Board Stupid Podcast Episode 75 - The Fox Experiment
Transcript
hello and welcome to board stupid the podcast I love talking T to board games d and d and other awesome stuff I'm Wayne I'm Simon I'm Tom we're just the Nerds talking about the things we love that are worth geeking out over so Simon are you ready yep yep son are you ready I am I'm ready to get breeding and if you guys are ready will dive in to this week's episode no further context required this week we played the fox experiment we played as a series where we talk about an epic board game that we played this week and this week it's the dice chucking trait collecting domestication study the fox experiment in this episode we're going to dive into the things we like and break down all the elements that make it great at the end of the day we only play awesome games and the fox experiment most definitely does not accurately emulate selective breeding programs in a way that the internet would get mad about right that would never happen that would never happen people would never be mad about a board game on the internet that that sounds ridiculous why would that happen it's got to balance out when the actual game is played by people who have more than two brain cells it's fine it's fine let's tell them why it's awesome let's do that so about the fox experiment in this game you're going to breed your own domesticated foxes in each round you're going to select a pair of fox parents who have certain Fox traits you will gain those specific trait dice roll them and then try to
move them around to make complete trait symbols which you'll then Mark off on a pop card you'll then gain trait tokens depending on how many you've managed to mark off which you'll use to upgrade various tracks on your personal playboard and at the end of the round the previous generation of foxes will go into the Minah uh and then all of the new pups that have been bred this is not going to be a PC review all of the new pups that have been bred will be moved into the kennels th comfortably retired comfortably retired thus becoming candidates to be the new parents in the next generation of foxes the fox experiment will play one to four players in the base game as you can buy it although with room for expansions up to six players uh designed by Elizabeth Hargrave and Jeff Fraser uh art by Joe shawcross and published by big Panda pandasaurus games uh Play Time says here about 60 Minutes accurate I think we did it slightly faster this time I you can definitely do it in less than 60 Minutes the first time we played this at a show with a very efficient German was was 40 minutes with about 40 minutes definitely speed March I think yeah I think we hit just under an hour this time and I played Monday and that was definitely not more than an hour and 20 so yeah I think an hour to an hour and 10 hour and 20 is should be all you need and very doable especially if you're not teaching someone to play at the same time yeah absolutely that being said for me at least I might be jumping the gun here would quite happily reset and start again and spend two hours playing this
yeah it's a really good game it's an absolutely fantastic game which we'll get into why that is as we go uh MSRP is actually £59.99 so £60 you can get it much cheaper on tinter webs so um onet on on tinet yeah so $59.99 as the MSRP but as stated you'll probably be able to find that much cheaper let's break down the components and art design and I'll throw that over to you gentlemen what do you think about the components and art design let's some with the box I think for myself it's a nice pretty image I think it might equally put a bunch of people off it's kind of an oil painting of a wintry scene with a couple of cute foxes on the cover and some people working in the background I think it's one you're either going to love or potentially or maybe not hate I think hate is maybe a strong word the ambivalent towards it's got the same sort of curb appeal or something like wingspan where you go oh that's a board game about breeding Foxes or watching Birds yeah it's that kind of strong nature theme as you'd imagine which isn't going to speak to everyone personally I like it as a VX I typically they've done very well recently like nature based games I think they very on Trend yeah AB yeah very much on Trend like Cascadia being another huge hit in that in that respect and then diving into the box itself and getting out all the components I think I think it looks great yeah you have wonderful stuff you a relatively small board compared to some of the stuff we've played recently the
board is almost a secondary consideration it's more like a a place where you hold stuff rather than you're actively play the board the board suggest to lay out certain cards and tracks and score counters um who even be smaller i d yeah well and you've got a you've got your own player board as well which is equally basically just a snapshot of the main art yeah it's kind of a winry town it's not quite exactly the same art but it's a snapshot of similar art style it's a little it's a little sort of Village research area that you've got yeah we assume that it's the the Russian town where this study took place right and and it essentially just boils down to a set of tracks for you to keep your uh tokens on for the engine building element yeah I think it's very pretty and it doesn't over complicate itself which I think is key A lot of these games can end up with so much going on and it gets lost in the background art I think the the iconography stands clear of the the art background which is very nice yeah it's it's worth it's worth pointing out that there's no text anywhere yeah unless you start looking at the cards there's no text on the board yeah there's no text on the board there's no text on any of the tokens or the tiles or the player boards it's all just a few icons yeah yeah which is for the most part pretty language independent like I say apart from some of the key rules on the science cards Etc comes with some great um help cards which is wonderful and I'm always a fan of a player raiding in games and this comes with a really really good one that's quite small it sort of lays out everything you need to do each round it's a single card
