The White Castle Review with Ryan Guerra
Transcript
Have you ever dreamed of being the most respected, the most valued, or as middle schoolers would say, the alpha sigma in the court of the white heron? Yeah, me neither. But you know how you walk into Best Buy thinking you don't need anything? And then you see something shiny and think, "Ooh, I need that." Well, today we're talking about the White Castle, a strategic dice worker placement game. You didn't know being top dog at the White Heron Court mattered to you. In fact, you don't even know what it is. Or maybe you do, but then I've got some serious follow-up questions. But once you sit down with the White Castle, ruling that Heron House like Big Bird Run Sesame Street might just become your new favorite hobby. The White Castle is a game for one to four players, and it will probably last you about an hour and a half or so. So, come hang with me at the table and I'll give you a brief overview of the game before meeting you at the end with some overall thoughts.
The White Castle is about a 700-year-old castle that is white. Profound, right? It is not about a greasy Midwest burger joint that only makes burgers sized for infants. Players take on the roles of clan leaders striving to gain prestige within the Heimeji Castle. The game unfolds over three rounds, each consisting of three turns per player, totaling nine turns per player. And whoever has gained the most clan points at the end of those nine turns wins. At the start of each round, dice are rolled and placed in a numerical order on bridges, forming a shared pool. On your turn, you select a die from either end of a bridge and place it onto an action space. Taking from the right side of the bridge is always the most powerful. However, if you take the leftmost die, you will receive the lantern reward. More on that later. There are four areas in which you can place your selected die. These are the castle, outside the walls, the well, or your personal domain, which is a pretty tough guy way of saying your player mat. When placing a die, you calculate the difference between the die and the action spot and gain that amount in coins if your die is higher or pay that amount if it is lower. In three to four player games, your die can be placed on top of an already placed die. In this case, calculate the difference based on the die that is there. First of all, let's take a look at the well. This is basically the White Castle's version of the water cooler, so it's a good place for us to get to know each other. The wells action space is unique because unlimited dice can be placed there, but the value you compare to is always one when you're placing. So, place a die,
gain any coin difference, and then you receive whatever two resources are displayed and one of these fancy dimeals. You better believe I Googled that pronunciation. Next, there's outside the walls, which has two dice spots that connect to the three core actions of the game. Gardener, Cortier, and Warrior. Through these, you get to send your citizens to participate in the life of Hamei Castle. These actions are each fueled by one of the three resources in this game. Gardeners cost food, warriors require iron, and cortier spend your mother of pearl, which makes the other two resources sound pretty lame. These resources are tracked and spent on your personal domain. To place a gardener, place your leftmost gardener mele on a garden. pay the food cost and immediately gain the benefit. You will gain this benefit again at the end of rounds one and two as long as any dice remain in its respective bridge. The Cortier action has two options and you can choose to do either or both. You can pay two coins to take your leftmost Cortier and place it in the gates of the castle and you can allow one of your placed courtortiers to climb the social status ladder of the castle by paying two or five mother of pearl to advance one or two spots respectively. Wherever this little climbing guy ends, his movement will grant you bonuses from the card that is there. Finally, warriors.
After all, no castle is complete without conflict. Place your leftmost warrior on one of the training yards, pay the iron cost listed, and take the immediate benefit listed there. The castle provides the majority of actions that players will take on their turns. Place your die on any available action space and take the benefits that are connected to any of these randomly placed die tiles of the same color. These benefits include gaining resources, coins, daimo seals, clan points, aka these fan symbols, and lantern bonuses. I promise I'll explain that next time I mention it. You can also gain well, gardener, cchier, and warrior actions here as well. And lastly, you can collect herand that push your token further up the passage of time track, which determines player turn order. And the last placement spot is your personal domain.
