Black Forest ►►► does this "fix" Uwe Rosenberg's Glass Road?
Transcript
hey everybody today on R runs through we are taking a look at Black Forest but before I get going please turn your subtitles on to C on channel so can rules SCH you know what they are and if you just want to hear my final thoughts for how the game plays instead of watching me play there is a link down in the show notes that will jump you directly to the end of this video because my final thoughts are part of this main um run through video instead of being a separate one like I've always done in the past doing a little bit of experiment I'll talk about it more in the final thoughts which you can just skip right to um it'll be I don't know 50 minutes in or something like that just look at the links in the show notes or look at your scrub bar on YouTube but anyway with all that out of the way well then welcome to 13th century Germany where there's a whole multitude of glass Huts being set up in the famous black forest and we've got two of them ourselves right here and here and over the course the game we are going to be trying to build up our infrastructure to make lots of glass and potentially expand our operation I'm going to show you how it works today in two playay run through I the yellow player Jen is the blue player and we've got the game all set up here um each player has two production Wheels one devoted to making glass and one devoted to making Provisions which we need to be able to get around the countryside uh each player starts with three bricks um no glass no potach one coal two water Three Wood over over here on this production wheel if you look
over here we' got two plus one more provision then we've got one meat and two coal and um that's what we're starting out with we also have our own little domain here with three sections of forest two uh fields for growing two ponds for various things a little pasture to hold some cows and our worker and I am the first player so I'm going to be the first one to get out on the board and start producing so let's take a look at the board which was randomly set up uh as part setup there's all these different trades people in all the different towns and every time you set up they're going to be in a different uh constellation of options and what I'm going to do right now is I'm going to pick some place to start and I'm going to activate those two adjoining trades folk and then on future terms I might just stay in the town and continue activ am or I could spend Provisions to travel along the roads to go to other towns and I've got decided what do I want to do right out of the gate well tell you what I want to do right out of the gate I want to build a building I start with some basic resources that I just described and over here you can see a big boatload of different buildings uh we've got four big ones that are randomly chosen every single time you play that are basically just huge sources of points and then we've got an additional 36 of them between these two boards um and uh they give us all kinds of ways
to generate Goods or convert Goods into other Goods or score points or all kinds of things now every time you play uh all of these tiles are flipped face up or face down they're all two-sided so this building could have been the ham seller or it could have been the bar um they both end up on the same space on this board because all the buildings in this row are about generating meat all the ones in this row are about generating pork all the ones in this row are about generating cattle Etc and the leftmost are the cheapest ones they don't require any glass the middle column requires one glass and they're a bit better and then the rightmost column requires two glass to build those and then like I mentioned we have the uh the big ones over here these require three glass and they give us some kind of well they give us points and in some way to score points at the end of the game as well so the setup you've got for all the different buildings uh never mind the setup for all the different sponsors is going to make the game evolve very uniquely every time you play but I do want to start out building buildings definitely and there are three uh trades folks let me do that if I come over here I could chop down one of my Forest generate some Lumber and build and I would combine that with either this one which is hey spend some Lumber to make a pasture or uh just get a field for growing or I'd combine it with this it says says for every two cow for every cow I've got get a porridge or
for every Pig I've got in a forest get a uh Lumber now I don't have any pigs or Forest but but there are other ways to build too if I come over to this one uh it's a choice between either building a building which I want to do right out of the gate so I can start using their special powers or increase my glass production and this is a big thing we're racing to do because every time we make it to the top of this track we get to expand our domain with a new estate which can be a source of points and a way to really ramp up our our overall um economy so if I were to come over here I could combine that with this this is the traveling salesman who says hey take any two resources you want and all other players get one of those resources or I can come over here and combine it with this one that says hey um spend that's what the red outline means spend a water and a porridge to get a cow and a pig or spend a brick and a water to get a cow or a pig and then thirdly if I want to build I could come to either of these spaces this is just a simple straightforward build combined with either hey the more pawns I've got the more meat I've got or the more Fields I've got the more porridge I can earn or this one spend a cow or pig to get two or three meat so if I want to build is my first action I've got to place myself next to one of those three and I've got got to be thinking about what else do I want to do and I think I think I've got
a fly I think I'm going to come over here this is my first space and now you only get to place your worker like a worker placement game wherever you want on the first round of the game for the rest of the game this little worker is going to move from town to town or stay within a given town and keep uh activating so this is where I start uh my the beginnings of my my black forest Empire so first of all I could do these two things in either order I'm do this one first I say hey I could get myself two porridge which would be nice or I could because I I start with two fields or I could get myself one meat because I start with two pawns it may sound like I should get uh porridge instead I get two instead of one maybe but I'm actually thinking right now I want that meat so I can see I've got two pawns here in the start so I am going to get one meat and I Mark that on my little production board I already started with one meat now I move this forward you can see it goes to this little spot that says now I've got two meat I've got two coal on this production wheel and two meat I've still got no porridge I've got no um what do you call them Commodities which is what this one is and then I've got one here and two here Provisions so anyway I've got some more meat and there's a reason I want that meat that you're about to see so I've done this now I'm going to do this this says Hey build a building which means I've got to come back over here and think about which of these now remember um all the second and third and you know the big
ones and the fourth they all require glass I don't have any so I'm going to build something in the leftmost column and I'm kind of eyeballing this one down here that you can't actually see because it's off screen um sorry about that this glass furnace although man uh you know this game takes up a lot of table space which means I've had to move my camera really far away from the table and so it's having a hard time Focus let me just go ahead and give you a quick glance at all of the buildings that are available to me in this game and remember it could be a very different combination if these were on their bsides instead of their as sides but anyway just going to give you a quick scroll through them there including the glass furnace that I'm planning on building it's worth two points it requires two bricks and one Lumber to build and it says Hey convert meat into progress on my glass meter and what did I just pick up folks I just picked up some meat so all the things in here are all about making progress on your glass meter or getting glass or getting Provisions all three of those things are very important so anyway that's what I'm going to do I am going to build a glass furnace it requires two bricks which I started with three so there goes two and um it requires one Lumber so I've got three Lumber I move it down here and now I've got two and I got my first building and I've got one two three empty spots I could put in actually if I wanted to I could immediately clear out either of these pawns to put it in those spots or either of these fields to put them in
