- Kickstarter Critique Review
Transcript
Ohoy there, YouTube. I'm back again today for another Kickstarter critique where I take a look at a different Kickstarter tabletop game project every weekday at 1:30 p.m. Eastern Standard Time. And sometimes I actually cover the games that I'm mildly interested in. Today is one of those cases. I was scrolling down through Kickstarter, not looking for the most popular, but looking for something that actually caught my eye. And here we are at the 29th most popular project in all the Kickstarter games right now. That is Fantasy Map Maker from Dupy Games. A cozy. Oh, it's cozy. I wouldn't have clicked. I I don't know if I would have pictured if I would saw the word cozy. I hate when people use that word is so oversaturated in this damn hobby. Uh, a board. It's not a mechanism. A board game of rolling dice and creating worlds. I'm a big fan of cryptographers. Cgraphers heroes. I like that. I've never played the adventures. Hopefully, one day. So, the idea of making maps, I like it. Roll dice, draw features, and fulfill quests as you craft a fantasy world. So, it sounds like a roll in the right map maker. I'd love to know the player length, the time count, and age because I imagine it's going to be solo of to some certain number, and that's a great thing to spotlight. Just fun on Kickstarter. Don't need that. Lots of wasted space here. Definitely feel like the main image could totally be spruced up. How? I'm sure we'll find out as we progress through. I imagine the price is going to be one of the things because this doesn't look like a terribly expensive game.
All right, it's raised $12,000. It is happening. 238, excuse me, 237 people have brought this to life. Maybe with you it's 238.
As always with the video, I'm thinking three things. Do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? Why will this mute? Sorry. Do I want it? Can you do it? How much is it? Uh, let's go. Let's see how they convinced Kickstarter backers from Castle Mine, Australia. Okay.
Dear friend, let me tell you about my latest adventure. The troubles began when our ship was blown off course on the way to the Midland. To make matters worse, we were beset by an unspeakable creature from the depths.
Crash landed at the rugged Isles. Wishing to be as far away from saltwater as possible, we headed inland, yet soon became lost in the deep woods of the desolate forest. Uh, I mean the forsaken forest. There we came across a sneaky troll who showed us the path. Yet by the time we reached the highway road, we realized he had robbed us of our remaining coin. We stayed at late night.
I wish maybe like I feel like this could have been a great video if you actually would have showed what any of this looks like in the game instead of just this theme. But by the way, this theme doesn't really I don't know. Like I guess I don't know. I love the theme, but it's just show me the game. And I know you are kind of, but not really. I feel like this would have been a great shot to to show some meat
being the local inkeeper with our jobs to pay for our lodgings. Then
it's just I feel like a lot of people who have played cgraphers are going to go into this thinking it's it's mechanical. And I guess maybe that's my problem. Maybe I'm going into this thinking this is not going to be much of a storydriven game and you're like no the story is here. I still want to see some mechanics too. night a celestial event passed above which we took as an omen to head east.
Yet the road led to nowhere.
As we trudged a minute thick here.
Uh wait, that wasn't it. Uh as we trudged through a barren wasteland, we thought our days were at an end.
Is this going to be the game you play? Um maps of the capital came into view. We knew we could find a way. I DON'T KNOW. I HAVE seen many things over the past months. Yet my map is still incomplete and there is much more adventuring to be done. So my question is this.
What
will you join me?
What is the gameplay look like?
FANTASY.
HEY. HEY. HOLY CRAP. THAT LOOKS GREAT. THAT LOOKS LIKE CASTLES OF Burgundy had a baby with cgraphers and I'm all for it. Now I want to play your game. That looks okay.
Map Maker is a map drawing board game in which you will create your own unique fantasy world. To play, start by choosing five quests. Then in each round, roll dice to draw features and landmarks as you explore and further develop your map. Once you are finished, tally up your score based on how well you did on your quests. For more of a challenge, add events or try the continent expansion, which combines four sessions of the game into one epic map. Whether playing solo or with a group, Fantasy Map Maker is an engage.
Now, I get it. I completely get what you're going for here. You're not just going for cgraphers. You're going cgraphers plus. But you're going to be making this thing that is so large that it's easily a cool thing that you'll keep from the game. Especially, you know, if you're playing in one of those times, like in one of those games where it's more about the chitchat and the talking and the having fun as opposed to the gameplay, which not to knock that at all, but that looks cool. Especially that four-part map. I'm in. I get the concept. I see what you're doing with it. I love it. I hate the fact it took me two minutes to get here though.
