Online Board Gaming isn't Real Board Gaming - Spicy Topic!
Transcript
hello and welcome to board stupid my name is Wayne and I'm Matt and it's time for some spicy topic it's a spicy topic side we haven't done one of these in a while yeah we haven't we haven't but um here we are New Year we're starting again with this format as well and um in this one me and Wayne normally discuss something that is a little bit more spicy depending on the on the topic again family family it's not going to be that spicy don't worry that so b game spicy spicy we're ner um but yeah so um but before we go into this this um episode one that did you want to say what it's going to be about yeah absolutely this is whether or not online board gaming is actually board gaming yeah and we got yeah we'll talk about it but first of all hit the Subscribe button so you can follow us every time we got a new read for you so we got a lot of stuff and you can follow us on all our other channels well yeah sub subscribe please this is an online day you welcome to do that this is not board gaming this is just click subscribe and watching us yeah and I will say after that let's go straight into the conversation bam rolling dice feeling nice cboard dreams and gang sches click subscribe it's a Vibe for two all we need what it what's it can for you and me
what what here what you should play see here we go so um as we mentioned before we're going to talk about it is online B gaming actually B gaming and we talk about stuff like um ball game arena tabletop simulator tpia tabletop um there's there's a lot of like simulating the board games that where you go there and you sit in front of your screen you can play with people online and you grab cards or roll dice but in uh in an online virtual environment yes exactly 3D physics engine or whatever it is now is this actually B gaming that's that's SC and there let me tell you let's start let's let me tell you so what inspired this topic so this was inspired by we saw lots of stats at the end of the Year everyone saying you know uh ended by 2024 I paid 5,000 plays of XYZ game and I'm like how did you do it how did you do it how did you do it seem like physically impossible I mean I we play a lot of games and uh there was some of the stats that you read online it's like you physically have to play eight games every day every day of the
year seven like seven days a week 365 days every year and without every seven games it's just like simply impossible how you doing it I mean we both work by probably like 10 hours every day of our actual job that pays for the mortgages and pay for the food The Bard um so and and a little bit like trying to find the round and people were like oh no well I play on on board game online and this yeah and I play like 10 of them simultaneously I'm like okay so I'm I'm absolutely fine of mebody does what whatever but then it was like me and when were like is he actually playing a board game does it count as like board gaming because I've got a very specific idea of board gaming because I'm quite old school because I'm old and so time is flying there's no hair left here he has still still got yeah yeah but so however a few a few what it's but it's all right but here's the thing I've always considered board gaming a tangible physical experience yes right so I think a critical component of board gaming yeah is the pieces and the interacting with the board shuffling the cards rolling the dice moving the bits around like that I think not having that it takes it takes it takes some it takes something away I think it's the part of the soul of it for sure yeah I think my
main beats instead it's like it's the same reason why I'm not too keen on to solo Bard gaming that is the the social experience that you had with with other people I do not do I I've never been tired too much from the solo gaming I tried to but probably it's not for me uh it's because the main reason about why I love this HBY why I love Bard games or whatever General whatever type of whatever difficulty is the fact that you interacting with with you with other the people with all the human beings around the table and every every time you're going to have a a different experience and and different things eliminating that and just playing online yes yes you chat in with someone you chat on a chat to me it's not the same thing and I know that there is a different things but to me it's not yeah I I couldn't agree more I think when we talk I talked about the sole of the the game being the pieces but that's not really true the soul of the game is the people uh interacting with the pieces together right you are creating an experience a social experience which is separate and distinct and different from an online social experience which can be great fun don't don't get me wrong I played something like World of Warcraft for too many years of my life I spent too many years and time on that on that game um and I got some my original Guild that we used to play 20 years ago
because it's yes it's been 20 years um are still we're still close friends and we were experiencing the video game in the video game experience together um but it's not it's not what I want from a board game from the board game which is to bring some people around have a beer or two yeah or whatever drink of your choice interact with the components have some fun in that contained bubble that cre where you lose together and just enjoy each other right board gaming for me has always been kind of a an ex not really an excuse but a way to bring people that I like around my table to all enjoy the thing that we like together and then have a laugh with it and talk about it afterwards and enjoy the experience that we created yeah that's why they did playing online to me doesn't doesn't work however I do as well understand when the people says like okay I do not have time to travel to go to to play a game or I do not have I do not have the actual money to buy that game or I do not have the um a group of people to play that let's talk about an initial Counterpoint then so initial Counterpoint to these arguments about the social magic of Bo gaming is one where okay well maybe you can't make that happen because you are away a lot right or that your friends uh I've moved away a long time and you have time or whatever it is so remote
