Skip to main content
Loading video...

Kingdom Death: Monster - Final Discussion

Transcript 2:05:21

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audio book with a 30 day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audibletrial.com forward slash bg unlocked the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey everyone welcome to the final discussion for kingdom death monster as of i guess technically right now because this we are done 30 lantern years we are done with determination nation as a series uh highlights we killed all three legendary uh creatures technically we shouldn't have fought one of them the the golden god of a thousand years or whatever we shouldn't have fought him but we killed nemesis wise we had the butcher uh the slenderman the hand once uh manhunter lion knight the watcher and then the gold smoke knight um quarries we had white lions screaming antelope phoenix and gorm and the giga lion so that's how our settlement was and

i think i hate this game you think you do i think i do because it i have a pros and cons list this is the only discussion i've ever made a pros and cons list for okay like most of the time it's literally on the like you know after we're done playing it then it's like okay well here's negatives here are positives like say this is almost taken an entire year to do it it's taking a year so i need some structure and so i wanted to at least have some structure because we have already done one discussion years ago like years ago a year years later um and then i did my own discussion uh halfway uh maybe about halfway through on my thoughts 14 15. something like that yeah and uh our the rating for all of us were tens at the very beginning at the very beginning and then mine dropped to a seven you guys were still tens at that point cat also dropped um and then we're here and that campaign was such [ __ ] that ending is it i am i'm not sick to my stomach but i could be if i wasn't so apathetic by this point like i'm just so numb to all just the negatives that i have because at this point what lowers the rating for me is if the negative i can't look over the negatives to the positives like i said i do have i do have quite a bit of prose and there's probably more as we talk um but the negatives are just so bad and there's the number one con that i have is the reason why i can't look past it and so we'll go ahead but that was what you guys think of the campaign

we'll start with there before we get to the pros what do you guys think josh you missed um six games was it six we did we did well because we like five did you ever fight the lion knight no i missed it man we we we he was so bad granted he came in literally the last time you fight him was so we he started at level one around 18. and we had basically kind of these characters so yeah you guys smoke he was a joke but story-wise he was cool so you missed one two three four five so you might have missed seven eight you missed quite a bit actually uh but nothing really happened so pretty much up until like lantern year 18 to 27. what so what do you guys think of the of the campaign devil will start with you well actually i'll try to keep this as structured as yeah as possible i mean this is the first time i have done you know i i have started several campaigns and probably the most of the group that is into the game true i mean i myself have purchased it in its entirety that's true after helping us purchase right yes i win a core game mega bonkers like i got the looks at gen con it's like oh welcome to king of death i remember hearing one guy say as i don't my like 400 [ __ ] dollars and he's like crying because he's also paying a [ __ ] that's a giant [ __ ] black bag of [ __ ] that i had to carry back out and uber out of there anyways i'm off topic what did i think of the campaign it's like i i mean i enjoy the the

gameplay loop of this game i just i'm a weird guy you know i like the skinner box i like winning getting stuff spending stuff i like all that i like those ideas i you know i love monster hunter i like building the gear i like building stronger um it just does it for me you know in in like my tastes i it just does it for me i mean yes the ending the story events i understand i understand all your qualms there yeah and i agree with them yeah i mean you know i you know especially with the legendary monsters i was very distasteful i don't want to have a punishment right after i've just killed one of the you know proverbial beasts of the game the the toughest of the tough sure when you lost the arm yeah uh and yeah they i would have liked a nice little comic a story of like what happened you know why it ended but it just just ended yeah you know uh oh you're talking about with with the gold smoke now yeah yeah that's true that's what i expect i expected the story event like hey here's a whole new section you go to in the book for that but nobody was just a little excerpt like the uh like every other boss the vignette of death yeah that one had kind of a little hey here's what happened to the settlement and stuff like that but it's just like okay uh he you killed him and uh you guys died it's like i mean um i don't want to steal from like what you're gonna say here no no you're good but you know everyone you know the big thing that's in right now is the vague story mm-hmm you know and um you got like dark souls you know like sure big you know i know i don't mean to steal pieces no no it's completely okay but um and that's what they really tried to do here with

this game story wise you know just keep it all gray you know a little snippet here maybe you can all piece somewhat together and kind of figure out what's going on in this world where you came from why this is even happening why you died like this um and the really only sources are it's like online you can look at the the minute many descriptors or you can read all the hunt events and then maybe you can figure out something but it's just so awkward and impossible to gather all together right because normally what they do is destiny did the same thing was in a grimoire like you kind of get the basic overlay of the story but nothing too gritty but you can go somewhere and find it they don't do that like it's you don't you it's not like you can go to their website and find all that lore and like you get the snippets and the mystery because i'm all fine with that i know you guys are probably gonna say dark souls and i i'm right there with you that vagary which when the dark souls come out 2008 something like that 2009 so back then that's what was in that's what people loved it but now you have sakiro that has a story and people are head over heels bloodborne also is still vague but you can get the whole story so i get the dark souls vibe and that's what they were going for back then but at least for me it's like okay fine have the vagary though oh what is it at least give me somewhere to [ __ ] go and then re get everything right it's like that that i mean it was really cool at the time but now it's like okay give me some more yeah like you can keep it vague but give me some meat somewhere like yeah so i mean i i get

where you're coming from in the mystery and that's what makes it cool but even in dark souls where it was so vague you could read item descriptions you could find it because the game gave you the lore now they have books where it's like hey here's your i have i have the dark souls compiendum and it has every item in every game so you can that's a thing yeah yeah and i actually but i kick-started a uh a storybook called you died and it's a dark souls uh amazing and it's like so it's there here it's just like what and it's not even what adam poots has made it's what other players have like scrapulated now maybe there needs to be a vati vidya over this game to where he does make it happen right he does a deep dive into kingdom death yeah um but like where's the source material coming from exactly

it works for you and that's and that's that's that's your your ilk like you you can overlook probably every negative that i'm gonna i'm gonna pinpoint because i mean yes i mean definitely one of my you know my cons is that it's unclear yeah it's so hard if you want to be a person you want to get all the rules right do this game just right it's hard yeah it is hard there's a lot to keep track of and you can almost never call yourself a purist trying to keep it all clean sure and you know kind of when we were getting to the end i was trying to like okay well maybe and now i'm just like whatever yeah let's just just want to play one to finish um so it's kind of like i get that way whenever it's a video game and i'm just like i just want to beat the [ __ ] game like every time i die i'm just like i'm more mad because i just really just want to get it over with right uh and that's kind of where we were at for the past probably five six lantern years we're just like oh you uh you died no you didn't yeah so okay josh what what were your thoughts on that i was actually going to let cat go first oh okay cat i will have less to say in typical cat style um i was disappointed with the campaign itself um seth will know this very well when i have to piece together and i have to form the lore by myself i get mad because that's not my job we watched the movie bright i hated it because i was like that's cool who the [ __ ] are all these people like we never got to find out like my biggest qualm is after all that after doing everything why did we die like i want to know why like like okay he's the gold smoke night

why did we do that be the final boss yes like there's just more that like i crave to know because a lot of times when i play these games like i don't play it for the action um i i want to know the story um and so the campaign left a lot to be desired because his writing is just it's not it's not good no it i mean it's i mean i wouldn't say it's bad like i don't think his writing's bad like his storytelling and whenever we say he we obviously mean adam but i'm sure he's not he has a team he doesn't yeah anymore and i want to i do want to say because in my last discussion when i did by myself i had a different expectation for the game i expected it to be an rpg and it's not and since then i've accepted that and that's not even the negative the role-playing where this is not my character uh that's actually not even a problem like i actually kind of started to enjoy the different people that we could be like oh who do we want to bring out here whenever we were literally fighting him i was so excited to use yahweh and then i was like what about matthew actually he's really strong too so that that's not negative um but whenever you're talking about the campaign this is not a story driven campaign but it likes to pretend it is at times and rather early portions definitely yeah when we were building our convictions and building ourselves yeah yeah that was it felt like it like we were building ours you know right but then it felt like towards the end it was just like a little snippet here and there of just half-assed oh uh he comes down from the heavens yeah it's like okay like just [ __ ] make it make it just blanket make it just be like an 80s movie where i don't have to know why things are happening things are just happening uh but

they they want to allude you that there's a deeper history yeah but they provide no no problem no substance no material that's not that's not the word i think after the launcher it really kind of dried up you're right because it's like to the watcher like say if we just ended it level two at 20 when we fought him it would have felt fairly gratifying wasn't the watcher the end he was the original end you're right that's a good point i mean granted his fight wasn't fantastic we mulched him yep but he would have been harder had we not had the twilight but thematically it would have ended earlier and it would have just would have felt better because our we survived that was what started our settlement we would have lived on and yeah it was since what because what happened made sense it's like oh well yeah he was literally the watcher yeah it cracked and we found a new cave where he originally was and it's like that could have alluded to a second kdm like been like hey actually now this whole new world think of the brand stuff but you're right that is a good uh distinction because after that it was literally oh you guys have to have lanterns and only five level threes yeah that was it yeah because you fight who do you fight up until then you well if you okay if you find them early you will miss butcher level three but that is it that is it and then yeah so i mean you're right it sound like they added five extra lantern years as padding it's like literally just adding in uh like extra dlc just to make the game longer um so and yeah i agree with i agree with

you cat um so josh so i'm actually adding i i came into this whole board game collective as a heavy video game person uh and this board game is trying to do way too many different genres at one time yeah um it has the mmo aspect that we have to be several different characters like in destiny you can share loot amongst across three characters regardless of abilities and whatnot um it wants you to do that this gold smoke night i felt gratified that i died early to make sure that we won but then everybody died oh yeah that is a dark souls ending that is not fun yeah that's true at least in dark souls i have multiple endings even the first dark souls has two i either kill myself to keep the fire alive or i succumb to darkness and become what i'm trying to kill the lord of the cinders so it's true to kill this thing and then to have it kill everyone as i die immediately yeah i made my death worthless yeah that is true because we were like man that's such a good way to go out yeah we were sitting there and you like literally critted it like four times and like we have to and we do we have to do with board games anyway we have to act out some things and that that would get me excited when we're pretending of where we're hitting it or like throwing in the insanity aspect of how cool it is and then we're like okay you roll the one you're

getting minus four because of your death mask yeah like we you weren't even upset no one here was upset like i wasn't upset until i i heard breathless sleep yeah oh so everybody died so it didn't matter yeah my dad was meaningless yeah um so i i like all those different games but i like them as their own thing um i like dark souls for its its vague story and like the item description discovering um i like that in this game i i liked a lot of things in this game i don't like it all together yeah yeah and i think the and also my my pros and cons from the bottom up because my number ones on them are obviously the bigger ones because it was the first thing i thought of on both lists um i will say though that probably the reason i even because i've quit we've quit campaigns before through the series and the reason why we kept going there was a reason why we i kept playing otherwise i would have just wrote it off but what helped a lot honestly was having devin here because one you played it way more so you were able to keep clarifying things and you were the one who knew whatever lore there was so if something happened you'd be like oh that's because of this and i was like oh great so now i have some cognizance of the [ __ ] item or or who were fighting or why the event happened and i was like okay i'm getting more into the story so that was our thoughts on the campaign unless you had any more to say uh my only other thing to put in is that