those spots but there's no reason to do that right now I got plenty of open space I'll just put this glass furnace right here next to my glass hut okay and now this means anytime I want for the rest of the game I I can turn two meat into one progress let's do that right now I will go um boom boom and I start I'm sorry we start down here and I have just now moved up one step I move up two more steps and I will get to expand my domain which is a source of points and more resources and all kinds of things and so I've begun the be the I've made the beginnings of an engine now I probably want to build a building from this row over here because this is the one all these buildings generate meat in different ways and I've got a thing that can take that meat and turn it into progress on my glass right so a a plan is starting to come come into play especially because if you pay attention to the four random um big buildings one of them is the farm store it's very expensive three Glass three bricks three um Lumber five porridge I won't build this for quite a while but it's worth five points plus two additional points for every meat I've got at the end of the game so as you might imagine I probably want to invest in uh you know creating some kind of meat making Technologies although there are ways to make meat out on the main board as well get this thing built before the end of the game use the meat throughout the game to advance my um glass works but then also turn excess meat at the end of
the game into points I think I've got a plan and we'll see how well it comes together okay that's it on your turn you move your meele from one location to another uh do the two actions that are available to you and then we move on to the next player it is Jen's turn and where is she going to go well I'll tell you where she wants to go she wants to go up to this town up here because um this trades person right here is the only way in the game right now that we can create potach get two get a potach for every Pond you've got and remember each of us started with two ponds Jen would like to get some potach because she would like to start making glass because like me she would also like to build some buildings but she doesn't want to start out with a crappy lowle ones she wants to jump to the medium ones but she needs glass for that and to make glass we need potach and that's the only place to go for potach uh and so you'd say oh yeah she can come here or here right and combine it with those two actions here's the problem there's already somebody in that town and this is where the board gets tightened up because if you ever move into a town with another player's meele and I should say when you're playing a two-player game like what I'm demonstrating today there's you know there's me I'm the yellow player there's Jen there's a blue player and then there is a third neutral meeple um that is basically taking up space so if Jen wants to move in that town she has to pay a premium to get in there if she wants to move into this town she has to pay a premium to get in there and she has to pay it to me because I kind of
run this town so she wants to move up here and get that potach so she can start making glass she's got to pay it to the supply because of that neutral player and that neutral player started there u i was the lead player I was the first player I had to pick one of the five towns for it to go to and then Jen CHS the spot as the second player and she's still not happy about that cuz that's where she wants to go now what's the premium she has to pay she would have to give to the red um player or I the supply she would have to give any one basic good and she could do it I mean she's got extra Lumber and water and all that so that she could get that potach really quick and I mean she'd be able to combine that with this one which says Hey chop down trees to get a lot of lumber so she could give one Lumber to get in there knowing she's going to get four back um so she could do that she's just not crazy about it uh but there she does have another option as well down here in this town is the uh traveling salesman uh if you visit this person you get any two basic Goods you want and all other players get one of those basic Goods but you notice there's this thing up here I didn't mention folks there's an extra step that I skipped on my turn here's the handy Dy little player a the game only comes with one of them so you pass it around I guess to say who the current player is but before you do your movement which is what you saw me move in there and then visit one or two adjacent trades people
um or complete a job if I move to a job instead or beg which I should say if you ever are in a spot where hey I can't move someplace to do a thing I want to do and I can't really do the things where I am which is a terrible situation to find yourself in your whole turn can be just to beg which is to say you just kind of get out of the way so you're not blocking any spaces and you get one provision Provisions are the resources you can use to move around from town to town that is a terrible thing you never want to put yourself in a position where you're just having a bag we'll see if that happens to either of us as we start playing but anyway before all of these steps there's this step optionally spend one commodity and what um that comes back to here this says Hey and the first thing you want to do if you want to spend a commodity which is this little blue resource and unfortunately at the beginning of the game you can see here's Jen's board right here we start with zero Commodities we don't have any but if you have a commodity you can make this traveling sales uh uh person move to any spot and swap with the uh trade people over there so you can move over here and then the trade person come over here and maybe you'd want to do that because then hey this space is a place where you can build two buildings at once and it's a great combo or maybe you want to move over here because you want to make this person combine with this person hey this will give me the um that I need to then make the pastures as an example so having Commodities is a way that you can reprogram the board before you make your turn and in the two-player game there's an extra step
when you are spending a commodity to move the uh traveling salesperson around you must you must move the neutral player someplace else as well so that's how you can get them out of the way so it's still a matter of having to pay a resource to get them to move but you also get the benefit of moving this so that's all a possibility so anyway so Jen would like to go up there she'd like to get some potach but remember the other thing about this is there are two ways on the board to get potach right now get two potach because you've got two pawns or visit the traveling salesman who will give you two of any basic good so I think that's what Jen is going to do Jen is going to come right here that is her start and she could do these in either order first of all she will get herself two resources and and those resources will be two potach and this is where the fun comes in folks um one two she has just moved up so now she's got two potach and two um coal she also has one coal over here by the way and some meat you may have noticed this created a gap to the right of this uh spinning wheel and you can see that little arrow this is a mechanism that Designer U Rosenberg has um been doing for years now now ever since um the prequel to this game glass Road this is basically an unofficial sequel to Glass Road it has some of the same ideas but really changes the gameplay up quite a bit but this is an uve Rosenberg um
production wheel system wait was glass Road the first to do it or was or at Labor it might have been or at Labor came out before glass Road I could be wrong about let me know down in the comments folks I I I always lose track anyway though so whenever the rightmost space of the of the arrow becomes empty the your um uh production house immediately produces whether you want it to or not it will do it so this automatically rotates as far as it can without bumping this Arrow or this arrow and what just happened well before it rotated Jen had um oh I'm sorry oops shoot shoot shoot that's porage we're not doing this wheel we're doing this wheel Jen moved two potach up right that's what she want right porge and po they're both kind of yellowy H it mixes me up every time she moved up to poach so we're moving this wheel we're making production over here although if Jen want to she could have given herself two porridge and moved that wheel instead but anyway since we're moving this wheel before we moved it Jen had three Lumber um two potach two water and one coal and no glass but now that this rotates Jen has one glass and she's lost one of all four resources that she needs to create the glass um so now she only has two Lumber One potass and water and no coal so she can't make any more glass until she gets some more coal on hand at w or say she gets three coal somehow at
which point things will rotate again then she's got two glass Etc so this is the Crux of the game figuring out the resources you need to get the basic resources earning them so this production wheel can change so you can get the advanced resources glass over here and over on this one you know getting combinations of meat coal and porridge to be able to get these the Commodities we need to move the uh traveling salesman around and the provisions that we need to be able to move ourselves around so anyway so that was it first of all Jen got herself two potach and hey um because Jen got some potach so did I so this moves one for me and I'm not complaining because now thanks to Jen well I just lost one of each of those resources but now I've got some glass too huzzah okay so anyway so that was Jen activating this now Jenna is going to activate this she could either make one progress on her glass track like you saw me do with my glass furnace or instead she could build and Jen is going to build and what is she G to build um from all 36 different buildings really 40 if you count the big ones but um well now that she's got some glass she could build from the second row and again sorry they're really far away from my camera so I can't quite focus you know what let me go on ahead and give you a glance and add a glance so you can see what all these are too by putting them on my green screen camera here we go and remember again this is just in this game
