COMPREHENSIVE Black Forest Review - Game Comparisons, Peer Review, Deep Dive
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today this episode has been my most highly anticipated one of this year as as of today this is finally the episode where I get to talk about Black Forest I pre-ordered and purchased a copy as soon as it was made available and I've been playing it solo and I've been playing it two-player as well multiple times in order to give you my conf comprehensive thoughts on this game this is definitely my most anticipated game of this year not only is it the big box release for Rosenberg this year who is my favorite designer but it's also a sequel of sorts both thematically and mechanically to one of my favorite games of all time which is glass road so this very comprehensive review is going to go pretty deep into this game including the things that I usually like to talk about with all of my reviews and first impressions which are the game play highlights or in other words the mechanisms that make this game unique or give it some presence the game comparisons particularly with glass road but also with other Rosenberg games the peer review going over some of the comments that people have made about this game as well on Board Game Geek and then finally give you my concluding thoughts but also to include a lot more of a deep dive strategically as well as pointing out things that I think are pretty unique or interesting about this game going through some of the more
interesting buildings uh some of the strategy that I've come across these last couple of plays and just just overall interesting things about this game in addition to what I think about this game and how it compares to some of my favorites and if I would play it again so let's dive into it so starting with game highlights let's talk about what I consider worker movement but many people call would call worker placement the correct of this game revolves around these action tiles or traits people that are randomly placed throughout a central board uh at the beginning of the game you take an empty spot in a village after you move to it and take the actions depicted on each adjacent tile in any order you choose you must be wary of other players though as you may have to pay a resource to them if you enter a village with them in it already and that scales up for the more people that are present in that Village you enter one tile in particular is the traveling Merchant which may be moved around by spending Commodities on your own personal from your own personal Supply more on that later switching places with another tile making the initially random setup even more dynamic as you play throughout the game where you can mix and match and move around these action tiles to different Villages creating new combinations of actions that you can take when you decide to step into that Village and take those actions next are the the resource Wheels as in glass Road you keep track of your resources with
wheels you have basic goods and upgraded goods and when you have at least one of each basic good on a wheel you automatically move that dial clockwise to essentially convert those resources automatically to make an upgraded one one wheel in particular uh you have the teal commodity which is spent by moving the traveling Merchant but also the purple Provisions which must be spent to move your pond from Village to Village next you have the Tableau building aspect of this game your Tableau is called an estate and you modify your estate by placing building tiles Landscapes Stables Etc cows and pigs as well onto your estate and arranging them depending on the uh puzzle that you're trying to solve with certain buildings and how you score them but you also get to advance on a little track uh which is this little glass Beed that you have and when it reaches the very top of that track you will be able to add an extension board to your original estate where you move that track over you restart that glass speed at the bottom and can progress and add even more extensions if you reach the top of that track again you will score points based off of these extensions at the end of the game and it allows for more uh tiles to be placed on obviously but also to replenish more forests for you to utilize for different buildings and actions that you take in the game game there is a new mechanism when you compare this to Glass Road in the form
of jobs and as you rotate through your right dial on your resource Wheels you eventually will unlock the ability to have jobs available on the main board and you randomly place these jobs at on a board each job has a particular location that they can be placed at whether it's dependent on a printed spot on the board or depending on where a trades person is already at on the board as well but essentially you can travel to these jobs you can spend the resources required to fulfill the job and you get a lot of resources in turn so it's a one-time effect to really bump up the resource Gathering and some of them have some different effects as well more on my thoughts on jobs later finally the last mechanism I want to talk about is how you end the game the game takes place over many turns as many turns as necessary until someone on their wheel moves a purple provision on or through the game End Icon everyone will then get one more turn including the person who moved the provision and then scores are added up like normal in this game in addition to the points being on the building tiles that you place leftover glass and endgame points earned you will also gain points based off of animals only placed in Staples as well as extra estate pieces you've added onto your Tableau as we've already discussed and how far you move your dial on the provision commodity wheel so let's move on to game comparisons so
obviously Rosenberg has a huge back catalog of games to compare to and some of these comparisons uh all of these comparisons I'm going to make to Black Forest are from Rosenberg games whether they are big comparisons or small whether they were intentional in the design or not I'm not sure but these are the ones that I could find so first of all glass Road aside from the theme obviously black Forest is based off of glass Road itself mechanically I believe this was the inherent design of black forest was to build off of what glass Road was doing and obviously I think anyone else who plays this game is going to first compare it to Glass road because of a lot of the similarities that they have with the resource Wheels how they work the types of buildings you can build a lot of these tiles not only just share the same names as some of the tiles in glass road but some of the same abilities as well you have the Tableau management with the ability to be flexible about where you place your building tiles and your landscape tiles the ability to remove landscape tiles and stables in this game uh at any time that you want that's also a mechanism shared with glass Road a lot of similarities are there once again in addition to the theme now moving on to some other comparisons first let's talk about Aura at labora this is the original Rosenberg game to feature a resource wheel of any kind now it it did come out 2 years before glass rote and the wheel was used in a different way