double-sided card that gives you all of the turn overview uh and then it sort of also gives you an idea of how to interpret the symbols and rewards on the pups as well on the other side because I mean it's not a terribly complicated game but that is probably one of the more complicated bits yeah yeah I'd say so you also get a ton of little uh Fox meeples uh a set in each player and something you guys noticed which I didn't notice at all was that there's a few different like sculps of five different sculps which is wildly unnecessary cuz they are essentially just Place markers you put it down to note that you did something so the fact that there's five different ones is really cool I think is really cool but yeah unnecessary is probably a word because I I literally didn't notice no no and and they're not used for a huge amount of stuff they are just score placeholders really they're used to track who's won a given round that sort of thing I really appreciate them though as a rather than being a cube or something like that oh yeah absolutely they gave with foxes and you got a bunch of foxes I think that's cool much better than cubes 100% you get many many custom dice many dice all the dice many custom dice I was rolling five five colors of dice that represent the four main traits plus the generic friend wild tra do you remember the the traits Tom it's like ear floppiness tail bushiness uh spottiness I think spottiness kind of yeah wols and ws and WS 100% the legacy
of loud boy lives on yeah it's very representative because the idea being obviously that the domestication of foxes being the study what the scientists noticed was during the whole process of domestication they would only be picking based on friendliness that was their only consideration and the only thing that they would pick the parents based on how however there were physiological changes that were related to that so what they noticed where the friendlier the pops were the more they started to favored those particular trait yeah those physical traits they'd bark more in uh in the presence of humans because they' get excited or their their tails would get shorter and their ears would get floppier because that's I don't know why and they get like spotti your coats very interesting um I must be quite tough as a science experiment stepping away from the game of a sec to separate that in the mind of how do you like you gauge friendliness yeah that that's yeah gauge is the word I want probably they'd engage humans more since last saing zero days since last saing let's start again how do you manage to differentiate and separate your brain from am I am I inherently more inclined towards seeing friendliness in this one because it's got floppy at what point do you realize and recognize that good question it's probably deeper than the uh the color dice go probably yeah yeah that mean already getting we're already deeper than the depth of this game is yes because it's a very light wash I want to mention the the color palette in play here so your player pieces you've got a nice soft yellow purple uh kind of a
minty green I'd say and red a soft red it's definitely not the hard red that you see in a lot of games it's they're very pastel colors yeah and then the dice themselves you got again a nice blush soft pink uh almost a grayy brown and then what I've called purple and green but I think you guys were calling blue blue but it's kind of a Bluey green it's they're lovely colors I mean p has do wonderful work with the color palette espe they're not quite as uh neon as some as the pandasaurus games but it's the same sort of uh color palette just pastelz yeah it's yeah I think it's a fabulous color Choice handfuls of little round tokens matching those dice which you'll collect based on the dice you rolled essentially absolutely the traits yeah and then the couple of wild card bits you got yeah your your fifth color dice so four four traits Dice and then your wild card dice which I wish would glow in the dark cuz it's that kind of bright green but I don't think they do y you also get um these sort of tarot siiz cards you get a deck of generic male and female parent cards and they all delineate what dice you might be throwing they they really only come into play sort of at the beginning of the game and to then space fill later on the later generations become dominated with p that you've bred from earlier generations and that's one of the key interesting things about this game because you also have each player will have a deck of WIP clean um it's got cards tarot cards rolling right
rolling right style yeah literally rolling dice collecting the traits adding stuff up marking off the tracks giving them a name and customizing your your particular Legacy of uh friendly foxes yeah it's really nice uh and they work great not St sted yet and I think I've played this four or five times not stained yet not stained yet yeah should not but you never know no well they're these they're these easy WIP clean pens that you now get in basically every roll and right game right you get a set of those as well yes it's the railroad ink pen railroad ink pen exactly yeah um you also get a bunch of cards that aren't the sort of large tarot size of more normal cards you've got a study cards science cards and Patron cards and you'll use those for various effects in the game and they're all lovely as well no issue with the card stock good quality stuff yeah for sure how do you rate the production then gentlemen of the fox experiment uh I think it's really good that we did note that within the different sort of player colors you have different art for like the males and females and there'll be a couple of different sort of art palettes for the males and females but they do recycle so you know they're not fully there's not hundreds of different pictures of foxes but there's a decent range M I mean who can tell one fox apart from another well I know one of them looks like he's s some [ __ ] you know there's like some scary looking foxes he's in the blue the blue no he looks ter I think he's in the um I think he's in the the general male yeah one of I've got a family foxes that live outside my flat I couldn't tell you one from the other so the fact that these aren't entirely unique across 50
