Skip to main content
Loading video...

Oath: Chronicles of Empire and Exile Review - By Board Of It

Transcript 16:56

hello everyone tally and farrell here from board of it ah oath the mysterious beautiful highly anticipated board game from acclaimed root and packs premiere designer cole worley for between one and six players oath has stunning components hundreds of individual works of art and has legacy elements without being a legacy game it's described as an experience where players change the course of history in an ancient land and where the effects of one game will ripple through all of those games that will follow now you can consider this review our final word on oath but if you're mainly looking at playing solo or two players we will put out a smaller review midweek based solely on the ai opponent the clockwork prince and our thoughts on him so if that's something you're interested in please subscribe so you know when it goes live oath is a complex opaque game so this overview will in no way cover much of the nuance found here the board is split into three regions with each region having two or three sites which are locations that players can interact with or control you'll play as either the chancellor a

citizen or an exile the chancellor will begin the game in power control at minimum one site and will also hold the title of oathkeeper in each game there will be only one or four goals in play and these goals show how the chancellor can win their win conditions are as follows control the most sites control the banner of the people's favor control the banner of the darkest secret or control the most relics and banners if the chancellor fulfills the swim condition at the end of the fifth sixth or seventh round they will get to roll a dice and depending on the outcome the game will end and the chance will win or it might keep going if they get a bad roll at the end of the eighth round if the chancellor holds the oath keeper title the game ends immediately and they win if you're a citizen you work together with the chancellor and share the same troops so you want the chancellor to win but each goal has a successor goal and if a citizen meets the requirements when a chancellor wins they win instead so you're working against the chancellor some of the time if you're in exile you can also win by fulfilling this goal but you have to maintain the position for two turns or have it at the end of the game if you're in exile you can also win by revealing a vision card and meeting requirements at the beginning of your term the vision cards have the same demands as the four goal tiles described and are always in the deck on your turn you can do any number of

major or minor actions major actions cost supply and this you can think of as a form of action points which will refresh at the end of every turn based on how many warbands you have remaining in your supply major actions are mostly what you'll be doing on your term and these include things such as traveling between sites gaining more warbands you can draw cards and put them into play you can trade for one of the two resources which are favor and secrets you could recover relics and banners or you could campaign which essentially the game's form of attacking you can pretty much attack anything sights relics banners and so on and the way this works is through dice rolling so the attack will roll dice attack dice based on the number of warbands they have on their board and the defender will roll defense dice based on what the attacker has targeted early on in the game you'll be feeling your way around drawing cards maybe gathering power and if you're in exile trying to get hold of a vision card later on you'll make a play for your flavor of win condition which will paint a big target on your back and is sure to turn everyone against you at this point the game becomes savage and only guile ingenuity and maybe a dash of luck will allow you to come out ahead the first game will be tough because oath is very thematic so everything has a name that you'll have to learn secrets favor oath keeper it's

very complex with many sub rules even after playing the first round tutorial you still won't really know what you're doing so you'll just have to start pulling on strings but by the end of your first game you will kind of understand the game a lot more than you think and you understand how the main actions work and i'll tell you that the second game is much easier the more you play oath the more you get back because it has so much depth that the more you play the more you learn its intricacies and you'll see how one system will affect another you'll know how to play the game how to manipulate it in your favor and you'll just end up having more fun one of the coolest things about oath is the fact that every card is unique in its power and in its artwork they really shake up how the game will play out each time and the right card at the right time could allow you to win the game you know they can do things as simple as if you're trading and you're trading on a card that has the same suit as some of your personal advisors you get more free stuff or you could be campaigning against someone and it could be an iffy proposition but if you have access to the right battle plan it could turn that 50 50 into a decisive route it is consistently fun to draw cards enjoy the delightful artwork and then puzzle how to fit them into your strategy honestly the system of how the cards work and the fact that you have personal cards you can use cards at a site where your

porn is at and that you can use cards anywhere from sites you control it's just one of the best aspects of oath that said the high number of unique cars means that this is a game where not all cars are useful some are totally situational some are only great if you're trying to win in a certain way whilst others are either incredibly awesome or completely meh supply is in short supply e so to spend it on drawing a bunch of duds can be very annoying and at worse means that you've wasted much of your time so playing oath oath is at its best in its opening stages you have a fresh start new sites to explore new cars to draw it's a world of opportunities the game board and the world deck put a puzzle in front of you and you get to figure out your own personal solution essentially early game you're allowed to do what you want and oath sings land is easy to obtain and cards are cheap you get a constant sense of progression and you watch your character grow and become strong you're feeling good you have powers from all the cards in play and you decide to make a play for the crown and then all that joy dissipates you see oath suffers horrendously from late game fatigue as soon as somebody's in a position to win or the chancellor will be able to roll at the end of the round everything changes it'll often feel like a totally different game you see some players essentially are going to

have a not fun time and lose their turn because they will be forced to spend all of their supply and their actions just stopping another player from winning just so the game can keep going other players might get to advance their own goal but they'll quickly find that the routes available to them are now very limited really it just becomes very tough and tight and not in a particularly fun way oath has a closed economy and by this point the banks are usually pretty empty so players will struggle to trade and gain favor cards from the world deck also by now very expensive and the sites are usually filled up so there's little opportunity to improve your standing through card play you'll find yourself spending an entire turn's worth of supply on something that would have only cost to supply in the second round worse the end of the game can often be anti-climactic you see sometimes a player will get in a position to win and there's really nothing anyone can do about it but you're all forced to play out an entire round before they can win and often this will be the longest round of the game because everyone's trying to look for a miracle that will allow that not to happen or even more commonly you can find out that you're unable to win it all and then you just have to play out the rest of the game one example would be the dice roll for the chancellor for the chancellor it's exciting sure but for everyone else they just roll a dice and the game ends on a dime and probably just as your engine was getting going it just ends and then you come like oh