where as with older games such as Agricola and laav where you have a lot of resources being tracked a lot of resources being offered from a central board for worker placement actions to acquire those resources or at labora used this resource wheel to uh simplify how many resources you would obtain when you acquired such a resource from a worker placement action and so it was a more communal type of wheel that helped keep everything in track and it really sped up the gameplay of each round having to replenish the resources that were made available it was in two years after or at labora that we first saw the resource wheel being used uh personally in your own Tableau to keep track of your own resources uh and so that's the biggest comparison that I think many people will make and I will hold off on some other comparisons with or at labora later on in my final thoughts but the other game that does use resource Wheels is orian Burger Canal a more recent release from Rosenberg uh in the last year or two depending on when you might have acquired it if you did back it on game found versus the syx release this year uh for a new version a second edition with new new artwork and some modifications to to rules but that uh resource wheel personal resource wheel mechanism is seen in orani Burger Canal
however the stipulation is that you can move the uh dials between the basic and the upgraded Goods at any time versus uh the automatic movement that you see in black forest and glass Road the next game that I want to compare this to is fields of ARA first the fluidity of how animal are added and stored to your tau is very much seen in other Rosenberg games but I feel like it's really represented well in fields of ARA because you do acquire a lot of animals and you move them around consistently as you uh remove tiles or add different tiles to your Tau you uh it's you are often interchanging these animals in a more consistent and uh Dynamic way compared to other Rosenberg games it felt the same in Black Forest the the fluidity of how you moved around animals depending on the game state in addition the way that most buildings are laid out in a random Arrangement uh is very reminiscent fields of ARA so and and these are the buildings that you can acquire and build in fields of ARA the building offering is more or less the same from game to game there are some sections or some categories of buildings that are interchangeable and randomized from game to game there but there are others that are are going to be pretty much static for you know the uh from one game to the next in Black Forest that is different where you get to place all the buildings
on one side and then flip over with the a side and then flip 10 random ones over to their BS side which have different effects and so you more or less get you know a a small percentage of of buildings that are different each game um more thoughts on that later I I realize I'm saying that a lot but I do want to condense a lot of these thoughts and coales them into a coherent conclusion at the end so black forest to me in in regards to the mechanism of how buildings are offered kind of fall Falls in between caverna and Fields of ARA or I should say it's probably a little bit more random than fields of ARA caverna is a very static you know this is the offering that you get for all games right it it doesn't change in the base game rather and and Fields of ARA introduced a little bit more Randomness to how that's set up and then finally you have black forest of note I do want to mention that Tito Lawrence was the designer of one of the expansions or the only main expansion to fields of ARA as well and so there might have been some influence when coming to Black Forest and the approach to giving us the offering of buildings to build from in the way that it is as per the rules so I thought that was interesting the next game is Mercer so this is an old game from Rosenberg back before uh glass Road and oret labora came out but after the big three Agricola at the gates of loang
and laav came out and in that game it was a very different uh theme compared to a lot of Rosenberg games then and since where it's more industrial uh or I should say more Merchant based and more uh trade oriented with order fulfillment and things like that you would move around an old map of Europe and spend resources in the form of time to move around the board and so that was very reminiscent when I first thought of and and and witnessed that board for Black Forest which ended up being true that you do move around by spending Provisions which you do acquire throughout the game and so there's the ability to be stuck I don't know if I previously mentioned but you have the ability to be stuck in Black Forest without being able to move anywhere in the same Village as well as other Villages and so you might have to beg for food and use up a turn to gain the resources to move the next turn and so that I don't feel happened as much in Mercer it doesn't happen too often in Black Forest it may happen but that Central board movement and planning out where you want to go next is very much a a decision that is made in both of these games the next game is holler toow on my list to compare and most mostly for the jobs uh that you see in black forest the jobs and how you randomly shuffle them and place them out onto a board in certain spots in Black Forest really
reminded me of the randomness of the different decks of cards that you can draw from during the game in holler toown and this kind of goes into my concluding thoughts about how that Randomness works from game to game and how much it affects a player's game if the right jobs are revealed at the right time and in the right place and then finally the last game that I wanted to compare is plantan nubo now I have not played this game yet I've looked at videos especially last year when it was uh released in Europe for essn it is now currently being released in the United States as we speak I so I haven't played it at all and don't understand all the rules at this time but I do understand the Crux of taking actions in that game is somewhat similar to to Black Forest you do place in plantan nubo you place your tools out in the tool phase to take an action in wherever you place your tool you take an action in between uh or you know flanking the tools that you placed you can spend other resources to take both actions as well and so the ability to choose a a a space in Black Forest and to go to uh and and to automatically take both of those actions in any uh order is definitely more flexible and feels a lot easier to do that has nothing to say about the tightness of the resources of this game but uh I feel like that option and the uh decisions uh that you get to make in Black Forest are kind of multiplied in a
