Skyrise: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over skyrise which is the newest game by roxley games and designers Adam Gavin and Sebastian um so this is going to be a relatively interesting discussion mainly because there's a couple ideas uh that I have floating around that on this game um first and foremost let me get this out of the way I do not like this game pretty much at all uh this is and whenever I have a lot of games like this normally and I've had time to sit on it so normally if I was actually doing what I used to do which was a run through and then and then a discussion immed mediately after I would have like emotions would have been super high and usually those types of negative reviews get a lot of backlash um there's been time where I can actually sit down and digest it and you know calm down if the game was uh you know really annoying um but I actively do not like almost anything about this game um and the problem that I have with it is one there there's quite a few things so let me get the positives out of the way the game is beautifully produced uh the deluxe components are amazing the met I mean there's not metal
coins there's like one metal coin one Metal Key like um which I mean nicely weighted the the components are fantastic the the buildings uh which I have like these these Deluxe um sunnd drop uh buildings look amazing that is pretty much all I have honestly as a positive um and the reason why I said this was going to be interesting because it begs the question on should games like is is that what gets a lot of people riled up uh about a game in in a positive way because right now every new game that comes out seems to have an eight or above on Board Game Geek um which I don't take that much stock in board game gek ratings but a lot of people do so if you see this sitting right now in an 8.2 it's like oh that must be a really good game but that's every single game every single games that uh that seems to come out now is an eight or higher and it makes me think okay is that people having you know buyers remorse are they in denial that a game that they paid a lot of money for is not actually as good as it should have been um but that's that is an entirely different different topic because I know people are going to apparently completely disagree with me on this uh now what skyrise says what it
is is a it's an auction game because the rule book which is very thin like they have uh two pages in the back are based uh on history of the characters you can be the characters are they it doesn't matter what what the four characters are uh because the only thing that changes about them are the values of their buildings for auctioning but in terms of victory points they don't have special powers they don't have any of that they are literally just here are my arbitrary auction values for my buildings um so that's that's the two pages then this rule book does another thing that I actually really really dislike and I never knew quite what uh what it was called until I listened to Paul Grogan talk about why rule books are bad and what this game does is it front loads you with a lot of info basically the F the concepts of the game which I have always hated how it does because it's like here's a bunch of info that you have no idea how to apply it and I get it in theory because you read all that and then when you actually read the rules you should be able to revert back to what you just read but to me it's never worked uh because it's like well I'm reading all this but I'm not getting it so whenever I read it it's like you feel like you have to flip back and forth but the actual rules are are two pages it's and it's auction the game is two eras It also says the game is 30 to 75 minutes which is a weird kind of range but uh there's two eras and in the
first era you have a certain number of buildings each building has a value on the bottom and that is your auction bid uh now whenever you say auction when I'm thinking auction I am thinking a lot about reading the players bluffing the players uh seeing if you can okay like whenever you're bidding for stuff in a game it's like okay I'm going to bid H like a lot of times where you hide it in your hand and you and you put it out it's just like a lot of times you're thinking of what the player that you're bidding against can do it's like okay and even if it's a round table bid there's a lot of hm do I make them go higher oh [ __ ] okay like yeah they bid 10 do I bid 15 and make them bid higher but man if they don't bid higher then I'm going to lose out on I like I I I can pay 15 but I don't really want to but man if I can make them pay 17 or 20 o that'd be really good you know I'm going to risk it there's a lot of that this game has none of that everything is relatively open information because your values are flat they are a flat number cuz whenever you bid the very first time I played this game I thought I was like oh that's interesting cuz you're bidding for these various locations you're bidding there's these random tokens that are on there that correspond to the different uh colored areas of the board as well as um there are these four whatever
they're called uh patrons I think they're called patrons yeah there's four patrons that have random victory points for them but there's tokens scattered throughout the board so you're bidding for the type of area you're bidding for some locations there's these open objectives you're going for but when you bid you have your numbers of your buildings F like you know secretly towards you but the problem is is you can see what your opponents have off of your player board for both eras so it's not like you're trying to get them to to bid higher if I put this 24 down cuz when you bid you place one face up in the area that you're bidding as long as it's the center tile or adjacent to a bid uh or a building that's already been built if you're starting the bid so I put down 24 my opponents who can see that whenever you bid you have to place the next building you're not bidding for the spot that was there so if I'm putting it a 24 in a green spot let's say I really wanted that my options are either put the highest number there and hope that someone else doesn't have a higher number available but whenever you're bidding for you're actually not bidding for the spot that's there uh you make a trail of building so then the uh the yellow player has a 74 they they're not taking 74 from that spot they have to put it adjacent to that so then they have to go in like this white area and then green could take their