different foxes is is neither here nor there saly saly saly that that St M but yeah I really like the the overall design I like the overall production I'd easily give this a four if not a five very good yeah I think i' I'd rate this for as well gives a number Tom oh uh s looking at the cards I'm looking I'm looking at the pieces way no i' definitely give it a full very nice yeah really nice really solid production yeah solid production absolutely let's dive into the core mechanics and the game play so uh Simon you won this game how did you win it how did you win this fox experiment do the best foxing do the best do the max fo foxes friendly Fox friendly foxes so there's a few different bits that are going to win you points at the end of the game um the couple of main ones on that is the studies that you do throughout the game and these are small little cards that are asking you to basically get certain preferences certain certain requirements of traits in the foxes in each round um thus moving up the score they start at two points then five points and 10 points getting progressively harder throughout a study as you kind of narrow down this one or two specific traits as you go so it's um it's a bit of a point sound right you can get points from studies which is targeting certain sets of
colors for more General overall friendliness which we mark on the main board yeah one one pop from each generation will win the most friendliness and will secure points for that player at the end of the round you get points from patrons and they want you to do specific types of studies or other kind of you know research that says if you've if you've looked into this kind of thing or you've done more in this area you'll get more points they're the Seven Wonders guilds right yeah end game scoring you get points for your own little player board you can upgrade various things so you start off with one fox and one study one wild dice uh and then you can unlock more foxes so you can each round kind of roll the dice for each set of foxes you can un up more studies and if you get far enough across your own little upgrade board they also become worth some more points so yeah as Tom say it's kind of a point salad on those and if you manage to roll an absolute ton of dice and kind of fill out a fox trait on any given Fox Beyond five in that thing so you got a super super super super super fluffy tail super you're you're just gaining yourself points right there on the Fox as well overflow and become add addition points and there's there's the little the science cards that can be used as oneoff abilities or saved as points at the end of the game M yeah I think that's more of a kind of buy the buy I don't I don't think anyone's going to be aiming to store science cards because you don't gain that many I have five at
the end of the game well Color Me corrected I don't know what can I say so yeah you got numerous roots in there you can you can choose to focus or or spread as you see fit and you'll get yeah a good result either way I I think we've excellent not had a a massive split in our scores from top to bottom I played on Monday and it was uh 69 to 68 to 67 so you could got much closer and we all went on kind of different tracks and routes to victory yeah I I like we've played a few times now it feels like you can sort of focus down different trees and different orders of unlocking your upgrades and still compete and do reasonably well yeah I think yeah very much so yeah definitely point sality but uh it Stills feels pretty rewarding no matter what route you go down let's break down what a turn looks like um you start with a selection phase and what that essentially means is you're doing an open draft of stuff right you're either going to draft only part of the round that's turn based everything else is simultaneous yeah which is quite nice yeah it helps smooth things along and make you makes things pretty quick uh yeah so you will select either a male parent a female parent or turn order for the next round which will get you some sort of bonus you pick something from the supply track which also sets turn yeah which is for the following round yeah really cool um and that's really interesting because obviously if you go first internal do you get your pick of the best foxes yeah and they'll start as we said in the beginning you kind of get the generic stack I think they have at most three dice they do so it could be
