Skip to main content
Loading video...

Brass: Birmingham - Discussion

Transcript 34:35

thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for brass Birmingham uh again the greatest game ever made right um according to another one yeah according to everyone not not through any um not through its own Merit but through the the uh cringiness and the uh uh the uh uh what's what's the word vindictive nature of this player base there is actually a Reddit page because we obviously got to talk about it uh where he pulled stats of like the voters like how many voters uh for uh brass and gloomhaven and it was hundreds of players of the brass Community who voted once on gloomhaven and the gloomhaven players were significantly less of voting brass so it's clearly like this community who just for some reason hates gloomhaven for zero reason just going out voting at once that shut it down to number three right interesting um and so that was just some an interesting piece of data that in and of itself means absolutely nothing except two people who need to go outside and touch grass it does it does though point out the inherent flaw in caring what other people think and that and the inherent flaw of the BGG ranking system uh as a system that is just bad uh but because in my opinion I think they should scrap that and do a once a year

vote where everyone get goes to boarding beak vote one game get you get one vote for your favorite game and that's what determines a separate link of right like here's the BG top 100 because you wouldn't get duplicate games and you wouldn't get [ __ ] like this where um if you're going for what number one is exactly because obviously I don't care what is in the top 100 um but some people who's new to the Hobby might come in and be like oh well I don't really know what good what games are good I'll go to this this trusted system and they might they're gonna see brass pandemic Legacy number two now and gloomhaven and then you couldn't have more different games yeah a couple that like TI's number five yeah uh arcs number Arc Nova's number four right yeah so just radically different games they all suck

I wanted to bring that up because I I was thinking about doing a separate video talking about that but then I realized I don't actually care right to do a separate video so I was like well we'll finally do for six months it won't matter it'll be over anyway exactly nobody will care right so I was like okay perfect opportunity to to play this game put on the channel and then kind of talk about it there now do I think brass Birmingham is the best game of all time absolutely not do I think gloomhaven is the best game of all time absolutely not right neither is like there is no best game of all time because time isn't out yet right there's gonna be more games next year that is true and everyone is different uh so it just you just the comparison of those two games you could not have the furthest ends of the spectrum between the two right now with that being said do I think brass Birmingham is a good game I do no I don't think this game is bad I don't here's the weird thing I don't particularly like it though like that's kind of where I'm at like like I think I've played this game multiple times now and I'm I'm kind of like all right right yeah that's that's the game I have some kind of criticisms with it But ultimately I think it's a solid Euro but I wouldn't willingly choose to play it over a lot of other euros and and right I this is in that Niche this kind of reminds me a little bit of like Concordia where it's like yeah this is solid this is a solid game

all right nothing to hate yeah but nothing really stands yeah nothing's like whoa and that's what because everyone Raves about this and everyone raped about Concordia and I'm like yeah it's fine and I think some of it is it is a straight up solid Euro game I like this to a certain extent kind of like um barrage there's some player interaction because you're taking other people's resources and but they benefit them yeah it benefits them but then like I wanted some coal that I had out there like I had planned and I had just the right amount of money that I couldn't buy coal yeah and someone took it I was like okay now I have to change my play it didn't drastically change it but we were close enough at the end that money star being less and less valuable yeah because pretty much I was doing every play where like I ended with one dollar but then I got twenty dollars right and that was just enough to do the next play the next turn yeah you're kind of strapped for cash at the very beginning and then by the middle of era to your income level should be enough to be like I don't need to take a low and you could take a loan if you really don't have another action and you just kind of want to set up for bigger moves right but that's it it has it does have a nice flow to it I think like it naturally is like okay you're starting out in just Industrial Revolution it's hard and by the end of it you're like yeah we got our business going boom now it's just kind of maximizing points um the end game every single time I've played this has always kind of been the same beats where it's just like drop

