Blood Rage: Valhalla Review | Is This a Worthy Sequel to Blood Rage?
Transcript
The world has officially ended. The Vikings are in Valhalla and they can finally spend the rest of eternity hanging around, having deep conversations, trying to understand one another, and fulfilling their true dreams of being bakers and florists. Nope. Actually, the opposite. If you experienced Ragnarok yourself in 2015's Blood Rage, you invaded, you pillaged, you fought and died your way to glory as the world was being destroyed, and the player with the most glory won.
Those clans are in Valhalla, summoning, contesting, fighting, and dying their way to win the most glory in the afterlife.
[snorts]
I'm Ryan with Tantrum House and today we're looking at Blood Rage: Valhalla, the sequel game to Blood Rage, and it's designed by Eric Lang and published by Tycoon Games. Over the course of this review, I'll be referencing the OG Blood Rage quite a bit, but as far as mechanics go, I'm just going to go over the rules of this game. Then I'm going to have a quick section going over the lot of the differences between the first game and this one. And this section's going to be time-stamped, so people who have played the OG Blood Rage, they can just see what those differences are, but new players, they can get the scoop on this new game without having to sort out which mechanics belong to which game and all that craziness. And I'm going to go into detail on how things work with this game, but this is not a how-to play, so I'm not going to hit every single mechanic. It's just enough so that you know how it all works. Now, Blood Rage: Valhalla is an area control game for three to five players where each player is going to control a Viking clan and compete for the favor of the gods. The game is played over three rounds or ages, and in each age, a god will arrive onto the board, players will draft cards, they'll perform actions to gain control over the board and fight and die over rewards. They're going to summon monsters to fight for their clans, they're going to complete quests, and they're going to prove their valor in different regions. Then the age will end, dead warriors will return to players, some things are going to be reset, the next age is going to begin, a new god is introduced onto the board, and the carnage continues. After three ages, the player with the most glory wins the game. Now, each player is going to start by choosing a clan. There are different themes like the Wolf Clan or
the Stag Clan, but each faction works the same way. So, pick the color and the theme you like most. This player clan board will be where you track and upgrade your stats. And you have rage, which is your economy to play cards, axes, which dictates how much glory or points you get for winning battles, and horns, which tells how much glory you get for completing quests. There's also a nifty section at the bottom that lets you know what actions you can do in the action phase. Now, onto the game board. Players will be summoning, invading, and fighting over nine regions in Valhalla. Each region has a different reward for winning, and this is one of the ways players will get upgrades for their rage, axes, and horns. The middle of the board has Odin's throne, which is the most lucrative area to win, but players can't summon their units into it, so it's a bit harder to take, and there's more avenues into it. Three of these regions will randomly be locked out of rewards until a god inhabits them.
Players will start by choosing three gods who will provide their gifts over the course of the game, and these are going to be the cards that players will draft each round. And with each rage, a new god will enter a region in Valhalla, starting with the lowest locked region, and work their way up. If you prove your valor to these gods at the end of a round, you get powerful effects that upgrade your player board per usual, but can also do fun things like steal glory from other players or kill enemy figures on the board. The base game has five gods to choose from: Loki, Thor, Tyr, Freya, and Balder. There's an expansion that has some others, but we were given the base game for this review, so the base game we will review. Each god has a pool of 25 cards, and when players have chosen their three gods, those cards all get shuffled together to create the god gifts deck, and it's going to be used for drafting at the beginning of every age. Each god has a different style of play and their cards encourage different strategies.
Thor is about helping you win battles with big numbers and getting you more glory from your wins. Loki, he wants you to lose battles so you can steal cards and you can steal glory and benefit from your figures dying. Tyr gives you big numbers to win battles. He hits real hard. Freya, she'll protect your figures or manipulate them in order to affect the outcome of battles. And Balder augments his power based on the amount of quests a player has committed to or completed. The first game recommendation is Loki, Thor, and Tyr. So, that's what we'll have on our board today. Players will also randomly select monster cards to put into the God's gift deck. If players draft these monsters, they can get access to powerful abilities like negating the strength of battle cards with a strength of three or more or killing enemy figures in the region where the monster is summoned or gaining glory when the monster is killed. The cards in the God's gifts deck will come in four flavors. Battle cards, which are red and come into play when players contest areas. Upgrade cards, which are black and will be placed on the upgrade slots on players boards to give permanent effects for the rest of the game. Quest cards, which are green, will temporarily be placed on upgrade slots and they're going to give rewards for completing certain tasks.