i'm completely fine with a dark souls like you constantly die and you're punished and whatnot don't make it to where my character permanently dies i have to lose and start over i would not play dark souls if if my first death i lost her i'm not playing dead cells that thing is trapped that game i hate it that game is trash hot garbage i'd be fine okay side note with dead cells if after you beat like the boss then that's where you go back to but nope you can get all the way to the very end and start all the way over once you die yeah it is [ __ ] yeah i quit but you're right that's a good point um so yeah when your character dies it's just like uh and whenever you earlier in the game i find it hard to believe anyone play starts this game and doesn't get attached to their character especially if they're brand new to the game that's just natural yeah i mean if we went back obviously we have the expectations oh yeah brand new into it definitely yeah because i was i was so upset every single fight every time he got hit i'm like i [ __ ] hate this yeah so i mean i mean the whole thing is you know what a lot of people have described it as you know a city game you know it's a hidden city essentially you know it's it's not the individual survivors it's the settlement that generates them yeah if you can create a proper survivor generator because i see the game it perpetually tries to kill your best people because you're coming out with your top group and if you keep doing that it's going to random kill them it's going to find a way so you have to generate you have to dependably generate

powerful creatures powerful fighters so i see what they're doing i mean it's not super fun running into those circumstances so you like you've got this ageless god yeah and then [ __ ] roll that shitty one and then you fall into a crack yep like like when i the first time my first character death i was okay with it because she ended up beating said character and it felt we felt accomplished right we get to the final boss and i died literally a turn two two two attack yeah it was a turn but two attacks earlier and like it's soured because he kills everyone else as soon as he dies i guess thematically what we were going to do anyway was bronze them so no better bronzing statue than the heroes who killed the gold smoke knight and that's how they're remembered but you're right so let's get to my cons list because i know we're going to bounce around on that so we'll start with my my pros like and i from what i have so far and we'll there like i said they'll probably be more expect a long discussion because we probably have a lot to talk about because it was a year this is a year discussion but we might jump uh it might be quicker who knows but my number might one of the pros is a sense of progression so one of the things that was very very exciting and we brought it multiple times i brought it up today and then also uh while we were playing was you do over the lantern years whether it's your settlement or your own individual heroes as you cycle them out you do actually have a feeling of that you're that you are improving like

dark souls and we're gonna probably keep referencing dark souls alone that's what the closest thing is very it's very at least inspired by yes because in those games at the beginning you feel worthless you feel like that you can barely hit that you're dying all the time and same thing here but by the end we're literally okay yeah that's a 90. like or that's a crit or you roll a four and it's a crit say like to show progression in dark souls eventually bosses from the beginning of the game become common enemies oh yeah that's a good point so like we're sitting here fight you guys i wasn't here for this but you guys fought like level three antelope legendary antelope and destroyed they were nothing and the first time we fought the lion it was insane it like killed two people and kat had to get like a 10 because that was the only way we could have crit and she got it and it's like has the elevation of beating the monster the boss and whatever and monster hunter or dark souls or bloodborne and any of those from software games and you're like yeah and those are the moments that feel good that make you feel like like we literally it was like oh gold smoke night okay i have yahweh oh well we have gideon we have matthew we have met let's see who do we want to bring out to beat the [ __ ] out of this guy like the only i mean we had crotch licked me off in abelcorn they were even the losers and but and i'm gonna i feel like every pro i have is gonna be a double edged sword because i can say a con about the exact same thing because while you have that sense of

progression you mentioned earlier they always try to kill your best guy so you even you only get like a taste and there's a reason why probably because we had gods two ageless people a one who couldn't come out of retirement and then an immortal character right that was gonna say that only very specific things could have killed them so they probably don't want you to have those because it makes the final boss easier or the watcher or whatever but then it's like why have them why have that as an option if you're not going to scale to accommodate the the same mechanics that they put in right well i mean here's the thing how i'm feeling is that they want you know you you get to gain these powerful people they they want you to get them but at the same time that's what makes them so epic that they survive so much and i think that's what they're trying to create they keep wanting to test and try to kill everyone that can yeah but at the same time those that make it through and become this level yeah just that much taste here and when you're an ageless swordmaster with a [ __ ] black sword and a regeneration suit and a regeneration yeah it's like oh i lost my arm oh i'm not worried about that right you just get it back i'm deadpool over here yeah yeah i mean or like you also have like a luck god yeah like oh my god lux on it crits on fours or higher or like a [ __ ] i mean actually by the end of it like i just had a [ __ ] ton of armor so i was like oh was that seven damage okay and i couldn't be knocked back so i was always constantly [ __ ] wailing on him um and then cat the only thing that sucked about her character because this is a nasty ass build

the claws yeah she just was i mean but she was just immortal so it's like hey how about you go stand in front of him so he'll focus you oh what is that 96 uh brain damage okay you survived like that's what made you gross it just sucks because you had to sit there and hope that he came near you right when you become a tool yeah yeah pretty much yeah an instrument of victory yeah i mean but other than that if you were if you got um what was it where you could spend survival if you were still like insane or frenzied i guess it wouldn't matter because the oh it was immortal that made you not be able to spend bitter frenzy or whatever that's what it was but yeah like if you could have dashed you would have been [ __ ] disgusting because what was that okay uh yeah oh there we go oh look at that that's 70 that's that's the deck oh trap no problem yep i actually can ignore that so but i still like that like you're right you're like the negative that i had for that one you were able to debunk by saying the fact that you almost want to shelve them and be like okay we'll wait which is what we did um but once we got to ageless and stuff we're like okay we'll just keep bringing them out right like why not you're not gonna die that's the point of asia yeah and so that's that's one of the pros is it does feel good to look back and be like man a level one lion was so hard and then now it's like let's go hunt level three for sport why not chuckle in its face as it roars at it it was bad like i think we beat like an uh like a level three white liner envelope in like

25 minutes it was uh it was the one that didn't get to go oh yeah it was the goal it was the legendary because he happened to get ground fighting and we just it i don't think it got to go it just didn't it didn't even get to draw an ai card we killed it that quick yeah we dealt 15 wounds in a turn 16 no 15 wounds yep yep god because i was like double that i was like oh what i just have to double its toughness okay that's 30. okay that's two now it's at 13. okay oh there it is again yeah i mean ground fighting you just get i mean if you ever oh it's such an early game check yeah that attack is like oh do you have range like an early game that would have been quite a check it's like oh we have no range in the party now like late games like we'll just [ __ ] set up ready for like a [ __ ] gang bang say that yeah my character alone gets to attack up to nine attack rules have three three attacks yeah three dice yeah three dice plus three rolls because they get the surge for free yeah i mean so it so that's that's one of the the pros that i thought of that was actually one i added later so one of the cons is and we've talked about it before is that i believe they want this to be almost what i'm going to call games as a service yes and where have we seen that succeed oh never it succeed it's like succeeded twice maybe and i mean so what i mean by that is the amount of content that is promised to come out and

i'm sure it will i mean there's no i have no i don't have any qualms with the company as like but because they have so much that's gonna be coming out and i guess i should put they want this to be a lifestyle game they want it to be where it's like hey this is one of the games that you are always playing um whether you're doing different campaigns or you're doing this one again and you're trying to do different builds and stuff like that my problem with that and the reason why it's a con is it almost makes it seem like the company's shady hey let's keep dumping just little little pieces of stuff let's keep oh here's over there here's a little miniature that comes with a card or a new sticker that gets added to so you have to keep buying you have to keep [ __ ] adding money into the game i mean yeah i i mean i agree with that it's so addicting it's it's infuriating but i see the the dark part of it because it's just like what we hate in games with all of their dlc and you have to buy half of it to even have the game playable and it's definitely of that same ilk i mean i but i i don't i know i don't know maybe it's what's the word i'm looking for uh stockholm syndrome i guess but it's yeah i definitely and that's kind of what it is like if you've already put the money in i mean and that's gonna be a personal thing if you have the money well that's your [ __ ] money yeah but if you want if you don't have a problem buying 50 pinups just to have them well i mean like if you're gonna be a collector about it yeah you they you can do all that and that's perfectly fine as a con for me though is it's never enough like it's literally hey here's spend 40 bucks on a mini that

doesn't do anything every single menu i have over there except the ones that we've personally made just sit there yeah and it's not like they're story related there's no map where they're moving around and doing stuff where you can go talk to them they're just there like we brought in the guy who's dressed up like a cat yeah he was a halloween survivor i don't even know why we brought him in dressed like that because that's how he was and it was like oh that's closest to the character but you do have to bring up i mean what we're talking about miniatures is that they've done what no one else has custom miniatures sprues to completely recreate the very armor that you are that you have created then that i have to say is the other worth mentioning is pretty cool it is and let's see do i have that okay uh okay that is also a a con um putting them together well the reason why it's like i said it's a pros it's a pro and con because you're right no one has done that but did they need to there's a reason there's a reason why no one does that because no one buys their games so many people like i mean and they have a [ __ ] ton of money like literally millions of dollars because of how much it costs to [ __ ] even play to play the game yeah but the miniature assembly is what turns so many people off from this hobby it's like someone like i've heard multiple people say oh i would i'd buy that i just want to put the minions together i remember you guys would dedicate nights and nights to just sitting up for the core game yeah yeah we're trying together rachel yeah and that's the thing it's like okay fine miniature i actually enjoyed it it's kind of fun and you're right it is absolutely a lot of fun to sit there and be like okay

what does everyone wear i took pictures so i could look and be like okay so that's what that's what they have and i'd make it together like here's you with the beacon shield in your twilight sword with the gorm armor like that represents you as the final fight here's me with mine and this is badass but you want to know how it also is another negative if you keep playing this game you run out of pieces so it's only customizable for that current campaign unless you want to start breaking unless you want to start you can magnetize them do a little drill and that's insane it's possible but it is positively ridiculous yeah so it's like okay well they sell the land or the armor sets separate so keep pumping money into their game so you can even make a second character with lantern armor or or leather armors things like that otherwise only one person really gets to play their character unless you want to share armor um like biggest comparison most multiplayer games now uh destiny the newest call of duty fortnite all that stuff they have seasons where it's like okay for this next x amount of weeks this is the content you have since it's a board game they can't just pump it out right you have you have a wait time for development and literally years yeah and it doesn't it doesn't fit the formula as well as video games do it right so the the whole thing that they're trying to do is super

flawed in my opinion um i get why they do it it's to help fun things later yeah true to make money and that's fine yeah that's whatever uh and i agree uh super customizable up until point i i just don't see how it's viable for a lot of people and i get the new sense of having to put stuff together i'm not one for doing that sure but i thought i was gonna hate it uh i enjoyed it like it was it was fun i mean frustrating and definitely at times to get them but then if you can do them right like that would never be a minion that they would make with the lying claws and and the cut in the cape to almost perfectly represent this build yeah um and that is really cool but going back to the games as a service or the the lifetime game is do i have it as another con yeah so actually that's kind of it just because i have other cons that will relate on what i'm about to say and i want to kind of keep it structured but yeah that's the problem is you have to you have to constantly wait for for the the lifestyle for the extra stuff to come out um so cat did you have anything on that not really because i didn't put them together well the games as a service the fact that it's like i i don't yeah i don't know much too much about it um it frustrates me whenever i have to spend like a lot of money on one thing um you didn't even spend any money on this game yes i did well you put in towards the the big

