Skip to main content
Loading video...

Keyforge: Call of the Archons - Discussion

Transcript 28:44

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and today I'm doing a no run-through review on ki Forge call of the archons the newest game by Richard Garfield who was the creator of Magic the Gathering in this review essentially I'm probably gonna be doing a lot of comparing between ki Forge and magic strictly because that there's a lot of weirdly some similarities simulant similarities there we go between both of these games as they are designed by the same person um you might be thinking if you've seen any of my other know run-through reviews I'd be like oh great he hates the game not true the reason why I'm doing a no run-through review for this game is because one uh I don't really care to do bronzers for card games strictly because it's difficult to actually show you know all the cars and stuff like that and two it's just because that this game like I feel like my feelings for it are gonna be are gonna vary depending on the types of deck that I play and who they match up against the run-through that I had recorded was actually basically two types of control decks and if you don't know what that means a control deck in magic just like kind of in this one is pretty much to prevent your opponent from doing anything a magic it's from playing creatures playing spells playing man that any of that they basically

aren't playing the game while you're doing everything in this game the run through both Devin and I had essentially two control decks that we just kept destroying each other's creatures and stealing and capturing ember and it was just like slog and we were pretty much bitching the entire time so what are my feelings towards ki Forge well I think it is actually a very very good game that has some flaws for me and as my usual discussions or reviews I'm going to talk about things that I don't like and I have played this with multiple people I played it multiple times and with multiple decks and these complaints have held pretty much every single game so my biggest complaint my personal bass biggest complaint with this game as is and I believe that they are going to release other sets similar to how magic releases their different sets I think they're going to do that here but as is based off of the four decks that I have played a lot of this game is you doing stuff on your turn and you waiting for your opponent to do stuff there is very little interaction aside from I mean there was interaction obviously it's a two-player game but between its it's weird essentially there's no instance there's no counters there's none of that if I play a creature on the board he comes on exhausted and it's like great okay he's there my opponent can't he can already have creatures so then all he does is just he could in turn just destroy my creature

so it's like great so a lot of what I felt a lot of decks that I played did was just keep destroying other people's creatures and you want to do that because it prevents them from either destroying yours they get benefits from attacking or a lot of cards hinge on their being creatures on the board and also prevents them from just reaping which gives them ember so it's kind of extremely annoying to play one creature or a bunch of creatures and then they just get destroyed like there's a there's a card called gateway of D to Gateway to dis or gateway to D or however it's pronounced Angeles is destroyed every creature and it's like like you can't counter that you can't stop that you just have to let that happen and I can see I guess some people might like that because they know that they will always get to play their cards but at the same time it's not fun going the other way around because you're like well I wish I could counter that which I could do something wish I could you know return crit like I wish there was funny enough one of my complaints with magic a long time ago was the stack rule I wish there was a stack in here or at least some type of counter mekin somewhere it's like cabin destroy that creature now I'm gonna cancel that card so I mean but here's the real big problem with with that and this was a complaint from everyone I played cat

Devin and Josh the people have been on my channel before those three people had the same complaint and they personally did not like the three houses the the three house mechanism and at first I was like oh well that's part of the strategy you know you are trying to figure out how to incorporate your deck with these three houses in it but the biggest problem and that I've seen so far is that there is no integration between these houses they are literally just three separate houses put into one deck essentially take magic take three tribal decks and put them into one but even then you'd be able to do combos with each and every one of them because you have mana that gets spent on these types of cards in here yeah that's not the case you literally add on your turn choose a house and you can only play cards from the house activate cards from a house or discard cards from that house and it's pretty much like I I don't get it I like I I understand that that's what this game is about but at the same time it's like why why like you could see so many awesome combos that you have with this with but this deck that you have that's supposed to be 100 percent unique and it's like for example a Mars card is called soft landing which is the next friendly Mars or friendly creature or artifact you play comes into play ready great oh wait

I can't play anything else because like I can't I can't play some massive troll and he comes out ready he doesn't come like it has to it obviously has to be a Mars artifact or Mars creature so why have that in the deck like why can't you integrate these unique houses together and have these awesome combos Josh had some amazing combo B's like well I can't do it because it's from different houses and I get that's part of the strategy of the game but it kind of leaves you wanting more like you want more out of your deck whenever in all reality you're kind of doing the same thing now let that lead me to Kats biggest complaint which is why do I have three separate houses in my in my deck when and I understand the game just came out and that their propaganda and I've heard that they're creating new sets and they're gonna be probably more houses and more abilities so it may make all of my current arguments and and dislikes null and void but as is this is the the complaint since she was like I don't get why we have the same houses and her deck it just changed up a little her deck had two of the same houses my deck had and it's so and one of them was different and if that's their idea of a unique deck mechanism that's kind of lame I bought four decks and two of them like two of them two of the Texas is weird so