that I've got this combination of buildings the next time I play it could be a very I mean you'd see some of these but you'd see a lot of these were flipped on the other side so anyway so you could just go on ahead and pause and look through all of those but I need to decide what is Jen going to build from the second column because you can see all of these need one glass plus whatever all of these need two glass and there's a lot of options here I mean it's an overwhelming number of options but the fact that if you can identify a particular type of resource you want you can just kind of limit yourself to um hey just that row and knowing that whatever's to the further right is going to be better right so that kind of helps let me go to tell you a bit more about these you notice they're colorcoded um the blue ones are like the one I gave self are just conversions you can do whenever you feel like it as many times you want the tavern you can see this is a bside um so turn a water and a porridge into two potach hey there's a way to make potach anytime you feel like it uh if you got the water in the porridge then you got to go out somewhere and deal with a trades person it'll give you that water in that porridge so honestly just uh drop it on that I mean Jen can afford that that's pretty tempting but that's what the blue ones are the tan backgrounds these are just one time thing you build a ren Ender it's going to be wor three points at the end of the game it will immediately give you six coal um plus as a one-time thing you can turn a meat into three coal so this could give you nine coal right out of the gate you would be set for coal for I was going to say half the game not half the game but
for a long time and um you know that I mean you need coal on both of your production Wheels both to make glass and to make Provisions so that's a pretty cool one-time benefit and again it's worth three points the orange ones these give you a permanent ability for the rest of the game so that can be a pretty big deal too um you know that uh you know like so whenever you visit the you know this particular trades person just get an extra Co whenever you visit that who is that trades person if we were to look out on the board let me see if I can spot them really quick they're somewhere out there oh it's this one so if you ever visit this trades person who basically says hey bring the the cattle for porridge or bring them um or show your uh you know how how many how much cow do you have get porridge how many pigs do you have get Lumber visiting this person um would also then generate coal for you I guess uh This Is The Herder visiting The Herder for the you know because you got a herder's Hut will give you extra stuff it'll make this a more valuable place to visit so that's nice too but remember Jen's not looking for a level one she's looking for a level two and if I'm honest I think going and put this back there and try not to jaw somewh around to to much I think he's kind of interested in this fort so this cost one glass X is the number of other players we're playing two- player games so X is one so one glass one brick and one Lumber it's worth three points again and no uh Jen
never has to pay resources for the rest of the game to enter a village that's occupado remember Jen wanted to go over there to get her poach but she didn't want to have to pay red she might want to come over here but she doesn't want to have to pay blue she has this for the rest of the game she will never have to pay to move in so um she'll have a lot more freedom of movement basically so that's interesting oh this is interesting one as well sometimes you'll see buildings that have different colors on them so this is saying hey um remember orange is a permanent ability you got for the rest of the game um right place uh you whenever you pay pigs to visit the butcher where is the butcher let's find him oh here's the butcher right there so if you ever visit the butcher uh it says Hey pay a pig to get two meat take the pig um that you would pay for that and put it over here on the Tannery you can have up to five of them at the end of the game you'll get two points so this could be a 10-point tile or this could turn visiting this into 10 points over the course of the game and you can see what it cost to build but anyway that's a you know this is a combination where hey it gives you a permanent power and yellow backgrounds are end of game scoring opportunities so it means uh this is a two for one kind of thing if Jen wanted to visit that and then she'd want to be coming here but guess what to come over here she'd have to pay me to get into town Jen just does not like that she is taking the fort and it's going to cost her her one glass one brick and one Lumber there we go and so Jen has built a level two building
doesn't give her any overall over strategy like me I'm starting to try to build a meat to Glass industry but Jen just wants to have the freedom to never have to pay uh to move around so that will definitely pay off for her over the course of the game plus another nice uh thing it was a fairly Cheap Building to build um right okay so that was Jen's turn it is my turn again and I'm in a bit of a pickle if I want to move down to this town you know first of all it's going to cost me one provision to travel this road and then I'll have to pay Jen to get in it'll cost me one provision to travel that road and I'll have to pay the neutral player to get in now where I already am I could just stay here it won't cost me anything or I could pay two Provisions to skip over this town and move to the next one and start doing stuff over here heck I could pay one provision to take this Backwoods Road and then another one to get all the way over to that town over there so I do not want to have to pay I do not have a fort I don't have a personal soldier who escorts me everywhere in the world and ensures I don't have to pay to get into towns so what do I want to do well I kind of almost want to stay in the town where I'm at at because remember this thing says Hey every time I visit this trades person uh because I've got two pawns I get a meat and remember I want to convert meat into glass product although I need to prer two so maybe I want to go out and get some more pawns uh because if I've got four pawns on my state I can generate two meat every time I visit here and
it's just passive you know I mean it's just if just having the pawns lets me generate the meat that's in stark contrast to the butcher over here who basically says hey if I've got animals I have to spend them to create meat now unfortunately at the beginning of the game I don't have any animals so coming here is not great hey I'd get something out of this but I'd get nothing out of that because I didn't start with any animals now Jen did because Jen was the second player she started with one Pig there's a little reminder up there in the top left corner of the board that the second player starts with a pig the third player starts with uh more stuff and the fourth player starts with even more stuff but I was the first player I don't have any of that thing so I don't want to come here to get one meat and half of another thing uh and then my other option would be to come here and again this does no good for me so this would be a great time that if I had any provisions right I might spend those Provisions to move the uh you know the traveling salesman up here to move this tile out of the way that doesn't do me any good but I don't have any not Provisions I don't have any um Commodities to do that so I think I'm going to leave town but the problem is I gotta pay to get into this town I gotta pay to get into that town so I'm probably going to spend two uh Provisions to travel farther to get to this town or that town over there so what can I do in these towns well comeing over here would get would get me get a cow and either you know or you know depending on which spell I land in
you know get a cow and then spend a coal to get four bricks need bricks for lots of building or uh spend a brick to get a pond folks are you seeing what I'm seeing I'm seeing a nice little combo there I like it I'm not even going to look at this town I want to do that because I'm thinking hey I want to get more pawns on my estate so that uh this space over here will generate more meat so I can make more glass and expand uh my domain right so how am I going to get there well traveling this road would take a provision that one would take a provision and that one that's too let's go on ahead and take the back road I come along here one provision and um I reach this spot where there's nothing here yet now this is ultimately going to be a place where there might be a job which are these tokens over here like the job here later in the game might be um hey if you come here with seven coal you can spend that seven coal to get four bricks one glass um four uh Whata call it Lumber One Pig and one cow that would be huge but we don't have any jobs yet they're going to start they're going to show up on the uh scene a little bit later so I'm moving over here and there's nothing there so I'm not going to stop there but it cost me one provision then it cost me one provision again and I'm going to land right there so it cost me two provision to make this big old Trek which means I got to come back over here uh this has says hey got two Provisions for this token and one provision for this token I'll go on ahead and spend one two and I've made it