black friday thing yeah i think that was it yeah yeah but like like even when it's a hobby that i enjoy like i look at the price tag and i'm like [ __ ] like [ __ ] so i i and i also i also don't like it when a game makes you buy dlc to kind of like put things together to get more yeah but so yeah i mean i'm not a fan of stuff like that i mean when they when they call it a i'm not interrupting anyone here um you're good with the i mean creating this lifestyle game like how many different types of games exist in that genre what um is all that comes in my mind are war games that's the only thing i can think of definitely skirmish games are like your your warhammer your x-wing your things like that those are your lifestyle games but those are tournament heavy so that's what keeps them you're you're constantly gonna be doing magic is like that right yeah yeah magic would be one um and then i would almost say campaign games are a lifestyle uh so saying things like uh seventh continent taint grail gloomhaven um i wouldn't necessarily call those lifestyle because they don't they're not all pumped out over a span of years right they're like here's your game here's your campaign it has choices play it but yeah so it is a little bit different there is almost nothing that's like this right and i mean well a lot of the skirmish games like the warhammer i mean they have a very similar miniature accessibility you know it's like you know you buy them in bundles and then you and you have to put them together true and then some just an astronomical prices you have to paint right in tournaments exactly i felt like

colors i felt like they were they were searching for something like that but they wanted to get that that dedicated audience um without you know that say the people that were willing to be that dedicated to a board game but just weren't into war games something else just a little twist on it um and that's kind of what i feel like they were trying to do sure and i mean that's a valid point uh it's like it kind of josh mentioned it has had different aspects of a lot of different things it's like it's almost like they want to have their cake and eat it too they wanted to have a little bit of everything but it's like but it's like well we want to have it like a skirmish game but not a skirmish game it's like but they almost failed to design it as such or hone it in to where it's like okay yes i do kind of get that lifestyle feel but where the [ __ ] is all my [ __ ] like why why you can't buy it in bundles uh you have to like literally you have to wait like the gambler's chest is the one that's next and that's a big thing of their kickstarter extras and it's like what was that gonna be like like so i don't know like it to each their own and everything about this is i mean it's a discussion so whatever it's obviously subjective like none of this is like it's clearly

like objective um funny enough the next pro i was gonna have was miniature assembly so uh i did have it as a pro because there is good things to it but the biggest con was that you have to put it together and it's like yeah so so the next pearl i'll say is the settlement phase now this is gonna be this would be fun for her i really like the settlement phase uh i think that especially once we stopped recording it because at that time whenever we were recording it i was like kind of really just like okay let's try i have to be entertaining and also like we have to be efficient with everything we're saying but there's a lot of times where you want to sit and think you want to play around with different and that's not fun so off camera we were able to just casually look through the innovation deck and enjoy it and enjoy it yeah what it's worth that's the that's the the role-playing part like that's where you finally get to look back and be like okay this is our settlement this is what we've done we had a theme we were extremely just [ __ ] we were barbaric chads like that's where the uh the whole civilization part of the the game comes into effect yep and that's what i i personally almost always enjoyed it now the settlement events were not fun uh most of them suck like very like very few times are they ever decent it's like them in the hunt phase they're just after you yeah i mean there's there's there's several good in the settlement events but then

there's just as many bad yeah that are out to just kill your guys yeah i mean when that guy wiped half of our population that was the hand he came in and like almost played everybody but then gave us two babies yup gave us babies i mean you have a lot of ones that get added from the expansions that were thrown in there that are just like the the dorm rain oh man or it's just like you constantly acid rain it always ate your your resources and it's like look this is the one thing we get is resources and it's so important and it's so important i guess now we it would it wouldn't matter because we had so many that were like oh [ __ ] it oh yeah settlement phase 29 yeah uh gorm rain all right you know what you can just take all those that's cool get rid of all the hide we have it um but those were stuff like the nicknames and things like that's whenever the story elements came in that we could also be like oh this is what we are and now the principles were really cool i wish there were more um to kind of give you a little bit more variety in how your settlement was structured it would be cool yeah different themes because i know they have like the the whole romantic build versus the barbaric build right i would like a few more builds yeah absolutely kind of mix and match with yeah i mean i don't know what themes that's up for the creators to make but true that would be kind of neat yeah where you can yeah like kind of almost like a thing for animal crossing where it's like oh hey i have a japanese theme i have a european theme i have so you can do multiple different types of builds or mix and match and try and get come up with full combos uh which would be really neat like i like sitting there and deciding

oh man what whether we want to build oh we can do this and like oh that'll be perfect for that and like what we got but once again there's always a negative to it and the negative for me for the settlement phase was the fact that you were almost never building for everyone so in a four-player game you were almost each settlement phase was like oh okay everything is going towards you because that's what we fought we fought the antelope to get this one specific person gear well everyone else mainly cat up until literally halfway through the game she just sat there and is like well i mean i'm not i'm not doing any innovations i'm not getting any armor so why am i here yeah and that's kind of disappointing because everyone it's like well we all fought it and so i we should all reap the benefits from it but you you can't and then that's that's whenever you go and hunt the same thing over and over and over to be able okay well next time we'll get you this because we'll have to fight it again but other than that like the summon phase i did enjoy i did kind of look forward to seeing early on in the game what we were going to use the gear for um so yeah i mean what do you guys think i know you hate the settlement phase i just hate it just because it it like oddly has never been my thing like i don't enjoy i just don't enjoy like that kind of thing and when you have two people who are already like really into it like when you handed me this and i was like you guys are like basically the head haunches out it's just because like i i just don't like to look at this and be like oh my god like look at your gear

where do i need to put it what do i need to do it becomes a reference later on more than anything because like we know exactly what the characters can do right yeah and so the only thing it was confusing is because we had to wait until the very end of the game before you got the claws and it's just yeah it's just never like my cup of tea like if someone's willing to do it for me i'm just like you you probably know best well like i certainly had to reign myself in on my personal gains you know really like i don't know i know too damn much and it's like i'm like i'm realizing in my settlement phases i'm like okay no we're going to take the steps that they described so that everyone can get involved because it's like i'm not going to meta this so then i've gotten to point like okay so i every single time i put out every single innovation i put them out and because you know neither of them have like played to the point i have so then when we get endeavors i distribute everything we gain generally six so you get two to spend you get to spend i have two to spend so you have absolute executive decision over that endeavor we can try and you know convince each other but that is those are your endeavors to spend and i'm thinking about doing that with resources that that might be difficult but that's kind of i'm trying to craft it so everyone's involved because you know because marcie's kind of the same place as you are you know kind of like i think i could do this thing and never really fully learning all the rules because it's like here's devon just churning oh you're [ __ ] twice no look i said no put that that stop crying phase not wounding and it can be it can be overwhelming because there is so much to this game like look how many endeavors are in there like i look at that and how many of them were [ __ ] useless yes a lot of them were just hey add these cards to the innovation

deck and it's like okay sometimes even it's just this might be a bunny trouble sometimes it's something that it's like oh i could do that but i could also roll one and get eaten like so do i want to do that yeah um let's see settlement phase wise i i think it's fine um but once again it devin makes a good point like we would always focus well you made this point we have to focus on everybody and it just felt awkward to just sit here and watch everybody all right we're just going to get cash right lion lion gear we're going to get me antelope gear gorham gear yeah watch one person get excited because they're the ones being and then like you almost feel like an [ __ ] because it's like okay uh so we have six iron um i'm spending all of it uh for me and i mean you probably like that that would work because there's times throughout the hunt phase or the fight where it's like you gain like hey gain a random basic and you're like oh okay i have this yeah that's not that's not a bad idea to sit there and be like okay as probably a settlement would do is like okay well we hunted okay so boom boom boom here's what you get like divide divide and portion it out but it's like that would be weird because it's like it's a settlement so you build it for the settlement because this is not my person this is the settlements person yeah it's awkward i mean it's one of the suggestions of that you can do you can do a democratic style or you can do it where you do hand out everything and um

yeah it just depends on where it works you know right personal group and it worked out i mean everyone got what we wanted like we got a building towards like there were times where it's like okay well i got my armor so endeavor and do whatever you guys want like i don't care like i'm happy with this and so obviously it'd be worse if you were in like a group where like everyone argued with each other it's like well can i no no i need the hide and it's like why am i playing with you you suck who hangs out with this guy right she keeps doing so so i did enjoy the summer phase quite a bit oh another another thing about the campaign i know i'm backtracking it would have been so much better if like the people that killed it because in the fight itself it said his face was mournful mm-hmm like sorry sorrowful yep um if like the little snippet was like the smoke comes out of him and then suffocates whoever's alive and then they turn into gold smoke nights that would have been yeah that would have been something or or something where it's like you feel like you like you you feel like you're overpowering him but you see once again his sorrowful face as he realizes that your attempts are all in vain like you you can't kill him because he's some god and he still strikes you down that would have been oh you know what and that's all it takes literally is more [ __ ] story explaining just a little more not just like okay breath of slumber what yeah it's like

why'd we even bother why'd we spend 30 [ __ ] that's like watching a six-hour movie and it's a dream sequence at the [ __ ] end it's almost like season eight of game of thrones it's like why did i waste why do we waste a year just to fight this guy being like oh my god he's so and he was easy like one person died that was actually i was like okay thank god one per i was actually like one person died like he wasn't a pushover he actually and we let them really die we were like okay yeah we were like okay yeah i don't think you have a once a lifetime you died okay then it's like oh nope everyone else dies so you're like what the [ __ ] well i mean wait you know and in the ranges that the game offers i mean we were [ __ ] gods true i mean honestly i would have been surprised if we were challenged yeah i would like how do you win this game i mean because i was like look at my stats these are absurd i'm a master he's the master you're a master yeah we're decked out in masks in the best armor in the game and i was like yeah i would have been surprised we were generally if we were challenged if it was like ferocious i mean we were challenged by the the god like the the the gold eyes we sure were yeah so that one i mean while i was frustrating it like the hunt phase really was what killed that fight for me that was actually hard like that was like oh by the way yeah he uh teleports oh any uh bleed oh he uh punches you with this giant feathery and oh disembowels you and it's like oh yeah cause like that was the first every single time butcher level three in the two legendaries every single time we

had we had everything and i was like man i don't know if we're gonna be able to do this oh we killed him in one turn yeah okay so then with the the [ __ ] phoenix i was like i was unfazed i was like oh yeah he has all this stuff who cares and it's like oh my god two people died and then we almost died yeah we almost died and i was like huh so that was exciting i expected the gold smoke knight to be something of this equal caliber right and he wasn't so well he was because he e t p i did a total party kill against all of us so my next con uh was actually added while we were doing the session and uh i have the hunt phase is repetitive and boring i i started to not care for them i hate the hunt phase so much so much because it is literally nothing but pure random like you have absolutely no control over anything so half the time you're like do i ever want to bring these people out because who knows what the [ __ ] is going to happen and that is i i hate it i hate it in the repetitive nature is the overwhelming darkness whenever you're hunting you're going to see that they're same hunt events and even the deck like the the the custom deck that devin and i went and bought and printed uh made it a little bit better but half the time when we were rolling on that table we kept seeing the same thing oh wow the gambler again yeah yeah yeah yeah uh and it's like like i get it that you're gonna be going on a hunt and i guess thematically makes sense because if you're fighting the

lion you're gonna have this you're oh well this is the path towards where the lions live but it's like i always theme doesn't always make good game mechanics and that i feel like it's just a phase that they put in and it's like man that was okay for the fur once you once you haven't seen everything but it now i just hate doing it it's an extra step that i don't want to do go ahead oh i was just gonna say i would have liked it a lot more if like it was right random's fine the repetitive part of it is a pain in the ass i don't want to be on this hunt board and then get moved back have to do the darkness again and then possibly get the same event over and over and over again i also don't want to be horribly viciously maimed right before a fight right literally carried off by and we know for a fact they're adding in many fights during a hunt phase before you even go for a fight and i'm like why hey let you know how your characters can randomly get [ __ ] up and potentially die even before they make it to the showdown it's like this is the game the showdown is the game this is a subset of the game and it's awful i mean i i understand there's definitely a huge portion of rain that might be here a huge dose and i understand that um they do have methods within the settlement to try and mitigate to the best of your abilities yeah i know that it is it's constantly like it's always it's going to be great because we had that one that was just we were swimming and courage yeah