tall building and that's 90 and then that's 93 so that's higher than 74 and then you go around the table blue has 103 so they you have to make this adjacency thing which the first time I heard that rule I was like oh that's different but then you play the game and you realize that you have virtually no control over go going for public objectives you have no control over your private objectives because let's say you really wanted a green spot or you really needed a green spot because of your your private objective well if someone outbids you you are immediately out of the running for trying to do that and then let's say it comes back to you the last one is 103 and you have a number that's 110 and you're like well okay cool I can actually out bid for that spot oh wait a minute there's not a green location next to that so my original plan of trying to get a green spot I can no longer do and because you have to place them adjacent in a trail you can't it's like okay well now in this case my options are yellow and and white there's tokens on there I don't want those tokens but I guess if I want to place a build a building then then I guess that's the only thing I do and then you place 110 everyone else passes and you win that spot the building gets built and then everyone gets their buildings back I despise that because again there's no there's no bluffing
there's no reading there's no control over anything that you're able to get unless there are no long longer any adjacent spots because an auction ends whenever everyone passes or there are no more adjacent spots for people to continue placing buildings or someone places a Wonder there's everyone has one Wonder building that immediately wins a bid but I I I absolutely hated that that was just so frustrating because the only time that you ever have control over what you could what you actually want in this game is is whenever you start the bid and because you start the bid you can place a building in any spot that there is no continuous uh adjacent spots so you automatically win the bid and the problem is the person who wins the bid gets to start the next auction and I it's a rich get richer it's like lucky me oh it's my turn I won that last bid well I have my small building of of value whatever two let's say you're in air or value 14 it doesn't even matter like what everyone else has because oh man there's a building right there in that yellow spot and there's a building in this red spot well look at that I can start in this Green Spot oh no one else can place there I guess I automatically get it I have never played an auction game and it's been very rare
that I have played a game where a majority of players do not get to play and that has happened many many times and even if you are doing that yeah you're putting all your buildings all your eggs in one basket but the fact that you're vying for control over these tokens as well that increase the value of uh your buildings that give you random victory points that allow you to be the first one to get your buildings out while everyone else just has to sit there mind you this isn't a player elimination game uh you just have to sit there and watch them do that in an auction game that would be like going to an art auction and you have a [ __ ] ton of money to be at an art auction and they just don't let you bid it's like yeah I'd like to build bid $1 million on that piece oh man I have a billion dollars in my bank account so yeah I'd like to bid 2 million no no no no he gets it why I thought this was an auction yeah it is uh but he started so therefore he wins well I can out bid him I no no I and yeah maybe maybe whatever this kind of has like a tapestry feeling where it's like everyone who plays tapestry and likes it they they'll even say it's not a civilization game then why is it the [ __ ] tagline why does it say tapestry a civilization game now granted luckily this doesn't say skyrise an auction game but that's what it is that's the two rules of the game or two
pages of rules is how the auction works but there's no like hm man yeah I could really use that spot right there okay I'm going to place this this building down to VI for control of that oh wait no one else can out bid me I guess I get it and everyone else just has to sit here uh I I absolutely like hated that and it's entirely possible like that you could just not win a bid um like and what's also incredibly annoying that I've had is because you're going for certain spots you everyone has a public or private objective which is basically cadas have a certain number of colors like the last game I just played of this it was I had to have buildings in green spots well first of all all of the private objectives are 10 points so if everyone does it whatever so I don't like that um but it's like okay I'm just going to try and go for that because I I know what I can go for well so I'm going to start in this green spot because maybe I'll get it oh wait no someone else got it uh or wait someone out bid me so I can't even Circle back to green and if you try to read ahead of time like let's say you put your your building in like a red spot hoping that people out bid you so you can do the higher bit in green trying to do from some Forward Thinking you have absolutely no control if that is the case if you place a lower value
building in a white area hoping that the next player albid you goes to yellow and then you whatever it comes back around to you and you can get to a green spot you that is complete luck that that even happens you you can't dictate what the players do because let's say that's where you're banking on everyone could just pass then you have a building in white that you do it's like okay cool I just lost a building I got nothing for that um I I that it it's just so bizarre of a design design decision um so the fact that you can see exactly what people's values are now you have to retain what they say on the on or like what they've placed on the board um but every time I've played this it's like okay I'm going to place this building here that should be the highest one okay I ought to win it that's even that's not even you know if it's not even uh adjacent free spots that's just like okay I know exactly that I have the highest value building here so I auto win because no one else can out bid me like that's mindboggling of of decision making um going for the the the public objectives are also completely out of your control like some of them are hey have certain buildings adjacent to Lakes have a chain on each island you're also