your hand just to put rails down right I I really don't that's not kind of my enjoyment of the games where it's kind of like I'm just doing this just to get points I'd rather do something cool right like it'd be like and of course there's players of this who probably have it set up to where they're like I have eight beer that on my final turn I'm gonna spend this and sell and right it's like oh man I played badly and that's where I feel like I feel like I played not as well as I could because I should be all set up for that yeah but I don't know I think there's people like this game just has an inherent No One's Gonna Let You do that right that's the thing and that's kind of what bugs me that's why I don't like Architects is like oh it's so cool you can put as many workers in the same location and multiply no one's letting you do that so the inherent cool factor of the game is is [ __ ] blocked by players uh and that's what's the nature of the game right when you play this your mindset has to be clicked to these resources aren't mine right I put them out there but they're not mine so I I can't get upset if someone uses it right uh first time play I was like what the [ __ ] because it felt like you do a whole turn to uh set up to set up and then someone just undoes that and you're like well I just wasted the turn yay right um Brett what do you think what are your overall thoughts was it as bad as you thought it was going to be yeah okay which isn't awful yeah it's just you know I could tell watch them play through um I could tell this is gonna be either

I'm gonna spend every turn agonizing over every possible move and trying to math everything out which is no fun right or I'm just gonna do some semi-random things that kind of look like they might be a good idea but not have a long-term strategy yeah which is what I did and it worked out okay but definitely not a winning strategy yeah it's uh I mean this is kind of what this game turns out like I in most Euros I can play and be like okay I feel like I'm doing really well every time I've played this I'm just like it's it's a toss-up yeah I don't know how many points I'm gonna get I don't have any points I mean I could theoretically math it out and sit here and be like he's gonna get this many points but I don't want to do that you could but I carry I like that factor that I don't know like it's always I feel like it's a toss-up like I think like you jumped ahead in the canal era and it's like I thought I did fairly well I was like I was a little shocked that you were that many points ahead of me right um and then at the end it's like he has a lot of rails and a lot of good spots um and it just came out that I had a little bit better yeah you had uh eight more points which funny enough came from I think something like that twice twice um and here's the thing that frustmates frustrates me about this game and some other games is whenever I see my final score and I lost and I can't figure out why I lost it's like okay well then what scenes have to play again you know like if I could pick out okay I messed up there I messed up there um like okay I'll do I'll do better next time here I'm like I have never changed

how I play uh 130 seems like a decent score so why did I lose and it's like and the game doesn't have the incentive or the variety for me to want to come back and try and do better because it's like I'm just going to do the same beats or whatever and just hope that this time it happens to work out better right um interesting I have the same philosophy of of what I enjoy in a game but the opposite spectrum of complexity okay I want much more simple straightforward games with very little hidden yeah because then you can develop strategies and then you're actually just playing strategy versus strategy ultimately right whereas all the variety and all of the randomness of the heavier Euro type games for me that that's what makes it I can't strategize anything but for some people it is such a great thrill that it's going to be different and right what what working before I'm gonna have to tweak every time yeah so I get that yeah yeah no that is actually a very good point considering just the twos obviously like because like yours is like chess nothing said I know how this entire game works front to back so therefore it's how well I am as a player versus you as a player right um and I get that as well but it's like for the inherent nature of a board game I don't want to come back and play the same game over and over so I'm like that's boring to me yeah and trying to learn from a grand master yeah I guess that's true in chess it's just like by by getting beaten by them several times can I move the pawn ah the twinster strategy okay nope nope nope we're done I Didn't Know You're a Grand Master I'm

gonna I'm gonna quit playing you you beat me already from saying whatever the [ __ ] you just said uh yeah and for game as efficient as this one I do still think that the deck is just a weird Edition like how you can get screwed you can buy the cards and like my opening hand was awful it was so bad so it's like you you like you do kind of tailor your strategy off your opening hand um and yeah they do have to make with the cards you draw play into that and it kind of did but it's like my my strategy was not to do this like my strategy was to do this but I had no purples right so theoretically I could have built anywhere um but I had a lot of cards that were particularly were the the resource cards right and I'm like okay well I I can't build in purple because I have no purples they have a way around that obviously you can spend an action too you burn you burn a card and multiple cards to then draw the Wilds it's there at least it's there right but in a game that's all about efficiency it's like so I wasted the turn really and then if you if you spend your turn to do that and then someone like you ended up going builds there it's like right okay like I guess I'm screwed there and you asked me the question like how many times I do it earlier and I did it twice and I said I'd roughly do it probably twice yeah um I think the Scout action for the second half because I do think

