Menara: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games locked and we are doing a discussion over minara we're on this dexterity game kick um because we played men at work and I think during that discussion we were talking about this one and a few other ones um that you should see discussion for uh but this game was uh always raved about to uh by Z from The Dice Tower and I was like you know what I'm finally just going to pick up a copy um cuz I mean how many Cooperative deck dexterity games are there I think catacombs is yeah I don't know cuz I don't play a ton of dexterity games right um so I don't know yeah and as you can see we did not do well we did well we did well we did not do well enough and we completed the goal yes we didn't complete the game right we're like hey we got our we got our stories awesome oh we have to keep going that's right and then uh this yeah this is I I think this game is an absolute blast but it is weirdly brutal but it's a co-op game to me it needs to be weirdly brutal like to me the best co-op games are the ones you practically never win yes yeah in a fair way in a fair way right but well for me that would be more about the strategy of figuring out how to win this is
definitely this has some strategy oh yeah it yeah it actually does cuz the way we were playing it is different than the way I was playing it the first time where we were basically just going by the seat of our pants right um of like okay let's just flip over and see if we can do them uh but yeah you have a decent amount of control yeah in what you're placing and and some strategy and understand like you might hand tiles over to the pool because you don't need them but you might need them yeah or you might take ones because hey if you fail I don't want to lose that one right now right it doesn't help anybody today mhm but might help them tomorrow if we get the opportunity because there are a couple times where realistic like I just want to dump all those out and put them back in the bag yeah and this is one of the few games where I actually will look at like the the cards in the deck and count cuz it's like okay like can we complete a hard one cuz the game ends in one of three ways regard like you have to have a certain number of fls to win y the game ends if you run out of cards columns or tiles um so it's like eventually you could go the rout of just get the easy ones but eventually the hard ones are going to stay there and then it's like oh that's right we have to do those which is why to me that's where the cool balance is is because if there's like if you can go through the booklet and and say like hey can I complete every single hard one you should do a hard one yeah because that allows you to get the hard ones out and
allows the medium easy ones to be more available so the next time it's like okay yeah going to have some difficulty so play an easy one we'll get something figured out and then work it from there yeah exactly and you don't really see a lot of yeah dexterity games that are one cooperative and and have strategy yeah right um and it's also really one it's really cool because it's it's a fun dexterity game and kind of like what we were talking about with Men at Work how everyone's still involved right uh even though it's competitive this is cooperative so you're everyone's completely involved trying to be like okay do we finish out this section so that we can place that how do we place it where should we place it um and then still relying on everyone being dexterous enough right to you be able to place the columns stop it we win together or I lose uh but that's what makes these games so much fun is that even whenever like you were like placing it and you knocked it it just it's like yep right it's just hilarious instead of like you [ __ ] us I saw you were close and then you went oh hell like what we were in the easy end stage all you had to do was not that yes uh but yeah like so Brett what do you think of the game it's very good you
like it very good um original concept again don't know anything else I can think of that's any kind of dexterity or physical type building type game um outside of like Legos right yeah that's cooperative and and and again a decent amount of strateg decent amount of control of the odds but the odds are still going to catch up with you at some point yeah there's never a time like even whenever you're setting up and actually building the tower it's like okay that's the best it can be structurally sound and it feels so flimsy like and even in the AY stage all we got to do is not touch that edge right but I got to place this one right there yeah and like and the cards aren't so rest I mean there are some for sure that are like like you have to put them all on one tile right uh but for the most part like the one where it's like you would think it's really hard where you have to take one that has one like taking that and having to keep it balanced to like move it down to the bottom or it's like ooh but if we can move it up and place it on there that would get us our our story quota um show so it has kind of like well so it has kind of like what men at work has where you have to balance certain things as you touch them um there's not a whole lot of like balancing you're just building a structure right but like to me me work the structure tends to be a little bit more solid overall yeah there are pieces
that can be not solid after you get past the second layer it's not solid anymore this exactly so it's one of those things where it's like and it's all super kind of unique shapes um yeah it's interesting that they have different quantity for the color of pillars yes so that can get burned you can get burned on that aspect um yeah especially because the cards will dictate what side you have to use and the sides will also one it changes how you would place it m um but also what colors you need right uh but even whenever cuz like I've had the shape before and it was always awful but our random orientation has happened to be like the perfect right spot to to lay it down and it fit perfectly and it was solid and and so it's those type of things that I do think this game shines in and I can understand why Z likes this game a lot it is cooperative it is strategic it's simple again it's two three pages of rules and then basically let's just explain everything like every card yeah that's literally it and what I've done every time I play is I've just kept it open right I'm like I wish I wish I had on the back I much prefer that but uh but is also in four language or the rule book so put on the back would Mak my difficult because it' probably be in German because I think they're German I would I would go out of
my way to say they are a German company um but what's also insane is there are three levels of difficulty where it's that easy goes you have to have three aor of three mediums four hards five right and that also dictates how many columns you have in your hand based off the number of players so if we were playing on hard difficulty at three we'd only have four tiles like in our hand or four columns sorry not tiles four columns wow if you're playing with four it's the same so you have four people who have four columns and you have to create a tower of five stories high right yeah while also come to think of it even without the Dexter aspect it's it's not a bad game no exactly even if you didn't have to worry about things falling over yeah like that's that's insane but what great about that is it doesn't become like they don't add all this extra [ __ ] to make it hard it's literally the same like it's just limiting you now are more limited on what tiles you have way more counting on the like okay I know for a fact there's 30 yellows six blue eight white yeah um like I bet people who play this on hard are like so meticulous about like what's getting placed okay now you always hold a white cuz for this tile like just weird [ __ ] that like people people do um but I like the camp aspect and that's also for the fact that that's five cards at the beginning if you can't fulfill a construction it's not like well you lose it's just like add it now
you have to have an extra floor right um and there's no way to remove it right you have an extra floor to do yeah which is just insane I have never won this game it is so difficult right um but like yeah I agree with you any Cooperative game should be difficult because if you win it all the time then you figured it out then what's the point right um I think there was actually an expansion for this game too no idea where uh I'd even find that I actually had to buy this secondhand cuz I couldn't it was out of stock everywhere um yeah rituals and ruins I don't know what it adds but let's see what it says uh oh new challenging floors of the ruins provide unique tests of skill so five new types of construction plan cards eight new Temple floors the tiers of the Gods red and blue crystal stones the cards of Fate 13 rituals H 10 oh scenarios man that's a lot yeah they don't make expansions like that anymore they usually make like like one map for a game and then it's like okay 30 bucks right so do you guys have any negatives on the game think anything yeah no so I guess my follow-up question would be do you like dexterity games when they're competitive or cooperative because we've played both this uh and Men at Work and they're both
I mean they're both dexterity based building games I probably like them the same okay amount because like minute work still invest in everybody else's turn even though it's competitive and think like Jenga I'm still invested in everybody else's turn true yeah like I'm trying to think like especially for dexterity cuz realistically I'm kind of waiting for you to fail competitive when it's competitive and when it's not competitive I'm looking for you to be successful yeah right and so I'm investing on your turns because of that yeah aspect where like you can have abstract board games where you have multiple people I don't care yet because the board State isn't a point where I can make real 100% decision gets yeah so do you care um I do but that has more to do with my personality yeah um I difficult games I prefer Cooperative sure um for the simple fact that you know I'm we're all trying to do something hard together instead of we're each trying to outfigure each other yeah or or set it up so that you have to do something that's almost impossible yeah um but know minute work is great yeah but this this would be my preference it is interesting because it's like in in the dexterity genre specifically it's like competitive almost has an unfair Advantage because it's like well if I'm more dexterous than you then I have a better chance of succeeding sure
