Skip to main content
Loading video...

Alien Frontiers Review

Transcript 25:24

welcome to John gits games as selected by the voting level supporters of our patreon page today I'll be reviewing alien Frontiers this hard scii themed worker placement game uses dice as workers you'll be rolling them and modifying them with alien technology before utilizing them to construct colonies on an alien planet first we'll go over some gameplay examples to teach you the rules as well as get a feel of how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review here's the starting setup for a three-player game of alien Frontiers you'll notice there are already some red dice out on the board they are from the non-playing character they kind of tighten up the board so those spots we can't go into and we'll never be able to remove those dice I'm going to explain how to play the game through a series of turns which will explain all the different options but will also give you a feel for what the thought process is behind playing the game so we're the yellow player here we start the game with these three dice you can get up to three more which is nice but at the beginning we just take all of the dice we have and we roll them this is a worker placement game and these dice are the workers on each turn you're going to put every one of your dice out onto the board Bo in different locations and evaluate them however each location is restricted by the number of slots they have as well as certain ones require like a pair over here a three of a kind over here and this one requires a straight of numbers we know that we can generate more workers we start with three but we'd like to get four five or six and so if we look at the shipyard we see that we're going to need a double which we have however it'll also cost a single Fuel and a single ore for that fourth ship so we can't quite do that this turn instead we should probably try to get fuel and ore to to set up next

turn being able to grab that ship so if we look at the lunar mine we see that you can put dice here as long as they are greater than or equal to previously play dice there are there's already this red one here so that means pretty much any die can go here that gives us a pretty cool option we could take both of these ones and put them on the mine and each die is going to generate a single ore so usually uh it's hard to get ore out of here with low value dice cuz people like to put high value stuff in here but we're the first player we can sneak in and take two ore and finally we need fuel so we could take this four and put it over at the solar converter there are no restrictions at all for the solar converter Beyond eight Max Dice and we look at the little grid and we see that four on a die is going to get us two fuel for our person we've put all of our workers out so this ends our turn and it would now go to the player on the left all right so the blue and green player have gone it looks like the green player was able to build another die and now it's back to our turn and there's quite a bit more going on the board the first thing that you do on your turn is you take every D of your color and you pull them off the board and then you roll them looks like we got lucky we were hoping for a double in order to activate the shipyard we got more than a double so we can take these uh two ones right here and we can put them down in the shipyard because there's an open slot and because they are equal to each other because of this little equal sign on the board so then we pay a single Fuel and a single ore because we're getting our fourth ship and that ship is going to come into the maintenance area and we'll be able to grab that and roll it at the beginning of our next turn so now we're

left with a single worker and it's a one value there's not a whole lot we can do when we look out to the board we can't get or because it has to be three or higher we could get some fuel but it would only be a single fuel so instead what we're going to do is look to the Colony Hub down here if we take a die and we can put a die of any color down onto this slot here we're essentially calling this row and there's enough rows for each player to have their own if you put a die down and you don't have any colonies in process then you're going to go ahead and take one of those colonies and put it to the first slot in this track right here each subsequent die put into the colony Hub is going to push this little Colony forward once until they get all the way to the end and at that point you can spend a single Fuel and an ore to send that Colony down to the surface of the planet but we'll get to that in a

minute all right it's our turn again and you'll notice we lost an or that's because green went to this Raider Outpost you'll see that it always has to be a sequentially ordered set so we have two three and four and when you go there you can steal up to four resources from a variety of players so they stole a single ore from us and three ore from the blue player so pretty unfortunate for both of us and now we grab all of our dice including this new one that we made last turn so now we have four workers which really increases the amount of stuff that we could do with our turn uh there are a couple different stations that I haven't talked about yet so let's go ahead and activate one of those let's start by taking this six here we can put it down on the lunar mine to take an ore that replaces the one that was stolen from us by green and now we can take this other six here and put it onto the terraforming station you'll see it has a six printed on the board that means that only sixes can go there when you activate that terraforming station you need to spend a single Fuel and a single ore in order to immediately turn that spaceship into a colony and shoot it down to the planet so we go ahead and get rid of our fuel and our ore and we immediately take a colony from our supply and put it straight down onto the planet when you look at the planet you'll see that it's split up into eight different regions with these dotted lines and they're all these little tiles on them these are bonuses that you get if you control a territory and you control it if you have more colonies in a spot than anybody else so if you're the first person to go down then you're going to get to take that tile as well that shows that you control it each colony on the planet gets you one Victory point and each territory that you control also gives you a victory point so in this case we just generated

