Skip to main content
Loading video...

Talking Pendulum, Quarantine & Solo Gaming with Jamey Stegmaier of Stonemaier Games

Transcript 34:21

welcome back to another episode of the cardboard Herald my chance to talk with creative gamers and game creators and it seems like at least annually I have my chance to talk to one of the biggest game creators in the hobby welcome back to the show Jamie Steve Meyer hey thanks for having me yeah man well you are back today to talk about a couple of things but one of the most hotly anticipated things is pendulum this is projects and/or code names and I guess you've always used code names for your games tell me about how sand is representative of this new game pendulum yeah so here's the the pendulum box this game designed by Travis Jones and Travis created this really really interesting worker placement system that uses time optimization and involving sand timers this is where the sand comes in so it's not interacting in the game it's not yeah it's it's it's about sand timers where you are putting workers on worker placement action spots at a certain time and then when a timer flips to that area where the workers are those workers are locked in into there's actions to do those actions they gather some resources to do some things and the workers have to stay there as long as that timer is there and until that timer runs out you know for a lot of people they're their first instinct is that as soon as you say Sam timer that that's going to bring in real-time and then when you bring in

real-time people are like well that takes out all the strategies so tell me about how you managed to incorporate a temporal element into this game but actually make it a strategy game that's domeier's known for the worry that I have with some real-time games that I get really stressed when I play them they can be they can cause stress but that isn't the case in pendulum we it's more of a sigh so what is the simultaneous actually game you are placing workers in in real-time simultaneously with other players just as I would compare it to seven wonders you're choosing what you're doing simultaneously other players in seven wonders but this timers are long enough in this game that you're you don't really feel that extreme time pressure the timers aren't making you race around and do things rather they're just determining how long those workers are locked in so it's it's really more time optimization is it worth putting my worker on this spot or there's gonna be a three minutes and timer which may not sound long but when you're when you're making choices in a worker place we came through min this is a long time you can even find yourself sitting there kind of waiting for the timer to be done or am I gonna put my worker on the 45 second action spot where I know I can move them pretty soon again after they take that action but they're not locked in it isn't frantic it's it's it reminds me a little bit maybe more Sulkin how you you are kind of just timing things exactly correctly so you can pick up a worker off this one spot and put it down at this other spot

at the right time but I really did pay I totally hear that it I paid attention to a lot during the process of development because I didn't want people to be stressed out as I am when I play some real-time games do you think that that stress is is proportional to say the amount of analysis paralysis that someone may have I mean if someone is that kind of critical thinker who needs to understand all the ramifications of everything that they're doing and that's how they enjoy board games do you think that this game is going to be for them or is this going to be an automatic turnoff I have some friends who play this and some play testers who noted on their feedback I am normally they said something like I am normally an analysis paralysis player but this game helped me get over that and just make decisions and make meaningful decisions throughout the process I'm sure there is a small subset of gamers that will be immensely frustrated by this or they they just they won't be able to deal with it they need to spend that extra time to focus on it but I think there will be a bigger subset of people who maybe normally struggle a little bit with analysis paralysis and our have I feel a sense of freedom by the timers in this game where they they know okay I have three minutes to make a decision the timer is telling me this I that that is my limit I will make something to happen that is meaningful and issuing to me within that tell me about the general course of play like if one person is taking significantly longer than other players to make decisions is that going to