two of them had two of the same houses and the other two had two of the same houses now again if those if you know cross played those you'd have a different set but it's like it's still kind of lame because yeah the decks are what number singing and I get and I'm starting to suspect that Devon might be right is that whenever they're like oh there's these millions of different combinations of decks well yeah you take one card of the Mars deck out and put a new one in it it's a unique deck that no one will ever have okay so there are a lot of the cards that I was playing against I was like yep yep I have that card I have that card in my deck I have that card in my deck and I mean that's the Simca mean that's not really the same complain against magic because you build your deck in in magic so it's it was just kind of lame and and she just didn't really understand what why is how is my deck so so unique and so special that you have pretty much all the same cards I do just a different house you can't integrate them any differently I can't have these like a five of a Mars house with a broaden our head like one one of the decks I have is Mars brawler and sanctum I can't integrate the Mars abilities with Brahma or sanctum not really so it's like okay really having that unique deck is nothing nothing special same way you know vice versa you can't really integrate these decks all that much you essentially just have three separate houses doing their own

individual thing but they all kind of have they're all wrapped together around a theme like they're the decks are kind of themed based not card based if that makes any sense one of my cards is one of my decks is a control deck one of mine is a ramp deck and all this kind of stuff you learned through magic and magic mechanisms and magic decks so it's like he kind of took all those and all those ideas and he basically assigned those kind of abilities per house and then just threw them all together is what it feels like anyway so that's this was kind of a it just it was like the game works you know really well but at the same time it's like you people she will compare this to magic and whether that's fair or not I don't know because Magic's been around since 95 no in 95 or 93 it's in 97 it's been there out for like 20 years and I think it's 93 because it says old as I am so it is 25 and art and key for just came out at 2 weeks ago so it isn't really fair to compare them but at the same time you look at Richard Garfield you're like dude this is your creation like you pretty much took your things for magic and made and made another game just trying to be a cash grab and that's what I'm worried that this game is going to be and I'm already starting to be proven right because there's already decks

being sold for $200 or more in with the decklist hey you want this view you've played enough key Forge and you debt you aren't getting your deck because at one you're you know spending - I understand the decks are 12 bucks and that's that's awesome but because it's random you have no control over what kind of deck you want to play so if you're like I would really I really want a deck with these three houses and these types of cards Oh someone happened to get that great oh they price gouged it okay so I can see and it's like great don't buy it but at the same time it has that same mentality of magic you can build a solid deck without spending any money but if you want a really really good competitive deck you're gonna spend money you have to spend money justice the way it is like magic is that that kind of game where the the more money you seek into your deck the better your deck will be and they've omitted that and and basically exiled that with key forts which is one of the things I really really like is that you have no control over your deck so tournaments are gonna be played where hey you spend 12 bucks you buy a deck you learn your deck and you just become better at it well you can't really become better at it because you can't really integrate all the houses together but anyway with with this it's just kind of like people will buy more and more decks and that's kind of where I found myself at is the four decks that I have I like two of them so I was like what do

I do with the other two I can't break them down and use the cards that I like in that deck so it's a great so wasted deck or I can give it to someone or I can love my friends he's and see if they like it I know someone who has bought they bought twelve decks and I think it was for each so they have a bunch of different combinations but it's like because there are twelve dollars each and you just kind of want to see what the next deck is gonna bring you you're just kind of gonna play a deck once or twice and never play it again I for the most part I mean obviously people aren't gonna do that in some and on some might but I already find myself wanting to just keep getting decks and and testing those out but I'm not gonna so those were kind of things that I didn't like about it just it just they to reiterate no integration of really houses because you have to call a house Josh's biggest complaint was that as well you can't integrate the houses Devens was it's a cash grab or he was worried it's gonna be that's the first thing he thought of whenever I said each deck is unique so we can't Dec build and then Katz was why why are our decks the same and then mine is waiting for your opponent just to destroy and mess with your show you can't stop them from stealing Ember you can't stop them from capturing Ember you can't stop them from destroying your artifacts you can't