two points and we show it on this track over here the reason you want these tiles is because they all give you bonuses if you look at this one right here it's a bonus for the Herbert Valley and you pay one Fuel and one or less every time you use the shipyard this is really good for us because we just destroyed a ship in order to land this Colony so this will make it much cheaper to get more ships going in the future at this point we don't have too much to do with these two dice so we go ahead and take them and put them in the colonist tub this is essentially what you do with dice you're not sure what to do you'll just push your little Colony forward just getting it closer and closer to dropping it on the planet getting more victory points and grabbing more

tiles so it's AR turn again and it looks like blue is able to create a new ship and green was able to use the colony Constructor for this one you have to place three dice that are all the same value but you also need to spend three ore in order to do that they were able to do this because they stole a bunch of ore from everybody on that last turn when you do the colony Constructor you immediately take a colony uh disc you put it down on the board it looks like they went into the Bradbury plateau and they took the bonus if you look at the board you'll also see that it's printed here it just has a minus or and you'll see that it's kind of connected here that just means if you have that bonus it costs you one less ore when you do this Colony Constructor so in the future green can do it for only two ore the die we use for the terraforming station is gone so we remove that from the board and then we take the rest of our Dice and we go ahead and roll them cool so I think this is a good spot to show you how the alien artifact area works if you'll see you can put up to four dice here or anybody really can and if you put dice whose values are equal to or greater than seven then you can take one of these three alien artifact cards and put it into your possession and they give you really good bonuses as the game goes on so we'd probably take this five and a four and we put that down here 5 and four equals 9 which is greater than or equal to seven so now we can grab one of these three and uh let's take a look at them the booster pod is pretty simple it says if we pay a single fuel we can add one point to one of our unplaced ships so if we roll a four we can spend a fuel and turn it into a five that's pretty cool we've got a alien Monument which is really simple you get one Victory point if you possess this card so just holding this would scoot us up on this track so that's pretty pretty

great it's important to note that when people go to this Raiders Outpost they can take up to four resources or they could steal one of these alien artifact cards from somebody so while you might have that Victory point for now somebody might come in and steal it from you later on the last one is this polarity device which is I think the one we want to go for you see it says pay one fuel to flip one of your unplaced ships to its opposite face so this is really great it could turn a one into a six uh which would be a very good thing when you're trying to make ore so let's go ahead and take this card and put it in front of us whenever there's a slot open we go ahead and draw the top card it looks like oh it's a stasis beam this is the opposite of the booster pod you can spend a fuel to remove a value from one of your dice which can be important sometimes when you're trying to make a run or make a two or three of a kind lastly it's good to know that you can always put a single di of any value down into the alien artifact Zone to get rid of all three of these cards and draw three new ones since we have this cool power that needs fuel to activate and we have no fuel we can go ahead and take this six put it into the solar converter would get us three fuel it's important to note that you can only use each of your alien Technologies once per turn so three might be a bit Overkill but as you can see fuel is useful for a variety of

reasons so here it is our turn again and it looks like both blue and green created new ships so that's not great blue is up to five ships they can start doing a lot of stuff on their turn and we only have three so we go ahead and take all of these back and we roll them and in order to do the final demonstrations I'm going to cheat a bit I'm going to push this colonist a little bit forward in the hub uh don't worry about it you didn't see anything so now we have a colony that's one away from the end of this track and we want to get it there to land it on the planet to kind of go after green zone here but when you land a colony on the planet from the colony Hub it takes a single Fuel and a single ore we only have fuel right now but we have two different ways we can go about getting the ore that we need the first thing would be just going to the lunar mind we can't do that right because the highest value here is a four and we just have ones and twos but we can make a six by using this polarity device we just got we can spend a single one of these fuels and take this one and flip it to its opposite side there it is it's a six and now we can take this and plunk it down on the board which gets us the ore that we need the other option if we were to put this back to the way it was it's not as efficient but it shows off a cool mechanic you can take these two twos here and put them on the orbital Market over here the way this works is you can convert fuel into ore at a ratio of whatever the value of dice you put down here they have to equal each other so if we put two twos down then we can spend two fuel in order to get a single ore likewise if we put two fives down there we could spend five fuel to get one ore but that wouldn't be very good so we could put this here we

could take both of these fuels get rid of them and this would generate the ore we need obviously this is significantly less efficient than the first way but it's definitely an option you can consider so finally we take this guy right here and we put it over on the colonist Hub which pushes it to the end we spend our ore and our fuel which lets us drop the colony down onto the planet so we could put it in all these different zones but it's much more fun to drop into a zone that somebody else is in once a player does not have a strict majority in a region anymore they actually lose the bonus that's associated with it so this tile is going to come back here green is going to lose that point and they're no longer going to get the benefit that that bonus was going to give them and lastly of course just putting a single colony on the planet would get me a single Victory Point play is going to continue this around and around the board until one player places their last Colony on the Planet at this moment the game ends immediately and we check over here to see who has the most victory points that player is the winner I'm going to briefly explain the six different region bonuses that I didn't get to in the rules so if we look over here we have the LM bad lands and it means every time you put a die into that solar converter that gets you fuel you're going to get an extra fuel for each die put down that's pretty great we have the hinen Plaines which makes that market that uh lets you trade fuel for or at a two for one or 3 for one ratio if you have this bonus it's always 1 to one we have the pull footo Hills which is really nice it means that each card that you activate each alien artifact gets a minus one fuel cost associated with it so this polarity device if you had the pull Foothills bonus would be free to use again only once per turn next we have the burough desert if you control this

Zone you can spend a single Fuel and a single ore in order to get access to this artifact die which you can join in with the rest of your dice really nice thing about this is if you're ever able to terraform it by making it a six you get to buy it back for the super cheap rate instead of of this really expensive ships down here next is the azimoff crater it says that whenever you put at least two dice down into the colony Hub you get your usual tube movement but then you get an extra bonus move and finally the van vote mountains simply lets you put a single die into the lunar mine each turn that breaks this rule so you can put a single one down here even though there's all these fours but you only get to do that once per turn for my review of alien Frontiers I'll be going over each item of this list starting at the top and working my way down to the bottom so let's start with those positives and the first of these has do with the way that alien Frontiers goes away from the standard round based architecture that most worker placement games live in most worker placement games involve everybody putting their workers down in some fashion until they're all on the board and then you clear them all off somebody becomes the new starting player and You Begin a new round with an empty board alien fonteer says nah I'm not going to do that we're just going to keep going around the table until the game is over and what this means is so in a standard worker placement game you have like three phases to a general round you have an empty board where you have lots and lots of options you have kind of a congested board where you have some good options but definitely not all the ones you want and then you have the late round where there's almost nothing left and you're like I have nothing good to do with this piece alien Frontiers Treads right down the middle of that very well so the board is always well congested but not too congested or too open because at all

times all of your opponent's pieces are out on the board so that's a very cool idea that make this game feel definitely fresh to me and it also takes away that necessity to always be gunning for being the first player in the next round well there are no rounds in this game you just need to continue doing the best that you can and I really like that change to the worker placement mechanic positive number two is more of a personal one for me and that is that I love the hard sci-fi theme that is just spilling out of every corner of this game when I was young I was borderline obsessed with hard science fiction novels I would spend hours at the library pulling every book from the Sci-Fi section off and looking at the front cover reading the back I read every single book they had in that section for Isaac azoff and I read hinin and Herbert I just love this setting it's very nostalgic for me and so when I'm playing alien Frontiers it really pulls me right back into it because the art is exceptional and it also just really encapsulates that Vibe I feel like when I'm playing this I'm seeing all these different things that could have been on the front covers of all those books that I loved so much when I was a kid and I that really increases the enjoyment for this game for me and I think a lot of people also like this space theme that is also a retro sci-fi kind of thing going on where things are what the future look like in 70s and I just love the way it comes together in this game and it really makes it pop for me and now let's go into my first neutral point and that has to do with the actual dice rolling portion of the game these dice are normal they go from one to six in their values and so when you roll a whole bunch of those in this type of game you want the outcome of that dice roll to restrict your options

