Anno 1800 Board Game Review: Does Anyone Want to Trade a Lightbulb for Champagne?
Transcript
hi everyone tally and farrell here from boardovit and welcome to our review of anno 1800 the board game based on the civilization builder video game of the same name legendary designer martin wallace takes on the challenge of converting no1800 from one medium into another so the main idea of anno 1800 the board game as i configure it is you're someone that's been put in charge of an island or inherited an island or yeah i discovered an island there's some rudimentary infrastructure and you have a population and the goal of the game is to have the most content population of any island ever i guess i don't really know and the way you make them content is by giving them things they want you know such as artillery or beer which are both real examples i don't know sven something about this doesn't seem quite right i mean i'm pretty sure that dogs can't have beer right in technical terms it's a cube manipulator city builder economic type of game and whilst it doesn't look or sound like very much no i mean to the viewers at home it probably looks really dry and boring and unclean compared to some other big fancy production games this has provided us with some of the most fun we've had at the table in recent months
you'll begin anno 1800 with a player board which represents your island there are already some rudimentary industries some ships a harbour and some workers represented by cubes now these different types of cubes are different types of workers so these are farmers these are just called workers these are artisans and then later in the game you can gain some purple in engineers and some teal investors for each one of these population cubes you have you'll have to draw a matching card that shows a person that's living on your island paradise and it also shows their hopes dreams and aspirations and what they want to be content this woman wants schnapps to be happy that is extremely troubling anyway making these islanders happy is what compromises the core gameplay loop you will give them what they want and then they have a bonus for you which you can take at any time but essentially that card is complete you keep it there you score it at the end of the game and you move on to the next islander and the game will end when everyone in your island paradise of industry has been made happy eg when one player gets rid of all their population cards to give the islanders what they want you're going to have to build industry to produce the goods that they want and this leads us to the most common action in the game expand which is where you build industries and this you do by
using a worker to produce a good that simple you produce wood and then you take the matching tile so to build this coal factory this requires one word which we've just done flip it and now it's in our island and ready to be used next turn importantly you don't need to use workers every time you produce a good you can actually trade for them using these tokens with your opponent so here i have no green left and i couldn't even build a wood or get some wheat anyway because these positions are full but if i spend a trade token i could trade with tally for some of her wheat which she can't refuse but gets money in return to fulfill a population card is a single action as is connecting with the old world which is where you spend expiration tokens to get one of these old world boards and they just allow you to expand the space you have and build more industry then same as this spending and expiration token you can discover the new world and this will allow you to get a little new world board that has goods you couldn't otherwise get and are crucial for building specialist industries like chocolate or rum or tobacco you may get to a point where you can no longer produce anything because you just don't have enough workers left in this case you can hold a festival in which all the workers will return back to their home probably a little hungover but then they will be ready to work
again on your next turn the final actions involve swapping out population cards for new population cards or gaining these museum cards which will give you points at the end of the game depending on what cubes you have it's also worth noting that there will be objective cards in play which might give you points for having certain industries or just provide alternate actions and that's it whilst it can be tricky to navigate the paths needed to make your more discerning citizens happy the turn to turn gameplay is wonderfully straightforward and quick one thing we love is a game that allows you to build a very complex system or engine but reduces your turn to very simple actions which only take a few seconds and no 1800 does this masterfully each action is straightforward and once you're shown it it's easy to follow no turn takes longer than a moment so anno 1800 is able to consistently keep you engaged because your turn comes back around so quickly so you have these snappy tones but then ana makes interactivity a core mechanism meaning it's crucial you never take your eyes off the table this is because your population has a lot of wants and needs for goods more than you could ever hope to produce in a single game so why would you spend two or three tens creating good that you'll only use once when you could trade with another player and that's why it's so important to watch what they are doing and we love how accessible this information is because there's only one or two industry tiles on this main board
so at a glance you can see if one or both have been taken and adjust accordingly honestly the trade mechanic is what brings the whole game together it's so funny to announce to the table i need sausages does anyone have sausages and then watch two players fight and argue about who has the best quality sausages in an attempt to get you to pick them you also have these moments where someone will build a complex stage four purple industry and that's exactly what you needed so you outright cheer them as they just saved you three turns it's also nice that the trade can't be refused and rather you are compensated and that money can be important so it is worth building popular industries i know 1800 is actually a bit of an enigma for us because despite on the surface it being a really dry ugly game it's given us more laughs per hour than 99 of the board games in our collection we think this is due to the very strange theme of fulfilling people's needs and then those needs being cigars and light bulbs it really really tickles us and this combined with the fact that some players but not all have the same industries creates so much table talk and riffing on the game humor is a surefire way to increase enjoyment now this was our group and our experience of playing the game so it won't be true for everyone make no mistake the core gameplay mechanisms are solid but just bear in mind that the laughter we have in this game does elevate it for us and all of our delight aside it's not a perfect game one thing we're a bit ambivalent on is