and online board gaming does make things more accessible for people it it does it absolutely does uh and I'm not saying that something that is bad but still to me then is it's it's a different thing maybe it's still a different things the digital board game experience is a separate I think I think I will do it like once or twice but I will get bored with I have played like enough i' played a bunch during during Co time is a great example um me and friends used to play El horror a bunch we played Spectre Ops we played a few different board games online and yes it was fun for sure I had a great time playing online but it's 100% not as fun for me for me for my perspective it it it loses 50% of the mag magic at least for not being around the table I know because did the same we did a DND D campaign um on uh with different households and uh it was fun up to a certain up to a certain point not having the people in the same room not having that you know cost and like staring exactly that is um that thinks it takes away a lot of these zombies that otherwise you can supplement with with video games absolutely I mean video games are a thing for a reason isn't right so um let's talk about another thing that what I love about the physical presence the
physical board game which is that the cool Factor right the cool factor of setting up an epic game like Rising Sun uh or oath sworn or any of those amazing games where you set it up or Nemesis people come around and then suddenly you're immediately Eng engaged like wow we're so ready to play this we're going to sit around you put the lights down put some music on right you've got got the drinks ready maybe you've a special drink for the occasion something like that and you're all ready to sit down and have a great time and you're in the zone there's something about that magic which can't be replicated no I think it's impossible no you you can't it's the same thing so I did play a couple of try to play a couple of like Warhammer games on online as well on tabletop simulator just like those are not my meaning those are not the one that I painted yeah you can you can train and become the better player I don't that's not what I probably look into a video game into a into ball game so I just want to have fun and I want to have that interaction and that want that seeing the mean of of on the table and be like oh my God this so um and that things you I can't get it I can't get it from an online from an online thing no and because like we were saying the the physical space that you're in um enhances the experience right enhances the experience being around that physical space with each other it definitely adds more to the flavor yeah um also what great thing about uh not being online is you don't
have any issues with technical problems because I do remember during the co times Discord constantly breaking yeah or my mic breaking or wait can you hear me can iar what's going on is or you've got lag or whatever it is well you still got the other things like people asking is it my turn whose turn is it so at least around the table that's not going to happen so much so you can't have technical issues disrupting the flow and I think this actually leads into some of the things I just generally don't like about some board games which we talked about in a few episodes Matt uh which is I don't typically like games with LA integration anyway so the more technology there is in the way of me and my physical pieces the less I tend to like it so and I I can say that about things like Chronicles of crime which people love kind of bounced off me um forgotten Waters and the other ones from the new Crossroads type games um um freelancer completely bounced off me um and I just didn't really I mean and I tried to enjoy I wanted I bought the games I bought them I spent money I wanted to enjoy them there something about the the the digital integration bugged me a lot uh and I don't know what it was if it was just the extra usage of something that wasn't on the board I like my digital and my and my physical things separate yeah fair enough so that's why you're not why I'm not that's why I'm not there folks you won't find me on B but um but I appreciate why people like that they like the ability to be flexible and to suddenly play a game if they're short on time right yeah um I'll
probably play VA game that if it's that but that that's that's me I don't know I just like we always trying to cut out time during our weeks just to play games so we got couple of nights every week that we know that we just going to be playing games and not for the recordings and stuff like that and I do understand that we probably are an extreme that but at the same time if you can't play a ball game tonight I I'll keep I'll keep my will to play ball game for the for the for the next time I don't know I don't feel the urge but we again we are kind of like a special case we we play so much anyway that it's uh it's a little bit it's a little bit different but at the same time I kind of like I don't have the that thing to be like oh tonight I got two hours free I am going to get on BGA and play terraforming M with a random dude from from Kansas and he's going to beat my ass just I say I probably I probably watch a movie or I'll probably pain some or I'll probably I can imagine logging in logging into BJ and playing June imperum with that guy that played a thous like why should I should I play beating my ass for like an hour no no no no it's um I think again it's a different experience I I I do not say that it's wrong people that do it it's
just like I can't force it I did try to force it on me and he doesn't didn't stick so is there something to be said that playing on board game arena or playing in the digital space is more is more competitive if you're playing random people would that make game Space more competitive than just playing in your own home with friends so I guess if you're a very comp yes and I guess if you're a very competitive person and you like a game and you want to win it you go online you want and you want to show off how good you are at that game that you played already a thousand time fair enough it's probably we don't have the time to play the same game of for a thousand time I don't and I I I try um my view of of The Bard games is say Bard games are not competitive competitive in in in the game but uh there is not it's not sport it's it's not a sport it's not a competitive um car game like it could be like I don't know Netrunner or or magic or or stuff like that is missing is missing the the the legs to be overall competitive I know that that now in in Vegas they've been starting of world series bow games I love it as a concept com but it's not like yeah it's not it's not that compar as a war tournament or a or a magic tournament where he's got more legs to be a compet