and give you interesting decisions however you don't want to be Crest Fallen if you rolled a low set or really happy if you roll a high set because you don't want Randomness to become too big of a factor in this sort of of thing and I think the alien Frontiers could have done a slightly better job of balancing out and equalizing low to High Rolls I don't think if you roll High consistently the whole game you will definitely win but it's going to give you a small Advantage there's a couple reasons for that if you roll high you're going to get more ore from the lunar mine you're going to grab more fuel from the solar converter you'll be more efficient at grabbing cards from the alien artifact section and of course you need sixes in order to use the terraforming station which is very important versus if you roll low then you get to do better at the trading Outpost OB viously you want low numbers to get a good conversion ratio and you need a low number or two in order to effectively use that rating Outpost so that's a pretty big difference to me and obviously that colonist Hub is pretty equal you could put a one there or a six there and they do the same thing so there's no benefit there so I wish that maybe they made the solar converter inverted so that ones and twos gave you three Fuel and fives and sixes only gave you one to kind of counterbalance this slight advantage that you get for Just Happening to roll high but as I said ultimately it doesn't break the game I just wish had been given a little more thought neutral number two has to do with downtime and the fact that it can definitely become an annoyance in three to four player games especially in the mid to late game and the reason for that is because at that point you're going to have a whole bunch of dice that you just rolled you're going to have several alien artifacts and you're going to have quite a few options that you can do you can increase or decrease the value of

this die you can flip a die you can add one to two different Dice and you can do all sorts of manipulation to this hand and then you're looking out on the board and you're trying to decide what the best thing to do is and then can you even get there and you're having a really good time while you're doing that I always enjoyed that puzzle flipping stuff around and doing this kind of thing but if you ever looked up at everyone else around the table you'd realize they're all on their phones or this is kind of really bored because there's not much that you can do when somebody is having one of those really long turns now I know some people talked about having a variant where everybody has a shield and you can roll your dice at the end of your turn and really think about what you could do until it comes back to you and that would probably remedy this to a certain extent but ultimately each person puts a lot of dice down on the board so it's very likely that the person even just to your right is going to do something that's going to stop that whole plan that you had going already even if you were the next player and then you have to just start over again from scratch and then just figure out what the thing you want to do is so I feel like something potentially could have been done to reduce the downtime a bit ultimately the best thing you could do is probably not play four player as much but I'll get into that when I go over the player count neutral number three is honestly more of a warning and that is that alien Frontiers has the potential to be quite mean based on the play group that you play with I have played games of this where that rating Outpost is constantly full because it's not that hard to get a run of three dice especially with one or two alien Tech Dice manipulations and then when you do that you get to steal important alien tech cards from other people or just steal their resources uh from a variety of players so there have been times where I just feel like I

can't get around the table back to my turn without having lost almost everything that I gained on the last turn and in those instances well I feel like well I got to mess that guy up because he's took all my stuff I'm going to to try and make a run of three and steal his stuff back and it just it's an ongoing pervasive thing the flip side is I've played many games of this that were pretty much completely passive and that Raiders Outpost laid dormant the whole game and everybody was just trying to do better at their own thing without really sticking their fingers in other people's pies so it very much depends on the play group and the people that you specifically play with I don't think that the Raiders Outpost is crucial to winning it is just it has the ability to vastly change the temperature and attit ude of the game based off of who you like to play with so now let's go into my one negative for alien Frontiers and that is that I really dislike the way the endgame trigger for the game makes the game into this crazy Mad race to get all of your colonies out onto the planet as fast as humanly possible to the exclusion of everything else and that's because the game ends once one person puts their last Colony onto the planet and then you see who has the most victory points the issue for me is that that person is always the person who wins because almost all the victory points you get in the game come from those colonies down on the planet and controlling different regions and putting a single colony down often times can give you control of a region which gives you a point or at least takes control away from that main opponent that you had reducing the points that they have and obviously someone would not Place their last Colony onto the planet ending the game unless they'd win anyway but after playing the game about five or six times I just couldn't get

over how much that irked me because there's all these other cool things that I want to do that I would spend my time doing and I wouldn't end up winning almost ever because the things I want to do are build cool engines and do NE D Dice manipulations and do cool combos on my turn not just spend all of your time hitting that uh terraforming station as much as possible and getting three of the kinds and getting ore to just keep spamming that colist Constructor that feels like that's not interesting to me there's so many other things you can do I don't want to just spend my whole time doing those two things and then trying to make some ships to make up for the fact that I'm destroying them all the time in that terraforming station so I actually house ruled the game after about six plays I changed it so that the game ends once one person and hits a victory Point threshold based on the number of players I think it was like eight points for four player game something like that and I like the game way more because of that because you could do a really cool turn where you have a three-point swing based off of a couple things that you can do with discarding cards and putting colonies on the planet and you win the game and you might not even have all your colonies down and I just found that a much more satisfying experience so uh take that as you will I did actually change the endgame trigger for the game to make the game more pleasureful for me I didn't hate it with the old endgame trigger it just never really sat right with me now let's talk about replayability as I mentioned in my one negative point I felt after five or so plays that there was only one way to win the game and that was to just make ships as much as you can to immediately destroy them in the terraforming Factory and then try to get three of a kinds and lots of ore to just get those colonies down the planet as fast as possible and that was the only way it seemed to win so I actually

hous ruled it as I said to increase the replayability to make the different winning options much more varied so I think as the game shifts the replayability is okay but that's definitely a flaw of the game having that one better strategy with my fix to the game I got a whole bunch of plays I ended up playing this game 13 times so if I only played five games with a base set in 13 times total well I played it way more with my modification and I enjoyed it much much more and it got a lot more longevity so you need to keep that in mind also this game has a bunch of expansions and I've bought several of them but I haven't actually got any of them to the table and I really should honestly because I might find that some of those expansions might vary up that one dominant strategy with the base way that the end game triggers so I'll give that a shot but just as far as the base game is concerned there are potential issues you might also want to change it like I did all right let's discuss some different player counts now alien Frontiers plays two to four players and mechanically they all feel quite similar in the smaller games you put more dice out on the board they're just always there to lock down some of the stations but the way the games actually turn out is that well in four player games time is just a monster it's enough to make me not recommend it because it could just take so long to get back to you once you hit the mid to late game and I just don't like being bored while I'm playing a game there's really not much to think about while other people are doing all the different dice manipulations if I had four people here and three of them really wanted to play it I would play a four-player game but I would never go out of my way to do that the flip side is with the two-player game it also

plays pretty well but this game can have a little bit of runaway leader show up in a two-player game because you only have that one person to interact with that and if one person's doing really well the other person might not be able to really slow them down also if you're playing with a mean player where you just stealing stuff back and forth you only have that one other person to be mean to so it can really be a slapfest as you're beating each other up so I think three player is The Sweet Spot because you have a little bit more downtime than the two-player game however you can have two people kind of gang up on somebody who seems to be doing really well also if lots of resources are getting stolen well there's another person who might have their stuff stolen instead of yours or you could just spread out the pain among a lot of your opponents not necessarily feel as bad about just keep beating down the same person which is a thing that can happen to me sometimes in conclusion I think the alien Frontiers did a great job of shaking up the worker placement genre when it came out back in 2010 it seemed like at that point that one in three games were worker placement games and they all played so similarly and then Here Comes alien Frontiers and you're rolling Dice and using them as workers and you just keep playing around and around the table you never clear everything off I remember several posts on board game eek where people were confused they wanted to know who the first who the new starting player was because they just assumed you cleared everything off the board because that's the way every work rep placement game worked and it's like no no no that's not how alien Frontiers Works leave those pieces out on the board this is new this is different this is great and when you add on to that the awesome theme that really pulls me in as well as great dice manipulation I was super excited about this game and I had a lot of fun with it but that does not take away from the fact that I think there are some definite issues here the biggest one is

the fact that I house ruled the endgame condition after five games of it I felt like my back was to the wall because I wanted to love this game so much I loved the ideas and me mechanisms in here but I hated seeing this dominant strategy which wasn't even that fun to play and you might find in your play group that that was not a dominant strategy for you but it seemed like that's the way every single game played out and I felt like I had to house R it I really don't like house ring games but once I did I enjoyed it a lot more so you need to keep that in mind when it comes to this review because a lot of my game plays came with a slight modification to the rule set I think as the game came in the box with the rules as printed there were some definite issues there which made it an okay game but definitely a flawed game with my modification I enjoyed it much more but there are still some flaws there downtime is still a definite beast and I feel like you really should have equal opportunity when you roll those dice you don't want low rolls to inherently always be worse than High Rolls even if it's a slight Edge type of situation so if you enjoy work rep placement games and you love rolling dice there is a definite chance that you will enjoy this game but you need to go into it knowing there are several flaws that may become apparent to you you may be okay with them or they might bring down the experience for you if You' like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also if you'd like to become more involved with the channel you can directly support it at patreon.com jits games thanks for watching

Progress saved