one dice two dice or up to three dice they might all be the same or a combination of one two or three different uh you might want to look at your your study so you've been asked I mean the one I've got in front of me asked me to invest more in green and pink dice so I might be looking to start with for foxes that are going to offer me to pick up a green and or a pink dice absolutely because at the start of the game you're going to get studies and they will focus you towards the type of foxes that you want to be breeding yeah so once you've all made your selections and you'll do that until you've got both a male and a female parent and you've picked turn order uh you're then going to move onto the breeding phase which is essentially collecting all of the dice that the foxes give you and chucking them great it's the best bit which starts off at like what five four five dice and and gets really unmanageable had 18 dice on my last it it becomes it becomes two two hands tremendous tremendously satisfying so satisfying yeah tremendously satisfying just rolling buckets and buckets of dice and that's fantastic and what those dice do is give you uh the traits they will tell you how friendly or how bushy your Fox's tails are or how woy they're going to be and interesting right so they range from a half of a trait yep through to one uh to through to one and a half in different combinations and then you have to try and piece together MH the traits as complete symbols yeah I've not seen although there might be something I just simply haven't seen in the stack there's
not really any fiddling with the dice once they're rolled so change this to another face kind of thing there are yeah they definitely are you can change them after you've rolled them you can add extra dice syb I've seen one where I can add extra but I've not seen one that says you can change this to yeah I had I had a science um card that said after you've rolled the dice change one dice to any face you want oh perfect which is really useful cuz if you roll a half you can change it to a one and a half way better yeah on your green dice the wild one and then you've got you know one and a half symbols to sort of divide up as you like so once you've roll your dice cars roll your traits you're going to try and add them up to make whole symbols using your extra friendly dice your green dice which are wild to either finish off half a symbol or you create whole symbols of their own and if you've got friendly tokens which you collect through other sort of various bonuses in the game you can Chuck those in as well they handed out as sort of like consolation prizes they're like a little catchup mechanic right if you pick the later initiative order choice or if you lose around on the friendliness score you get them as in reward and they help I think they really help even the scores effectively a half of a dice to add on to something else and they will round out those those half dice that you roll quite frequently absolutely really smart it it is interesting though because you you can't not roll at least a half so you can definitely build towards well if I'm rolling two pink dice I can't fail to
get at least one whole point that I can put into pink next time so you can kind of work out so end of this game that we've just played I was rolling something like six green dice knowing that I couldn't fa fail to get at least three whole green and then fill in the rest with my four wild dice I could guarantee I'd get at least five green which is what I was looking for on my study it's it's the hardest the studies get is to five in a certain color yeah plus a combination of pink on top of that um so yeah you you can choose up to a point where you where you place your little check offs on the dice all your your blue dice you fill in your blue row plus any extra wild you want to add or in your pink or green or brown rolls which represent those different traes you kind of want to get the most you can generally so sometimes you're picking foxes purely for the volume of dice regardless of color other times you might want to angle in just for the colors depending it's interesting so the pups that you get basically give you two types of reward um the first and the third marker on each track for each trait is a dice which gives you nothing when you're breeding that pup but it means that you're then putting a pup into the pool for selection next round that gives more dice yeah the other spots so two four and five give you trait points that are the main mechanism for unlocking the engine of the game they're the little tokens that you can use immediately after the dice rolling phase to then unlock more things on your board so more foxes more studies more
dice or potentially the benefit of a patron which would be an ongoing and end game score once everyone's rolled their Dice and assigned the values and written on their pop cards you're going to determine who the friendliest pup and that's most importantly giving them a name yeah give them a name of course yeah a a a name if you're choosing or a or code number as Nick yes X1 exactly U yeah and the friendly the friendliest pup is essentially the one that has collected the most traits that's simple as that just total yeah total number once that's done you're going to score any studies each pup that you have bred will go towards one of your studies uh which is great and that will score you points at the end of the game that's matching up the sets of colors to a certain stud you're trying to do if I've got a pup that has you know three woess or three blue and two spottiness or pink and my study needs me to get three blue and two pink then he'll score me that study hooray yeah hooray exactly that and uh yeah once that's done and you scored your studies you're going to collect all of the tokens that you might have generated unlock any upgrades which we talked about and those are great um they will do some wicked stuff that will really make you more powerful as you go through the game like breed more than one pup for example it's one of those that feels like every single one is super power F and why would you ever choose anyone else and then you choose which way to go like more dice in a dice checking game of course I want all of the dice oh wait I can I can do a second Fox so I've got two chances to do a study everything twice yeah so I rolled 52 dice in the last oh yeah it really scales exponentially yeah more studies so more