sense that you're looking at two different action combinations to take an action from rather than just one from one action space for a worker placement you know uh so I assume that it's going to feel very similar when I do happen to try plantan nubo with the added decision space of having more like a combination uh more than one action space to choose from so let's move on to the peer review so normally when I go through the comments on Board Game Geek and coales them into a list in this section I look at the what people have good to say about uh this game or and and the cons you know this or that and in this particular review I I found it was interesting that a lot of people who have had the opportunity to play and review this game they either inherently enjoy Rosenberg games or they don't and so a lot of people who ended up not liking Rosenberg games in the past for some reason you know whether they or other friends wanted to play the game they ended up playing it and reviewing it and gave it a lower score a lot of the low scores ended up being that kind of the gist of of their comments were well I really don't like Rosenberg games and this one doesn't stand out from among them and so you have those folks who have uh you know negative negatively reviewed it because they're I I feel inherently biased against it and then you have those who are inherently biased for Rosenberg games giving it a glowing review and rating on Board Game Geek and
so in both camps I try to pick out instead some of the topics that either rubbed people the right way or the wrong way and those some of those topics include how long the game plays the game L it being more of an indeterminate set of rounds and turns rather than a static and set number of rounds or actions that you can take in the game come to think of it as I look at a lot of the big box games that I own and have played from Rosenberg none come to mind that use uh an indeterminate amount of rounds structure for their game I think all of them use a set number of rounds now I could be wrong and there could be some other maybe uh smaller games like Bonanza for example does not have a set number of rounds but you out of the uh The Big Box games I think you have a set number of rounds for each of them except for Black Forest so I thought that was very interesting and some people had good bad things to say about that the tightness of resources a lot of people enjoy that in games in general and they enjoy that about Rosenberg games and some don't right you have the front loading of building tiles the offering of the different buildings that you have at the beginning of the game is controversial as well as the variability from game to game in what buildings are offered you have the comparisons with glass Road as well uh in addition to
game length as well as uh the mechanisms like the additional complexity that black forest has with the worker placement and worker movement but also the big differences being the way that actions are taken meaning the worker placement in Black Forest versus the card play of glass road so a lot of people have things to say about that and then finally I wanted to talk briefly about the two-player rules in uh some reviews prominent reviewers have mentioned that they dislike this concept where in a two-player game specifically in Black Forest you utilize a an extra third uh worker plate or worker Pawn as a player and they help add interaction to when you visit a village you would lose a resource as if it were a three player game and you're interacting with this dummy player you just lose a resource you don't have to give you know the opponent the other player a resource unless you're in that village with them too the Crux of this is uh when or the stipulation is is when you move the traveling Merchant with your commodity uh resource you do that action you switch tiles uh with the traveling Merchant but then you have the ability to place that dummy in a an entirely different spot it can be in the same Village it could be in a different village it doesn't matter and so it gives you the opportunity to potentially block a a space that some your other opponent would want to take or to place it in a village that would you know
force them to give up a resource if you plan it out correctly and predict where they might want to go now before I get into my concluding thoughts I want to do something unique for this review and that is a deeper dive into some of the aspects about the game that didn't necessarily fit into any other category so first of all for theme talking about the theme I really like the aspect that this is a continuation of the story that glass Road tells it it kind of seems like it's the next step in like industrialization of the Black Forest region rather than focusing in on a single part of of the you know a single little Hut or little region that you're focusing on in glass Road you're expanding this out to neighboring Villages uh it really felt like artistically as well as thematically with even some of the building tiles and some of the jobs and where where you place them and everything it it felt like these were actual cities and Villages that are and were located in the Black Forest region and so for me it was a really nice touch and and what it it took what a dry Euro could have been and made it a little bit more interesting to look at and to be a part of when playing the game now I find so according to the rules the the next point is that the uh the different building uh boards the larger boards that hold all of the small tiles and and the the large building tiles as well
have backsides to them and the largest one has a scoring or sorry the mediumsized one has a scoring track that you are asked to flip over in the main rules and use when you are tallying up your scores I never did that I'm used to Glass Road where there is no scoring track and you can uh just tally up the scores by visualizing your Tau it's it's pretty straightforward and easy once you do it uh one or a few times and it was very similar in Black Forest I felt like it was pretty easy to score your points um in addition to that some of the uh talk about the scores as well I I felt like a really good score that I've seen myself and and others achieve and try to reach was in the 40s perhaps 50s or so um in the solo mode there are uh there is a ranking very similar to like the solo mode in newsford where you're trying to achieve the highest uh score possible and it kind of Tears out different scores that you might be able to get and I believe it's about 70 or 80 points that a solo score can really maximize out of I don't know if that is possible I I suppose it is possible if you really delay out the game in in a multiplayer version of glass Road or sorry of black forest but uh but like that 40s and 50s Mark was seemingly a pretty good place to end up at the the board itself that you keep track goes up
