Clans of Caledonia Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm talking about the clans of Caledonia which is a euro economic start board game for wonderful players picks for an hour and a half to play now the idea of the game is you are trying to get as many points as you can by basically farming the resources are competing contracts and competing end-of-round objectives but the game plays pretty quickly in terms of and what you do in each of your turns because you just do one simple action and these actions can be a number of different things such as I'm putting workers down on the board which will increase your income each round you can put different resources on the board which will kind of increase your production of that type of resources so you've got a budget of resources such as your wheats and your your cows and sheep which give you milk and will in return you can also kind of slaughter those I'm going to get you kind of beef or or lamb you've got the capability of turning the wheat into into alcohol or bread there's lots of different things you could do and I'm kind of production lines that you can go down to get different types of resources most of the things you can upgrade your own unique player board which will let you kind of travel around the map a bit quicker because you can gain the ability to travel over water you've got the ability to increase your income from your workers you can also do other things such as giving you more power in the kind of buying and trading places of the game because this game does have a an active stock market so
you've got that commodity speculation kind of aspect to it where you know you can not only harvest your own resources but you can also buy them straight to the market or sell them straight to the market obviously the more of these kind of resources that you that you invest in the more you can do that so it's pretty much about your management of money you know how you're going to spend your money most efficiently and to ultimately fulfill those contracts to get the points the the game is as I said we do is one of those actions in return so you know tends to fly pretty quickly it's very much of a money driven style game because when when I place things on the board not only do things on your player board have a cost to them but also the Lambs you're laying on also has a cost associated to it as well and you've got kind of four different types of kind of lambs you can build on or have to consider because you've got your kind of fields which you can build your resources on you've got the mountains which you can build your build your miners on which will give you your income and you've got your fields which will let you build your Lumberjacks on which will give you a bit less income the end of the round objectives are very varied you got such as ones or ones that can kind of give you points based on how many resources you have in your in your pool you've got ones based on how many company workers you've got deployed on the board and all kind of different things like that or even kind of like how many workers you've got on the edges of the wall and stuff like that so there's lots of different things you have to consider and you can also see what kind of
scoring criteria is going to come up as the game goes on so you can plan in accordance to that which is a which is nice in terms of its strategy the the game kind of works in this aspect where you going to keep taking actions until you run out of actions or run out of money and you pass and the first person to pass is going to take more income than the kind of foreign players who pass you know in respect of how quick the actors are you also have to consider that some players might run out vacuums are not quicker than other players so you might have to sit out that game a bit longer than they want to at times which is a bit of a you know a double-edged sword there there's a lot of things to consider in this game because as I said you've got the and you've got the resource market you've got the contracts you want to get then you can only have a have one contract at a time which could be quite restrictive obviously when you complete these contracts you need to get rewards in return and those rewards a bit money they can be kind of a free upgrade they can be expanded on the map without having to pay the cost and but they also give you rewards based on these three different kind of boots they're going to score at the end of the game so you've got your I think it's the sugarcane you've got the cotton and you've got tobacco as well and whenever anybody couldn't complete a contract with any of those goods as a reward you're going to move them up the kind of scoring track and at the end of game for each or depending on the position of each others on the scoring track you can either either going to score four five or of three points depending on the popularity of this good so the rare are the ones that been shipped you get five points each and the
most kind of common one that shipped you can get three points each and that goes for all the players so and that's a bit of a strange concept it's a bit more difficult to explain than actually it works in practice and personally I thought it was a little bit all that part of the game of though it was a little bit overwrought and maybe could have been simplified to you know just just streamlined a bit more because it just seemed like it a little bit convoluted for the sake of it but other than that I think all the game mechanisms are very clean very simple you know just do a quick upgrade you get something else on a map I mean once you finish your actions you're gonna kick all your produce we're just gonna no give you wheat and your and your milk and your wall and stuff like that and then you can convert them freely into the other goods depending on what you've got placed on the map at the end of the game you're also going to score a lot of points based on who's who's completed the most contracts and also based on the different kind of clusters of farms that you have on the board because for every farm that you have or every kind of yeah there's a cluster that you have and within shipping distance of each other um you know whoever's got the majority of those is going to score a whole bunch of points and so on if you're a second or third and that's something to really consider in terms of you know grabbing up the land that you really want there's also incentives to go to the corners of the board because when you go to those corners you could I'm not kind of one up abilities which would give you you know free meat or it can give you you know a bunch of money or you can get contracts and stuff like that so there's lots of them you know there's little