And then there's the monster cards, which are also black and they'll be played in the upgrade slots on player boards and those will be the monsters that you can summon over the course of the game. Once set up is done, each age will have six phases. Phase one, the god arrives and replaces the lowest number region token. Phase two, God's gifts. Players are going to be dealt six cards. They're going to draft one and then they're going to pass the rest of the cards to the player on their left. You're going to draft. You're going to keep doing that until every player has drafted five cards. There's one left over. All of those cards will go on the bottom of the God's gifts deck. Fun fact, players will pass the cards to their right on age two and then in age three they're going to return to passing it to the player on their left. Phase three, the action phase. Players are going to play upgrades or quests from their hand.
They're going to summon figures to the board. They're going to march around the board. They're going to contest regions. These are going to be the fights that decide who wins upgrades and things like that. And I'll explain how contests work. When a player has figures in a region, they can choose to contest it. This doesn't cost anything. It's just the action for your turn. This triggers a call to battle where each other player, going in clockwise order starting to the contester's left, has the option to move exactly one a figure from an adjacent region to the fight. Players can move one figure and they get one chance to do it. So, if you skip, then you want to get in on the battle, tough cookies. You already passed. Then, every player who is participating in the contest must choose a card in their hand and place it face down. Everyone reveals and any battle cards, the red ones, augment the battle. Other players may have quests, upgrades, or monsters, but those won't affect the battle. Figures in the region, monsters, and battle card effects, they're going to combine a strength that each player is going to have. Whoever has the highest strength in the region wins the contest, gains glory according to their acts track, and for winning, they take all other figures into their kill pile.
If the player who initiated the contest won, they also get the region reward and place one of their clan tokens on that region, meaning it can't be contested for the rest of that age. If another player won, they don't get the region reward or place a clan token. So, the region can still be contested again on someone else's turn. The winning player loses whatever card they played and the losers take their cards back into their hand unless a card ability makes them discard it. God regions can also be contested and have powerful rewards for players who win them. It may be killing an enemy figures in any region, automatically completing a quest, or maybe summoning figures to another region. And these scale depending on the age. So, you get points and progressively increasingly powerful rewards.
Once every player has spent all their rage, the action phase is over. An important rule, once a player spends all their rage, their turn is done, even if they have actions that don't require rage. So, everyone needs to be careful about when they go out. Plus, other players can still play if they still have rage. Next is phase four. Players will reveal their quest cards. If a quest is completed, the player gets the clan upgrade reward and points based on their horn track. That's it. Phase five, prove valor. You'll go god by god and the player with the most figures on a god, it's not strength, it's the most figures, so it's just a numbers game. The player with the most figures on a god, they prove their valor and they appease that god. The winner will remove any figures they have in the region and they move them into the feast hall. They're going to score points depending on the age for each figure removed.
If other players lose in a god region, their figures stay on the board for the next age. Lastly, phase six. This is the release warriors phase. Players will get all their warriors back from other players and the feast hall. Any figures that are on the board remain there. Players get their clan tokens back, the first player token is moved to the player on the left and the round begins anew. Rinse and repeat for two more ages. At the end of the third age, players will score one more bonus, glory for their clan stats. This can get them 10 or 20 glory for each stat depending on how far along the track they've gotten. Once all the glory is added up, players announce their totals and the clan with the most glory is the bestest Viking ever. Lastly, there's also the rainbow bridge module, which creates a connection between Blood Rage 2015 and the new Blood Rage Valhalla. Players will set up their Blood Rage game and they're going to place the rainbow bridge next to it. They'll decide in advance which three gods will be in their Valhalla game and these gods will have missions that players can complete once per age for additional points in the OG Blood Rage. This could be to complete two quests in an age or have at least four figures on the board by the end of the age. When players complete these, they'll place clan tokens from Valhalla on the rainbow bridge to keep track of their achievements.
