Dark Moon Game Review
Transcript
today I'm looking at Dark Moon a hidden traitor game designed by Evan Derek star day 2030 this is commanda Adama sorry Reed of the Dark Moon Outpost when my team returned from their latest Expedition there was something different about them different I don't know what you're talking about I feel f fine in Dark Moon players are secretly assigned to a team either players are uninfected the good guys we have to quarantine the infected and get off this fracking Outpost or they infected the bad guys I'm not infected I feel fine would you like to procreate with me the good guys win by surviving until the end of the game and completing four events the bad guys win by sabotaging the good guys Commander please will you give me the passcodes to make the shields go down then maybe something else in this room could go down on something else for example in a five player game there are three uninfected players and two infected players nobody knows who else is on their team the players have to try and figure that out from the choices the other players make throughout the game Chia keeps failing her repairs which makes me think she's infected but she also keeps wanting to have sex with me so she must be human the Crux of the game revolves around these dice each player has a character screen and
throughout the game they'll have to roll their dice behind their character screen and select dice to submit to the game for example if John Reed is trying to fix the shields he'll roll up to three dice behind his screen and submit one we need to fix the shields we can't let the silons I mean the infected get in once JN has rolled his dice he'll choose which to submit if he's uninfected he'll want to submit a positive dice for a successful repair yes sometimes you got to roll a hard plus three if he was infected he might choose to submit a negative dice to force a failure but he could still be uninfected one of the good guys and be forced to submit a negative dice because that's all he rolled Frack I couldn't repair it I've never fixed a CS unit before I was FastTrack to Commander on a graduate scheme I've never seen real action you're infected you're the one that wants to bathe in the blood of the uninfected crew members to suckle at the teed of Humanity's Extinction and let oy's blessed Darkness cleanse you what what was that about bathing in blood nothing you're infected he's infected and immediately we've Hit Upon one of the best things about this game the deception in Dark Moon happens publicly unlike other games of this ilk if you want to sabotage a repair or a task you have to do it while brazenly staring your opponents in the face pretending it wasn't your fault I only had two dice and they were both negative as a shy is my witness I promise that
seems really hard but the reality is that uninfected players will have to submit negative dice results throughout the game making them seem infected the game balances this nicely by waiting the diece 66% in favor of negative how you react to your dice roll is crucial to maintaining your innocence oh no I only rolled good dice I mean bad dice let me try that again oh no oh no the dice are all wrong oh shoot the dice oh no I didn't want to roll that at all at the end of every player's turn they have to pick up two task cards and choose one this is an opportunity for the infected players to do some hidden sabotage because they can pick the card with the more dire consequences this one kills everyone immediately but I promise the other one was just as bad completing tasks helped the uninfected complete events which get some closer to winning the game failing task have bad effects which help the infected win the game the players that have chosen to join the task each in turn submit Dice and the numbers get added up I can add this plus two dice taking us up to five so say we are this Shield malfunction needs seven to succeed if it fails one Shield damage token will be placed oh no I have to place this minus two dice which takes us back down to three I feel very sad emotion towards this
outcome some task cards Force the players to make difficult game-changing decisions this card allows you to ask another player to give you one of their dice permanently increasing your maximum dice P to five and decreasing Theirs to three strengthening you and weakening them Commander Reed I want you to give me one of your dice if that other player refuses to give you one of their dice then an outpost token is drawn damaging part of the Moon station and bringing the infected closer to Victory I would love to give you one Chia but I can if I woke up the next morning after giving you one and found out you were infected I'd hate myself you didn't worry about me being infected when I had my hands all over your Outpost that's different and you know it these decisions bring even more tension and mistrust to the game for example there's a card that allows you to pick someone to be quarantined if the vote passes then that players powers are severely diminished the uninfected players need to try and find the infected players and quarantine them to weaken them we have to vote on her she's infected she needs to be quarantined and a brilliant move for the infected players would be to quarantine one of the uninfected players the good guys vote for him to be quarantined and you'll find that the plutonium isn't the only thing on this Moon that needs drilling your dice are a precious commodity when you submit dice to a task you don't immediately get them back so you won't always be able to help out when you want to and because of the way