to the other side of the world and now I've only got one provision left and if I can make some meat and some porridge then I could get and this is a problem I need to make some meat and porridge because otherwise I'm going to run out of Provisions pretty soon and that'll be scary but I'll worry about that in a bit that's a that's a tomorrow problem because today I'm going to come here I'm going to spend one coal to get four bricks then I'm going to spend one brick to get another Pond I like it I like it a lot so let's do that thing all right so this coal is empty so I'm going to have to spend coal off of this uh so and that gets me four bricks so I go from 1 to 5 and then the other thing was spend one brick to get a pond all righty and I've got two more spaces for it I'll put it right there nice um okay wow I've almost got this area completely filled now remember anytime I want I can remove pawns or fields to make room for other things uh you know and heck maybe I'll just ultimately have six pawns so I could generate uh three meat at a time by filling all those areas in if I have an entire domain uh you know one of my my Estates filled up I might at some point want to build Knight's Manor too which is worth six points minus one um per empty space so uh the knight's Manor wants to see a fully loaded up location so anyway so I did that that was my onesie twz okay cool cool cool and uh I think that's it I am done okay and now it is Jen's turn again and what is Jen
going to do she could stay in this town and do that combo that combo that combo or she can move to that combo that or that one that one or that one okay and uh let's see here H I think Jen's going to spend one of her Provisions all right there we go so she can move this one down to zero or this one down to one okay uh and she's gonna uh beat feet over here um which actually kind of bums her out because if I were still here she wouldn't have to pay to get in so her fort's not actually doing her any good cuz I moved so far away from her and you could argue that's another reason I moved so far away from her because I didn't want her to take advantage of her hey move into my town for free but anyway Jen's going to come over here she's going to do a different take on what I just did um first of all she started with a pig remember so she is going to convert that pig into two meat one two and then she's going to do this one over here and remember I said hey based on the number of Pawns I've got got meat I already have I just got meat off of that or Jen just got so she says Hey for every field you've got get a porridge anden Jen says oh that's nice I have two Fields that's what everybody starts with let's get one two porridge and look what just happened folks Jen uh now is going to automatically produce boom boom and now she is overloaded with Provisions she has six provisions and two Commodities um and she just hit this little token right here and this is here
as a reminder let go ahead and give you a better look at her board everybody has one of these this is a reminder that when you eventually move this production wheel two times you remove this cuz you only redo it once and it's a reminder that jobs have entered the game and it's also a reminder that Jen now gets any one basic resource she wants and what basic resource does she want if she takes a coal over here she'll automatically produce more glass uh but then I me know she'll be at zero on all these things if she takes some porge or some coal she could uh let see what does she want she'll have to think about that but before she decides what she's going to take how about we introduce our first job to the game right so we take the top one off of here it's different than the one I just showed you before it says hey put it in this space and says go to that space wherever this is go go to do this job go to this space spend two provisions and um and by the way Jen has six provisions and uh then you'll get to move up twice on your glass production uh you will produce a forest you will produce a pond you will produce a pasture and you'll produce two fields that is freaking huge I mean neither of us have enough space to take all of this stuff so that's really interesting and like I said it goes into that spot which if you look around on the board is right up there Boop so that is now a place that if we
come down to this town and then spend provision to go that road or instead go that way and that way you can go there and get those huge paydays and now that is first come first serve anybody who wants it um and has two Provisions they're willing to give up and they in their movement there they'll get all of that huge payday and then the job will be gone and they'll end up taking that token off the board and a new one will show up somewhere else on the board now eventually in a two-player game there are going to be two jobs in any given time because once I do my production on my wheel I'll put a second one out there but that is the first one and that uh that tells Jen that I mean she's got enough provision she's got six provision she only has to spend two but the problem is she does not have enough empty space on her board to take advantage of all that so with that in mind what Jen wants to do is she wants to expand her domain as fast as she can because this will give her two more empty spaces um you know her GL when you when you ex when you make make it all the way up up here that means your glass hut has gotten everything it can out of the surrounding area and it moves on to a new place in the Black Forest thereby creating a new place to um house cattle because a farm is set up and then this comes in with more Forest that um you know you can harvest the resources from According to the rule book this is very historically accurate that these um glass Huts moov throughout the forest constantly looking for new places to get
the potach and all that stuff and leaving behind um you know terrain that uh was repurposed into farmhouses so Jen wants to do that so she's got more land so she could take advantage of that job which means she needs to start working her way up that path so how does she do that well over here you can move up one step per coming over here into that town which normally you'd have to pay to get into but Jen doesn't have to pay to get in there giving up three bricks let you move up so I think Jen's got a plan remember because Jen did this she could get anyone she want she's going to take a brick because coming up here she can spend those three bricks and move half of the way towards expanding her environment plus interestingly oh shoot if this were next to this she'd hit both of them she'd top down a forest to get a bunch of lumber and then spend those bricks to move up and so she'd have space you know cleared out that she'd have room to be able to put a another Forest back when she hits that job over there so it's unfortunate those aren't quite but Jen once she gets up there she'll probably stay in that town for a little bit and um you know yeah I think that's her plan in the future now that that job has shown up Jen's uh got her eye on the prize okay and now it is my turn again and what am I going to do well I am down to only one provision I am in trouble uh because remember I talked about this if you
start your turn unable to do you can't stand still you must move either to another spot in the town or pay Provisions to go elsewhere and if you you can't move to a a location unless you're able to do at least one thing at that location so it's possible you get to a spot where oh I can't really move and do things so I have to beg to get a provision so I it cost me a lot to get over there but you know what this is a pretty happening Town remember how I came here and I got four um bricks so I can make more pawns and I want more pawns I think I'm just going to move over here doesn't cost me anything and this is interesting by the way if there if if somebody had been here and IID moved in here I would have had to give that person one item one basic good of my choice I would have had to do that but then once I'm here as long as I stay in the town I don't have to pay once you've paid the fee to get in the gate it just isn't a side want to mention that anyway I don't have to pay I'm just gonna stay right here I'm gonna get myself one cattle I can hold up to two right there in this little pasture and I'm going to give up another brick to get another Pond okay Boop now I've got four pawns and remember I got to get all the way back over here to take advantage of those pawns get the meat I need for glass but there's something else if we look at this trades person there's an option there is pay break to get pawns or for every Pond I've got get some water so now visiting this space if I stay in this town longer lets me get four water at a time and I only have one