courage for days it was amazing you can especially ambush yeah i mean there's one called [ __ ] acid rain where you take like three damage to every single hit location for everybody yeah i mean they've got um the harvester which i still don't agree with oh yeah yeah i bought the different one the [ __ ] house uh house bird one homebrewed yeah where you can just throw the instrument yep yeah i agree with that that is just fine because that that is easily the harshest one yeah that i have ever for the record it's uh a all servers getting around this or it must spend a survival or be devoured whole if you have noisy gear you are also devoured and no matter what no matter what you cannot avoid this in any way so if you ca if you have zero survival which you always depart with some but in her case with her being immortal she can't spend it she would have just been eaten but it's like but she's immortal so she should be able to kind of cut it together way out your [ __ ] claws you'd eventually get out like it's jar jar jango fett or uh boba fett in the sarlacc pit he eventually got out and it's like okay so that doesn't make thematic sense and why can't i throw the noisy gear right it's but so and that's just fine but anyway the point i was making is that the settlement does provide a few key things i mean one that mainly comes to mind uh you know they do have a an innovation that's why you're talking about yes like they have they have things like the war that's an expansion though that is uh but then they also have one which is like the main one that comes to mind uh and that's you know the song of the

brave we never got it that's true um but song of the brave is incredibly instrumental on the huntboard if like if you can manage to build it which unfortunately we never did yeah but it allows everyone to take path of the brave no matter what okay it also allows you when you arrive to take one of your negative one tokens away that you probably would have gotten from overwhelming darkness gotcha so that makes the hunt so much more breathable true just i mean there's a whole bunch that can go on don't get me wrong i just want to say i want to defend it a little bit no that's fine but i mean there is a bunch of luck i feel like for all my cons you're going to be like yeah no i agree but which is fine that's perfectly fine i want that it's called an opinion no and i want i don't want to say that you know why i am so into sure yeah and that's what i want i don't want people to watch this and be like wow that guy is just talking over everyone and they're they look scared to even disagree it's like no i want if you just read once and he hit me pretty hard if you if you like it then that's perfectly fine you like it there's a sudden cut in it and devin's got like ow blood coming from his brow yeah i mean what i would like i mean because for those that have played it a bunch is like say a whole separate i would like to say like say if they had different uh campaigns i would like to see a whole different table yeah like i mean it could still be the zero through 100 but i would just like i would like a new true yeah because it would definitely definitely it would fret yes it would freshen it up um i know you mentioned that the the lonely tree or the flower night and someone else has like a different overwhelming so it's not overwhelming darkness yeah it's like okay so they understand

that that's annoying so it's like just make it how hard is it to print a hundred [ __ ] things it can't be that hard no i mean i mean they've got the writers i mean he's got like a thousand artists yeah he's like it's like six billion dollars at this point so he can afford to pay someone people have even homebrewed their own hunt tables extend it yeah i mean sure they're pretty great yeah i bet you can honestly find and print them off like we did with these cards and that would have been nice um but it's like at the same time they have the money i shouldn't have to pay some some fan to make a different table it does feel like i mean i mean because i'm sure you're going to cover it here later but yeah we definitely feel like we have to compensate for an awful lot for what um you know for what we're paying for here yep yep so uh so i'm gonna keep going on cons because i have more cons i have nine cons written and then six uh six pros um my number my other con is that the difficulty almost seems fake because it's all random like i have randomness equals difficulty and it's not that like the ai deck and all that is is perfectly fine because that's technically random but it sounds like oh well the game's hard and it's because i remember that guy we we talked to a gen con he's like it's impossible like he was like adamant that you couldn't get to let your near 30.

and it's like yeah probably because we probably would have constantly had full party wipes just by sheer rolls alone like how many times were we sitting there it's like oh that's interference like when it obviously wasn't but we fudged so many die rolls we ignored basic words like oh they're gone like throughout the thing and it's like well that's what makes it hard because your best people just oh that's a shame you needed an eight yeah nope uh that's your fifth bleeding token and it's like okay there's nothing i can do about almost anything and that's what makes it extremely frustrating because it's like the game didn't really make it hard like the way it's like it's not that i didn't understand how to fight him right it's the fact that wow i just happen to roll on a table that kills me like okay that's that yeah so we've we've said it before like even in video games like hard for the sake of hard is not a fun mechanic like if i can't find a way to it's like to overcome like a difficult situation through either experience or through um figuring out a puzzle or something then that's what makes it very frustrating because it's like well there's no way i could have even you can fix this like i just have okay well that's a one you can or ten technique you cannot perfect a dice roll right right so very much yeah i mean even then you have the dm who can sit there and be like okay like he can make it easy mentally you can just be like oh you roll the one you failed to do

this but stumbled upon that yeah like and i mean at that point it's like and i'm not even talking about the hit location deck that's that's a mechanic that's something that you they have they put items in the game to mitigate that the randomness of that the cat lie we did it from seven eight lantern years where it's just like okay let's constantly have that fourth person surge to constantly look at that that's how you mitigate randomness with the and it's both in the hunt phase and the settlement phase and on the traumas where it's just too much randomness i don't mind random to for story elements but when almost every low role even on what's a good table is a bad result it's like why why can't you just give me something hey you killed the legendary antelope uh sorry your arm gets ripped off and you get some dick [ __ ] sword and it's like why why why your game can be hard and it could be random that's fine just mitigate it like [ __ ] calm down and and like okay yeah there's some randomness that's fine but you can there's multiple ways that you can work around that i almost feel like there's not it's just you get what you get right for the once in a lifetime reroll oh right those are definitely and that was actually patched in 1.5 they nobody would do starbucks until that patch yeah why would you yeah why would you it was really hard uh well i act like i know like i [ __ ] bought this game in the first game you went out like that first mission i want to be a fan boy so hard that i backtracked in time and i actually i

bought it i was on ebay and spent 18 grand yeah to buy kdm 1.0 to get the true experience so i'm not a like a [ __ ] pleb right i definitely agree um we're coming from there that there is just there's so much randomness and it is it's so hard to mitigate uh all of it and you can't it is impossible um and what they do give you the cat eye circle at the the rawhide headband to try and control it's just you know and there's even a few um innovations that let you kind of be a little more strategic during your fights you know to avoid some of that dice roll randos to get a re-roll here to increase your odds or sharper or something like sure right and it's in i mean i would like a little more a little more tactical you know to give me to make me feel like i'm overcoming this but i understand it's it's a city they wanted that's how people keep describing it's like it's you know did you make a strong enough survivor to come in here and kick ass and it's like i did but through no fault of my own there were seven [ __ ] hunt phases that it was if you roll bad you die and it's like i couldn't i can't control that right and everything you mentioned affects the fight i actually don't mind almost any of the randomness in the fight i get it where it's like oh man do i hit oh man i miss like that's okay it's the randomness outside where the murderer where it's like okay so someone just kills our most experienced hunter why why can't we stop that like um or the

like literally the 10 cards that you draw for the hunt phase and then it's like okay well there's it's just all that outside of the game really randomness that actually really bugs me right and then like i said before they're trying to kill your experience guys yeah they have an image you know that they have for this game they want to keep you in like keep it the way they want it you know they don't want you to have like a god character for too long yeah they want to try and kill them off and make sure that you are generating people dependably without relying too much on one select group yeah and that's i see that's what they were trying to do yeah which almost negates one of the ways you can build your settlement because the way we built it we had like we have 13 population so if they're constantly trying to kill your people it's like okay i will never play that way if the other way you have 90 people in your and so you're oh wow one person died okay i have so many others right so it's like it almost quells you away from one of the ways they that you can play the game right but then they they do compensate it with you know because with the barbaric build obviously they give you like we cannot die from brain traumas you know they give you that they give us the ones for lifetime reroll that has infinite usage in the rules this is like if they are participating they can use it so even during our intimacies you know so we're still can dependably generate uh survival survivors um they come out jack they come out check once you have the innovation mother i am here so they i think they did okay you know i mean honestly if we could have died from ones and twos from brain trauma that's true that's a

big pile of [ __ ] so they they do okay i mean they i mean depending on you know the different builds here sure that they both have they've definitely improved on keeping them a little more balanced yeah at least from what i have read on one point you know the original yeah sounds like that they did they did improve somewhat from their original original name but i mean honestly my original topic was you know the randomness and yes it is you just have to you have to grin and bear it it's expensive you have to accept it that it's part of the game and if it's just you don't like it not for you right for you you guys have anything to add yeah two to that one what do you guys think about the randomness you guys fine so randomness in a in a video game because i'm experienced in that more than board games um so randomness oh and dnd randomness and dnd sure yeah you there's use your mind to just mitigate it in this there's clear-cut rules like i still get mad when i play destiny 2 and the loot i get after playing a nightfall [ __ ] three hours in yeah and i get [ __ ] at the end of it pisses me off like why yeah i should be guaranteed something decent at least um that's actually a good point for the [ __ ] random drops the death blows and that it's like the only way to get the riot mace was to get the death blow on the gorm and it's like oh anyway sorry keep going

no no you're fine um i understand the the randomness in fights because like quote unquote if this were to actually happen i'd be terrified but uh anything could happen like true literally anything could happen uh i get that in fights and in society like just right now anything's possible right uh i get the random events in the settlement phase and all that i get the random events and the hunt step but to have it happen hundreds of times to the same like four characters right the only like thing i could think of to mitigate it would be to like these or this person can never experience this again yeah that would be one way to mitigate it right or that i would try to mitigate it it's like why should this person ever have to deal with the gambler ever again yeah or the harvest or whatever yeah um they've understanding being a stat maybe at a certain point of understanding you're like yeah i know that's bad i ain't yeah that's true and i mean a few of them are like that if your understanding is three or higher it doesn't affect you yeah and it's like they so they have inklings and it seems like they understand that that's a problem but they don't have it enough yeah and and one point that i'd like to make i probably should have made this at the beginning if anyone's still watching is this is all before wave three and four so they they could fix all this

in wave three and four and it's like okay well now the problems move but we obviously don't know that um so yeah i mean i agree with you that it is technically anything could happen it's like oh well that's life sometimes you can't avoid whatever and you you die along the way and it's like yeah but i try to escape life i understand that someone can break into my house right now and slaughter us all i don't want to play a game that also reminds me that death is imminent so yeah you games are an escape and trust me i know devon likes to grind because of monster hunter i love grinding in destiny i love it um and i am not i'm not a fan of grinding i like grinding in dark souls because there's a sense of progression and that's exactly where i'm getting at i it pisses me off when i play destiny and i get [ __ ] yeah uh like in diablo or in xyz game as long as i am moving forward i don't care about the grinding right but if the grinding's senseless then i'm i'm literally doing insanity yeah yeah you're you're literally just wasting time um cat what do you think i mean we've said it before in other games like any kind of randomness is it's just hard to deal with like when you're you know you're on a roll you're hitting crits and all of a sudden you're rolling one you're like well yeah [ __ ] like then you take the good with the bad like that was gonna relate to what i was gonna say next was dice happen

