Spirit Island - Board Game Review
Transcript
welcome to allies or enemies where we talk about games and especially how they work for two this time we are looking at spirit island designed by r eric rice spirit island is a co-op game for one to four that has players taking on the role of island spirits in an effort to chase off colonial invaders it's a deck building area control game with a lot more mixed in before we get too deep into it this is a complex game but it is rewarding we had actual headaches after the first few plays and took a break from it for a few months before coming back but once it clicked it really clicked and now we can't wait to figure out new spirits and combinations the biggest thing players will have to get used to is losing early which will always happen to come back later which will hopefully happen but we will get into all of that later let's start with the basics of how it's played the bones of a turn are actually pretty simple level up your spirit choose cards play fast powers activate invaders play slow powers and repeat but within that framework is a mass of variability and depth in the growth phase you're going to be choosing whether to increase your presence gain new cards reclaim cards increase power economy or some kind of combination of those then you choose your cards and you need to think about if you want to play before or after the invaders if you have the aspects to trigger your innate powers if you want to attack current invaders or stop their
spread or remove blight and how do you work with your partner or partners should you spread fear and then you need to worry about the invaders who are going to attack your island build their cities and continue to spread every single turn there are a lot of moving parts at work here it's a game that is going to demand your full attention but luckily the rules are pretty easy to follow with a couple of notable exceptions such as the fact that invaders attack both the land and islanders simultaneously but most of it makes sense it's just kind of thinking and it will require multiple plays before those things fully click you win by either raising the fear to the max level or destroying invaders to match your current level you lose if invaders finish their colonization or if your island becomes too filled with blight the replayability here is through the roof the core box includes eight spirits ranging from fairly simple to quite complex and all of which play very very differently some spread fear some destroy some defend some focus on one type of land or on acting before invaders they all have different starter cards and innate powers and the spirit you choose will greatly influence how you play and then there is the difficulty which starts out fairly challenging and ramps up to nigh impossible finding
ways to meet your ever-growing comfort and expertise at the game with new bumps in the road the base game comes with a number of adversaries with a range of difficulty levels as well as two-sided boards that offer a more complex and realistic alternative we have played this game a lot and have still barely scratched the surface although that hasn't stopped us from grabbing the expansions which add even more spirits and adversaries and tokens and cards to the degree where we could play this game every day for months and still not see everything spirit island plays from one to four or six if you've got the newest expansion and it seems to scale well as each player adds one new board as well as a proportional number of invaders and islanders and everyone acts simultaneously so added turn time shouldn't be a factor but added planning time probably will is more spirits means more combinations more danger and generally a bigger web of decisions we of course only play with two and two players is great it's fun figuring out combos of spirits and getting to use some more specialized ones that could be tricky in solo games one big plus is that this is not a game that is going to have an alpha gamer quarterbacking problem there's just way too much going on this is a pure teamwork co-op game and that's a big part of the chump
there has been a significant amount of love put into this production the boards and cars and invaders and little dehaan huts are all well made the artwork is gorgeous the spirits all have their own feel that starts with their look but with a style that ties everything together in the game the icons also make a lot of sense and the game does a good job of combining just enough language to keep it all clear if there are any complaints it would be with the power tokens which feel really plain and the expert side of the board which can be hard to differentiate but those are small complaints in an otherwise outstanding production we've had more of a journey with this game than almost anything in our collection as we said off the top our first games felt hard it felt like my brain was overheating but after a few games of stumbling and a bit of a break to regroup it clicked and this game jumped way up our list biggest tricky to understand with spirit island is that you will lose early on some games you're gonna feel helpless for those first few turns but as you level up things get brighter and brighter it's a really strange game flow that takes some getting used to as a gamer it's hard to be comfortable with falling behind but when you make that comeback it pays off even bigger this should not be the first co-op game you play it shouldn't even be the third but if you are looking for the next level
and you've played pandemic and you've played pandemic legacy and maybe another co-op game and you want a real sandbox of choices and you're okay with a learning curve this is a game that is going to become a real staple of your collection and that is it we love to hear about your own experiences with this game did you have the same learning curve what are your favorite spirits how are you enjoying the expansions and please do like and subscribe and hopefully we will see you all next time for another game