to 60 and so I suppose that that is probably around the place where people were maxing out with scores during play tests now anyway so I it's it's great that that's there and you could perhaps use it during the game to really keep track of the points that you have and everyone else has as well uh that's a feature that I've really appreciated in uh glass Road on board game arena is to be able to follow that score at least for a portion of the scoring uh from from your opponent or opponents to kind of gauge where you're at in the game and kind of help you strategize a a little bit better however uh in this game while that could be utilized another thing that I found was interesting was that there is a very artistic back to the largest building uh uh board and in that uh as you might see pictured here there are spaces that are very that fit a small building tile perfectly and there's some that you can even count as two for like a large building and so it got me thinking as far as like a house rule for the variability that is or the lack thereof in this game when it comes to building tiles you could potentially use that large board and randomly assign buildings uh to that board and replenish them as the game goes on in a similar fashion that you would see in glass Road I haven't tried this out myself I don't know if this would work if it it would
affect any balancing of the game at all and it wouldn't it would lose out on the organization that you would have with the front side of that building and how each building each row and column is organized by resource type however I did think that was an interesting idea and I probably will try it out at some point just to see how it goes but that might be a little house rule that you might be able to use uh not just to you know improvise with a building offering but to utilize something that does it appears to have some sort of uh significance and it fortunately does it is like SE sectored out and sectioned out to have these small buildings placed into anyway so I thought that was interesting uh the so the tightness of the resources is pretty evident in this game especially when it comes to the actions that you take there are approximately one tile per resource that you can potentially gain on your uh board as well as your resource dials uh on the main board itself self and so early on in the game I feel like it's very expensive and hard especially depending on how each of the tiles are arranged it's not it's not completely random every tile uh you know worker placement tile has a certain back to it like a family crest and they are they start on certain spots around the game and so there is a little bit of organization to where those actions
could potentially be and they're spread out enough like you wouldn't have all of the constructed building tiles in one Village for example at the beginning of the game at least and so there is a little bit of uh help and spread to be able to go around the different Villages and take different actions to get different resources and so that is nice and when the traveling Merchant happens yes things will get mixed up but it still feels very tight at the beginning of the game uh for example the furnace maker and and it's expensive for the actions to take themselves for example the furnace maker requires three bricks to advance two spaces on your glass track on your Tableau and you start the game with three bricks and so you either have to make your way down to the other trades person which I forget right now where it gives you four brick to use which is the only spot on the board to a to be able to use that and then make your way back to the furnace maker to use that to advance your glass track uh that that takes two turns that's using Provisions who knows how much how many Provisions that might be depending on where you're at but in that sense you can see that there are a lot of many steps that you would have to take a lot of actions in turns that you'd have to take in order to to progress your glass um Track by a couple of spaces the same could be applied to buildings I felt like there were a lot of buildings that were pretty expensive that I was eyeing for either points or for a nice anytime action
trying to approach this game as it is instructed in the in the game there's a little uh hint or a couple of words of advice in the back of the rule book and it's similar to Glass Road where you want to start the game with blue production buildings anytime action buildings to help you convert resources and make things a little bit easier however a lot of those buildings were kind of tough to get you know you have to really pinpoint one that you could build and and build quickly before someone else does depending on where you're at in the central board and what kind of action combinations could ly get you to that point where you can build those and so it it did feel a like it was a little slow at the beginning really tight in the beginning of the game to acquire the right resources in the right timing uh in the in the right time line and time frame to be able to build those buildings and progress your engine to the point where you know things are snowballing to the point where you can really see the end game in sight and so uh I thought that was interesting the traveling Merchant really helps alleviate the resource tightness and so I do appreciate having the commodity tile or resource rather to switch up the action spots maybe you know using it as a reverse action where you send it away and bring another action tile to the village that you want to be in to use that in combination with another action and so there there is a lot of strategy that happens with the traveling Merchant but once again you have the stipulation of moving the dummy player and having a lot of
interaction based off of that dummy player in the two-player version but uh you know it's just like the supplier the the traveling Merchant rather is like the supplier in glass Road where if you gain two resources of any type you're giving everyone else one of that resource and so as a double-edged sword you can progress your own resource gain and your goals you know you can try to achieve your goals a lot faster with that but at potentially the expense of quickening someone else's game too so a lot of strategy and thought going behind that mechanism as well um the jobs themselves so I wanted to talk about these uh so they're they're really interesting side quests I feel to give you a lot of resources that can come in handy in the game so addressing the tightness of how this game feels especially in the first couple of turns where you're just trying to you know not use as many Provisions as he can and to you know gain food and meat to gain more Provisions free up the flexibility that you have to go from space to space and then moving that dial to reveal the jobs right and so those jobs at first glance were very generous right like okay I can probably grind to get seven of a certain type of resource to get a you know a ton of different and varied resources to really uh up my abilities to build buildings to gain glass Etc right uh