At the end of the game, if a player has at least two tokens under a god's mission rewards, they'll gain that god's favor, which is going to earn them an extra card in Valhalla when they play that. If you get Loki's favor, you get an upgrade where the first time you lose a unit, you can place it on that card and raise a clan stat. Or Freya rewards you for the first time a unit survives a battle per age by giving you rage. Where players place in the first game will also get them starting glory in Valhalla. For example, the winner will start the next game with 12 glory, second place with eight, and different numbers depending on how many numbers you played with, okay? Now, I'll go over the differences between OG Blood Rage and Blood Rage Valhalla, okay? Then I'm going to give my thoughts on the game.
If you've played Blood Rage before and you've been paying attention to the mechanics, you've likely spotted a bunch of these differences already. I'm not going to go over everything, but I'll hit some of the big ones. First, there's no fjords or boats in Blood Rage Valhalla. Two, regions have restrictions on how figures can move between them. Three, Ragnarok is not destroying the board over the course of the game. So, every region will be accessible the entire time. The playing field gets more chaotic because players will fight for three separate gods in three separate regions in the third age. Four, old school Blood Rage has three separate age decks with locked cards, but in Valhalla, you shuffle everything, all three gods and the monsters into one deck that has more variability depending on which gods you choose and which random monsters are in play. Five, monsters are not summoned as soon as they're played.
You play the upgrade, then you summon on a future round for free. Six, the player boards. You don't have specific upgrades for chieftains, monsters, warriors, etc. Any upgrade can be played in any upgrade space. Another thing is quests. Quests are placed face down in upgrade slots until completed, but if you have upgraded every slot in your board, you can't play quests from that point on. Next, horns. Horn upgrades give glory instead of increasing unit amounts on the board. Number seven, when a conflict begins, players can bring one figure from a surrounding region, not all of them. Number eight, players have their own discard pile for cards and retain three cards between ages instead of one. Nine, regions don't have limits for how many figures can be summoned onto them. There are other differences, but that gives you a good idea of how the gameplay has been adapted to the new mechanics and what they wanted to do with this version. So, what do I think? I think it's a really solid game. The bones are here and the experience is a blast.
Blood Rage Valhalla is an interesting sequel that shores up some of the flaws in the old game. It tweaks an old formula with modern variability mechanics. If you played the first and you've moved on, this is a fun mix-up to the formula and a great place to get back into the battle. If this is your first experience, you don't have the "This is different" syndrome that others do. So, jump in and start having a blast. That said, as far as sequels go, I'm going to use an analogy with another Tycoon game franchise since they're the ones who bought CMON. Everdell. Everdell Farshore was basically Everdell with a new coat of paint and some tweaked mechanics to help fix base Everdell's weaknesses and add a thing or two. Silverfrost, however, is Everdell with a drastic mechanic change that really evolves the game and it's still familiar, but it makes it new enough to where it could be called a sequel if they were really trying to do that thematically.
Farshore made me feel like I was still playing base Everdell, while Silverfrost made it hard to go back to base Everdell because of the new new things that they changed. Blood Rage fits somewhere in the middle of Farshore and Silverfrost for me. It's a familiar enough jump from 2015 to the new one, and you just have to learn the new mechanics. But, it isn't a drastic leap forward that pushes it into true sequel territory for me. It almost feels like if I got an itch to play Blood Rage, but was so familiar with it that I needed to add, adapt, evolve some mechanics to spice things up and make it feel like a new play again. Both games are great for what they are, and playing Valhalla gave me an itch to play Blood Rage. But, playing Blood Rage also gave me an itch for some of the updated aspects of Valhalla, which is a good thing. So, what are the pros? I love having the gods be the harbingers of a new age, and I love that they supply their cards into the mix. Players may miss the 2015 strategy of knowing which cards would be in which age so they could form a plan based on what's coming, but I like the unpredictability and the variability of not knowing which upgrades, which monsters, which quests could come into play at what time. Does it make it strategizing more chaotic?
Yeah. Is it harder to keep track of what other players could be doing? Yep. Can it also create harder swings? Absolutely. One of my games swung hard at the end, where the first player decimated everyone else with a bunch of new plays. It was a learning experience for the other players, and they could look at how they could have done things differently, which was nice. This is a good sign. But, due to the randomization and the variability with the god pool, I won't be surprised if we see overpowered strategies and combos popping up in the comment section on BGG. Player preference and mileage will vary on this one. So, figure out which experience fits your play preference better, and then pick the one that you dig. Valhalla still has some combos that are pure Blood Rage. In one game, by the third age, I had an absolutely disgusting synergy with Skull. This is a card that gave me glory every time I killed an enemy figure.
