same thing and it's just like and the Germans have to attack Russia at the right time otherwise there's no way for the axis to win because Russia should just build up so much infantry they'll outpace Germany's
production and so but you have to kill them to be able to take out Great Britain as the Germans and realistically Japan is just trying to slow down America for the Germans to win the game yeah that's it no I've heard the exact same thing and MMO 44 has that same element of like well this the the B this battle leaned more in whoever's favor so they're they're more powerful in this but they at least come out and say that like it's not a hidden thing no I know but it's like for me when it's grounded in actual real life history it's like well you know what I'll just spend you know 5 it's reading the history Wikipedia article and say I played this game right I mean for Memoir I have less of a problem because they actively say that and and once you actually put a couple expansions it changes that gotcha cuz I have like the airplane expansion with it and it completely ruins the balance of the original fight where go and so then it really does become a true head-to-head game gotcha I have other issues with mr44 but but the the the thing is like if this is designed with this history in mind that's cool and history Buffs will like that I just don't see the point especially cuz it's like this game is like roughly around an hour if both players are playing right and it doesn't warrant that the hidden movement gets stale the die like I would not care about the die as much in a 30 minute game because it's 30 minutes like Randomness there's a tolerance level some people love it they like some people love randomist their entire time
I like Madara is a uh that's like a example game I've been given a lot lately for Randomness it's like I can be really into the theme in the story for a bit but then eventually it's like I just start getting more and more annoyed when die rolling is just bad and it's like I can't be thematic it's D and D if I was rolling [ __ ] all night it's like I can't role play anymore because I'm [ __ ] not doing anything right this does that same thing and just if you're looking for a good kind of tug-of-war head-to-head game get Watergate if you're wanting history that one is just Superior in every in every way because there's no Randomness like a die roll I mean there's obviously Randomness in the cards you draw and that's just but that's not that's not uh that's like predetermined Randomness you draw your cards and you're like this is what I have to work with so now I can strategize versus okay I'm going to do this and now I hope an alter like a third party y succeed same reason why War the ring doesn't frustrate me at all it's not like cuz you roll your dice and you're like now what can I do I was hoping for a movement I didn't get it what can I do now this would be like boy I sure hope I can move and that's the thing whenever I look at to me I always go back to head- onhe head games to war of the Rings so War of the Rings I always think of what strategy could I do next time to better play the game right like should I have moved the armies of the elves out
farther or should I have gone the dwarfs into the fight earlier right this game I don't know that I could do anything better or worse I mean I almost got all my ships in that was my goal it just so happened that we were down to The Last Ship I knew exactly where you were it was close enough for both my ships to get to you yeah and it's like yeah [ __ ] it let's do it and also because again I have to announce myself before I succeed like there's a couple things that they could do to fix this game I mean in rules tweaks uh at least in terms of searching is if you succeed then they know where you're at yeah cuz if I shot a missile at a at a ship and I [ __ ] whiffed no one knows anything I'm like damn it I missed like if I was if I was on Space 17 trying to sync that and I roll a one it's like so I think the problem though gets into like these reaction cards because how do I know if I this because we had sometimes there were three ships out but I only was guarding one of them how do I know which one you guarded because m is just like the reaction oh oh I see the maybe search whether you Whi or not I get to do it that's true and so without that knowledge you'd have at least three of the cards and again three ways for me to stop it because I will say that's where I start that's one of the reasons why I started trying to get these ships in is I had two of those cars for a while and I was like I'm just going to sit around
and um wait for thisit yeah try it yeah I was doing the same thing with your I had cards that canceled your successful searches I just I was just holding on to those yep um I actually don't mind the ger the one thing that differentiates the both players is the British Force always has five cards and the German player has three I actually don't mind that uh I thought that that was pretty fair because if I always had five cards as well on top of the fact that I can lie about my movement that'd be a little much I like that bluffing part uh where it's like okay I just tell you hey I'm spending four to move up to three spaces right don't have to move three don't have to move at all um I could be near my ALT Mark and be like okay I'm drawing three even though I could draw five right so I like the bluffing aspect there are elements of this game I do like but the things I don't like I really don't like yeah so it kind of just makes me not like the game as a whole there's just better head tohe head games there are I will say I mean in terms of abstract strategy I guess is what this is called it's not it's it's not horrible uh it is thematic I guess and probably could be even more thematic if you're reading the history notes on every single card right uh but I don't know man hidden movement games maybe it's just a genre I I found like the three I love and it's like yeah
why what game is coming out that's Superior to any of these like the latest like mind management doesn't do it for me no um Sniper Elite doesn't do it for me friend of mine really likes that one but he's never played like a lot of hidden movements so he plays that one and really likes it it's like I got the ones I like and they're just they just I mean you can't really compare this to Fury of Dracula or anything like that but it's like of movement which is what this game is I mean I'm trying yeah cuz I mean I have my I think I have two trying to think if I have a third one and they're good and really there's one that I feel is superior like there's one that I always play and then like Fury I'll play it yeah but it's long enough that I have to be in the mood to designate two and a half hours of play time for right two and a half hours man that's quick oh really it's like it's usually three I use I have a bare minimum of three for that game two and a half as I think are bare minimum it's pretty constant that either guess I've always played with four as well so we uh yeah we play with four okay yeah well I'm pretty good at keeping people going like I don't want people seeing talking to each other it's more like people will talk for a long time and it's like okay you're talking five turns that's it's going to change just play down that is true uh yeah so um I mean I don't know
uh I don't know enen kunter uh Maas Kramer is a name that I do recognize uh but I am totally drawing a blank on on what he's uh on he's on what he's designed damn it oh it's Matt mathas Kramer yeah he do I knew it I I'm I was like I'm pretty sure he's there he designed Watergate H which makes sense because this is very close to Watergate yeah uh so probably the other guy tainted it I get it you you could you don't want to make another game that's exactly like Watergate but right so if you want basically if you're deciding between the two cuz they're they're very identical in like the two separate decks and stuff if you want Randomness in your game get this if you don't want Randomness in your game get Watergate yep that's uh pretty much it um on a scale of 1 to 10 what would you give the hunt six six that's also where I'm at funny enough uh I do think it's slightly above average yeah um it it wasn't unplayable it no it's not unplayable it it for the elements that are in the game like it does work it did come it does come down to the wire it came down to the battle um like I this game is kind of like I mean I'm not comparing it to Twilight struggle at all the and Watergate is also like people are like oh it's it
kills Twilight Struggle No it doesn't no the only element of the of both these games that it compare is the cards in my hand have action points or an event right which one do I want to do uh but at least in Twilight Struggle it's like man if I play this card for its action points that's going to give my opponent the ability right that and there's just way more going on however huge amounts going on yeah so but this game does kind of benefit from um knowing what cards your opponent has played uh which ones are out of the game it's smaller like T struggles massively yeah there's what three eras or something period like you're not playing that for less than two and a half hours oh God I know uh but also knowing like okay if you can memorize the AP value especially as a German player you can be like okay he's used a lot of his high value cards play this card you can count cards yeah if you are reserved with your high value then you can come out on top on on combat um yeah there's definitely and that's why I say that's why I'm giving a six it's not terrible it's just not a game that I want to play very I'm not keeping it like at the end of the day is really where it comes down like because of this so close to Watergate I'd rather just play that right um so well that's it everyone that's our thoughts on the H uh less than we think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope
that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with time ofd is for you