stop them from destroying your creatures you literally do your turn and you wait they do their turn great you just read all my stuff okay I'll play more creatures oh you destroy them again so those are all the negatives that I can that I've accumulated over all the experience of key fours so now the things I do like about the game well my favorite things about ki Forge is the ease of access that this game has over magic magic is you have to learn all these cards and you have to learn how the deck build and you have to learn how to ex-old well and it just it just kind of never ends now the latest format of magic that I've played is commander so it's a little bit more I would say difficult to create a very solid deck because it's a hundred card decks well this is giving 99 cards with a commander so you really kind of want to build your deck around your commander but you have to have this extensive knowledge of the magic cards to build a deck and it doesn't really work if because I used to have six decks and I sold all of them except for three and you can't really hand someone a deck and be like okay great you just play this because they're not gonna know everything they don't know hey here's a fetch land oh man what LAN shot really or here's a here's a tutor so I'm gonna I'm a sirki they just don't know what what your deck is meant

to do and even if it's meant to do one thing it probably has a lot of steps it needs to do or has a bunch of things they don't know what those bunch of things are with key Forge that is not the case like and I tested this earlier with just handing a deck to someone who has played magic once and and I just wanted to see how how well they did and yeah you can jump into this game without having any previous knowledge of magic or really of a deck building or of cards or these kinds of games which i think is really great I like the fact that they have a game kind of like magic with same ultimate theme really not theme of the game the theme of the card to integration and decks that someone who has no experience can jump in and play the deck and and the skill is learning your deck and maybe finding those combos in there one of the things that I personally like but some people I can definitely see a lot of people hating is the fact that it doesn't require any deck construction just because well I like it but I don't like it I like it because it saves a bunch of time you spend 12 bucks you buy a deck great if you find a deck that you like great just play that deck just play that deck over and over and it's like yay I'm having fun because I didn't have to build this I didn't have to put this together I didn't have to put the deck together and then be crushed whenever it sucks and then you feel like an idiot

the deck already works not against every deck but at least it works in that what it does what you wanted to Oh Mike obviously like magic where hey I have a mill deck but oh great you your burn deck so you'd kill me before I can mill you out stuff like that so there's them there's that matchup but at the same time I can see a lot of people having problems with the fact that there is no deck building because you have no control over what kind of deck you get in its then like I've mentioned before you will keep potentially buying board more decks just to find one that you want to play and at that point you might be burned out on it the artwork is fantastic in this game very vibrant very colorful you know they did a great job on the artwork just like magic has has that extensive and detailed artwork I love like in older magic cards I don't like but pretty much half like newer magic cards or even like up to a certain point I haven't found a magic card that I didn't like the artwork on and same here like I love the artwork um they added a quick a quick a quick rules thing so a lot of the rules are on the PDF and that's kind of annoying because I'd like to just have that on the hand and there are some finicky things so the other thing I do really like is how your turn works very smooth very free-flowing

there's no okay well untap upkeep draw okay first main phase combat second main phase and main phases there's none of that there's no okay well I'm gonna play this card okay then I'm gonna do this and then oh you have to go so now we have this thing and I have you know it goes into your it's your turn in between this separate phase that we have the stack thing going on and then now the stack resolves because no one can do anything and then now we have to see okay what happened okay now that's resolved now I'm gonna continue on the but this phase if there's none of that it's literally on your turn you if you have six ember you unlock a key great other cards can make them more expensive but potentially six ember you unlock a key great you have to and you can't sandbag you can't hold a lot you can't and you wouldn't really want to because there are so many cards about messing with an opponent's ember that it would only probably hurt you but potentially you can't ever have 18 ember in it to spend it all and win the game it will take you at least three turns to have if you have eighty number three consecutive turns to be able to constantly unlock keys but I really like that so you spend your ember then you go to your turn where you select a house and the whenever you select your house these are the only cards you can play activate or discard I like to thank you can freely discard cards and just to get

more cards into your hand it's like okay well none of these are really affecting me or my opponent right now so rid of them cuz you were gonna get your card back there's no you can't draw you lose there's no milling it's a shuffle you discard pile that's your deck but I really like the free-flowing nature of your turn after you select your house you just play as many cards from the house as you want so if you have five creatures of the same house great you have five creatures on the board that's awesome so there is some I mean yeah if you're playing one creature at a time it's probably gonna get destroyed but then just hold on to it until you just draw a bunch of creatures from like brown are for example their big fire type creatures so it's just like BAM now I have an army and then unless of course they just have a the disk infection which this board wipes a lot of stuff but I mean there there is those those matchups and and I do like that part I like all the different houses like my favorite house is I do have my favorite house and I mean they're a lot more fun and I like all of them but I just wish that the combinations were better in your own deck I like broaden are a lot they're just big and just heavy heavy creatures what's what's weird is that their health and their power are one in the same well not really one the same but like what they're powered that's someone's damn if it's a five that's how much damage they dish out but that's also their health so at first I was like wait so if they're if their health goes