are things they born to be competitive yeah I think it's the circle that we draw around board games right which I think if we really B down is it's a social physical interactive experience yes right that is awfully fun and enjoyable social experience around board game which are competitive within its framework but outside of its framework that's it so I always think think about this scene um I got two hours of my on my uh I'm like all right when's not around my girlfriend she's not around no one is around I'm going to I want to play a ball game I'm going to sit down in front of my laptop that already been sit down in front of it for 10 hours prior to that for work so I'm just fair enough um and uh I'm going to play Junior per good Imperium with with a dude that is literally will will beat me up like really really badly I still have to play an hour and a half two hours of the game and is it fun no because if if you are beating me at June we creating like um an experience a story that next time are going to be oh last time you did that this time is going to be my it's our friendly rivalry with the dude from Aransas you you're not you're not going to do it no um that's what I don't that's what I don't like the same reason why I don't like the anonymity right yeah yeah exactly it's just like yeah you lost yeah maybe maybe you learn a
little bit more about the game do you need to do it do do you do you need to learn more about how good to be at that game I don't know I don't know we've always thought about board games the beginning and end of it is is it fun right we we love games it's the beginning and the end is it fun we want to have fun doing it and the most fun that we can have in the space is with our friends around the table our partners with each other hanging out enjoying the game um I think putting more barriers in between that like screens I think just starts to slowly degrade the experience to a point where for me it's no longer what I consider a board game no I think it's a simulation of a board gaming that is uh is kind of like a a a boring video game I'm not I'm I'm not saying that that is the truth me it's a boring video games cuz it's you adding complexity to a video game like with your mouse picking up the dices and roll stuff like that I just like it's a boring video game I will prefer play video games before we wrap it up M let's let's talk about a couple more interesting counter points yeah go so let's talk about how the fact that with BGA and things like that it has specific rule enforcement coding where you can't mess up the rules you can't mess up accidentally scoring okay which can be quite good for new players that want to experience a more complex game but maybe don't have uh the confidence or knowledge or experience to like dive into something like I don't know Twilight Struggle or ti4 or whatever
without the help of the additional sort of admin controls yeah that that that's really true because especially like the more complex games you need either someone to teach you yeah teach you the rules really well or you need to spend a lot of times reading books um that that is definitely a plus the fact that you cannot uh involuntary cheat or because that is better the involuntary cheat is of bad just because like makes the game either too easy or too hard it could be go go both both way so that is that is really really good and I guess the next Point you're going to make about an next Pro about it is the fact that you got a larger library of games for cheap for way cheaper to try any number of games for just a subscription yes that is uh that that is a big Pro huge I have to say that that is a big Pro cuz uh um I mean between us we're lucky enough that we can afford to to either buy the game or we got some of the games been sent to us but overall we can play and we go to a lot of conventions and so we we play we get a chance to play a lot a lot of games but if if you don't if you're not um lucky enough that is a definitely a way to play more games to have a a better idea of the games without having to spend every time a lot of money or traveling a lot and and everything seem that um that
is probably is my it's my biggest Pro of all the of all theal online things I think that it's not really beatable yeah unless you got a ball game Cafe near to you where you can go and use the library maybe I mean there are there are quite a lot there are quite a lot but uh if you are that remote and you don't you leave yeah we see Aransas now they me Des is anyone from AR guys can as far as we're concerned it's like a postapocalyptic no one Liv there just one guy with a laptop like I wish that's it uh but yeah that is the biggest Pro again if you can go out and support your local board game CA I will prefer to do that go do that rather than than BG but this is this is me um that's just I yeah again this was nothing against whatever of you guys us it it just like point of view that's not what we here to do and we had a spicy take on whether or not BGA and online digital board gaming is board gaming and that was quite a chat yeah that's it take let rrap it so Matt what an interesting discussion yeah know someone is going to roast me down on the comments I can't wait please let us know in the comments below whether or not you do a lot of online board gaming a lot of digital board gaming please let us know your Pros why specifically you like to do
digital board gaming bja or otherwise um and whether you think it is a experience on par with the physical experience exactly so um again probably are I'm very much against not against but I'm very much on one side when it's a little bit more yeah no I'd rather not no no I'm in person or nothing at all we're both on the on the so please change both on the other side change on mind absolutely yeah so let us know if you think digital board gaming online board gaming is on par with or near the experien in person or if you just like it for different reasons exactly let us know why why you prefer that to video games for example that would be really interesting to know and if you liked this discussion then please consider um hitting the Subscribe subcribe button please absolutely please follow us for all of our content that we release twice a week every single week uh just for you uh and check out the rest of our videos we got lots of these lot topics and lots of other stuff go back yeah and check the library absolutely and we're going to catch you again real soon what you what here what you should play see