chances to score different things which is great yeah if you're struggling to get those five green Dice and pick up another study or just couple of blue SC a bunch of first or second stage studies rather than focusing to a third stage yeah and again one of the patrons that we had in the last game I played uh gave you bonus points for every study you had where you at least started it so if you had three or four studies and you had at least part way along that's another six or eight points at the end I think this time we all unlocked the patron that gave you points points for variety on your yeah for having a trait sorry for having an upgrade unlocked with one of each of the four different trait colors so having a set of those four upgrades was points so we were all desperately trying to fill in as many upgrades as possible not necessarily not necessarily to score points but because it's extra points with the pat that's what those trait tokens that you've collected are going to be spent for just unlocking upgrades and it's uh really really smart and the final one of those you can get is uh getting a patron interested in your study and that basically means you can pick something that will give you some end game scoring it gives you a really well potentially very powerful onetime bonus as well when you you put your fo down in that Pat space very tempting typically getting science cards is pretty much for all of those and those things are little one-time use effects that you can spend the cards to as we said earlier roll extra dice or get an extra little bonus PR really cool uh once that's done you just do some Administration clear the old generation
out put the new pups out score some you who's the most friendly uh and then you start the whole thing again and kind of it isn't it for five rounds and then it's over it's it's actually stward yeah yeah it's particularly the first sort of two or three rounds before people have started unlocking extra pups and extra Dice and the dice balls are relatively short and there's not a lot of L things to sort of make decision points on first three rounds are over before you realize what's going on yeah and there's only five so I found one of the most interesting decisions points in this game is as you're filling in any given Fox and you're choosing where to increase um the the scores on in any of those given traits and potentially unlock more dice as Tom says you don't make immediate benefit of unlocking those extra dice but it will go back into the pool for selection next time if you happen to have made your initiative selection so that your first next round you then get the best choice of everyone's potential future parents if that hasn't happened do you then go oh I don't know if I want to make a fox that's got two of every dice I might purposely Scupper this one a bit so Tom doesn't get another dice next turn CU he's going first also this is the first game I've played where there is actually an incest rule yes there is an incest rule yes if you should probably I don't do incest Ro yes yes Inc it is discouraged there you go it's bad yeah which is interesting yeah if you if you
pick up the cards from your previous round that you bred you can't pick up both your male and your female and breed them without a penalty which absolutely makes sense yes super interesting that they they throw that in there's an extra role band but yeah would recommend playing with it fascinating game um it has some like I said really interesting decision space that I quite like and uh but it isn't too complicated in fact BGG calls it a 2.3 out of five I was I was going to wh this in sort of the the wingspan um area which is about the same okay I think wingspan is probably slightly simpler I I see I don't know cuz I think the the wingspan engine towards the end game gets more complicated because lots of abilities yeah there's I think there's a lot lay exaction does lay exaction does lay exaction there's a lot of Cascades and triggers in wingspan there's not really any of that I don't think there any here all the decision is in how you manipulate the dice it's yeah it's choosing which if you can using your wild card dice which ones you want to focus in on and then which upgrades you want to go for first or to focus towards certain studies and traits so you can unlock beyond that I I yeah I'd say it's less complicated than wingspan so yeah two to two and a half I think it's really straightforward to explain yeah I think this is I do think this is more streamlined than something like wingspan there's not many yeah there's not many sort of like complicated little exceptions in the game
absolutely all righty let's talk about the theme and gameplay interaction so we we'll try and steer away from the politics but what do you think of the the theme and gameplay interaction uh does it work together with the theme how how all the mechanisms work yeah I I think it does a good job of emulating how things like domestication projects work right you you can see that um you pick I mean obviously everything is simplified down to dice everything is abstracted you can see how certain physical traits are um collected together and magnified over time it's it is very abstracted in how that works and obviously your foxes don't become superpowered and have you know five times as many traits as they do as their great great grandparents in real life but it it does a good job of sort of emulating how that Focus manifests yeah I'd say it's a quite a simplification of it but think it does s true to having that feel I'm just thinking in comparison to something like Dinosaur Island where you are collecting combining DNA okay it's not quite directly the same but so many many many more levels of complication in Dinosaur Island many than than this this is much more direct this this blue and this pink this male and female give you these dice which are combined for the next one yeah that next card will have all of those dice just combined and then the next slot and then it it's a slow and steady