some them had some really interesting effects too so like the the captain job allows you to build a small building for free I feel that's really strong uh I could build a very expensive building say like later in the game if there was an endgame Point uh you know Trigger or Point building that I wanted to build like The Village Church for example I could build that for free like I don't have to pay two glass I don't have to pay all the other resources for that building uh very strong so when the captain job pulls up it's very I feel like it's very sought-after right and very strong and a lot of the other building or a lot of the other jobs gave some really good resources right uh sometimes it gave you just straight up glass it gave you animals uh landscape tiles and Stables which are sometimes hard to get by or or to acquire as you get by through the game and so they were very efficient they didn't lead to a lot of you know direct points but they did give you the ability to uh jump start your game in the middle of the game usually and get to where you wanted to go so I thought that was interesting the large buildings in particular offer different endgame objectives to pursue right and so they are the bottom row in glass Road the four buildings that are offered and replenished throughout the game those are the endgame you know triggering points uh or sorry the the game end objective that objectives that you're trying to chase and so the large buildings offered that similar offering as well to chase usually by the late to
you know mid to late game and so I felt that was a great way to start when you don't know where to begin with this game you look at that really large offering of buildings and you feel a little overwhelmed where you you kind of step back and you look at those large buildings and say okay I can try to pursue that I think that will be a lot of points so let me break down the actions and buildings that I would need to eventually lead me to build that large building so I really liked that I think it helped uh pinpoint what you tried to do overall things would change of course during the the course of the game but uh I really like that and then breaking down those large buildings you had the category one buildings that offer General endgame objectives that you're trying to pursue the uh type two buildings were straight you know 10 points he would turn in three glass and a bunch of other different resources for just 10 points which is usually somewhere in the middle between the tier one and tier three buildings and then the tier three buildings were like a mix of a lot of these different actions you had uh buildings that would give you production anytime actions as well as ongoing abilities or you know game end objectives to try to pursue as well and so I really enjoyed the the different spread and I like that you're not playing with all of those as well from game to game it does add that variability that I think a lot of us are trying to chase uh in games like this my favorite buildings of these types the large buildings were the construction yard and the livestock Farm which I think uh in my you know preliminary
thoughts and on strategy I felt like these buildings really followed strategies that you would try to pursue anyway to score well in this game and so I found like when those buildings were out those were very worthy of chasing rather than more so I should say than any of the other buildings which did give you a lot of points but perhaps were going a little too out of the way from what you might normally want to pursue in a game if those if those buildings were not offered in the first place and so the small buildings they like I've said you know they don't have a lot of variability other than the the 10 that are being flipped over to the BS side at the beginning of the game if you're not playing the beginning version of the game itself and so uh once again I I kind of mentioned this too like it's really nice how they're organized each row has a different resource that they're working with and then each column also tells you how much how much glass you would need to use to build them the leftmost column is zero glass and then it goes to one and then two for the rightmost column and so it was pretty easy to uh navigate these buildings when you say uh when you ask yourself okay I need water uh for my on on the the dial that I I need to gain water let me look at that row of three buildings that deal with water okay I can build this one does that fit with my plan or on the other side you would gain glass right you would move your dial gain one or two glass and be like okay now I have one glass I know I can build
at least this column of the middle column of buildings right and so let me take a look at those see how many points they're worth maybe some of these buildings align with other resources that I need for strategy Etc and so while the front loing problem or issue if you think it's an issue while that that uh fact is real and present the organization really does help out it it was very reminiscent actually of uh um A Feast for Odin in the way that each column and row is uh situated and organized uh for the worker placement aspect of that game the buildings were very much organized in a similar fashion which made it a lot more digestible to understand so let's go through some of the small buildings that I I thought were very interesting and potentially could be uh strategy provoking in in what you try to pursue from game to game if if they are available so first is the Fort not having to pay other other people resources when you enter a village including a dummy player if you're playing the two-player game takes a a burden off of your shoulders if you are able to build that building and especially at lower player counts one or two players if you're playing Solo or two players it's very cheap it's worth three points it's it's a very nice building and you don't have to worry about losing resources at all you're just playing glass Road essentially at that point and not having to worry about the worker placement and interaction and so so I I figured even though it's more expensive at higher player accounts that
it would be a Chase Building for for some I think when you you play the game the tenement building is probably one of the easier ways to gain wood and clay and so or bricks and so wood and bricks are pretty much I would say like 90% of the buildings or so require wood and Bricks to build and and they're very hard to come by frankly a lot of the buildings I I'll talk about a few of them but uh the buildings I've looked at the front and backs for wood and brick in particular and they a lot some of them you know like half of them are kind of difficult to do or they would run out pretty quickly I I just feel like comparing this to Glass Road it's a lot easier to come by the resources that you need to build buildings um than it is in Black Forest it just felt so tight I think that's part of the reason why it felt so tight was that it these building resources were hard to come by and so the tenement building is probably one of the easier ways to gain both wood and Bricks at the same time and so that often was a building that I was trying to chase when playing the game the carving wood shop Workshop is another way easy way to get wood and the clock maker uh moving on is an interesting building being able to get some free resources really helps out when you have a like a bunch of resources that jam at that zero spot and and you you know it it feels really daunting to have to work your way and you know build buildings and take actions to free up that that