controlling going for control of these islands by having the tallest building there it's like okay that's a certain that's five points and then some of the public ones are are three points and it's like okay they can hit multiple times but it's like okay oh man I just happen to have three buildings adjacent to that like even when you're trying to go for it it feels way more work than it's actually worth in terms of victory points that you really just going for the the tokens that are just randomly placed on the map uh the Wonders are aren't cool at all like they're so again so Random some are clearly better than others like one was like oh hey I got my private private objective that gives me 15 points uh or 10 points or whatever it is and then it's like oh man this wonder that I get to place triggers and it's like hey you basically V you know fight for control of the islands again oh wait you got 15 points at the end of era 1 you get your one Wonder now you place it oh man okay that's another 15 points huh I just get to collect an extra token cool there's these patrons out on there these patrons have um these tokens that you place on them they're they're uh face down these are victory points that range from there's a three a four a five and an
eight uh those are the victory Point values they correspond to to tokens of a b c and d you don't know what those values are so you have no idea of where to start for some area control you're like okay I might not get my private objective but man I'm going to get a lot of these tokens for the one that's worth eight oh wait no one knows what what Patron is value eight at the beginning of the game okay well everyone's getting these Patron tokens and it once you collect one then you can look at it you can be like oh I got a D okay let me look at the one oh cool that's the 3.1 okay I guess I'm not going to go after those and then you finally get like one a token and you look at it and it's the 8.1 you look around and everyone else has collected A's so you're like cool I got one that person got four of them okay well that's clearly the most valued one that ranges from 3 four five then eight points it's like you got 30 points over there while I got Max 15 like this game is just so weird it's so weird and the reason why I was like okay this discussion is going to be odd is because everything mechanically about this game I I do not like uh but it's also insanely overproduced which is like Rox ley's thing like I remember with Santorini like but that sanini was super solid as a 1 V one
abstract game and then you had uh r lands which is also overproduced but also a really good card game then you have uh dice Throne which I know is super popular I I burned myself out on that game I do not like dice Throne at all but uh and then you have this one which is also insanely overproduced uh and it reminds me of like okay what games are over produced that really shouldn't be but you kind of okay it because the game is good well foundations of Rome is definitely one of them in fact they're making one that is not produced like that but that's fine because the game itself is super solid it's just a really nice Super Deluxe copy but yeah it doesn't need to look like that and hence why they're making one without it in fact that's based off of another game that's called a chire that is definitely not uh yeah definitely not bougie in any way so this game def I don't I just don't understand like how how this game was made because I swear to God if people tell me oh it's not it's not really an auction game then don't Market it as one don't have literally the rules auction and then bidding cuz technically yes it is that you can out bid if you pass you're out of the bidding race but there's it's
so static it's so like okay I guess what you just place as a value I have one Higher I don't give a [ __ ] about anything that's adjacent to that so I guess I pass and actually the reason that I bring that up so many times is because the last game I played uh the person who kept winning the auction knew that none of us wanted any of the spots adjacent to him so he just kept starting the bid in the exact same spot and it's like I don't want that there's not a token that I want there that helps me in any way it doesn't help me on any of the objectives so I'm going to pass it's like pass okay pass he wins he gets to start the bid again same exact spot pass pass okay yep yep okay you keep winning yep that's all in that Island you're going to have all your buildings there that's cool but and that would be fine if it was really literally just based off of the the different colors the four uh areas to control but the fact that you also get a bunch of tokens that are victory points based off the patrons and where your buildings are he just ran away with tokens because it's like yeah I mean I guess you could say we let him do that however it's like okay cuz for me me out bitting him in a spot like in a spot just to prevent a token it's like
I I don't I don't share the mentality of my opponent not gaining points is the same as me gaining points I I just don't have that mentality and it doesn't feel good even though it's like okay you didn't gain 10 points this round um that's the same as if I gained 10 points no it's not because if they're at 20 points and I'm at 10 that doesn't make me go up to 20 it's no we're still you're still 10 points ahead of me uh and yeah it was like there's there's nothing that that we're getting out of this because again you're going to be the first one to finish out the uh the eras and therefore you're going to get another 10 points so yeah oh yeah you ran out of buildings first cool and what's also interesting is as the game goes on people gradually dip out of the game because eventually once you run out of buildings it's like okay well no one else can cuz you the a era two ends whenever everyone's out of buildings era one ends whenever one person is era 2 ends when everyone does so whenever you are in Era two and one person finishes and it's like okay now it's like me and you if it's a three- player game it's me and this one person bitting back and forth okay well you can't beat me on any of these so I'll finish out mine and in fact there's nothing stopping this the second player or third player from passing and just letting one person just Place their buildings how they want to place them and then the second the last person
doing the exact same thing I've never played an auction game where most players aren't playing it it and I thought I was going to like be like you know what I've had time to digest it and I'm going to be a lot more calm but the more I why am I talking like Trump uh I apparently not because the more I talk about this game the more I I really really hate it oh man oh man do do do I do I not like this game at all um yeah yeah so so that's that's skyrise