being a little bit like in the first half of the game everything's so much cheaper yes you have less money but because of like your connections are cheaper it's easier to spread out so you can kind of tailor where you are going to go with your links to your hand a little bit better yeah where in the second half because railroads cost so much more and I'm trying to do it as efficiency I'm trying to pop two every time I do an action yeah having Wilds in my hand to make sure I'm going to the right setting and can build multiple times in the same city kind of powerful for me yeah yeah I uh I mean I get that like having that just holding them in your back pocket if you're not drawing what you want to draw but I think in both eras uh how you start is is kind of gonna it's gonna dictate a lot it it I feel like it dictates if you succeed or fail yeah um so some people could just get that opening hand where it's like man I can start in Birmingham and I have new Newton I have Coventry and I can go like I can do that man that's just it's all set in stone and because I have these cards chances of them having them are slim to nuns so I'm just kind of set up to succeed and I have a talksetter and Stafford and kidderminster and Redditch and I'm like

so one of the things I do dislike with the randomness of these tiles is the fact that here we're playing a three-person game so we're supposed to be able to go up here and you have two blinks I also you know I probably house rule that I probably almost be like if a location gets two blanks you you reshuffle yeah um to where every possible selling point and depending on the number of players has at least something I would honestly just Shuffle the two that were down there and it would take one of the spots up there yeah with the double yeah that's that's honestly that because like funny enough we were playing a three-player game and I was like this is basically a two-player game yeah because no one ever you went up to Stone just because you had the card for whatever because I need a beer and I didn't make a connection for my own beer yeah so that was the only reason I held onto Stone yeah so but then like I was I wanted to go the blue this entire time and kind of isolate myself and be like I'm gonna use my own resources like to stay up there but there was no reason to because I have I gained I can't sell to Warrington right so it's like well that's it's dumb right okay um so I kind of find that a little bit yeah I agree with that I think that's annoying I like that these are in here because didn't the original version they were printed yeah they were like set it was set yeah uh probably I mean that is a very fixable house rule yeah um but if you don't do house rules um that's a thing that can pop up Brett what do you think of the cards what do you think did the randomness did irk you was it kind of just whatever not really because again I didn't have a particular strategy yeah so I just felt like the

cards were just options like the building the city if I choose to or I can build this resource well where am I nearby that okay I need to build a rail to get there then I can lay it down the next turn and then somebody can take it all away but at least I'll get points for it yeah yeah and I've already connected to it yeah the only strategy I had at all that I could see made any sense was get some level two buildings out as fast as possible that is a very solid strategy that was my strategy uh so yeah so let's actually talk about about that because I personally don't enjoy the hard reset because generally you're not going to get a lot of level twos out you can get some right but also to each game I played yeah you got one I think got one two this one I didn't get any um that was basically by Design as well I was looking like I could get these level tubes out but at the same time I kind of didn't feel the need to because you guys did so I was like well I'll use your stuff right uh so thank you for that but at the same time it's kind of like I it's like you're you are you're playing two separate shorter games and it's like I just I you I feel like you're you're kind of getting your engine going to get these cooler high level buildings out but then it's like oh game uh air is over right and you're like man all the tracks I made all the buildings I made those are just all gone and now I have to start over with less money yeah and I don't particularly like that I

don't think it's that big of a deal but for me as a player I'm just kind of like well that's annoying it does feel like a big loss yeah right because you're basically starting the game entirely over and not a lot of games do that my father's work is a kind of a Euro Style game where it does kind of but you have permanent perks that you're you're always ahead and then this yeah I get level twos out for at least coal and iron but even then you're still kind of slightly behind or that's you're going to be behind in the canal era to try and get ahead in the rail uh railroad era so I think my best play of this was I got at least one if not both of the level one beers out level one coal and iron out and then I got rid of the level one of these buildings clay buildings I think is what they are yeah I think it's Compton okay um because then I was able to build at least one level two and flip it and it's worth the same number of points it's worth less income but it's worth two connection points so at that point you're just getting more points per round and that was honestly the one the better games I played because a lot of those have the low levels have good connections so you just start trying to build them one area connecting as much as you can um I do think I under use development in this game I think it seems to be an action that is seems like it's useless but it's probably a lot more really powerful especially if you can get your own iron out yeah use your own Iron to then flip

