Dead Reckoning: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for Dead Reckoning, which is John D. Clair's newest uh card crafting game. So, if you're familiar with uh Mystic Vale or Edge of Darkness, uh it's in that similar vein. I think he also did Have you guys played Thunderstone? Seen it, haven't played it. Okay. Uh that that doesn't have a card crafting um but John D. Clair is like the card guy. Like all of his games have a [ __ ] ton of cards. Uh so, a lot of variety. Uh and this one was one that was high on my anticipated list for 2022. Um because pirate games, at least in-depth pirate games, there's not a lot of them um that I'm familiar with anyway. Uh but there's a lot of like little ones or very simple just oh, it's a pirate theme, but you don't really do piraty things.
Right. And I think this game encapsulates uh the theme very well uh while also being pretty Euro. Like this is a a pretty solid Euro game with a few elements of Ameritrash. It does a pretty pretty good uh blend of of the two. Uh for me, I think this game is great. Like I've enjoyed besides my solo uh I didn't I didn't like the solo variant, but my multiplayer run-throughs of the game I've enjoyed because it opens up so many avenues of just different ways to play that for me feel very balanced between um all of them. So, uh that's my quick two cents. Uh what do you guys think of Dead Reckoning? Go ahead.
I enjoyed it quite a bit. Um kind of like uh you said, I like pirate theme, but there aren't what I call just that meaty pirate game where I feel like oh, I can just go and be a pirate. Right. Um I will say that uh I like the exploration. You know, the islands aren't you know, known. Um Mhm. The upgrades kind of cool way to do it. I went fairly heavy in my upgrades on my ships. Yeah. Um and I had quite a few that already have like at least two if not three upgrades on a single card. Right. Um which I liked. Which is definitely a a heavy strategy you can do. And I mean just like both sides of the same coin. How many did you have? 10? 10 to I had four.
Right. Uh and and I felt like I did just as well. Like if you get the right upgrades In the for your strategy, then it's like okay. You get a sweet card. So, I mean this person alone was producing nine barrels. And it's not even upgraded. Ew. Right. Two, three, four. Yeah, gross. Yeah. And I mean I was like, okay. Like I was one barrel short from getting the 12 with just this card. Mhm. Yeah, that's And what was in my hand. Right. And I was like, man, I could almost just get that achievement in one turn. Yeah. With no real work behind it. Right. I mean, you can go heavy it just with that card alone. Right. Um allows you to just go and buy a bunch more advancements. And I like the fact that they restrict you where it's like you only buy two. Um and if you want more, you can go fight.
And if you win, then that's how you can get more advancements in that turn. Uh but you're limited to where they get slotted. Like if you want a specific card on a a specific advancement on a specific card, you have to play that card. Meaning you're not going to get that upgrade um for a little bit. And if you happen to have the card like for this one, it just happens that the two upgrades I put on it, I had the card in my hand so I could upgrade it. Cuz if it was still in my deck, I couldn't hold both of these cards to upgrade it. Right. Exactly. Um and then the other cool thing, and this is similar to like kind of all his card crafting. Not Mystic Vale so much, but Edge of Darkness has the fantasy thing where it's like, "Oh, like you have a gunner, so thematically you're going to make your gunner combat heavy."
Right. Uh, but you don't have to. Like you can like this ability right here just for each cannon he can place influence. So my gunner could be my control guy. Right. Uh, and then I made uh, I made my crew, which is this was the first time I leveled up my crew to level four. I made I just wanted additional movement. Right. Cuz my initial strategy was it wasn't so much I wasn't trying to end the game early, but I was like, "I want to produce." I was like, "I don't want to fight anyone. I want to see how well a level four purser works." Right. Uh, cuz I'd never done that before. And so I needed fast movement. Um, and then uh, so I could get to my islands, produce them, pick them up, and head back. I wanted kind of just go Go in and out. Right. And and it ended up working out quite a bit, feeling very satisfying. The one time you guys you [ __ ] with me over here. Uh, which was intentional cuz I'm like there's no I can't get them both.
Which one do I care about more? This one. Okay. Right. Um, but uh, getting a little ahead of ourselves. Brett, what do you think I thought of reckoning. Okay, this is my second time playing. Um, and the first time playing my impression was if I like this sort of game, I would really really like this game. Yeah. I would recognize all of the positives about it. And that was a four player four hour game. Yeah. It was it was very long rough. Yeah, all of us were learning right. but to be fair, we played it for four hours, never noticed that it was actually taking that long. True. Because all the time you're still plotting and you're not just waiting for your turn. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You're sitting there and like that's one they did they did two things. Just ease of uh, like just ease of play. One, I love these discs. This is so simple.
