Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ticket to Ride Legacy: Legends of the West Review

Transcript 16:29

hi everyone I'm tally this is farell and we're Bor of it and Welcome to our review of Ticket to Ride Legacy Legends of the West for two to five players this giant box contains a 12 game Ticket to Ride campaign with each new game providing new content and ways to shake up the well-known and beloved gameplay of Ticket to Ride just for your information we played the entire campaign with the full five players and it was great or not it was terrible you don't know yet so with signified Legacy and it being Legacy game with spoilers you should know that we are going to spoil some of it there will be spoilers in this review uh coming up and there's one main reason for this and it's that this box costs $120 and because of that we feel it's important to discuss what's in it the highs and the lows without having to tiptoe and dance around the subject now we're not going to spoil everything we're not going to go in depth on every mechanism that comes up and we're definitely going to leave what our favorite surprises were surprises for you as well but we are going to discuss things that happen throughout the campaign and there's going to be b-roll of various different things that to you will be out of context because you don't know what's coming uh but just be aware of that and also be aware that we received this as a review copy from Asma day laic and we thank them very much

yes tickets Please everyone tickets please if You' never played Ticket to Ride before it's pretty simple on your turn you can either pick up colored train cards or you can discard a number of those cards of a matching color to claim a route on the board in the base game you will get points for claiming those roots but you're also trying to go for long form routes as given to you on ticket cards where you'll get points for connecting two cities together lastly the player that gets the longest route of all will also get get some additional points now we'll cover the core rule changes between Ticket to Ride and Ticket to Ride Legacy as there are a few important changes in Ticket to Ride Legacy you still have the tickets but pretty much everything else is out the window for one it introduces physical money you'll start off with a small amount then you'll gain some or lose some depending on various effects in the beginning of the campaign many of these effects come in the format of event cards another new introduction these will be triggered at random times and have effects you can probably imagine EG gain $3 for each completed ticket you reveal or pay $2 each time you connect to a port city also another introduction

is the fact that players now gain money each time they claim tracks that match their player color at the end of each game you'll only score for three things cash in hand tickets and an additional bonus for the trains you have remaining the fewer trains you have remaining the more money you will get however whil there needs to be a winner for each game there also needs to be a winner for the overall campaign throughout the campaign new mechanisms will be introduced for you to engage with that will either give you in-game money or may just be counted at end of campaign scoring that means winning game after game isn't the only viable way to take the title of ticket to ride Legacy Champion we're going to start the review with broad Strokes we had an absolute blast playing this going in we're both a bit eh on Ticket to Ride we never actively choose to play it but we would play it if our families wanted to however we enjoyed pretty much every game in this campaign and so did our group although it does have its ups and downs but the key takeaway message would be if you're trepidatious about getting Ticket to Ride Legacy because you're so so on Ticket to Ride don't be because it does plenty of interesting and engaging things for people that might feel that way well yeah something we really enjoyed is I think we found this a better version of Ticket to Ride because we really enjoyed how it changes the core rules to the original Ticket to

Ride For example now you have money as the element of scoring and I think it streamlines the scoring from the original ticket to ride because it could be a little bit finicky where because you were claiming points for laying Roots if you forget to claim those points it could cause trouble later on you might have to recount everything whereas here the money is kind of cold and clean and simple I also think it's quite interesting how now you have a incentive to build roots on your player colors it's just a nice little twist because it gives you money and just gives people something to focus on and there are also a lot of little elements that are added in that just make the game come to life a bit more a bit more interesting you have the employees which are little cars that give you kind of asymmetric Powers you have major cities which give you a free card if you connect to them and you have the events the event cards though were more divisive for us uh as they're a little more zany and I think the core problem with their system and how they work is that the cards that trigger them are shuffled randomly into the train card deck so they're drawn random times rather than carefully being placed or stacked because it can lead to annoyances frustrations and odd occurrences for example I can't tell you the number of times in this campaign that we had an ongoing event card drawn that players were excited to engage with only for another card to be flipped on

top of that one canceling it two players turns along and then there was another experience something that happens occasionally although less so where an event will trigger very early in the game and negatively or positively affect only one player for example in an early game a card was drawn that said if you build here get $5 and that was drawn on the second player's turn and it just happened that the first player had built there but he was the only person who could have built there and obviously him getting $5 at a time in the campaign where $5 could be a quarter or a sixth of your final score was pretty frustrating for everyone else however on the whole 85% of the time they're interesting they add new considerations they work well they make the game exciting they they also introduce a sense of progress because some will go out the game when they're used up multiple times it's just that it comes with a lot of Randomness anyway that is only how Ticket to Ride Legacy starts out as everyone knows with Legacy games as the campaign goes on the game will be expanded and new mechanisms will be added from the third game onwards to nobody's surprise the map will start expanding as in the beginning you just start with a single jigsaw piece which is a map of New England we think this aspect is pretty cool because the winner of each game will get to pick usually

