Skip to main content
Loading video...

Windmill Valley Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 5:16

I have windmill Valley so windmill Valley a game I've had on the on the back burner for some time I wasn't quite sure if I was going to take a punt on this one um because I thought know Bor and dice have been hit on this recently I've not played any of the Danny Garcia games yet because they seem a little bit convoluted for me but as the months have gone by the more and more good things I'm hearing about this game so I thought you know let's give it a go and I'm really glad I did because I've been playing a lot of this game and enjoying it more and more so mechanically I love how simple this game is but it's it's still interesting in the way those me mechanisms work so basically you have this um resource wheel or this action wheel with two different cogs on them and these cogs are going to determine your actions and the the number of kind of rotations that these wheels make is up to the players you can choose to keep the water level as it is or you can choose to increase that water level to give more spins the more you increase the water level you'll get some passive points that way as well um because you could potentially be helping the other players now what I do like about this game is that I think there's six separate actions or maybe even seven with the additional ones um that you can take and they are all very simple in their own right simply draft a card draft an upgrade for your resource will and you know take um you place a windmill on the board and so on so all very easy to to explain but the

potential for comboing and synergizing actions together really does come through so for example you might say I'll go here uh to place my windmill down that might contribute towards um you know a race objective that windmill will then unlock some further scoring on my player board it will allow me to bury some tulips the Tulips will score me more endgame scoring points um when I place this chulip down it gave me some money and so on so again you can string these actions together to make very powerful and satisfying turns um the engine building is very interesting as you can literally upgrade your resource wheel to make the actions better and even if there's an action that you're not that interested in anymore you can completely overlap it with one of these upgrades and just do you know be gone with that particular action and focus on something else um you know the game is fairly linear in what you want to do collect ulips place them in rows of the same type and different different types and columns um unlocking points that way um you can buy these characters which are really cool or you can just draft these characters sorry which will either give you in-game benefits so for example they might say every time you bury a tulip you you get a tulip and things like that which are very useful but more importantly you can take them as endgame objectives so you can use them as two ways that in in-game engine building benefits or end game scoring benefits and I think the game of objectively I can't really fault too much with it I

think the only criticism I have is that sometimes those objectives on the characters can be a bit swingy um because on your turn you might not have any objectives that suit you but on your opponent's turn they have one that's going to double the points of all their tulips and they've already completed that row so therefore they're going to score another 15 points without putting much effort in at all and I've played this quite a few times already and that really does swing who wins the game or not so I might appreciated seeing those objectives maybe capped at a certain amount of points lower than what it is in the game of course I don't know the the maths behind that decision but it just feels a little bit wonky for me and every time I've taught this I've made that very clear that you want to be keeping an eye out for particular objectives that are fitting your strategy um but still despite that nitpick the rest of the game is highly enjoyable I get combos Galore upgrading your player board is so much fun uh the game also moves at a very brisk Pace you can play a two-player game of this in 45 minutes to an hour um if you're teaching this at you know a four-player game it's probably going to take more than an hour and a half maybe two hours for the first play um but it doesn't feel like you are sitting there doing nothing all the turns feel fun um and yeah it's just a lovely Euro that I can see sticking around in my collection for some some time because it's it's actually very easy to get to the table and to teach

but it still hits all those sweet spots and what you want for a Euro so definitely going to be a contender for a Euro of the Year for me um it might just fall short because some others I've played out just a little bit better but it's still going to probably going to be in the top three um I I'd be surprised if this doesn't make the top 10 of the Year for me in overall 2024 releases yeah so all in all it's a quality design and it's made me want to um maybe take a a closer look at some of those other Danny Garcia games that haven't quite grabbed my attention but if they're up to this quality then um I know they're going to be good so that is windmill Valley

Progress saved