Yes. Yeah. to be like, this is where all it goes, this is that. Instead of So you're not Oh, hey, can you hand me my like, you don't have any of that. It's all hands-off cuz it's all in front of you. And then like you said, the leveling up system, you don't have to level up at the end of your turn. You can draw your hand, and the only thing you can level up are the cards you drew. So you're like, okay, please draw my buccaneer. Okay. Oh, wait. He just did that. All right. Oh, he picked up that card. That's going to have him attack me. Looks like I'm leveling up my gunner. But anyway, keep going. No, I mean, but the complexity of options, the limitations of abilities, you know, having to balance all this stuff out, you know, I don't enjoy that mechanically, but I totally see the genius and the the smoothness Mhm.
that this incorporates everything. And on top of all of that, it is except with with a couple of exceptions that I'm sure will come up soon. Mhm. It is very thematic as far as, you know, the main thing that we're trying to do is collect resources, money in particular. Right. Right. But the ability to attack some of the merchants, Yes. to attack each other, and you score points, but it's also not guaranteed you're going to come out well, or you both could benefit. Yeah. Or you both can sink. Yes. Right. It's like we do we No one has any damage. We all land in like the twos, and it's like Surprisingly Surprisingly realistic within a game system. Right. to to have all that. And that's making it too weird because the what this game so closely relates to is Fantasy Flight's Merchants and Marauders. And that one is That's the Ameritrash. You want the die rolling of combat. You want the weird fiddly rules.
Similar in the sense that you could be a merchant the entire It's like Zaya. You played Zaya. Yeah. Similar kind of concept of pirates where it's like, I don't want to attack any of you. I just want to get my goods, and I want to go to that location and sell and make money. You can do that in Merchants. And I didn't in two games. Two full full games I played, I have never attacked anyone. No, I guess you haven't. And I No, you liar. You attacked me. I tried to. I couldn't. At the end of this one? No, I thought you attacked me at the very first one. Yes, because I fought I I went back and fought you. Okay. Um Maybe. Yeah. But okay. But I have unlimited fighting. Yeah, I don't think I've ever attacked a merchant rather than That I don't think you've done. But I think you were I think you Which may be why I've lost both times. Uh I don't know. Because because the combat system you you can certainly benefit from in resources.
Yeah. Right. So, I Oh, sorry, go ahead. No, that's Um so, yeah, let's let's talk about negatives of the game, which for me I actually I don't have many if any and I'd be kind of nitpicking. But the elephant in the room for this game is going to be combat. So, let's go ahead and talk about combat. Um which is he I I guess I can't really say John Clair likes uh dice or cube towers because I as far as I know he he has one in Edge of Darkness and he has one in here. Um but this is one I think after our first game Brett's like, "I'm amazed you like this." Cuz I love the combat in this. I think it's so much fun. But you would think that in a strategy game I would hate it because you have no outcome.
Uh you have no guarantee on any outcome. You could have all you could throw all your dice in there and lose to one person who has one cube. Right. Um and that I can definitely see that where it would be very frustrating. Here's why I think combat doesn't bug me as much as it would in some other games. Because when you lose, it's not that bad. Right. Like you you could lose. Hell, you could even sink and be like, "Oh, okay. I still got eight cargo from that." You know? Um That was Go ahead. lost to me. Well, I sunk one time. I think I'm the only one that sunk in this. Yeah, and it was I don't think I care. Right. Um, because it is so random, at least for me, I don't get it in my head that I should win this.
Right. Uh, versus other strategy games or where I'm like where I'm planning what I want to do and and then I I have random chance decide. Um, that's where it bugs me. Like in games like War of the Ring where you roll your dice first and those are the actions you get to take versus here are the actions you can do and let's hope the dice let you do them. Yeah. That's that's where where I think the random is starts to bug me. But here it's just like it might just be the whimsy of the dice tower where it's like, "Ooh, how are they going to fall?" Right. Uh, but of course the more cannons you have, the more battle abilities, uh, the likelihood of you winning is higher. Or benefiting. Or benefiting where it's like, um, it's like, "Shit. Okay, well, I didn't win, but I sunk you and you took four damage and I'm getting five coins out of this. So, all right."
Uh, or when you fight a merchant, it's not an all or nothing. It's like, "Oh, you fought it. That sucks to suck. It's a heavy armored one. Uh, six cubes versus your two and uh, yeah, it won and you get nothing out of it." No, I think he he really made it where it's like, "Yeah, I lost. I'm taking damage. Not a lot of ways to heal, but I get to level up a card." Right. Um, and that would actually end up being the way I got my fourth level up. Right. Not intentional, but I was like, "Oh, there's a level three in there. Okay, well, here's my fourth one or here's my third one." Uh, what do you guys think of combat? So, I'm kind of with you. Like, you know, you were telling me today like anything I would like to combat. I said that would be the one thing that would probably make you not like it. Yeah. I kind of like the combat. I mean, again, like you stated, losing isn't always the worst thing ever.
