Skip to main content
Loading video...

Detective: City of Angels {Sleuth Variant} - Discussion

Transcript 17:35

viewer discretion is advised everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free on your book with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audible.com for word /bg unlock the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey everyone welcome to a no run-through review over detective City of Angels the sleuth alternate variant if you don't know the sleuth mode is basically a solo mode or a fully cooperative mode to hear what we thought of the game in its classic mode where one person plays the chisel or the GM go check out their actual discussion and run-through of that here we're just only going to be talking about what our thoughts are on the game in its sleuth form so what'd you guys think Oh much better you think so this it brings my score really yeah really um it definitely does bring my score up as well by uh obviously because it brings it up mainly because this is really really good in co-op and I also think it's really good and it's classical oh yeah as well so basically they made two forms of this game where their main idea was to do the chisel the classic mode so you think that they would doesn't focus more on that and then be like ah who gives a about the other one but it still worked out like amazingly I have a

few I wouldn't say negative things about it well for do you guys have any negative things about the uh um I have to my only negative that comes to mind at the moment is that with it being three players and it's only the second case so it's easy yeah we did the murder at Sunset Boulevard because we wanted to for the run through we did the very first case which is still a gumshoe and to test out the sleuth mode we also did another easier case with it being easy like we had double the time that we did the first game yeah and we had it solved by yeah by three turns in yeah yeah yeah that's true that's but that's just because the difficulty setting I'm sure if we were to do a veteran or our or hard-boil don't know about hard point in their pants yeah I feel like bet I think it was this person let's check was English yeah and then I I had my moment of clarity there right at the end we're like let's just solve it yeah yeah there was that and that's one of my biggest negatives and it could only be because we've done it at the easier 1:12 terms might not even be enough for a veteran or even a heart or hardboard that really have to go and don't a double overcome yeah yeah yeah

so but it is kind of annoying that you have to wait for the final guess which is which and that's what makes a little bit different but yeah that's one of my negatives um the other negative I have about the sleuth mode which it's not really a negative like I said it's just something of kind of it's something to bring up so a discussion topic doing this um I kind of feel like with with the sleuth mode you then turn this game into something that is already done in five other games yeah like you have the chronicles a crime detective modern crime meet the four other games and Sherlock Holmes and hell there's even another one that's really really old called witness which is similar so yeah five other games so then it doesn't really differentiate itself enough in the sleuth mode what do you guys think about that um you're not wrong yeah um it definitely turned into uh it's a cooperative whodunit yeah yeah because then the other ones like like someone like detective in chronicles they're not always whodunit like no we just like in the last ones we did four both of those it was like oh like there's some dark dark yeah like um well I will say though is like this kind of has a little feeling of Chronicles and Sherlock Holmes because instead of an app reading everything you have the

sleuth book which i think is awesome the sleuth case book I think this is really really neat but what it takes from chronicles of crime is that you can go to these people with individual things and ask them about stuff versus Sherlock where it's just here's you get what you get if you're the right ass yeah well it's more um like it's more cut-and-dry like if you find that information in Sherlock Holmes you can't go back to someone else and ask them about it in this and in chronicles you can yeah which I always think is fantastic because I always hated that Sherlock it's a great now I have to kind of juice and figure out hello but that person must have been lying which is still fine like they were wrong them but it's more and more these games come out Sherlock keeps going to the bottom and all these other ones just keep keep going up um but with with that being said I feel like and is still a great testament to this game is that I do think you're missing something without the chisel just a little bit you don't have that tension you don't have that competitive nature of like home and whether whether they find out you know that I would also like to find out great yawning hands like you can you have no reason to be tired so I've only been awake for three hours um but yeah so whenever you have the chisel giving you that you can see and

you can also feel like oh well you know what did they say what options did I have is he telling the truth and then oh he can get leverage over me you missed that competitive nature but if you don't like the competitive nature then you have a really good cooperative mode a good very well and he'll even a good solo mode like grant all of them can be played solo so it really changes everybody think do you think about that in particular do you think you were missing out on anything with the co-operative no no um it's fair to say that the chisel is like you know what gave this game its edge of that unique aspect but I mean I personally I enjoyed the cooperation better yeah yeah because you're not like oh well I suck at this so and I will say um like we played we played noir jazz music over which helps a lot but yeah you do have a more interactive experience yeah with with the cooperative nature versus the classic mode because not all hoarding information and just doing your turn and then only really interacting with the the chisel and here it's this constant flow of conversation because it's like oh well what should we do next what shall I ask him about in and just kind of figuring out the story but yeah I mean really like - not a whole lot because like if you want to know more but we thought that the game

itself go check out the the other discussion um but the way they kind of make this still fit the theming is that you can still challenge the the people you can still search locations and they come with these question cards but I think is really cool that tells you what paragraph to go in the sleuth book and then what's a search and there's no yeah there's no good information you literally only do your actions and and then the big twist is that there's a final guest marker that goes up based on how much stress you get and you get stressed when you incorrectly challenge which then flips it over once you get three and it goes up and you just shorten the amount of days which like I said the game could be like incredibly like oh wow what are we gonna do in harder part of analysis that you I also will say I do like that they have the different difficulties I like that sure life doesn't have that such a case and there are some that are easier than others but for the most part uh yeah I I thought I thought this was still a lot of fun and felt just like the other ones so I don't know which one I'd rather play like I'm honestly torn which one would you rather play the chiseled one or the fully cooperative I mean cats fully cooperative so I think for me it'll depend on amount of players catch him oh yeah I feel like if we had

a third detective the like four total players yeah dizzle okay I feel like that would do a lot because obviously was just down to like what information did she get what did I get and then we're just kind of copying off one another with a third person that opens up so much more so I would say three or more detectives and then the chisel yeah that would be better with that would that would be better yeah and then cooperatively this felt great yeah three three people yeah I feel like 3:00 is really and just a good place one two five so basically you're saying four to five players for chisel three or less cooperative sleuth okay great with that i think i think that's a fair fair assessment because you're right it with the chisel it is just youtube like going after each other yeah the third one would be like oh would you find out and they he can to go on two completely different paths um and like one person's case could be completely cold and then and the snap of like their fingers they've found out what the other two have and then are on the trail yeah like I like the aspect of that so fork like four or five players with the chisel three or less with the slew the sleuth

yep I mean that that hits nail right on the head for me the other thing I want to reiterate is that the voice-over is is almost a must go on their website van rider Gamescom I think is whether it is and fine because they read the briefings which does such a good job with it I almost wished that he did the epilogues

yeah I think I always been really nice but I I very much like the epilogues I always loved that in any of them though like Sherlock whenever it's this long as you feel accomplished yeah and you're like oh yeah we did it and this one was really cool at how you went to the paragraph - because what you do is you write your suspect weapon and motovan and you add up numbers and that tilts you the paragraph to go - and then it tells you oh if the detective says congratulations you did it if not then you go into overtime and it gives you plenty of chances of overtime and then if you go overtime twice and it's like okay you failed um I am well here's here's the other thing that kind of now really upsets me but it's like well I really liked about the chisel was once again the banter well not really mean physically saying it but the reactions though I could give you and then I can give her um I feel like I was kind of missing that in the sleuth mode because there wasn't any of that like if I was looking at the case for this one in where whatever book here we go the chill whole book in the chisel book for the for the second one and we can look at it now those are all the options we had yeah there's like double the amount yeah so we're missing a lot of options and a lot of things that they could say now some of it is actually it's still things that we thought we were told and maybe maybe that maybe they're actually all the same like the

same and it just looks like there's more verses in the book but it's it's so good like so uh yeah I mean I like that I just I really really liked it so it's going one to ten you can hustle score was a seven score was a seven and with the coop I would bump it up because I really liked detective games I bump it up today have 8.5 yeah that's a pretty significant jump would you agree with Josh would you like the chisel like classic mode at four or five maybe okay yeah yeah Josh this is nine nine yeah um I am at a nine point five because I can't imagine that the case is getting harder being any less fun in fact I actually want them to be harder because like I love the struggle and trying to figure that we had that for a little bit in this one but then like once we kept getting more and more information and since there were three of us just constantly getting information there was no but whether you know whether y know whether she no yeah trying to come up with our own solution that one and that's what I'm saying about I'm missing something because we all were like we can all just harass her and that there were just like 12 12 questions exactly and you just get all the information regardless so you don't have that like okay well instead of me asking them I'm just gonna go to where they're at and figure out what you have because you have a specific card that I cannot get

so that's the kind of thing that I'm missing but still like with with the added difficulty of the cases with both modes being available and equally good depending on your playstyle and it's just that's balanced yeah that's amazing our this company van rider games and the crime story by Evan Derek fantastic job like van rider is just there there enough incoming company I feel like big score was surprisingly it was a lot of fun even though we never we set it up in first time player were like oh this can be stupid and like overly complicated and then come off the games always seem way more complicated than you play in you're like oh okay this is pretty straightforward yeah so yeah with big score we were like this is a lot of fun that we played in it's still a fun even though I lost and then hostage negotiate like it the companies like that you make good games make me want to go cuz I seen hostage negotiator before and I was like doesn't anything fun but since their games have been a two out of two for me I'm like well actually check out their other one stone Meier was the same way I'm like I gotta play all their games ube might actually be that way with Indian summer so just companies that do solid worry they may have misses hostage something like suck ass but you never know but the fact that they still do really good work if they don't just over produce and make the same game over and over it's just it's just a testament to what gaming can still do especially when they're kick-started because I don't

think this company would even be around if that's the glory of Kickstarter but although anyway so oh it also says 30 to 50 minutes or to 150 minutes that seems well right like so that and I didn't feel like it was already long and even with detective games if it's like like like integrated and you like are involved in it the entire time you could be like oh wow that case took three hours holy like I was involved the entire time though so time flew it doesn't feel like it dragged at all yeah no there's not one thing whenever we were pretty sure of the answer we were still like still invested in the story instead of like oh come on now if we had to wait no I dad would have comedy like news like this is stupid so technically we cheated cuz we're like let's just go ahead and guess I guess if you can in the wood then you'll just say okay now you're in the overtime like that could be your punishment if you got it wrong house rule it yeah yeah that's that's our thoughts on detective City of Angels the sleuth mode if you know what we thought that the classic mode go check out the regular discussion and watch the run-through but let me know what you think of the sleuth mode in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day there's for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and write nice to that subscribe button it's a little bell click that so you get

notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you

Progress saved