build and I think it I think it plays out really well I think it think it the them really well I like that because the dice rolls vary from half a half a trait up to one and a half a trait you can end up with two parents that you breed together that end up with a lower score in a given trait than either of the parents yep if you're unlucky yeah which can happen those traits could yeah could skip a generation or something and then suddenly come back later on yeah I I think they've clearly thought about it and I think it has been well implemented yes it's heavily abstracted but I think the theme and mechanisms do work together quite well let's talk about the flow of the game so turn length I think is pretty good um mostly because the only turn by turn phase of the game is the selection phase which happens pretty quickly it does happen pretty quick yeah you as we said later on in the game you're going to have more cards with more dice picking options in them what we have noticed though is once all but one of you have picked say the male the person who hasn't can focus on something else because they know no one else will be picking from the last two if you're third pick and the first two picks are the male players sorry the male foxes for the other two players and your three player game you don't need to worry about picking your male Fox you can do something else instead you could have first pick of the females or you could have first pick of the um supply rewards initiative really good that yeah I don't know if that's a bug or a bit feature
I'd say it's a feature I think it there's a bit it's definitely strategic not everyone on recognize it or notice it as a thing they might always go for two foxes and then the initiative that might be how your game group plays but both the times I've played it we've gone oh hang on neither of you can pick the male Fox that I've wanting now because You' already picked it so I'm going to like give myself the bonus I want in the initiative and then I'll come back there's no penalty to that I suppose the question is then then is is it strategic when it's it will always be the best option there is never a time when you wouldn't do that yes you just need to recognize it yeah I guess but I don't think it's a strategic decision that's the point I'm making it's just it is the decision you make but yeah it's it's not tremendously deep strategy no but uh yeah uh and then the rest of it is simultaneous which is awesome it's super smooth I mean and yeah I think once you get really experienced at this you can blast this out at 45 minutes because the game does as soon as you get towards round five we we all recognized it oh wait it's round five damn that's that's that's done suddenly over oh okay well yeah you'll you'll spend a good few minutes potentially working out the best dice layout depending on round four and round five yeah and if you've got one more Fox than an opponent might because they might not have upgraded to unlock the third or fourth Fox you're going to be one set of dice rolls behind them but it's not a massive delay in any no it's it's nice not to have to really wait on other players making decisions during
the rest of the the rest of the turn yeah yeah abut and there's not really a huge amount of player interaction so you don't really need to pay attention to what other people are doing quite right there's no gutches on taking the patrons for example CU they're all friendly mhm um the only real sort of I mean if there is any sort of take that the only really take that is in the selection draft everything in the in the simultaneous resolution phases doesn't matter terribly yeah you might be ultra competitive about overall friendliness of a fox and somehow try and use all of your stored up science cards to Wi wiggle your way to one more Point than the opponent but again I I think that could either be held off information until it gets to the point of it it just happened that we weren't treating it as particularly private information so no no absolutely right uh let's move on to some final thoughts then so what do you like most about the fox experiment and is there anything you didn't like fistfuls of dice fistfuls of dice yeah it is f i I like I like and this is really a slightly more complicated roll and right it is I I think that's giving it something of a disservice it is more than a Rolland right it it is but at its core it is uh dice build it's a bit of engine building but it's dice powered engine building the the roller right a big aspect of it and the RO right element sort of carries through the whole game yeah it's a good factor of it
it's not the entirety of it there there's a lot more at work than just chucking the dice and seeing what you get no but your your engine your um player board for example could have also been a a WIP clean board true could have been or they could have made this smaller and being a proper full rolling right could have more complex one I don't think they necessarily needed to I really like where it sits like thetion yeah looking at the the Dozen Oro trait tokens I've got set on my upgrade board if I was having to track all of those on another WIP clean board and then rub them out as I spent them and note them down again as I more I think I'd be a bit dizzy and you'd probably suffer from the staining of the white clean balls more at that point I like how it's set out it's a good balance yeah I like that it has stuff around the roll and right dice building yeah engine building dice um chucking mechanisms yeah s what did you like the most I mean yeah the dice is the thing I like how and became more apparent to me on this one I looked at the foxes that were available worked out which were going to give me most of the dice I needed and then could very quickly it wasn't a painstaking thing very quickly math out whether I could ever achieve the full end of my study or if I couldn't and then I could just move on to another you know pick a different Fox for what for a different