water I could you know completely fill up with water the more you fill up with these Goods the more stuff happens over there so that's not bad that's not bad okay that was my turn it is Jen's turn now she is going to pay one provision of which she has many she's got now she's down to five Provisions she is going to what was it going to be yeah she's going to move over here she doesn't have to pay to get into town because her personal Soldier escorts her around she is going to spend all three of her bricks to move up two steps and she's about to expand and this says remember this is what she wanted to do from the beginning of the game visit here she's got two pawns that'll get her or Ian two potach alrighty so Jen gets two more potach so now um you know she's getting closer to be able to having more glass all righty so that was it for her and now it is my turn again and what am I going to do I think I'm going to stay in town and just move right here get myself a second cow and do this again spending another coal so now I'm completely out of coal but I get four more bricks one two three four I am absolutely maxed out on bricks you need bricks to build most all the buildings in the game so bricks are a really important thing but you can use them in other places too like say this location a brick plus water gets you more livestock more livestock means more meat to um you know make more glass in my glass hut Al you can see I'm full up now if I
want to I can anytime I want for free remove these to put even more pawns out there if I have six pawns then I could be making six water and over here I could be making six potach as well so that could be a very effective you know get a ton of resources and then clear the pawns out and do other things who knows but anyway that was that turn it is now Jen's turn and Jen is just going to stay in town and move over here she is going to chop down a forest which means she has one less place to store pigs it's one of the nice uses of forest uh to get four lumber so where is she 1 two 3 four right okay so she's getting close where she can gets more glass she's a little bit of coal now and then she's going to activate this again and uh she's going to get two more poach boom boom so she's happy to stay there just you know saving up for some resources to do other things later now now it is my turn again um and yeah well let's see I don't need bricks anymore now I'm in a problem I have a problem if I want to stay in this town to get a bunch of water right uh because I've got four pawns so I could get four water I've either got to well I I could do this to say hey get some more bricks I'm full I have no more room for bricks or I could do this I could get another cattle but I'm full I've got no more room for cattle I'll have more room for cattle later on once I move this over here I've got room for pigs pigs can stay in the forest but as
much as I want to stay there and take advantage of the town I kind of feel like my time is up there because I could only activate one thing because again folks this game is all about planning and I'm not wondering I'm wondering if I've not done planning as well as I should have I'm wondering if it's time for me to move out and do some other stuff and that means I got a pay Provisions my last one oh I am broke but I can move to an adjacent town now if I move over here I got to pay big I got to pay two people to get into that town I do not like that so I'm going to head south and do that that or that so what am I going to do well I think I would definitely like to chop down a forest to get some Lumber and build another building although I've got a problem I've got no place I can build remember I can clear out these fields whenever I feel like it uh right I only have one Lumber so this would give me a lumber which I could then pay there to get a pasture so I have more room for livestock oh that's nice or I could do this one that says hey for every cow you've got get a porridge I've got two cows so this is suddenly my town to start building up stores of livestock to eventually make it back over here and convert them into meat so I could do more glass although I'm going to need some Provisions to make it over there yikes so that's pretty nice that not too shabby so which of those three do I like I kind of like chopping down another Forest because then I've got more room
for more pawns if I go back up there so what the heck let's go on ahead and do this right here I go first of all I can do these in either order I'm going to chop down a forest from my terrain and that gets me one Lumber okay cool I've got two Lumber but then the other thing is pay one Lumber two one of two choices either get a field for free or pay a lumber to get a pasture that is what I'm going to do I'm going to pay that Lumber and I am going to get a pasture which can hold up to three cows or pigs one or the other you can't mix and match but uh any animals that are here at the end of the game are worth an extra point this could be another source of points for me at the end of the game so that's not nothing what the heck let's just go on ahead and move my cows over there suddenly they're prised cows they're worth two points a piece and now I've got room for um five cows i' I could build all right anyway I'm not done yet all right cuz I did things out of order a little bit let's say I did this one first I got the pasture then I chopped a thing down got the wood back and I'm going to build now I only have one Lumber I got a lot of bricks though some of the buildings you don't need lumber at all you could build them completely out of bricks but I am broke on everything so that kind of limits what my building options are over here although though I do have one glass so is it possible I could build a level two building are there any level two buildings that need only one Lumber because that's all I've got or
alternatively no Lumber um well there's the Tannery which honestly I'd love to do but it needs water and I do not have two water there is the faer which says Hey anytime I want turn three coal into a cattle and it's worth four points and I've got the bricks I got the one Lumber I got the one so I could build that and get another uh you know I'm I'm I'm not doing very well now but I'm setting myself up for success in the future uh let's see any other things all okay for one Lumber I could build the grosser which would be a onetime thing three different res I turned three resources into five porridge I'm so low on I mean that doesn't make much sense right now um but there's also the renderer which I could build do I no I don't have any meat so I can cannot do that one unfortunately oh there's one more way up here for my glass and my three bricks turning meat oh interesting so if I combine the tenement building with the glass furnace then I want to generate meat like crazy and anytime I want I could turn that meat into a glass production or into a combination of bricks and lumber so if I'm setting myself up to be able to get really good at generating meat then I would have well potentially three uses for it glass production more building materials or victory points if I get the farm shop built so that's really
interesting although it doesn't help me now because I'm A Million Miles Away From The Butcher right but that's if I build a level two there are Level ones I could still choose as well let's see uh for instance I could afford the ham seller which says every time I visit the butcher it's only one point but get an extra meat whether I'm butchering cows or pigs wow that's nice uh or I could build the sistern which doesn't need any wood whenever you move to a village uh the village where um the uh where oh what do you know the village I love the village where this one is get to water automatically okay and what else can I build that no I don't have any porridge and I don't have enough water so it's looking like I mean I'm going to build something it's going to be the sistern or oh man I have to admit it's kind of short changing myself now but I think I love this tenement building all righty so there's my one glass that I have thanks to Jen let's not forget and one two three bricks and it's a tenement building and I'll put it right here next to my pasture so so now the cows say oh are you going to feed the people of the tenement building with our flesh to get your build to make them build stuff I just might again my my engine has not paid off yet but I am setting myself up
for success in the future whereas Jen she's just making short-term gains really quick okay what is Jen gonna do I think she's just gonna stay here in town chop down another Forest which gets her another Lumber right yep or no I'm sorry another four lumber although this is kind of a problem this is a bit inefficient Jen only has room for one two more lumber so she's literally throwing two Lumber away uh you know unless before she does this she could get some coal to move the wheel so she has more room for lumber over there she was thinking she was going to do that to get a pig and do this because she wanted to clear out more space so she could then go do that job because she has room to fill all these in but what is she going to do what is she going to do I think she'll do it anyway so it's a bit inefficient she can only take two of the lumber for chopping that down and she gets a pig that she only has this one space she has one Forest left to hold that one Pig so that was it for her and now we are back to me super poor guy who literally can't leave town unless I beg to get some Provisions to start slowly working my way back up there but I don't have to leave town yet I could just jump right there which says Hey chop down another forest and get another Lumber and then build another building and what you know I just made some space to build another building without having to throw any of my pawns or Fields away uh plus the other thing hey for every uh