one thing that will likely be an issue for some people are the turns oath has issued quick light turns in favor of big turns with multiple actions many of those actions taking a long time now there's no issue with this facet of game design in itself the problem here however is that oath like root is a game where the state of the board is going to change ridiculous amounts between turns and this means that by the time your turn comes around any plans you had likely aren't viable so you'll spend the first couple of minutes of your turn just looking at the board and figuring out what you can actually do then late game when things are tight turns often become glacially slow because you don't want to make a mistake that will cost you the game this means that even at play accounts like three players it can really be eons before your next turn oath is also a game about player interaction there'll be king making there'll be crabs in a bucket even generally who wins is often down to chance rather than strategy multiple times we've seen a single action and one player's turn indirectly allow the following player to get into a winning position oath is dense and complex with actions having ripple effects that cannot be foreseen it's great thematically as it ties in with the whole seizing power and rise and fall of empires aspect just know that often your ability to win

is not so much in your own hands as everyone else's we quite like this because it prevents one player from dominating and if a new player can win they're more likely to be engaged and want to play again oath is a game where when you're in the ascendancy you'll be having a whale of a time but it's very easy for that good time to become pure frustration things can be quite hard to obtain and all too often you'll put in two or three turns of hard work get in a good position have what you need only for literally the next player in turn order to ruin everything and take it all away there's a lot of fun to be had in oath but all too often you're going to come up against pure frustration because of this in the majority of games that we've played at least one player has wanted to concede and even more oath has a terrible habit of making you feel like you're out and it's just completely pointless to play even if you aren't now as a counterpoint i've heard people say that each game of vote is part of the story so even if you're losing you should do all that you can in that case to weaken the future chancellor so then they will have a worse start and you will have a better one and i think this is actually really terrific idea the only issue is is that as gamers we are hardwired to take a board game one at a time and treat it as a single event

so if you're losing it's very hard to keep your head up and keep invested in the game even with that thought in mind so who is oath for coming on to play account if you're only gonna play at two or less we can't recommend it whilst the clockwork prince is a great idea to welcome in a wider range of players it has a tendency to break down or worse it works and frustrates the other players by being too overpowered and then it breaks down uh three players there's a tendency for something to just be passed around in a circle with nobody ever getting closer to winning in the later game at four players plus this is where the game really shines because more players means more roots to victory more variety and more guile so oath is a dense game like this isn't the game that you're going to want to get if you're just going to drop it onto your wednesday wednesday game night once every couple of months you want both if you have a regular group of four plus people who meets like every week and are happy to play this successive game nights in a row that means you'll be getting the best out of the gameplay the best out of the chronicle and the ongoing legacy elements and you'll get to see better how your actions ripple throughout your games honestly this limits who it would be best for and what we should say as the bottom line is if you don't think that you can play this at least five times without deciding if

you like it or not then don't even think about getting it because it will take at least that much to shine speaking of this one of the selling points of oath is that one game will affect the next and you're playing a continuous story which is impacted by the actions of you and your friends we're glad to say here oath really lives up to its promise and is honestly one of the areas where oath really excels all of the sites that are controlled by the winner will shift to become the center of their empire and any cards at those sites will remain in play for the next game which thematically is very cool because they were obviously part of the win and creating that empire you'll also add new cards and lose cards from discard piles and cards played by other players i.e denzians that are part of a failed empire so you're always seeing new cards and introducing new sites this keeps the options available to you feeling fresh and the thrill of discovery alive this is not a game that you have to worry about becoming stale weirdly despite the issues we've talked about oath is tremendously addictive we once played three times in one evening and then the next day i was itching to play again this can provide a lot of fun but like many of cole worley's other games you might find that your first play or two you absolutely loathe it and then a few plays later you'll suddenly find that the clouds are broken and you're thoroughly enjoying yourself when oath clicks and everyone's going for a different goal and people are plotting and scheming and using all their little powers on the

cards you'll have a tremendously rewarding experience and you're going to end up with great stories to tell it's just such a real shame that there's such a thin line between this aspect of oath and the frustration final thoughts oath is a tough game to recommend we believe it will only really shine with certain groups of gamers ones who have four plus members can meet regularly to play it and play repeatedly and that's fine because not every game has to be for everyone the one thing we would say if you're interested is that just no oath walks a tightrope one that very often falls off it's all too easy for players to lose things they've spent a lot of time and effort to gain or for people to end up in untenable positions through no bad play of their own the mechanisms in play here on the issue as they've been proven to work terrifically well in games like innis or comment it's just that in oath they can often lead to players feeling utterly frustrated in the majority of our games we've had at least one player who just wanted to concede and we even have a friend who's refusing to play oath at all now that said oath is a beautiful wonderful addictive game that we always look forward to playing in the hopes that we'll create some interesting stories we're sure that there are people who are going to love oath and enjoy playing it with their group we're just here to give our own opinion if you enjoyed this video we'd really appreciate it if you could give it a thumbs up please feel free to ask us about the

game in the comments and please subscribe to our channel if you're not already yes we'd much appreciate it thanks for watching bye

Progress saved