the end game trigger and we just find having to depend on another while on the players getting rid of all their population cards means that you never know how long the game's going to last and when you're in it because players are picking up cards quite a lot at the beginning and sometimes throughout the game you just never quite know who has what and how far away they are from completing them and this means that i can see it being a difficult game to get to the table sometimes just because you can't bank on how long you're gonna have to play for me i just wish it was that little bit shorter or that there's just a more reliable endgame trigger maybe when the first person completes 20 population cards or something like that it just every game of this i have this one moment somewhere in the middle maybe in the final third where we've been playing we've been playing we've been playing and i look around the table and everyone's just still got a big handful of population cards and it not even in a bad way because i'm having fun but i'm just like how long is this game going to last there's like no end in sight and you just feel a bit adrift sometimes when you're playing we've also found the objective cards a bit superfluous and we're talking about the ones that you score off not the ones that give you alternate actions those are quite interesting because the issue is we tend not to even look at them until maybe the final round of the game because you're too focused on the main goal for filling your population cards
and say an endgame objective will give you six points for a cigar factory if you have six cards that will require a chocolate factory that's what you're going to focus on you're not going to spend three turns explore the new role to get that cigar factory out from easily six points not worth it and then this in turn tends to make this endgame scoring sometimes a bit of luck if no one's paid any attention to them because the person that will score the most out of these endgame scorings are the persons who had the cards that aligned the most with those industries or without condition but this was just our experience and i'm certain there are point maximizers out there who can definitely work this system to their favor speaking of the cards you're dealt the randomness does also worry us a little there's a fair chance that the luck of the draw can give someone a major boost towards a victory getting a starting hand of cards will require the same industries makes your opening rounds a lot easier compared to someone who got cars with all differing needs then once you've fulfilled those cars the bonuses can also make a major difference if you get a hand that equally gets you new workers and allows you to upgrade them you'll be laughing but if you've got a hand like i once did that gets you no new workers then you'll struggle to really ever have enough and be able to keep up with the other players of course you can swap out those cards for new ones but it's still luck of the
draw and a wasted turn in a game that's about turn optimization the last criticism will level at an 1800 is also the biggest we have this game is severely lacking in quality everything feels cheap and low effort the cards are thin and rough the tokens are all the same size and have unimaginative symbols you have to jigsaw the board together what we personally hate the most is the fact that the player guides are essentially made out of paper so one accident and it's all over we honestly can't remember a game that we've played that's made less effort with what's in the box and in the region we're in this costs around 55 pounds and honestly that is complete highway robbery for the quality of components you get it's actually really outrageous to be fair to the game the components and the quality doesn't impact on the gameplay which is the most important thing and once we start playing we do completely forget about any of these issues but moving on to something that's a little bit better about the component quality the artwork on the tiles is quite basic it could be a lot nicer but it's also by ironically being so basic it's quite easy to see so if you have a card the symbology is very easy to pick out essentially although some of it in terms of you can match the symbology but maybe you don't know what the item is the famous example being the toilet paper which is
cotton but we just call it toilet paper because it looks like toilet paper and it's also funnier to have people demanding toilet paper who's got the toilet paper exactly um and the the artwork on the population carts these are also it's quite humorous in that people very much look like people who want the things they're asking for so that's probably the highlight of any kind of art design really these population cards so final thoughts it's pretty clear that this is a very strong recommendation from us if you like economic civilization builder or key manipulator games this will be a hit on your table it's also perfect if you want friendly non-negative player interaction but but the production quality of anno 1800 is some of the worst we've seen and probably the worst in our collection and that makes the price a little bit unforgivable also we had a few minor quibbles but there's actually just been an expansion announced which is coming out next year that apparently fixes almost every criticism we had so watch out for that what we would say is let's just end with we have a lot of love for anno 1800 and if you get the chance to play it at a friend's house or a board game cafe then definitely give it a go and see if it's worth it to you but that is our review of anna 1800 so thanks for watching we can't wait to play again because we're addicted but uh yes thank you so much and if you want to ask us any questions
feel free to do so and please like and subscribe because it would mean a lot to us and the dogs mainly the dogs look at him goodbye