the tile to right get access to higher level ones that's probably a strategy that was underutilized everywhere I did it once because I didn't get a beer out and then I got rid of one of my Pottery ones that cost zero but kind of the cleanup of what you did trains at the second half I did the development on the end of the first half I got one of my irons out and then did two developments my next turn to flip it for points and to get rid of all the things I couldn't use anymore what were you gonna say Brad um just gonna say you know that it's it it's kind of like a it feels like a wasted action until around round two when it's required that is true yeah and and actually it wasn't actually several times I went what happens if I just don't build those buildings anymore at all right leave those ones there and just ignore them I mean because like the there's very few tiles that you can't develop out of right so it'd be interesting to find out if if you're if your income's high like 22 or 17 or 15 if you're if you're you just spend a couple turns developing using other people's iron or potentially your own to just really bull pass some of these uh the manufacturing ones to just wipe them to then be like okay well that's gonna give me seven nine eleven potentially getting to this higher level positive to so on your turn like in one turn where it's like oh I can build uh build a beer thing for two and then I have my level five out so that's 20 points right um

but still I there's a lot of this game that I feel like is is a little bit of waste of turns not major right um but I personally as a player I don't like to because they're at least two times where I was like I need beer out I can build beer but I have to build a connection I don't want to build a connection and build beer because that's just gonna be taken so you're you're constantly kind of like hesitating to even play the game because you're just scared someone's gonna take your [ __ ] right and you have no way of knowing if people have the ability like the when and I think in the canal era I could have built in Walsall but I was like I don't like I I can build the connection I can build my beer there but what the [ __ ] do they have can they take it so and it none does everything because I need my beer I did that once because you built here randomly like I think the coal and it was literally my next turn which I was going to build beer for the next round I was like I can't do that anymore oh he builds one train or he decides to double train it and he'll take the beer I need yeah yeah and beer is everything it is everything in this game like you can make you can get a [ __ ] tentacle you can get a [ __ ] ton of iron even if you don't build it yourself it's available because it might cost a lot but beer is so limited that you're just like hesitant this entire game and I don't like that feeling yeah like I don't like sitting here being like man I'm scared if they're gonna take my one resource because that's like the whole [ __ ] thing that's what I just did so interesting um because whenever I put out resources whenever I built buildings and plan out resources I was planning for you to take

them yeah and and I I never had a plan for them because I'm not planning one step right but well that's why you're down here I know you're going to take it and I want you to take it because I'm gonna get the points I'm already connected to it right yeah um no there's value I do feel I think that's a valid strategy with the colon iron but I think beer is so valuable we're gonna get more points than you would gain from flipping the beer over like you flip you flip a level beer over that's gonna be five points versus the 11 I got from using it you know right so because there's there's so many ways and spots for iron and coal that you're never really [ __ ] blocked out of that but there's only one spot like there's two spots there there's two of just the beer spots but there's beer beer beer beer beer there is but there's too isolated where you're guaranteed yes you're gonna benefit from right right but because if you're built if you build your own like let's say I had uh Derby right I could the Derby card even that's a four player game but I can I can play Derby and build my beer over there and that's mine so I don't need a connection right great I don't have Derby I have the one card I have the I have the the beer card this that's this is all I ever got that allowed me to build beer so I had to make a connection right there for because I had to have a connection there to build it everything you guys have a connection and so I feel like there were multiple rounds where I was doing one official I was just building a connection pausing doing something [ __ ] all right connection somewhere else to stall out