Cuz I'm not buying there being that much theme except for, you know, I don't know,
worldbuing adventure.
Join us on Kickstarter and let the journey begin.
Yeah, I don't think going theme hardcore was the play with this one. It It looks like a much more mechanical game, but granted, it does have that cool it factor that I would spotlight like that like that one picture where you combine the four maps together. was like, "Oh, yeah. Put like the big thing. That was cool." All right. And I think having that image would also like showcase this more to the people who are like, "That looks really awesome. I want to do that." Like as and plus it's a solo game. One plus spotlight that like that. The fact that that's not on the main image that feels like a disservice. Spotlight that 60 minutes also. That that's that's meteor. That's meteor than I was expecting. Fantasy map makers are relaxing. Oh, matt relaxing. Not cozy, but relaxing this time. Uh, dungeon mapmaker and map pack. And then the fantasy mapmaker improved edition and map pack. Okay, so this is a relaunch.
Uh, the second edition, third edition, it looks like this. Okay, let's make sure people got their stuff as always. All right, this one is from last February. Still waiting on the link to the cards. Have only been able about one month ago. About one month ago, they did it. Looks like good customer service. Excellent. I'd love to see an official backside for the cards. Exorcist sharing this great idea. Here's a wellthoughtout response. Kudos. Very nice. That's what I love to see. All right. This one from 24. I'm sure this is fine. It's not allowing me access two months ago. Still not still taking care of it now. Great stuff. Great customer service. Excellent. Excellent. Third point. I'm doing it. I love great customer service. That looks good. Can you do it? Yes. I feel comfortable. Fantasy mapmaker relaxing map drawing board game for more one or more players. Play solo, competitive, multiplayer, or cooperatively. And they include expansion in the continents if your game spice things up with events. Awesome.
Oh, so it adds those extra modes in that. I would have that on the main image potentially too, right? Like people love people love that sort of stuff. More content. Fantasy maps are really fun to draw and to create and explore. And I think this has some really good systems for drawing maps that make sense. Uh, it has a really good system for drawing maps that make sense. Okay. Yeah, I kind of love that quote. I had to chew on it a little bit, but it pretty much saying, "Yeah, it doesn't feel like you're it." I think that's what what that's saying is it doesn't just feel like you're adding Oh, yeah. We got to add a cave in one of these three spots and a mountain here and like it's saying and it makes sense like it. What do players think? All right. 311 great band took it to packs. This is stylish
with other people. I was so
Show me some maps. Show me some maps. I don't know. I just got the people. Cool. Okay, good stuff. Great. That's a great video to start with. And honestly, that doesn't allow the hefty lifting. Do I need a preview as much now? I don't think so. Like, do I need a how to play? Yeah, it's still still very nice. But that like I saw you take it to a convention. You played it with people. They had their thoughts. They had their feedbacks. That's a great video. How to play select five quests that'll be scored at the end of the game. And it also helps with the can you do it? makes me feel comfortable. So, here's the game play. Wish that was way more spotlighted instead of the first minute of that video. The restrictions of the goals and events make the decisions along the way more interesting and fun. Okay. Uh the restrictions of the goals fine, you know, it's it I don't think that uh events are I I just the restrictions of the goals and events make the decisions along the way. No, it's fine. It's a fine quote. difficult interesting decisions because of the constantly changing goals in events. I like it.
Events. It's I don't like it, but it's fine. Events are optional card. I'm so weird. Uh eventual optional cards that could be added during setup. Events are triggered whenever doubles or what. Whatever. Oh, solo playthrough. That's what I care about. Hour 50.
Great. Looks great. Love that. Excellent. Uh for German speakers, check out the rules interview and overview. Awesome. Clickable links all over the place. The game has a continent mode. This was so much fun. I love foraging for an entire world that did uh in Yeah, that's the shot. Like that shot right there needs to be on your main image at least somewhere in the backdrop of like, yeah, check out this cool map we made because as someone who has kids, like that's the kind of thing that if I had one of those that I made with my kids or they made or something, that's gonna be something that I have for a very long time. like your game has the potential to do that to me. Show that on the front, I think. Choose main quest from a selection of six to pursue. Blah blah blah blah blah. Cool stuff. Good things.