But, I also had Thor's favor, which gave me two extra glory every time I gained glory for any reason. But, I also had the ogre chieftain, which kills all warriors and elites when summoned into a region. So, when I brought that bad boy out, I nuked a region with enemy figures and immediately racked up points, which felt wickedly delightful. I then also had Tyr's Command, which allowed me to march all of my figures to a single region. So, between players contesting against each other and me hand staying back, my tactical nuke, and my marching ability, I ended the third age with the most figures on the board, moved them into all three god regions, and I watched my score rise like Bitcoin in 2017. It was pure blood rage, baby.
The other nice thing about the god gift deck being variable every game is that you can get any of the monsters at any point. This can kind of help you get more use out of them, and you get to use them in different ways depending on how your game is going. The Draugr kills an enemy figure before battle cards are revealed. If I draft him in the third age, I may snag him up to help me with a contest or two just to get a particularly troublesome enemy out of the way, or to just win a thing that I need. But, if I draft him in the first age, he is a terror on the board for the whole game, and I can win more contests because other players they're just not going to contest me as much, or they're just going to lose more when they go against me. Having that variance and flexibility was a welcome change to knowing certain monsters would only be available at certain times. All this said, there are pros and cons to this new approach. In playing Valhalla, I did sort of miss the guarantee of escalating power with the cards from each age. In Valhalla, any and everything could be available at any point. So, it's more about the luck of the draft. If Blood Rage is building a Lego set by opening the bags in order and seeing your build one bag at a time, Valhalla is like opening everything, dumping it into a pile, and creating order from the chaos. I think both approaches are valuable, and they're fun in different ways. So, I think it's good. It just depends on what you want out of the game. I also really appreciate that summoning units is cheap, and regions don't have a unit cap. You can never get blocked out of a fight unless you aren't positioned
correctly. If players are feeling especially bloodthirsty, everyone could summon all of their units and have an all-out war for Odin's throne. Having movement restrictions between some of the regions forces players to be intentional with their summons, but we had some absolute bloodbaths when contesting. And uh it created some awesome, depressing, and hilarious results. Battles in Valhalla can occur on a much grander scale, and I'm all for that change. I'm of two minds about having gods inhabit the board and keeping all nine regions available for the whole game. It allows for a wider, greater scale to controlling the board and picking your battles as the game progresses. And contesting god regions and gaining their benefits can create some gnarly swings that winners will love, and losers, they're going to have to figure out creative ways to solve it.
That said, it also made me miss the Ragnarok mechanic in Blood Rage that constantly changed and shrank the playing field. It forced players into almost claustrophobic encounters as the world ended. Valhalla keeps the ages wide and grand, so the carnage can spread kind of thin depending on which gods players want. Hear me on this. This change isn't bad or it's a flaw, but it is a consequence of being a new mechanic in a sequel game. Both approaches are viable and they're great, and I appreciate aspects of each. If you've never played the first Blood Rage, just enjoy how this game plays in the third age and pass me by. You're going to have a good time. Now, some of the cons. First, the rulebook. There are inconsistencies in terminology, which is a cardinal sin for board gamers. Units are destroyed, killed, and removed, but destroyed and killed are used interchangeably, and removed means something else. The book may say contest at one point, then conflict in another.
Gamers know that word choice and phrasing is key when having to refer to the rules. So, this inconsistency can create unnecessary confusion. This next one might be a nitpick, but in the end of the game box, it says, "Once the release warriors phase of the third age is complete, the world has come to an end and so has the game." This was true in Blood Rage, but Ragnarok has already occurred. The world ended and Valhalla is the afterlife, so is Valhalla ending? Is the afterlife experiencing its own Ragnarok? Or was this a copy and paste error and it just kind of showed that the rulebook needed a few more passes. I already played the first game, so I could parse out the information that I needed for the most part, but it did take work and I'd be curious to know how new players do with this rulebook.
