Arcs: The Blighted Reach Expansion Review - Complex, Engaging, & Innovative
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is farl and with B of it and today we're going to be reviewing Arc blighted reach expansion which is a followup to our prior review of arcs the base game the blighted reach expansion allows you to play a three game campaign of arcs adding a not insignificant number of new rules and asymmetric abilities and goals for the players this review is assuming that you've seen our review of the base game or at the very least have a solid familiarity with the Basse game of arcs so arcs is quite a sharp clean Snappy design and bided reach takes it and makes it something weird something strange something messy there's going to be an added complexity and in the guise of the world of arcs players are going to take on asymmetric roles and it's during a time of the kind of dying breath of an Empire it's failing and a new fredator ISM the blight and you're going to all as individual players have your own personal goals that you're trying to achieve and you might follow these throughout the entire campaign or you might fail miserably at your goals pivot have your worldview changed and go after something different
if you want to know the core rules of arcs then check out our review of the base game as here we're just going to cover the changes and what the expansion adds firstly all players start off in the two Imperial clusters with each system containing an imperial ship players will start off as Regents of the Empire with one player getting to be first region the Imperial ships are neutral pieces in many ways that can be used by everyone but they also prevent players from harming each other when they are present EG combat and taxing each other's cities the rest of the map contains free cities and blight free cities can be used by anyone controlling the system to either be taxed or raided and destroyed for trophies blight is all over the map and is a tough little enemy requiring two hits to be done damaged rather than one it also stops movement progress as if it was another player's loal ships so it's harder to move around the map there will also now be event cards added to the standard action cards which allow a player to copy the actions of a lead card but they result in a crisis or edicts and they also allow the player with the initiative to call a summit the expansion comes with new court cards and some of the box cards trigger and effect when there is a crisis whenever there's a crisis also all of the blight on the map will cause damaged
ships that share a sector edicts are new actions that can be taken by the relevant players typically relating to the roles that players have been given or the first region and a summit will allow players to trade and negotiate with each other and also allow certain players to leave the Empire to become an outlaw or restart the Empire if there are no re moving on to the fates these are roles that are given to players which have titles like the Admiral or the steward each of these roles has a unique deck of cards which may add new court Cards into the court deck give players law cards or Court cards or add new rules and edicts into the game which affect everyone each Act will have players aim to reduce a Tracker down to Zero by completing objectives which are relevant to their character depending on success or failure different cards will be granted and added to the court if a player fails their objective then they have to change Fates to a b card if they succeed they can choose to either stick with their current fate or they can choose a b fate but they get less choice and if a player fails their second fate they get forced to change again to a c fate card usually the campaign be one by the player who has collected the most power or victory points over the entire three act
campaign however if players Choose Or if they fail in the second act they will be given a c fate for the third act now SE Fates are wild and unpredictable and they essentially have an ultimate goal and if they reach this goal they will not so much win outright but they will supersede any player who is not a c fate from winning now if there are multiple C Fates then whoever has the most power out of the C Fates which complete their goal will win so essentially C fate if they've completed their goal and have the most power out of all the C Fates will win then if there are no C Fates in play or all the C Fates fail their goal the player with the most power will win the campaign I think the first point we'd like to make about Arc sped reach is that although you hear campaign and three games and all these changes it doesn't actually to us feel like so much of a campaign more just like a very extended game of arcs and this is because you don't really change your board State between games so you will maybe get some new stuff a new role or some new goals but you're going to keep generally the resources you have your positions on the board your buildings on the board your tabl so what you have at the end of one game leads directly into that next game whil it is very easy to pack it away between
gaming sessions thanks to the excellent storage to maintain your positions the best way to experience it in our opinion is in one big sitting you know get your friends around have some brunch make a whole day of it or maybe even an afternoon into an evening we do think there's something to be gained from keeping the flow but either way you're going to have a great time although we do like the fact that you continue on from your previous position there is one potential flaw that we have seen in that when you change Fates it is then possible for a player to either walk into a fate that they have the perfect position for or into a fate where their goals are very unachievable because of their current position on the board now if you're forced to change you get an option of two Fates so it's more likely to be the former that you walk into a good position now it could be argued that that is just a reward for setting yourself up in that way in the preceding game or games but it can also make things anticlimactic and obviously less fun for the other players in recent example our last campaign I had to change to a c fate in the final game and because of the way and the role and my abilities in the preceding games I was in the perfect position to go into
one of the Fates that I drew so I picked that one and long story short I managed to get 17 out of 20 points that I needed towards completing that goal which in that game was an instant win because none of the other players were C Fates and there really wasn't so much that other players could do about that either and obviously we just decided to concede the game after the first chapter it went to me and it was very anticlimactic to an experience who just spent you know five six hours playing now obviously not going to happen that often or in every game but just be aware the second big point we would like to make is that bled reach in many ways feels like a different game than arcs like it's using the core of arcs to propel itself because ANS is clean and snappy and vicious whereas blighted reach is slower kind of dense complex messy and this comes from the new load of core rules you're going to have to learn you're going to have to learn about how The Empire Works how event cards work how Outlaws work how the blight Works you've got EDI crises and Summits you've got the Imperial Council and these are just the base rules to play blighted reach on top of that you've got all the different players and the more players you have obviously the more complexity because every player gets an asymmetric role which is going