kind of abilities you can get by building into the corn to the board and incentives incentivizes you to do that and that's pretty much the flow the game I mean you're going to score they're different things and you know it flows pretty pretty quickly and I think once you've got the rules overhead in your mind after a round of two is pretty young it's pretty digestible and the balance of the game is really good especially considering that every every game play is going to be given a unique player ability and those abilities are quite different I mean you've got ones that you've got to give you there's one ability that lets you have two contracts going at a time when you do take a contract to you and you have to pay for one and you can get to you've got ones that can kind of let you sell milk at the end of these your production phases for full cost so it's a good kind of money income that you've got ones that can you know whenever you go to the stock market and buy yourself stuff you can get it for one cheaper or sell it for one more and you've got one sitting to give you cheaper abilities to build in different in different places on the map so there's a lot of different unique abilities in the game and you need two player powers which make you you specialize in something we can kind of each player can manipulate to get the most out of their power to earn you know to specialize which is which is always a nice touch and can give a bit more replayability to the game the the time investment I think is is pretty good I mean it takes about an hour and I have to play or at least run that mark give or take but I would say it's especially quick or I would say I'll take this welcome ID I think it's just about right
so yeah no real issue there at all and I said play up time is pretty good because the player actions of quickly go by quickly is the only thing that I would I would consider is if some players are really kind of going over their moves thinking meticulously about how they're going to spend their money and you know for a fact you're just going to spend your quick buck and do a quick upgrade then sometimes you can be out of the game for a bit longer than you want to be and you know just be sitting there and and you know just just loving on your next move when you know what you're going to do player interaction is it's pretty loose in this one to be honest there's not a lot of conflict in the game I mean I've seen got that you know the resource market which is page rhythm and you've also got the you know the the grabbing of the land you want but I think overall that's pretty much it there's not a lot of player interaction and of course if you want a particularly contract that another player once then is getting in there quicker it might might frustrate them but personally I found that there was a lot of player interaction to really steer you off track and to have a few impact on your game aesthetically I think the game looks very nice I mean it's Clemens friends are who I love because he's made so much great artwork for the games I love I would say that the components are pretty small I think it could have been 10% bigger the main player board is pretty small although it's modular so it's nice again for replayability the resources the individual player resources boards are just a little bit small for my liking I could have done as
I said being 10 to 15% bigger theme-wise I mean it's just standard euro farming style game so there's not a lot of theme here but I like the way that the resource is converging to one another you know having the week to convert into the alcohol and the bread and stuff like that and even just deploying the animal was under when you want the meat you can take down and was off the board to get that meat to fulfill this contract so you've got that kind of real farming and filter out the setup and teardown time is it's not too bad I mean you've got the player boards which you do have to deploy all the resources on individually and that's a little bit fiddly but you know not too burdening something I would I would say about the game is that I never really felt like I was ever taking extremely powerful terms and I didn't really have that whole kind of crescendo feel to it although you do get more powerful by deploying more resources and covering more of the board so that you're in comfort you know increases each round very much feel like it was a bit of a flatline in terms of the arc of the game I didn't feel like I've really ramped up and got more powerful the the scalability I wouldn't pretty wouldn't play this with more than three players because again just up down time I wait for other player's actions but you know you can play solo mode if you want to although this solo mode is a bit your own school kind of game so it's pretty you know it's pretty bland and it's just going to be competing against your previous scores which is not something I tend to favor and and I said it really I mean I think this game is extremely well designed I mean there's not really much I could complain about because I like
about Italy you know the unique player powers work well the resource market works really well you know it's got your standard euro trappings in terms of saving up resource to cash in his contracts I've nowhere to hold up to do so is important because about what those the resources to completely objectives but you have to bear in mind that as the game goes on that resource or the contracts that they get more expensive so you have better in mind you know increasing your your travel ability is important as well because you do want to get all these different clusters of off your farms and the game also does a good job of not being able to do everything I think and that's something that I can't see click competently you know having to if you really want to specialize in the contracts you're probably gonna have them dig that something else and so on so it's got that adversity you can kind of focus on something else each time although I do feel like there's not a whole lot of scope to explore in terms of different strategies and stuff but yeah everyone this game is well designed it's well put together I can see why it's so well received but the only problem I have there I felt like it didn't have the highs and lows of what I won in the game it's very much quite as I said quite flatlined and there was no real memories of excitement there was no real moments of having you know where I felt like I played real well or had a really strong powerful time but I built up to so in that respect it fell a little bit flat for me but I don't want that to be a condemnation of the game because it gave me so well put together and I did have a good time playing it however I don't think it'll be something that I'll kind of seek to actively
request to play again although if someone did kind of recommend or suggest playing it with me then I would have replaced players so I'm certainly not a negative review whatsoever I enjoy my play this one better it falls at about a 7 out of 10 for me where if I'm looking to play an hour and a half to two hour game I want to pay you know an 8 or a 9 out of 10 and also your 10 out of 10 at this point so this feels a little bit under par for me or that that's gonna really kind of you know get my excitement going and you know I didn't really feel like you know I had the urge to come back to this one but yeah a solid game classic caledonia and one that I think a lot of people are going to recommend especially if you don't like any conflict in your game and you like the resource market stuff like that this one does do that well so yeah I hope you enjoyed this review if you have please like and subscribe my channel got my other videos too forever house I'll see you next time on chairman or the board bye