from two to three options which new region of America should get added to the board and not only do you get a new map map piece which fits with the rest of the board like a jigsaw but you'll also get a new mechanism generally these mechanisms are transitory lasting for maybe one to two games before being phased out so you don't have to worry too much about being overwhelmed with lots of mechanisms I think the whole concept really na Nails what makes Legacy games thrilling and drives engagement because there's a new incentive to be first it's also providing a lot of novelty and replayability because which regions are added and in which order will create a really different experience for players campaign to campaign unfortunately this exciting turn of events actually leads to our biggest problem with Ticket to Ride Legacy because to keep up with this everg growing map you have an Ever growing pool of trains and this means that it takes longer to trigger the end of the game because you trigger the end of the game by getting down to two or less trains so so obviously it's going to take more turns if you have more trains now our first five plays of this were one session and game six and seven were a second session and those two sessions were roughly equal in length just to show how much longer this game begins to get and the problem we have is that we don't believe Ticket to Ride gets better because it's longer in fact

it just gets more tedious and definitely do not believe that uh what you see in the FAQ and on BGG that the max length of game will be 90 minutes it's just not true and the problem I have and what baffles me is that the designers obviously knew that this would become an issue because the final three games of the campaign before you begin the game proper you're allowed to claim Roots uh yeah before you begin and in the final game you could put down up to 20% of your trains before you begin playing properly and it's just if they knew it's an issue and they're shortening the game length arbitrarily because of it why not just make a smaller tighter map this is the aspect of the game which in our opinion could have used the most tweaking because people aren't excited just by getting a new map piece and connecting Miles City to Detroit or by getting a novel ticket route they're excited by the new mechanisms which are unlocked in the boxes and through the story deck so obviously they can in some cases are be divorced from the map tiles and I would have liked to see that done more rather than just keep making the map bigger I'm sure that the Publishers designers wanted it to be epic and expansive and it is but that doesn't make it a good fun thing it would be much more of a great experience if it was Tighter and punchier now we did play this the full

campaign at five players so obviously that will extend it compared to playing at two or three but I would also argue the way you want to play it and the best experience is at those higher player counts where ticket to R Legacy really shines is through the mechanisms it introduces Each of which incorporates some Regional flavor from the unlocked region it makes each game feel novel and provides some different scoring opportunities I remember one game where half of our group went treasure hunting and the other half decided to build tunnels and the scores came out pretty even many of the mechanisms also make Ticket to Ride More interactive like the rubber that you can send to grief other players and many of them make it feel more tense like the many mechanisms that run out so it's a race to grab what you can one particular highlight were the postcards which is something introduced at the end of the first game and continue throughout the campaign and essentially there are tickets which have postcards on them and if you complete that ticket you get a postcard card and it's like a secret little card that gives you a little story Flash and will give you some sort of onetime power ongoing power or different way to interact with the game and they're really fun they're really interesting they kind of ramp up the tension because they make those tickets so much more important to you and it's really interesting how the postcards might give you say an edge in

one element of the game that you could lean into so it becomes a little bit asymmetric or sometimes they'll give you a preview of things that are upcoming or direct you in a certain way to play and generally they're just a really nice addition they're really fun to play around with it was cool to have a secret mission and we definitely enjoyed their inclusion however and you might see a theme running through this review now there is also a serious issue with these postcards and that is the randomness it is random which tickets give postcards and because you draw tickets randomly it might be that one player ends a game with three such tickets whereas another player goes three games without ever seeing a postcard ticket now this is attempted alleviation on the part of the designers because you can only get a postcard for one of these tickets per game however if you complete three postcard tickets they still all go out of the game so you're reducing the pull for other players even though you only get one postcard and then on top of that the postcards do vary in usefulness some of them might give you a bit of money at the end of the campaign for a lot of work and sometimes things which might be outside your control and then others will give you ongoing abilities that might save you money game after game after game so final thoughts overall Ticket to Ride Legacy was an amazing experience we played the whole campaign with the full

five players and everyone loved it it introduced many wonderful twists and turns and raliz the core gameplay of Ticket to Ride not everything introduced wowed us but for the most part it did Delight us particularly some of the gimmicky stuff honestly if you any so so on Ticket to Ride we personally think there's enough here to draw you in however it was very much a campaign of two steps forward one step back Ticket to Ride is a really brutal and competitive game for how light it is so it's very surprising that there's more Randomness in this box which I think some people are going to come away frustrated with also the decision to constantly expand the map and increase the game length is something that does get on the point of tedium although we will say that we did enjoy every game we played it's just that we'd rather those games weren't 2 and a half hours when that doesn't extend the experience the problem is this cost $120 and we're not sure we can say it's worth it and remember that we got this for free though this game is very much for people who love tickets to ride it it's just a really hard recommendation because so much of it it is just that little bit off I think with a few tweaks and some careful crafting rather than maybe introducing a mechanism and leaving it to Randomness this could have been a world beater and well worth the price however I think if you're looking

into it you have to ask yourself do you want a carefully balanced competitive experience or do you want an experience an experience to share with your friends because that's what you're going to get it certainly is that right like that was probably the best part about it was the routine of getting everyone together playing it and everyone being excited it was like amazing experience so that was our review of TI ride Legacy thank you for watching if you have any questions please ask them Please Subscribe uh if you haven't already it would really help us the channel and thanks so much for watching see you

bye smug points oh you're so annoying good job

Progress saved