up does their power go up like if my and I still don't I think so but I'm not quite sure because I could never find it anywhere and the quick rules are in the actual rule book or but I dunno if their health goes down their power stays the same so I'm assuming if their health goes or if the power goes up their health doesn't go up their health is always that number but it's just finicky stuff like that there is another issue with like a car named bad penny where when she is damaged she goes into into the opponent's hand or if she's destroyed that damage if she's destroyed she goes back into the opponent's hand well my question is like can you play a card that kills her on your turn if you call the same house and then she goes what can you play her again like this to me because there's no phases there's no okay well now at the end of the phase everyone who's damaged dies so just stuff like that but I do really like the freedom of the player's turn it's like okay well I'm gonna play this card that has a playability that returns creatures it's great there's none there so he's he's done now I'm gonna play the rest of mine so I can actually have an army double play and or the fact that that lets me do or you can't really activate artifacts go on playing are the fact and then I don't play this creature that doesn't ability that effects this creature you can do stuff in that order and there's no real faces there's no tapping for mana see if you can do it there's no resource management really you just get to play your cards

and that always feels awesome like unless you have a really crappy hand which you can still mitigate by wiping your by just discarding cards that you don't need I do really like that almost every time you feel like you are doing something unlike in magic where a lot of times it's just like Grey I keep getting screwed on my deck and nope I I have no card so let me draw more so I can only ever draw one you will always have a hand of six in this game which I also really like you draw at the end of your turn at the beginning so you have some control over that and then the game is pretty quick unless you get a slog like a to control decks against each other and god that sucked that that that really sucked um I mean that's that's pretty much it the only other thing I think of is that they have a chain or a handicap which big decks or not big decks some big cards that like our power moves give you chains which ultimately determine your hand size or how many cards you get to draw at the end of your turn so if I play a card that's like just already every creature on their board that card gives me three chains so now I if I have a hand of five I don't get to draw one at the end of my turn because that now it's a minus one card modifier so if in the it goes down at the end of at the end of your turn and it goes down by one but over time if you're playing all these really heavy cards and your change you're gonna have no cards in your hand

and that's gonna obviously that hurts like hand management and and card draws and magic and in this game are really important um so I mean that's really all I can think of I've had two games where I ran away with a victory the other the other like three or four games I had it was it was pretty close but I don't think anyone in my group except maybe Josh is interested in playing so so that is my thoughts on key forge and potentially everyone else's thoughts they just didn't need to be here for it because I kind of grant it they also like to give Josh like the game he even said Richard Garfield he still got it like it's still a solid game like don't get me wrong like I do and and I do enjoy playing this game but that's just because I realize it for what it is do I still like magic more uh I do like I like magic quite a bit and especially commander a lot but that's because if I'm like I want to play this deck I can I have that conscious decision like I can integrate awesome combos from any card within magic whereas here you don't really get all these awesome combos from you like you see them like I saw I always see a bunch of all my different houses okay so that's that's that and I hope they I hope they do more of that I hope they I mean some say friendly

creatures but none of them really like it they just don't do a whole lot at least in my decks and that's the difficult part you guys may be like other were you talking about I have this deck that integrates all my houses completely and it's like that's fantastic that's a problem potentially a problem with a lot of people for a lot of people with this game is great I didn't get that deck and I may never get that deck so I'm just gonna keep giving fantasy flight money and in the hopes that I get a deck that I like and and that's that so that is key Forge on the scale of one to ten obviously five being average ten being perfect and one being a straight-up gutter i'ma give it a seven I think it's a solid seven I do think it's an above-average game I think you could easily be an eight or nine if they start integrating counters and and card combinations I'm not saying they have to integrate deck building no that's actually like I said one of my favorite things is that it is ease of access but at the same time it can be frustrating if you never get like let's say they release these counter decks and you just happen to never get them so it's like great I won't have counters you do okay cool cool they may never do that because of that very reason so then you I mean more houses bunch more house it's like a ton of houses so great you have a house I've never seen before that would be but awesome then and then now I have to kind of learn your deck

and now learn my deck in a different way to combat your decks similar to magic it works the same way but as of right now I have a lot of houses that are pretty close to being the same so yeah it's a it's a seven it's a seven for me I think a six is too low I do think it is not slightly above average it is above average and I mean I'm gonna keep this game I'm gonna see what what they do with it and potentially I might pick up a few more decks just to round out the variety but but yeah yeah I think a seven out of 10 is a good number for key Forge so let me know what you think of key Forge in the comments below whether in that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button is a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day of this for you

Progress saved