Mhm. Um you're gaining something out of it no matter what at the end of the day. Yeah. Um If you sink, at least you get to keep cargo. Right. Um merchant ships, yes, it's better to beat them, but at the end of the day, you're gaining something out of them every time you lose. Yeah. I want to say I think losing is always the same. Like I think it is always level up a card. Yeah, I'm trying to remember if the level six one that I had was that Uh I think it's usually just the weaker the ship, the the less damage you take, but it is always level up a card. Yep, level up a card. Okay. Yep. Uh but the rewards of winning can be really good. Right. Uh and I like that. I like the fact that with merchants, you can be like That's a really good like Right.
viability that I can just trade with them. basically, winning that heavy armored one gave me another fully upgraded buccaneer. Oh, yeah. Dang. Yeah, that's gross. Um But it was late in the game, so I wasn't I didn't draw it. It would have should have been my next draw. And then I should have had both the deckhand and the buccaneer with at this point six sails just between the two of them. I could have gone and taken two of your sections instantaneously. Yeah. And that And that was one of the things that I started realizing was I don't have a lot of advancements. I have these four islands Right. that no one has taken for me, which is surprising. So, I need to end the game quick cuz I I Like I at this point, you guys are technically better off in terms of piracy. I just like I just need to end it.
have the money. Like I have the I have the purser. Right. Like he's he's what's helping me out here. Right. Um Brett, what do you think of combat? Um I don't know. I really didn't participate. From from a distance. You guys look like you're having fun. No, I mean, I like uh I like the overall system. Um it's it's again really weird with the rest of this to have like a dice throwing or a cube throwing tournament interrupting it, but it's just a quick thing and it's over. Yeah, and that's the other thing. In Merchants & Marauders, the combat is dice and then you actually will roll I think they're six-sided dice. It's been a while since I played it. But it's six-sided dice and your mast, your hole, your cannons, all of them are a die value. Mhm. Uh and each can pull a certain number. They all have like their own, you know, rules and combat in that is very meticulous.
Yep. Uh and here it's just, "Okay, you're rolling six, I'm rolling five. All right, just throw them in there." And "Okay." Yep, it's just so quick unless people and then you go back and forth on battle abilities, which never really came up in the in the run-through because Right. no one upgraded their gunner to a higher level. Like cuz the gunner at a level three gives you the um two extra drop two cubes. Yep. And not a whole lot of battle abilities came out. Right. Again, it might have been a four-player game that we had a little more combat going on, more contention for space and resources. Um well, the the space is always 12 islands or 12 here, but more people buying therefore more cards are coming out. Right. So yeah, that that could be a reason. It could also just be there's a lot of advancements in here.
So Right. Uh I mean, hell, even one one of these they're actually they're all at the bottom, but battle ability getting crown. I know. You just get it get a point. And I like that. I also like the fact that it's not who sinks who or who deals more damage to who. It's yeah, you messed me up. I am I almost sunk, but I got the three crowns, so I win. Right. And you've been almost sunk the whole game. I know. Like I had to start How do I repair that? I need to get a crew to level four, but man, if you can get all your crew members to level four, you're just like, "Yeah, okay. Just throw caution to the wind." Right, and you just go fight. You just go fight, and as long as you don't actually sink, then you're just like Cuz you couldn't even hold on to them, and I love the free-flowing nature of the main phase.
Yes, love it. I Cuz it it just opens up so much. You can have your three crew, and if you get the cards that let you draw more and a higher hand size, then you can be like, "All right, I'm going to move, attack. Okay, I I got messed up. Crew, heal it. Boom." And it's all gone. "Oh, let's go fight again." Right. I Actually, I'm going to move there, I'm going to buy that, then I'm going to actually take that island from you, then I'm going to move over here and fight that merchant, then I'm going to move over there and fight you. Like, you can just do so much without it being like everyone going Is it my turn yet? Yeah. Right. So, I know it was funny cuz I was talking about negatives, and then we turned it into positives, um but I So, any negatives from you guys?
Um the idea that there are merchants and at least the way they get dealt out this time, but I think the majority of merchants you can't attack kind of goes against the piracy theme. It's like, they're protected. Right. And that's just a weird idea. Mechanically, it works much these these advancements, like that there are specific merchant ships. Yeah, um I know in Merchants and Marauders, there are specific I Yeah, like neutral ships that come out, and they're not always out, but you can only go and attack them. You can't just attack nothing. Right. I Yeah, I don't know what the I think they the advancements are thematically supposed to represent your crew experience. Yeah. Not merchants themselves, as them getting better for being out on the high seas, and then the merchant cards are actual merchants.
Right. I So, I I've never found that quite weird, but to tie into that, I think a negative can be, which happened multiple times I think for you guys. It didn't affect me cuz I wasn't attacking anyone, but you can stall out. Like this board can be of I mean what, 12 advancements and none of us wanted them. Right. you have in a three-player game, when you have someone who isn't buying any that relies on you guys to then buy them to then hopefully get some merchants out. Right. Um cuz if you don't want to go pirate mode and attack another player, then to get that advancement or that that achievement, you have to be merchants. And if they're not coming out, then it's like cuz you you had two over there and then it's like, well, I guess I can't get that unless now I have to start fighting someone.