traffic jam of resources uh when you've utilized them all at the same time and and so having that clock maker really it feels like it really helps to to unjam that situation that you might you know you feel like you're in I'm often feeling that way in glass Road myself where you yeah you just have a ton of resources in the way of producing glass for example and so uh so yeah I I I really like the clock maker the poach Manu facturer is a very interesting building removing the charcoal from the glassw work dial completely during the game is great to easily gain glass you don't have to worry about charcoal slowing you down but it also takes uh charcoal is also a requirement for some of the actions to to take on the main board um you know I I'm looking at the board right now I I don't see it but oh here it is the the tile that lets you spend one charcoal to gain four brick now that's pretty strong and like I mentioned you need brick to build buildings and so um if if you're only if you only have that charcoal on the provision style which in my opinion often is very uh depleted when it comes to the basic Goods because you're constantly wanting to get provisions and move around the board and so it might become a detriment when you don't have that second charcoal uh on the glass wheel to be able to be used for actions like uh getting brick on the main board Etc and so the poach manufacturer does
feel like a sort of double-edged Sword but it's very it's a very interesting concept to take a a resource off of your board completely I really like that you have the bath house you move the traveling Merchant a lot during the game I feel not only to allow yourself to progress the game and gain more Provisions but to utilize the traveling Merchant themselves and so gaining a free water to you know get more glass and and move that production and prevent that that jam of resources in the zero spot for basic Goods is very useful I really enjoyed the bath house the Tannery uh being able to butcher pigs for meat helps you keep up on your Provisions it's one of the main ways to gain meat in in this game other than visiting the spot where you gain meat by uh having pawns out right not only are you utilizing that to Pro you know give you Provisions but you are saving those BS for endgame points as well and so it you know if you are utilizing a strategy where you're gaining bores or sorry pigs and and using them for meat you can save them for you know 10 points which is a laot so I really like the Tannery and it's a great building that kind of hides a little bit of an endgame Chase of you know victory points that may not be as apparent as like the large buildings for example the breeding station is an interesting building it's I felt like it was pretty hard to set up I I tried to chase this building myself to have a lot
of stables you have to have a lot of animals to maximize its effect but if you are able to do so it is worth a lot of points to the point where it's as almost as much points as a large building itself and so this is a great way and and to kind of sum up my strategy thoughts I think going after animals is very strong I think if you are able to build stables and and collect those animals onto those Stables you will gain points at the end of the game a lot of points for that and it also makes certain actions on the main board more efficient and so being able to really get a lot of animals for chasing animals uh you know for the sake of that strategy and for some a lot of additional points actually is is really nice uh three buildings here the irrigation system the Wilderness Hut and the Wildlife Park uh speaking of animals are these are really easy ways to gain Stables other than visiting the or even other landscape tiles if you're pursuing those as well it once again makes main actions more efficient and it really prevents you from having to go to the action the trades person where you turn in wood for a stable right and so once again I think animals are crucial for building a really high base score in this game and so these buildings will help the second to last building is the I haven't used this building yet but if you have water this really seems to open up a lot of flexibility for you to to do
different things in the game the The Farm head trades person is pretty much the only way on the board to gather uh stables for animals right so that's the the trades person that I mentioned before and so yeah if if you have The Distillery I think the uh yeah you have a lot more of that option to to pursue this uh this winning strategy in my opinion and then finally The Village church is pretty reminiscent of The Village Church in glass Road I just wanted to mention that I liked seeing like this building and some of the other buildings that shared the same effect it kind of became I guess nostalgic is as a word to describe it but also just reminiscent of the game that I've been playing a lot of on board game arena and before one of my favorite games of all time and it's just really cool to see some of that overlap with this new game and uh it helps me decide whether I want to try to chase it or not and if if it is like a strategically you know viable strategy to chase some of these buildings that I feel like are or or are not you know viable in glass Road and so uh really cool to see some of these buildings make it come back right okay we finally made it to the concluding thoughts and so almost 45 minutes in and I'm still talking about this game and and just really enjoying this experience so thank you for making it this far if you've listened to everything if you're just jumping to this point that's great too but in any case let's start first of all with a comparison to Glass Road uh I've made many comparisons to it mechanically thus
far but how would I compare it myself in terms of enjoyment and the desire to play uh Black Forest versus glass Road right uh first of all obviously this is a sequel to Glass Road it rumor has it that black forest was in development all the way back in 2012 and it was the it was the base idea that glass Road was taken from is is what I understand and you can kind of see that kind of in a similar pattern to how the development of Patchwork and A Feast for Odin occurred where Patchwork was kind of taken out as a mechanical uh part of A Feast for Odin and made into a game in and of itself which did really well and it spurred into different games as we've seen in the polyomino verse of Rosenberg and so I'm I'm getting the same sense that that's what happened with glass Road and black forest it's really interesting uh it could be interesting in a negative way for some people to say Hey you know this game had was in works you know 12 years ago and it was seemingly scrapped until now until someone else like you perhaps you might think that Tito lawrens came in to fix this game and to resurrect the the ashes of a of a you know scrapped game uh that had potential uh and so some other people you know maybe this game had been worked on perhaps as more of a back burner type of project in the last 12 years and now eventually has been you