um it's like so yeah it's like okay all right redeeming qualities it's like if it's not an auction game game then what is it okay it's an area control game but you have no control over the areas that you're trying to control okay so it's not an area control game um because there's a lot of games that have that type of thing where I mean foundations AR is a is a good one is a really good one of trying to V for control uh to get victory points from public objectives um yeah I mean gr foundations Rome is is way more expensive this is a deluxe edition game that's not that I mean the the the cards are amazing they have these etched backs that's really sexy uh the metal coins the blimps like the insert is really good fits everything nice and tight the uh the scoring markers are these blimps that I was like well that's annoying cuz they have discs instead that would just be easier but then the uh I was like oh man yeah I think these are score markers and they actually stack like so that was taken into consideration I was like man good on you good on you but I almost feel like because you're supposed to keep the the the values hidden I almost feel like you would get way more out of this game if it was actually public knowledge I mean it is public knowledge on these boards at the bottom it tells you what your values are era one uh and era two but I almost feel like it would be easier if you just saw
what like everyone had their values like face up so you could actually look and be like hm do I try and get them to waste their thing cuz you also get vict points for controlling the five Islands the four sides in the middle piece uh and that's literally based off who has the tallest building there but everyone has three value or three story tall buildings and then it goes like oh you both have you all players have one tall building in that Island okay who has the most medium ones okay you're tight there who has the most short ones and also it has like a price is Rip Vibe where whenever you bid uh like if you put like a a 24 down someone could outbid you with 25 and I don't know why that's just worse like that like it's so frustrating because it doesn't go sequentially like that so let's say it goes 24 25 like someone could just do 30 and it's like the fact that you out bid me on 20 like by one point on a spot that I actually wanted is very very annoying but also what makes it even more annoying is it's not for like the same spot it's not like you can look at and be like okay I know they really want yellow I'm going to try and snag that yellow from them because by the time it comes back to them anyway if you outbid someone whatever they wanted is gone it like since you out bid them they can no longer get that spot that they started their building in and then by the time it comes around it's it's trailed and snaked to a completely
irrelevant spot that they're like okay I guess I'll pass and I'll wait for the next turn oh that's right I you won the auction so you get get to start I feel like this game could have been better if it just naturally went around the table it's like okay you started the auction player to my right you won or whoever won who gives a [ __ ] who wins no matter what I at least get to start so that I at least have some control over where it goes and then everyone has it's kind of like when you're playing tiny towns and people keep calling out resources that you don't want you know at least that you're going to get to call out a resource that you want um here it doesn't happen if you don't win an auction you are at the mercy of wherever the [ __ ] the other players are taking you and yeah and it's it's just it's it's just not fun I I did not have a good time uh anytime I've played this game so with that being said on a scale of 1 to 10
um I'm G give it a four I think this is a below average game uh it it would be a three because I literally have said nothing good about it except its production and that's the only reason it's a four a two buming two a three because of production just it's like okay whatever um yeah it's it's so mechanically and game wise I think it's a three but taking everything into account with the way the the board looks the insert the The Minis are are really good uh it's it it's it's a four out of 10 I really really did not like this and I think I think there there could be something here for that the adjacency thing is is different I don't like it in practice it it it is different it's like it's just too too random and they and what's annoying is they they elude to the to the the thing of of player choice where it seems like players have a decision to make but you really you really don't and that is also frustrating so I don't know get rid of the tokens the random tokens getting in and leave it to the public objectives and your private objectives although the private objectives are the same except for different colors so you it you'll know oh man they keep trying to place on I guess they because there's no reason for me to take white to try and go for white location so really just when you
play this game don't try don't try just put out a random building and and then if you get it you get it and then whatever the final score is you're like that's what that is that was that game that was 30 minutes um I guess that's another thing it's it's not long although I would say most auction games shouldn't be long uh I don't know I am very curious on on what everyone thinks of the game I like genuinely because I these these types of games that come out there's very few games that I review that actually I have basically zero redeeming qualities on there's usually one every year and luckily this is not like a high profile game where I'm just hopefully I just don't get you I hope you kill yourself you worthless [ __ ] you don't like the same game I do that matters to me hope I don't get the those uh like I've gotten for some in the past but like I'm I I I really want to know how people take the strategy on this game but I've played this with many people you've seen on the channel That that we play higher strategy games cuz it feels like they wanted it to be light and Goofy but it's not in theme or really in mechanics so I I just don't know I I I don't know why this was made so yeah four out
of 10 but that's my thoughts on skyrise let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tents or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you