Yeah. And that could be annoying when you're like so I wish there was a way to kind of mill like the cards out maybe. Yeah, well, most many games um that have this kind of a card drafting, at the end of a round, all of those get swept away or all of them get reduced in cost. Right. Get more attractive. So I could see wipe them all out, redeal them all Yeah. That would be so tedious. Well, each round, not each person not each turn necessarily. Oh, I see. each round. I get that and to me I see that cuz you could get stalled out, but I actually kind of like the fact that it's clean and there's no real upkeep between rounds. Sure. Um No, there's yeah, there's like none. Cuz that's where like to me and the higher-tiered Euro games is when I have no upkeep in a Euro Okay.
Um Yeah, it's everyone's turn cuz everyone when everyone knows how to play this game, like in our four-player game, it was like it was constant reminders, okay, Justin, you need now you have to decide if you want to go to pirates. So so we all understood how the game was working. Right. But this one it was just like boom boom boom boom. Right. Like, oh, here's my turn cuz you know what you're doing on your next turn. Like, oh, is anyone going to do anything? Oh, okay, he took that island from me. Well, that kind of throws a wrench in my plans. Okay. Right. Uh I could do this, I could do this, but I need one more sale. Oh, I just upgrade that person. Yep. And then I got it. Yeah. But I will agree, the fact that there's no like pay two coins to get rid of a upgrade in one spot. Yeah. You know. On your turn. Yeah, that and that is there is nothing like coins do nothing for you except be points.
And take up space in your cargo. up space. Uh so, yeah, it would be nice if like cuz if at the end Kind of once you get the 12, like once I did that and I wasn't getting advancements, I was like why the [ __ ] do I do with cargo? Especially when you have like the crew upgrades, you don't need to spend it to fix anything. Yeah. And those type of things then that Then you just kind of hoard it. So, it would be nice if it could be like instead of coins maybe you just maybe like whatever double it if you really want to make it like more worth for it, double what that is to wipe it. Right. Um that would be a lot because the level four is it would be eight just to get rid of it and Right. And you gain you lose nothing from buying it cuz it's going to be at least a point maybe potentially a point at the end of the game. Right.
But that could be very annoying when you're like, "Well, I don't I don't have the cards to be able to attack someone. Yeah. So, I can't attack any merchants." Especially like the like Brett wasn't going to go fight people. So, having two pirate flags out there to go fight other players kind of burned two spots that you don't want. Yeah. Oh. Yeah, oh yeah. Yeah, exactly. I mean, I almost bought one, but I saw the game was kind of getting close to the end. I was like I think I just hold on and see if I can get enough to get to that 12 just to get that next upgrade just to be there. Right. And it does throw a wrench in things if you're trying to be thematic in some way. If you're like, "I want to try this strategy. I don't want to attack a single person. I want to be a merchant. They don't attack people. They defend if they're being attacked.
Right. So, let's try that. Uh and then everyone else is like But then I mean the other side of that argument is well then you just don't do that achievement. You you're omitting that one. Those last two really are not happening. Right. So if you're going the other way, which in this case the only reason I have a keyword in that last one was because I ended up winning in that final fight. But yeah, explore and then yeah, I kind of did the the two merchant ones. Um I mean explore is kind of a merchant one, too. It is and this one is always in all the games I've played this is the first one everyone's going for. Yep. Like just naturally because you want the better tier advancements.
And there's limited. No not everyone can achieve it. Exactly. Jump on it fast. Hell even I was very surprised cuz Brett even mentioned it and I was like that's my strategy cuz he was like well I'm so far behind I can't He couldn't win it because there was one left. And but he didn't do it and you had like seven movement. I thought you were just going to go and snipe it. And I'm like this close to deciding both like it I could but it doesn't play into what I actually want to accomplish. Mhm. And it's the hate drafting of it. But I So I saw it and I was like I could. Yeah. And I frankly would have but I didn't have the sales to get there. Right. Oh yeah, see I didn't I wasn't counting your sales cuz you had mentioned no okay, I have to focus on what I want to do so then I was like okay, I got to survive through Zach's turn and then I was like maybe he won't have the sales cuz you were at four at the time. And I was like maybe you won't have the sales and you're like yeah, I got six and I'm like okay. Well Cuz you might just do it.
Like there's that triple out here and I saw I thought you were going to get it cuz you had the cards and I was like I was like I am getting that triple sale. Like that is my entire goal for uh to get that triple sale. looking at it, but uh and I I didn't have quite the sales. I had the ways to get the goods, but then I have was like, "Well, I need to backtrack and then I don't have it." But then you went like down and then you went over there and I was like, "Oh, good. He's not stealing it for me." So, yay. Yeah. But yeah, I mean that's a very valid strategy. I wouldn't have been upset because I mean that's five points. Right. Like which ended up being the difference of of the score. And it would give me enough time to start fighting the actual people. Mhm. You would have had to achieve another goal to end it. Yes, and I had none of those. Literally I Well, no no, that's not true.
