Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 15:12

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode I go over my first impressions of Rise of Babel this will be a game that will be kickstarted in July of this year at the time of this recording in about a month or so and this game is designed by Ivan Alexi and Elijah morar art by Andrew Bosley published by BN games as an overview in this game you are simulating the construction of the biblical t of Babel utilizing deck building and track advancement to acquire and place tiles onto a shared tower construction site playing a tile laning puzzle game where you try to get as many adjacent tiles of your color in orthogonal and diagonal rows the player with the most points after three construction rounds wins the game to go over some game highlights and mechanisms here first the deck building aspect here you find standard deck building rules and with how your hand plays as well as how cards are acquired from a market row everything is very familiar if you have played past deck building games such as Dominion most cards have multiple options on them as well in an either or format next the tile placement from a bag you draw random tiles to place onto a holding area on your Tableau ultimately to be placed onto the Tower of Babel but as you play cards from your hand you will take steps to get those tiles to the tower such as loading them onto elephants progressing those

elephants along a track to advance towards the construction site and you can also Place tiles into a warehouse which may allow for opportunities to gain extra gold to purchase cards from the market or to place those tiles directly to the tower without going through the elephants at the construction site you play tiles wherever you can potentially covering up bonus spots for extra actions as well in addition to the main tower you have other small 2x two Tower grids that you can play tiles to to help increase your scoring opportunities note that there are opportunities to play confusion tiles onto the construction site which thematically confounds the languages of the people and when these tiles are placed they count as negative points to the tiles of players adjacent to it next the round structure so once one floor of the main tower is filled with tiles you immediately perform an intermediate scoring and place a new floor on top of it which is a bigger grid from the one before this happens twice during the game so three scoring opportunities occur during the entire game finally there is an expansion that will be available through the kickstarter called the fall of Man expansion which adds a few modules and rules to the game originally you have a player board with four tracks that when Advanced on give upgrades such as adding carts to your elephants to carry more tiles to the construction site or allowing for faster elephant movement Etc with the expansion there are more more tracks to play with

on your own personal Tableau some of which include a meeple that you move along the construction site adjacent to your elephant if this mle reaches the construction site you place it face down onto a shared grid board where you gain the column and the row benefit of where that mle has been placed and it will be place there permanently in addition to that asymmetric characters also give unique abilities to players during the game now to compare this to other games the first game that I thought of that played very similarly to this mechanically was endless winter while rise of Babel is a touch less complex than endless winter some of the modules of endless winter feel like the same puzzle as you're trying to solve in Babel especially with the puzzling interactive tile placement portion of both games endless winter has multi-use cards along with deck building and more modu to Tinker with but rise of Babel feels a little bit more focused on the tiling puzzle at hand in conjunction with the deck building the fall of Man expansion does up the complexity a bit to make it feel more like endless Winter though but still I don't feel like it reaches the same complexity as endless winter does the next game that I thought of was terra cotta Army now I haven't played this game yet but I know that one of the hooks of this game is the interactive puzzle of placing army figures those terra cotta army figures onto to a shared board with scoring

opportunities depending on how you place them and how in which directions they face Etc there's an element of racing to place tiles before others and to block them as well which is seen in Rise of Babel as well one thing to mention about Babel is that there are cards that you deck build and draft that have abilities that allow you to take your own tiles off or to push other tiles from other players off as well of the construction side making it directly more interactive and impactful than just simply blocking someone else's or racing to take a spot before someone else my first impressions of this game is that I think this game hits a good balance between the Simplicity and elegance of deck building and an interactive puzzle that allows for healthy competition among players even though I play the game solo I can extrapolate and get a sense that this game will scale well enough puzzle wise uh with the interactive F placement at higher player counts perhaps at the behest of some analysis paralysis with the order of cards that you play from your hand and I mean this because having you know being able to play five cards from your hand and each of those cards having sometimes two or even three different options of what to do with those cards could give you some thinking time to try to figure out the best order of operations to play those cards in but the fact that you draw into your hand before it's your turn again could mitigate that once again maybe maybe allowing for some of the choices of other players to hinder your plans

especially with the tile placement aspect of the game but I think there is some mitigation with the analysis paralysis that could potentially be here this game is still under development and because of that I learned the game from a rule book that is provided on tabletop simulator which is where I demoed this game as well maybe after the time you know after this recording is done and by the time this game is fully launched on Kickstarter the rule book and AIDS will be further developed but while I was learning from this earlier draft of the rule book I still was left with questions as I was trying to figure out the mechanisms of this game and the rules of this game fortunately many of those questions are answered on Board Game Geek and perhaps more of those questions as are elucidated from other players will be answered and addressed as well but do go into that knowing that there maybe some difficulty learning the game as I did have some of those difficulties trying to parse out the rules for example the solo mode did not have a an immediate rule book to outline what the automa player exactly does I was once again able to extrapolate most of what they did based off of the cards that are available and of course it was a learning game so it didn't matter to me to get all the rules perfectly just to get a feel of how the game played but still if you want to play the game perfectly it might be difficult to do so