inhibit everyone else from being able to make decisions or can they really play and optimize their their own placements and it'll just be to the detriment of the person taking all their time it's a little bit of both I'll get back to the judgment part in a second but because it is simultaneous the worker placement of some days and worker movement and placement you are never really impeding other players there are a few spots that can be blocked but we use the grande system grande workers system that that that I used in viticulture where there is a grande worker essentially that you can place anywhere that you want so you always have that freedom with a grinding worker you can even get more grinding workers in this game to free to take those actions that maybe have been blocked by other players but it's all happening at the same time and so if one player is taking a little extra time it's really only hurting them use the word detriment and probably - it is a little bit to their detriment to do so but what I've seen in play testers is that if they if they are finding themselves needing a little extra time sometimes they'll just place all their workers on the 3-minute action or the two-minute action to kind of give themself a pause and say okay I need to collect myself a little bit I will give myself this extra time I know it's gonna take extra time but I'll put all my workers on the 3-minute actions get myself a breather collect myself look at what resources I have evaluate my position and one day actually didn't mention is that the game is broken in two rounds and so these these periods of real time simultaneous play only lasts around I believe it's eight or nine minutes maybe ten at most and so you have the

session where it is real time in simultaneous and then it stops and at that point you can really collect yourself and there's a few things that you do together with other players but you can you can then look at your strategy for the next round rather than having the whole 90 minutes or 60 to 90 minutes be simultaneous and in real time so for a lot of real-time games I'm thinking right now of maybe some live like cane Clank ohs games like pandemic rapid response time is a resource whereas in this game it sounds more like it's a limiter or an ops consideration that may be affecting how you generate resources or interact with the game if you taken out the time element it's a worker placement game where the goal is to what what am i doing in pendulum yeah you were trying to somatically you were trying to earn the throne of this mythical mystical fantasy kingdom that we've invented for this game the world called dunya that's the thematic goal the I'll show you one of the player mats here the goal it's a really cool Travis thought of a pretty cool well I think this is really neat we're a victory point system it is a bit of a race game but with victory points kind of at the end I'll show you what I mean so there's a player mat here at the beginning of the game on this side of the map and that each character is double sided with a little bit of difference but you'll start with tokens at the beginning of these three tracks which represent different types of resources military prestige and Commerce Zeus and these tracks are different

lengths for each character and so during the course of the game when you gain victory points for getting one of three different types of victory points and you're advancing your token on the track once you have all of those tokens and this extra special victory point type in this parchment area then you will trigger the end of the game and so you're kind of racing to get all three of your tokens to this to this parchment and even after that you can continue to gain victory points there is a way that you look at points at the end of the game of multiple players get into this area but each of the tracks are different so you can see how that one is a little different than this one this one has a really long military track so they need to focus on military early but their commerce is very strong they have a shorter track of Commerce and so that's that's the the core objective of the game this is kind of race to get different types of victory points on different track links you know this is the first time where you've really dived into high fantasy as a theme genre here and that was like something that came naturally to the game was it something that came along with Travis's original pitch to you like tell me about the development of this world I love escapism in games and I love world building and so originally the original theme was I think the game was called heir to the throne an heir to the Empire it was based in the Roman Empire and I asked Travis without taking anything away from the game if he would be open to a fantasy theme like you said we haven't done that yet and he was totally open to it and so I approached the artists that I was excited to work with a guy named

Robert Leafs and I asked him basically Robert if you're interested in this game could you spend a month we basically just pay you for a month of world-building just about a few weeks building a world and we'll put the game in that world and Robert had a lot of fun doing that Travis came in and gave him some ideas and worked on some of the different characters and so yeah we built a fantasy world for it and there are some recognized ok characters you saw dragon in there there's a Minotaur see a Minotaur on the wall behind you there hey our Minotaur is a little bit a little bit different okay you know you're dipping your toes into this high fantasy ness like you said I have I have a Minotaur behind me her alone and Minotaur from magic that's a in order to honor Anson Maddox a fellow Alaskan one of the original artists on Magic Man I love his stuff but yeah you know like are we going to see kind of a twist on the classic high fantasy you know I'm thinking now jaws of the lion just came out the new glue man game and I think of Isaac Childress really making a big stamp on the world of fantasy gaming in part of having a really cool game but also in trying to subvert some of the expectations for what is a classic fantasy setting and this looks a little bit more on par with what someone might expect out of classic Dungeons and Dragons it's like accurate well we really did try to incorporate time the theme of time into the world and to the theme of the game so I think that's our

twist to it you're right there is there are some very familiar elements here and Isaac I think did such a wonderful job with a world building and gloom Haven and frost Haven taking those things that are a little familiar but creating his own races and people's and yeah where it's definitely not at that level but it is there's there's story and the rules about what the what the world about and it uses that time theme to differentiate itself a little bit while being a little familiar at the same time well tell me about the origins of this game in the first place I mean so what is the interaction where Travis approaches you and is like yo stole my are interested in a game with real-time elements like where you immediately intrigued or you were like oh boy okay I'm going sit down a look at this to be courteous but then move along like how did this project come about so we we host something called the stomer games design day every year I think we've done it for around six six or seven years at this point and it the the idea behind the design day is that we it's it's a it basically just a one day event where a bunch of designers were around the country a lot in Saint Louis but from some of them come from around the country gathered together at pieces game cafe and st. Louis and it's kind of like an unpublished their plate their prototypes to play people show up to play test the games and we also play some published games to learn from them as well and we've mainly just done it because we thought it would be fun to do this but one of our little reasons for doing it is that we kind of hoped that we would discover a game there that we wanted to publish and so we've been scouting at this event for years for a

game that we wanted to publish and a couple years ago Travis brought this game to design day and people played it people had a good time with it I looked at it a little bit but not a lot because it was a real-time game I must admit that I dismissed it a little bit as a real-time game both from my own experiences with real-time games and from what I understand other gamers perceptions of real time to be but then the ratings came back for the game and it was by far the highest rated game in the history of design day it earned a nine point three rating on the standard ten point scale that that BoardGameGeek uses and that's kind of like a fun thing we do a design day it doesn't really mean anything but we do ask people to write the games just so maybe if we miss something we can go back and say oh what's up with this game and that's happened here I I missed it and unfortunately the people playtesting that that day didn't miss it and so that's what brought it to my attention and I reached out to Travis afterward and said let's let's take a closer look at this I need to take a closer look at this and actually play it and I found that I really enjoyed it aside from the Roman theme switching to the fantasy theme how has it evolved since the development there are a few key changes I mean a lot of it a lot of the core systems remain the same there was one thing so now like when you place a worker on the board here's the board right here like you you placed a worker when the timer isn't there and then once the timer goat is flipped over to this spot that's when it's locked in and you actually pay the cost and use the action you move the worker down here to show

that you've used it in the original iteration it was it was almost the opposite of that they used the same system I think when you place the worker that's when you paid and what maybe when the timer wasn't there it's just so long I don't remember exactly what the difference was there a lot of it is also the user interface for example on the player maps there's an engine building aspect and that you are acquiring these square cards that represent provinces in the kingdom and when you acquire them through military you slide the cards into one of these four slots and they improve your engine for that category of thing and originally this was a separate mat that you were using so every every player had this not they were dealing with and this other mat and what we really found throughout the play test process is that in a simultaneous action game like this where real time is used you got it you have to condense everything and make everything as perfectly clear as possible where players will miss things and so by having this light as an example of having two separate things for players to look at while they're also trying to pay it into the time on the board that was too much we needed to condense that a little bit so a lot of changes like that just to make it more user friendly so as you're getting ready now as we're recording this to to announce this game to the world and to tell people all about it are you more nervous than you typically are for a game because it's just like your initial reaction that you had to it when it was presented at the Stone mire design day you know you were like a real-time game I mean sure it might be

good for a real-time game but you know we're looking at real board games here are you expecting that reaction and

what are you hoping to do to mitigate some that reaction where someone just hears real-time and writes it off immediately I am fully expecting there will be some people that do that and and there are a lot of games in the world they're plenty games to be able to choose from so it's okay if someone hears real-time or hears sand timers and they're like I'm not interested and my only hope is that someday that they will have a friend or they'll be at a convention they can they can try it to see if it does open up their eyes a little bit to what a real-time game can be in the same way that someone who says I don't ever want to try a legacy game every now and then they actually do finally try like is the game they're like oh this is actually pretty cool I think there will be some people that say that and I am I am certainly nervous about that how big that people will be but similar to wingspan I was worried about wingspan for a thematic reason somewhat different but but thematic reason I think if people actually do give it a try or take the time to watch a review about it they will see that the impact of time is a lot more similar to a simultaneous action game than a real time game and that the time system is used in a in a pretty interesting unique way but but I am nervous I'm always nervous about a new release if I never know how many people will be excited about or not so well we'll see how it turns out in a few weeks and we do the pre-order well speaking of the pre-order I mean your your last monumental release was of course tapestry and that was probably

the biggest pre-release marketing campaign that I've seen outside of Kickstarter I mean Kickstarter has some ridiculous stuff going on but you know that that was just orchestrated in such a brilliant way with all these these steps of release of information and going on podcasts such as mine and you know there was so much information out there and it really built up the game and the game itself was fairly well received I think it was it was polarizing the people who loved it yeah absolutely loved it and then there were also a lot of people who were very unhappy with the game I because they they went in expecting something different than what they got and then there was also of course some balance issues that were addressed later on did you learn anything from the the tapestry release and does that affect how you are planning on presenting this game and rolling out the the pre-release cycle are you just planning on full steam ahead do the what's worked in the past I mean obviously tapestry sold so one thing I try to be really careful about when I talk about a game is I think we've probably even talked about hype before you and I though yeah it's firm high yeah and so what that means to me as a publisher is that I try to be really careful and I probably mess this up even in our chat today but I've tried to be really careful about talking about using

adjectives to describe a game it's not my place to decide if this game is beautiful or not or if this game is fun or not or I'm not I don't want to tell people this is the the best game or the most fun game or the most beautiful game that's where the for you to decide I try to do it and this is what I tried to do with tapestry I tried to tell people what it was and why we made the decisions we did that go into it that that made tapestry what it is and so that's my job I see my job as as a presenter I'm presenting information about what the game actually is in a way that is hopefully exciting for people the way I unravel that information and so in the end yeah I'm gonna approach tap pendulum in the same way that I approached tapestry I'm gonna unveil what the game is and what went into turning the game into what what you see on the table today and people can judge for themselves whether they play it or based on the reviews that are gonna come out which will be actually a little different apps ooh that'll be the one difference I waited I had the reviewer embargo for tapestry right on the day that the game the pre-order started and I've moved away from that so that'll that'll all happen a week early so reviewers will start to talk about it about oh because people can have plenty of time to watch over those reviews the side of the game is for them or not but well before they can import from anybody yeah yeah for sure and that gives people information and like you know make decisions based off of that and I think part of it may also be expectations I mean the the yeah the pre-release campaign at least you know

like I mentioned it it was big it felt monumental this is the next stone Meyer game and the the video released looked so beautiful and I think a lot of people decided for themselves that this was meant to be like a a paradigm shift in board games and maybe having too high of expectations and then finding that it's a civilization game where you're playing Lee civilizations that it wasn't living up to those lofty of expectations maybe that's part of the the reaction to it now as we're speaking about getting ready for release in everything co vid is making all sorts of important impacts on the world really as a whole not just the release of board games but how is Cova defecting stomer games i know that we have a lot of information about how it's affecting kickstarter releases and you know people are changing when they're putting Kickstarter's up they're modifying their dates for delivery and because of manufacturing concern it's like kind of stuff but in a practical sense how is quarantine and just the the general miasma in the air affecting Stone mire and what you guys do there there are many ways where and maybe it would have affected a has impacted other publishers like a couple of publishers

that are heavily dependent on conventions for marketing that really hasn't ever been our strategy so in a year when all the conventions are cancelled we probably could have sold a few more games brought a few more people into the Hobby that way and I hope that comes back hope meant to come back strong next year but it hasn't really impacted us I work from home so I've worked from home for years and so working from home during this time hasn't really been all that different from us there was a short period where our webstore orders were much higher than usual because retailers were figuring the whole curbside pickup system but I think they figured it out now which i think is great I think a number of retailers have have found ways to continue to serve their customers and I'm happy to sell games to them through distributors so I mean a lot of ways not a lot has changed the big variable for me is is the holiday season the winter holiday season that will come up later this year I am worried about the the long-term economic impact that the pandemic will have on people for the first few months people are at home a lot they they want things to do at home and so board games I think a lot of people turn to board games but in the long run if we still have 20 25 percent unemployment people are going to be buying a lot of non necessities during the holiday season and my opinion maybe it'll still happen but I'm concerned about it so our holiday print run which we initiated a few weeks ago is a lot smaller than it would normally be because I don't want to have 50,000 games sitting in the warehouse if the economy really really does poorly around

that time what do you think do any theories about that it's just it's a big variable to me right now I only have a window into very small elements of the whole production and then ultimate release cycle of board games and right now if anything I think the the biggest impact for a lot of people is not just the economic impact which is there but I think as I said earlier there's a miasma in there there there's a sense of futility there's a sense of darkness I mean strife in this country in particular and all over the world really and there's a lot of important things being done in relation to that but I think that also makes it really hard for a lot of people to get excited about the next board game the next I guess frivolity the the thing that's going to be a little entertaining nugget for you to distract yourself from everything going on I mean that that is important entertainment and having that sort of social interaction with people and obviously board games are selling I mentioned jaws of a lion earlier Frost Haven was the biggest Kickstarter so people are obviously buying these things but I know that there are at least people in my board game group that either through feeling kind of down due to quarantine or due to social strife

and injustice in the world they're feeling like man you know I don't even really have the the emotional fortitude to sit down and have fun playing a board game right now maybe that's the the social worker in me but I don't know I I think that's going to be the the biggest factor in what this country looks like in six months from now when we're looking at the holidays is how ready people are going to be to fork down a bunch of money on you know entertainment and distraction yeah I I think I think you're onto something there I for me for me I have loved the escapism of board games and I love the the strategy and whatnot but there certainly have been times in the last few months where I not have felt that despair and I wondered how widespread that will be and how long we'll see that yeah and I've thought about it in my own work too I mean I I do this podcast and I have the video channel and I'm putting out reviews and I think to myself like oh man should I be doing videos that are specifically related to some of the things in the world that I have a platform to talk about and to a degree I've utilized this in the past to talk about social issues and political issues that I I think are

worth acknowledging at the very least but at the same time I also feel like some people need the distraction in order to not yet fully fall into despair and maybe that's just me justifying how I keep to my hobby and keep playing games and keep putting up videos and everything but you know people are still watching them and I'm sure people are going to keep on buying board games which you know maybe we should get back to actually talking about the the board games themselves tell me about the the solo implementation because up until this point and I I think you've only had one game where you don't have a solo element to it which is between two castles right and that's come right behind you yeah yeah exactly did you crack the nut on how to have real time and elements in a solo game well I I didn't yes yeah yeah Morton and and is his ultimate team they they do have created it I I don't even understand I've decided that that I I don't even try to understand the complex systems that they use this isn't the right word they may use systems that I think solo gamers can can embrace and can enjoy but on that much of a solo gamer so yeah there is an Ultima system in it there's a full deck of cards there's this map that is solely for the autonomous system I think the cards are the main other component yeah there's a there's a second atomic cards right here pretty

big stack of them so yeah it is fully playable in real time against no one well that's at least a relief for all the people out there who are quarantined and presumably yeah it'd still be quarantined when it comes to September you mentioned that you're not much of a solo game of yourself yet some of your games Stone Myers games are the most celebrated solo games out there at least among if you're going to list say top thirty solo games I venture to say that there's going to be a couple of yours in that list for a lot of people have you changed some of your feelings toward solo games throughout the process of working with Morton and his team you know like were you originally someone who was like dude I don't ever want to play a solo game whereas now you might be like I'd consider it um as a gamer as a gamer my preferences have not changed as a publisher as soon as we publish Tuscany and I saw how many people really enjoyed the solo mode in viticulture Tuscany I was kind of all in from then on I trusted that Morton was doing a great job based on how people were receiving it and I yeah I was excited from then on to put it in any of our games where it's possible you mentioned between two castles that was the one that he won not that he couldn't quite crack but he has figured it out now so we are doing an expansion for that that will have Solo in it and I'd prefer to

never again publish a game without a solo mode included in the box and not just a pretty robust so I you know the autonomous system it's a pretty robust system that makes you feel like you're playing against an intelligent opponent without having to deal with all the maintenance of actually running another character another player so I trust the system I know that I think I trust them more into doing a great job with it and I'm happy to put it in any of our games as we would forward yeah one thing that I've thought about in relation to my own life and I'm wondering that this may be something that has or maybe has an impact at you when I first started talking with you for you know this podcast back in the day you were a single dude you add your board gaming group of course you had your company and now you're in a committed relationship and if your partner is someone that you play games with I am not sure if she is or is not has that impacted how you feel about like making sure that a game is not just good at two players but it has to be great at two players I know that as my wife and I became more focused on just her and I being the the core of our game group particularly after our son was born it became way more important to me about a game was good at two players yeah a couple different thoughts there oh one is I would say so yeah I live with with my girlfriend now she is a great gamer she was a gamer well before she met me

she normally beats me at games I'm not this necessary there to compete but that is just a show that she has she was very good she's very talented gamer but well before that a lot of the original play testing for any of our games was just too was me and Allen my co-founder and so 2-player was always the focus and always the easiest thing to play test and so that was always kind of there but what I found especially with the combination of living with Megan being in the committed relationship and kovat is that two-player games are my main outlet they're really my only outlet for playing on a tabletop and so we've it's been a lot of a lot of fun to navigate that to find games to really I've opened myself up to a lot of games that are not only played with two players because normally in my game group of you know 10 to 12 people those wouldn't really hit the table but now I I love if I can spend 20 bucks $15 on a two-player only game because I know it'll get to the table quite a lot and even within that category it's been fun to figure out which games we both enjoy because I want it's been most important for me that she has a good time playing it but also in the end I want to enjoy it too so there we actually have you played a game called shards of infinity I haven't I heard it though it's a it's a two-player deck building game and we played it competitively at first and it was fine I had fun with it but it really wasn't for Megan and so we bought the

cooperative module and brought that in and we both had a blast and that really elevated how I felt about the game because I was I was having fun then and Megan was that I was having fun because Megan was having a great time too so it's been interesting just to navigate that process and I'm sure it will bleed over to our games a little bit too speaking of which when are we going to get the the great stone Meier cooperative game it it's a big game I know we've talked about of those past I probably every one of our clans I've mentioned it it I'm hoping it'll be a late 2021 release I think realistically 2022 just because it's such a big world but uh but I am actively working on it every day at this point there have been periods where I've gone weeks without really sitting down to work on it cuz I'd like to focus on it for a few hours at a time but I am actively spending a few hours on with every day at this point this is going to be your winds of winter moment you're just like George RR Martin's taking it's it's just on the corner if I if I don't have it done by this convention that you know lock me away and I'll have it done yeah great you've said that six times over the past ten years great well I'm hoping that by late 2021 we're able to check this out but that is going to kind of wrap up the conversation about pendulum here and for all of you in the audience who are interested in snow mire games stay tuned to the channel because Jamie and I are going to secretly well in a

temporal sort of way swing the pendulum over to talking about the new tapestry expansion and we'll have that up at a later date when we're able to share that so thank you all for watching and thank you Jamie for talking to me about pendulum and let's switch on over to tapestry awesome if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard Harold calm our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Harold

Progress saved