I was close I was That was the one I was actually going for. And that's why whenever I I left the goods here and you took it, I was like, "Oh, perfect cuz I can take it back and that'll be another permanent." Uh and I had the upgrades to just pop there, steal it, go down here, and just get it. So, um cuz I don't know how close you were to getting your fourth. Um So, I'm probably not actually. No, you wouldn't have been able to do this one. So, well, but I was going to go full pirate. You were going for those. So, I could have gone pretty close to these, too. Mhm. Um cuz cuz literally my plan was if I didn't think you were going to win, I was definitely going to take those two pirate sails and I was going to get I had enough cannons on a lot cards. I was like uh I had the boat's miss. I'm going to get double cannons next turn cuz I had the goods for it. I'm going to get double cannons, skip a sail, and let's go to war.
The only sheer defense I had was ending the game in in harbor as well. Yep. Cuz uh my other goal was a lot of points come from area control. Right. In this. Like what I get 22? 10? Yeah, 22 points. Yeah, so I thought about cuz I could have taken this one with the instead of your spot and I thought about it, but I was like I was like, "It's two coins. It's two goods. You don't get those two coins two goods. Mhm. Um, it puts me another brick over there which is another permanent. Um. Yeah, and this one I mean Brett had locked up. Yeah, Brett had I was like I can't fight the fort. Yeah, I will. So. I could boast like there's not enough it's four coins it's not worth it. Yeah. It's not worth trying. Yeah, I mean unless it's so easy to just take in terms of influence cubes.
Right. Um, that trying to steal that I mean you could have fought the fort take it and so trying to battle me over it. Right. Um. But then he could have taken it easily just as easily back and I was like with the fort there it was like for the coinage it wasn't worth it. If it had been this one for nine. The coinage might have been worth fighting a fort for that one. Right. And then just the way these open seas can come out hell I mean getting I mean if if you have I think that's Skull Island but my it's in French for some reason. Right. Um. The I mean if that's next to a few open seas and you have a purser then it's like oh man that just gets me five coins right there. Right. And then because it's just I think the freedom of every turn is so nice. But you bring up for me a negative the open seas.
It's kind of. Or or maybe it's just the overall layout is maybe too random. Yeah. Um, that. Yeah, with the open seas specifically. Yeah. Yeah. And this time there were three of them. That's you know a fourth of the overall board. Uh, right. Is is not capturable producible islands. Right, in. And two of them happen to be next to each other and this one is pointed in a way where it only benefits you. In my solo game all four of these were open seas and I was like okay so those are useless. It it ends up becoming a just a random spot. So I suppose you could reveal during setup if. You can it would have been nice cuz the islands themselves are not tiered in any way but it'd be nice if you like did like almost like a pandemic deck thing where it's like okay in in these first six there's an open sea or and in these six there's another open sea, so you're guaranteed them to be somewhere so they can't get next to each other.
True. Right. But no, you're right. It's I I understand why they did the open seas like that to make certain islands more contentious. Yeah, right. because in all reality, like I was getting three coins off of this one Mhm. Uh and I controlled this one which was giving me two, so that was five coins I was getting on a sweep back through. Yeah. That I'm amazed you guys didn't just try to steal those from me. Well, you tried to steal this one. But but this one um which is easier than this one. Right. Last game we had two diagonal, so that benefited two islands. Yes. Yeah. Significantly. Yeah, I mean, and hell, this one uh just alone would produce a ton. would produce three cargo. Right. But coin. Yeah, the open seas are kind of lame. I like what they do. I like the how they produce extra and hell, you get an office. If I I thought about upgrading my least if they were all pointed in all four directions.
Yeah. Yeah, that one was kind of doing nothing. Yeah, I mean, and that one I mean, the open seas where they were just didn't didn't point to the well. Mhm. But I thought about upgrading my first mate and being like, well, let me get an office on that one, so that's going to give me four coins you know, just on its own. Uh and but once again, it's it's weird because to be super efficient, you need this game to be very long. Yeah, of course. Uh for me to be like, okay, I want to go full merchant, I need the seven. That means I need to upgrade my boatswain, uh which I don't want to upgrade my boatswain, so uh I need to hopefully get an achievement that lets me just upgrade. Um so I I This game here's another negative. It says it's 120 minutes. Ours actually ended up being um you know, an hour and a half, which I felt like it a was a pretty good time.
Um but honestly I almost feel like you're just you're right there. You're just you're on the cusp of making a really good crew. But the game ends. Yep. So you're like, well, I couldn't be the the badass pirate. I couldn't be the most glorious merchant. Mhm. Um just because Or a hell of a middler. Yeah, just right mid game. Yeah, jack-of-all-trades. I'll say I feel like that in a lot of Euro games. True. Yeah. Where you finally get it all kind of the perfect puzzle Mhm. and now it ends. Yeah, that's true. Uh So not a core engine builder. You feel like you're building an engine but you never really finish it. Right. Right. Because what's interesting, Edge of Darkness, we'll have to play at some point because it's a deck it's the same card drafting thing uh but you got you share a deck almost because your cards that you build go into a river. And people can take those cards but they have to pay you to use them. And so if it's tiered, like if you have it like like your highest card, like I could use that but I have to pay you a coin for each ability I want to use. And when I discard it, it goes to you. So you're guaranteed to use your cards but other people can use them.