and it's not even the fact that dice are involved because like i said the the rolling to hit okay it's like oh man yeah that sucks so i missed or getting the trap and it's like [ __ ] um but that's thematic and so you're right it's like oh man okay who yes a ten and then you're it's like all exciting you're like ooh but then you could equally roll a one and then it's an auto fail no matter if oh wow like you're 30 yeah if you roll one it's still a failure and it's like yeah so that that sucked but dice do happen but i think it's just the event it's really actually the randomness of the events yeah yeah like just to pull a card to be like oh man someone just got wow harvester okay i guess we died yeah it's like all right would you wouldn't you feel like you could understand oh hey the ground's trembling move don't bring any instruments guys you might draw that yeah like the only way i could think of to also justify it would be more like story to it because like in dark souls you're playing a character living through a cycle true and it feels like that's what they wanted our characters to be like they're living through lantern cycles until a definitive end yeah yeah that could be true i mean because the way we just appeared we just woke up yeah true i mean oh yeah that we never made that connection we always assumed the lantern years were linear but they could literally be a lantern cycle where it's like okay these people lived and then now they're lying forward to keep the the lantern lit we we killed our quarry

and then the current characters died and then were reborn or something that would make a lot more sense but we don't know but we don't have it so i think it's like every hunt xp like every age is wasn't it like a lifetime for someone it was a very very indescriptive amount of time right yeah i guess it was i mean because it's strange i mean the way the i mean the laura reeds is like i guess like the watcher essentially it feeds off our history feeds off of human history and that's just what we happen to i mean because there's different campaign styles you know on how you what you end up doing sure but and but you know i think they all start where you kind of just wake up and you know what the hell's going on then you have different story events that lead you down your different campaign routes but i mean in the core game story of the lantern we happen to find a watchers lure yeah so then he allows us to grow and build and protects us while he feeds off of us yeah and becomes what he needs to be or whatever is he isn't that amazing that's that sounds so [ __ ] cool put it in the [ __ ] game i know like uh so i was going to have another con quite a bit of reading i actually tried i was in there and i'm like okay kdm lore i'm like devin's finding it somewhere i had no idea where to go collector kdm just re it sucks but yeah if you just you know flip through all the minis and then read their little descriptors i got quite a bit of data from yeah and that's that's you could probably make like your own like little lore book like for your for your game i mean that's the thing is there's people who make apps and stuff like that and uh ways to help you know streamline the game and things like that and i but you have to get this approval

if you're if you're gonna make money off of it i think and it's like i don't know how it is i don't know if he's like that guy that's like no this is mine um which funny enough my my other con was going to be designer direction um and we've kind of been hitting on it where they wanted to eat have their cake and eat it too we devin and i know for a fact with the wave updates that he just keeps wave three and four keep getting pushed back because he literally has said i can't i cut i want to keep adding stuff and as a end user as the one who paid for the game already it's like i understand it's not a pre-order system but at this point it kind of is and it's like stop like you give me what i give me quality not quantity yeah i think i'm sorry no go ahead i mean think that you know those people though you know those very dedicated people that put all that money you know when this first when the kickstarter first was created yeah how many years has it been oh they haven't seen all of their stuff yet that is true they saw a second kdm before they got to see their wave 3 stuff a second kdm well the 1.5 oh yeah yeah where the update the [ __ ] new the core game so new people can get it and they're like where the hell is my [ __ ] wait a minute and that's the thing is like you're sitting there and it's like okay so there has to be some reason why and it's because he can't [ __ ] just say no to stuff he keeps putting stuff in oh hey in the middle of the hunt face you can fight giants and it's like that's cool let me do it yeah look like and then the other part is it's like it's not like we have to

wait for the factories because we make the we put the [ __ ] minis together so it's like it's like i have to wait for the molds and then wait for all that to get done it's like i make half your game so like and it's even sorry no no well i like just what it makes me think of is like he's someone who like pulled like the rookie maneuver where it's like i can make a game so i'm gonna do it i gotta prove for everything but like he has no actual structure in his life like if he has that much content like maybe he should actually focus it and turn it into like a separate game like he has to have a play it's like it's a business that he's running yeah and that ties back to the lifestyle like he wants to keep making it to where there's always something there's always something new and don't get me wrong i am stoked for wave three and four and i have met adam and he's a very nice guy so this is no slight or dig at him as a person i'll kill him but from a designer from he's like i've never met him before no he's very nice and he was super friend helpful whenever i asked him hey can i still jump in to i didn't back it but can i jump i think he was super helpful with that um but it almost it's a rookie old kickstarter mentality it's bloat that makes people hate kickstarter because i guarantee you if this game was released today it probably wouldn't do as well and is this because this came out and what when was the 17 it's been a few years yeah 1617 was 1.5 i think some people wait four years and they start yeah and they still haven't seen seen all of it and they put like they're like three thousand dollars to get everything or some [ __ ] i don't know what it was to get everything to get everything at that

time yeah yeah but and and that's what makes it extremely frustrating because you look at some of the quality which i mean the car the call the quality for some of the expansions now is [ __ ] like it's print on demand but for the most part the cards are really good but the thing that's even more frustrating is you see simple things those tokens over there the green and red it's like what the [ __ ] are those there's no there's no design on them so they're not they're not waiting on art uh they're the we put the minis together so they just have to make sprues and that's the that's the designer direction that that is very frustrating uh the last update was in november so it's been four or five months so no one even knows and that's what pisses people off and whenever it comes to kickstarter if like i said if this had come out in 2020 i guarantee you would not do as good the reason frosthaven is making six million it made four million in day one because gloomhaven is such a pure and almost perfect example of a perfect game for a hundred dollars and it really is and and you sit there and you look at examples like that and it's like frosthaven oh it's basically glue haven with a settlement phase [ __ ] oh yeah what oh the full pledge is 240 okay nope no problem all of it no problem isn't that beautiful it is and and so then you look at stuff like this and you're like okay so uh most people don't even have half their [ __ ] but they're still waiting they're like man i ca i like i can only imagine what it's gonna be like and it's like where is it yeah especially with everything that's been going on like

just in the world recently like there's a lot of like well is it getting made like is it even allowed to be getting anything but no one's telling us yeah it got delayed till 2021 for wave three and that's not even the good stuff ivory king or the the uh every dragon black knight that's wave four so that's that's like 20 22 23 if it doesn't get pushed back again yeah all the cool stuff that that can the campaigns of death and gambler's chest are wave three and the campaign of death is literally a comprehensive rulebook so yeah so all the stuff that we paid for that we were excited about for the most we won't see it for at least three possibly four years yep yep and so yeah so that's designer direction i didn't really want to i actually deleted it because i'm like ah that's fine but it is it is a concern and it is frustrating with a game like this um go ahead oh well i was just saying um he definitely has an army of artists i don't know how like how it came about to where he wanted to create this game or sure how that right i had to deal it had to have been like he must have like a bunch of artist friends or artists that he hired or something like that let them have free range because that's why i think i read that he just gave them he said what he wanted to do and let them have free range in their creativity that's why we see so many different images in here we got that little more anime style one that are more like like a cgi style like the gorms scare or the more like the olden i don't want to call it victorian like say the the lions art where it's very uh illustrated uh yeah yeah i know what you're doing um

where's the show down the line where it's just the lion yeah it's all it's yeah but yeah with like in that red and yellow look too so like he's got a bunch of artists and i think they just all created all this [ __ ] and he's like i love it all let's put it let's get in this game yeah and that's kind of how it all came to this i mean it's beautifully unique but then at the same time bloated as you described and it's like look as a good designer you have to turn to your team and be like i that sounds awesome no yeah i want to make a quality game not a quantity which comes with being a businessman like you have to have that mindset not everyone can do whatever professional or like you said make another game like hey it doesn't have to be no yeah there's nothing wrong with being creative so yeah that ties to the lifestyle so the other one is and this one will probably be my one of my weakest cons i think devin will most likely disagree with when this one the most but there are times where this game almost feels like there's no replayability and the reason why i put that on here is because the exciting thing about kdm is the unknown oh man how does this monster fight what's it gonna do once you fight it one two times then it's like oh okay that's the reason why i'm excited for all the other extra stuff in wave three and four because i don't know what they're gonna do but once you see them then you're like oh okay like the only things that we haven't fought are the dragon god i know yeah

lion god spider cools dragon king sunstalker yeah oh and the dung beetle night and flower night actually i fought the flower night with you but in the tree the tree and the tree so some of those are nemesis so when it comes to quarries yeah you guys haven't fought the kingsmen either oh you're right because we did slenderman instead yeah so the the main ones that we have left to fight are nemesis and funny enough i actually love the nemesis by the end of this i was excited for nemesis and they were my least favorite part at the beginning of the game because they were so hard but that was it was also because we filled the game with everything we did we did i had to take a bunch of stuff out because you can't i guess you could play the whole campaign with everything punish me daddy but it would be it would be disgusting adam pooty adam pooty you're right and so that's where the no replayability kind of comes in it's like if i were to do this again like a campaign it's like oh yeah it's the [ __ ] lion again even literally in this campaign it was like what did we fight like we fought or give us like new game plus or something where like we get to keep our settlement and like our heroes die fighting the gold smoke night or whatever reason well that's stopping you from home from that and then you just continue there is actually a strange story event that can occur it's super rare really it's it's a settlement event it's called clinging mist okay and if you roll certain on it you the the people that you have out get so lost that they just happen to stumble upon another level one line and

have to start their own settlement and so then you keep all the gear that you create all your innovations in settlement but everything you've crafted remains it remains so there you go there's your new game plus but you have to randomly get it it's incredibly random and it's yeah so um i mean and that that is that is kind of disappointing because it's like if it's a lifestyle game it should have unlimited and i know unlimited tech you can play this over and over and over but why would you have i mentioned it multiple times why why would we go fight the gorham again there's no reason i mean yeah good i see where you're coming from um but i like i lean more towards like if there if there was more developed story like honestly like i'm not i'm not i wouldn't be too wild about playing this again like full through um but i also want to see like the other side like i want to see like a more nurturing settlement a kinder set people who don't just eat dead bodies yeah yeah yeah oh my god everybody goes everybody gets to eat my corpse and then die i mean and that and that's that's exactly it that's what you do do you're okay well we played this way and now we're going to play it again as the other way but that's that's external game stuff that's the story element though which i'm obviously more invested and that's fine yeah that's that's that's what i want to do like devon and i want to do a like a swordsman thing uh like a seven swordsman seven swordsman master thing like oh that could be fun put in do what do a different campaign and that would give me the freshness and the newness but

that's the extra like but whenever it comes to the actual game it plays it'll play out the exact same way yeah no yeah that yeah it's kind of yeah yeah say when it eventually gets to the point where like you've fought level ones and twos of everything and level three is like the pinnacle of it and you can kill it before it even attacks back why even have them in the lantern years right exactly i mean because like devin i said most of the time these people don't live as long as they usually do like uh you you get them to where like in all honesty we should have shelved them and been like okay well we're just gonna wait again they wouldn't have gotten yeah literally what we did with bathsheba and malachi was we shelving because we're they're like okay these guys are so good and now they're hot trash look at that uh in comparison yeah we got attached like that's just yeah you get comfortable it's a comfort thing especially for me and and the reason why and devon and i we had a couple reasons like this the reason why you go to fight the thing over and over and i hate it is you try to get the death blow because that's there's only specific items that you can get like my riot mace which is the best mace in the game is based off of a death blow from the gorm and so you have to keep going after the gorm over and over and over and over until you randomly get it on a perfect draw or mitigate it by the by certain ways and there are ways to do that and we did that like two or three times yeah and that was exciting every single time i was like oh man okay see if that's what put strategy into the