know perfected or polished enough to be released in retail and so I I don't know the the inner workings of of this game and and the design and the development of of this design and so you know I I I think it's it's awesome that this game is finally here uh something that has been talked about for so long is finally at our table and so now especially now that this game has come out it came out at a time for me personally where I've really been able to Deep dive glass Road as it's been available for a couple months on board game arena and so the comparisons are very fresh in my mind and and very astute I feel glass road is obviously a quicker game it's limited by four rounds five if you're playing the longer game it is very limited to to the cards that you choose it I mean it utilizes a whole different mechanism to allow for interaction between players among players with with the way that the cards work and so that is very different than what is going on here I think Black Forest is more easily digestible and understandable if you are uh you know understand worker placement and worker movement uh but if you you know if you play Black Forest and then glass Road you see the similarities and vice versa and so for me you know what would I what would I play I in my personal experiences now with how much I can game in person one
you know having glass Road available on board game arena is just a godsend I think that it's allowed me to really appreciate and enjoy the Simplicity and streamlined experience that you have with glass Road and the card play is so unique among Euro games in general that I feel like there is so much you can explore when it comes to understanding your opponent and in addition to understanding the game what makes the game in a vacuum work and so for it being shorter and for it being uh having that interaction you know in lie of the cards uh via the cards I should say that I feel like still makes glass Road a more preferable game to me uh I really did enjoy Black Forest though I really enjoyed the solo experience of it B uh I feel like almost unanimously people enjoyed the solo game of black forest and provided an experience in about an hour or so for me to solve a puzzle and to move around the board you know it utilizes you you pick up the five uh pawns and you move them around as you would in the multiplayer game blocking yourself from taking actions twice over in a certain round and there's also a interesting thing where you mix up the trades people worker you know uh placement tiles Midway through the game as well and so it it rearranges everything and so you have to kind of start over very similar to how you utilize cards and then uh put them aside in the solo version of glass
Road and uh so yeah I I really like the way that you know despite me enjoying glass Road more and more likely bringing it being able to bring it to the table or you know now digitally I still really appreciate how black forest utilizes a similar approach to this Euro game experience of resource wheels and Tableau management and building but with this kind of unique Approach at least to me a unique approach to worker placement but making a dynamic as well having the traveling Merchant move around and switching up some of these tiles was really cool I will address in my personal experience with the dummy player uh I did mention that I've only played this two- player that I did not find that interaction to be very negative at all it served it kind of served for me the the type of interaction that I enjoy in glass road is seen in this two-player version I I I felt the same trying you know trying to get into the mind of my opponent and predict where they might go I didn't execute it very well and so uh many times I would place the dummy player in a in a spot that I thought was really good for my opponent but it ended up being really good for me a couple turns later and so I essentially blocked myself many times and that that didn't turn out well and so I think with more experience within this game I think you'll be able to really understand uh what your opponent is trying to do and and make a better predicted uh movement of that dummy player if you're playing this two-player and then to touch on the game
length as well like I mentioned before it's definitely different than glass Road and a lot of the other Rosenberg titles as well I think a lot of Rosenberg titles big box games of his are longer in general they you know tend to be around 2 hours long uh and that is including a set round structure as well so you know when the game ends after a certain number of rounds or turns and that's not so in Black Forest and so it approaches games like Yokohama and others where there is not a set number of turns that you could take kind of right there is kind of a pseudo timer you might be able to math out exactly how many turns you might have if you don't travel within a same Village and use provisions on every single turn right and so there is a sort of timer and you can kind of gauge how long a game could last but that's not going to be the case from game to game it's not going to be the same exact same from game to game and so that aspect I think does inherently make this game longer and I will say that including the teach I I should mention the game did last about two 2 hours 15 minutes or so at a two-player level so I think to get down to two players with three or four or sorry two hours with three or four players it might take longer or it might take you know more experience with the game to really get it to that point it's going to take longer if you're playing with new players and and so that might
make the game Drag a little bit more and especially with how tight it is it just you know it could it could feel like it's dragging a lot especially at the beginning of the game the job offers and the randomness associated with it felt very it kind of soured some of my experiences I will be honest some of the jobs that came up for opponents of mine came out at the exact right time that they needed it and they had the exact amount of resources that they needed and could utilize it quickly and you know faster than I could uh and and to benefit their own strategy better than I could and it just helped them propel them to Victory if those jumps Wen in place they might have lost to me and and the same as as is flipped I there was another game where I played and got the captain the job that I mentioned before and was able to build a village church for free and those eight points uh helped me beat my opponent if I didn't have that I might have tied or probably lost to this opponent and so those really did make it it made or broke the game and so the I it it kind of didn't feel great in a more deterministic way that I wanted to approach this game at a more strategic level and not having the randomness of the jobs affect me too much I will mention that I did play it incorrectly I should have flipped in a two-player experience you should end up having three jobs total to choose from rather than just two and so I I did
limit myself some options there but I will I will say that it did really you know favor one way or the other uh in a two-player experience rather and it it could be very beneficial or very detrimental to your experience as you do play this game for two hours and build up a an engine and a strategy that you try to deterministically create and Propel Propel yourself towards the endgame objectives that you want to pursue uh you know those those jobs can be very tantalizing but also very helpful and Propel your opponents farther than what you can do do on your own and you're kind of left to catch up or try to pursue another job that perhaps isn't as beneficial but you know you're just hoping for another uh job to pop up and and serve your strategy well so it's very similar to the experience that many have had with holler Tow and if that really did rub you wrong then that might sour your experience with black forest as well then finally um the components yes the the Dual layered resource wheels are warped at least with the printing that I have and many of the printings that uh most other people have uh I think in the United States in in particular and so that really does affect you you can approach it you know put weights on them or just wait for another printing to hopefully fix it so I actually wanted to address this comparison I felt like glass Road Compares more to AA labora than it does to GL or black forest and then then it
does to Glass road so or at labora is a bigger box game than glass road is it's a longer game you have more of a static assortment of buildings to choose from versus glass Road where it's more Dynamic the offerings that you have you have more flexibility to build out your Tableau or just as much flexibility to place you know tiles and cards wherever you want to in or at labora in Black Forest but you can also extend your Tau like you kind of can in or at labora in as compared to Black Road and so there's a little bit of like the that interaction too where you can use other people's buildings uh like you can in laab as well uh where you know you have to spend a resource to and give it to another opponent to be able to use their building in or at labora you can you kind of get that sense when you enter another village with another opponent in Black Forest and so to me that all kind of culminated to an experience that I've had with or at labora now it I prefer black forest over or at labora because or at Labor I'm saying that a lot uh has more of a static you know assortment of buildings and so it's it it feels a little bit more stale in comparison to Glass Road um strategically it probably isn't there's a lot to explore with that game anyway but but black force does feel like it has a little bit more variability from game to game even though it's relatively not as much compared to other Rosenberg games so uh where does Black Forest rank if so glass
uh glass road is more preferred in my opinion than Black Forest is right I think the the jobs and the the the front loading of buildings having uh despite the a little bit of variability amongst the buildings having them all being front loaded just kind of gives me the Vibes of caverna which I think is inferior to agrica in my tastes that's you know obviously not true for for the main majority of folks who play these games but um I I think I do prefer glass Road over black forest but where does Black Forest compare to other uh Rosenberg games so Agricola is my number one glass road is my number two and or a ranburger canal Still Remains my number three I think i' like Randy Burger Canal more because it's it feels a little bit faster because it's only two-player game or solo the buildings come out in a more Dynamic and bite-sized way like it does in glass Road where you can look at you know five buildings or so kind of formulate what ones you want to pursue which ones have good Combos and synthesize well with each other and then throughout the game you're slowly introduced to more buildings and can create more combos that way versus having to have everything out in front of you to explore in Black Forest uh not only does it frontload a lot and and create a lot of you know potential analysis paralysis but you don't get to see different combinations and you know see new buildings come out from game to game you've pretty much seen it all after a few games of black forest and so the the variability I think the replay
the replayability doesn't come from the buildings per se but perhaps from the uh the way that the main board is situated what kind of large buildings come out Etc so so I I think I prefer orani Burger Canal for its replayability preferences over black forest I I normally would have like newford next and I think I would play newford as well over black forest it does feel a little bit shorter a little bit quicker um a little bit more streamlined as well and and with a very similar presentation and the Combos and variations of of buildings and cards that you can play onto your Tableau I think I like that experience a little bit more than black for Forest but you know I think I would then play Black Forest ahead of all the other Rosenberg games I think it's really close between fields of ARA and this game very they feel very similar in terms of uh variability I I I really do like the resource wheel though and keeping track of that in in Black Forest and so I you know I think I like the Aesthetics a little bit more than I do with fields of ARA but that's yet to be determined because of the expansion which I do own and would love to play some more I I do and then from there you know even though I really enjoy holler toow and laav A Feast for Odin Etc I I think these are excellent games caverna is still an excellent game I just I think I if I had to rank him I would I would put Black Forest ahead of them uh
maybe glass it's you know comparison and as a sequel to to Glass Road really does elevate it in my opinion uh it it it doesn't quite reach the same on as it does of like my top three or four Rosenberg games and so um yep so once again you know a few things help it fall short for me it's not the two-player dummy and the interaction that it provides I really like that I think it really comes down to the buildings and the jobs that really make this game just a touch uh too swingy for my tastes but all all that said I love the mechanisms of this game the Aesthetics the art is fantastic and it's something that I I feel like I would want to explore more as a solo game and to you know potentially introduce this to many people and play at a a longer Gathering right I usually would only have time to play glass road but if I do eventually have more time to explore a game and play a game over and over again with a regular group of people black forest I think has the potential to be very replayable you know there's I think the opportunity to create a meta in this game and and really explore that so I'm so glad that this game has finally been released after 12 years of design I'm I'm I think it the weight was well worth it um I give it a nine out of 10 on Board Game Geek for what that's worth and highly recommend it if you do enjoy Rosenberg games so thank you for listening to all of that I've been really working hard on getting this
episode ready and uh and you know visually you know acceptable and uh and hopefully worthy of your time as well on on YouTube and and so thank you for for making it this far and hope you uh consult me uh the next time uh in the next video and and uh appreciate your time now so I'll leave I'll leave it there and uh hope to see you again soon take care