so that oh I didn't spend a lot of money you can do beer in the cell on the next on the next turn and that's not a pre-planning I enjoy because it's centered around hesitancy right whereas in like let's say a game that is long-term playing tilatum that's that's all long-term planning but you can't really do a lot to stop me like I'm always making continuous progress this is kind of like one step forward two steps back and that's where I do like that in this because for me Euro games I want some player interaction and that's the player interaction yeah it's the what like Ashley hates and work replacement games she can't plan for what I'm going to take well I like that I like the fact that someone is probably going to take the spot I want yeah yeah I have to figure out a different strategy around that or figure out planning of I'm going to take this but that means I'm not getting that sure yeah I think I like a lot of my Euro games where it's kind of like here's my strategy here's your strategy we'll just see which one ends up working out this game um the like gather resources but also in a lot of work Replacements especially now that one worker per spot thing is kind of dead like even viticulture was like that then it's like oh this game kind of sucks and then they added the Grande worker where it's like you can still take a spot but I have this one this one usability that allows me to go there and I can only use it once so you have to plan for that that's perfectly fine but here it's kind of like oh God I I need I want those resources but I'm basically putting them out there just so

everyone else can use them and so therefore I helped everyone else out because what I feel like I gained from the tile flipping over isn't isn't worth what I could have used the resources for right so that's kind of where I'm at on that it's um it's kind of the same thing if you play Black Angel like when you're playing dice and like you roll your dice and they're your color dice but anyone can use them but they have to pay you a resource to use them at least in that sense your someone has to actively give you something to use it and here they're free for the taking except they're giving you points uh they are or because of the rule we found out of you have to use the closest right people can kind of actually manipulate that to where your stuff is never getting used uh so it's like Insurance instances that is bad but um I mean that would be tough to do more than like maybe once or twice um but it definitely can come up sure but I mean that's the thing it's like in a game like this it is so efficient you want to keep every every turn feels like you need to constantly be moving forward and for me I feel like there's just one too many step backs that makes this game for being like excellent for me right um but I mean these are all just grievances really like I don't think that it's inherently like a bad design or uh or a bad flaw of the game it's just things that if someone were to want me to play Brass it's like do I feel like being a dick today do I feel like being annoying

today not really worse yeah I mean that's kind of what it sounds like and it's like I don't feel like being an [ __ ] I just kind of want to do my strategy and oh cool you built in front of the water thing right yay that's annoying I hate you today you know what's funny we were asking about what industry like what air what years these were that's right there yeah I saw that uh after I was like I think I was like 1860s is that right you said 1880s like an idiot we're both 10 years off if I was in between the range it was without going over without going over yeah um again overall it's it's a solid Euro uh That's Where It's At for me it's like it's gotta know where it's at I I this is one that I will never understand why it's raved about as much I think this one I do not get I get Arc Nova jumping up to four uh obviously I get gluehaven pandemic Legacy was one that I was like are you kidding me so I get this the one because to me it's kind of like the Twilight Imperium why Twilight imperium's up it's a game yes it's a re-skinning of brass it's a little bit better version so you have all the people who love brass from way back when going out and down voting all the games ahead of it well some more of that but it's a solid enough Euro game that people have constantly I mean it's been now made three times after okay and so to me that's kind of

the positive is it's loved it's long like it's been around for a long time it's still solid yeah and they did like just one one or two little tweaks yeah just suddenly to not start to not like piss off off the fans of it they didn't do completely overall individual player powers and yeah so a whole new sideboard with tracks so that's why I think like I don't think it's the best Euro game out there but it's solid it's not a bad year game yeah um and so you have this I call I don't know cult following is the wrong word for it but you have this group who loves it for long enough and that's it yeah that's more of it yeah we have like people like me I haven't even played Arc Nova yet um it'll take a little while for me to probably play it no it's like because it's new but I mean it's just it's just new right so um it shows that's good because it jumped up yeah there is something to be said about games that are tried and true we kind of like Overlook those now because it's not the new rightness um and and I think that's why I like Concordia is still loved because it's it came out in what 2012. yeah and this is I think 07. well original brass I think it was 07. okay um so here's the thing that sucks though about this game in particular is that whole [ __ ] with the BG like yeah is now it didn't do this game any justice because now everyone's like okay so they can come into these [ __ ] Petty yeah and it's like okay I don't want to be involved in that because that's the top