Uh the expansion part one. Woo. Solo playthrough. Excellent.
And so that could be
good, good, good. All this stuff is great. Creating the map, challenging my brain away no other game does without it feeling like work. Okay, that I think that's playing towards the cozy. Make it challenging, but it doesn't stress my brain. Um I like having my brain stressed. So, I don't know. Like, I guess that's because I'm I guess I'm weird. Like, I love when I'm really confused and like just so lost in a game that it feels like I'm just I call it swimming in the game. Feel like I'm just swimming in the game trying not to drown. Like, cuz that's what I feel. That's how I feel in the game where it's just like, oh my god, I'm just trying to swim through this and not lose my 67 points. Right. I need All right. Uh let me know what you think about that. Have you Have you ever What game makes you feel that way where you're swimming in the game? Reasons to support Blood on the Clock Tower. I swear that one gets me every time. I have no clue what's going on, but I love it. Reasons to support the game. The number one reason.
Cool. Is to make it. When you finish the session, you just have a score. You have a map you explored and created during the game. That map has personality. It feels like your little world. Yeah, that's what I'm talking about. Love that. Pledge levels fantasy map makers. So, I love Great to know it's 25% off the MSRP. I wish you'd actually show me the price. Make me go over here. That's annoying. Uh cuz if it's if you're on iOS removal, it's that's a whole extra click you got to make. Just put it here. Put it right there in the graphics. So, what's the price? And did we sell it? Well, like I want the continent expansion. I feel like everyone wants that. 157 277. No. Wow. What inarnations? You sold that very poorly. No. No. Okay. Okay. No. No, no, no, no, no. This No. This is for the deluxified.
Sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry, sorry. I thought this was Wait, does this have the expansion? The all-in. No, they both have the expansion. Okay. I thought I thought for a second people weren't buying the expansion, which just blew my mind. No, people are saying I don't need the dice pad and the extra sheets. Yeah. Yeah, that feels very honestly that feels very like 1960s board game kind of thing. We're like, "Yeah, shoot us a shoot us a a a self-addressed envelope to this and we will send you more scoring pads kind of thing." And yeah, it doesn't feel super deluxified. Like I don't need a dice tray. Extra maps. That's nice, but I'll I'll get to that bridge when I cross it. So, but they still got 77. So, I have a hard time grading that one because I don't feel like that's a true deluxification. It's more just like, ah, here's a little extra piece of swag and some extra things you can print off. Um, but 77 is still a nice number. Not going to knock that. So, the price, $42. Oh, man. I'm in. I'd put that on the main image right there. 42 bucks. Especially if you tell me you're including the expansion because this one does. This one. This includes the expansion.
It's just not including 20 of the content. Okay, cool. Sheet. The game sheets. Extra game sheet packs. Oh, there's only 20 in there. Well, I guess that's playing through five times. So, yeah, it doesn't feel like a great number. That feels like the kind of thing where you'd want to have uh stretch goals. Hopefully, they do have stretch goals. Bingo. I'd put that higher. You're funded now. Especially if those stretch goals are going to get me more pieces of paper in there so I can get more cuz uh digital add-ons. Dungeon make mapmaker print and play. I don't know what this Oh, this is from your previous thing. Got it. Dungeon Mapmaker map pack. I would put a little bit more information here like if you want to sell me on it because I was like and then I was like I don't know what this is so I'm I'm over it. Uh because it looks like it's an RPG thing which if you're an RPG person then you're like yeah duh of course it's an RPG thing for us but if you're not you're confused potentially. Fantasy mapmaker is a perfect blend of competitive casual play with the added benefit of having a finished map you can ooh and ah yeah that was cool. Alternate game sheet borders. Why do I want this?
Why do I care? Dice upgrade. Those don't look that upgraded. Dice tray upgrade. Okay. Box upgrade. Absolutely not. Why Why would you bury quest cards under all this? Cuz like you have 47 plus cards. Most factories that manufacture games, they don't have sheets of 52 or 54 when they manufacture. It's going to be like more like 60 to 65. So, they have extra cards. This might already be baked into the cost. But that's the stretch goal I feel like most people are going to want, especially considering you haven't even sold me on these alternate game sheet borders. Does that literally just mean these ones are going to have numbers in the corner? Why do I care? Is it Is it to make it Oh, so you can have like codes or something? I don't know. GIVE ME THE five quest cards that are actually going to add to your game. And if there's not one person who says that in the comments, that tells me your stretch goals are way too far buried.