cattle You' got get some pors let's say I did that first I did that first and I got two pors for having my two cattle so I'm starting to build up some production again to get me some Provisions to get the heck out of here so that's a start um plus some Commodities which would let me move the uh traveling salesperson around but anyway so I've um done that and now I just chopped down a forest I've got room to build more buildings and I've got two Lumber one water uh some porridge what am I going to build I should be able to build oh and I still got a ton of bricks that I made up there so uh this gives me different op options like with two Lumber plus T bricks it's a onetime power um I could build the uh sh Island house which is not worth any points but at the moment I build this if I've got two pastures I immediately get three cattle now I don't quite have that yet I've got one pasture but I'm in the place that I can convert Lumber into P oh whoa I'm in the place that I could all right so if I don't come here and build first if I come here I can get that porridge I can oh yes can I do that yes I can all right so hold on a second I not chopped this down yet I have not gotten that lumber yet I instead of moving here I still get the two porridge and I'm going to spend oh I have to spend one Lumber to get the pasture then when I come over here and chop down I'd only have one Lumber which
would not be enough to build the house I would need two lumber for that no no see it's at this point that I wish I had one commodity to move the traveling salesperson over to me so I could just get two of anything I want all right okay well forget that I'll stick to the original plan chop down the tree get the two Lumber but I won't build that um that shashin house I will oh uh I will build something else because with two Lumber and a bunch of bricks I should have plenty of options I've got four bricks so it's not enough to build the ham Celler anymore I could build a sistern um all right I don't have enough water for that don't have enough lumber for that I only have two Lumber so I'm just scanning for stuff with Lumber I I don't have the or I don't have the glass anymore so all those are denied me yeah I think actually the only one I could build is this sistern which I'm not complaining about there goes the last of my bricks and we talked about this before one point and whenever I move to the village with my favorite location or my second favorite location my favorite is the butcher whenever I visit this I get two water automatically for just going in there and so boom I now have by the way 1 two three four five six points I've built three buildings already whereas Jen has only Built one but Jen is going a very different way than me and um right so what am I gonna do next I don't know i' I I I folks it's getting to the point where I might have to start
begging I've got one more Forest I could chop down and then make another pasture before I go and then I think I might have to beg to get out of here all right but anyway in the meantime it is Jen turn and I think Jen is ready Jen is going to spend one of her copious provisions and travel over to this job where she will spend two Provisions one two and um right so that's that and so she moves up to one two which means we're GNA have to make some room Boop Jen is moving her operation into a new forested area so she got more Forest she could chop down she now has another place to hold cattle these every time you expand your domain you or you with a new estate you get two points all righty so Jen got those two she gets another Forest so a she'll just go ahead and put that Force there she gets two Fields so with X she'll just go ahead and put them here she gets another Pond she'll put it there she gets a pasture she will put it there right next to her other new Farm her farm with the extra pasture right so she got the pasture she got that she got two of those she got right boom so that was huge Jen now um you know with four Fields she can um you
know generate I see oh no this is the one for pawns so now she's got three p which is not quite enough to go to the next level of that but hey she can make more potach now with her pawns and where does she have to go with all these fields to produce uh where is it where is the thing that car oh it's this one down here it's this one that says hey for Jen has four Fields so she can be making four porridge if she comes down and visits that and then oh I don't know Slaughter some animals or um builds a building so that could be in the future but anyway that job is gone a new job has come out it's going to appear sometimes the symbol or this symbol right so what is this this is spend five poach which Jen has five poach to get two um uh Glass three steps on the track and five porridge it goes right here sometimes they'll have an icon for an actual person in which case they'll go on the person itself or I'm sorry you go on the town of the person then going to any of these spaces in that town will let you do it but Jen's got another place to go and send all her potach and generate a bunch of glass moving up two or three steps she will expand and her uh domain again sooner than later so things are going pretty well for Jen um right although to be fair I mean in terms of points Jen's got three four five and nothing for the animals here and I've got three four five six on some level I'm winning but on
another level my complete and total object poverty I am definitely losing uh so anyway it's my turn and if I want to get out of this town I got to pay for Visions which means I'd have to spend a whole turn begging so I'm not ready for that yet I have Lumber so I'm GNA do one more um stop in this town uh to spend a lumber to get another pasture which by the way is another place to store my Mumu cows and and uh right so and then hey for every cow I've got get to porridge so there's one two more porridge or for every Pig I've got in Forest get some Lumber I don't have any pigs I've just got those two cows so I've reached the end of the Rope here folks I've got no more room unless I wanted to eliminate these uh oh I do have one more Forest I could just keep doing this a while longer but I'm running out of buildings I can build I think I might turn I might have to beg to get the heck out of here I was kind of hoping that Jen might visit the wandering traveler to maybe get me some meat or some what's it so that I could automatically get some like I did before but that looks like it's not going to happen so I'm probably have to beg sooner than later but I could squeeze a little bit more out of this town first but what's next folks I'm not
quite sure but I think I'm going to stop right there cuz that should give you a pretty good idea of the flow of black forest and now it's time for final thoughts and folks first of all let me say this has bit of an experiment for almost a decade now I have been uh separating my runthrough from my final thoughts but did you know when I first started back in 2008 I think I did just have one single video and a few years into the history of the rot Channel I split them up because at the time that made it easier for audiences just to see what they wanted to see they want to see the demo of gameplay or did they just want to hear what Jen and I thought hey I'll make them as two separate videos but these days now that YouTube has the built-in chapter system that makes it very very easy just to jump to any particular segment of a video I was recently thinking maybe I should go and combine them back into one so let me know down in the comments folks what do you prefer uh you just want one video where you can just get everything and you can just jump around on the timeline or would you rather have them separated uh like I said a bit of an experiment uh that uh Black Forest is giving me the opportunity to try out with you being the participants so anyway like I said let me know uh the old ways or the new way or even the even older ways what is the best way regardless uh let's now talk about black forest and the interesting thing I should state right out of the gate is this is um the spiritual sequel to one of my favorite uve Rosenberg games of all time in fact I looked it up it's my third highest ranked U Rosenberg game glass Road uh glass road is so amazing it's only supplanted by holler toow and agrica as
my number two and my number one but glass road is better than laav it's better than cver it's better than fields of ARL it's better than Feast for Oden gasp uh glass Road has always been so amazing to me one because it has the gorgeous brilliant absolutely astonishingly wonderful Goods double Goods conversion wheel that has been brought over here in almost exact same way there's a couple of little twists here uh but for the most part this is the good conversions wheel that uve owns and nobody else ever seems to mess with and that's too bad because it's one of my favorite mechanisms and all board gaming so glass Road pretty much had the same setting and the same core uh production methodology but glass roads compared to uh Black Forest half of the game is radically different it first of all black forest is I would say two to three times as long as glass Road one of my favorite things about glass road is it's it's licky split and I can finish a game of that in under a half an hour uh you know once we're when we're in the swing whereas you because it has a fixed uh you know turn structure whereas this one it is a variable length of time and um you know it it depends on how hard and how fast you race towards the end but it this game can go longer and personally Jen and I wait wait I'm comparing the two um right well let's just get right to comparing two because I'm sure there are a lot of folks out there who have played glass Road maybe they love glass Road as much as Jen and I and they're wondering why should I pick up black forest I still have glass Road uh let me tell you why I like glass Road more than black forest and why I like black forest more than glass Road I