10 is definitely the top 10 Board Game Geek is petty because it doesn't matter to us because we're not you know six years old right but it matters to some people and especially it's it's just like really you couldn't just love the game and leave well enough alone you had to go out and just manipulate a ranking system just because you're vindictive right okay like anyway I was gonna try this game but that whole thing makes me just not even want to try it now right um I had tried it because it was talked about highly before that whole thing and I'm like ooh that's a perfect time to to get on the channel uh yeah so that's I mean that's pretty much all I got for it um do you guys got anything else to talk about right you got anything um just just a couple of Novel mechanics that I novel to me at least mechanics that I that I like like well but you like the turn order um being dependent on how much you spend yeah that's thematic and that's also interesting strategically it is and after multiple plays I finally use that to my strategy again it was kind of around it was centered around the hesitancy where I was like okay I'm just going to build one rail you're setting up for the next and and then I'm hopefully guaranteed to go first so then haha now I can do my beer and my cell action or or you can attempt to manipulate it well you can manipulate it to the point where you go last and then first so you actually get four actions in a row that's true that's a good point uh yeah I I do enjoy that um obviously my preferred way of turn order

is like I always want to go first but you can't you you cannot do that yeah you're originally gonna spend a [ __ ] ton of money right um one it's kind of a flip a little bit on the five tribes if you guys have played yeah where you auction your points um to try and go first so if you really want to go you're getting rid of getting rid of a lot of the points to do that I do always enjoy a tweak on turn order yeah um it's Unique yeah one of them yeah uh what else what else did you like did I like yeah I think because he said that he said there were a few a few novels um the idea of of being able to purchase excess coal and iron and then sell it back at market rate and fun fun fun theme but also so you don't run out of critical resources right yeah because you do need those for pretty much everything yeah and it's a neat thing I think you did a few times where it's like that's actually something I could have utilized that I didn't even think of was when we were buying all this because no one was doing a lot of coal like probably at one point I could have just bought built a coal thing just to have it immediately flip right because that's all back I did that two or three times yeah yeah and it's like oh that could have been and then you need to call from the next time but you now made it from three dollars to one dollar and made money on that call plus the flip so now when you need it for your next round it's now cheaper right um or then people start buying at a cheaper rate and you do it again right uh do you feel here's a question because I just remembered I was gonna ask do you feel because this game is around 07 not this version in

particular but the system and because there's not a whole lot of variety to it basically none right do you think this game has a meta I assume but I've never played people who are playing you know have a hundred plays of this true um so I assume there's a meta yeah well the only reason I say that is because Twilight Imperium which is incredibly complex game with lots of Randomness has met us gotcha so if that game has metas in the community that it has and this has a large community as well and there's less variation true I can't see that there isn't it meta somewhere yeah I just don't know what it is yeah I'd be very curious if someone in the comments can tell us if they're what the meta is is like words like you always want to do this or you always want to do that I mean magic the Gathering has metas that come in and out I mean the rulebook gives you like they have a little section of hints and their hint is don't be afraid to get loans like your income can be low um and the fact that we kind of didn't like once we could ramp up our income we never brought it back because there was a couple times where I was liking it as nine I was like realistic I probably should start taking some loans for the money that I need I think in the second era I was the only one that took a loan yeah and uh and then from then point at that point on because I it's like okay I'm gaining 13 I jump down to 10 that I lost three money but I gained 30. I'm sorry for the rest of the game right and that was kind of where I bet you that type of meta that's thinking of

is there and we're I'm just not seeing it yeah yeah uh uh all right well scale of one to ten uh we'll start with Brett I'll say seven seven it's an eight yeah I'm also by the seven um kind of the same thing I gave Concordia like I kind of put them in the same this is a this is a good game I don't consider a great I definitely don't think it's number one I don't think any game should be number one because it's stupid uh but I could see if you didn't mind like I had a few more negatives uh if you didn't mind those then this could be an eight but I also really like Variety in games that's probably the biggest thing that keeps us from an eight for me is there's just no variety yeah um it's just a solid it's a solid Euro game for me so yeah even Concordia has more variety yeah than this and at least there's a bunch of expansions for that so that one is like oh yeah I'd come back to this one this one I'd kind of have to be in the mood right like this isn't as [ __ ] you as like some other games like barrage or uh because at least you're the first step first it's just I'm just [ __ ] you over just to do it you're like cool yeah I'm just gonna pack up you know uh so that's our thoughts on brass Birmingham everyone let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribing everyone for whatever time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new

content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved