Libertalia Winds of Galecrest vs old Libertalia - Which one is better?
Transcript
libertalia we're going to talk about the comparison of 2014 and 2022 edition stay tuned hi it's tyrone and stella here from maple university thank you for joining us today we are going to talk about two libertarians yes the libertariae is that the plural fully battalia apparently maybe not oh well i like putting an e on the end i know you do words yeah sound fancy anyway so libertalia libertalia this version the 2014 version is has been well it started with sitting on our shelf of opportunity for for a very long time you owned it before we even met correct i own it i haven't played i'm pretty sure i went to a local board game shop and then bought it because it was on special or it was recommended either one it was that's just not my hobby and we finally play it um in the drink of it it was actually on board game arena yes which i know and we'll talk about this but in the rule book uh for the newer version here um that was really where jamie got playing it as well and where the new stonewire version has come from indeed and then we are also we also have how to play video on the old version but mainly in this video we're going to give you the feel and the differences between the older version and the new version yes
so the game was designed by paula mori as we say it's now a uh stonemayer published re-release it is fundamentally the same game but eight years on there have been some tweaks and there have been some adjustments and some changes and components as well without fundamentally changing the core of the game the feel of the game so the game plays two to six players and uh you will begin we're talking about the new one or the old one the old one sorry the l1 plays two to six there is now a solo mode um so the competitive mode it will play two to six players and you've got a deck of 40 cards and then one player takes it's now six cards from that and then everyone gets the same card so everyone's playing with the same hand you'll go on a voyage as pirates out to try to get as much loot as possible the battalia is a uh mythical country associated with pirate folklore and you'll go out on four days of this journey at the start of the game and everyone's fighting over these loots and some of the loots are better than others and really you're trying to position yourself to get the best loot and the best effects so everyone on a day is going to choose one card play it face down so everyone will choose simultaneously so simultaneous action selection there good and then they will be i was hoping it's all exactly the same these will be revealed and then they
will be sequenced from left to right in number order and if there's a tie it gets resolved by this reputation track here all of these characters have daytime abilities and we will run from left to right resolving those abilities and those will give you money or they might give you reputation or let you do things with other characters there's lots of different effects 40 cards in all then once you get to the end any characters that are still there you'll go from high to low taking the loot so when you play the good cards you get the good loot when you play the bad cards you get stuck with the bad loot the bad guy usually earlier than later yes so when you play the low cards and often those will those will trade off because the effects on here can be better for the lower cards or they can and the effects up here they might be more damaging so you've got to weigh all of those things up yeah so you'll do that over four days for voyage and then you'll be collecting money through the the powers up here uh then you'll cash all of your loot in for points or cash or your loot in for money cash all your money in for points uh which is tracked on this little dial here yep then you do it all again and you basically play three rounds in the same way everyone gets new cards between rounds and everyone will take again they'll add
the same cards to the hand but will carry over different cards from the previous round because your hand is bigger than the number of rounds and yeah so you'll do that three times and whoever has the most points at the end is the winner that's basically the game that is the game both games both games yes yeah so for those who are familiar with the uh with the original game what is new um it's actually really easy because the rulebook tells you what's new we don't even have to uh we don't even have to go through and work it out for us really i worked it out myself when i posted on instagram what did you tell me you're at the royal ball so obviously all the components look different these are the cards from the the original game here so different i still like the artwork on the old one it's just like this is different but both are good it's like really stuck like look at the style right it's really like it's more human like what's the word for it so he's like looks more human more realism realism that's it yeah yeah um so that's that's part of it the deck has 40 cards instead of 30. there are some new effects so some new uh things to play with there the major thing that's different is the reputation track this was never in the original game so when you played cards of a matching type everyone had a unique secondary number here down on the cards and so you would sequence them according to that now you've got this reputation track where if you do effects that will push you up
to the right of that it's going to instinctively push you further to the right on the island as well so that means you resolve it later but you get the loots first yeah you also start with more money if you start with less reputation and if you max out the track you can just generate money that way as well so that's probably the only new uh mechanism that's been introduced to the game otherwise most of what's changed is just is this one here little tweaks so the number of days has changed it used to be uh six days per round now it's four then five then six the loot uh also the components of the loot they're now these sort of azul type tiles whereas they used to be these little cardboard tiles yep same same basic collection of loot but now there are two different things that each of them can do so there's a different side to the board and there's also double-sided tiles which show the same things and so there are the basic effects where the chest is just the most valuable it will give you five coins uh the relics are the worst they'll give you minus three sabers let you you can take a saber and then you can discard someone else's character from the island barrels aren't worth that much money but now they give you reputation maps you have to collect as sets but then what's new is that you can use the opposite side of these and they give you some other um more competitive more interactive
effects so maps is just whoever has the most gains money but everyone else keeps them yeah sabres are discarding um more things from other players amulets is gaining money based on the reputation track so it brings this more into play uh chests combo with maps things like that even more replayability i would say because the effects there are more effects that you can choose from yeah so yeah it just adds adds a few extra things into the game it is fundamentally the same game new artwork as well yep there is now a solo mode so there are some cards that have the effects for how the solo one works there's also a variant of two players as well there is a neutral midshipman card here that will essentially it means that if one player plays above 20 and one player plays below it lets the player who played high remove one of the loot tokens and stick you with something worse so okay that's a variation to the to the game that's introduced there it's good to know we've played this a few times already uh oh sorry is that it taran yes that's it okay so we played this a few times already on bgs really quick to link of it because everything is automated really nicely elegantly but you know obviously the tactile element is here now it's more here and compared to the old one i mean i still
like the old one but i do appreciate the reputations track which gives more mechanic which gives more strategy and it's rather than random cards got deal like depending on which one gets resolved first yeah especially if you use the second amulet power yeah which as i you know bring it up in detail here it's a coin for each token to the right of yours yeah on the reputation track so amulets are worth a lot if you tank your reputation yeah so that's that's a good thing as well because you know uh part of the extra strategy it can do obviously this game would be but we really love it but it does need to be played with the right group meaning it's a gamer's party game so it's not that light we once we play with somebody who hasn't played a lot of games um they've only played monopoly for example i mean it's not their fault but they kind of like they you know they probably wouldn't grasp the same with other games which is meant to be part of the fun is the interaction between players and the bluffing and seeing okay which one is going to get the loot which one is not just a fun interaction bit does it make sense yeah so this is definitely adding good things and this is definitely better with the loots with a tactile um i don't know i feel like the old one might be not i mean it's probably sold out in a lot of places anyway we i got lucky i bought it yeah i don't think i don't think i've seen it for sale i know it was out of
print for some time which was where the new uh the new deal came from yeah so yeah i'm glad to probably just play this and this one here rather than keeping a lot of coins you every end of the set this replaces the scoreboard the scoreboard yes that's right so rather than scoreboard you each press i have to assemble this but that's okay it's pretty easy um to assemble so you just keep track the balloons in this chest which is uh thematic as well what do you think tara yeah i think one of the things having played this on bga first and then played the original and this one i do like the automated nature of bga for this game there are for a quick game there is enough things going on in terms of components that yeah i do probably prefer it on vga i would probably play it there although this one has got the mechanics do you like this replication as well the reputation i haven't seen it have that much of an impact but we haven't played with the amulet yeah um i feel like i do if i think that this person is going to play something else like i want to be the most the leftmost person and i look at my reputation uh i'll i'll surely be the first one hopefully and oh there's only one person um before me so the chance that i probably going to play like if you being like really strategic about things yeah it is good for some of the effects where uh the player who plays on the left basically is the only one who gets the effect yeah
yeah or the right or something like yeah we have one there's one where it will there are ones where it will penalize the right most player but they still get the best loop um we saw one where it removes all the hooks and savers yeah and get points and coins points but only the only the player who is on the left is going to get anything out of that so having this for a bit of extra um it's more strategy it gives you a clearer view of what's going on there yeah it's definitely more strategic right a little bit more yeah and then so i like the was it a bear made one that gives you money every there's the bar made i think i think um that was in the original yeah um that's right it's an original but i do like it and then try to get her out early and then give you one coin and then you can retrieve it again at the later round and then play it again at the start of the round you can actually keep characters round to round with hooks which is uh an interesting new feature as well one of the hook effects we didn't see much of it because we had that character that was uh destroying all the hooks but this is an interesting way of building an engine through the game as well yeah there's just a lot of repliability i would highly recommend if you like you know a gamer party game yeah you know which one is is is it lighter than the zulu i would say no no it's a little bit heavier it's fine it's like it has more meta it has more rules but less it has more rules strategy like strategy but has got that matter like you're looking at other players um it's
high interaction i would say would you recommend it yes like always i think it's a good game yeah would you pick the old one if there's an option between the older fashion or the newer version which one would you recommend obga version context contextually speaking um because i do view this as a light game i would probably actually go for the original one because it has fewer mechanisms a little bit less to teach but i think that just is a reflection of um the sorts of groups i would try to introduce libitalia to as more of a gateway i think when you put these things in it makes it a better overall game for existing gamers um but i think for me with the way i'd play libitalia that would be the direction i'd go that's a fair comment depending on who you're playing with that's basically is the answer yeah the answer to everything the world not really so have you played libertalia or you know are you excited to try this one you think that it is worth it do you you know do we want the question is now also do we want to get rid of the old version and then just keep this one are we going to call the old one i don't know we'll see yeah i mean you know we just buy more shelves or that or as you say maybe keep both depending on the group that you are playing with and you know someone make sure
everyone's everyone have fun anything else han no that's all from me yes so that's basically it let us know in the comment sections below and hopefully we will give you more informations about other games you got other type of videos how to play play through my short and sweet and your quick how to play and so on um if you like this video and if you find it helpful you can please do this what does it go hit like button that will be very helpful and appreciated and subscribe to us if you haven't already done so i'm also on instagram so find me there as well and hopefully we will see you and you and you later bye