Skip to main content
Loading video...

Why do we need The White Castle Duel? TCbH Review

Transcript 5:36

When it was first announced, the White Castle duel was kind of mystifying to me. I mean, the original already plays great at two. In fact, the entire one to four player count works spectacularly. And so, the big question when White Castle Duel was announced was why do we need this? So, with all of that baggage, I'm actually really stoked to say that I like this game a lot. Within its square box, frustratingly defying any sort of consideration for shelf appeal by sharing dimensions with the original, Duel is familiar in concept, but thankfully drastically different in execution. From a high level, they look the same. Players take turns activating locations for a choice of benefits, triggering passive wealth accumulation from expanding lanterns, with the major goal being to put out samurai quartier and farmers for endgame point multipliers with a strong emphasis on sequencing and the tension between opportunism and long-term investment. From there, Duel does everything different. Workers, not dice. They're colored totems that you place, which always activate one of three personal lanterns tied, at least in the first round, to the color that you cover. With each location, able to have one of these pillars of each suit. And your benefits are often tied to cards, which when obtained, you get immediate effects, but you're pressured to take flip actions before the game

runs out as their backs are adorned with symbols used for point multipliers with your core tier and samurai. And all of this is done in two rounds of only six actions each where in a brilliant twist of organic game state development, the second round, players instead activate locations by removing the top cylinder from a location and gain the lantern benefit of that color. Again, setting up interesting decisions and emphasizing tough opportunistic choices. All in all, this captures the general spirit of the White Castle. It's all here. It's the crunchy decisions. It's the smart sequence of play. And it's the variable setup. But it does shave it down into about a half an hour experience that is not in any way lesser than what you've already experienced with the White Castle. If anything, this is condensed, but it is compacted at the same time. It is just as crunchy, just as maddening, just as puzzling as the original, but in a much much tighter shell. And in some ways, that's going to be a lot more fraught for people. The question I keep coming back to is when am I going to choose this versus the original? The obvious answer is when I want a dense, nuance Euro I could still tackle in 30 minutes.

But truthfully, the original isn't that much longer. Well, if you're not using matcha. So, for me, it's more of a tonal difference. There's something really distilled about Duel. And like the best Duel adaptations before it, encourages directly confrontational, if not fully combative, player interaction. There's a distinct sense that everything you do impacts the board state for your opponent in ways present, if not fully prevalent, in the OG. And to be honest, while Mrs. TCBH likes the original enough. This resonated with her much more, possibly because there feels like just as many ramifications, but fewer sandbox choices and more direct consequences of individual actions instead of when you place this then based off of the number of dice or the color of dice and then it might also trigger this and that immediately leads into another action which might itself trigger some more things. In Duel, you technically have more worker placements than in the original White Castle, but there's less of a chain of events with each individual action. Some of that is there, but it still feels more deliberate here. So, I also have to consider that when your chief gaming partner likes a game a lot, it's not one you want to dismiss and ultimately would play a role in if I had to choose one versus the other. But fortunately, that's not a choice I need to make right now. If I want a

rich, more expansive game with more focus on long-term goals, my bay is still by my side. Whereas this tighter knot of blissfully agonizing opportunity cost, condensed and compacted presented with the dual moniker is here. Is it better than the original White Castle? No, I don't think so. Because the original is more flexible. It's more robust. And in some ways it's less pressure, but if you like high octane euros and you don't want them to always take a bunch of time and you like things that are sculpted to precision, especially that are going to accommodate two players, then the White Castle Duel really does something that is different than the original and justifies its own existence. And that's our review. But let me know what do you think about White Castle Duel and this whole series of twoplayer interpretations of original games. Put it in the comments. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for being such an awesome community. You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved