Windmill Valley Duel Review - The Biggest Duel Game Yet!
Transcript
Game designer Danny Garcia was shot out of a cannon as he started his career, designing hits like Barcelona, a Windmill Valley, and even this year just recently, Gotti. Well, today we're going back to the Windmill Valley, looking at tulips trying to get them, but this is Windmill Valley Duel, a two-player only game that just came out of Essen. It was on my most anticipated games for Essen list. I finally got a chance to play it. So hello my friends. Today we're going to be taking a look at Windmill Valley Duel and my thoughts on it on the other side. We'll see you there.
Before I get to the moment you've been waiting for, I wanted to tell you about finding your Grail game at Noble Knight Games. Grail Games are games that you've always wanted but are no longer in print and very hard to find, hence finding the Holy Grail. Noble Knight buys and sells pre-owned games and developed a condition grading system from 30 years of experience from buying and selling games so you know exactly what you're getting. Maybe it's the top 100 game Mex versus Minions and you don't want to wait a year for the next printing, or maybe the slipcase version of the classic game Acquire from the 1960s. So go on your Holy Grail quest at Noble Knight Games by clicking the link in the description of this video or on the eye up there in the upper right. Now it wouldn't be Windmill Valley Duel without a bunch of windmills, would it? Now these are really good for end game scoring, but we'll get to these later.
Now this is the biggest quote unquote duel game that I've seen. It's actually a full six panel board. It's much larger than I thought it would be. Now the action selection system revolves around these interlocking gears between both players. Now on your turn you'll be turning your gear clockwise one or two spots or possibly more if you're spending tools as a currency. But let's say we just went one spot. You'll be selecting either the one on your side or the one in the middle or again if spending a couple of tools you can actually do both of these. But you're always paying attention because after your action the other player is going to get to do this action as a follow action or just take some money. And of money you can take from that action is more and more as you get closer towards the end of the game. And these actions do all sorts of different things like going to the market where you can spend money to get tulips like one or three coins for two or three white or black tulips respectively, or maybe you want yellows or reds, or maybe you take a face down tile which you can spend nothing and even get some of the two lesser valuable tulips.
Well, what are you doing with these tulips? Well, sometimes we take in a ship action to do foreign trade with those tulips like, hey, I'm going to be able to turn in one yellow tulip for three points. But guess what? Now the next time someone does it, it's actually less points. But you also get an additional action which will change right after this time too. So next time the ship comes here, that action will be different. Or other times you might be planting one or two tulips and placing any color on one of these edges and getting a bonus like one point or even maybe additionally two points. Once one's placed, the same color has to be placed next to it. And maybe a little bit longer, someone else places a red here. So now it's going to be either a red here, yellow here. That's it for this sort of planting harvest spot. And this is important because you might be placing windmills, spending coins like three to place this single windmill. And we're placing one of the windmill spots here and this is important for end game scoring because this windmill now is touching three yellow here and three yellow here for six yellow.
And that's going to get you six points because everyone here. But the better tulips allow you to place more and more windmills which cost more over the course of the game, but actually help you with the multiplier. For each one of these there, you'll get a point for every one of these tulips so you can multiply those at the end as well. You might be gaining upgrades and taking these action upgrades and either placing them on the central wheel, getting what's below it immediately like, hey, I need some money. I'll get two coins to put this here. This is an upgrade that both of us will be able to use during the game because it's in the middle wheel. But you have to be careful about what you cover because those actions are sort of going away. Or you can place the upgrade on your own spending one for a wood one or two for a silver one because these now are ones that only I'll be able to utilize. You'll also be gaining helper cards which can either be used as helpers. And so at the bottom gaining different abilities ongoing, like when you take the market action, get an upgrade. you take the helper action, get any tulip.
Or when you plant, get a coin. But if you turn that card upside down, it's a contract that will get you points, like two points for every windmill that's in with a red tulip or two points for every windmill that's in the with the purple tulip or two points for different spots that have a purple tulip plus any other tulip of different colors. And it's interesting cuz you can select which side. Do I want it for my helper gaining when I take the the helper action, gaining the market action? Or do I want it for the contract putting it here? Three points for every uh black tulip that I brought to the flower trade market. But what this does is it gives the opponent the ongoing ability. But if I take the ability, it gives the opponent the ability to get this contract because if either one of us takes this card and puts it here, it's going to push these off, meaning that this player is going to be able to activate this contract by paying a coin if they want to. Plus, it's also getting rid of an ongoing ability. So sometimes you're doing it because you want to get rid of an ability someone's using.
Sometimes you're doing it because you want to get rid of a contract that's not quite done yet for somebody else and they're not going to be able to get as many points out for it. This is a huge strategic and tactical aspect of the game. And many of the actions, if you take at a certain amount of time during the game, it's going to cause this to move up, which is a clock. And once it gets here, you're going to end the game at the last turn. Then you're going to do the final scoring with all the windmills that I showed you. Whoever has the most points at the end is the winner. Before I get to the moment you've been waiting for, I want to let you know that Game Toppers is helping make this the best Christmas ever by upgrading all of your gaming experiences with their Christmas spectacular sale, which is going on through December 22nd as they have 15% off all game table accessories and storage solutions including their Premiere 3.6 mm double stitch edge game mats in over 40 styles and 12 sizes from top board game artists like Vincent Du Trait and Ryan Locket.
You can also save up to $150 in savings with $50 off Game Toppers, dining covers, and leg kits. And these savings can be combined with their Game Toppers starting at only $4.99. Visit gametoppersllc.com to learn more. Now, coming to this review, I try to generally share my sort of thoughts and biases coming into this cuz it does paint the picture of what I'm going to say. Now, Danny Garcia, as I mentioned, is a a beloved designer that's had crazy good designs that people love over the last few years with, you know, Windmill Valley, the original of this, and and Barcelona and Gauchy recently, and you know, a handful of others. Those are the biggest ones, I think. Um and now Windmill Windmill Valley I liked, but it didn't really stand out to me. Same for actually Barcelona. Most people I'm in the majority the minority here. Most people love those two games. In fact, in my recent review of Gauchy, I said this is the first game that I've played from Danny Garcia that now I'm on his bandwagon cuz that game I really hit me hard. I love it. And so I was very interested in this because I liked the theme of Windmill Valley. I liked parts of it, but it just didn't stand out for me, unlike most people. But I love dual games. I love two-player games. I love, you know, more streamlined, condensed versions of longer games that give you a feeling of that. So I was like, oh, okay, well, I kind of like Windmill Valley, but maybe if this brings it down to the type of game that I like, I'll I'll love it. So this is why I was interested in this and why it made my top 10 most anticipated games at Essen.
So first of all, let me tell you what I like about it. This is a bigger dual game than most. So a lot of times you see these games that come out that are like dual, Seven Wonders dual and this dual and that dual. And usually they're in a small box. Uh usually they're like, you know, 20 to 30 minutes long. Uh they're small. This is in a bigger box with a full six-panel board, a decent amount of setup, uh lots of components. So it feels it it's a larger sort of dual game than most dual games. I think that's what you need to know because that might be good for you. That might not be good for you. Some of you might be like, okay, great. It's not quite as small as I thought it was going to be. That's that's a positive for me. Some of you might go, uh I was really looking for something really smaller. Then maybe this isn't for you. Um so let's talk about more of the mechanisms. The best thing here is the interconnected gear actions. So overall in this game there is a ton of interaction. This game has more teeth than the original. And I like teeth in my Euro games. I like being able to mess with other people. I like being able to make sure that every action everyone else takes depend it does something that changes everyone else's decisions. In this case, just the other player. But the interconnected gear actions is awesome because I mean what you pick affects your opponent because you get to do the follow action. So it's like, hey, I'm going to pick this, they're going to get to do that. And this is interesting because you might move you can move one or two for free, right? Or spend a couple of gear of you know tokens to move it a a third spot. But you might move it twice even though that action isn't ideal for you,
but because you don't want them to be able to take the action if you moved it once. And I love that. You're constantly thinking. You're always every decision in this game is like, what am I going to do this turn? But what is it going to allow my opponent to do? And it does it in in a lot of areas and I like the interaction here of this. Uh sometimes yeah you know you not only just moving past things, but that that mechanism of what am I going to give them? I love that as well because it's flexible. Money is can be really tight in this game, especially as some of the spots can get covered with upgrades. There might be no money upgrades money items left on the wheel, right? And so uh you instead of just taking that follow action, you can just get money. And that the amount of money depends on when during the game it is. You know the later in the game, the more money you get because of the the sort of calendar there. I like that it gives you flexibility to get money because otherwise I would have been like money's way too tight in this game. But you can always get at least one coin at the beginning of the game up to two or three towards the end.
Uh and so I really like that. The helper cards. Oh man, talk about teeth. So I love this because you have them for an ability that's ongoing or a contract which is, hey, at some point in time the cards slide off, you can spend a coin to activate that contract, right? And get you some points. And I love this because even just deciding what to do, you know, do you where do you put it? As you put things on, it slides things off. Are you ready to slide something off and get your contract done? Are you milking an ability you don't want to slide off? Um and you can decide, do you want it to be the helper on your side giving you an ability or do you want it to be the contract on the other side, placing it on the opponent's side? And this is huge because you can be like, oh my gosh, that opponent's been using that ability over and over, they're milking it.
It's in the last slot. I don't want them to use it anymore. I'm going to put this as a contract, slide his off, theirs go off, and now they can possibly up, you know, up pay for that contract. Or maybe it's like, hey, you see them going for a longer-term goal. You they're building up this thing to get this contract. Well, put a car on their side and push it off and make them activate it now if they want to where it's not going to be as good as later. It's just this aspect, this push and pull of which side do you put it on? Do you put it on theirs? Do you put it on yours? Why? The ability or the contract or the timing or both. This alone is, in my opinion, actually even more than the years, probably my favorite part of the game. Uh the action upgrade tiles. I love that when you do this, you've got a choice. You can upgrade one of the middle uh gears that that's good for both of them of you and your opponent. And you just get to get what's there, but it doesn't cost you anything. Uh you take the action, you get what you want. But you got to be careful cuz again, if you cover up things that you want later, it might screw you up. Or you can put them on your own board, but it's going to cost you one or two coins depending on if it's wood or or, you know, a metal action. And I like that too because some do you want to work on your own thing or do you want to just for free get something better out there? Now another good thing is that you can if you know that like you have a lot of money and they don't have a lot of money and the money's tight for them, you can start covering the money actions, making them less available, pushing them almost they they kind of paint themselves in the corner and you kind of slam the door on them. So again, lots of interaction on that which I think is really cool. I also like with the interaction that there's the market where you can basically pay coins to get
some tulips. But the way this works is you can get like a face up one or you can get the face down one on top of the pile. But if you get the face down one, you still slide off the one that's there. So you could be like, oh, they have enough coins to get this tulip which they're clearly building over there and putting windmills around. I don't want them to have it. I'm just going to take a market action to take the top one. I don't care. Slide that other one off and they don't get it. And it kind of reminded me of like the the the light game Point Salad where you're purposely like kind of hate drafting where you're like pushing something off that they can't get just because you you know that they're about to do that or they can do that and you don't want them to. Again, teeth, messing with other players. Uh I like that you can control the end game timing depending on the action selected because as certain things happen and as different actions, the calendar is going to move forward which is the clock in the game. So you can decide, you know what? Ooh, I don't want to take this action cuz it's going to do this, get me closer to pushing that down, making the game end. Um I think I'm you know, I'm behind. I want to go a little longer. Or the conversely you can be like, ooh, I'm winning.
They're starting to catch up. They've got this engine for end game. I need to stop them. I'm going to take the actions that are going to quickly try to push that calendar back and end the game. I always love that in a game. It's here. So overall I really like the game. Uh on the negative side of things. So there's a lot of information to track in this game. When you both have three helper cards, there's, you know, uh 6 12 different things you got to look at. Six on each side. You have the the ability for me, the contract for you, the ability for them, the contract for me. And if I take the helper action, what am I going to do? You got to like interpolate all of these things and see what the best thing is. And it's a lot. It gives you a lot of good crunchy decisions, but it is a lot to process as the game goes on including all the different action tiles as the game gets going on. And some of those tiles that the icons are kind of small, right? They have to be in order to fit there cuz there's usually multiple actions on there. So towards the end of the game you got all these icons that you're looking at both hey, what can they do on their board? What's in the middle? What's in my board? All these help. There is a lot of information to track and some of them are kind of hard to see. That's a negative. And on top of that because of all that, there's going to be some analysis paralysis. You can sit there and you're going to think for a while sometimes on some of these actions later in the game when there is tons of decisions, tons of things to look at. Looking up icon, you know, legends to see what things are.
AP can definitely be this. There can sometimes be some turns where you can't do anything towards the end because, you know, you're specializing some things. You're like, I can take this action or this action. None of them really do me any good. I don't have any money. I can't get anything at the market. I can't do this over here. You know, sometimes you might have a turn where you're like, I can't really do anything. I guess I'll just take a coin, right? And again, earlier I said I like the flexibility of that, which I do, but sometimes you might have some underwhelming turns, especially when you get stuck without having money and sets like that. But there is that way out of it by just taking money. It's just not as exciting as the other turns. The last thing is the in addition to the AP that can happen in Alcer Process, this ship action. I felt like this was could have been streamlined. It's very procedural. You do this. You move the ship. It can't move to the one that has the, you know, the the the tile on there that has the the the ocean there.
You you know, hey, if it's on the bottom thing, you score. Then you take the action on that. Then you discard the action. Then you put a new action. If it's on the bottom one, you slide it up. If it's on the top one, you you you turn the ocean one over and then this one becomes the ocean one. And it's just like I get it why it's there. It makes sense. It's fiddly. This should have been streamlined and developed further, I think. It's the only part of the game that I feel like has rough edges. It's like, okay, every time you do that, okay, I've done this five times. Let's make sure we do this right. You know, it's it's a little fiddly. But other than that, the game is is great. I think if you liked Windmill Valley, you're probably going to like this unless you don't like huge interaction with your opponents. If you don't like Euro games or you are constantly either directly or indirectly messing with the opponent, you're this game's not for you. This game's not going to be for Rado, for example. He's going to hate this because you can really mess with other players with it.
But if you like Euros and you're like, hey, it'd be great to have Windmill Valley have more interaction and have a lot of teeth and be a lot meaner, but still keeping it down and feeling familiar but yet very different at the same time, then I think you're going to like this. And that is what I think of Windmill Valley Duel. This is the Game Boy Geek breaking down barriers, growing relationships with board games, and helping you find the next one you love.