the dice are waited the less dice you have the more likely it is that you'll have to submit negative dice there's nothing I can do you also need dice to vote with so if you spent them all on trying to fix the Outpost you'll be pretty disappointed when you don't have one to stop yourself from being quarantined bye-bye Commander there are three ways the infector can destroy the Outpost and win the game first firstly by destroying the shield by placing all the shield damage tokens secondly by placing all the Outpost damage tokens now these have a double effect because once you damage parts of the Outpost you can't do certain other actions in the game for example if Shield control is damaged you can't repair The Shield so you'll have to try and repair Shield control first the Third Way is by damaging life support when life support is damaged a fatigue token is drawn representing one of the crew members if all six are drawn then the game is over but if the fatigue token representing you is drawn then you're fatigued you can no longer use your special ability or submit more than one dice to tasks is it me or is it really dark on this Moon every aspect of this game is designed to provoke discussion for example on your turn you can use your action to issue an order to another player which gives them two actions instead of the usual one but who do you pick and can you trust them to use those actions wisely CH I'm issuing you an order get those Shields fixed now okay
I'll try and fix the shields oh no I don't have the dice to fix them and for my second action I reveal is in infected no I treated you like my daughter if an infected player thinks they're on the verge of being caught they can reveal themselves using their special ability to damage The Outpost further I place one Shield damage token can bringing you up to five now your Shield is as weak as you resolve on future turns revealed infective players can continue happily sabotaging The Outpost with a new selection of actions that they're given but their powers are stronger if they remain hidden there's also the commander role which puts one player in charge of picking the event cards which can affect the game it's a powerful position who can be trusted with it in case you haven't been getting the not so subtle hints Dark Moon is inspired by the Battle Star Galactica board game in fact it's an updated version of a print and play game called BSG Express all of this has happened before and will happen again because it's surprisingly quick to play battl Star Galactica is a beast of a game and takes 5 hours to play with many moving Parts the idea with BSG Express and now Dark Moon is to distill down the best aspects of that game and offer a similar experience in a much shorter time frame but does it achieve it yes and no Dark Moon is a really fun game that offers accusation arguments deception all the things that games like this should have in a streamlined format looking at it on its own merits I highly recommend it and
I'll definitely be keeping it in fact I'll probably be playing it way more than Battlestar Galactica would you like me to make a fool of you for 1 hour or 5 hours it doesn't replace Battlestar Galactica for me for two reasons one is simple I really enjoy the theme of Battlestar Galactica and sometimes I want to play a 5our in-depth game but the other reason is that in Battlestar Galactica the sabotage is hidden it's in play Dark Moon is very different the sabotage is out in the open and for that reason I enjoy them both but they're different enough that you can have both in your collection and not see a problem in it I only have a few minor criticisms with this game I think that the task and event deck could use a bit more content you generally see the same cards come up each game and I think that Dark Moon could actually benefit from an expansion something to add a few new ideas and keep things fresh oh no the shields malfunction again oh no the shields malfunction again oh no no the shield for Frack sake who designed this Shield the player screens are pretty flimsy and they fall over far too easily and it's a bit of a shame coming from stronghold games who gave us the sturdiest screens ever in their game article 27 I generally like the artwork and graphic design in this game I think the board looks really nice but the character art lets the game down a bit on the visual front you don't think I'm beautiful I think that Dark Moon achieves exactly what it's set out to to offer an engaging hidden traitor game and a reasonable length if you like the idea of lying to your friends accusing them getting into a heated discussion over a game and you want something more involved and interesting than the resistance but less cumbersome and
unwieldy than Battlestar Galactica then you should get Dark Moon yes you and your uninfected friends should come to Dark Moon ashyra wants to eat them sorry meet them if you like this video please subscribe to my channel for more of the same let me know in the comments what's your favorite hidden traitor game check out my website at actual all.com I'm actual all on Facebook and Twitter there are links in the description I've been John perkus thanks for
watching