regardless it doesn't matter what the game is if I'm just more skilled then I'm most likely going to win and in The Cooperative sense it's you're only as strong as your weakest link if someone isn't as dexterous then you're trying to actually course correct right um and I like that I I feel bad in competitive games like that where it's like well you're you just can't physically do it so it's not fair inherently um but here it's like okay how can we make it easier on on you if okay if you can't reach or something oh now I see what you were doing what yeah what you were trying to make it easy on me the whole time no yeah this is me just like really just di that bre I mean if you're wearing a burgundy shirt I mean you just kind of just one like if you're well into your 50s like you just these games are no but I mean that's the thing it's like you in a Cooperative setting which actually I lean more towards um you're you're incentivized to try and make everyone on the same playing field cuz otherwise if you're just like well I'm going to make it easier on me well you're going to lose if someone's like oh let me just try and reach for that oh and then you lose and you're like right for the record that was a genuine mistake I didn't no I you you really didn't want to play anymore just look at the the recording you're just like why would you do that no I know and it's funny cuz I was looking at and I'm
like oh yeah he's going to go for the white but subconsciously I was like why do I feel like he's going to bump that and it was like the slightest nudge too hell I think you even like went to lean forward and it was like like just careful SpongeBob careful SpongeBob it wasn't the stable as I thought it was right um so yeah well on a scale of 1 to 10 what are you guys giving
Manara eight eight what do we give Men At Work We give like a 10 didn't we I think so yeah yeah each of us I'm goingon to say 10 yeah yeah no I mean again for a dexterity game I I like the theme of men at work better I like that construction that does go a long way I think Men at Work is more inherently fun because it's chaotic this doesn't feel chaotic to me this feels very meticulous and strategic where the dexterity matters more I don't know if that makes any sense but like see I'm probably actually the other way to me it's almost a strategic game that has dexterity thrown into it this one yeah that's what I'm that's what I meant is Men at Work is more chaotic where it's it's like funnier and and more lighter because it's like because because it's competitive you shouldn't be taking it too seriously so you're in more of a jier mood whereas here you're like methodically thinking about what's in the camp what what what's in the deck what's in the bag what's in the box and that's that's for me like cuz man work feels more like what I consider a dexterity game yeah it's just pure can you move this piece onto this following the rules how are you like trying to balance those bricks on the [ __ ] there's no I mean there's strategy in the sense like okay I need to put this to try to get a certain reward so I'm winning cuz it's higher than everything else yeah or I'm going to put this I know it's stable enough to hold but it's going to make everybody else more life more difficult so I'm kind of gambling
on the fact that someone's going to knock it down before it gets back to my turn right this is almost exclusively all right what cards still in there yeah can I complete this should we complete this what's the next TI and then basically to make it challenging it's make it Dex yeah make make it balance yeah cuz there was not a single move I made in me at work that I was like methodically planning every time it came into my turn it was like okay what's the new what's the new task to try and come with and then it's like oo this is fun it becomes it quickly devolves into chaos and here you're trying to create structure out of it right um so it it is actually interesting that even though I like the dexterity has a co-op better I actually would rate this a nine yeah um which is just one point under Men at Work yeah uh and that's why for me it's an a it's because to me it's like if I'm going to play a dexterity game this isn't the dexterity game I'm going to pick you're probably going to be in a more joke or having like bear and pretzels kind of mood right where this is like now if the group is exclusively Co-op players they don't want to play competitively yeah this is the game I want to pick for the next game but if I want to your dexterity which is again beer and pretzels where our Cofe shop laughing up yeah I want something Sil yeah I don't see anyone like laughing while playing Manara it's not like it doesn't come off to me as like a cuz we were laughing at
Men at Work this we play games of this like okay wasn't fun at all I'm not saying it wasn't fun I'm just saying it wasn't a a different mood it's a different idea but I like the idea it's a strategy game with a dexterity element yes as a strategy game I I probably rate this higher yeah right right but as a dexterity game because that's what I think they're kind of going for it's an eight for me yeah but what's cool is you like a lot of people it's like oh I I only won a few dexterity games in my collection or one you can own this and Mena work specifically because that's the one we've played most recent and you're going to get different um feelings out of both of them so you could own both and have for different reasons for but still get your dexterity kick right so yeah yeah so uh 89 10 yeah cool all right well that's our thoughts on Manara let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you