reason go go broad Instead try and get a different trait color maybe unlock a new study and look for something in a different color I like that it always allows you to quickly pivot and you don't well in the playthroughs we've had so far you're not punished for having tried something and it not worked out so you're having to choose something else you can you catch up as it were very quickly I think yeah yep I think it's great I very much enjoy the say the the D rolling not really dice manipulation but you how you choose to allocate your friendly dice to get the most out of your traits dice is actually quite interesting um if there's anything I don't like I do feel like it's something of a narrow decision space what I mean like that is like sometimes I feel like there is certainly an option that is better than the other options so I feel like there's not two equal options to me yeah right and like yeah if you pick a study card guess what I'm doing I'm picking that fox I'm picking that fox and I'm picking that reward cuz that's going to help me get this these these these studies which yeah it's that's fine I don't mind a bit more of distinct Clarity sometimes actually again it's not necessarily a bad thing but it is certainly a narrower decision I think the way the way that the upgrades resolve right you can you can do upgrades after you do your selection phase so you before and after sorry before no it's only after before and after before and after breeding it's not before the selective phase before and after breeding sorry yeah so you do the selection phase yeah uh you've picked your two foxes and then at the end of the selection phase before you start rolling dice you can go well I'm going to spend um some traits do an upgrade get a new study you're only going to pick the study that synergizes with the
with the two foxes that you've just picked that's what I mean yeah yeah the decision is narrow um but other than that I think it's it's fabulous I love the design of the game it looks great on the table it's fun to play I love the integration of roll and right with sort of a wider board game I think more games should do that I think it's real fun um but yeah uh who is this game for and what I mean by that is if you like game X you would also like the the fox experiment I would always feel like I'm in a hard place to recommend necessarily if you like X then you'll like RS well you might like that I I think I think it's a very generous game so I think it is open to quite a wide range of people in that sense um unless the theme particularly turns you off for whatever reason um so yeah as we say people who like a lot of roll and right type stuffff I think there's enough here in that catchment area we've mentioned wingspan already it's got a degree of that I mentioned Dinosaur Island it's by no way so maybe the dinosaur Rolland right raran right whatever it was called raren right yeah although that was there was more actual drawing involved dra um I'm trying yeah can't Circle back to me I'll see if I can I was going to make a weird comparison that has nothing to do with Foxes or nature uh but race for the Galaxy has some of the same um DNA being that it's an engine builder that is very much dice powered for the resources interesting yeah I think if
you do like if you're a fan of RM rights you should certainly try this but like I said I do want to stress that it is much more than that I think there's definitely a board game in here um if you like engine building if you like open drafting it has those elements kind of a a light brush of those elements the open drafting isn't going to be you know super punishing um the engine building you're not building a complex engine that's going to you know trigger off a bunch of things yeah it's less of a draft and less of an engine builder than say the century series correct it's you're not having to constantly work out if I do this then this then this I'll get that at the end it's just this is these are the two FKS in front of me so this is what I'll get this time yeah depending on what there's not there's not much in the way of I want to say hate drafting right mean spirited drafting it's very difficult to hate draft in this game I think you could theoretically sort of try and work out what other people are going for if you took someone's like someone's parent that they need you're probably going to do it at your own detriment too yeah because the foxes generally improve across all traits over the course of the game you really you can only get two dice in each trait From Any Given pup at maximum that's eight dice most of the pups at the end of the game end up with maybe six or seven of them anyway yeah there's not really a huge amount out of hate drafting possible yeah yeah unless someone is actively choosing the lowest numbered dice foxes over and over again by its
