Skip to main content
Loading video...

"Arcs Isn't a Trick Taking Game" — Cole Wehrle | BGSS Clips

Transcript 8:05

You know, you mentioned the trick taking thing. And that's at least in in my comments has been the most polarizing aspect of Arcs. That it's built on trick taking and I say that in in quotation marks uh for a really specific reason. I mean, this is a mechanic most people kind of associate until recently in this big trick taking blow up um which you say you weren't capitalizing on wink wink uh Yeah, I mean Um you know, you typically associated it with you know, playing card games at grandma's table, you know. So, where did this idea come from? Talk to me about the evolution of the action selection turn order and ambition declaration action mechanism that you've rolled into trick taking which I think is probably not the best way to describe [clears throat] it but

No, no, no. And and in fact, we describe I think in the Kickstarter copy, we talk we use the phrase trick taking like once. But in all of the published parts of the game, we like hardly use it. We're like well, it's not really a trick taking

game. It was there. This is part of one of my follow-ups and in this campaign, the word trick taking as far as I can tell is not there. Well, it was it was always it was always a like kind of a bad way of describing it because it and the reason why it was in the first campaign was I I had a whole designer diary where I talked about the influence of trick taking traditional trick taking games on Arcs. And I so I wanted to make sure that influence was clear but it it isn't it isn't really a trick taking game. It's much closer to a like Carl Chudyk like lead follow system in just in in how it ended up working. So, let let me talk a little bit about about why I mean, you you've asked a three-hour question and I'm going to I'm going to try to give you

And do you have time by the way? Like we didn't even get into any of my questions. This has been such a good conversation. Uh you know, we

Yeah, we've been we've been skirt we've been skirting around. So,

We have. Let let me let me give you um let me give you a reasonably condensed answer. And then if you have specific things you want to talk about, that's fine.

Yeah, yeah, okay. So, here's the reasonable Ignatz version. Um when I was working on Arcs, I really uh I I was thinking a lot about narrative tempo. Because uh Root has these short turns where everybody's turn in Root is about the same length and they usually take a maybe a minute or so. And they're like little chapters in a story, right? They have beginning, middle, end. You wake up, you do your day, you do the evening. Uh in Oath, the turns are longer. And we experimented with other kind of impulse-driven versions of Oath, but the longer turns were better because we wanted them to feel more like chapters in a book. And like they they had to be like big paragraphs, big chunky paragraphs. Uh but critically, everyone basically has the same amount of supply. There's variance, of course. And everyone basically has the same number of actions. They're very uh homogeneous across all the player counts.

But I was thinking about cinematic storytelling. And part of making cinematic storytelling is variations of tempo. So, you are having a big moment and it's a protracted scene, and then I cut in and do a little thing. And then we we cut to a third player, and then it cuts back to you. And then maybe that other player has a little bit longer. And with the with I dynamic turn length, uh you get all sorts of different um tempo considerations that are much more narratively rich. They even has have a kind of cinematic feel. You know, when Risk was first advertised as a game, one of its key selling points was that it had a dynamic turn length. Which of course it does. You play Risk until you want to stop. You know, you move your armies around till you want to stop moving them around. It's There weren't a lot of games like that. And so, I really liked this idea. I also loved the metaphorical resonances of trick-taking because I knew that the game um I I wanted to build a game that had emergent asymmetry, but the problem is as as as you back out as you stretch out your asymmetric positions, we have less to in in engage with as players. You're a medic trying to evacuate a planet that has some disease and I'm like a warlord trying to topple a government. We actually don't have any room to interact meaningfully in the story. And so it's like if I have a metaphorical layer in the game, all the players can be accessing the metaphorical layer and fighting over essentially the narrative spotlight.

And so what I need then is a dynamic auction system and trick takers are the most dynamic auction system in the world because you have a hand of cards whose value is going to be contextually driven and that context is not driven by this turn this card is Trump. It is driven by who is winning each round. It's very organic and adaptive. So all of this stuff was kind of floating around my brain and I realized, okay, if we're if we're going to like trick taking, it's it's it's got a great metaphorical resonance and by the way, um, you see it used all the times in poetry and in short stories and like the longer modern period because, you know, Pushkin realized that there's something to these card games that lends itself to a story or Alexander Pope, he's writing these heroic couplets and they're talking about a trick taking game because they it has

it has a metaphorical resonance. There's a whole section of the Rape of the Lock that's like about essentially card games and it is so charged up. Um, so the actual card frame like structure was built very early. We didn't have an action system for it for a long time. When we launched the original crowdfunding campaign, we had an old sorry, not actually we didn't have a victory system. When we we didn't have a victory system for the game for a long time. When we launched the crowdfunding campaign, we used a very traditional kind of Twilight Imperium style objective system which I hated. Even at launch I hated it. But it did the job. So And it didn't exist? Not not at the Kickstarter launch. And When I was working on the game that summer, I eventually paused development and like took it back into my office and slammed the door and just worked on the ambition what would become the ambition system for about a month and then I opened up the door and said like, "Hey Nick, hey Josh, come in here. Help me Help me work out this problem."

Oh haggard, just like stuck in your room with like a little

yeah. And and and I I I want to emphasize that because like it my my designs are always done very collaboratively and there are moments where I'm working alone, but very often I'm like pulling people in to get their feedback and thoughts and and Nick and Josh were really helpful in terms of thinking about you know, what should it cost to declare an ambition. What I realized was that the reason why the victory system, the TI style system didn't work is because I needed a victory system that felt like contract bidding. Because you have to declare to the table, I think this. I'm going to make this thing and be important. And then the table gets to respond. And so, you know, it it doesn't really look like contracting contract bidding looks in bridge or something because Arcs isn't bridge and it's not a traditional trick-taking game. I mean, I always whenever someone asks me about that, I always say like, "You don't win tricks in Arcs. You win ambitions."

And so it's like well you're winning contracts and there there are ways that that can like lend itself to trick taking, but but the actual design kind of grew in its in its own way. So that that's the very short version of how Arcs uh became the way it is. But this is a process that took 2 years. That's so interesting you didn't have ambitions figured out. I think that's such a obviously such like a cornerstone of the Arcs design and creates so much tension being able to declare that um that ambition before somebody else's, get that higher point count, observing what the board state is and how it's changing and and who has the advantage and what you have in your hand, what you can do. Like there's so many layers to that onion and it's incredible that you mentioned that you didn't have that figured out at the beginning of the of of the campaign. It's like why on earth was I backing that? I'm just joking. I know.

Well, that I mean that that's a good question. Hey, you right there. Thank you so much. You made it to the end. Congratulations. You have an attention span slightly longer than a 5-year-old. Now, prove it to me that you're a big adult and you can watch an entire episode. It's right there. If you don't like this one, maybe try this one.

Progress saved