fight that's what made the fights really exciting was whenever we had our build and it wasn't just i broke my mace again but it wasn't just okay all right i missed it wasn't just that like we actually had to be like okay hey 10. perfect it wasn't like okay so i'm just i got to move around here and then so that was exciting but detroit that's why that's your replay ability is literally fight the same thing over and over and over until you happen to get that perfect hit uh or the resources that you want because there are times where it's like oh you need a shimmering mane ah sorry you didn't draw it or you didn't get a crit on that location we almost died yeah yep and that's the monster hunter so this is why i said you'd probably disagree with me on this one the most oh the the replayability because because you love monster hunter literally more than all of them combined and so you probably will have a problem literally fighting gorm over and over and over and over for i don't know if i need the stuff and i haven't done it and that it goes to the point where you sharpen your strategy once you know how the monster plays because it's like that first time this [ __ ] storm storm because then he's got that piercing vomit he vomits all over you and then it's an instance of your injury and it's just a bad day yeah that's true um and then once you figure it out where he's gonna go how he's gonna move and it's like you learn like and it's thematically cool because you're like hey by the way don't get in front of it because you know he's gonna throw up so you you maneuver around him but then unfortunately you know meta exists so you've played the game before you know how gorham fights so yeah it's kind of it's be hard to go a new group

of friends or whatever it's like it's like you're like you know that they're going to die if you don't tell them what to do like do you want them to be the experienced person or do you want to thematically like you would as a as a wise person in a barbaric settlement go on the hunt with the newbies and be like don't stand in front of it advise them or do you sit back and be like well he didn't know that it was going to throw up in britain what an idiot i guess he wasn't meant to survive in determination nation you wouldn't do that determined but it's like a lot of people in board games have problem with quarterbacking so it's like if it's not me and you it's like oh well i want to go nope don't no but i want to no it's like some people please stop people have a problem with that but it's like thematically i would tell you not to stand in front of his [ __ ] vagina mouth and throw up on you but yeah so you would just want to yell hey that has a vagina mouth you probably don't want to be near it yeah and so you have to balance like okay well once again cool theme or in game mechanics and sometimes it's just like okay well i know it doesn't yeah it's never balanced uh let's go to a pro because i do have more the number the other pro i have is the ai monster deck this is one of the coolest this is like that's like the pinnacle of this game to me is that ai monster deck because no other game folklore gloomhaven said all of them okay what's their health 70 okay and you just okay well i will do six damage nine damage and you just take it down here it's actually like oh man what i hit and okay his fuming scrag and his fuming calendar or

cooter or calendar big lion ball yeah his balls and it's like okay like that's really cool because then you can look at it and be like oh man okay so you thematically explain things that that we do and then it's like okay well it's gonna have a reflex and he's gonna [ __ ] deflect it and then hit you back and that the ai deck that's probably one of the best iterations of monster fighting and and boss fighting in any board game that i've played because it it so accurately represents well they're not just standing there like oh yep nope keep hitting me it gives you what you want as a boss fight yep like not diablo um uh dragon's dogma yeah is the game around it is kind of shitty but the boss the fights were awesome because you can like climb up on the [ __ ] ogre and stab its eye and that was a cool game uh and so the it's like wow [ __ ] followers oh yeah they're gross like slaves or whatever the hell they were it's like they're not really people and then you wore them out yeah oh that's true you did do that but like yeah but the fights were awesome and it's like each of them were different because if you go and fight a like i played the [ __ ] out of that game i couldn't get pretty much cuter so people want to hire yeah like you're a [ __ ] horse yeah that's all they work and you can like like weirdly lower their mouth as far ends like oh no and they were just hard hitting their people their character creator was fantastic the game looked pretty bad um

but like so when you go and fight a chimera it had three separate heads it had the lion the goat and snake and like depending on the order in which you killed them it changed the attitude of the beast yeah so like if you killed the goat it couldn't cast magic anymore so it focused on melee and poison damage from the snake yep killed the snake it cast more magic like you killed the lion the goat [ __ ] jumped around everywhere and tried to kill you yeah well it casted magic so like and and this almost executes that to a t yeah because it's like okay uh okay i'm gonna hit it and it's like i hit it's paw and you get a critical you chop the paw off so whenever it does another ai it's like oh it actually bleeds out and it doesn't and it's like it does it so well and like like i said each of them are different you hit the antelope it [ __ ] bolts it's like well it's an antelope like yeah it has a mouth on it's [ __ ] you swing at this humanoid night and it it knows you're going to attack so it counters yep and then hits you right back yeah that was actually even though it didn't come up well i actually came up law because i surged to do any type of damage but it was like you're getting it's like you can tell you're getting cocky that oh you're gonna keep attacking and just [ __ ] just [ __ ] you up before you can and it's really it's just it's really cool because you actually get the feeling of the like the progression of damage to the animal it's like yeah it's not a health bar so you're gonna sit there and be like okay well half of its ai deck is gone so it's not gonna be doing as much or potentially and that there's your variety in in the or the replayability whenever you're finding monsters because

they will do different things technically but overall they do have a general theme so like i said there's pros and cons to really the same thing that i'm putting on the list um but yeah what do you guys think what do you guys think of the the ai oh yeah i mean just like you pretty well covered it i mean it can make them they act very strangely once it comes down to it yes you know you've wounded them and now it's wounded it's scared it's jumping around it's doing like the same [ __ ] over and over and just keeps growling at you to try and make you run away or keep attempting to parry or and sometimes you get really sad when everybody has jumping repeatedly in their hair just ground and it like always makes sense too like i think it's really interesting like uh i really like the ones where like you're fighting like a humanoid um person like one of the knights the nemesis yeah literally the special showdowns and the nemesis ended up being the coolest fights yeah and i hated them but like i love the cards that like when they go to like reflex and hit you they're like you know they strike back in like disgust because it's just like oh yeah he's like how did you hit me like how dare you like i think that yeah yeah and that kind of going back to the sense of progression was like at the beginning whenever it was like when the butcher first showed up and it was like oh god we're gonna die and then he comes back and then it's just like me just bolting towards him we have to like restrain attacking you over and over and over and over because you couldn't he was like and he was getting furious and just kept chopping at you and you wouldn't die like the first butcher fight uh malachi

got hit once from on like hack city or something and you made your character go on the court that was the man hunter man because he like had to pick me or him and he picked me and he shot me and i'm like i'm not i'm not letting him die yeah and i'm like you guys can fight him um yeah exactly or like the traps where it's like thematically cool with the manhunter for example you go in and you get one of his uh tombstones or steak drivers and it's like you want to attack me he's just like nope i just slammed you on the ground you're like it sucks and drawing the trap is always horrible uh and it makes you mad and it makes me mad almost every perfect hit you had that was bad that was really i'm like a perfect kid okay i might get to nope trap um but later on you build and then it's like okay the trap's there so it really the only sad thing is i don't get to wound him uh but sometimes it's not it's not as horrendous as it was earlier in the game but yeah the hit location deck the um and i will say i like that they do have these moods and the statuses as the monsters level up because that's what's gonna change from level one two and three is the special cards where it's like oh this time he's gonna grab you and deal five damage to a location and knock you down and it's like oh god okay so we can't get near him so yeah so that was that was a pretty big pro because that's that is my favorite thing about about the game number four that i have for cons is both these are kind of limited to uh gameplay is restricted gameplay so this is kind of where i the

restricted part is they have so much items but there's almost a specific way you have to build like it was so difficult to want to do anything cool without it it's like well i can't make it like the the miramasa or whatever it's like well we can't make it like we can't make that useful because a lot of it really rely on do you have fighting arts or things like that so it's like well i have to randomly get that for even to make it worth it so they they give you a lot of stuff but then it's like with these affinities and with this limited you know three by three grid it's like well i can't realistically make that so now we literally have a pile of [ __ ] yeah that it's like there's so many cool items in here that we we would never use yeah like the affinities kind of made it feel bulky and weighted down and it's like oh man what if i get this no i can't because i literally have to have these affinities in a specific way so there's our pile of stuff like you can't just equip it just to have it equipped and and that's kind of that's kind of a bummer because i want to i like the idea of all the gear and stuff and i'm even fine with the three by three stuff i think the affinity is kind of what kills it um because it is so restricted like you you can't have like there were times whenever it's like oh who wants to take the final lantern i don't know this is going to [ __ ] up my whole thing because i need these affinities and so someone has to make a sacrifice it gives you affinities but it's like old is it worth it right like okay great it gave me two affinities but it's like [ __ ] up it does it just messes everything up

so that was one of the cons that i had what do you guys think um i mean with the i can't really call it con it's just um it's always something that i felt like was i'm part of it yeah i can see it being very frustrating and it's unfortunate um maybe i'm just not experienced enough with the game but yeah it does feel like i mean you have to build that set and use that set yeah um and then deviations from that are almost impossible right because they just they don't have enough um benefiting uh a mixed abilities like it'd be hard you couldn't have like this helmet this chest and then all this other stuff and and it like uh tactically work out for you right that's just it's too difficult i don't know maybe if i knew a little more of the game maybe some more of the expansions because it's not being like supposed to mess with that somewhat but it's just uh it's hard and i yeah it's definitely it'd be cool if you could mix up a little yeah a little more hodgepodge yeah like that's the that's the rpg nature it's like okay well let me build my character the way i want to build but it seems like that the to to adhere to their way to keep it in line with their difficulty and their scope it's like nope okay well we don't want them to customize or have fun we want them to play our game the way we want them to play it so this is really how they're gonna have to do it instead of realizing that okay we have a lot of items we have a lot of ways for them to build let's compensate for that let's have different ways like that the monsters can fight because of this certain build instead of trying to break it because i i know for a fact if you had freight rain you'd have god characters

not even off stats you'd have it off of your elements and i know there's ways i literally saw today an insane build like you can build to where you're fighting art and stuff like that like you benefit from if you're insane and in ways like that you have the lion knight gear uh that makes you attack literally nine dice um in korean sevens or higher and that's and bow and then you know gorm set and lantern and all that's cool but we literally have okay lantern gorm broad white lion then that's it we couldn't sit here and be like oh man so i'd really like to use blood paint and a sword and a whip and that'd be really neat no you really can't because it's not going to be that beneficial it's kind of like whenever you're playing d d and it's like you want to make a character that's really cool outside of like combat but there's a lot of combat so you build a combat character otherwise you're useless in the [ __ ] fight that's kind of what you do here is you have to make him efficient to go in the showdowns because of course that's the whole deal yeah and that's it's it's just it's not like a huge con because i loved playing as this but it would have been really cool to sit there and be like oh man i'll take bandages in the mirror masa and i can i can fix myself up it's like ah no you're not you can't because the three by three or the yeah the three by three thing and then the affinities just kind of kill it like we have so many cool things in here that we just would never use we'd literally have the butcher's cleaver and it's like now all those arrows that would have been giving you compensation uh it's like no no well we'll take those

out because they don't benefit in the affinities but the mid-tier arrow you bring that idea to level two not a level three throw that out yeah you need the dense bone arrow and that's that's it which is really i mean that's that's correct that's what you would do um and that's kind of comes back to the replayability where it's like oh i want to get the lantern gear okay here's your set like no no i know you want to use the bow it's not good with the bow you need the club so you don't get no stop crying again you're like you're going to use the club and that's kind of disappointing because you want even if you know it's not you're not somebody stop stop the camera okay i'm gonna be direct like i know it's not supposed to be attached to the character but you can at least have fun making the goddamn thing and it's like oh well okay well i guess uh this is what i have and i can't do anything else about it so that's uh josh cat you got anything no not to add no okay uh i know this is a long discussion i have one more left for both of these and my number one is for pros is actually theme it'd be ai deck but the theme that's the reason why i kept coming back like i know we were talking about how the i mean the the story is very frustrating and there's [ __ ] nothing in it but everything that devin has read and everything that is in the game is so cool yeah like i don't know how many times i said how this game would benefit from being an rpg like a tabletop rpg like a world that you can actually role play and try and survive and be in

