Skip to main content
Loading video...

Defenders Of The Wild Review: Can You Save The Commonwood?

Transcript 21:26

eating beforehand it's probably a bad idea do you want water no it's okay okay now my throat just feels like coated it's like oh yeah it's okay fine grease Hello everybody welcome back to the channel today my name is Carly and I'm Kim and today we're going to be reviewing the brand new one to four player game Defenders of the wild from outlandish games

so in Defenders of the wild we you are playing as one of the four factions the machines have kind of come over and taken over the Earth and you're playing together you're putting your differences aside you're putting your distress aside I might not trust the coven but as a sect we realize we need to work together work together to get rid of the Mach get rid of the machines Beckham is eating a screwdriver so yeah so Defenders of the wild was a game that was on Kickstarter not too long ago and it just recently has started kind of fulfilling two backers I know the very first thing when I saw this game was I was like that's a lot smaller than I thought it was going to be I thought it was going to be a much bigger box um so yeah it's kind of like a smaller kind of more compact game so for this review we're going to be sharing everything that we liked and didn't like about this game but before we jump into that we're actually going to be giving you a really kind of General overview of how this game plays and then we'll come back and share our thoughts on Defenders of the wild War has come to the wild in Defenders of the wild you and up to three other players will be working together to heal the land and outsmart a seemingly impossible enemy the machines at the beginning of the game players will select a faction either the order the council the coven or the sect and gain all corresponding player pieces the factions that are in play will also determine what bonus actions are in play for that particular game players will also have to decide what character they will be playing as and gain the necessary cards that make up that particular character's deck you will Shuffle this deck then draw three for your starting hand players will also choose one of their faction home habitat

hex's next to the perimeter of the game board as the location for their starting camp and then randomly assign the first player Defender Of The Wild is played in rounds each round has an organized phase and an action phase in the organized phase players will secretly choose a Defender card from their hand to play before simultaneously flipping over all chosen Defender cards to reveal to all other players after this occurs players cannot begin communicating and strategizing together moving on to the action phase players now can take as many actions as shown on the lower left of their active Defender card these actions include things such as moving building camps healing clearing pollution or destroying mechs you must be aware that when you take actions near Mech you will take damage you will also take damage when you clear toxic SES and if you ever take damage that results in exceeding the maximum of three damage tokens another player must randomly choose a Defender card from your hand this Defender is killed and placed under the death token corresponding to that defender's habitat after taking all desired actions that player will then draw and resolve one machine card each type of machine card deploys moves and manages a specific set of machine components but the general purpose of the machines is to spread pollution shoot out Hunters create walls and factories when locations become too polluted they become toxic too many toxic locations will make you lose the game along with too many factories being built here are the three ways that you can lose this game the first is if all five Factory tiles had been built and a factory card orders the machines to build the final Factory tile the next is if all six toxic sites have spread

across the game board and a factory card orders the machines to spread more toxic sites and the last is if two Defenders from the same habitat are killed if any of these occur the game ends and all players lose to win the game all players must have built all of their camps and also rewi all of the factories the machines have built if this happens the game ends remove the machine core from the board and place all characters on the center base tile to celebrate your Victory together all right so I really hope that overview kind of gives you a general idea of how this game operates and plays but let's go ahead and start by chatting about everything that we' liked or enjoyed about this game Kim is our do do you want to start yeah um the thing that uh I think sticks out the most for me is how well the theme incorporates into like the mechanics of the game yes absolutely we've played a lot of games this year where like the mechanics are super fun but like the theme like and I like the idea but they just don't yeah they just don't they don't mesh right but in this game the theme definitely sorry Becca he grabbing our feet the theme and the mechanics definitely like it all makes sense together it comes through really strong and it makes for like this really fun experience you definitely feel like you're this faction that you're and you're like joining forces with the other factions to try to like Rew the

land that's one of the things like I loved the most is how well it just came through and everything that you did this game you really actively have to be working with everybody because the machines they move so fast it definitely is one that keeps you on your toes you have to work together but then you also have your own own thing that you're trying to accomplish like we all have these camps our individual camps that we are trying to build in our habitats if I build all my camps before like Carly does as soon as I'm done building my camps I exit the game you exiting I'm out of the game and it's like up to Carly to try to finish everything afterwards yes so you really do have to try to work together to like and kind of be like even a little bit still you don't want one person to just like jump ahead and suddenly be like build their last camp and be like see yeah because then that last person is there to defend for themselves something else I really liked about the game is that you obviously you take on a color and then you choose between two leaders that you want to be playing as and what makes it kind of interesting is that each leader has kind of like different cards from the other leaders I like that variability and I liked how there really are a lot of different combinations that you can do yeah especially if you're playing with two or three or four like that changes I've yeah I've played two three and four player in this game and that does change a bit bit because if

you're playing with two player you're not going to have access to all of the the power token these are the graveyards aren't they those are the graveyards it's okay Power tokens right here power tokens right here so like we have this set up for a two-player game and so we're only going to get the bonus action token and the destroy Mech pollution token but if you play with like all four then you'll have access to potentially to all all so it does like make the game feel different we kind of mentioned the box size is I feel like this game has a really good punch for kind of like a smaller box siiz game right it feels kind of almost like a bigger game in a sense and I feel like this very much it could have been a bigger game but I love that they kind of I don't know how to describe it it feels like just a really great weight for like a smaller box game like the setup doesn't feel like a lot the components don't feel like they're overly you know overly big or anything but yet the game just has a really good punch despite all that yeah and like adding to that or along those lines I really like all the components in the game the artwork is super fun I love how all of the cards they are different characters and so there's different work on all of them for the individual characters and it feels like like when you're playing the doctor like it feels like you're playing that doctor right and the artwork is not duplicated on other cards so it feels like very unique which I really liked another thing that

I liked the way the engines like work it's just it is a little bit like a little bit confusing and we'll I'll get into that but as the engines are moving along the board there's just something building the walls as they're moving there's just something so like I don't know fun and suspenseful like watching it happen because it's just like oh no it's leaving this trail of walls and then at other times they're going to like be spitting out the hunters so they like shoot out these hunters and then the hunters are going to come get you um yeah I just liked the way that the machines worked in this game and I like how you know everything starts from the center and it does spread out it's not a game where like all of a sudden this pops up over here this pops over here it really does feel like the pollution and the mechs and everything are actually spreading across the board another thing that I really enjoyed in gameplay you have your Defenders that you play you only get to add cards to your hand or like as you're playing your Defenders you're going to be decreasing how many you have and you don't get to draw a new cards to your hand until youve built a c one of your camps and then that's when you get to draw more cards yes and so like it adds this like I like hand management a little bit to it and especially like the other thing that it's fun and in terms of like hand management is that if you have two

um Defenders that are from the same habitat in your hand I can play so I can play Billy who has a who can give me four actions and then if I want to do a fifth action I can play a card to increase that that give myself a fifth action today but then you lose that but sometimes you really want to be able to get that extra action in before like to get rid of the pollution or to rewi something because the next time it comes around to your turn y maybe it's become toxic I don't know so it's just it was just yeah this fun you said hand management component to the game um I think the last thing that I kind of wanted to touch on was I really liked it felt like there were ways that the game was kind of helping you out a little bit I don't know if that's the right term but kind of what I mean by that is like for example like when you die or if you get you know if you get your all of your damage you can only take three damage and if you were even though you get maxed out you're still okay it's like if you happen to take one more damage than just one of your character dice but you're not like out of the game it's not super super punishing it felt like okay some CU that that does strategy that you could use is sometimes you might need to Max yourself out to be able to get done what you need to get done and sometimes it's worth it to sacrifice one of the people from your hand you just don't want to sacrifice too many you just don't want to sacrifice too many yeah and so yeah but some sometimes it is worth

it there's a kind of little stuff like that that didn't in my opinion make the game feel like it was too punishing yes it's a hard game but it didn't necessarily feel like I was being punished for the actions that I was doing I agree with that especially in terms of like if I'm thinking about when there's pollution like on a site you get to remove all the pollution that's on yeah exactly it's not like you just have to remove one pollution at a time it's when you remove pollution you just get all of it off or like when you are healing you can remove all all of it at once and then the other thing that I was thinking about was with the the mechs um whether they're hunters or snipers it doesn't matter how many there are um shooting at you so like these are the snip snipers if I'm there they're going to shoot at me if I do an action there but I only have to roll the dice once y you don't have to roll it for single yeah for me made the game more enjoyable and wasn't like oh man I'm just drowning you know that wasn't something I thought of previously like oh yeah you're right one final thing that I really liked and thought was interesting and I don't know if I've played a game that does this before I don't know maybe but it seems new to me is the way that movement works if I am playing uh this character who likes the water this is all considered like adjacent to each other because you can just move straight through and that's like considered one and like statically it's because I'm so familiar with the water habitat it

doesn't take extra time to maneuver through it to maneu maneuver through it yeah it was add it also to the like not too punishing exactly the game is kind of giving you these like little helps yeah we know it's hard but but and it's also like it works thematically too yes we've talked a lot about what we liked about the game let's go ahead and jump into maybe little nitpicks that we have stuff that we didn't like or stuff that we could potentially um see others not liking so one of the things that ID mentioned to Carly that was like a little yeah fiddly slightly nitpicky is that the consistency of of things I was when you place the third pollution token on a site it just automatically becomes toxic ooh take them off okay now it's toxic for everything else when you have like these tokens that you're placing and I don't know what it's just yeah consistency so when I get hurt I place three but I don't but you're still not dead yeah I'm not dead it's not until you place you were are getting a fourth one so like if I were to get a fourth one then I lose one of my characters M with the toxic sights you don't completely lose until so they're all out everything is toxic but you lose if you had to put another one exactly yes and then the same thing with the factories like they're all out but you don't lose until you would have to put another one

so like for whatever reason I wish for consistency purposes I wish that it had been okay there's three pollution things and then when you had to take the fourth one then it becomes toxic so that was like my first little like uh I guess nitpick the very first thing that kind of caught me or the first thing that I kind of noticed was I wish and there there definitely like are images and pictures in the rule book I wish there would have been a little bit more cuz there were times where I was reading through and it was explaining something and I'm just a very visual person and so as I was reading through it I just kept having to flip and reflip and go back to what they were actually talking about I just wish there would have been more images cuz it would have helped me jump into this a little bit quicker the setup like it's talking about setup and there's like no pictures it's like no I need like I need like visual representation in a b c d and I can just quickly go through for the defender special abilities it has them all written here but and most of the time they're pretty ex self explanatory and you can understand what they mean but there were some here and there where it felt like I wanted just to be a little bit more clear and I talked about the engines and the building the walls and like how like fun that was but it was also a little bit like what was the word you used earlier F yes fidly um especially when it came to the points where like the sorry I say like a lot I'm going be aware of it especially

when it came to the points where you are running your engine is running into a wall and then when that happens then it gets to reset and and then the car tells you that the engine will reset from the highest numbered Factory so say this had been built over here and then it gets to deploy from here or something but as you start building more walls and factories the engine starts running into things or sometimes they run into each other and then there's a lot of hedge cases there's a lot of stuff where you'll be playing and you'll encounter something you're like well what do we do now and I feel like the rule book didn't give me the clear enough answers to find the exact like the exact this is what you do in this scenario so we would just kind of have to make our best guess you know because that does happen a lot with the machines yes cuz yeah they're going to they're going to the engines are going to be running into walls or into each other or into the factories and then you're going to have to reset them but then and then it's like okay well then want order because like Yeah because sometimes they'll be doing something at the exact same time and yeah it's just it's just a little fiddly it is and that was just a little confusing and sometimes I felt like we were cheating then because we're like well I I can't my brain is not figuring out how this is supposed to go so let's just go ahead and put it right here put it right there yeah all right so what would you rate this game let's let's jump into ratings I am coming in at a nine a nine

oh my goodness I love it yep I am I enjoy a good Cooperative game I had a really fun time playing this with my family I was initially afraid that like maybe like it would seem a little syy game to game but because of the challenge and because of the variability and being able to play like the different hands and like you have four factions but like it actually feels like there's eight factions side of that you get to pick from and then the being able to add the difficulty level like I feel like I want to keep playing this game I want to keep ex trying to master it and see like oh what can we do to to accomplish it for that reason like just the theme and the fun and the togetherness like we were able to have a really fun time so it has a nine for me for for that reason yeah I really want to give this game like an eight but I think the fiddle like I feel like I'm in between a 7.5 and eight because I think it is a little bit a touch too fiddly for me personally to make it to that eight level if it would have been a little bit more streamlined had stuff a little bit more kind of intuitive and clear this would be an easy eight for me um I think I am going to come closer to a 7.5 having said that though I really really did enjoy this game and I really just love the card play and everything that you're personally doing right you're trying to manage your cards and you want to make

sure that you are staying on top of building your buildings and being able to build your buildings so that you can continue to have that card reeven but you don't want to push it too far because then you're out of the game and you're leaving other people to to work the mech on them um for themselves and you're just you're out by that point so I love kind of that push and pull that you're that you're kind of trying to um balance everything so there's a lot about this game that I really like for me the only thing that is bringing it down from an eight is just it's a little bit too t a little bit too fiddly for me and I wish the world book would have been a little bit more intuitive it kind of a little bit a barrier to entry in my opinion so that's the only thing that's pulling it down but if you can push through those things I really do think this is a great game the way that I thinking of the game as like if rot you're in rot and you have the different like you're playing as the different factions in rot and then it's like and you're battling each other in rot so I kind of think of like it's not related to root at all like this is not a sequel to root but in my mind I have this story that I've now told myself like oh these robots are coming to like rot and now we have to decide to work together instead of fighting each other because it does talk about how like and honest we're suspicious of each other in a weird way it kind of feels like a root light almost it kind of feels like that I'm not going to go as far as say like this is a lighter version of root CU it's not but it gives me similar Vibes all right so those were our thoughts and ratings for Defenders of the wild I wanted to give a huge shout out to outlandish

games oh so K I wanted to give a huge shout out to outlandish games for sending us this copy to review for you today and if you enjoyed this video and you haven't yet subscribed to the channel it means so much if you could do that really helps support us in everything that we're doing over here but until next time I hope you have a great rest of your day and we'll see you later if I get even one comment saying oh it's too early to decorate for Halloween I'm going to freaking lose it if people can decorate for like Christmas you know like super in advance and it's wildly accepted that's what I say it is never like listen to me it is never too early to decorate for Halloween I mean summer summerween what was that summer summerwe is that what it was called I summerwe that's a real thing it could be Halloween needs to be just a yearr thing just just live in your your witch I will I live in my witch era y MH

Progress saved