appreciate that glass road is easily at least half the length of Black Forest I mean maybe black forest could get quicker if we get better at racing but um you know and to be fair Black Forest even as it is you know unless you got players who are really being ponderous and spending way too much time not um moving their production forward but instead just setting up for stuff later it's still a pretty quick game it's quicker than caverna or you know most of U's big games but um it is still a variable thing and it is twice as long and I love a fast playing game also I very black Road the other half of the game of right okay here's what I produce how do I actually get stuff to produce in this game it's it's a quasi worker placement SL board traversal game which is a mechanism that I've been very fond of in a lot of games I mean ever since I think the first time I really saw it used a good effect in the colonists uh several years ago uh but you know that idea that every round I've got one worker I could just stay in the town where I am and continue trying to Leverage what's there uh and I mean I by the way not for nothing my favorite thing about this game other than the production wheel is of course the fact that wherever you go you're trying to make the best use out of pairs of actions and if you got the resources you can actually pay to reprogram the board to change the actions that are available to you I think this is great I love it um now that's in contrast to Glass road which instead of having any board at all
really uh had players playing cards uh every turn we're all going to play a certain number of action cards we all have the same cards available to us and those action cards give us access to the same types of things over here conversion you know production you know building all that kind of stuff and the interesting thing about glass road is I need to pay attention to what I think you're going to play because I get to piggyback off of what you're doing depending on how the cards play out in a really brilliant system that is all about getting into the head of your opponent Jen and I love that because we love the fact that hey if you've built a certain building I know you want to play a certain card to take advantage of that building so now that helps me make a decision for what cards I'm going to play knowing with a high degree of confidence what you're going to play and that level of passive intuitive um uh prediction interaction between players is something I've Loved ever since the first time I played race for the Galaxy um you know and I me know it's it's really done in a very cool way in glass Road and I should say all of that is gone all of it not a hint of it it has all been replaced with an equally well-designed system a more traditional system of traveling around on a board um you know either you know using the same areas or paying Provisions to move to other towns because hey I got everything I needed now I got to pay to move over here so I can start doing that combo and then I want to jump back and forth between these two for a bit before I move on unless oh I don't know a new job shows up um you know over here in which
case oh I got to pay two Provisions to travel there and there so I can be the first to get over to race over there and score that big thing uh because you can have a really great plan but those jobs popping up here and there if one pops up that's good for you uh and you're closer to it you might want to put your plans on hold because the game can throw um some you know curve balls your way which is very appreciated this is wonderful I absolutely adore this most importantly I absolutely adore that this is a game about trying to combo multiple things next to each other you know um I'm actually thinking of uh last year's last year's plantan nubo which had this same idea that you have a grid of things you put a worker between them and sometimes you can activate both but most the time you only activate a single black forest gets it right you are always getting the opportunity to activate two things in a given town there are four different three or four different combos of things and and I you know it's all randomly set up but then players can modify it over time to suit their needs uh which is an excellent level up over other games I've seen that has done this like plantan nubo or uh Skyrim uh no not Skyrim uh spum is kind of in the same you know because you're putting things out and can you know but I mean I it's really nicely done and actually I I shouldn't go any farther without doing a big uh tip of my cat to uve of course but also his co- designer um whose name is very
tiny on here Tito Loren so Tito I'm very impressed sir I don't know I have no inside knowledge about the development of this but I'm assuming black for primarily led by Tito um uh you know because he saw glass Road said hey how about I take glass Road and take we take half of the game out and to be fair half of the game that a lot of U Rosenberg fans do not like a glass Road sadly is one of U's less well-known titles which is a shame because I love it because it's so different it's so unique it's so unlike anything else uve has ever done before or since I mean heck it it owes more to um Bonanza than Agricola uh and so I've always been a huge fan of glass road but I know a lot of people like no I want a board I want workers I I want a more clear path I don't want to get do all these Mind Games trying to get into the head of my opponents I just want to pick what I'm going to do and figure out the best way to do it and not have to worry about all that stuff well again I don't know but my assumption is Tito said hey I've got another take on glass Road how about I do this really brilliant system of you know multi combo worker placement spaces that effectively you have one worker like say laav but you have to pay Provisions to be able to move the further away uh a space is from where you are the more you have to pay to get to it um again we've seen this in other games but it's done so brilliantly here with these combo spaces that are
just I me know they're like little mini engines of themselves you're building your own conversions engin on your board but then you've got all these little ones that you can reprogram and stuff really nicely done now I don't know maybe Tito just helped out uve I I couldn't say I have not read any designer Diaries probably should but anyway so Tito I am impressed sir them now all that said I'm not going to say improves it for me uh and in fact I love glass Road enough that I'm probably not going to keep black forest and it's going to go to the dice tower West convention Library like all my games do why I got to say folks it breaks my heart to do it and I thought honestly I thought the reason was going to be because of the absolutely absurd amount of overload when you first sit down at the table and you've got 40 different randomly chosen buildings to choose from every time you play 36 small buildings four large buildings and that's a ton I mean Heck if I thought um the caverna setup was much I mean you know black forest says hold my beer and really just drowns you in options I thought that would be a bit overwhelming when I first heard about the game and I was reading the rules but actually it works so nice because generally speaking you have specific Goods you care about and so you don't have to evaluate all 40 buildings you just got to evaluate you know this the three or the six based on what you need right now based on the engine you're trying to build so I think that's actually really nice I I I think it's actually brilliantly done better than I've ever seen it done before quite frankly the way that this grid makes it
so easy to parse because you look at the setup there are going to be every time you play Four big buildings you're going to want to get at least one of these because these could be a big source of points for you at the end of the game but knowing what those how those points will play out means then you've already see right okay if I'm going to need that I'm going to need meat what meat Bill okay well I'm going to probably want that meat building which oh that one's going to need water so that means I'm going to want ponds Etc set you can start right from the get-go based on what your final goal is going to be figuring out what all the inter room steps are and then working them out on this board and on your production Wheels I think all this is done wonderfully best of class better than I would have ever imagined uh and then I love these uh combo moves they're so great they're so satisfying um you know and you know I love the pain that sometimes like I just can't do it I'm exhausted I'll just literally stand in the center of town and B so I can get the provision to go where I need to go um you know sometimes that's literally the best move and you could still win the game even if you beg occasionally you know um anyway though I love all that so why that's one thing folks two-player rules two-player scaling introduces a third neutral player on the board right because there is one tightening element of this game that if I want to move into a town where another player is I've got to pay them to move in and I like that too I like okay sooner or later I mean you just J keeps doing this town back and forth eventually she's going to leave and then I can move in and I don't have to pay her or do I eventually give up and okay I've got enough excess wood I'll just
give her some wood and move in and then she moves out I I love those moments they're delicious they're you know frustrating but um you know but in the best possible yoy kind of way so I love all that what do I not love the fact that in a two-player game there is a third one arbitrarily put somewhere on the board that means you have to pay now honestly I wouldn't mind that so much except for the way that that thing moves the way that moves moves is by players giving up Commodities to do the main thing the Commodities do let you move the traveling salesman around that's cool I mean that is the main mechanism you have to reprogram the board to change engines from one thing to another on the board I think that's brilliant I love the traveling salesman but in a two-player game and it's interesting I don't think this ever actually came up in the main run through but play long enough and it will once you see what it is a player wants to do because actually this gets back to Glass Road the corner Stone of glass road is seeing what buildings a player has built your opponent has built and again I'm mostly talking about a two-player game here at higher player counts this is less impactful but as a two-player game everything is about anticipating what it is your player wants to do based on what they've done in the past that's just good design uve is known for it it's really great here um anyway though um once I figure out that oh you want to go to that town don't you I know you do uh because you've set up you've got three buildings that will kick off a huge amount of bonus stuff if you go to that town well you know what I should do then I should go on ahead and pay one um commodity and move the dummy or the the
neutral player over there just to make you pay to make you bleed to make you suffer just a little bit and you may say ah well that's no big deal it's just one and you're right it is just one but it is still a Cutthroat Act of aggression that I see no purpose for in this game at all and I vehemently hate I am very much reminded of uh the recent series of games from GARP Hill from Sam McDonald and Shem Phillips the uh South Tigers I haven't played the third one yet but I played the first two and both of them feature this very small little thing of uh this idea of influence you can occasionally earn influence tokens and it's a a card drafting game and you put them on cards um that either mean that means if anybody other than you drafts that card they've got to pay a Sur charge they got to pay taxes you tax your opponents and I imagine higher player count game in that game mostly you do that to um protect what it is you want to get it's a defensive measure but in a two-player game it is much more efficient to use it as an offensive measure to say oh you need that card don't you you desperately do well too bad I'm going to put some influence on it so now you got to pay extra money to get that card and that might throw off your entire game and it's just crappy it's just a needless aggression addition to the game just ruined both South Tigers games and this ruins this game for me the first time I could see that oh yeah Jen's going to go there W she's GNA have to pay two
Provisions to make it all the way over there that's going to be and she's oh she's about to get it she's about to get I know she's going to go there right I got enough um provision or not Provisions um Commodities I'm just going to go ahead and block that town and now she's got to pay to get in and again it doesn't break her it's still something you can play around but I feel like a total jerk doing it it but I have to the rules are very clear you must do it if I am using you know spending Commodities to move the traveling salesman because hey I need to Pro I need this over here because I need this to be able to get this stuff to trigger I need the more lumber so that I can do the build so I can build the building I want the rather than move over there to get the building I'll bring it over here and I love this because another thing I didn't mention Hey whenever I do that and move this to get the extra Lum I need so I can combo with the build over in this area all other players get Lum two that's really awesome awesome that's a good uh example of interactivity between players that's positive that's you know you know a feather in its cap but in a two-player game at the same time I do that I am forced to move this and how else am I supposed to do it how else I supposed to make the decision about to where to put that other than to look at my opponent and see boy it would really suck for you if I put it over in that town that is so Central to your overall strategy I guess that's what I'm going to do and I freaking hate it as much as I hate the infl um you know and again I should say all of these are small things in the grand economic scale of the game but they are still Death By A Thousand Cuts you know little paper cuts of oh I I've got
another way I can screw you uh they really hurt in the early game you could force somebody to have to beg um you know as a result of that you know because doesn't they have to go in a different direction because they can't go where they needed to go etc etc it's just spite it's a spiteful move uh and it just does not have a place in what is otherwise a phenomenal design that probably would have made my top 10 games of 2024 quite frankly but because it's here the game is out uh because I've got glass Road and glass road is nothing but positive vibes and um anticipating what other players are going to do so you can piggyback off them as opposed to anti this game now as a two-player game is anticipating what other players can do because there'll be two or three times over the course of the game where it will be my job to WR okay what do you value the most and you know J I got to the point where look okay I could spend three minutes looking at all of your stuff and looking at everything out there so I could understand your strategy to figure out what it is or you could just tell me and like okay just to be efficient because we want the game to move along quickly she'll say well it would really suck if you put it in that town and so okay yeah fine yay I got to mess with you for no good reason it's just I hate it I hate it I hate it and I hate it when designers do this so Tito I still will sing your praises and uve as well but I wish this was gone because here's interesting thing the tra the the SE charge you have to pay is only if you move into a town if the rules are very clear if you move through somebody to get to another town you don't have to pay I think the obvious choice would
have been as an alternative to keep out the take thatness of admitted you know of of of this two-player mode would be hey if you ever need to move through me you got to pay to move through and that will tighten up the board instantly and make it feel like a three-player game because there are plenty of times where you know I if I move into the town with you or through the town and then that would just be perfect the simplest little rule change a rule change that is actually simpler than what they came up with they came up with a more complex thing that also adds a take that element to the game when they could have done it a very very simple way and yes I guess I could just house rule it myself and keep the game but you can go to faq.com if you want to see how I feel about doing house rules I have more than enough games that I don't need to house rule to have a good time so I were that's again go to faq.com I think it's like entry number 23 or something like that hey why don't you do a house rule for this or that because I don't need to because I have glass Road and glass road is still as good as it's ever been and it doesn't have that little prickly oh I'm just G to I'm just going to stab you in the in the back with a letter opener you know kind of a thing and I don't know why that's here and I wish it wasn't here because otherwise this could be one of U's best and again I don't know how much of that is uve I don't know how much that is Tito Tito I'm inclined to give you a real uh lot of you know uh praise but not for this not for that one little thing that ruins an otherwise awesome
potential top 10 of the Year for me but anyway folks that is it that is black forest and I will say thank you very much for watching again let me know in the comments how you feel about having just a single video like this uh because I'm not going to tell you where to go anywhere but there's still stuff on screen that will let you go see other things on the channel so push one of them them um in 5 4 3 2 really the countdown is almost over we're all done here one bye-bye