Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cascadia Review: An Experience as Lovely as the Pacific Northwest

Transcript 10:25

hi everyone tally and farrell here from board of it and welcome to our review of cascadia the new tile laying game we are pretty hot on set in the beautiful north american region of cascadia you'll be drafting animals and habitats in order to create your own breathtaking landscape all the while trying to fulfill weird and wonderful scoring conditions now this is a game that is exceedingly simple to learn but really tough to puzzle out and is great for any level of gamer what's wonderful is the aforementioned scoring cards combined with the randomized animal tokens and landscape tiles to mean that every game is unique and feels different cascadia is for one to four players and it's honestly a sure buy for us so the only question you need to ask is which out of your friends and family is going to make the most harmonious ecosystem in cascadia you have these terrain tiles which have one or more types of terrain on them and on these terrain tiles they will tell you which animals can live there the animals are represented by wooden tokens with an image of each animal on them on your turn you'll have a row of randomly paired tiles and tokens from which you will pick one pair you'll then place your terrain tile

anywhere and in any orientation you like in your already existing environment and then you can place the animal token on any tile as long as it can accommodate that animal placing animal tokens on specific tiles may generate nature tokens you're going to score based on your longest contiguous region of each type of land and on each animal scorecard in every game an animal will have one of its unique scorecards in play and that will tell you how to score using that animal maybe you want to have pairs of bears all over the board or maybe you'll want a really long run of salmon maybe you'll have a fox that wants to be surrounded by a bunch of wonderful unique animals either way the game will last 20 rounds which will be when there'll be no more terrain tiles left to replace the ones you've been taking honestly we straight up love cascadia and it's a delight to play it has a simple core that when combined with the well-designed scoring cards makes this weighty puzzle that you can really sink your teeth into better yet it can appeal to everyone i would happily play this with my family or say to play game after game with tally competitively and if you just you know in general like these puzzle tile lane games then this isn't one to miss as we said a key aspect of this are the scoring cards they're well designed and provide novel and interesting challenges even better the fact that you always include five means that you'll almost

always have new and interesting combinations to deal with what we've usually found is that you'll focus on two to three animals fitting in the others when you can maybe we just need a bit more practice but what this has meant for us is that each game can feel completely different depending what animals you're focusing on because each animal scores completely differently and the scoring cards for each animal further alter the puzzle they're a real cornerstone of what makes this game so engaging and replayable but regarding the scoring cards i do worry that they're confusing and they'll be particularly confusing to the lighter crowd that would really like to see engage with cascadia this is because some of them can be quite complex in what they're asking and the only information given is a single sentence often paired with a maybe unhelpful image i can just honestly see people unboxing this and when they move past the first kind of wave of scoring cards being very confused about what they're being asked to do and what compounds this is in the rule book rather than have a dedicated you know area to give well-designed examples of how these work they cram all information on the scoring cards into one page and really there's not much more information there than it's already on the scoring cards just a few little extra tidbits what really perplexes us is that rather than give space to this crucial information they gave four pages of the rule book to a kind of mini game that i'm not sure many people are going

to engage with you see you have this achievement system where one time each game you can mark off an achievement this lets you mark on a trail on a map and if you get to the end of that trail you win but it's very weirdly in depth and it allows for you to play with five players despite this being a four player max game and i assume this is so you can swap people in and out but if that's the case it's a very weird system considering that obviously the player who owns the game is going to have a massive advantage of playing every single time you play it's a nice idea and it might provide a little bit of extra longevity for some people so props for trying but that said we just can't see that many people really engaging with it as who is really going to play this game 30 times with the same core group also as said why does this get so much detail information and even variants when another area of the game that's so desperately needing more information is crammed into one page at the back of the rulebook changing tact cascadia handles the issues of luck particularly well whilst of course much of the game can be luck based i.e what animal tokens and tile pairings are available and whether those pairings work for you have some really smart systems in place in order to negate luck and allow you to make smart tactical decisions firstly you have four animal token and tile pairing so that should at least give you something to work with and if three out of the four animals are

the same you're allowed to wipe them and redraw new animals next you have the nature tokens and these can be used to choose any animal and tile pairing or allow you to redraw any number of animals these are relatively easy to get and go a long way towards making cascadia always seem fair despite the randomness of what tiles are included and what animals are drawn out of the bag this randomness is what makes the game seem infinitely replayable each animal is seated equally in the bag but of course you won't draw an equal number or even the same animals game to game what's available will push you in different directions game to game and the puzzle of adapting to the different scoring card combinations each time will cause the game to shape up differently the excellent luck negation aside i do have this nagging feeling that luck will be more apparent at higher play counts and if all players were equal it might be the thing that decides the game this is because at two you generally have more access to different animal tokens as less were taken and the state of the middle of the table where you can select from won't change that much between your terms with four players you'll be looking at an entirely different landscape and what i mean is that if you have four players and you all need the same animal and one of you gets it when it's their turn it's not through skill that's complete luck and in a similar vein this game is a pretty

solo game so you're only focused inwards and even if you are keeping an eye on other people's habitats the issue is it's often very hard to tell what they're going for until quite a ways through the game usually by the point it's too late so you can have this issue where if you have four people three of you can look up two-thirds through the game and notice that you've all been going for the same things and then you have this one player in the corner who's just gone for elk and eagles and he's laughing because he doesn't have to fight for every little animal he needs and this isn't a common occurrence but it is something that is worth being aware of and why we'd rather play with lower play accounts but the fact of the matter is this is really an excellent game at any play account and the gameplay doesn't change too much on the more humorous side of things one little quibble we have is with some of the animal terrain pairings like you would think that a salmon would only be allowed to live on the river so it's kind of weird when you have a prairie tile and the only thing that can live there is a salmon it doesn't look very hospitable for the poor salmon based on the artwork we assume that this is to allow more variety in tile placements and to make it that bit more easy with regards to the scoring cards and contiguous tile placements yet it would be nice if this was stated somewhere as these weird little tiles do kind of pull you out of the game as we are speaking about design it's also worth noting that the art is done by beth sobel of

wingspan fame whilst the style is different here it's quite wonderful particularly the animal illustrations on the scoring cards in fact the whole package is lovely from the weighty wooden tokens to the quality of the tiles and the cards it's a really solid proposition for the price point so as a summary this is a game that we'd fully recommend if you are at all interested it's got a lovely theme and it's easy enough at its core to be enjoyed by a wide range of people yeah it's crunchy enough in the puzzle of how to go about the different scoring conditions even fans of heavier games like us are still fully engaged and this game has been a delight to play each and every time and each and every time the puzzle has felt unique not to mention how lovely it looks when laid out on the table although i don't think it films as nice as it looks in person but that has been our review of cascadia a game we 100 recommend and we hope it's been helpful to you if you have any questions please comment and let us know and if you enjoyed this or is in any way helpful we would really appreciate it if you could like and or subscribe and then the dogs will get treats every subscriber oh wow every sub goodbye

Progress saved