very design you're going to end up with a minimum number of dice to roll which keeps you well within a bounded accuracy type feature here and if someone picks the particular Fox that you wanted there's probably another option and Simon you said it it's relatively easy to Pivot grab a study upgrade take a new study go to a different cover wor about it so what is your final word and how would you finally rate the fox experiment actually I'm going to quickly cut that out I want to do value quickly that's all right based on MSRP I guess before we move on to the final word and your final rating uh how would you rate the value of the fox experiment based on its MSRP $59.99 consider things like gameplay experience that it gives you production all of that together I've certainly paid similar for similar games yeah um So within the ballpark I really wanted to get this game anyway we played this a year ago yes at Spiel um and I was really keen on it then and I was really Keen to pick up a copy pandasaurus were kind enough to gift us a copy I probably would have bought this anyway and in fact I instructed you guys to buy me a copy of this anyway yes they gave us one for review purp they very generous for I appreciate that all right you son what do you think value of the game if you put this on the table and I saw everything on it and asked me to how much I'd pay you I would think I'd quite happily say 50 probably not 60 y I think that's probably fair I think that's yeah
I'd be in much the same place lots of cardboard and wood which is great I prefer that over lots of plastic um but likewise I'd certainly expect I think 49.99 don't don't overlook the fact that there's 60 dice in this box I was just trying to count many actually yeah tell tell a light there's a ton of a ton of dice in here but yeah you're going to get this for y absolutely uh right so let's move on to the conclusion your final word and your final rating of the fox experiment there's 80 dice there's 80 dice Tom should we start with you what's your your final thoughts and your final rating my final uh my final thoughts are that loud boy lives on loud boy lives on in our hearts forever yeah in our hearts and in our minds don't worry listeners I'm as beused as you are and in my ears um no I I um I really really like the dice building element it feels it's more probably more random than I would go for with a lot of Euro games I prefer I prefer a crunchier Euro game this is on the lighter side but I really like what this does and I think it does it really well to emulate the material the the sort of the variation in in traits with the sort of gen and determine what you going to get because you know how much power and currency everything else you've got I I like a deterministic game this is not that but you have enough tools to manipulate the dice to make it
work and you have easy waves of pivoting so it doesn't feel bad when the dice go against you y cool I'm a bit more on the lighter side as we know so I actually quite like that I don't have to sit and feel like I'm failing to work out the best order I can roll the dice and see what I can do with it and I'm not having to think too hard and that might sound counterintuitive but that's actually quite a nice relief at times I think it's immediately accessible to a wide range of people and I think it's generous and rewarding we said it's five rounds so it's less than an hour of play it's not going if you're not enjoying it it's not going to like hang around for too long I think just overall it's really really fun I think it's such a well constructed game right it's everything is has its place there is no spare fat on it so there's no like extraneous mechanisms that make things over complicated because they could have done more with it there's there's not two or three other tracks of stuff to potentially move into oh I didn't even look at that this game you're kind of involved in a bit of everything which I think is the kind of game I like it sort of obliges you to do the everything so which is really nice I think it's a tremendously well constructed game and we say we say it's only five game five rounds sorry yes um but if you look at all of our upgrade boards we all well Simon and I got you know 80% of the upgrades unlocked in five rounds yeah I've got 11 out of 14 that's you I I did badly in this game
listeners yeah Wayne Wayne being an exception you were otherwise focused let's say yeah I was otherwise focused and he just can't roll dice I just can't roll dice I should I should try rolling them better to be honest have you tried being better at dice yeah have you tried comp it um yeah I think it's yeah like I said said a well constructed game not not too much bare fat on it very accessible I think the theme is great ignore the nonsense online it's irrelevant I mean we might already have made more of that than it is but yeah at the time when this game is just hitting retail if indeed fulfillment on the kickstarter to have 15 plus one ratings from people who legitimately couldn't have played the game yet is just nonsense yeah so there is that um so we'll go in and give it a 10 just to counter that maybe no we won't do that uh right cuz we score out of five yes I'm giving this a four you're giving this a four I'm also giving this a four I think it's a solid four it's a solid four out five four in a little bit we love it so thanks for listening to B stupid subscribe to us for updates and to get future episodes of the show delivered directly to your ear holes via your favorite podcast service you can also find us on Facebook and especially at Instagram at board stupid UK run by lovely Simon and anywhere you can find your favorite podcasts but also right now you can see I putting a load of effort and emphasis on our YouTube channels please follow us on YouTube you can see us exactly there's going to be a bunch more stuff as we go uh keep adding content to there so uh if you like the stuff give us a five star review give us a comment interact with us we love it if youve got any feedback or questions
please do let us know have you played the foxy experiment what do you think of the dice chucking trait collection and engine building did you enjoy getting to name your Dynasty like we did thanks for listening we'll catch you again real soon soon you remember the animals of farthing wood have a board game of that that' be that's like route before the
war that