Right. And I think that's that's a very cool take on deck building. It is. And this one is more your Mystic Vale where these are your cards. You're only going to get to use your cards. They build off of each other. But yeah, like I too I think the boatswain is the is really the hang-up. Like I don't get why he needs to be level three to get Right. a a basic upgrade. He needs to be level two. Right. Uh to get a basic. And hell, if he if he wants that gap then what he could have done as level two, you get a basic, level four is when you can start building advanced. Right. Uh or if he wants them to be cuz everyone else kind of becomes well besides your leaving your first mate. Yeah, I mean all of them kind of become something decent. better where it's like your first mate, he can now build three buildings.
Right. Um he can do that ability three times. Your purser is produce on four different islands. Right. Uh but your boatswain is well you can either build a basic or build a a level two. Right. So it would have been better if level two you build a basic, level three you can build an advance, level four you can build both. Right. Um Cuz they only have two possible upgrades. But Oh no, you can upgrade But you can Well you can upgrade your other ones. You can also, you know, put over your upgrades because that's Yeah. Cuz well you kept using the one that you bought a basic and then you got to advance it. Yes. Uh but that's that's an That's that's an achievement is to have four ship upgrades. Oh. Um and hell, I mean it's six points. It's actually the most ex the the the highest one on there.
Pretty much because you have to get your boatswain high and then you're only getting it once per cycle. I mean he Once again, a lot of this is mitigated by how the cards come out, right? In my solo play through there was one where it's instead of discarding this put it to the bottom. Yes. You want to upgrade your ship a [ __ ] ton, you get a level three boatswain or a level four boatswain, put that So now it's going to the bottom. Right. Every single time you use him. Right. Uh now granted, what I also love is you never This is in all of his games, Mystic Vale, Edge of Darkness and this one. You're in most deck building games like the good ones in my opinion are the ones where your deck is lean. Yes. Uh the ones I hate the most are you start out with 12 cards and you end with 50. You're like, "Man, I wish I could do anything with these but I keep getting my shitty cards." This one and all the others, you always have the same number of cards.
It's great. Yeah. Yeah. You always have your 12. So if you don't get the card you specifically need, well you're going to get it next turn. Right. You know. Or you get this upgrade that lets you draw two. Two extra You control islands that give you an extra hand limit. Like which how many There's two islands, so it's these two. Oh, yeah. So, you could have a hand limit of eight and then you could end up drawing eight cards. Right. And being like, "Oh man, I got basically my entire deck." Right. So, Oh, yeah. The sweetest turns when I saved to have seven cards in my hand and I was like, "Wow." Yeah. I Like I think I have like seven cannons and it's like, "I can pretty much go hunt wherever I feel like." Yeah. Yeah. And well, what's also wacky about it? Right. Well, cuz there's some where you're like Like the captain, for example, him at being at level one with a sail, you're like, "Do I want to level up my captain?"
Right. And and lose the sail? So, I think we Two games in a row, I never leveled the captain. Nope. I did it as my last level up because I knew I had to attack people. You and I almost did the exact same Like we did the same thing for our captain. We put a sail on it, so if we level him up, Oh, cat, I didn't lose the sail. So, it's speed. Yep. I I mean, hell, at level four, he gets a bunch of ways if you get the wheel on him and that it's like, "Oh man, if if you win, you can't use it against uh buildings, but if you win, oh man, that's just uh that's like a [ __ ] ton of money." Right. Like you potentially get like eight coins just for winning with your captain. Yep. So, what's also fascinating Actually, I'm going to grab them because I meant to grab them for the discussion. Um Do you uh Zach, do you have any negatives?
Honestly, not really. Um I like the card building aspect. Um I've seen this before in other games. I like it. Um where you slide cards in and out. Yeah. to think. Besides his game, what what other ones there are? So, Gloom does it. Um they have the clear cards. Yeah. Oh, Oh you're right. Um But you don't craft the cards. Well, you're crafting basically to kill people. I guess they stack but yeah. With different abilities. I'm trying to remember there was another game. It wasn't Mystic Vale or Canvas but in a whole different way. Canvas, right? Yeah, you're right. But but that idea this idea of using clear cards is new and kind of cool method to doing it.
I really like it, yeah. I think it came out and it was it it's I don't know if it's proprietary or what but I'm pretty Don't quote me but I'm pretty sure John Clair designed it with Mystic Vale. Probably. So I was going to say cuz Gloom might have been first. But you don't card craft. Yeah, yeah, the mechanic is the mechanic of using them in that way. But the advantage is I don't think you can copyright it so I don't think you can either but I've only every time I see the card crafting system with like when you're deck building is in his games. And like yeah, right and then Canvas does something similar. I thought that's just a cool mechanic. Um Again, to your point for as a deck builder, love it cuz your deck stays lean but it still becomes more and more valuable as you play the game.