but once again that might be mitigated in the near future overall I do have some concerns of the longevity of this game for my personal tastes while I think this game is excellently developed I wonder about its replayability for me and perhaps for some other people as well I think some people really enjoy will really enjoy the puzzle of the interactivity of tile placement and the focus on that in conjunction with deck building and I think that's great it really takes out a lot of the extra bits that you might have to worry about or be more analytical on in a game such as endless winter which includes a lot of different modules and different ways to interact with the game which may be a little overwhelming for some for me it seems like it will become repetitive speaking of tower of um Tower of Babel it feels like it would become a little bit repetitive with time without much variation in journey to get to laying down your puzzle it's I I find that endless winter once again it didn't seem very replayable to me personally because of the different mini games that you're trying to interact with and as a culmination if you you know play the game and interact with two or three of the different modules heavily uh during the game you end up getting a very similar score is is my prediction because I haven't played it multiple times and so you can correct me if I'm wrong but it felt like you were interacting with different portions of the game and kind of coming to a same score at the end of the game which could

be summarized as a point salad type of experience and so that for me was not in a sense replayable I think it can be for some people because you get to interact with different portions of the game and so that makes the game feel different every time but for me it didn't feel like there was an element of Mastery to explore different parts of the game to ultimately get a better score over time or something that is significant significantly better over time versus rise of Babel uh I feel like it's opposite it's the opposite case where there's only the tower construction as the primary focus of the game of gaining points and in addition to that you are gaining points from acquiring cards but that's it you are only summing the points that you get from your cards as well as how well you play the tower game and you sum up the intermediate scoring based off of that of the game and so there's only two things that you can do and and I I found that a little bit lacking to he might over time you know I find deck building games like Dune Imperium and lost Runes of intriguing in the sense that they are probably there are more ways to pursue the game points wise uh for example in D Imperium you can pursue you know trying to win every combat round and and gain points that way or you can really focus in on getting uh influence among the different factions and progressing up those tracks or you could try to buy as many cards that can give you points from

the market row as well and create an engine there so there are multiple ways to explore uh points in that game and combining those in two or three ways you know focusing really heavily on uh one section over the others depending on your your player you know asymmetric faction as well makes that game feel very different every time and there is an ele of Mastery to that that I can respect and the same I feel is true with arnac you have different areas that you can focus on the game the exploration or the research track as well or even the acquiring of cards you know a combination of all of those can lead to a ultimate score and I think it's it's difficult to understand the game just at the base you know level of it based off of you know one or two plays I think you really need to sink your your teeth into the into that game in particular to find out what how each um portion of the game interacts with each other and to find you know some skill in in repetitive play I feel like you can get to that ceiling a little bit faster with rise of bable because you're ultimately only focusing on trying to play the thaing game and and acquiring cards and that's it and the cards themselves didn't feel very uh you know they they didn't feel like they were breaking a lot of rules once again to to explain my my thoughts on Dune Imperium with the cards that you

acquire not only are they thematic and it helps that D Imperium is based off of an IP with characters and events that do make sense in the lore itself that the game is trying to portray but the things that they can do as well are very interesting and they make each card feel somewhat unique not all of the cards do that they each just mitigate the game in in small ways here and there but some of those cards like uh the there is one card where you can turn in money for points right and there's only one or maybe two of those types of cards that exist in the game and so when you see that come out in the market that could ultimately uh push you towards a certain strategy that you want to take and after glancing at the cards and Rise of Babel I felt like they all mitigated and and twisted the game in small little ways here and there to give you small advantages and you can create an engine with the way that you build your deck and trash you know basic cards as well you can tailor your experience to perhaps you know move a lot of tiles you know very fast with your elephant or what have you but it it didn't feel like it was as expansile or as unique feeling as the deck building and the card engine that you were developing in games like do and Imperium so ultimately all all that that is to say is that I think rise of Babel is a great deck building game and I think it really focuses and I think that's the intention of the game is to make a elegant deck building experience

that has one Focus for you to pursue which is to build the Tower of Babel and I think it's very similar in weight to say Clank I I didn't feel like the interactive board and the dungeon crawling experience related as well as per endless winter did compared to uh rise ofel but weightwise I felt like Clank and Rise ofel are more at the same level but because of that I I feel like Dune Imperium and arck have more interesting cards and more interesting ways of journeying through the game to gain points which create an element of Mastery and replayability that interest me that I don't think rise ofel has quite yet now with the expansion I think it UPS the complexity a little bit it doesn't quite reach the the Intriguing point for me to want to replay it again over and over again but I am not disappointed in the game that I played I think it has been developed and designed very well and I think if you are a fan of mediumweight deck building games that cuts out a lot of fluff and kind of gets to the meat of the matter games such as Clank and perhaps even Dominion then I think you will enjoy rise of Babel as well so those are my first impressions on rise of bable once again look for the kickstarter in about a month's time thank you for Consulting with me and hope you schedule an appointment with your board gaming doctor real soon take care

Progress saved