Also, your stretch goals are way too far buried. Even though like, man, you get stuck. Like, nobody's like, nobody's be like, "Oh, wow. I can't I really hope we get that box." It's Yeah. Yeah. Why do we need a box upgrade? If you want to make a second print run of your game, don't make a fancy box. make it have more content. Wow. And the dice tray upgrade. I understand this one. Like this one I completely understand because that one you get more of that you're making more dice trays. The price of the dice trays goes down, right? And dice trays are not expensive to make as it is. But it's just Yeah. But what is the upgrade? Does it mean everybody gets it? Because then at that point your other pledge kind of sucks, right? Or is it is this one going to have dice get upgrade? I don't think so.
I don't know. I felt like there was definitely a fumble on the stretch goals and this the organization of it like the order of it just feels not great and the positioning of it at the very bottom. I was able to immerse myself in drawing. I literally fell into a meditative flow and before I knew it an hour had passed. Now that one I do believe like this feels like the kind of thing that I can get my wife to play it. She'd really get into it. My my my son who loves to draw. This is more than a game. This could be a very relaxing experience drawing your map. Yeah, I get that. Uh, we got we got a bunch of video dub here. Cool. Wow, that is a that is a hefty video dump. Okay, a lot of videos there. Good thing we shuffled all those all the way to the bottom instead of spreading them out peacemail throughout. Uh, all right.
So, 16 19 doesn't feel great, but it doesn't feel terrible. 58 bucks in and out. That's not bad. Especially considering this feels like one that you're not like if there's only one print run of this ever, which there's not because I think this is like their third. I wouldn't be shocked, right? Like I don't think you would because that's that's what happens to most Kickstarters. That's not an insult. Just most Kickstarters do not get a second print run of their game. And that's fine, right? But like I just I don't I think it looks cool. Oh, what I was I lost my train of thought there. Uh, what I was say what I meant what I was trying to say was if you have a copy of this game and there never is more copies made, I don't think you'd be shocked, which means that you're not like, I can just get it after retail. So, the price feels fine to me. Price feels fine. We got the the custom stuff's there. Let's check out the updates, comments. Give this one a grade. It does look like a fun game, though. Updated, funded, and DMM digital add-ons now available. Just launched yesterday. Awesome. Yeah, get those get those stretch goals higher.
Get people excited about the the fifth the fifth stretch goal. Important elements of the box edition already pre-stretch. These include quality of life upgrades such as large cards, thick paper for the game sheet pad, and game sheet protectors. Then why is this this shouldn't be here then? That should be in the page when you're trying to sell me on it. If it wasn't in there, fantasy maker is now live. All right, cool. 17. No comments. curious. Congrats on getting funded. I'm so happy to be part of your backers. I can't wait to play your game with all my friends. Congrats on getting funded. Also, the extra game sheet pack, the same sheets as in the base game on the campaign page. You mentioned that they may contain extra variants and I was wondering what they were. Yeah, that's a huge difference. Like that's a m like that's extra game content. Good question because this is something I would love to hear feedback from. First, just to clarify, the extra variants are different distribution of features within the feature wheel section of the game sheet. The curve. Okay, so it's not like a huge ground shifting thing, but okay, if you loved this game, it would be different enough. The current plan is to have four variants of the base game and one in the continent expansion, then a different four in the extra game sheet pack and a different one in the extra game sheet packs continent expansion.
However, it may benefit everyone to combine these so that the base game sheet pack contains eight standard game variants, two continent expansion variants, i.e. the extra sheet pack is the same as the base game sheet pack. Whoa, That was a lot. That feels like one of those times that I have sometimes where you talk to someone and then you realize that they're not nearly as invested in the thing that you are invested in and you're like, "Oh, oh, okay. I gotta I got to roll this back about six notches here." Uh, cool. I don't I don't even know what your question was, honestly. And I just read it. This looks cool, but I wish there was a digital version available printed option like there was with that. Yeah, that may This feels like a total print play. Uh, and like not to say in a bad way. I'm just saying this feels like totally one that you could easily have as B. Actually, we're running a sale for the digital version throughout the duration of the campaign in case anyone wanted to get it alongside the pledge. That's interesting. Okay, cool. So, they're literally just taking the game and and bring it to ship print. Okay, thank you.