There also has been quite a few complaints about the rule clarifications. So, don't be surprised when you need to pause the game to have a family meeting or look online to figure out how to how an interaction works. There's also been a few complaints about rule clarifications. So, don't be surprised when you need to pause the game to have a family meeting or you need to look online to figure out how an interaction exactly works. I also have to address the elephant in the room, the Gamefound campaign. I followed this and I saw a lot of the craziness in real time. Backers were highly critical of the game board that was originally released in that campaign. And it was to the point where Tycoon Games created new possibilities on the fly and they had players vote on the one that they liked.
Obviously, what you see in the box and what's in this game is what won. It's not the original. The game was originally set in Odin's house and players were basically in a housewide bar brawl. Personally, I thought that setting was hilarious and I kind of wish it had stayed that way, but that original board was not it and the backers made their opinions clear. Then, there's the art and the theming. This was another point of contention in the campaign. And personally, I think the art is not bad, but it doesn't feel like Blood Rage. There's a lot of details to the characters, they're varied, and the fusion of cultures makes for some interesting designs, but I prefer Blood Rage's aesthetic choice. These changes could have worked if they had marketed this as maybe Blood Rage Elysium, a reimagining of the game where gods collide in the afterlife and they're gods from different pantheons, but it's touted as a sequel. And the cohesion, it may work in name and mechanics, but it fails in the visuals and the theming. And back to the Rainbow Bridge, it's weird to play a game of Blood Rage with a bleak and dark Viking aesthetic, then you transition into Valhalla where the clans look completely different. The armor is a mishmash of global ancient influence and Thor is a blue creature that looks more like something out of Middle Eastern culture than a Norse god. I actually just carried over whatever figures I could from the original game into Valhalla, so the theming felt more natural whenever I went from the first to the next. I think the online hate in the campaign was overblown, which is typical of the
internet, but I'm definitely in the camp that was puzzled by the decisions that were made. One of the buddies that I played with, he was unfamiliar with the franchise and I asked him what he thought of the art of this one and he seemed confused by the hodgepodge of cultural influences that mixed into each figure. And when the game referenced Vikings in Valhalla, he just seemed a little confused. Then I showed him OG Blood Rage and his first comment was, "That looks like Vikings in Valhalla. That's awesome." It's anecdotal, but I tried talking to someone without the bias and got similar feedback to what I had. There's speculation that the art was from a different game and shoehorned into this one. I don't know. I don't know, but it does feel like a downgrade when you're moving from one Blood Rage to the other. That's my opinion. And back to the Rainbow Bridge module, it's a neat idea, but personally, I feel it's tacked on and it's half-baked. It doesn't create the progression and cohesion between games that they were hoping for. For starters, and this is the last time I'll bring this up, the gods on the Rainbow Bridge module don't match the gods in the original Blood Rage. Also, it doesn't really provide catch-up mechanics for players who struggled in the first game, just benefits for those who crushed it.
Basically, this module makes it to where if you wrecked face in the first game, you have a greater chance of wrecking face in the next. I like the idea of connecting one game to the other, but it needed more time in the oven to really flesh it out better. Heck, I almost wish that they had waited on this and maybe did an expansion to make it more robust. I don't bring all of these cons up just to dunk on the game. The reason I'm bringing all this up is that there were some really odd decisions that made aspects of this game feel rushed or just maybe not as thought out as they should have been. Mechanically, Valhalla is a solid reiteration. It's a modernization. It's a evolution of the franchise. Most of my criticism isn't about the gameplay. If you dig the new art style and you want more Blood Rage with a new spin, you'll be in for a great time with this game. If you've never even heard of Blood Rage and you want a solid area control game that provides deep mechanics, cool combos, and battles of epic proportions, then I recommend it.
If you were hoping for a sequel that pushes the formula into bold new areas and it is a natural and seamless progression, you may be left wanting. Some people refuse to touch it because of the issues I've discussed, which is a shame because there's a really good game here. I recommend it and my friend group wants to play more. It also makes us want to play throwback Blood Rage OG and that's cool, too. Weigh my opinions next to what you're hoping to get from this game and make the call that sounds right to you. Thanks for joining in on this Tantrum House review. If you want to see more reviews, live playthroughs, or join in on our Saturday morning board game show, hit that like button, mash the subscribe button, and we'll see you in the next one.