Yeah, you improve the cards instead of getting getting synergy with with combinations. Yeah, and just that sheer amount you don't need to have 900 expansions to give you card variety. You can just be like, "Oh, yeah, I've seen this upgrade before but I haven't seen it with these cards." And also having a hand limit of like six and then drawing four every time is just fun. Yeah, it's great. Yeah. Yeah. Um so, there is an expansion though. As I say, you don't need a million of them but whenever I was saying, "Oh, the bosun out of all out of all eight of your crewmen, the bosun is the one that I'm hell even the pursuer like the first time we played I was like that's not uh that's not super great but I wasn't I wasn't producing that wasn't what I was trying to do. So then whenever he leveled up I'm like oh my god the pursuer is [ __ ] great.
Right. And the Bosun yeah he seems he's my weakest link out of all eight cards. I don't know if that's the same for you guys or maybe you guys actually leveled up you guys have two upgrades so I could Yeah I got I got the three you got the four. Yeah I mean I'll say I for what my goal was was which was hunting down ships the Bosun kind of made sense you had to do him. Yeah. But if you're doing merchant then I can see why why would I ever do it. Yeah. Just to get the seven cargo spaces and the upgrades. spaces definitely the best for you. for more movement. Right honestly the sail plus the four cargo space to me was more valuable than if you're going to go true merchant than seven cargo. Right that's what I did. Right I agree. Yeah.
I figured when you put two cannons it's because I mean when I started buying all the cannons like okay and you were close by and I was like And and I've got plenty of cargo space. Right and it's like yeah that's the right decision like when when you were debating it's like the cannon is the right decision. Well it's funny cuz like he went over and took that island from you and I was like oh I did not see that coming. see you either cuz he was taking it from me. Uh so oh and this also didn't do what I thought it was going to do was make a three player game. I thought one person was just going to get [ __ ] on the entire time like One one did. No. Oh. Not really I mean we didn't pick on you. Absolutely not. No I I actually didn't interact with you in any way. Yeah. In fact both of you interacted with me until you took his island so you So in in fact Zach was the one picked on the most cuz he took that island from me I took it back and then you took it from him which he didn't take back.
I would have gone down there and taken that one if I had the uh influence to do it. Oh, right. Oh, at the end of the game. Yeah. Um hell, even at the end of the game when I was there and he was going to attack you and you're like, "Well, why don't you attack him?" Because like Two Two motivations. Well, I was sitting there and I was like One was you're right. Two was Well, it made the most sense cuz yeah, it's like chances are like I mean, Brett didn't have any of these. So, unless he's hoarding a bunch of money that we were missing out on, it was the most obvious choice. But, I put myself in the position to make it to make me less appealing. But, it made the most sense. I had three damage. You just need to land one cube on a double damage and you're just going to sink it. And I'm like, "Yeah."
Yeah. Yeah. I am not upset by that in any way. Right. So, the Sea Dogs expansion, which is what I will probably start using. I haven't done it since, but if you don't like some of the cards, this is where it changes. So, regular games, if you're This module can be used to you draft four Sea Dog cards and you choose one of those cards and keep it. And then so, you'll get four cards. So, you can get In place of one of these? Uh yes. Okay. Yeah. So, what do they do? Um List the card type, remove the basic illustration and replace it with the Sea Dog card. If all the matching card types already have a Sea Dog, you may instead replace any basic illustration. For example, if you have two Sea Dog cards for captain, one of them must replace the illustration card on your captain and the other may replace any other basic. So, Sea Dog cards all have a name and an ability. The ability has a level indicated and then the text effect. If that card is at the indicated level or higher, then the text effect comes in.
So, it doesn't inherently do something. But, for example, your helms You can have a helmsman once your helmsman is at level four, it only costs two cards or two um uh cargo to build an office. Hm. If you have the blue jacket, this is a crew. At level three, place a garrison on any island you don't control. Ignore up to one damage from garrisons this turn. Um and they're all different. Like the blue There's another blue jacket that's a level two. Roll two dice, gain uh two um coins per two rolled, and you lose one coin per zero rolled. So, this is gives you deck variety. Um Master Gunner, level four. You can build uh four cargo from anywhere to build a fort. Hm.
So, uh Chief Officer, roll a die. If you roll a zero, uh you get to you get the draw a next uh a next card ability. Right. So, let's look at the Bosun ones because he's the one that sucks. Petty Officer, if in row four, add one wheel uh and one cannon to this card for the rest of this turn. Hm. So, if you're in in and these your Bosun needs to be a level three. Um but you replace them, so you technically don't have a Bosun um uh like card effect. Right. But, I think this is just a Oh, yeah. Uh Petty Officer, so that's a Bosun. Just gives you the influence cube. Hm. So, uh just if you want to add some variety, you get tired of the same cards. Um this would change up your deck by four. Like you would have four different abilities.
Um So, I think that's a pretty neat expansion. Yeah. And then the other expansion is a campaign. Hm. Um I don't know much about that one. But anyway, uh yeah, I think uh I think this is an extremely solid game. Each time I've played it, I've I've had a blast. Um like just just playing in different ways. Right. So, you guys got anything else? Can you think of anything else here? All right. On a on a scale of 1 to 10, what would you guys give Dead Reckoning? We'll start with Brett. A 9. 9? Dang. Yeah. I was not expecting it to be that high. Well, then.