I process this from drive to RPG. Cool stuff, things final grade. Do I want it? Yeah, I do. I do want it. It looks like a cool game. You have great customer service. I love the basic, you know, gist that I got, which is this looks like castles of Burgundy had a baby with cgraphers combined with you creating your own like real map, which is awesome. Like, I want to play this game. I want to set out colored pencils. As much as I want to say I want to chitchat in between turns, I don't really want to do that because then that's wasting time between other games. But still, there's a lot of people that do. I like it. I like this game. I like the cut of the jig. Do I want it? Can you do it? Yes. Great customer service. Going back to that main image, I really feel like that's a bit of a fumble there. Like a total complete fumble here. Show that OnePlus players, right? Show that low price tag. 42 bucks. Show that cool map that you made because you played the continent expansion, which should be somewhere like, yeah, 42 bucks gets you the continent expansion. Create your own world. Like that. I feel like this co this tagline which once again that tagline nobody's seeing that because it's way too small slash when I get here I'm either going to watch the video or I'm going to scroll down. So and then the minute the first minute of the video god like there's I forgot how much I hated that video. Like literally the first minute
and 30 20 seconds doing nothing but talking about the theme for a game that at this point I'm like yeah really are you that thematic? And I still feel that way. I didn't I didn't look at this game and be like, "Oh my gosh, I'm going to be picturing the magical adventures that I would have as I as I draw my map." But there's people that will and there's kids that will. And that sounds awesome. And I just I feel like not spotlighting that awesome map or some of this awesome artwork or something was a misplay on that first main image because I think if you got the family crowd in here, like look at all this wasted space. I don't need Yeah. Show me that great 4x4 map where they had all four of those. Color them up. Do that. But can you do it? Yes. How much is it? Feels fine. Kickstarter reasonable. 58 bucks in and out the door for the expansion.
Deluxifi. Definitely fumbled on that. Uh it just doesn't feel deluxified. And then when we get to the stretch goals, I have more questions. I have more questions and disappointment than excitement, which is never good because you didn't take the time to just put one extra tiny sentence behind each of these alternate game sheet borders. Uh, you know, now you can leave secret codes with your map. Like just just a fluff sentence or two. Oh, dice upgrade. Now we get the custom engrave with the like dice tray upgrade. What is this? Does everyone get it? Do the people who back it get two now? Like that one specifically. If I got your deluxified, which is the pledge that you 10,000% want me to get, I have a question for you. And that's not good. Box upgrade.
First question, why do I care? Second question, why is it a head of quest cards? Like all these things in theory cost Well, except for the the alternate game sheet orders, those probably don't cost money. But all these things in theory cost money. This one also costs money, but it might not like if you were printing on a sheet of 65 cards, which you know that's like so it's like a huge sheet of paper and then they cut out 65 cards of that, right? Then they organize it or whatever the number be 60 65 roughly in that area. This if this might actually and this is I worked for a manufacturer. I used to say this all the time. You have six extra cards. I would highly recommend you always use these six extra cards. Use them as player reference cards. Use them uh use them as advertisement for future games. Use them as a a who won the game card. anything, Assai is better than nothing. And it just blows my mind that they're so far down and just so woefully there like also I don't feel like the spotlight of the game great like how it's actually played but
no. Uh final grade is mixed bag. I'm going to go with a I'm going to go with a C. I feel like I really am excited about this game and I'd love to play it and I'm the target market for the game, but I still don't feel like you did a great job. I feel like it's more, oh, I love the basic concept you have and the fact that your map looks like Castles of Burgundy immediately gets me a billion times more excited. Like, I like the idea of making a map and taking the time to do it. There was another one that that I enjoyed oh so long ago about making maps, too. Like the guild halls explorers or something something or other. Um, but yeah, Fantasy Mmaker. I'm going to go with C, right in the middle. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Fantasy Maker. Enjoying the Kickstarter content, please be sure to click on that subscribe button down below or consider supporting the Patreon for a dollar a month as that really does help me out an awful lot. Have yourself a good one. Bye-bye.