to introduce new cards and rules and edicts into the game so the blighted reach is a significant Step Up in complexity from arcs and that's something you're going to have to square because what's going to happen is until you have the core rule set kind of fully understood and a nice understanding of how blighted reach plays players are going to suffer because they're not going to be able to see opportunities that other players have to harm them or opportunities they can take to progress themselves now we're not saying that it's complex sprawling and messy in a negative way lighted reach is an experience unlike any other and we think it is well worth a complexity each Fate has interesting goals Ambitions and abilities and the way that these interact are endless providing emergent narratives and drama the whole way through it makes you feel like you're in a rich and stored universe and it further expands the way that you can make big plays and see outrageous reverses of Fortune as an example just the base new rules of the Empire provides a lot of interesting decisions and player interaction one play player is the first region and they can use an edict to tax other players to add their resources to the Imperial treasury resources here can't be used but the first region can count them towards
Ambitions however players can seize the title of first region or become an outlaw and steal resources from the treasury Imperial ships prevent players harming each other whil in the Empire but allow use of them in battle against the blight if you know the base game of arcs you'll realize how spicy these elements are and the depth they add to the game playay now imagine you have a player who can treat the Imperial ships like their own and move them independently or a player who can kidnap your agents independent of Court cards or even a player that can give you elements needed to score Ambitions just prior to scoring that is what we mean by Messi the one part of these new ments which really didn't hit with our group was the negotiation so now after a summit you can negotiate and trade kind of pieces and ships and cities and captives trophies and for us we just never found it particularly interesting or there to be a reason to negotiate or trade these things because arcs is such a zero some game that generally what you have you have have because it's going towards the Ambitions or it's helping you round after round and none of that is really something you want to trade to your opponents because then it's almost a double shift where you're losing something and they're gaining something so it just never really came
together for us and we never really saw a reason to negotiate and a kind of secondary effect of the Summits is that they have kind of obscure actions you can take that players might well well want to take throughout the campaign but it's not something they want to take every chapter and only the player who calls the summit can take these actions on top of that so because they're obscure but you'll have Summits that happen one to three times per chapter because of the event cars which are introduced so you're getting them quite often and then it became really tedious in our games to say okay well this is what you can do at a summit does anyone want to do any of these things or at least to the player who was calling it no okay and then it's does anyone want to negotiate and this is what you can negotiate and go down and say that no okay let's move on it just was a continuous way of slowing down the game for no real benefit to gameplay and I think a big part that has hampered this is in Bas G Fox it has some of the best player AIDS I have seen in a game tell telling you everything you need to go but blighted reach only comes with a single one whereas Arc had them for each player so there's only a single shared player Aid with all of the new rules which is quite a lot so it makes it extra tedious to try and remember what happens in Summits
negotiations and what you can trade and it just didn't quite come together and I know those going to be people now up in arms saying uh you don't know what you're talking about we love the negotiation kns I'm sure that's true I'm sure that's completely viable but I would point out I rated John company my number one game of all time which is pure negotiation almost and I just didn't see it here in Arc to turn to something different I just want to talk about Fates it's exceptional how diverse they are and what excellent designers on show because you have 24 Fates and then the A and the B Fates have multiple acts worth of cards they'll inject into the game that will have impacts and these are very experimental they're very Innovative and it makes it genuinely a joy to discover these Fates to see other people play them to discover them yourself to be dealt a new one at the beginning of a campaign all the possibilities laid out for you so it's also quite exceptional in the way that they all interact with each other as you begin to to see the different Fates and learn their different rule sets you'll begin to understand how infinitely replayable the blighted reach is because of how they interact with each other and bounce off of each other it also shows you that every campaign you play of this will be utterly unique and as a final word it's impressive
design how they allow you to fail forward they turn something which is usually frustrating and negative EG failing your goal for that act and they turned it into something positive and exciting unlocking a new fate seeing what else the game has in store for you one small complaint we have about the fates is that some of the goals don't seem particularly balanced in a two-player campaign many of them do adjust based on player count however some do not both farell and I have had goals where it doesn't adjust and they score off of other players and as you can imagine in a two-player campaign where there is just one other player it can be quite frustrating to try and Achieve that goal we do think that the two-player campaign is very very fun but we think it shines more at higher player counts primarily due to the added chaos so final thoughts the blighted reach is exactly what an expansion should be we think you'd be hard pressed to find a more impressive expansion when it comes to content and experiences provided that said we wouldn't recommend this to everyone even those who love arcs and we wouldn't recommend getting it outright when buying arcs the base game is fairly straightforward rules-wise and the complexity comes in by trying to manipulate the game state to get where you need to go the blighted reach is not straightforward at all hi Spen it's complex it's messy it can be
confusing at times and it adds on a lot of play time yeah so as such there are going to be people people who love the bass game of ARs and hate blighted reach there are going to be people who love blighted reach and will never want to play the base game of ARS again because they find it boring something that actually the main person we've played with has said something to the effect of so you've got to consider who it's for it's very much a comparison of you know going Co Wally terms people who like root might hate oath and some people oath is their favorite game and they don't like root and I'm some people like both of course and I'm kind of bringing this comparison because blighted reach is almost the most most oath likee thing that I've played since oath definitely it's very much like that so keep that in mind and for our part we really love the blighted reach we think it's an exceptional endlessly replayable experience so we're looking forward to getting stuck into for years to come even if it does have some weak elements as we've highlighted and I think one thing to note is that looking back at the script it might seem at times as though we were maybe more negative on it than that would suggest but I think what we're trying to do is say these are things which might annoy some people or people might want to know before buying it or getting involved in it and we just want to make you aware of that as reviewers even if we don't think it
affects it overall but that was our review of Arc the blighted reach expansion any questions please let us know if you found it helpful please please consider subscribing if you haven't already if you have thank you and finally we really appreciate you watching you can check out our base game ARS review and we will see you next time bye bye