Well, okay. That's That's That's more. There we go. That's what I was expecting. No, it's it's 9. It's it's good. It's solid. get better like now that you've played it a couple times? No. No? Okay. So, it's the same rating. I feel I feel about the same except just more confident that, you know, now I understand all of these cards, what I want to do next time. Okay. That's the one that's going to be key. Yeah. Right. That makes sense. Which I was kind of missing before, but I'm still, you know, the overall strategy of getting and acquiring things and fighting people for it. Um Not your cup of tea. need more practice and I don't particularly want the practice. Right. But I see it for the how it is. Yeah. And for that's that's a 9. All right. Uh Zach? I think I'm going to give it a 10. Dang. Yeah. Wow. going to say 6. Yeah. I'm like, dang. You guys really like this.
debating 9 and 10 and I was like and I was kind of like but 10 is something I would definitely buy. I was like I think I'm going to get this game. Awesome. Awesome. Yeah. Uh yeah, we'll have to definitely If you like this and his other ones are just as good. Yeah. Um So, same rating. This one is I need to I it's weird because I I did that four-player game and not that that was miserable, but it was kind of miserable because it was way longer Right. than I was expecting. So, I was like, oh my god. Um and I never taken into consideration the solo variant to this because I'm not a solo player. I only do them for the channel. No, I I might agree. Yeah, I think I'm going to give this game a 10 as well.
Like the only I'm I cuz I have to be stretching for negatives. That was the my thing is like we couldn't even really we tried to find negatives. like, let's do negatives, COMBAT. IT'S AMAZING. WAIT A MINUTE, NO NEGATIVES, NEGATIVES. YEAH. The dead sea. Uh the boatswain's not great. a purpose. Yeah, and it's like it's not that great. Boatswain's horrible, but serves a purpose. But he's good. He's a good guy. Like like cuz I mean it makes sense like even the boatswain where I'm like, yeah, you have to get him to level three, but that's the other thing. Mhm. There's it's like if you want to advance your boatswain super quick, like that's the one that's the one you choose and go find a merchant. Right. And be like, yeah, I have gunners in my hand. I'm not going to use them just to lose. Right. I mean if he's in your discard pile, which he would be if you use him the first time, Right.
then be like, okay, I lost. I'm going to upgrade him. So like by turn two you have your level three boatswain. Right. Um there's there's so many just different avenues of of strategy that each of them are are extremely viable. And I don't play a lot of games multiple times in rapid succession. Right. Um and this one was one that I was like, yeah, now I'm excited to play it again. Yeah. Uh Yeah. And in our game and I'm really glad we did a three, it was an hour and a half. Yeah. And honestly, which is very rare, I wanted it to be longer. Mhm. I mean I did because that was the only way I was going to win. Right. Yeah. I agree. But like another 30 minutes Would have been perfect. would have would have felt pretty solid. Yep. Um and hell, even whenever I I I was like, man, I have all these. Like it's like I'm pretty much going to sweep. And apparently you were like actually going back and dumping a lot more money than I was paying attention to.
Right. Uh And some people might not like that either like the secret coins, but if they want this achievement, then they have to at least tell you, oh, I have 30 coins. For Eurogames I like secret coins or secret points because otherwise you have the people watching. Well, you have the person counting up and deciding, do I really attack that person because they clearly they're three points ahead of me and they're about to end the game. Versus Seth has the 30, I have the 30. I have five more on my ship. Does he really have 32 or does he have 31? Yeah, I think I literally I had 25 and I dropped seven. So I had I had 32. Right. Um Which you could watch and you could count. You could. But but this also does the exact same thing. In Merchants and Marauders, uh it's first one to 10 points, but you have to go back to I think you have to go back to port and you have a little chest that you drop one coin in.
Right. And but you can only get I think five points that way and the other five have to come from a bunch of other different stuff. And that's a that's another secret kind of thing. Right. Uh which which I enjoy and it makes thematic sense. Yeah. You're not going to know where the pirates are storing their treasure and how much they have of it. Right. Um and you could really just load up on your ship with a bunch of money. But chances are someone's going to go and attack you. Right. But I also, another positive, is the fact that and some people may not like this, I don't know, play Merchants and Marauders if you want to just I like the fact you can't just willy-nilly attack another player. Right. You literally have to have an icon to go do it. Mhm. So You have to make the choice to get that icon. Exactly. So for a while I was like, well, now I'm have done it. I don't think they're ever going to attack me. And then you guys then I started noticing you guys were buying more and I'm like, yep. Yep.
They're All right, now they're getting the icons. Uh so we'll just see. Yeah. Yeah, I think I'm going to give this game a 10 as well. Uh and the art is is fantastic. I love the art cover. Yep. I love how it's thematically appropriate to your crew. I would say I wish the crew for each color looked different. That's just I mean, if I'm really stretching, I I like that just the you know what I mean? dot on the side. There is, yeah. But it would be nice to be like, "Oh, my captain is a different captain from yours in terms of picture." Right. But other than that, yeah, it seems very thematically appropriate. Yep. So, all right. Well, that's our thoughts on Dead Reckoning. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.