because there's so much cool things around it and even with the expansions which i feel like do a better job okay there's a silver city okay where'd the hand come from what is he all that stuff even though it's frustrating that it's not there like to explain it somewhere else off their website or whatever it's still really cool like the idea to think of that the hand is some guy you only fight him once and i don't even remember that but he fights and then you can beat him two ways you can endure him out or you can fight him out and whenever you fight him out and you actually cause him to like flinch that's so [ __ ] neat because you're like oh damn this almost immovable god flinched and then he's like okay and just pulls out his sword once and it's [ __ ] around yeah and you're like oh [ __ ] and if you survive you get some insane fighting art and then you're like it's so cool like the the the god the god of a thousand years the white secrets all those story events were always so neat uh except for the legendary antelope um so yeah that i mean that that's literally what made me come back is because i wanted to kind of i wanted to be in the world because it's very [ __ ] cool i think this would be such an awesome like book like i would love i would love to read like just a horror like obscure story i think it would be so cool yeah the aesthetic and atmosphere it gives off is very much a souls game very much yeah um bleak nature um society's either on

the verge of collapse or is so new that like we're just piss ants to gods right it's basically like a very corrupted version of of like the beginning of genesis like we woke up we're like oh this is who we are like we don't know why like nobody knows why we're here right now on this planet they don't either so that's okay they don't have those answers but yeah like and thematically that's even that that is really cool because you wake up especially with new players you wake up you we we as real people don't know what to expect yeah so we learn kind of with them and then the the epic heroes that we have yahweh and maurice and laura vanderbin and raw are like the the elders of this settlement that know everything and at this point we do as well so that's really cool the watcher stuff where it's like okay well he was like he was like watching over us and he was actually like protecting us oh wow that's really cool and that's why it's so frustrating that the story isn't there because you want to know more yeah you want to delve into the whys yeah it is very enticing and at this point in 2020 people don't want vagueness anymore i don't feel like they do i think because every single story it's like oh well why did this happen every tv show movie it's like well they didn't explain that person that passed the screen and everything about his backstory so people want clarification so i feel like a thing like this doesn't benefit off of it anymore right it's like we don't want like a i mean a lore dump because that's what a lot of those dreams we don't want

exposition yeah yeah this is like okay so this is everything that's going on right now yeah this is the past the history this happened at this time it's like nothing that you're gonna [ __ ] remember right like we need to strike a balance it's like i wanna know about the current situation and then maybe once i reach the end a little bit of a synopsis yeah uh just a summary tell me you know like i would like to the book i know they're very vague about the watcher but yeah i would like that to be a little more upfront about it yep yep so i think theme was one of the biggest pros it was one i i typed out as soon as i was making making the list because it is really really cool and i mean the pros that i have here are strong and it's it's things like that that will still keep my score uh what it's going to be but the cons match so bad and this is the worst one right here you ready can you guess i think i know what is it yes is it the clarification issues no that is on here i passed it because we've been sitting here for a while and i understand that it's a long this is a long discussion i do have unclear gameplay that is very [ __ ] frustrating it makes it does make me very mad but there's a reason why and and the number one reason the cost of this game is the and that's why it makes me so mad because unclear gameplay the fact that this game costs literally two paychecks of mine is disgusting and it's it makes every single one of those cons eat like another tier higher because it's like i paid more gloom haven't i mentioned is a hundred dollars and you get a streamlined like campaign game with decisions that matter

with both dungeon crawl and the somewhat city building frosthaven promises a more settlement phase for literally a fourth of the cost of the core game here and now it has standees but there are minis and let's take a game like hate where i showed you guys the minis that game sucked but the minis were so [ __ ] good and i think for everything it was 300 and it's like i didn't have to put them together so you can't even benefit off well you get the minis no you don't you put them together and then if you run out or [ __ ] up you have to buy another armor set so you even whenever it's like you can't even pay for everything of the game and have everything because you're always going to be buying pillows [ __ ] i mean you bought you and i bought every single die set for no reason because we're just like we're indeed one of them yeah and i think the cost of this for everything so far is what three grand i think are we are we each three about three grand in i want to say maybe two when i went to gen con and purchased everything right it was slightly reduced in price versus how it would have been online i think it was about 12. okay and that was board game that was the board game of the core game uh and all the expansions okay uh i also got a few i got the echoes as well while i was there you get them um you know so and then so you put it like a 12 and then you add like the insert uh that's another

quite a bit more anticipating the expansion material yep and we did buy premium sleeves um we paid extra dice um each one of those 20 bucks yeah 20 bucks you have the white speaker and the ones that actually come with cards like because you haven't bought pineapples i haven't bought pinups uh we paid 30 bucks to have the hunt phase and this is obviously all extra stuff um you don't need oh yeah these these acrylic sets you bought the 3d terrain i did yeah um and i did i was like i can't i i fully understand so i mean i i just had a little extra money and i was like that would be really cool yeah i just love this idea of it all being textured i do too yeah absolutely but it's like no it's not going to be practical right um so probably and then with the the black friday [ __ ] that was like what 500 like because we didn't have to get everything whenever we got the wave three and four oh no the black friday stuff oh no it was like that was easily a grand yeah because i forgot i was thinking it was like 1400 you gave me yeah you gave me a lot of money for it then i went in a little bit more and then cat helped yeah it was a grant about a grand it was i think it was about 40 you and i spent like two hours looking through it to make sure we were getting yeah we we we looked for an hour and a half and made sure that we i could only give you so much no i mean i was the fact that you gave me anything was awesome um but like i know i spent at least 400 on the black friday stuff and then

initially when we bought this we split it three ways anyway so it was about yeah like 300 300 something yeah yeah yeah i'm thinking yeah because definitely three but um like i'm probably middling three three and a half for all the terrain yeah and this is for literally everything so of course you don't have to do that but if you really want any type of replayability any differentiating campaigns you have to spend more you don't have to get any of the extra models you don't have to get the exercise so at most for for actual game content you're probably spending at least two grand and that is disgusting and i fully believe the die hard fans and i'm lumping in myself and even you if if you if this game was a hundred dollars it would be [ __ ] but the fact that we've put in so much money that we're almost a little like well i kind of gotta overlook it and i'm like like i can't i have to convince my girlfriend or wife that i really like it and i i obviously can't speak for you but that's kind of where it's like well if this was a 100 game i would not have finished 30 lantern years yeah no no i would i would i would have wrote off that 100 and been like that's fine but if but i spent three grand and like he put money in it so i want him to play it you put money capital money it's like oh we're gonna [ __ ] finish because we spent the money um so we'll say that like

each game 30 games was around an hour to an hour and a half all right on average yeah so you get we'll say tops of like 45 hours out of this for the amount of money we put in yeah true out of out of just one playthrough yeah um and i don't i've never played gloom haven so i can't compare it let me have in each session's about an hour so and i don't know how many situations there are in this game it's like it's like there are there are sorry not exactly 100 there's like 94 scenarios so you're guaranteed uh essentially um and it's uh an hour per dollar you put in yeah yeah and we did not get that out of this right right yeah like so if it was three thousand dollars and we had um i don't know how to map that out i was going to but i don't feel like doing it so yeah and that's what so the the design the designer direction the limited kind of hey we kind of need to play that the randomness the the lack of variety um in in game play uh the just the unclear where it's like okay i i spent three grand and i'm not even really sure how these things work because he just kept adding more and more without retconning things that'd be like if magic just kept every card like yeah yeah oh here's a new set every month oh what no oh yeah they were they did do that they did do it and it and it breaks it down and it sometimes it's broken here and you have to take a liberties and if i spent three grand on the game i

don't want to sit here and make half the game not even talk about the minis but i don't know how to stay here and be like okay so how does that work well we're going to home rule it or you have to make it aesthetically work and it's like because there were multiple times where i'm like well why is this happening if that doesn't even thematically make sense yeah well that's what the card says and it's like okay yeah there are definitely several stretches and you see several instances of that uh like especially like in weapon keywords and like yeah where they work because it's like they wanted to it's like they wanted to create all these things but then at the same time they're like okay they need to work within the concepts of the game that we've devised so then it's now you're seeing things that are obviously made of bone right that don't have the bone keyword because you have this build called the bone zerker if you have these earrings you get these huge buffs probably nothing but bone in your gear grip yeah so then yeah you get like the the lion [ __ ] spear which is literally made of these great cat bones yeah doesn't have the bone keyword right so it's it you know it's like they create all these things but then they have to now so that's definitely one of my complaints yeah it's they had to skewer a lot of their theme to make it work within the mechanics of the game yeah and uh you know like say lion beast guitars yeah uh they they're obviously [ __ ] knuckles yeah can't they be fisting two right yeah there's nothing built around fist and tooth except for some fighting arts it's yeah it is literally just the wrong thing i'm not even we're not even going to go into nitty-gritty of stuff like that that's that i wanted to go go over kind of high-level stuff so um what you're getting at is cost

to like game play yeah it costs to gain pleasure satisfaction so like i've put in maybe a little less than a grand into this yeah and with that being said i have got only i i didn't even get to play six or seven games right so which i did verify you know like clarify before yeah yeah that's fine so out of the 23 out of we'll say i mean 23 out of 30 games that i got to play that's 23 and a half hours or so or whatever about 30 hours probably 30 hours in and i've spent almost a grand on this and i've spent a grand on magic cards easy yeah that is true real [ __ ] easy i've played years worth of games uh video games wise i've bought uh like if i were to put up the price of the witcher 3 with everything the sakiro bloodborne all three dark souls games combined i have probably 40 times the amount of hours and not even half the price yeah yeah yeah and that's really that's really what i if like i said if this game i'd probably be able to overlook some of the some of the cons if the game was cheaper and we have played games multiple times where i've made the exact same complaints and i'm like well the game was 60 bucks

and that sucks well i've even mentioned games that we didn't like and i'm like oh this was 300 and it's like oh [ __ ] this game is three grand well the core game is 400. for everything in a big kickstarter is 300. and that's it just elevates it so much and i guarantee you my ranking for this game and my feeling towards it it's so it's gonna be what it is because it's so expensive and like you said the satisfaction to cost doesn't meet up the ending of this year we played this for a year like this is a lot i've never even played a [ __ ] d d campaign for a year and for it to end with uh the smoke puts you in a breathless slumber what the [ __ ] you couldn't even do an ending right let alone [ __ ] half your game because like you mentioned it's unclear and ambiguous and it's like okay well why does that work but this doesn't work and it's like every time i was just always in the back of your head i guarantee you it never leaves it's like i spend a lot i spend a lot on this money so i have to let it go i have to let go otherwise what did i spend my money on and it's just cat what do you think well you didn't really put any money into it oh you i did but it's it's not as heavy hitting because i mean i did not put the majority right into it um but i mean like i'm definitely like content matters it really really matters quality over quantity yeah well like i mean it's the same for a video game it's like i can play a four hour video game and if it's got a [ __ ] awesome story i'm gonna be happy whereas like if i play a