Here you have three placement spaces that each require a particular color of dye. When you place a die here, you gain all visible benefits of that row that have been revealed from sending your citizens out to the board to work. It's almost as though putting in hard work pays off. I'm a millennial, so I have a hard time wrapping my mind around that. You also gain your action cards reward that is connected to that row. These cards will cycle through here as a result of taking the courtier action and will eventually move down to your lantern area to upgrade your lantern bonus. Did you just say lantern bonus, Ryan? We get to find out what this is finally. I'm almost tempted to not because I'm mean like that, but I promised. So, here you go. Whenever you gain a lantern bonus, you will get everything that is pictured to the right of this icon here. So, this bonus becomes progressively stronger as you move more cards down here, like turning your flimsy lantern into a flood light that could summon Batman. I hope that was worth the wait. Each round ends after all players have taken three actions. At the end of the first two rounds, you adjust the turn order based on the passage of time track and also award any applicable garden benefits. At the end of the third round, the game ends and players can now wallow in regret of any misplays as you calculate final scoring. Players receive one point for every five coins and dimeals they have. Points for having three or more of each resource remaining and points relative to their position on the passage of time track. Each gardener will grant points based on the value shown in its garden. Each Cortchier will gain bonus points based on how high up the castle they moved. And each warrior
will yield points based on how many cortes you have inside the castle. The player with the most clan points is the winner and construct their stuff as the greatest in the court of the White Heron. The other players are basically a bunch of lousy pigeons and not the nice ones, the really stinky noisy ones. So, is the White Castle a crowning achievement or just a greasy slider that's sure to make you sick the next day? Well, that's up to you. But here are some pros and cons from me. Let's start with the pros first. While dice drafting and dice worker placement has been done before, the system in this game is unique and it's awesome. The valuing of high dice for money but the low dice for the lantern bonuses is really cool. And also the dice stacking changing the values is just fantastic. Second, this game is so neat and tidy with incredibly clear and intuitive iconography that makes gameplay feel so smooth, seamless, and enjoyable. And lastly, it's incredibly rewarding. You only have nine actions in this game, and chances are your first action is going to feel really lame and pointless.
However, by the end, you're able to pull off stellar combos and do incredible things that are going to make you literally feel like you are a king that deserves to live in a castle. Now, some cons. First, since you have such a limited number of actions and resources and action chains in this are kind of cyclical, you can definitely have some players experience some serious analysis paralysis as they say, "Oo, I want to do this, but first I need to do this, but I should have done this. Oh, but not if I don't. Oh, but I need that type of thing." Some of us are patient gamers and can live with that. But if watching your friends think and talk to themselves isn't your jam, this might be a downside for you. And secondly, I'm a bit torn on this one, but I think there are some of us who feel like this game might feel like it ends just a touch too early. Like you're finally accomplishing things and feeling good about your life and then all a sudden it's final scoring. I haven't played with the expansion yet, but perhaps that would scratch that itch for anyone who feels this way. Personally, although I think any game can always be improved upon, it was really hard for me to come up with much for cons on this one. First of all, this is my type of game. I love it and I think it's amazing. It's incredibly well-designed and such a blast to play.
So, is this your next purchase? I would say that if you like dice worker placement, this is one of the best games for that ever. I think that's where this game really shines. It also has some great engine building and resource management as well. Personally, if I were to recommend this game to people, I would most likely suggest it to people who are into games like Lorenzo Ill Magnificico, Tua, Coinbra, and Grand Austria Hotel. Or if you like a big game that comes in a tiny box, this is definitely for you because let me tell you, this is kind of insane. It's like at the end of a camping trip when you go to take your sleeping bag and you're trying to stuff it into the sleeping bag bag sleeping bag. You know what I'm talking about? That's difficult. I'm Ryan and I'm honored that you decided to spend your time watching this video.
Feel free to comment your thoughts on this game or tell me a game you wish I would make a video about and I will be sure to reply to your comments. Now, after reviewing a game with such a rich historical Japanese theme, there's only one thing left for me to do. Immerse myself in a traditional deep part of Japanese culture. Aka, I'm going to go watch The Fast and the Furious Tokyo Drift.