60 plus hour video game and like it ends with if they mass effect three it like yeah yeah and it just ends that's such a good point like everything you're saying always leads into what i want to say next and i was going to say if these were so insane if these issues were in a video game people would riot like and you see issues like this in video games you just mentioned the ending to mass effect 3 and people [ __ ] on that as a say they're trying to make a whole new ending yeah and it's like of course you have people who are like i like it and i don't mind mass effect it's the only ending i know um but it's like the games as a service the things that they want to do in this game for some reason people praise this as like sheer perfection but it's like like a [ __ ] about a game that's 60 bucks i'm like why did i pay 60 bucks for that it's not worth 60 bucks this is not worth 400. i'm not even saying three grand because all that stuff is extra 400 this game is not worth 400 and with that being said there's two questions i'm gonna ask you guys one of course is gonna be the ranking for it after the whole campaign and but before that would you recommend this game to someone i guess you can answer say the ranking and then if you would recommend it so devon we will start with you what is your final campaign record because now uh this is the one campaign you finished i know i haven't just came in i mean we didn't do pandemic though no oh sorry i meant for kingdom death oh cause you have your you have yourself that's right i i stalled out my solo uh and i probably won't go back to it anyway yeah it's just whatever and see you you won't even play pandemic

again and that was less than this yeah and you didn't even pay for that it just there's it has a gameplay loop that is just stress so anyway that's awesome we're playing it right now that is true i have the chair i don't have enough turns that is true yeah you got a good one so i am curious on what your final ranking is and if you would recommend this to someone i mean i still really enjoy the game i uh there's there's quibbles there's qualms and you've helped me see a few definitely a lot of the the unclear uh you know a lot of the rules which is definitely frustrating i do remember especially whenever we played like three because for like like two three weeks we were doing three or four sessions and i remember there was a time where you were like it's a little much like you were actually finally i was like i'm getting through the wall he's seeing the light there are a lot of issues uh versus me just bitching just a [ __ ] it's like ah that's the one that he's like huh yeah i'm starting to see some myself i i think it was like where we played four games and i think like like three is mine there were a lot like popping up yeah a lot of like inconsistencies on clear gameplay or thematic issues where it's like yeah this is oh man that's kind of frustrating but anyway i mean yeah definitely the price all that it's it's a lot and i definitely would be trepidatious in recommending this to somebody without knowing their financial state true true because that's a good point for any game in all honesty yeah i mean i still love the hell out of

it it is like my favorite board game yeah i i come back to this no problem yeah i would i i salivate at the idea of bringing new people into it yeah to play with me i don't want them to have to buy it because it's super expensive right and it's like i don't want to do that to you i mean i bought it so i can enjoy it with other people true um you know i i'm still gonna i'm still up there i mean i really enjoy the game i come back to it easily it has all the replay valid you know repealability i need i'm still 10 10. i still really enjoy it it's a it is expensive it is ridiculous and that definitely it's marked up and i accept that and only because of my financial situation that i can burden this i guess you know that would have more trouble yeah i definitely would sure recognize that sure yeah and i guess the recommendation on the price point is very subjective because to me paying a hundred dollars for a kickstarter game is is no problem and i don't say that to brag but it's like some people might have difficulty finding paying for a 50 game and that's just the way it is so obviously whenever i mentioned recommendation it's kind of taking cost out almost like assuming that people can afford to play this because obviously it's like oh i recommend it oh you don't have 400 oh well okay i guess not it's like obviously if they can afford it would you recommend it let me rephrase so josh yeah yeah so josh will go to you next um so i would probably not recommend this to anyone not made mainly because of its price point yeah if you were like if someone had

four hundred dollars burning a hole in your pocket base game sure 400 bucks if if you had nothing other than that price range that you would want sure get it um and make sure you have a group of gaming friends yeah actually i would say this game is better with two it is definitely not too bad yeah it's probably because me and logan just were blowing down it was great there wasn't too much around the table when you and i did the big net of death and i did it with josh it's like you just control two people and like whenever it comes to resources and endeavors it's just one other person that you have to bounce back stuff and you'd be like oh like it's almost you with four because like if i don't stay here and tell cat what to build because that's her thing but if it's me and you but we can be like oh let's do it yeah you get to bounce ideas off of somebody instead of trying to manipulate yeah when they're going on and then the settlement in the showdown phase it's just you and like how i play blue haven solo it's you control two things and it's perfect uh here it's the same way in the two-player game so four i felt was a little a little much especially for a 30-year campaign um but yeah so you wouldn't recommend it i i wouldn't recommend this um i definitely would not recommend uh to buy everything right i get why we did and uh addiction yeah pretty much and i understand that you have the the financial situation where you could pay for it all you know but like i got the pin-ups i gotta yank it comparing me to like what you could put

three grand towards especially since not to brag or nothing i just bought a house right and like that's a down payment on a house yeah for everything in this board game yeah um and i'm not saying i didn't enjoy it i i've almost loved every single game there were a couple words like okay that's the bull right right but um 400 if you can split it with people and enjoy it with people yeah go for it whatever um i would not spend 400 to play this by myself or even if even if my brother was like i want to play this go [ __ ] you right right please go [ __ ] yourself yeah um but that being said the conglomeration of so many genres is overwhelming at times and that it really brings it down and then the ending i am almost never the guy that's like well the ending has to be perfection for it to be good i like the journey as it also but i like a good ending as well there wasn't even an epilogue i know and when you have the frustrations of consistent perma-death yeah with your parrot your character progression when you're trying to be a dark souls-esque game with sieve with a looting system and all this other crazy [ __ ] yeah it's too much right um

to adam poop like you have an amazing mind an amazing world yeah yeah flesh it out flesh it out had some more consistent things in it just to where like if you need to play this way a certain way and like this and that um i still think the game is good for a lot of it other than those i'm gonna say it's a seven seven it's a good game okay i'm not gonna say i'm not gonna go out and tell anybody go spend 400 right yeah which i mean initially you were a 10. and then whenever i did my solo discussion you were still out of 10. or i think maybe a nine but i think you're still really up there so it did drop drop a little bit for you so okay okay cat i will try to be as concise as possible one seth go ahead would you recommend it stop it um okay so what i rate it i'll give it um a five i'm gonna give it a five because it does some things really really good it does some things really really wrong um it has mechanics that i don't personally like it doesn't mean that it's bad game i rate things based on what i feel um there's just a lot to it and i do get overwhelmed i like simplicity i like things to just be nice and clean it's not and well for the record actually that was a pro of mine with

streamline game the the game to play it is simple like yeah like the game play is simple and that is nice because there's a lot of campaign games that are very just like uh uh cumbersome and you're just like oh god so many little this game does have fiddly rules and things like that but for the most part you know okay so here's my attack i roll this many dice that's what i hit on it it is very streamlined in that sense um and so that is a pro but yeah go ahead yeah sorry no it's fine um just [ __ ] upset i just hate you but i mean like you know it does things really good it does things poorly it happens um i am very story driven the fact that there it's not supposed to be like a story story that's okay i get it but i'm also very ending driven as well i love the journey i love getting there as well but um like if i had paid what you paid and then we got that ending i'd be like just [ __ ] kill my mom like right just so um that's why i'm gonna give it a five is because i kind of feel like betrayed by stuff like that it's like i just put so much energy and like stress and joy with my friends like depending on what happened but like and then you did that and you didn't tell like you can't even tell me why so uh before you give yours to like go back to her mass effect thing mass effect across three games was amazing all the way up until that very final part and it was

you only got that cut scene where the chest plate moves yeah oh you got the perfect ending if you got the perfect ending yeah and it's like that's not fair to however millions of people are fans of your game right i have it's literally the mass effect uh uh symbol the paragon symbol is and incorporated into my tattoo because the story and i actually do like the ending for three i mean it's it's [ __ ] because it was choice based literally up until the very end yeah it was like ending tron 3000 yeah and what what color of light destroys your universe exactly and that's all it was but for the up until that point it's like okay that's the ending i have to accept it uh still all the emotion that it put me through yeah um so yeah uh would i recommend this game obviously if money wasn't an issue if people just had three grand absolutely not oh i would not recommend yeah and there's a reason for it and like i said money is not an issue i can literally name you probably ten games that you could spend three grand on and you'd probably spend less than a thousand to get a deeper gameplay rich story rich and and social rich experience than this and that's not to say the pros i had are very strong and i'm sure there's more like whenever we were playing and we're all talking in theme and it's like the highs were really high and the lows were really low um where where you're sitting here and you as players have to incorporate story

and theme and fun into a game uh you shouldn't have to like the game should aid you in that and it almost doesn't there were a lot of times where we were excited to talk about our settlement and be like oh we're gonna bronze these guys out because that'll be cool thematically as they're the heroes um and you go through this whole year we've played this for a year almost religiously um i don't think there was ever really a time we took a break like there was never like two months where we just didn't play like yeah other than like the obvious like holiday break like where we were sure well any time that me and josh were both free yeah there was if we played it consistently and then whenever you were working all the time it was like hey do you care if we continue and you're like no not at all yeah and then you made it to the finale i made it a point i made it a point to be here so you go through all this stuff the hard or the the heartache the the headache the the sheer all the cons that i'm not going to repeat but for that to be the ending not even an epilogue they didn't even give you the the [ __ ] time of day uh if that was any video game it would be a [ __ ] one this game is clearly not that for me um like i said the pros are really good and i have a hard time because if if the price point if i and at first of all i wouldn't have even played this had you guys not agreed to even chip in and it's like oh okay that makes it 133 that's not bad i can do that but i'm not going to drop 400 whenever so many people had already kind of talked ill of this game um

so it's like if price point wasn't an issue it'd be a six for me and it was a seven my second with the price being brought in it drops it to a four and and because of how much money you have to actually put into the game to get any semblance of enjoyment at least for me um they're wrong i'm still excited for all the extra stuff but i know for a fact and i can't even raise the score on that because you don't know how it's gonna be and even if it's awesome i feel it's gonna fall into the same pitfalls that this game had uh where it's like okay well now i know how the ivory dragon fights all right i guess all this all that and it's like i can't go back i can go back and play gloomhaven because it's choice-based in its campaign and it's little snippets and i actually have customization on what i want to do i can do seventh continent over i mean we're still in curse

every time we feel like that we're moving forward and making traction it's like okay nope we're in this whole new area it needs it needs eyes yeah we've went to like 30 places that could possibly have that yeah so it's just and that's the thing is like if there was no other game of this ilk which probably in 2017 there wasn't that that i would have raped over this oh my god this is so unique and innovative board games have advanced so much for that campaign gameplay even the euro ones where it's like it used to be trading resources now glue maven you have a rpg experience that is euro-like so it's not just sitting here going up one three like you actually have control and get to enjoy it and that's why i feel like it drops below average for me and it's a real shame because it's got it was a ten seven four so it's dropped three three steps each time but obviously if money is not an issue it's a six luckily i haven't had to spend all the money like to pay for all of it i had help yeah so i mean it's it's props so you have a wide range you have a ten seven uh five and then a four um so that's it like you can go check out our other discussions on that uh definitely go watch the first one and you know let us let me know what you think of the game in the comments below at this point uh other than that you guys got anything else i'm hungry oh yep i we have definitely

we have definitely talked about a lot of stuff um so that's it everyone i hope you enjoyed the series the series was still fun because of you guys like i say i enjoyed my time i enjoyed it and that's kind of a thing of board games i enjoyed it because i was playing with my friends it was a great background so that was fun and like i said the highs were high like it was exciting but i can't look past these cons with the price point it's so like they they're very frustrating so that's it everyone that's our discussion for kingdom death monster after the campaign let us know what you think in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved